Intervention and dialogue of the President of the Government at the ABC Forum.

Spain Mariano Rajoy · Prime Minister of Spain

8 February 2018 · ABC Forum

Context
Rajoy addressed the ABC Forum in Madrid on 8 February 2018, presenting Spain's economic progress and forecasts for growth and employment.
Main themes
Spanish economic recovery, GDP growth and forecasts, job creation, unemployment reduction, budgetary stability, labor reform, competitiveness, export sector, economic crisis legacy, European integration, fiscal policy
Duration
~63 min
96th percentile
Words
7,564
96th percentile
Sentences
320
96th percentile
Readability
51
67th percentile
Grade
11.9
43rd percentile
Syntax
3.11
62nd percentile
Vocabulary
2.04
17th percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 36%35%
  • Economic 31%30%
  • Ceremonial 12%12%
  • Geopolitical 11%11%
  • Social 8%8%
  • Technological 1%1%
  • Environmental 1%1%
  • Not in focus 2%

320 sentences in 132 paragraphs

Madam President of the Congress of Deputies, Madam President of the Community of Madrid, Ministers, Mr. President of Vocento, Madam President of "ABC", Presidents of Ferrovial and Deloitte, ladies and gentlemen, dear friends,

Thank you very much to all for your attendance, which honors me, and I also appreciate the invitation to this prestigious ABC Forum.

I was here almost a year ago. At that time, I told you that we viewed the recovery of the Spanish economy with optimism and with that optimism we trusted that Spain would grow by 2.5 percent in 2017 and that four hundred thousand jobs would be created. Well, we closed, as has been recalled here, 2017 with a growth of 3.1 percent and the creation of more than six hundred thousand jobs. Today I announce that this year 2018 we will have a growth forecast of at least 2.5 percent, with the creation of four hundred thousand jobs. You will understand that I would like what happened in 2017 to also happen in 2018 and that, therefore, the Government's forecasts fall short and reality surpasses them. We will work to make that happen.

A year ago, I also told you that we hoped to recover, throughout the year, all the wealth that the crisis destroyed. Today I can tell you that we have already recovered, as was also mentioned here a moment ago, all the GDP, as well as the levels of tax collection and two-thirds of employment. You know that, for the Government, recovering all the jobs lost during the crisis and continuing to promote the generation of opportunities is the top priority.

This growth is accompanied by some very encouraging indicators. I will give you just five:

- 2017 was the fourth consecutive year in which around half a million net jobs were created.

- We have already reached the level of nineteen million employed, bringing us closer to our goal of twenty million people working in Spain before 2020.

- We ended 2017 with more women working than ever in the history of Spain.

- Employment among young people is growing at double the national average, and that is the best indicator of the present and the best guarantee for the future.

- In addition, Spain has been leading the reduction of unemployment in Europe for four years. Thanks to this, our unemployment rate, which remains very high, is the lowest since 2008.

In that 2008, an unprecedented economic crisis began. Spain suffered five consecutive years of recession: from 2009 to 2013; a five-year period of negative growth in which we lost one-tenth of our wealth and more than three and a half million jobs were destroyed. The unemployment rate skyrocketed to a staggering 26 percent, and six million people were unemployed. The loss of jobs was the most painful aspect of the deepest crisis in the last fifty years.

With everyone's effort and a new economic policy, we managed to transform the recession into recovery, the destruction of jobs into job creation, and uncertainty into certainty and the will to win, together, a better future.

That new economic policy that we implemented at the end of 2011, when we took on the task of overcoming the crisis, is based and remains on three pillars:

- First, budgetary stability, which has restored confidence in our country. No one remembers that risk premium that indeed reached 639 points; now it is below 70, as has been said here, and the rating agencies are improving our score.

- Second, the cleaning up of our financial system, which has restored liquidity to the business fabric and initiative to entrepreneurs.

- And third, the improvement of the competitiveness of the Spanish economy.

All of this was the subject of an ambitious reform agenda, which began with the difficult labor reform. What was then seen by many as a mistake has now proven to be a success.

The crisis hit Spain harder due to the unsustainable accumulation of imbalances: public deficit, external deficit, inflation, or loss of competitiveness. It was the consequence of a growth model based on external debt. Today, on the other hand, our thriving export sector is one of the main protagonists of the recovery: we sell one-third of our GDP abroad and we are the second country in the world that receives the most tourists and where visitors spend the most money.

2017 is our fourth consecutive year of growth, job creation, and external surplus. It is a combination of three elements that had never occurred in our growth model, and that is the main guarantee that this expansive phase will be sustainable over time.

Ladies and gentlemen,

We are promoting a stronger and more diversified economy, more balanced and competitive; a more open, more productive economy that is better able to adapt to globalization. All of this, hand in hand with Spain's constant and shared vocation: an active European nation, open to the world and sharing Spanish as a universal language, a source of culture, unity, and opportunities.

We want all of this with a very clear objective, to improve the lives of Spaniards, because now the most important thing is to continue consolidating the recovery so that it reaches everyone. Our task is summarized in the purpose of creating the conditions for people to live better.

One lives better when there is freedom, security, and opportunities; when everyone can aspire to forge, with their work, a better future for themselves and their children; when it is guaranteed that they can do so in an environment of economic stability, political normality, and social serenity; and when everyone is free to think and believe what they want, and knows that their freedom is only limited by respect for the freedom of others; frameworks of coexistence that, in democracy, are regulated by law and define the rule of law.

A good government must facilitate the conditions for those legitimate aspirations of all to bear fruit as each one wishes. That is the task we have set for ourselves, and this, for me, is doing politics: thinking about what is best for the country. We have clear ideas and, moreover, a good record of service and a clear roadmap that defines our priorities. And the main one, as I told you at the beginning, is employment; increasingly stable and higher quality employment. And the data shows that we are on the right track:

- We have had 48 consecutive months of increases in permanent hiring.

- We have already recovered the level of permanent employment prior to the crisis.

- And in 2017, long-term unemployment was reduced by almost half a million people. In fact, last year nine out of ten unemployed people who found work had been unemployed for a year or more.

This demonstrates that jobs are being created, and they are stable and quality jobs that promote equal opportunities and correct the gaps of inequality.

It is a goal of the Government to work to continue correcting inequalities. The effort is worth it and is already bearing fruit: there has been an improvement in the living conditions of families and the risk of poverty and exclusion is being reduced; dependency benefits are at historic highs, and the gender pay gap is narrowing in these years.

These are some examples that things are getting better; but we must continue to gain productivity if we want to maintain this line, because only in this way can we increase our income levels, improve salaries, and ultimately achieve more well-being and continue to improve equality.

Our efforts are directed towards this, and that is why the Government has agreed with social agents to raise the Minimum Wage for the next three years, as long as we continue to grow and create jobs at the current pace. This increase adds to the one we agreed upon with the PSOE in 2017. Then it was a parliamentary pact, and this has been a social agreement.

We offer dialogue and seek consensus. We do this because politics cannot be an eternal and sterile confrontation. Politics is about debating, but with the aim of agreeing and accepting that, to achieve this, we must always share the ends and sometimes yield on the starting positions.

Our willingness for dialogue and agreement is clear and sincere in everything that can improve the lives of Spaniards. That is why we put everything on our part for the signing of the agreement against gender violence, which was concluded in Congress with the consensus of all.

This Legislature could be fruitful in agreements. It should be. The Spanish voted for a political composition of Parliament that demands seeking agreements, and the economic moment, after the storm of the crisis and its urgencies, invites us to think in the medium and long term.

In Parliament, working groups, subcommittees, and commissions are underway to study improvements and seek consensus on many important issues, some of which were referenced here a moment ago: education, pensions, the autonomous system, justice, cybersecurity, or minors; and also on concrete measures for self-employed workers, with a law that we passed unanimously last year.

I believe that agreements are good for our economy, and that is why I believe there is one particularly urgent if we want to do everything we can to ensure that the recovery continues with more strength: the 2018 Budgets. The economy of each of the Spaniards will improve if there is an agreement for the economy of all, because the Budgets provide stability and certainty, and generate new investments that improve people's lives.

We want to agree on them, and I hope that common sense prevails and not other interests different from common sense. In any case, if those interests were to prevail -- God forbid! -- over common sense, we will do everything possible to ensure that it does not harm the Spaniards. In any case, we already have the 2017 Budgets extended. They are good budgets, they have driven the fourth consecutive year of growth, and they could drive the fifth.

But we are still on time. The budgetary pact is possible and is the best for all Spaniards.

I ask everyone not to see the Budgets as a mere political dispute; nor the autonomous financing. Both issues are key to public investments and the essential services that Spaniards receive.

We have been working for more than a year with the Autonomous Communities to reach an agreement on financing. We have evaluated the current system, its defects and virtues, and we are listening to everyone to know their priorities and proposals. The objective is to configure a system that guarantees access for all citizens to what is important: education, healthcare, and social services. In this case, the participation of all is convenient, and that of the PSOE, in addition to being responsible, is essential: it is the main opposition party and governs in many Autonomous Communities and municipalities. I hope and wish that it will rise to the occasion of its responsibility.

We need to agree on a system that provides security and guarantees that these fundamental public services are not again subjected to the ups and downs of the cycle, as happened at the beginning of the crisis; a simpler, fairer, more stable, and transparent system that does not create grievances between Communities. This reform is essential, and moreover, this is the best time to do it. Both the Government and the Autonomous Communities agree that it needs to be changed. They even agree, those who supported the current system, approved by the socialist government in 2009, despite my party's opposition vote. And the economic situation today is much better than it was a few years ago.

Ladies and gentlemen,

If we are able to agree on what is urgent, we will be able to dedicate more efforts to the challenges of the coming decades. I am talking about issues that we can group into four axes: the environment, globalization, external projection, or demographic issues. The future well-being of Spaniards depends on our ability to provide the best response to these important challenges.

The first axis is environmental and affects water, energy, and climate change. We are fulfilling our international commitments and, shortly, we will send to Congress the first Climate Change Law. We will continue to bet on renewable energies, where we are a recognized power in the world, and I aim to achieve a National Water Pact that is inclusive, consensual, and supportive.

The second axis is the result of the global world we live in and has digitalization and scientific advances as its most pressing demands. We will continue to support the digital transformation of our economy, industry, and services, in an environment of security, guarantees, and trust. And we must be able to retain and attract the best talent, with a science and research system much more aligned with the needs of the productive fabric. These are two tasks, as has also been recalled here a moment ago, essential for the creation of wealth and opportunities.

The third axis for the well-being of Spain depends on our ability to continue being active protagonists in Europe and in the world. My Government is firmly committed to the multiple task of European integration, because Europe is the largest space of freedom, well-being, and prosperity in the world. But, in addition, Europe is a responsibility. That is why we want a strong, open, and secure Europe; a project capable of exporting the values of democracy, the rule of law, and human rights; a project that is supportive, responsible, and forward-looking, which is in a position to offer comprehensive solutions to pressing challenges such as immigration.

The fourth and final axis is the result of great news -- we are living longer and we want to live better until the end -- and of another that is not so good: there are fewer births. It is a broad topic that we must address in the future, but today I only want to refer to pensions.

It is necessary to provide the best response to issues such as aging and to do so by combining public protection with the encouragement and respect for each person's initiative. No one better than oneself to assess their present and future needs.

As I was saying, we live longer and we have the right to live better. That is why we are working intensively in the parliamentary committee of the Toledo Pact to reach an agreement that will strengthen our pension system. There are many reasons to be proud of our social protection system, one of the best in the world, although some, I do not know why, do not want to acknowledge it.

The goal is to preserve it and, after some difficult years, there are now reasons for optimism. We have just learned that in 2017, for the first time in nine years, Social Security contributions grew more than pension expenditures, and the close of 2017 will show the highest social contribution revenues in history, despite the fact that we have not yet fully recovered the employment level prior to the crisis, nor are they yet sufficient to cover the total pension expenditure.

But this good news should not overshadow a lesson from the bad years past: the crisis not only left many people unemployed but also frustrated their expectations and their confidence in the future. Now that things are starting to go well, it is time to be prudent again.

From public authorities, we must encourage long-term saving; savings with a prolonged time horizon, which serves as a complement to the public pension but also for other life plans, such as children's education, a personal project, or overcoming any setback that life may bring us; an investment for the future that can be accessed when necessary. That is why tomorrow, Friday, I will propose to the Council of Ministers the approval of a Royal Decree that will allow people who save in pension plans and funds to recover all or part of their savings after ten years of contribution. In addition, the fees that savers pay to management entities will be significantly reduced.

In Spain, the public pension system is guaranteed by the State; an inalienable right of Spaniards that we promote with economic policies that favor growth and job creation. But also, as I mentioned earlier, we must continue to agree among all political forces on measures for its stability and improvement.

All of this is compatible with private savings initiatives. Private pension plans have existed in Spain for thirty years. They complement, not replace, the public pension model. The Toledo Pact, in its recommendations, encourages strengthening these complementary savings systems. Today, more than eight million people have a pension plan, with accumulated savings of more than one hundred billion euros.

According to OECD statistics, Spaniards dedicate less than citizens of other advanced countries to pension plans and funds. We rank 21st in that ranking, just behind Portugal, in this form of long-term saving. The reform I have just announced aims to incentivize that saving, appeals to individual responsibility, and gives more freedom and guarantees to the saver, who can access their money earlier.

Speaking of the future and freedom, allow me to conclude my speech by referring to the greatest challenge that Spanish democracy has ever faced.

In 1977, Spain regained democracy; forty years later, we have risen to the occasion when it has been our turn to defend it. In 1978, we gave ourselves a consensus Constitution; forty years later, Spanish democracy has shown that it has the instruments and strength to defend itself when it is attacked. And that lesson remains, and must always remain, for the future.

What has happened is well known and the response of the Government and many others is also known. It has become crystal clear that this Government never yields to impositions, even less so when they are illegitimate and illegal. It has also become clear that in Spain the Law is upheld and that those who violate it are held accountable before the Courts; courts of justice that also fulfill their role in our State and, from their absolute independence, protect the rights of all and establish the responsibilities of those who stand outside the Law.

Some thought they could live outside the Law and all they have achieved is to end up outside the Government. It was a difficult decision, but it was the only possible one. We did what we had to do in defense of the Constitution, of democracy, and of the Law, and we did it with the broadest possible support; I repeat, with the broadest possible support.

A lot of negotiation was needed -- I repeat, a lot -- for the "no" to 155, whether it was emphatic or capricious, to turn into a "yes." We were very clear that we had to seek what unites us above what separates us, not fall into "partisanship," because I believe, and have always defended, that there are issues that are above the ideologies of parties, because they affect our interests as a Nation.

Challenges to the State are met with State policies and must have the unanimous support of those of us who believe that the rights of all are defended from the Law.

I, as President of the Government, called for elections that gave a voice to the Catalans, with all legality and legitimacy. Citizens voted normally and now it is up to the new Catalan Parliament to choose, in a normal way, a normal president. Something as simple as a candidate who can be present at their own investiture, who is in their place and can be there, and who, once elected, can exercise their position and govern, debate with the opposition, and submit to their control. A president who is not embroiled in judicial proceedings.

More and more Catalans are asking how long a Autonomous Community can be subjected to the will and whims of a single person. I also understand that many others do not understand why a constitutionalist alternative is not presented to the current situation. It can and must be done. To all those who think one thing or the other, I want to send a message of reassurance: while the new Parliament seeks a President who can be one, or elections are repeated if it does not find one, Catalonia will not be without a Government, because Article 155 is the guarantee that essential services and the real needs of Catalans continue to be met.

My wish is for everything to return to normal as soon as possible. It is the best for all Catalans and for all of Spain.

Ladies and gentlemen,

In the end, those of us who are dedicated to politics are here to solve people's problems, not to create them. That is why my goal is always to ensure that there is serenity, normality, and stability.

The Popular Party can make mistakes; but I believe everyone will agree that today it is the only party in Spain that puts the stability of the country ahead of its electoral interests. Sometimes we do better and sometimes we do worse; but what matters to me is that Spain and Spaniards do well because, in that way, some of those Spaniards will also do better. That has always been my goal in politics and the goal of the Popular Party. That is why we are updating our offer to Spaniards these days to continue serving our country.

I will conclude now. A week ago we celebrated the 50th birthday of King Felipe VI and this year we commemorate the 40th anniversary of our Constitution. In these four decades of democracy, we have managed, together, to forge the best Spain in history, the Spain that our parents aspired to: an open, vital, modern, thriving, and hospitable Spain, a Spain full of reasons to continue working.

It is the Spain we serve and the one we want but, above all, it is the great nation that we are obliged to care for to pass on to the next generations of Spaniards.

Thank you very much.

Dialogue with the President of the Government

Bieito Rubido.- Everyone tells newspaper directors how we should run the newspaper, and I suppose that something similar happens to government presidents: that everyone tells them what they should do to govern the country. The big issue in recent months has been Catalonia and it continues to be the great problem of this country, even though it is very tedious and there is great fatigue among citizens with it. We, in the media, are also very tired every time we have to talk about a new chapter; but it is the most transcendent issue that Spanish society currently has.

The first question, Mr. Rajoy, is: Was the Government too slow in applying Article 155? Was there an excess of caution in its application? Would it not have been better not to have reached October 1 and to have applied Article 155 at the moment when the Catalan regional parliament approved the laws it approved to develop the entire subsequent process?

President.- I received many instructions, indeed, Mr. Director. Some wanted us to do it six months earlier, some wanted us to do it on September 6 or 7, some thought it was best never to do it, and some even said we should do all three things at once, that, if we were imaginative, we could do it.

I believe that, in any Government, the President of the Government has more data, more information, and has a more global view of what is happening at any moment. So, I believe we did it at the best possible moment. You ask me: Would September 6 and 7 have been a good date? Undoubtedly, because September 6 and 7 is when they launched those famous laws of transitoriness and the referendum law; but, of course, I had to assess some things.

For example, I had to consider what appeared three days earlier in a national media outlet, which read: "Mr. Sánchez and Mr. Rivera advise Rajoy not to implement Article 155." I think it was reasonable for me to try to be well accompanied to apply Article 155.

I also had to take into account, when making decisions, what they might think in Europe because, of course, Article 155 was not a minor issue; Article 155, among other things, meant dismissing a Government that had been democratically elected and that does not have many precedents in Europe; as far as I know, it has none. So, I had to assess that.

Then, when the Government presents a resource before the Courts, it has to try to win it and for that, it has to substantiate it well and load it with reasons.

Therefore, we believed that the most reasonable thing was to make the decision at that moment. At that moment when we made it, we had already secured the support of the PSOE and Ciudadanos; at that moment, we had also been able to explain things well in Europe; we believed that in the Courts we could do well because we were right and, above all, because we worked -- I think effectively with the legal services -- to win it and, therefore, I believe that, in the end, the solution was the most reasonable.

In any case, if someone believes it is better to do it fifteen days earlier or later, I am not too concerned; but, honestly, in light of the data we had, the most important was: I could not go alone, despite the fact that in the Senate the Popular Party had a majority, but we needed the support of those two political forces. I believe that, in light of all this data and considerations and a few more, the date was reasonable.

B. Rubido.- What role did the King's speech on October 3 play in your decision?

President.- The King made a speech, indeed, in defense of the unity of Spain and, therefore, he was up to the circumstances; but there were also other Spaniards who were up to the circumstances. He was the first. The Government was the one that made the decision to take Article 155 of the Constitution to the Senate; the Senate was up to the task, approving the Government's position; also, the Courts, the Prosecutor's Office, and many media outlets. I believe it was a great effort, the result of a great national consensus, which was very reassuring, because that meant that, from the highest institution of the State to the smallest of Spaniards, they were willing, each in their area of responsibility, to fight for their nation and for national sovereignty.

B. Rubido.- Two criticisms that are made to you regarding the way of applying Article 155. One, why was TV3 not intervened, which is a machine for generating propaganda -- the concept of propaganda; not advertising, but political propaganda -- for independence?

Two, why were elections called so soon and was no time given for Catalan society to reflect on the moment it was living?

President.- TV3? The reason why no decisions were made regarding TV3 was because the Senate approved it that way. I have to go to the Senate. Here, what I say is not done; I have to go to the Senate and I have to go to Congress, and I have to seek support. So, I was mainly concerned about four issues: the first, the Treasury; the second, security; the third, the offices-embassies -- that is what some called them -- and, fourth, the issue you have inquired about.

As I said before, I had to negotiate. Of the four objectives I had, I achieved three, and I was unable to achieve one. This is the unequivocal demonstration that the President of the Government cannot do everything. But I believe that controlling the treasury, dismissing some individuals who had responsibilities in security matters, and closing all diplomatic offices within twenty-four hours is not bad. Undoubtedly, we could do many things; but you know that Spain is a plural country and there are opinions for all tastes, and the Government has many capabilities, but it must seek the necessary support to be able to do so.

B. Rubido.- The promoters of the Catalan insurrection should logically be judged, but what do you think should happen to them?

President.- I have the good habit of respecting one of the basic principles of our Constitution, which is also one of the fundamental principles upon which Europe has been built, which is the rule of law and the supremacy of the law. Therefore, we have one function, the Legislative Power has another, and judges and courts have another. And if the judges and courts have made the decisions they have made, my obligation as President of the Executive is to comply with them, respect them, and not comment on them.

B. Rubido.- Yesterday, the issue of the FLA arose, whether resources from the Autonomous Liquidity Fund were even used for the initiatives of the independence supporters. You said you were sure that they were not, but Minister Montoro expressed some doubts.

President.- The Autonomous Liquidity Fund is one of the most important operations that have been carried out in Spain in the last forty years. I apologize for saying it this way, but I believe in it: the Liquidity Fund, the Supplier Payment Fund, and the Social Fund; 240 billion euros, of which 64 billion have gone to Catalonia in loans. Thanks to that, the bankruptcy of Spain was avoided because if three or four Autonomous Communities had gone bankrupt, as was the situation we found ourselves in when we came to Government, it is evident that Spain would have gone bankrupt, there would have been a bailout, and we would have had many more problems than those faced by Greece or Portugal, because we are much larger.

The Autonomous Liquidity Fund, therefore, served, among other things, to maintain many companies, to maintain many jobs, and to ensure that many people who contracted with the Administration could get paid. From there, how does the Autonomous Liquidity Fund work? The money from the Autonomous Liquidity Fund is not given to the Autonomous Communities; it is given directly to the suppliers who were not getting paid and is given directly to the bank creditors; directly. Therefore, it is not managed by the Autonomous Community.

What I wanted to say is that it is evident, and let’s see if we all have a little good faith, that the Government of Spain does not dedicate itself to giving money to hold a referendum like this, and therefore, I have no knowledge that this has occurred. If it has occurred, I would appreciate it if someone could provide me with the invoice that proves that this has taken place, in which case I will rectify and say: evidently, there has been a fraud here.

But that is the story. The terrible thing is to be talking about a topic like this, with the importance and significance it has, and, in the end, to be discussing whether an invoice was given or not. Each one can do what they deem appropriate and convenient; but I, certainly, believe me, have a very clear conscience. If someone believes that I have paid an invoice—besides, as you know, I pay the invoices—to pay for the referendum, frankly, they are not very well.

B. Rubido.- Mr. Rajoy, speaking of the FLA, regarding the Autonomous Liquidity Fund, do you share with your Minister of Finance the idea that Mr. Montoro has suggested of making some debt write-off for the Autonomous Communities with the State?

President.- I usually agree with the Minister of Finance, for my own sake and because I believe he is a magnificent minister.

The model of autonomous financing that I want, and I tell you this after having participated in quite a few negotiations on models of autonomous financing… Moreover, from a region, because I was Vice President of the Xunta de Galicia, I negotiated a financing model—at that time it was Almunia who was negotiating it for the Government of Spain—and then I participated as Minister of Public Administrations, even as a leader of the Popular Party, in the negotiation of these models.

The best model of autonomous financing is one that is the product of a unanimous agreement; that is the best model. The current one, which everyone criticizes and which I voted against, among other things, had a problem that is that the main opposition party at that time, in 2009, did not support it. I am in favor of that, and there, when it is discussed, which is being discussed now, everyone will be able to give their opinion and everyone will be able to say whether it has been good or bad for Spain to have avoided the bankruptcy of some Autonomous Communities because if three or four Autonomous Communities—again, I repeat—had gone bankrupt, the others would have too; and the whole of Spain would have as well.

So, as so many times in life, sometimes one has to decide between the bad and the worse; but in the end, what always counts are the results, and, with absolute frankness, compare how Spain was in 2012 with how Spain is in 2018.

B. Rubido.- But this comes up because some president of an autonomous community, specifically from your own party, complained that those who mismanage are rewarded and those who maintain rigor are punished.

President.- But all of this with one objective, which is to save everyone because, if we do not try to help those who are in a lamentable situation, automatically we all find ourselves in an equally lamentable situation. That is why I tell you that the most intelligent thing is to try to ensure that everyone reaches an understanding: those who have complied better and those who have complied worse. That is the position that the Government will maintain, which on this matter has not yet made any decision.

B. Rubido.- Two questions to close the Catalan issue. One of them is: Did the Spanish State lack a winning strategy, not just in your Government? Probably, since the Statute of Autonomy was approved in Catalonia, the State has been absent from Catalonia all these years?

President.- The State has not been absent from Catalonia all these years. We were there, we invested, we worked, and we tried to find points of connection. In the end, we have a certain tendency to punish ourselves. So, instead of saying that the State is to blame, or because it did not make an offer, or because it did not… has anyone considered that the guilty party is the one who goes over the law, tries to take away from the Spaniards the right to express their opinion about what their country is, the right to decide, declares the suspension of the Constitution in part of the national territory, creates a parallel legality, and ignores the rulings of the Constitutional Court? Who is more guilty, that person or one, who could be me or any of the people who preceded me in office, who may have been right or wrong at a certain moment?

It is not the first time, unfortunately, in the history of Spain that we have experienced an event of this nature. I focus on the positive part, and the most positive part is that Spain, in a moment of difficulty like this, has managed to overcome the greatest economic crisis in a long time in our country, and there we are growing above the others. And then, there is a good message, which is Article 155. The message of Article 155 is that the Spanish nation has instruments to defend itself when it is attacked and Governments that are capable of using those instruments. That is the message of Article 155.

B. Rubido.- The last one, about Catalonia. President, how is it that a complaint is presented against the newspaper "ABC" for conducting an interview with Inés Arrimada on the day of...? If this is already almost overcome with new technologies! In any case, besides, is there not an opportunity, from this incident, to reform the Law in such a way that there is no day of reflection, because surveys can be published on any website, social networks stir in any way...? I think it is a bit outdated, beyond the fact that I am surprised that a complaint has been presented against us.

President.- The second consideration, which has now become the first, because the first has been the second in the last part of the closure of your intervention, is undoubtedly debatable and, without a doubt, it may seem reasonable that we modify the laws.

The other? One should not take it so badly. These things happen, are forgotten, and we move on.

B. Rubido.- I suppose the applause is for my question, of course.

President.- Absolutely. Who would have dared to think otherwise!

B. Rubido.- Mr. Rajoy, the Legislature, the relations with Ciudadanos… The leader of Ciudadanos has been saying, in one way or another, that there is no blank check of support for the Popular Party. We are in February and the approval of the Budget is not in sight. Is the disagreement with Ciudadanos putting the continuity of this Legislature at risk?

President.- I hope not. I, certainly, do not have any disagreement with Ciudadanos. I believe we made a pact at the beginning of the Legislature. Everyone knows it, it is being reasonably fulfilled, among its commitments was support for the Budgets and support for European policy, foreign policy, defense… It is functioning reasonably. Among parties, there can always be issues, but I am very calm, and I, certainly, will work to ensure that Ciudadanos honors its word, and I have no doubt that this will be the case. We have listened to them and will continue to do so until the last moment.

B. Rubido.- If the Budget is not approved, would you extend it, and could that shorten the Legislature?

President.- One should never assume the worst-case scenario; but even in the worst-case scenario in this case, we have, as I said in my initial intervention, a Budget already in force, which has been extended, which is that of 2017 and which should not be very bad because, among other things, it served for Spain to grow above 3 percent and for six hundred thousand new affiliates to be created in Social Security.

Therefore, I believe that in either of the two scenarios, with the first being preferable, all of us here and those who are outside can be calm.

B. Rubido.- I will take a break, not political. Since we are talking about pacts, with whom would you prefer to have a beer: with Pedro Sánchez or with Albert Rivera?

President.- A what?

B. Rubido.- A beer or a glass of wine. With whom would you go a bit more relaxed?

President.- I think with whoever could keep up with my pace.

B. Rubido.- Let’s move on to serious matters. The Historical Memory Law seems to be getting a second twist from the Socialist Party. It even proposes in some cases that those who may make a positive reference to the Francoist era could be sanctioned with imprisonment—says the text or the proposal from the Socialist Party. Do you not think that, one, it is an attack on freedom of expression and, two, that perhaps you missed an opportunity to have annulled, when you had an absolute majority, that Law which only generates confrontation among Spaniards?

President.- I believe one thing. Spain carried out one of the most brilliant political operations remembered in a long time, which was the Transition. What happens is that here we have a certain tendency to recount how badly we do some things and we are incapable of saying that there are things that are very positive.

The Transition, and I can say this with confidence because I was not there, was a great political operation. There, people who were in exile and people who had been members of Franco's Governments came to an agreement. There was generosity, there was intelligence, there was skill, and that Transition did not go so badly because I believe we have lived, with some problems we have had, through the forty best years of our history as a nation. I believed that when the Transition occurred, the Spaniards, very intelligently, said: let’s look forward, we are not going to look back because that serves very little.

Therefore, you will never find me in a position to dedicate myself to reviewing the past; I will never do it, and others can do what they see fit; but, of course, it will not be with my agreement.

B. Rubido.- In the case of what is currently moving around the Basque Country and the Basque Nationalist Party, there is talk of a reform of the Statute that also gives it a twist, and they even talk about the right to decide. Does that worry you?

President.- The relations we have here with the Basque Nationalist Party are good, and moreover, they are people who have fulfilled their commitments; we have too. It is evident that I am not going to support the right to decide, as everyone knows.

The PNV has presented the conclusions of some discussions that have taken place in recent months, and the Popular Party presents others. I, logically, am closer to what Alfonso Alonso has presented, I am with them, than to what other parties may present. And from there, everyone will have to make an effort to build, respecting, of course, the frameworks and procedures that we have established together.

B. Rubido .- Apart from the proposal you made regarding the rescue of pension plans, although I believe that what needed to be modified was the fiscal part to further incentivize savings… I am not going to enter that debate now, because we are running out of time and I did not want to miss the opportunity, Mr. Rajoy. Perhaps there are major debates such as the demographic suicide of Spain or the difficulties with pensions; but, for example, there is this new economy, the emergence of the big Internet giants, and the question -- these are long-term questions, fundamental issues -- that I want to ask you is: when can the Government of Spain and the European Union seriously consider the role of these Internet giants who do not pay taxes, who go against the economy of some countries and who seem, at times, in the day-to-day of the political class, to have nothing to do with it, but, however, in the day-to-day of citizens, a lot?

President .- I believe that this is, indeed, a very important issue. I believe that companies must pay their taxes where they obtain their profits, whether they are called Amazon or whatever they want to be called.

I also believe that we are talking about a very global world, of large multinationals, and this is an issue in which one cannot fight the battle alone. That is why we, together with France, Germany, and Italy, have approached the European Commission to take this seriously. Work is being done thoroughly, and I hope that the results will be positive and that what I said at the beginning, that everyone must pay, first, their taxes, and, second, where they obtain their profits, becomes a reality. In fact, the Commission is already functioning, and there have been very important economic sanctions, for example, I believe I recall against Apple in Ireland and I also believe I recall against Amazon in Luxembourg.

I believe that we must work intensively. One of the things I would like us to advance towards in the future is the Corporate Tax. I believe that this can be done across Europe, I believe that this, without a doubt, would help us, and from there, I agree with what you say and it is one of the great challenges we have ahead in the future.

B. Rubido .- We cannot finish without this question. The Socialist Party has reproached you for not proposing a woman to the European Central Bank, and I suppose you will take the opportunity to, instead of Luis de Guindos, appoint a woman, right? Will the Minister of Economy be a woman? I was just wondering if we could get an exclusive from here.

President .- I do not rule out that the Minister of Economy will be a woman, nor do I rule out that it will be a man. We will see. But I believe that in the Popular Party, fortunately for us, we have many important women in positions of responsibility: look, the president of the Cortes, the third authority of the State; the president of the Community of Madrid; the Minister of Defense and Secretary General of the Popular Party… I am well accompanied.

B. Rubido .- Thank you very much, Mr. President. I had many questions to ask you, but we have run out of time. Thank you very much.

President .- Thank you very much.