Interview with President of the Government on the programme "Las mañanas de Radio Nacional de España" [Morning time on Spanish National Radio]

Spain Mariano Rajoy · Prime Minister of Spain

20 November 2013 · Interview on the programme "Las mañanas de Radio Nacional de España" · Radio Nacional de España

Context
Rajoy appeared on Spanish National Radio's morning programme on 20 November 2013 to assess the midpoint of his legislative term and Spain's economic situation.
Main themes
Economic recovery and austerity measures, mid-term legislative assessment, job creation and growth, tax increases and fiscal policy, public deficit reduction, gratitude to Spanish people, personal income tax reform, export performance, financial system stabilization, quitting smoking
Duration
~89 min
98th percentile
Words
10,629
98th percentile
Sentences
556
98th percentile
Readability
63
92nd percentile
Grade
8.9
10th percentile
Syntax
2.86
29th percentile
Vocabulary
1.91
3rd percentile

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

556 sentences in 210 paragraphs

Mr Rajoy, Mr President of the Government, how are you? Good morning.

President of the Government.- Good morning. I am very pleased to see you here today.

A. Menéndez.- Thank you very much for receiving us, for wanting to take stock with us and with the listeners of Radio Nacional de España. First of all, I have just heard that you have given up smoking, Mr Rajoy.

President of the Government.- I am trying to. I stopped on 13 October this year, in other words, a whole month and seven days without smoking, and I would recommend to everyone that they try it, although it is hard; but, for the time being, it is working. It's still early days but I hope to see it through - it makes a lot of sense.

A. Menéndez.- One month and seven days is a long time without smoking, isn't it?

President of the Government.- In my case, it's just a start!

A. Menendez.- Congratulations on having given up smoking.

President of the Government.- Thank you very much. I have to keep going and it's taking a lot of will-power.

A. Menéndez.- Today is 21 November and yesterday, if we had to look for an exact half-way point in the legislature, taking into account that the elections were held two years ago, would have been the exact half-way point of the current legislature. You took stock of things in the corridor of the Lower House but today we have more time to perform this exercise. Do you dare give a mark as to how this legislature is going so far Mr Rajoy, or is that too precise?

President of the Government.- No. I daren't give myself a mark, because I should neither be too harsh on myself nor be too vain, because a mark can only be given after the final exam. Let's say that I am taking my mid-terms and that the final exam will be at the end of the legislature and, then, we can take stock definitively. For the time being, what we have done during the course of these past two years since coming to power is try to overcome an initial situation that was very serious. We are laying the foundations for the economy to grow and create jobs. Some positive figures are starting to filter through, but, for the time being, it is still too early even to judge oneself.

A. Menéndez.- We are going to speak a lot about the economy in the coming minutes. I would also like to know, or rather, in this case, highlight the message of gratitude that you sent to the Spanish people yesterday for their hard work over the last two years.

President of the Government.- Yes. In reality, yesterday from the corridors of Parliament I wanted to thank the Spanish people. We are aware of the decisions that we have taken over these last two years. Just think about it, at almost the first Council of Ministers that took place only eight days after we came to power, on 30 December 2011, we took a tough decision, which wasn't in our election manifesto, to raise Personal Income Tax. I hope to turn this around before the end of this legislature.

But we took the decision, and many others, because there was no alternative. In other words, the deficit was so disproportionate, the debt was so high, it was almost impossible to get financing from the markets, and right from the very first moment, we had to take tough decisions. We have raised taxes, except in the case of entrepreneurs and for hiring young people, which we have lowered; but we have raised Personal Income Tax, VAT and also special taxes. We have taken tough decisions affecting public servants; last year we eliminated their Christmas bonus.

They are difficult decisions that no-one likes to take, but that were absolutely necessary and that, I repeat, lay solid foundations for the future, to be able to grow and create jobs, and I believe that some results are starting to be seen and that we will see even more next year, in 2014.

A. Menéndez.- In this part of the results, logically tied to the economy, growth of one tenth of a percentage of GDP, and yesterday we became aware of the export figures… What many of our people and our listeners are asking is when this economic recovery will start to be felt in their pockets.

President of the Government.- That is the million dollar question that our citizens have to ask and to which I would like to answer as soon as possible; in other words, for them to see that now, isn't that right? Well, I would like to say one thing. The economy, like many other things in life, cannot be fixed with one regulation, or one decree-law, or one speech; a lot of work needs to be done, many decisions need to be taken and many areas need to be seen to at the same time. But, if we don't sort out the situation of what is called the macro-economy, in other words, the public deficit, if we don't sort out the foreign trade deficit, if we don't sort out inflation and if we don't sort out the financial system, it will impossible to see anything later.

There are already some positive figures. The risk premium, which last year recorded some astronomical figures, has gone down this year. That means that people are starting to have confidence in the Spanish economy and that has meant we have saved six billion euros in servicing debt this year alone. That is highly significant.

Exports, which you mentioned before, are on the rise and to a considerable extent. We are the European Union country that has enjoyed the greatest growth in exports. That is good, because it means that we are producing here and selling abroad, and, if we are producing here, there are also jobs here, because these are people working in Spain. That is very important.

Prices? Inflation stands at virtually nil. Prices are not rising.

In other words, these are positive figures.

Employment? This is going badly and is our main challenge; but we can already see some good indications, since the October figures are better than twelve months ago.

We must push on. This encourages us, but there is still a long way to go.

A. Menéndez.- Will we finish the legislature with fewer unemployed than at the start of the legislature?

President of the Government.- I am convinced we will. Last year, 2012, was a very bad year; together with 2009, the worst of the crisis. This year, 2013, will be a better year in terms of employment and in the month of October, for example, on 31 October 2013, we had fewer young people under the age of 35 unemployed, thirty odd thousand less than last year. That is an important figure and I believe that this will be the trend for 2014 and 2015, and to that end we have taken all the decisions that we have had to take over these last two years.

A. Menéndez.- Are you in a position to tell me if there will be any more adjustment measures or any more cuts? Brussels demands, or it seemed to demand this, and even put a figure on it: 35 billion euros. I don't know whether before the end of the year there will be any new measures or if there will be any more adjustments or cuts before the end of this legislature, Mr Rajoy.

President of the Government.- If there are, it is because they are necessary but not at the same level as we have had to take in these two years. I believe that it is now a question of growing and increasing revenue, as well as of making structural reforms. In other words, for example, this year civil servants will receive their Christmas bonus and we have not had to take any further measures on healthcare matters, nor in regards to education. I believe that at this time we are in a position to say that there will not be any further major adjustments, such as those we have had to take in the last two years.

There will be structural reforms. The reform of the public administration service is under way. I will present an extensive report in January next year on the progress made, which is significant, on the reform of the public administration services, which will make life easier for our citizens and will result in significant savings. The Law on Market Unity is also out there; also the reform of the pension system, the de-indexing of the economy… In other words, we must continue to make structural reforms to become more competitive and to have an economy that can grow and create jobs.

A. Menéndez.- You have mentioned the Christmas bonus that public servants will receive this year. Will last year's bonus ever be paid, and if so, when?

President of the Government.- That will be paid out as from 2015 in the terms established back then by the Minister for the Treasury.

A. Menéndez.- Is that the message you would send to the public servants?

President of the Government.- Yes, that's the message.

A. Menéndez.- And as regards pensions, which were in the news just a few hours ago. In the end, the ceiling of the pension increase which was going to be the CPI plus 0.25% will now be a little higher: the CPI plus 0.5%. Is that correct?

President of the Government.- That's right. The minimum will be 0.25% and the maximum will be 0.5%. Now, just look at this year. The latest CPI announced was -0.1%. This year pensions will rise by 1% and 2%. All those higher than 1,000 euros will rise by 1% and those below by 2% and yet, in the end, the CPI will be, let's work this out, ah, around 0.5 or 0.4%. That is a highly significant figure.

The subject of the pensions is a very important subject for our future. Of all the money spent by Spanish taxpayers and handled by the government that I head up, just look, we spend 125 billion euros on pensions and, if you remove unemployment benefits, which is a little over 30 billion euros, the rest of the ministerial departments, which is a further 30 billion euros; and then pensions, 125 billion euros. So, it is very important that we have a consolidated, safe and reliable pension system for the future, and it is very important that we have a lot of people working, because those who work and contribute are those paying today's pensions, and those who will work in the future will pay our pensions.

A. Menéndez.- Is there any possibility that the base rate of pensions, for want of a better word, will be changed again after this modification of the ceiling in this revaluation process? Is it possible that this 0.25% will be increased at the lower level during its passage through Parliament?

President of the Government.- No, I don't think so. Such an increase is not being contemplated in its passage through Parliament.

A. Menéndez.- Within the economic measures and announcements we have been speaking about, and which I repeat is the opening part of this interview, you have spoken to me about taxation, about the fiscal reform which is pointing to and leading up to an announcement that will take place next year, as I understand it, in 2014. Where is this fiscal reform heading? What can you announce to me here and now, Mr President of the Government?

President of the Government.- Very little, because what we have done is commission a group of experts to draw up a proposal and, logically, I shouldn't jump ahead things, but let's see. We have to have a fiscal system; by the way, I would like to say to you that this fiscal reform will be accompanied by a reform of the regional financing model, in other words, clearly distributing State taxes and taxes which fall under the regional governments. Hence, this is one of the major structural reforms pending, and one which we intend to present in the first quarter, towards the end of the first quarter of next year.

I believe that the fiscal reform must be fundamentally designed to help entrepreneurs: to help small- and medium-sized enterprises, and to help the self-employed. Indeed, as I said before, we have raised VAT - in fact, our VAT is still below the European average - Personal Income Tax, which is high, and special taxes; and we have reduced or established National Insurance breaks, tax breaks, and lower Corporate Income Tax rates for entrepreneurs. In other words, Spain needs entrepreneurs, Spain and the rest of the world; because entrepreneurs create well-being and wealth, and they create jobs. Hence, the priority objective of the fiscal reform is to help society take risks, to help society to make an effort, to help society to create businesses, to create small companies with two workers or four, five, six, ten or fifteen, because that is the future of Spain.

Therefore, a key issue of the fiscal reform is to help entrepreneurs. I always tell young people… The other day I had a meeting with the young members of my party here and I told them that it is very important to be entrepreneurial and, if it doesn't work out the first time, it doesn't matter. A young man aged 24, 25 or 28 can fail once, twice or three times and it doesn't matter. In the end, he will learn from this. Hence, the basis of the fiscal reform is to help enterprise, because entrepreneurs create jobs, well-being and wealth.

A. Menéndez.- Will there be any change in the VAT rate, or in any product that will change category, to put it that way, or in the cultural VAT rate even?

President of the Government.- No decision has been taken in this respect yet. We have had to raise VAT, as everyone knows. The European Commission asked us to raise VAT even more, they even asked us to raise VAT for tourism and the hotel and catering industry to 21% instead of its current 10%. This is a very important sector, we didn't do it and I would have even preferred to have lowered it. I am aware of the problems with the cultural VAT; however, in the case of books it stands at 4%. This is the super-reduced VAT rate, while for other cultural products it is higher.

We are not going to change anything right now, for 2014 we are not going to change any VAT rates, not for products taxed in one way or another; but in the future we cannot discount anything. But now, in the short and medium term I can't see any major modifications being made.

A. Menéndez.- From what you are saying, any possible modifications will be made for 2015.

President of the Government.- I don't think we will even be making any VAT changes for 2015.

A. Menéndez.- Not even cultural VAT?

President of the Government.- That is not a decision that has been taken yet. It cannot be discounted but the decision hasn't been taken. What we do want to do is reduce Personal Income Tax.

A. Menéndez.- Are you concerned by Spanish investments in Ibero-America, investments by Spanish companies; we have recently been talking about Repsol, and about a possible front opening up, even with PEMEX? Does this certain instability concern you regarding Spanish interests in certain countries in Ibero-America… countries like Venezuela, although there are others without this level of instability?

President of the Government.- Ibero-America is a major priority for us. I have crossed the Atlantic nine times since I became President of the Government. We have very good relations, there are many business owners and many SMEs opening up in Ibero-America, and our exports to Ibero-America have increased significantly.

We have investments there; we are the second leading country in the world in terms of investments in Ibero-America, after the United States, and we export there, albeit not to a great degree. Just look, yesterday I was reviewing the export figures and we export more to Portugal than to the whole of Ibero-America. That is a truly noteworthy figure. More to Portugal. We must export more.

Am I concerned? We have had some problems… We have had problems in the case of YPF-Repsol in Argentina. I have a wonderful relationship with the President of Mexico and PEMEX is a shareholder, a major shareholder in Repsol. The Minister for Industry, José Manuel Soria, met last week with the Chairman of PEMEX in Mexico City and with the Mexican State Secretary for Energy, and I hope that all these problems get resolved. I am not overly concerned by the case of Repsol.

A. Menéndez.- And in the case of Venezuela, taking into account that just a few hours ago President Maduro passed a law endowing him with super-powers, even to govern by decree. I imagine any kind of Spanish exporter to Venezuela must be concerned by the legal certainty there.

President of the Government.- I am not going to make value judgements, above all, to anticipate events. At this point in time there are no grounds to indicate that Spanish investors will not be respected in other countries, and I am convinced that this will be the case.

A. Menéndez.- The banking bailout, if you like, to close off economic matters, because I would like to move on to other areas. Will the banking bailout cost the Spanish people money?

President of the Government.- The banking bailout is a 10-year loan, with a 10 year grace period, in other words, nothing is paid back for 10 years and then interest of 0.5%. That will then become public debt in 10 years' time, but it would have been far more expensive for us not to have concluded this operation. In other words, we would have had to pay the deposit-holders of all the financial institutions. Hence, I believe the decision taken was the right one. A country cannot survive without a financial system, and, of course, we have invested a lot less money than important countries like the United Kingdom and Germany. We have paid in a part of our GDP, but both Germany and the United Kingdom, and even the United States, have had to invest much higher amounts of their public resources.

A. Menéndez.- We are taking stock of a legislature, Mr Rajoy, in which the 'Bárcenas affair' has also been newsworthy. This has resulted in your appearance before the Lower House of Parliament, perhaps even because of front-page shocks, publications and news articles. I would like to ask you for your assessment of where we are in terms of the 'Bárcenas affair'.

President of the Government.- This is an affair… The most important thing I have to say on this matter is that I hope it never happens again, not an affair like this, nor similar affairs such as those we have seen recently.

A meeting will be held today in the Lower House of Parliament at which, on the part of the State Secretary for Parliamentary Relations, in other words, the Partido Popular, a raft of measures will be proposed to the other parliamentary groups that I announced at the Debate on the State of the Nation and that we intend to submit to Parliament before the year is out. It involves increasing controls, greater liability of public officials, demanding a much higher level of transparency from political parties… Hence, I hope that this will be useful for the purposes you have mentioned.

As regard the heart of the matter, I have given my explanations to Parliament. The last time I spent five hours in a debate on 1 August in Parliament. At the moment, this matter is in the hands of the judiciary and I will respect and comply with whatever ruling they hand down, as is usual. But, I repeat, the most important thing now is to avoid these things happening again in the future.

A. Menéndez.- Do you regret having said or done anything in the last few months in relation to this matter? For example, do you regret not having dismissed the former treasurer Luis Bárcenas?

President of the Government.- In fact, the 'Gürtel affair" came to light in 2009 and Luis Bárcenas has ceased to be the treasurer of the Partido Popular, and even a Member of the Upper House, for a long time. He was neither the treasurer nor a Member of the Upper House in 2010, and three years have gone by since this affair. But, could we have done things much better? I am sure we could have, but we also learn from our mistakes.

A. Menéndez.- So, if you could turn the clock back, you would have dismissed Mr Bárcenas sooner?

President of the Government.- In reality, I think he stopped being treasurer after only four or five months. But, of course, we need to go back to 2009, and in 2009, one is privy to certain information and then, later, one is privy to other information. That's the way things are.

A. Menéndez.- I would also like to ask you, because this is a current affair, week in, week out, about the sovereignty issue of Catalonia, the territorial model, the possibility of an enquiry, or not, within the Spanish legal system. Do you agree with former President of the Government Aznar when he says that he is in favour of a custodial sentence for those who call illegal referendums?

President of the Government.- I think that on the matter of Catalonia… I will give you my opinion on the matter of Catalonia and how I see the matter.

I have spent a lot of time on the situation of Catalonia in the last two years since we came to power. Catalonia has some very serious problems; and other less serious problems; but some of the problems are indeed very serious. Its most serious problems include the extremely high level of unemployment, the very high level of accumulated public debt, its difficulties in paying the suppliers of the Regional Government itself or of certain local authorities and its impossibility of turning to the markets for financing. That is what we have tried to resolve.

The government, with the liquidity instruments that it has implemented, has allocated 29 billion euros to Catalonia to finance its debt, to pay suppliers and to finance its public deficit; 6 billion euros of which was to pay suppliers alone. This very week, 1.4 billion euros to pay suppliers. We have paid more than 900,000 invoices to 35,000 suppliers.

I believe that this is our main priority; the government has attended to the need of this main priority and it has done so because it is its obligation and its wish to do so. And the main objective is for Catalonia to be able to turn to the markets soon, to obtain financing and to pay suppliers without any problems, and I believe that the efforts made by everyone should be aimed at achieving this.

Aside from that, my position is well known; my position as Mariano Rajoy or as a member of the Partido Popular. I believe in the unity of Spain. Spain is the oldest country in Europe, we have spent more than 500 years living together. Catalonia and the rest of Spain are united by emotional, trade and personal ties, by all manner of ties. We have done many things together during our history and we will have to do many more. We have a project ahead of us which is the European project. We have to find our place in the word. We have to be great, because that is the way to play a part in this world, to exist and to improve our level of well-being and wealth. Hence, that is what I am going to defend, as indeed everyone knows.

And, as President of the Government, I only want to say one thing: the President of the Government is the first one to follow the law and ensure it is followed, and one thing that I am not going to allow under any circumstance, and my counterparts in the Regional Government of Catalonia are aware of this, is any encroachment on our national sovereignty. Whatever Spain will be shall be decided by the Spanish people and no Spaniard will be excluded from the decision regarding what they want their country to be.

Having said that, I hope that "seny" [common sense in Catalan], which was spoken about on so many occasions, wins the day and that common sense prevails. And I will do whatever I am able to do to achieve that.

I am not going to stir up trouble; but neither am I disposed, of course, to encroach on our national sovereignty. As long as I am the President of the Government of Spain, no-one is going to trifle with this or with Articles 1 and 2 of the Spanish Constitution.

A. Menéndez.- Will José María Aznar's words smooth the way or not? Or in fact just the opposite?

President of the Government.- I take responsibility for my words and I talk about what I am going to do. You will appreciate that I cannot go into what other people say, regardless of how qualified they may be, as is the case of Mr Aznar. It is an opinion that I respect, as I may respect other opinions. But I will stay with what I said; I answer to my actions alone.

A. Menéndez.- One more point on this matter. Are you annoyed by the "I take note" that he said? When José María Aznar presented the book, he left us with a somewhat scathing phrase. Well… that's Aznar. We all know what he's like. He said, "I take note of the absentees". I don't know if that annoyed you.

President of the Government.- No, no. In this matter there is a story that is doing the rounds, and all of us who live in this world are absolutely aware that it is a story that will continue doing the rounds.

A. Menéndez.- Can you tell us the story

President of the Government.- Well, about what must be said, about how such and such is interpreted, about what we are going to do, about what this means…

Having said that, I should say that I have had a wonderful relationship with Mr Aznar for many years now and I am absolutely convinced that this will remain so in the future. Aside from that, the story will continue doing the rounds, but it is not a matter that involves me. We have a wonderful relationship.

A. Menéndez.- " Parot Doctrine ". Almost 50 people have been released from prison. I believe it was a month and a day ago that the European Court of Human Rights overturned this doctrine; we have been counting this almost form the very first minute. What can we do to avoid hurting the victims twice over as a result of prisoners being released?

President of the Government.- The hurt the victims are feeling is absolutely logical and normal. It wouldn't be logical or normal for them not to feel hurt. I said at the time, and I will say it again, that I don't like the decision adopted by the European court. I don't like it firstly because I can seen the pain it causes the victims; and furthermore, I have been the Minister for Home Affairs and I know how hard it has been to capture some of these people who have now been released from prison. I know the work that the Guardia Civil have put in, the work that the National Police Force have put in and the work that the National Intelligence Centre has put in. Many people have worked very hard and have risked their lives. I am aware of all of that. I know how difficult it was to catch these people

Aside from that, what we cannot do now is attack the judges. It's not fair, because these judges taking the decisions now are only doing so on orders handed down in the European ruling. And these same judges are the ones who prosecuted these offenders, who put them in prison and who sentenced them to harsh custodial sentences. They are the same judges.

Hence, this is not an easy situation; it is a very difficult situation; but the European courts, and we are part of that system, have taken their decision. What we must do is continue working. I said at the time that "the government has not negotiated with ETA, nor will it negotiate with ETA", and I hope that justice prevails in the end. And at the end of the day, as normally happens, justice ends up prevailing.

A. Menéndez.- Is there any possibility that these ex-convicts - there is a petition currently in its passage through Parliament, which I believe also has the support of the Partido Popular or that may receive its support - cannot opt for any form of aid, or grant, or subsidy, or pay out, until they repent?

President of the Government.- Yes, only in those cases in which they repent. Yes. That is a resolution that has been voted on with our support in the Lower House of Parliament and which will soon be drawn up as a legislative initiative.

A. Menéndez.- Will it go any further or will it be this…?

President of the Government.- No, it will be what the Lower House of Parliament decides.

A. Menéndez.- And in this matter, do you feel that the Partido Popular has distanced itself somewhat from the victims' associations?

President of the Government.- Look, I don't feel that. I have been Minister for Home Affairs. I have gone through many things, as have many other people. I have attended many funerals related to truly dramatic affairs. I have seen many injustices and many broken families. I believe that the Partido Popular has always been on the victims' side and it will always be on the victims' side, doing whatever it can to provide comfort and support. Do we always get it right? I'm not going to say we do, but, of course, our intention and will is the one I have just mentioned.

A. Menéndez.- Do you expect a definitive gesture from ETA during the rest of this legislature? Will the Partido Popular be in government when the matter is finally laid to rest?

President of the Government.- I believe that what ETA, which has not killed anyone for some years now, must do is break up and declare that it has done so. This no longer makes sense. It has never made sense, but much less so now. These things never make sense but, if they are waiting for the government to do something, they'll have a long wait. We are waiting for the dissolution of ETA and that is what all democrats must work towards together.

A. Menéndez.- One of the subjects that arouses passions among the political class and the press is the renewal of the General Council of the Judiciary. This then needs explaining to the people, because it is a complicated matter; it is not an easy matter to understand. Is it correct, Mr Rajoy that today you will get in touch, by phone, with Mr Pérez Rubalcaba, to close this matter off once and for all?

President of the Government.- Yes, I speak with Mr Pérez Rubalcaba...

A. Menéndez.- Every day?

President of the Government.- Good heavens no.

A. Menéndez.- Or do you send messages or the suchlike?

President of the Government.- Of course we speak. It would be worrying if we didn't. Just imagine if we didn't speak about Europe and about how to defend Spain at a European level, or if we didn't speak about Catalonia... Where it is more difficult to reach a consensus is on economic policy. Just imagine if we didn't speak about the revamping of the institutions; it is clear that one party cannot and should not do so by itself, however clear a majority it has; that would be worrying, wouldn't it? In other words, talking - then, if you reach an agreement, so much the better - is, of course, something very important in life. And you lose nothing by talking; at least, that's my opinion.

As regards the General Council of the Judiciary, what is important for me about the General Council of the Judiciary is that it performs its role and does so well. Isn't that right? The process is now under way and I believe that the process will be concluded in the days to come. I believe an agreement will be reached and I am very pleased that this is the case. This is a difficult subject; if an agreement is reached we will be subject to criticism and if an agreement is not reached we will equally be subject to criticism, because we are incapable of reaching an agreement. But listen, neither must this be given undue importance.

The key is that the persons elected, in the same way as we elected the members of the Constitutional Court, act independently and fulfil the duties entrusted to them by Parliament.

A. Menéndez.- The matter at hand is that you said something else in your election manifesto. You didn't speak about a distribution with the same quota from each political party but rather that the judges would decide for themselves.

President of the Government.- In that case there is a double legitimacy because all the judges that have put their names forward to Parliament to be elected as members of the General Council of the Judiciary need to be backed by their fellow judges and others are put forward by their own association. So they need support from their fellow judges - without the backing of the judiciary they can never be elected - and then they also need the backing of Parliament.

Hence, I believe that there is a double legitimacy and to reach an agreement one needs to give ground in respect of one's initial approach.

A. Menéndez.- But that wasn't in your election manifesto, was it?

President of the Government.- Whenever you reach an agreement it is very difficult to reach this agreement by imposing your conditions on the other party. You must give some ground, must you not? If not, it is not an agreement, but a fixed contract.

A. Menéndez.- The matter of Gibraltar is in the spotlight again, Mr Rajoy. It seems like it's August, it's that cold in the streets, and it seems like it's August again with this incident of an oceanographic vessel in waters in the Bay of Algericas; with the words of Mr Picardo, the Chief Minister of the Rock, saying - it seems like a provocation to me, but it's a value judgement - that it could be confused with the patrol vessels of the Guardia Civil and that, perhaps it would even end up in shots being fired. That's where the quoting stops. Close inverted commas if you will allow me.

With this matter, are relations between Madrid and London close to reaching some kind of solution or not?

President of the Government.- Relations between the United Kingdom and Spain are excellent. Since I became President of the Government, I have met on various occasions with Mr Cameron, who has visited Spain, and I have visited London and we see each other often at Council meetings in Brussels. We have spoken about this matter and there is no reason why this matter should undermine relations between the United Kingdom and Spain, and from my point of view, that is not going to happen.

Aside from that, the European Commission has just visited Gibraltar and the European Commission has just announced that the controls imposed on the border by the Spanish Government are correct, which we already knew, but this has now been ratified by the European Commission. I stated that smuggling goes on in Gibraltar, a lot of smuggling. Gibraltar is a tax haven and Gibraltar is in breach of environmental regulations. We cannot accept these matters and we are not going to accept them. We have already filed a complaint with the European Commission for the environmental breaches, also for certain tax matters and, of course, we are going to control the smuggling operations going on between Gibraltar and La Línea.

A. Menéndez.- What is happening is that London… What is happening? Are they bad losers? Is that why they called in Ambassador Federico Trillo and they want to consult him or they want to meet with him, after Brussels stated that they are not quite as right as they think they are?

President of the Government.- I am not going to go into this matter. My obligation it to maintain good relations with the British people and that is what I will do; but my obligation is also to defend the interests of the Spanish people and, of course, that is what I will also do.

A. Menéndez.- Matters that greatly concern our citizens. I appreciate that all of those we have spoken about fall into this category but there are also specific issues that greatly concern the man in the street, such as healthcare and education.

When this crisis is over, Mr Rajoy, will healthcare - I know that you are going to say that this has been transferred to the regional governments - when this crisis is over, continue to be the same healthcare that we receive now or are we inevitably condemned to change to another model; perhaps like that in Madrid, for example?

President of the Government.- I hope that even better. Let me tell you a few things. In the same way as there are things to do on the matter of education, and, in fact, we are doing things to improve the quality of education, Spanish healthcare is one of the best in the world. Sometimes, we have a certain tendency to punish ourselves and to say how good others are and how bad ours are. Out healthcare system is among the best in the world and those who work in Spanish healthcare are among the best professionals in the world. And sometimes, we should be proud of the good things we have, shouldn't we?

I hope that Spanish healthcare continues to be among the best in the world. Good healthcare is expensive. We spend, as I said before, 125 billion euros on pensions; this is the budgetary item on which most funding goes; but the second item is healthcare, on which we spend around 70 billion per year. Just imagine, all the ministerial departments together (Public Works, Development, the Guardia Civil, Security, Defence, etc.) all amount to 30 billion euros whereas 80 billion euros are spent on our health system; but that is important because healthcare is important to the people, as you can imagine. And I am absolutely convinced that Spanish healthcare will get increasingly better and, I can tell you that it is among the best in the world.

A. Menéndez.- Is the model to follow that of the Region of Madrid: the externalisation/privatisation model?

President of the Government.- The model to follow is that which provides the best healthcare to the people. In other words, the one that cures people the fastest is the best. That is the model to follow.

On certain occasions services can be externalised, which already happens in many autonomous regions; in others it is perhaps not suitable. What is important is that healthcare is free, universal and good quality. Whether the service is provided by one hospital or another seems merely secondary to me. I have gone on occasions… I normally use the public system, I normally go to one of the public hospitals, but I have also used the private system. What is important is that it is good and is not a burden to the taxpayer.

A. Menéndez.- Now that we are dealing with specific matters, in this case the Ministry of Health, will the Anti-Tobacco Act be amended so that people can smoke at Eurovegas, Mr Rajoy?

President of the Government.- No decision has been taken on the matter. Firstly, we will proceed with those procedures that are still pending, above all, at a European level, and then, this will be the last decision that is taken. The Region of Madrid wants to do this and the government is not looking on it unfavourably. There are lots of jobs at stake. Madrid could become a centre of attraction for European citizens and those from many other places.. But, at any event, it is a matter on which we must have a close look, see how it can be done, see how to avoid it being disruptive and causing the least problems for people. I repeat, no decision has yet been taken on this matter.

A. Menéndez.- If smoking is not allowed, will the investment be lost or is that a little over-dramatic? I don't know.

President of the Government.- It's a lot more complicated than that.

A. Menéndez.- Is it more complicated?

President of the Government.- Yes.

A. Menéndez.- And as regards education, Mr Rajoy… We have come from the "white tide", which is healthcare, and in terms of education, also with a high dissatisfaction rate, we have the "green tide" or has it been given another colour? There are those who say that the best way to provide support for Mr Wert is to criticise him during the parliamentary passage which, by the way, will today come before the Upper House. I don't know whether you agree.

President of the Government.- I have been Minister for Education. It is not an easy ministerial department, it is complicated and one where decisions already generate conflict. I know about the Ministry of Education because I held that post.

I believe that the Minister for Education has followed the electoral manifesto of the Partido Popular, I believe that he has been very brave, he has spoken with a lot of people, he has taken a step forward and, of course, he has the full support of the government, and of course, of the President of the Government.

Aside from that, we should pause for reflection because, if not, it is very difficult for us to reach a conclusion. 25% of pupils that start their studies do not finish them, not even compulsory secondary education (Spanish acronym: ESO). There is a school drop-out rate of 25%, or one in four. The PISA Report, which establishes educational quality in various countries, places Spain in maths, in reading comprehension and in other subjects at the bottom of the table of the OECD countries. In a situation like this two things can be done: nothing, and stay as we are, or try to improve the quality of education. We have opted for the latter and that is very important. In Spain there is a very high level of youth unemployment. Let me tell you something: the better trained these people are the greater their chances of finding a job.

The other day the Heads of State and Government held a debate in Europe on the Digital Agenda. Just imagine what a spectacular figure this is: this year in Europe there are 300,000 vacant places for specialists in Information and Communication Technologies because there were insufficient qualified staff available, and by the year 2015 - the report was presented to us there by José Manuel Durao Barroso - this could rise to 900,000. Listen, we must make an effort for people to familiarise themselves with these new technologies because there are possibilities in that field to find a job.

Hence, education must adapt, it must undergo reform and it must look at how the world is and what jobs are in demand. And that is our education reform. Now, I understand that the Socialist Party and others don't like it, because the only model here in Spain to date has been their model. The only thing I want is not to see a school drop-out rate of 25% and for our pupils to leave with a better skill set. That is all I want and I believe it is a wish that may be shared by many other people.

A. Menéndez.- Has it really not been possible to reach an agreement? You are accused of going ahead with this by yourselves. Was there no room for negotiation, for a rapprochement?

President of the Government.- No, not at all. We have done everything in our hands but they didn't want to. Just imagine, in the last few years the only Education Acts in force in Spain were drafted by the Socialist Party. We passed a law in our last term of office and within 48 hours of coming to power the new government passed a Decree-Law repealing the Act enacted by the Partido Popular; within 48 hours of coming to power and by Decree-Law.

This has been debated a great deal, and I believe that that is important and, above all, we need to look at what is being done in Europe, we should place great emphasis on Vocational Training - great emphasis, because there are many jobs to be found there in the future - but we must be aware of one thing: today we are operating in a highly global world, that is very open and very competitive; nowadays people move around the world, from one side to another, and so, nowadays you cannot compete with those from the next town, or with your neighbour; you now have to compete with the United Kingdom or Germany, and jobs are sought at a global level.

So it is very important to receive training, to learn, to study and know, above all, about those things in which there will be job offers in the future. Just imagine what I have said: 900,000 jobs in Information and Communication Technologies.

A. Menéndez.- And precisely because of this experience, as a former minister, there were people saying that Minister Wert will not be tucking into his Christmas dinner at the ministry this year; that there will be a crisis and a cabinet reshuffle before Christmas. It is my duty to ask you about this, Mr Rajoy.

President of the Government.- I have no intention of making any cabinet reshuffle before Christmas and, if possible, not during this term of office. I believe that the government is working very hard indeed. Many reforms have been made. Of course, I said yesterday, and you reminded me of this, that I have to thank the Spanish people, because we have had to make many reforms, but also the ministers, who have worked very hard.

It would probably be hard to find a people anywhere in Europe, and just look at the problems that there have been in other countries, who have been asked to make as much effort at the Spanish. That is also comforting. I know that many decisions we have taken have been unpopular. I know that and I understand that. If I didn't know and understand that, I wouldn't be here.

But, as I said before, any judgement must be made at the end and I believe that everything that is being done is worthwhile, and I also believe that my government is working very hard. They have been brave and I am very grateful to all of them

A. Menéndez.- Perhaps this cabinet reshuffle has been caused by the European party lists, Mr Rajoy.

President of the Government.- I have read that in some of the papers.

A. Menéndez.- You as well.

President of the Government.- Yes, I have read that. They would know.

A. Menéndez.- There are those who mention Arias Cañete, for example. I don't want to set up a sweepstake because I know that won't get us anywhere.

President of the Government.- That's true. You're right.

A. Menéndez.- But, in light of these European elections, if a minister were to be number one on this European party list, that would force you to make a cabinet reshuffle.

President of the Government.- Undoubtedly. If it were a minister, it would oblige me to change at least one minister, of course.

A. Menéndez.- At least one.

President of the Government.- Of course. If it were a minister.

A. Menéndez.- And on the subject of the European elections?

President of the Government.- These are events that you are trying to get privy information on. Moreover, I cannot answer that question at this time.

A. Menéndez.- Well if you can't answer me…

President of the Government.- Exactly, I can't answer you for the simple reason that I don't know.

A. Menéndez.- Ah! And who does know?

President of the Government.- Well I imagine that… I can't answer that one either.

A. Menéndez.- Tell me, when will your interview with Barack Obama be held? Will the visit be here or there? I believe you said earlier that you had crossed the Atlantic nine times. There is still a big one outstanding… One of substance.

President of the Government.- Yes, we still have, let's say, the formal one to go in Washington. But I have met with him several times already: I have been in New York, I have been in South Korea, a short time ago in Saint Petersburg and also in Mexico. Relations with the United States are very good. Spain is in Europe, Europe is internal policy and European decisions affect Spain a lot. One of our main priorities is Ibero-America, but so are the Mediterranean and the Maghreb, and, of course, having good relations with the United States, with whom we share values such as democracy, liberty and human rights, is fundamental.

They are very good at this time, I am very satisfied and the meeting with President Obama will be held next year.

A. Menéndez.- Next year?

President of the Government.- Yes.

A. Menéndez.- Here in Madrid, or there in Washington?

President of the Government.- No, in Washington.

A. Menéndez.- In the first or second half of the year? To be more precise.

President of the Government.- I am sure it will be in the first half.

A. Menéndez.- And if I ask you for the month, I'm sure you won't give me that detail.

President of the Government.- No, no

A. Menéndez.- The first half, let's look at dates I haven't asked you about the Draft Bill on Citizen Security which has been in the news this week and which has raised a certain part of the political debate, because the opposition is in no way in agreement with the text that you propose to classify as very serious and with the fines of up to 600,000 euros… There are those who feel that it is a tailor-made anti 15-M Draft Bill. I don't know if you agree with this description.

President of the Government.- I couldn't disagree more. What has happened is that there are many people and certain opposition parties that want to give their opinion before reading the bill properly.

The Citizen Security Act, first of all, has not been approved; it hasn't even gone before the Council of Ministers. It will probably do so this Friday or next Friday. Probably next Friday although I can't rule out tomorrow.

The main objective is that, as we have removed many summary offences and criminal offences, these need to now be classified as administrative breaches. That is the main aim. In other words, it is not a more repressive law, as some say; rather quite the opposite; in other words, those offences that were previously classified as criminal offences now fall under the administrative system.

I believe that this law has, and I have spoken with many people, the general support of the people, support from residents' associations, the support of parents, the support of traders… What does this law do? It provides administrative sanctions, for example, for those that burn rubbish bins in the street - administrative sanctions, which means fines - which seems very reasonable; administrative sanctions for the clients of prostitutes near schools or hospitals, something that absolutely everyone agrees on, or administrative sanctions for mass drinking gatherings or those who organise activities that disturb the peace of their neighbours. In other words, they are administrative sanctions and this figure of 600,000 euros that you mentioned is exactly the same figure as existed in the previous law.

In the case of demonstrators outside Parliament, another thing that was mentioned, administrative sanctions only exist when there are demonstrations without having requested an authorisation as required by law. In other words, demonstrations always require authorisation, all of them, whether political demonstrations, demonstrations claiming one thing or demonstrations claiming another thing. Those people who attend demonstrations with their faces covered or who throw objects, or burn rubbish bins or turn cars over will also be fined, something which seems fairly reasonable.

Hence, this is a law along the same lines as all the laws passed in democratic countries that defend citizens' rights, so I feel fairly relaxed about it and I believe it will receive the support of the vast majority of Spaniards.

A. Menéndez.- It includes a paragraph against 'escraches' [a form of demonstration whereby the demonstrators go to the home or workplace of those they want to condemn to publicly humiliate them], a reality that was unknown until recently.

President of the Government.- There is no paragraph against 'escraches'; it doesn't talk about 'escraches'. It talks about unauthorised demonstrations, but unauthorised demonstrations are unauthorised demonstrations per se. Anyone who wants to hold a demonstration, and they all do this, only has to address the corresponding government delegation. For example, the trade unions, on 1 May, always hold a major demonstration on the occasion of Labour Day, and, as you would expect, they go to the corresponding government delegation and they declare they are going to hold a demonstration. Of course, it would be a little strange to have a country where anybody and everybody could hold a demonstration without requesting authorisation and where seven or eight demonstrations could be held at the same time.

In other words, that which already exists.

A. Menéndez.- Immigration affairs. I don't know if you are in favour, Mr Rajoy, of removing the concertina mesh, those knives in the fences in Melilla, which has also been in the news this week, or of maintaining them.

President of the Government.- That has been there for a long time and I have instructed the Ministry of Home Affairs to prepare me a report on the matter. Of course, I believe that the physical integrity of everybody must be maintained. I don't know exactly what they are or if they are harmful to humans. No decision has been taken on this matter but it is under review.

A. Menéndez.- If it can be shown - they are knives that cut; obviously they are harmful to those people that try to climb the fence - would you be in favour of removing them?

President of the Government.- All of the accidents that have taken place to date have involved people who try to climb over the fence; but, of course, the fence is there to stop them crossing, as you would expect. We must look into this. What I obviously don't want is illegal immigration, but nor do I want to put people at risk, because we are all humans.

A. Menéndez.- And regarding the matter of "Prestige", now that we know the government is in favour and will appeal against the ruling handed down, on the eleventh anniversary, moreover, of the sinking… From the point of view of our citizens, perhaps the hardest thing to understand is that no-one will pay for this environmental disaster that was in the news eleven years ago, Mr Rajoy.

President of the Government.- We have appealed against the decision because we consider that civil liability exists and that, in the end, the ship-owner and the insurance company should pay for the costs that were met by Spanish taxpayers as a whole. Furthermore, we do not renounce, when this criminal process concludes, exercising actions seeking civil liability. In other words, these are the two actions that the government will take in relation to this matter.

A. Menéndez.- I don't know if you suffered these last few days when you were reminded of the strings of play dough when you said…

President of the Government.- No, I didn't suffer. What I must say to you is that we are opposed to this ruling. On the one hand, I am pleased that, in the end, it is said that the government did things right, made a great effort, and did everything that was in its hands. I was there, I was Vice-President of the Government and I was sent there by President of the Government Aznar at the time. Everyone who went on the part of Central Government worked very hard, put in a lot of hours, in the end the director of the Merchant Navy was acquitted and the judge said that he had done everything he needed to do. From that point of view, that is satisfactory for the many people who suffered and had a rough time.

What does not satisfy me at all, as I said before, is that neither the ship-owner nor the insurance company assume any civil liability in the end. Hence, let's say that the captain should not only be sentenced for disobedience, but also for harming the environment, which is what will allow us to later proceed against the ship-owner and the insurance company because the captain himself will be insolvent.

A. Menéndez.- You said to me before that you routinely speak with Mr Pérez Rubalcaba. Have you asked Mr Pérez Rubalcaba if he will stand in the primary elections? Just in case you can give us a heads up. Has he said anything to you?

President of the Government.- No. I haven't asked him and the decisions other political parties take have nothing to do with me. It is not my…

A. Menéndez.- But do you speak about these things? "Come on Alfredo, what you have got going on…"

President of the Government.- No, no. I must say that the decisions of other parties are for them to take and the rule of minimum courtesy is to always respect this.

A. Menéndez.- And since we spoke earlier about things we have seen published, I saw an article, as you surely did, that stated that Ana Botella will not stand again as mayor of Madrid. You must know something. Give us your opinion, at least.

President of the Government.- Ana Botella is a wonderful mayor of Madrid. The thing is, we are not dealing with who heads up the European party list, there are no issues with the Regional Governments, there are no elections round the corner, what we are involved in at the moment is a period of government and all our attention is focused on that. And Ana Botella is a wonderful mayor of Madrid

A. Menéndez.- Are you in favour of reforming, or modifying, or making a new proposal regarding the Strike Act, which was one of the requests from the mayor?

President of the Government.- I am in favour of a Law on Minimum Services, so that minimum services are complied with, because this is a formula of ensuring that two rights are compatible: the right to strike as recognised under our Constitution and ensuring that the right to liberty of our citizens is respected. Hence, what we should do is pass a Law on Minimum Services and I have commissioned the Ministry of Employment to that end.

A. Menéndez.- As we approach the end, you surely will have an interesting time with the three world motorbike champions who even are going to bring their bikes along Mr Rajoy.

President of the Government.- Yes, the three world champions are coming here today of course: 125, 250 and Moto GP. This is a truly outstanding achievement for Spanish sport. I said before that we should be proud of certain things we have which are very good. In the field of sport, Spain has a generation of athletes such as we have never had before and we should also be proud of that and all pay some tribute to them.

A. Menéndez.- Are you a good rider, Mr Rajoy?

President of the Government.- No, I am not good on a motorbike. My sport is cycling.

A. Menéndez.- A two-wheeled sport, at any rate.

President of the Government.- Of course. The thing with cycling is that you have to use your legs whereas motorbikes require a different kind of effort, but a lot of effort as well.

A. Menéndez.- Be careful with one of my final questions, Mr Rajoy. Do you think the Golden Ball award should go to Cristiano Ronaldo or to Leo Messi? Be very careful.

President of the Government.- Ribery is another possibility, isn't he? According to some…

A. Menéndez.- Don't go off on a tangent. Madrid or Barcelona?

President of the Government.- I am a Madrid fan. If I had to vote, I would vote for Ronaldo, but, of course, Messi had also had a wonderful season and Ribery has won everything, because he won the Champions League, the European Supercup and the German League with Bayern Munich. But, in the end, Ronaldo… Just look, the other day he scored three goals in Sweden and I believe he is at the peak of his career. He is a player who give his all, who works very hard and who… It is a difficult decision.

A. Menéndez.- You would vote for Ronaldo?

President of the Government.- Yes, I would vote for him.

A. Menéndez.- If Mr Rajoy had a vote, he would choose Ronaldo. Finally, when this is all over, Mr Rajoy, when the lights are turned down, when you are no longer President of the Government, how much time do you feel you owe to your family?

President of the Government.- I imagine quite a lot. I try to spend time with my family. I have breakfast with them every day. I get up early, at seven o'clock, I do some sport and at eight o'clock - today I did this as well - I have breakfast with my wife and two children.

A. Menéndez.- Do you listen to the radio?

President of the Government.- No, not at eight o'clock. Between having a shower at eight and having breakfast with them… There's not much time of course between eight and eight twenty, they leave at eight twenty and I come here; I have everything timed to the minute and I start working at eight twenty-one.

And then, whenever possible, I have dinner with them. And at the weekend, I am tied up some weekends. One needs to be there. Sometimes, it is not a question of the number of hours, but the effort you make, that they see you, particularly the children. My two children are still quite young.

A. Menéndez.- Mariano Rajoy, President of the Government. Thank you very much for receiving us at Moncloa Palace, for an hour-long interview. I am grateful.

President of the Government.- Thank you very much. It has been a pleasure.