Press conference by President of the Government and Prime Minister of Republic of Ireland

Spain Mariano Rajoy · Prime Minister of Spain

27 April 2013 · Press conference by the President of the Government and the Prime Minister of Ireland · Granada, Spain

Context
Rajoy and Irish Taoiseach Enda Kenny held a joint press conference in Granada on 28 April 2013 following bilateral talks on economic challenges and EU reform.
Main themes
Spanish economy, Irish economy, European Union reform, banking union, fiscal consolidation, Irish EU Council Presidency, structural reforms, economic recovery, European integration, single market, job creation, Granada millennium celebration
Duration
~51 min
94th percentile
Words
6,128
94th percentile
Sentences
236
92nd percentile
Readability
53
72nd percentile
Grade
12.0
45th percentile
Syntax
3.12
63rd percentile
Vocabulary
1.99
9th percentile

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

236 sentences in 81 paragraphs

President of the Government.- Ladies and gentlemen, a very good afternoon to you. It gives me great pleasure to appear before you all together with the Prime Minister (Taoiseach) of the Republic of Ireland, Enda Kenny, to report on the working meeting held today, 28 April.

I would firstly like to give the Prime Minister and his delegation a warm welcome to Spain. I did so before the meeting we held, but I would like to repeat that here formally. I am grateful for your visit here to Spain, and more specifically, to Granada. You are most welcome here.

This year, as you are all aware, we are celebrating the millennium of the foundation of this city, a city which was able to integrate its Muslim origins with its incorporation within Spain in 1492 in a totally unique manner, as did this renaissance palace within the interior of the Alhambra. This relationship between the traditional and the modern is rooted in the very DNA of this city, as it can be found in the poetry of Lorca, the music of Manuel de Falla and the paintings of José Guerrero. This constantly transforming identity make this city something exceptional and in this exceptional city of Granada, a source of pride for all Spaniards, we have gathered today under circumstances that are also exceptional for the Spanish economy and for the economy of the European Union as a whole.

I would firstly like to sincerely congratulate the Irish Government and its Prime Minister for its six-month Presidency of the Council. It has frequently been said that since the entry into force of the Lisbon Treaty the Rotating Presidency of the Council has lost importance. Allow me to express my disagreement with that assertion. The extremely important task of leading the legislative work of all of the formations of the Council of Ministers of the European Union falls on the Presidency of the Council, work which affects the daily lives of some 500 million citizens. I believe that the Irish Presidency is making a great effort, I believe that things are being done very well and we are convinced that between now and the end of this Presidency, on 30 June, we will be able to show some very positive results for Europe as a whole.

What did we principally speak about at today's meeting? Firstly, about the situation of the Irish economy, also about the situation of the Spanish economy, and then, we spoke about the challenges being faced in Europe that very directly affect both the Irish and the Spanish economies.

I explained to the Irish Prime Minister, after listening to what has been taking place in Ireland in recent times, that this is something that is undoubtedly having a positive effect. Ireland is now overcoming the difficult times it has been through. Much work still needs to be done, as is the case with Spain, but we are absolutely convinced that both countries will overcome the situation we are currently experiencing.

I have explained what we are doing in Spain. Firstly, we are undergoing a process of fiscal consolidation. We started off with a high public deficit, of 9%, which we managed to reduce by two percentage points in 2012, in other words 20 billion euros, whilst going through a recession and with those difficulties in accessing financing that you are all aware of. We need to keep up this effort. In principle, the objective for 2013, as you know, is 4.5% and in the Stability Plan approved on Friday the objective is set at 6.3%, which means we will have to reduce our effort by some 18 billion euros, something I believe is important at this time because, in addition to continuing with our fiscal consolidation process, we need to make an effort at attaining growth and creating jobs, which is our main challenge.

Secondly, I outlined to the Irish Prime Minister the reforms that have been implemented since we came to power and the raft of reforms that we have approved and which we intend to submit to Parliament in the coming Councils of Ministers, a raft of reforms which, I repeat, includes those measures adopted last Friday which include certain very important structural reforms, as were those that we have implemented in recent times.

And finally, we spoke about Europe. The objectives we coincided on regarding Europe are fundamentally three:

Firstly, not only are reforms in individual Member States essential and necessary, which is a different issue, I would say, but it is also necessary that Europe continues with its reform process and continues, above all, working hard to create the single market. Hence, this is an objective that we share, it is a very important objective and one that we will undertake together and do all we can to see that this reformist process in the European Union goes ahead.

Secondly, we spoke abou the process of European integration .This is fundamental. And as regards banking union, which is a matter agreed on by the European Council on 29 June last year, as you will all remember, our two governments stated that we will work hard on the matter of banking union so that everyone takes us seriously, and so that all the EU Member States that last year approved the start of this process of banking union are aware that this process must move forward.

The single supervisory mechanism has been approved and that is a step in the right direction. We believe that in order for the single supervisory mechanism to enter into force it is not necessary to reform any of the EU Treaties, and in this respect we agree with the words of the European Council, Mr Van Rompuy and the European Commission itself.

Thirdly, we believe that the resolution mechanisms and direct recapitalisation need to be approved at the earliest opportunity.

Hence, I repeat, that we are in full agreement on this matter; the Irish Rotating Presidency of the Council is making a great effort and I hope that in the month of June Europe will make further progress on banking union, which is tantamount to making progress in the consolidation process of the European Union, and hence also in the process of the irreversibility of the Euro.

We also spoke about the Budgets for the period 2014-2020 that were approved by the Council and the need to reach an agreement as soon as possible with the European Parliament. As you are aware it is necessary to receive the approval of the MEPs.

And finally, we spoke about a matter that concerns us all, it concerns the Irish people and it concerns the Spanish people, which is liquidity and small- and medium-sized enterprises. We believe that the European institutions need to make a greater effort. We will work - the Irish Prime Minister and myself - for this to happen; this has been spoken about at certain European Council meetings, and it needs to be implemented as soon as possible because in order to grow and create jobs, in addition to many other things, it is very important to count on small- and medium-sized enterprises, and for them to receive financing. Above all, Spain is a country where the majority of job positions - as you are all aware - are created by small- and medium-sized enterprises comprising, one worker, or five, ten, fifteen, twenty or twenty-five, and it is precisely there that we, those governing, must make the greatest effort. In addition to the value of small -and medium-sized enterprises themselves, which create the middle classes and which create stability, it is absolutely necessary and appropriate to resolve the major problem we are currently suffering from in Spain- namely unemployment.

I will not go on, later I will answer your questions, but I repeat, if I had to summarise anything, I believe there is full agreement on the policies to implement, both at the level of individual Member States - fiscal consolidation and structural reforms - and in Europe. And in the case of Europe, it is fundamental that banking union comes into effect as soon as possible and that - needless to say - steps are taken in the right direction to implement this.

I will now hand over to the Irish Prime Minister who I once again welcome here. I thank him for his efforts during these six months, which he must combine with the efforts as Prime Minister of his own country; I believe he is doing things very well and, of course, satisfactorily in the eyes of the Spanish Government. Thank you.

Mr. Kenny .- A very good afternoon and thank you very much Mr President of the Government. Thank you very much for the welcome my delegation and I have received for this brief visit to Spain. It is a true pleasure to hold this meeting here, in the Alhambra, and I would like to thank the director of the Alhambra for her brief but clear explanations on this magnificent place, on the restoration works that have been completed and the great tourist appeal of the Alhambra.

I have known the President of the Government for many years now. I have come here in my capacity as Prime Minister and as Rotating President, and also to show my support for the Spanish people in these difficult economic times. It seems to me that everyone acknowledges that Spain is a key player in the European Union and in the future of the European Union, and we hope that the government is successful in the face of this complex situation. This is another reason why we have spoken about the measures and decisions taken by Ireland in recent years. We are an example of how a country can follow a programme such as Ireland has, taking clear and decisive decisions in this path towards progress.

I have spoken with the President of the Government about what the Irish Rotating Presidency is doing, about the current situation and the situation of the latter part of this Rotating Presidency and about what we expect to achieve.

One of the issues is to achieve a mandate to start trade talks between the European Union and the United States. This is an issue of great interest to the Spanish Government, as well as for us and for other countries, and we hope that during our Presidency we can establish a mandate that allows us to start negotiations.

I have also updated the President of the Government on the Connecting Europe Facility under the Multiannual Financial Framework. We have spoken with Mr Barroso regarding this matter, there has been a series of meetings in Brussels and we are due to hold another meeting on Monday. I hope that this will allow us to prepare matters so that we can have this instrument ready by 14 June.

There is also the question of the 2013 Budget which needs dealing with. I believe it is very important for this Facility to be approved during the Irish Presidency because there are important aspects of this Facility that are crucial for Spain; for example, the allocation of six billion euros for youth unemployment. This is a particularly important issue in Spain and it is an issue on which the President of the Government and his team are working. This would be a good opportunity and it would show the young people here that the politicians are listening to them and that they can take decisions aimed at their benefit.

I also spoke to the President of the Government about progress on banking union. On 29 June 2012 the European Council took the decision on decoupling sovereign debt and bank debt. This decision still stands, it has not changed. Meanwhile, the creation of the single supervisory mechanism has been approved and this should be ready for the meeting in June.

It is also worthwhile stating -as did the President of the Government- just how important it is that the decisions taken by the European Council are put into practice so that the citizens of the European Union can see how seriously their leaders take the practical application of the decisions they have made. That is why the issue of banking union will be a test of credibility for the European Union at its meeting in June. And I would like to say, in relation to that, that the Directive on conflict resolution must be finalised and approved, and that the common rules that the banks must apply and their forms should be ready, as should the ESM. This is a test of credibility for the Union as progress is made towards banking union, which is essential for the future of the EU.

So we decided to share information regarding those things that Ireland has done and those things being done by Spain as regards access to financing, loans to small- and medium-sized enterprises, opportunities to pave the way for companies to access credit in order to create jobs. We have decided to share this type of information because it is important information for both countries.

This has been a short meeting. In my capacity as Rotating President of the European Union, we have endeavoured to show our solidarity with Spain and also to bring the President of the Government up-to-date on certain issues, which we have talked about: the Rotating Presidency, the trade agreement with the United States and the issues that we are going to have to face up to in the future. Thank you.

Q.- You have spoken about a revised economic plan for Spain. Has this been focused on the idea of reducing the deficit to help reduce unemployment? Could this serve as a model for other countries, such as Ireland, that has high levels of unemployment?

Secondly, I wanted to know if you spoke about increasing the powers of the European Central Bank. This is something that Mr Rajoy has mentioned due to the crisis dragging on for so many years.

Sr. Kenny .- Is that question for me or for the President of the Government?

Q: For both of you.

Mr. Kenny.- Yes, we spoke about the European Central Bank, but not about the issue of extending the powers of the Bank. The President of the Government indicated the difficulties faced by the Spanish Government. We have a fiscal plan, we have a programme and we are sticking to this programme. It is working and there is more confidence. I highlighted the reduction in the interest rates from 15% to less than 4%. We have an increase in private sector employment: we are creating 1,000 jobs a month when we had lost 50,000 in the last three years. We have said that the government is working with the banks and the agencies that operate at a European level on matters of employment. And the government of our country is also implementing a plan to reduce our deficit to 3% by 2015. We are sticking to this plan despite the difficulties.

President of the Government.- As regards the European Central Bank, we have not spoken about changing its powers, as the Irish Prime Minister said in answer to your question. But in my first speech I pointed out that it would be important to help SMEs at these times. There is an instrument that could do more than it is currently doing, and that is the European Investment Bank.

As regards the European Central Bank I would only like to mention two things: firstly, that the European Central Bank has done some important things, at least since I became President of the Spanish Government, and also before that to the benefit of the European economy; its independence must be maintained, we must all do this and it has a very important function in terms of controlling prices, but it could also help economic growth.

In terms of your first question - this was the second one - on the fiscal deficit, all the Member States of the European Union must control the state of their public finances, all of the EU Member States have certain commitments and we are all under an obligation to present a Stability Programme. Spain and other countries have made a significant effort. We made an effort last year to reduce our deficit by two percentage points, but this reduction of two percentage points represents a deficit reduction of 3.5 points in structural terms. In other words, an enormous effort, and I would like to know if anyone else has done this in any other economy going back many years.

This year, the idea contained in the Stability Programme we presented, and which the European Commission has favourably assessed on an initial basis, is that next year the Spanish public deficit will be 6.3%. I believe that this decision is wise and balanced. I would like to have zero deficit, the objective is to continue reducing the deficit, but we believe that if things take a more even path, this could have a positive affect on growth and job creation.

Hence, the Stability Programme, which was presented by Spain to the European Commission last Friday, after having been approved by the Council of Ministers, forecasts a deficit reduction down to 6.3% for 2013.

Q.- For Mr Rajoy. President of the Government, your own forecasts state that unemployment will be higher at the end of this legislature than when you came to power. Do you understand the frustration of those who voted for you to fix this problem? What do you have to say to those citizens?

And, secondly, do you believe that this extraordinary situation warrants extraordinary decisions, such as changes in the government?

President of the Government.- Those are two things. I will try to give as clear an explanation as possible. I hope not to go on too long but this is undoubtedly a matter of importance.

We have made conservative forecasts and I believe that we have made these forecasts in an attempt to be credible, and we have made these forecasts with the aim of bettering them in the hope that things improve considerably. Last year we said that "economic growth in Spain will stand at -1.7%" In the end, we achieved economic growth of -1.4%; in other words, better than the forecasts.

Forecasts may change. The whole of Europe is lowering its forecasts at this time. The European Commission has also done this for the European Union as a whole, the International Monetary Fund has done this and individual Member States have done this. Last year the United Kingdom made its forecast for this year of 1.8%, which it has now reduced to 0.6%. France made its growth forecast for this year of 0.8% which is has now reduced to zero. We have also revised our forecast.

Hence, forecasts can be revised, but the real issue, the most important issue, is that we all work towards revising our forecasts for the better.

Let me tell you one thing, it is better to tell the truth, explain the reality and not pretend it doesn't exist, with ours heads in the clouds. That makes no sense and leads nowhere.

Some 3,400,000 jobs were lost in Spain during the last legislature according to the Active Population Survey; a huge number of people. At the start of our term in office we found ourselves faced with very significant imbalances in the Spanish economy and I will now explain what we have done and what we are going to do. An imbalance in prices, in the public deficit and in the foreign trade deficit, in addition to a situation, as you are well aware, of the financial system; these imbalances are the main factors to have caused the recession, in other words, negative growth and, hence an increase in unemployment in our country.

What have we done over the last year? We have tried to correct these imbalances and we have done so with an economic policy based on three pillars: reducing the public deficit, major structural reforms and the restructuring of the financial system. That has lead us to begin to overcome these imbalances. This year inflation will stand at a little over 1% and that helps make us much more competitive. There is a second very important result: the foreign trade deficit: the balance of payments of our country will be positive and even last year it stood at practically zero. This had not happened in many years in our country and demonstrates an increase in Spain's competitiveness. Added to which the public deficit has also fallen.

So we will carry on working to continue reducing these imbalances which will result in slowing the recession until we finally reach economic growth, which will result in increasing levels of employment in our country. But it is impossible to grow and create jobs if we don't correct the serious imbalances that the Spanish economy still suffers from.

Hence, that is what we have done and what we will continue to do. I repeat, we first need to correct the imbalances, then we will then see growth, and that is when we begin to create jobs.

Last year was very difficult. Spain overcame a major financial crisis and Spain overcame a very serious debt crisis. Last year the risk premium with Germany - the ten-year bond - reached levels higher than 600 basis points while today it stands at just over 300 basis points.

We had to make many reforms, we are now in a better position and this time next year we will be in an even better position and enjoying growth. And I can tell you now that the aim of this government is to fight to be obliged to change the forecasts we made on Friday for the better. That is the aim of this government and, if we continue persevering, which is what needs to be done with this economic policy, and if Europe continues to take steps in the right direction, I can assure you that by the end of this legislature, and even before the end of this legislature, we will not be suffering from economic imbalances, but enjoying economic growth and the creation of jobs. That is what we are working towards with perseverance and what we will continue to do for the time being.

As regards the second question, it hadn't crossed my mind but I can assure you I will not be making any changes in my government. I am very pleased with the work being done by the ministers at an economic level and the other ministers, with their effort, their dedication, their honour and their courage in a situation such as this where Spain is experiencing the worst economic crisis we have seen in a very long time, which, furthermore, coincides with a recession in the Eurozone and, in general, in the European Union as a whole, which is the destination of over 60% of our exports. Even in this situation of recession, the Spanish balance of payments will be positive this year and that is a fact that demonstrates the competitiveness of the Spanish economy.

But this process, and I have always said this, is not easy, above all it takes time and, above all, it takes time to see the results. But, if we don't correct these imbalances that we are currently working on, it will be impossible to grow and create jobs. I believe we are heading in the right direction, the government knows where it is heading and it is fully aware of what it is doing; but the government, in all honesty, will not deceive its citizens by making forecasts on unemployment or on growth that are not true and serve no purpose precisely because, firstly, that is not being honest, and secondly, it is of absolutely no use whatsoever.

Q.- A national question. Firstly, Prime Minister, what would you say to the Labour Party about the Abortion Bill that will soon be passed? Will it be a more liberal Abortion Bill? Secondly, what progress has been made in the talks with the Labour Party on this legislation? Will an agreement be reached at the Cabinet meeting on Tuesday? It seems that some will be voting against the party. How many votes do you believe you will lose in this respect?

Mr. Kenny.- This is an issue we have been dealing with for 30 years and which has been very controversial in Ireland for a long time now. I believe that we should wait to receive the explanatory memorandum before commenting on the content of the Bill.

We have taken a very clear stance and referred to the ABC ruling against Ireland, there have been informative hearings for a long time now and we are presently finalising the drafting of the Bill that will be submitted to a committee to analyse it and to make the pertinent consultations and deliberations.

It is a question of saving lives; essentially of saving the lives of mothers by giving them the same rights as unborn children. It is a question of legal certainty, which is also important, and what we do will fall within the framework of our Constitution. It will be totally legal and no new rights will be introduced into our current legislation; but we will be introducing legal certainty and trust in relation to women and their unborn children. So let's wait until the presentation of the grounds is prepared and then everyone will know which debates have taken place and what contributions can be made to the Draft Bill.

I have not spoken with anybody today on the matter. It would seem that what has been done is very constructive, and progress has been made, and the government will have the explanation of the grounds ready by Tuesday.

Q.- For the President of the Government, on a purely national matter, I wanted to come back to the matter of the Council of Ministers meeting from last Friday. I would like him to explain, firstly, what happened for him to state last Wednesday that taxes were not going to be raised and then on Friday the Council of Ministers took the decision to raise them.

Along the same line, as regards the unemployment figures, I wanted to ask whether the President of the Government understands that our citizens are frustrated because jobs are not being created and whether he is going to call a meeting with the leader of the opposition on Tuesday to tackle the matter.

I would like both leaders to evaluate the opinion given by the German Chancellor who proposed that the European Central Bank should raise interest rates this week. I don't know what their opinions are on the matter.

And, in line with this, do they consider that now is the time for those countries that are committed to growth policies to unite and stand up to Germany and say that now is the time to change austerity policies for growth policies?

President of the Government.- You have managed, with your given capacity for synthesis to ask no less than five questions in less than a minute and two of those are for different people.

What I said on Wednesday was that we would not raise Personal Income Tax or VAT, and we are not going to raise Personal Income Tax or VAT, and we will do everything we can to lower Personal Income Tax as soon as possible. However, as I said earlier, these things take time and it is very difficult to resolve the serious imbalances that plagued the Spanish economy in only a year or a year and a half, especially if we are in the only region of the world which is suffering from a recession at this time.

Hence, the key is to know what to do, and take the decisions that need to be taken, be patient, have a little patience, and then persevere. Of course it wasn't my intention at the time but we did increase Personal Income Tax, and I want to change this back as soon as possible.

As regards the tax increases, just look for yourself, if the public deficit next year were 4.5% instead of 6.3% as we said in our Stability Programme submitted to the European Union, this would mean that we would need to find 18 billion euros more, either from greater State revenue, tax hikes or spending cuts. Hence, this is a very important decision, the decision adopted in the Stability Programme, to change the deficit or the objective from 4.5% to 6.3%.

Instead of these additional 18 billion euros, we are talking about three billion euros: one billion will come from revenue and the other two billion from spending cuts. In other words, at the right time, because things must be done in this way, we will explain where these one billion euros in revenue will come from and the two billion in spending cuts. But we are talking here about a budgetary adjustment that is far less than last year. In other words, the major effort was made last year with the Personal Income Tax and VAT rises and with the tough and complex decisions that we had to take.

Hence, that is my position regarding taxation.

Unemployment figures. I am absolutely aware… This is the greatest problem of the Spanish economy at this time; not the economy itself, but which Spanish society and our people are facing, and this is the main objective of this government, its fundamental priority. We are not working or taking decisions with any other goal than attempting to improve the economy and create jobs. In other words, anyone at this time in Spain knows that the major national objective is to grow and create jobs. Then we can be in agreement or not with the measures that one or another may apply, but the whole world… There is no political party or individual in Spain that doesn't want to see growth and job creation.

As I explained earlier, this is a difficult situation. I never said that it was an easy situation. We are going through a very serious economic crisis, an economic crisis we have been immersed in for more than five years now. I said this earlier, between 2008 and 2011, 3,400,000 jobs were lost in Spain. And it is not easy to rectify this, but what is important is to know what needs to be done, and what needs to be done as I said earlier, is to correct these imbalances; we need to reduce the public deficit, this needs to be done; we need to make structural reforms, those we have already made and those we announced in the Council of Ministers meeting last Friday; we need to continue restructuring the financial sector and we need to make progress in Europe: the banking union that we have spoken about here today is very important to be followed by fiscal and political union, as well as resolving the problems of liquidity.

However, that is not achieved overnight, but, I repeat, progress has been made - I will say this again, I am aware that people are not seeing this yet - which was essential so that we could return to growth and start to create jobs: progress in the public deficit, foreign trade, progress on inflation… All of this is very important and, hence, what is important is to maintain this policy, because this policy will lead to economic growth and job creation.

We have made our forecasts and we could have made other forecasts, but in all sincerity, I believe it is better to explain the reality in which we find ourselves and what is happening rather than saying one thing and then, after two years, say "oh look, I got it wrong and we have one million more unemployed than I said we would have". I don't believe that to be worthwhile and it is not playing fair with our citizens.

However, in the same way that I say this, I would also say that the forecasts can be improved on and things could go much better than planned. In the same way as the forecasts for Europe as a whole have worsened this year - I gave your colleague the figures earlier: the United Kingdom spoke about 1.8% growth for this year, which it has dropped to 0.6% - why can't we, by doing things right, go from a forecast that doubles growth from one year to the next?

We will see how events unfold. The government's forecasts today are those we approved on Friday and I believe that they give credibility to the Spanish economy. It is true and I am fully aware that this may frustrate many people, and their hopes, wishes and feelings, but I want to say to them that the government knows what it is doing, and while the situation is difficult and complicated, in the same way as we have already overcome many imbalances, soon we will start to see growth in the country and that is what we are working towards.

The next matter -there were many- is the leader of the opposition. I often speak with the leader of the opposition, a lot more often than people might think. We speak often and exchange opinions and perspectives on many matters, above all, on the matter of Europe. I am prepared to agree on what can be agreed upon. What happens is that we speak often but then his party doesn't vote in favour of a single one of the structural reforms that the government proposes. It would be good if some of his party voted for at least some of these proposals. Not on the matter of the preferential shares, or evictions or anything else…, but it doesn't matter. The government has to assume its responsibility, because that is why it was voted into office.

What I seek with the opposition party is to maintain dialogue, that we reach an understanding regarding what we need to do in Europe - that seems important to me - and then regarding major national issues. I understand that the opposition party criticises me for raising VAT or because I reduce one item or another… That is probably the function of the opposition party. But at least there is dialogue. At this time the government wants to talk, is indeed talking with everyone, and is aware that it has to assume the responsibility because that is why it was elected to form the Government of Spain.

In terms of the European Central Bank and the interest rates, I believe that we should all respect the independence of the European Central Bank. Hence, I am not going to say what the European Central Bank must or must not do and I am sure that we would all agree on that.

Finally, as regards these confrontation policies, which summarises what you said, but better expressed than I could, I want to say that Europe is built by us all. In other words, Europe is not built by majorities or minorities. We all need to feel at home, Europe is a difficult process. This started more than 50 years ago, just imagine, the Treaty of Rome in 1957, and before that, the Coal and Steel Community. This has taken a long time to build. The Euro, which, to a certain degree, is emblematic of the European Union, took many years to be put in motion. There was a lot of debate, then we had to meet certain requirements prior to 1 January 1999 and then we didn't start to use the Euro until 2002. In other words, Europe has been built little by little.

But I believe that we are at a decisive point in time. I would reiterate what the Irish Prime Minister said earlier: the European Council was very important last year and now, this year, progress needs to be made in June because this will send out a message to everyone, "Listen, this is serious, we are serious people, we comply with our agreements and our citizens can see that when the European leaders get together and take decisions, it is for them to be followed through with". That is why today we have jointly taken up the battle in this direction, not against anyone, but rather in favour of Europe and of all Europeans.

Thank you all very much. Thank you very much again, Mr Prime Minister, and thank you to the management here at the Alhambra, because I had forgotten what their hospitality was like, and they have treated us wonderfully.

Thank you.