Press conference by President of the Government and Prime Minister of the Slovak Republic
Mariano Rajoy · Prime Minister of Spain
- Context
- Rajoy held a joint press conference with Slovak Prime Minister Robert Fico in Madrid on 23 April 2013 following bilateral talks on economic and European issues.
- Main themes
- Spain-Slovakia bilateral relations, European economic reform, fiscal consolidation and structural reforms, Eurozone crisis, Economic and Monetary Union, banking and political union, trade and investment opportunities, European cohesion funds, infrastructure development, UN Security Council candidature, job creation and growth
- Duration
- ~41 min
- Words
- 4,873
- Sentences
- 181
- Readability
- 47
- Grade
- 13.1
- Syntax
- 3.12
- Vocabulary
- 2.00
This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.
181 sentences in 74 paragraphs
President of the Government .- A very good afternoon ladies and gentlemen, and thank you very much for attending.
It gives me great satisfaction to appear before you all together with the Prime Minister of the Slovak Republic, Robert Fico, to report on the results of the working meeting held today, 23 April.
First of all, I would like to welcome the Prime Minister and his delegation to Spain. I sincerely believe that the excellent health of our bilateral relations, as well as our common work in favour of the European project and of our common currency call for an effort to increase the ties between our respective countries, cultures and societies.
As we have seen in the fruitful meeting held today, Spain and Slovakia are two countries that are both partners and friends, bound by increasingly dynamic trade and economic relations, facing a challenge of fundamental importance for our respective citizens: strengthening Europe as a space of well-being, competiveness, prosperity and the development of international society in the 21st Century. We are aware that this goal requires intense political agreement coupled with frank and fluid dialogue at all levels.
There is a growing presence of Spanish companies in Slovakia; however, we believe that this presence may be further increased as a result of the opportunities opening up - particularly in the construction infrastructure sector. Slovakia will be the recipient of significant European funding for this infrastructure in the coming years. The Prime Minister and I agree that the Spanish experience in the absorption of these funds and in the construction of infrastructure represents an unbeatable opportunity for our companies.
I also offered the Prime Minister the benefit of our experience in absorbing European cohesion funds. And I would thank him for coming here together with his Deputy Prime Minister, who is entrusted with overseeing major investments and European funds, and who will hold a meeting this afternoon in our Ministry for Public Works. I am also grateful to him for including a meeting with Spanish business leaders in his schedule.
Our mutual understanding is also manifested in our international relations, where we are clearly in harmony as can be seen through Slovakia's support for Spain's candidature for a place on the United Nations Security Council for 2015-2016 and Spain's support for Slovakia's candidature for a place on the Human Rights Council for the period 2018-2020.
As you are aware, Slovakia has been a Member State of the European Union since 2004 and of the Eurozone since 2009. This means we fully share the aspirations of the European project and, hence, the problems and the crisis that has hit both the economy of the Union and the stability of the Euro.
As both the Prime Minister and I have been arguing at the recent meetings of the European Council, Europe must continue down a path of reforms, with the aim of fostering growth, quality job creation and the competitiveness of our economies, whilst streamlining and cleaning up our public accounts.
The Spanish and the Slovak Governments have both adopted fiscal consolidation measures and structural reforms in an endeavour to return our respective economies to a path of growth and job creation. However, we would also call for measures at a European level, to go hand-in-hand with those we are currently implementing in our own countries, to guarantee funding and liquidity, and thus foster growth - conditions that are also essential for exiting this crisis as soon as possible.
To that end, the Spanish and Slovak Governments will continue working together in the European decision-making bodies with the firm conviction that the situation being suffered in the Eurozone requires a strengthening of the Economic and Monetary Union to adapt it to the challenges of the 21st Century. To that end, we must pave the way for true banking, fiscal and political union in Europe.
Reforms are not an option but rather an obligation, both at a national and a European level.
Thank you very much. I will pass you over to the Prime Minister of Slovakia.
Mr. Fico.- Mr President of the Government, I would firstly like to thank you for the programme you have prepared for our delegation, all the meetings in which I have taken part and those yet to come. I would also like to take this opportunity to invite you, once again, to visit our country, to visit Slovakia, because bilateral meetings focusing on economic issues are of great importance.
Although Slovakia and Spain have very good political relations, that is not yet the case at an economic level. The presence of Spanish capital in Slovakia has not reached the same level as is seen in other countries, such as Germany and France.
My main task is to present Slovakia as an attractive country, a country that can be trusted, a country in Central Europe which enjoys good conditions for entrepreneurialism, as was also confirmed by the 2013 Doing Business report drawn up by the European Bank, which stated that Slovakia was the Central European country with the most favourable business environment. That is why I have conveyed to Spanish business leaders, and I would like to convey this at all levels, that Spain and Slovakia must continue collaborating at an economic level.
Ladies and gentlemen, it matters not whether a country is governed by a conservative party or a socialist party. I am the Prime Minister of the Slovak Government and I must take anti-crisis measures - a crisis that was unthinkable just a few years ago, and one which has even become a crisis of values. We would never have accepted taking these measures back then. Each country in the European Union must take a series of very sensitive decisions that affect a great many people. We must adopt reformist measures that change the image of the country and the lives of our people.
That is why it gives me pleasure to have been able to speak with the President of the Spanish Government about such matters as the consolidation of the public accounts. We agree that the consolidation of the public accounts is essential, but this cannot be done in such a way that it prevents economic growth. That is why I trust that Slovakia and France, and other countries, including Spain, follow this path of consolidation, which allows us to continue following the Maastricht criteria whilst not preventing economic growth.
As regards the consolidation of the public accounts, as the President of the Spanish Government mentioned, this consolidation must go hand-in-hand with major reforms at a European level. The Government of the Slovak Republic also supports the integration of the EU institutions. Without this integration, the European Union will never be a competitive region, a region that can compete with China, with certain countries in Latin America and with the United States of America.
The third issue, which is very important for the Government of the Slovak Republic, is the fight against tax havens. I explained to the President of the Spanish Government the practical problems we have with certain companies in tax havens and he confirmed that Spain is in favour of supporting our position in this respect and will adopt measures to do away with tax havens, because this is also a way to avoid tax evasion thereby achieving the necessary funds from tax collection activities without having to resort to increasing them.
I also spoke about the authorisation of European funds. We cannot be in agreement with the bureaucratic obstacles in Brussels preventing Member States from spending funding on priority areas. We cannot spend these funds on training or on acquiring information technologies with no tangible benefits for us or for economic growth. That is why I informed the President of the Government that Slovakia will take the initiative to convince the European Commission to be more flexible and open in how these European funds are disbursed.
As regards bilateral relations, there are no problems between Spain and Slovakia. I will be delighted to receive the President of the Government in Slovakia. I have also conveyed the invitation from the President of the Slovak Republic, Mr Gašparovič, to His Royal Highness the Prince of Asturias, because this would be very positive for further developing our relations, both at a political and economic level.
We also spoke about the candidatures to the different international bodies and we spoke about our relations in terms of education. We want to support different programmes through the Ministry of Education. We have a programme whereby Slovak students are able to have a gap-year to study overseas and a number of Slovak students have come here for a year, to Spain, to get to know the country. We believe that this type of experience is very beneficial for both countries.
Ladies and gentlemen, I trust that today's visit will help drive forward greater cooperation at all levels. I hope that the idea you have of Slovakia at the end of this trip is one of an attractive country which is worthy of your investment.
To end, I would like to once again thank the President of the Government kind organisation of this visit. Thank you.
Q.- I would like to ask a question about joint ventures, above all since the Spanish, or the Spanish companies, seem to prefer Latin America, and whether it is still possible for them to return to the region of Central Europe.
Mr. Fico. - The principle I work on is that until something is well known, I will not provide information on the details of the specific programme or project. But one of the aims of this visit was to present our country as an attractive destination from the point of view of a business environment with a view to capital investment.
If we compare our fiscal system with the Spanish fiscal system, there are many differences. In Spain, Income Tax is levied at a rate of 30%, and even up to 50% for some individuals. We thus consider Slovakia to be an attractive country, which is what I stated at the Business Forum.
Our country is prepared to support those companies that are willing to invest, particularly in infrastructure, because the Slovak construction companies do not have the capacity to implement the kind of projects we are going to be undertaking. The cohesion and globalisation create opportunities in all countries. In the same way as we are working in other countries, so others can work in our country.
Q.- Mr President of the Government, one question for you and another for the both of you.
Does the government have an explanation for the fact that it has had to revise the macroeconomic forecasts again, as the Minister for Economic Affairs announced? Will this have a direct repercussion on the measures to be approved by the government on Friday? Will there be further adjustments or cuts?.
Along these new economic lines, as regards the deficit, are you in a position to confirm, Mr President of the Government, that Brussels will make Spain's deficit objective for 2013 more flexible and, at any event, if it will give more years beyond 2014?.
Also a quick question for both of you regarding what you think of the statement made by the German Chancellor, Angela Merkel, who has asked for EU Member States to transfer more sovereignty; she even stated that there are some countries that are reluctant to transfer this sovereignty. Would that mean, for example, pooling sovereign debt or issuing Eurobonds?.
President of the Government .- Economic forecasts are normally made three times a year: firstly, when the General State Budget is presented for the coming year, and that is why we made the forecasts in September 2012; then later when the Stability Programme and the National Reform Plan are presented, which we will approve, God willing, this Friday, 26 April, which will subsequently be submitted to the European Commission for approval and also for the approval of the European Council in the month of June, which is the body to give definitive approval thereof; and subsequently when the Budget is presented for the following year, in other words, in this case those for 2014, will be presented in September, which is when the forecast for the year 2013 is finally adjusted. Hence this takes place on three occasions.
What has happened now? The recovery of growth in Europe, which was forecast for 2013 by the international authorities and institutions, is not happening and that has given rise to everyone having to revise their forecasts; this was done for the European Union as a whole by the International Monetary Fund and by the European Union itself, but the vast majority of the Member States have had to do this as well.
Let me give you some figures: the United Kingdom in August 2012 gave a forecast for 2013 of 1.8% growth which it has now dropped to 0.6%; in France the growth forecast, when the Budget was presented, stood at 0.8% but now they are saying no and it has been cut to 0.1%; in Germany, when the Stability Programme was presented for 2014, "growth of 1.6%" was announced, whereas this has now been reduced to 0.4%. The same has happened in Ireland, Portugal and indeed in all the Member States of the European Union.
Hence, Spain has not done anything different to what it did on countless other occasions or to what all the EU countries have also done now, which is logical. The economy is subject to many changes and circumstances; there are structural issues which logically oblige governments to make changes in their growth forecasts. I remember that last year, in 2012, we said that economic growth for the year would stand at -1.7%, the Commission stated that it would be -1% and then half way through the year we changed it to -1.5% and it finally stood at -1.4%.
In other words, forecasts are not something that you always get right and so, obviously, you have to revise them, as, I repeat, they are changed by any other civilized country in the world. I have given you figures for countries such as France, the United Kingdom and Germany, where the change has been far greater than that of Spain.
Therefore we will make our forecasts this coming Friday, in terms of economic growth and the public deficit, among others. This is a revision of the macroeconomic chart, which, in short, will be submitted to the European Commission for its approval or not, and to the European Council.
You asked whether there will be more cuts in public spending, that was your second question. Nobody like making cuts in public spending. We have had to make important decisions, uncomfortable decisions, which we know are unpleasant and are also difficult to take. I want to make that clear, that they are difficult to take, but if we are taking them, it is because they are absolutely necessary and essential, and being necessary and essential, if we don't take them, despite seeming tough to take in the first instance, we would be destroying our own future.
We will now try… Of course, we will not make the same cuts as we did last year. It is likely that cuts will need to be made to certain budgetary items. Nor do we want to raise such taxes as VAT or Personal Income Tax this year; but, in short, we also depend on the growth forecasts and on the public deficit path for the coming years. But, I repeat, this Friday we will present our new macroeconomic chart.
You then asked a question, both for me and for the Prime Minister of Slovakia, on sovereignty and on the statement made by Mrs Merkel. I agree. The European Union project is a process under which all the Member States of the European Union lose sovereignty. Spain does not have its own currency, its own monetary policy or its own exchange rate policy. There is no greater loss of sovereignty than that! To give you an even easier example to understand, the fishing agreements with other countries, for fisherman from my region, or from Andalusia or the Basque Country, are now made by the European Union.
In other words, when one joins an organisation such as the European Union, there is a significant transfer of sovereignty, and, in fact, the more progress made in the integration of the European Union, the more sovereignty is transferred by Member States.
We are now in the midst of a debate that I believe is key to the future of Europe, which is the debate on integration, and, as I have said on many occasions, even right here, in June last year there was a Council meeting where I stated that Europe is heading towards banking union, fiscal union, greater economic union and political union.
Banking union, should this be shaped soon will undoubtedly result in a transfer of sovereignty, because this means that there is a single banking supervisor for the whole of Europe - it is not the Bank of Spain, but rather the European Central Bank that supervises all the banks around Europe; a single resolution system for financial institutions around Europe and a single deposit guarantee fund for the whole of Europe. But this is all extremely important, because we are bigger, stronger and can thus much better guarantee the rights of all our citizens. Just think, if we had had banking union, what took place in Cyprus would not have occurred under any circumstance. Just look at how important banking union is.
That is why, when people say "but we must transfer sovereignty", I say that I am in agreement, which is why, whenever I can, I fight, firstly, in favour of banking union, but I would also do the same for fiscal union and for political union in the future, because, in all sincerity, we are five hundred million people in Europe and Europe has a great advantage over other parts of the world. Europe has a highly consolidated welfare system like no other, it has a health system, an education system and a public pension system like no other in the world. And hence, we must do two things: firstly, conserve this and be more competitive to help maintain this. That is why we must be more demanding, control our public accounts well, but above all, we must make reforms and seek greater integration.
That is why, If you say to me, "transfer sovereignty", I would say yes, I am in favour. That is what we have been doing since we joined the European Community way back in 1986, and whilst banking union is a very significant transfer of power, I would repeat that it is key for shaping the future of Europe and for the well-being of all our citizens.
Mr. Fico .- Mr President of the Government, if you will allow me I would like to return to the first question asked of you.
When the President of the Government was asked the first question I had the same sensation as if I had been at a press conference back in Bratislava. An image is being created of the different Member States of the European Union as being responsible for the state of their social systems and economies. I see this as a political matter and one which our political opponents will always exploit against the government, whether it be a socialist government, a conservative government, or a government of any other political persuasion.
What the President of the Government said is also valid in our country. We also had to change our forecasts. Slovakia is the sixth most open economy in the world, and when Germany announced that it had lowered its forecasts for growth, this seemed to us a powerful argument. Consequently Slovakia also had to lower its forecasts for growth.
We must adapt our strategies and policies to this reality. I am delighted that Slovakia is one of the few countries that will show positive growth in 2013, as it will in 2014. But what is taking place in Spain, France, Italy and Great Britain is also taking place in all the former Soviet-bloc countries. That is not the result of individual policies, but rather of a serious crisis and each country must react in some way to this crisis.
Yes, we can talk about ways to react to this crisis or of which measures to take. Yes, we can talk about that, but no country can say that "the crisis is not affecting us or that we don't need to adopt any kind of measures".
As regards the second question, my response will be brief. Did the introduction of the Euro result in a certain loss of sovereignty? The single currency is a sign of each State and yes, the Euro did represent a certain loss of sovereignty for each country that adopted it, but as regards Slovakia, I should say that the introduction of the Euro has been a tale with a happy ending. If it is a positive loss of sovereignty, if it means transferring competencies to an international level, I could only possibly be in agreement.
In answer to our friend the journalist, we have the example of Schengen. Today, if you get into a car in Estonia and you have enough petrol, you can travel as far as Portugal without being stopped on the way. Is that a loss of sovereignty? Yes, in a certain respect it is a loss of sovereignty but it is a positive loss, because I don't believe anyone is upset about not being stopped on the border or that they don't need to wait in line, as we did previously when going on holiday to Croatia.
Europe will never be competitive if we don't collaborate more closely, if we don't join forces. We are 27 countries, soon to be 28, and each one of those countries have their own economic policy, some have the Euro and other don't… We are a marketplace of 500 million people. How can we compete with the United States or with China, which have a much better and more developed system of cooperation between the different countries?.
Greater integration is the solution to the crisis. Yes, Slovakia also participates in debates on the image of Europe within five or ten years. I believe that this crisis will force us to take measures much quicker than we thought we would. Just a few years ago we could not have imaged that we were going to reach agreement on banking union or on a single banking supervisor, yet now that makes perfect sense to us. From that point of view, Slovakia is prepared to speak about greater integration, which means transferring competencies, but there is a line that we will not cross. For example, we will never accept that national budgets are approved by the European Council. We will be prepared to consult and we will accept that budgets follow broad trends in the European Union, but budgetary sovereignty must remain in the hands of the different Member States at a national level.
So yes to greater integration but each country has a line it shouldn't cross.
Q.- I would like to return to the Business Forum. We spoke with business leaders about whether they can imagine closer collaboration, but they said they couldn't see any reason to do so. So, I would like to ask you how you intend to motivate them to that end. What added value can you offer them so that Spanish business leaders invest in Slovakia?.
Mr. Fico .- I would not like this to only be a one-way ticket, but rather a return ticket. There are already many Spanish companies operating in Slovakia and Slovak companies operating in Spain; for example, a railway company.
The truth is that neither country is very aware of the business environment of the other country. Slovakia is one of the countries with the best business environment in the region of Central Europe. If we compare ourselves with other countries in our region as regards the quality of the labour force; for example, the company Telefónica rates our workforce and labour conditions very highly. And we need to be aware that this is very interesting, that we have interesting things to offer to other countries.
There are many projects being prepared at this time, but I won't say anything else until they are done deals.
Q.- My first question is for the both of you and regards how you assess the European Parliament's decision to urge Slovakia and Spain to recognise Kosovo as an independent State.
And for Mr Rajoy, what is your opinion on the new call for independence made today by the President of the Regional Government of Catalonia, barely two weeks after your meeting with him at Moncloa Palace?.
And, if you will allow me, I would like to know whether, after the latest news and judicial statements, you still maintain one hundred percent that there was no unlawful funding of the PP nor were there inflated salaries paid out to members of the party leadership.
President of the Government.- As regards your last question, I said everything I needed to say at the appropriate time and I am not going to repeat it now.
On the matter of Kosovo, I respect the decisions taken by others, but I should say that Spain adopted its position on this matter some years ago and the government maintains this position to date and will continue to do so in the future. In other words, Spain will not recognise Kosovo because Spain does not believe in unilateral declarations of independence. Obviously anything that can benefit individuals, their well-being and an increased quality of life can count on our support, but Spain has no intention of recognising the sovereign nature of Kosovo, although it respects, as you would expect, the right of others to think differently.
As regards the statements, I believe that it makes no sense to respond and enter into a debate about who said what. My position is clear and I think that this is the position held by the vast majority of Spaniards. I believe that this is the European nation that has spent the most time living together, we are bound by many things and we have done many things together. The last 30 years have been some of the best in our history, although we are currently going through a difficult and complex process in which there is an economic crisis that affects us all, but we are united in our aim to exit this crisis, in our progress and in the European project.
I have said this on many occasions and I will say it again now; I don't want the citizens of Catalonia to be deprived of their status as Spanish citizens - they are presently both Catalans and Spaniards - and I don't want them to be deprived of their membership of the European Union, or of their international relations, or of a future with a high degree of well-being and progress.
And that is my position, a position which is basically contained in the texts in force at this time, and if anyone doesn't agree, those texts in force include provisions allowing for the possibility of their amendment.
I would like to move on… Although nobody has asked me about this matter, I want to make it clear: Spanish business leaders are very interested in investing in Slovakia, they are interested in taking part in tenders and, in fact, some have already done so and there are quite a number of Spanish companies, some of the best in fact, already working there. What we are trying to do, and, among other things, that is precisely why we have met here today, is to improve our relations, to increase our level of awareness of each other's country, and so that our business leaders, both Slovaks and Spaniards, can appreciate that both Spain and Slovakia are lands in which there are things to be done and profits to be made for the companies involved, but which will also benefit the citizens of Slovakia and of Spain.
Mr. Fico .- As regards the problem surrounding Kosovo, I will be very brief. Slovakia has its own reasons, which are very clear and well-defined, for not recognising the independence of Kosovo. Furthermore, I am convinced that this attempt for recognition should be something decided upon by individual Member States and not by the European Union as a whole.
That is why we will remain in the small group of States that consider that Kosovo does not meet the conditions for recognition as an independent State.
As regards the daily lives of the people of Kosovo, this is not affected. As regards issues such as the free movement of people or issues that affect the daily practicalities of individuals - we are not talking about political issues - in this respect we do not want to put obstacles in their way; we must behave correctly with everyone.
President of the Government .- Thank you.