Speech and subsequent Q&A session with the President of the Government at the Annual Assembly of the Family Business Institute

Spain Mariano Rajoy · Prime Minister of Spain

28 April 2013 · Annual Assembly of the Family Business Institute

Context
Rajoy addressed the Annual Assembly of the Family Business Institute in Spain on April 28, 2013, discussing the economic crisis and unemployment challenges.
Main themes
Family businesses, economic crisis in Spain, unemployment, job creation, economic recovery, government economic policy, intergenerational commitment, wealth creation, Spanish business resilience
Duration
~71 min
97th percentile
Words
8,545
97th percentile
Sentences
354
96th percentile
Readability
52
68th percentile
Grade
11.8
43rd percentile
Syntax
3.10
60th percentile
Vocabulary
2.00
11th percentile

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

354 sentences in 127 paragraphs

Mr President of the Family Business Institute, ladies and gentlemen, a very good morning to you all.

First of all, allow me to thank your President, José Manuel Entrecanales, for his words of welcome.

As you can imagine, the duties of someone in my position include a great many obligations; some more pleasant than others. Among those of a more pleasant nature is my duty to attend meetings of the Family Business Institute. As you know, I am a regular at these meetings. Ever since that meeting in Tenerife in 2005 for the 8th Conference of your association, not a single year has passed in which I have not attended this meeting with you.

I have always been invited to speak and it has always been a pleasure to do so. However, please believe me when I tell you that what interests me most is to hear your concerns and listen to your ideas in person. That said, I will tell you now that I do not intend to speak for too long at this point so as to make the very most of our time during the subsequent Q&A session.

As I look down the list of people at this meeting, I see behind each name a company that continues to resist the blows struck by the crisis, that continues to create wealth and provide employment, and continues to open up borders for Spanish products and services; and in that unique way of operating that is so characteristic of family businesses.

All companies that create jobs and generate wealth deserve the same degree of recognition and respect, in my opinion. In principle, there is no reason for a family business to be better or worse than any other type of business. Nonetheless, they do have a distinct difference. Family businesses stick to an inter-generational commitment; one that is not limited to the company founders and those that later inherit the business but one that also extends outwards to their employees, customers, suppliers and the society at large in which they operate.

Through your company, each one of you has invested your job, your assets and the commitment you made at the time to pass on a bigger and better inheritance to future generations. Yours is a story of chapters that string together the hopes and aspirations of the past on a path that stretches ahead into the future.

To see you here, year after year, strengthens my confidence in the future of our society and in my conviction that we will be capable of emerging from this crisis. That is why this is one of my most pleasant duties as President of the Government.

So, dear José Manuel, it is not the Family Business Institute that should thank me for attending this event but rather I who should thank you for inviting me to take part. I offer my gratitude to you, Mr President, and to each and every member of this institution for being so kind as to invite me once again. I take comfort from the results of the survey I have just been shown; it is a truly hope-inspiring figure.

Ladies and gentlemen,

At about this time last year, when I had only been President of the Government for a little over three months, I was given the opportunity to share with you a diagnosis of the economic situation in our country, to explain the measures that had already been adopted at the time and those that were going to be developed in the future. Twelve months on and we can now ask ourselves: Are we in a worse, unchanged or better situation than we were back then?

Only a few days after the Active Population Survey on the first quarter of this year was published, some might consider it bold while others might consider it a form of provocation that this question be asked by the person who now holds the post of President of the Government of Spain because it is blatantly obvious that the situation is worse now than it was then in terms of jobs and unemployment in this country. Moreover, you have already heard me say that the main priority for the economic policy of my government is to reactivate economic growth and job creation in Spain.

That said, if nothing else were to be said or added, then the answer would be clear: we are worse off than we were a year ago. A figure of more than six million people out of work is the most dramatic manifestation of this crisis because, beyond the direct economic consequences of under-using this country's production capacity, it represents the frustrations of millions of people who feel crushed by an overwhelming reality that, day by day, causes them to lose more and more hope in the future.

However, far from paralysing the Government of Spain and its leader, this figure becomes an ever greater incentive to developing its policy. Regardless of how dramatic this figure is - and it is dramatic - it did not come as a surprise to us. Jobs are not created during a period of recession, they are lost. To think that unemployment can be reduced while economic activity is contracting is to believe in a magic wand or in disjointed arbitrary policies.

To recover growth in our economy, to create jobs and to reduce unemployment, we must first remove any obstacles that lie in the path of economic development. Before any sustained and stable development of our economy can be achieved, we must first draw up a precise diagnosis of the situation in which we find ourselves and perform a dispassionate analysis of our most recent economic history.

Analysis and diagnosis lead us to the following conclusion: the Spanish economy has survived for years on the basis of strong borrowing, which enabled investment and consumption beyond the limits of its revenue. But when the time came to repay its debts - and all debts must be repaid sooner or later - consumption and investment shrunk; not only because they had to be adjusted to revenue given the lack of borrowing options but also because we needed to start repaying the debt. The excesses of the past and the obligation to gradually pay off our debt led us into our current position.

Our economic imbalances soared. The current account balance of payments, which measures our economic relations with other countries; the disorderly growth in prices, measured in terms of inflation; and the difference between expenditure and revenue in the public sector clearly required an immediate correction.

To think it was possible to maintain those imbalances and, at the same time, enjoy growth in economic activity and employment was a dream, a sad illusion; a terrible mistake that led us to the unemployment figure I mentioned earlier and the deepest economic crisis the Spanish economy has experienced in recent decades.

Today, leaving aside a few stray individuals, we all agree that we need to first clean up our economy to achieve growth and create jobs. It is the sine qua non of any future recovery, it is essential. Regardless of how tough and painful the clean-up job may be, it simply must be done. Not doing so would be to condemn the people of Spain to an extremely long period of economic decline.

For that reason, in these last 16 months of government, you have never heard me talk about premature 'green shoots of growth', 'boom periods' or 'recovery just around the corner'. I warned from the outset that turning the economic situation around was not going to be an easy task, or a fast one, and that, with that in mind, the sooner we got under way the better.

Ladies and gentlemen,

We have now seen that the balance in terms of employment and unemployment - our main goal - is still not positive, in actual fact, it's still rather negative. But, have we firmly established the new foundations on which the future economic scenario must be based? Are the rungs in place that will enable us to climb the ladder towards economic recovery? In this regard, ladies and gentlemen, the balance from the last year is absolutely positive.

Whereas the foreign trade deficit was once a choker around our necks, stifling our chances for growth, that situation no longer exists today. In 2013, the Spanish economy's ability to seek finance overseas will be well above 2 percentage points of our GDP. For the first time in many years, we now have a foreign trade surplus again.

Whereas the disorderly increase in prices was forcing down the competitiveness of our economy, the CPI will remain below 2% this year. This morning, we were informed that prices rose in April by 1.4% year-on-year, in spite of the fact they are still feeling the effects of a VAT increase. Let us recall the previous months and look at the bigger picture: October, 3.5%; November, 2.9%; December, 2.9%; January, 2.7%; February 2.8%; March, 2.4%; and, finally, April, 1.4%.

Our public sector deficit stood at 9% of GDP in 2011. I ask you to remember that Spain was the only country in the world capable of going from a public account surplus of 2.7% in 2007 to a deficit of 11.1% by 2009 - in only two years. That is a 13.8 percentage point fluctuation within the space of only 24 months - worthy of Guinness World Record status. Only the slightest of corrections was made to resolve this situation and that has forced us to adopt unprecedented fiscal consolidation measures in this country, and during a period of recession. In 2012, the deficit fell by 22 billion euros, which is a primary structural deficit reduction of 3.1 percentage points of our GDP - the best reduction in any of the most developed economies.

A year ago now, in April 2012, the situation in the financial sector was putting the Spanish economy in a critical position. What for some was "the best financial system in the world" was on the verge of giving up the ghost. Perhaps people confused the part with the whole and thought that the extremely high level at some of our leading entities was representative of the entire sector. That was not the case and, perhaps because of that misconception, it has taken us four years to tackle the process of restructuring the sector.

I don't need to tell you that, following the far-reaching process of restructuring that has taken place, the situation has changed and I expect that, sooner rather than later, the financial sector will once again be performing its role as it should be, i.e. channelling savings towards investment and consumption.

The credibility of Spain's accounts will grow exponentially as the effects of the reform become more and more noticeable. The best evidence of that is the trend in the so-called 'risk premium'. Whereas this figure stood at 638 basis points in July 2012, it now stands at less than half that amount. I need not emphasise what this means for a country that will have to refinance 230 billion euros of public debt this year. Some analysts estimate the saving for the public purse at more than one billion euros in this year alone.

None of this stems from hypotheses but rather from facts that demonstrate a change of course is under way, a new scenario for our economy, from which I would like to emphasise the clear improvement in our competitiveness and the gradual reduction of our net indebtedness.

Seeing how I would like to leave more time for the Q&A session, I will only offer a few examples at this time.

Do you recall the last four months of last year? I do, because every time I attended a meeting or spoke to the press, the first question asked of me was always the same: "When are you going to ask for a bailout?" That question has not been asked for some weeks now. Nobody is asking it and nobody is thinking it.

Without seeming triumphalist and with the necessary level of caution, we must admit that the climate has changed. Just think, for example, about the much spoken of ungovernability of our public finances due to the impossibility of controlling regional finances. Well, fiscal consolidation efforts have been made at all levels. By implementing their economic-financial adjustment plans for the period 2012-2014, all the regional governments as a whole have reduced their deficit from 3.31% of GDP in 2011 to 1.76% in 2012. And this has been achieved during a period of recession. Not all of them have managed the same level of reduction, but commitment and effort are now the norm.

As regards our local authorities, the deficit target set in 2012 (0.3% of GDP) has actually been met and surpassed: 0.15% of GDP. We're talking about 8,100 municipalities that were considered unmanageable by many in terms of harmonising their fiscal balances. However, they have come through and met their targets.

All of this has its consequences: in April 2012, we were paying 6% to finance ourselves at ten years; it went up further still after that and even today we are paying 4.2%. In the first four months of 2012, foreign investors had reduced their investment in Spanish bonds by more than 37 billion euros. However, between July 2012 and January 2013, they have acquired more than 46 billion euros of Spanish debt.

As regards the foreign trade sector, it should be noted that the contribution by export activity to the GDP rose above 32% - an increase of two percentage points - and now exceeds such other economies as France and Italy.

The trade balance, excluding energy products, posted a surplus in excess of 15 billion euros in 2012 while this figure stood at a deficit of four billion euros in 2011. Our trade balance with the European Union is now in positive territory - something that has not happened since we joined the Community. Spain is not only consolidating its leading position in terms of tourism services but has gone on to become a net exporter in other services besides tourism. In fact, the net balance in non-tourism services has grown by 28%.

As my last example of the radical change taking place in the trends associated with the foreign trade sector, the second half of 2012 saw the Spanish economy post a current account and capital surplus in excess of 13.6 billion euros, equivalent in annualised terms to 2.5% of the Gross Domestic Product. If you try to find similar results anywhere in our recent economic history, I assure you that you won't.

As regards the labour market and despite the fact that a number of people insist on blaming the rise in unemployment on the labour reform, more than half the recorded increase in unemployment (53% to be precise) took place in the first quarter of 2012, when the labour reform had not yet come into effect. I am sure I need not remind you of the effect that the new employment legislation has had on agreements between companies and employees, enabling jobs to be saved or created. Just think about the automotive sector, to highlight a very specific example.

It should also be remembered that the reduction made to the public sector workforce is having a particular effect on increasing unemployment figures: whereas the number of public sector workers rose by 347,400 between the start of the crisis -let's say 2008 - and the end of 2011, this number has been reduced over the last year and a half - and this was very tough -by 374,80

In terms of our competitiveness, unit labour costs compared with the economic and monetary union are at record lows since the i ntroduction of the Euro. More was achieved in 2012 than in the previous four years and, thanks to this, the loss in cost competitiveness accumulated since 2004 has now been corrected.

In short and so as not to overwhelm you with more numbers, I will summarise what Spain has achieved in the last 12 months:

None of this has happened by chance. As I said before, we set ourselves a number of strategic objectives from the outset:

We have developed three core areas for action to achieve these objectives:

All this has required significant effort in terms of drafting new legislation, the best example of which was the Constitutional Law on Budgetary Stability and Financial Sustainability, which was accompanied by an endless list of other efforts at various legislative levels.

The important thing now is not to stray from the course nor lower the intensity of the changes. This legislature - and I've said this many times - must be remembered for its consistent process of reforms. For that reason, we approved the new National Reform Programme on Friday, as well as the Stability Programme for the coming years. I will now mention a few of the reforms that will be undertaken over the course of this year.

For example, the Independent Fiscal Responsibility Authority will be launched to further develop fiscal discipline and consolidation; the Transparency, Access to Public Information and Good Governance Act will be approved; as will the Plan to Eradicate Bad Debt in the Public Sector and the changes in taxation that were approved at the last meeting of the Council of Ministers.

As regards the reforms of the public sector, definitive approval will be given to the regulations governing the following targets: fostering the removal of administrative duplication and increased efficiency in the management of common services and resources; and streamlining and organising institutional administration. All this will be complemented by a Law on Streamlining and Sustainability of Local Authorities, with a State Foreign Service Act and the promotion of e-Government and the reduction of administrative burdens at all levels of the public sector.

In order to guarantee the sustainability of the pension system, it is necessary to adapt this essential pillar of the welfare state to the new demographic and economic reality. To this end, a group of experts has already been formed to prepare a proposal for its submission to the Toledo Pact.

In order to improve the regulatory framework surrounding the financial system, a Savings Bank and Bank Foundations Act will be promulgated and a series of measures will be adopted to improve supervision in the sector.

To this can be added the measures to restore normality in the credit process; steps to improve labour intermediation and employment policies; support for entrepreneurs through the Entrepreneurial Support Act; a Constitutional Law on Improving Education; the implementation of the market unity programme; and the Law on De-indexing and Developing the Spanish Science, Technology and Innovation Strategy 2013-2020. Furthermore, the Electricity Sector Reform Act; the Professional Association Services Act; the Chambers of Commerce, Industry and Services Act; the Law on State Account Coverage of Spanish Business Internationalisation Risk Coverage; a new Telecommunications Act; and other steps in the transport, real estate sectors, agri-food and environment sectors.

As you will see, an ongoing process of reforms.

In terms of affairs within the European Union, we will continue our discrete and ongoing efforts to defend our ideas and interests. There are those who might think that extending the deadlines and changing the limits for compliance with the Spanish public sector deficit correction requirements happens by chance or that one European commissioner or another was having a good day. I can assure you that nothing is further from the truth.

As you are aware, in Europe, we are also defending a faster integration process and the implementation of measures, such as banking union, that are essential to our economy. We will not falter in this regard; we will stay smart, stand strong and put forward arguments that deserve consideration. The strategy adopted by my government has always been to complement action at a domestic level with actions at a European level in order to generate synergies that favour both our pro-European commitment and the achievement of the fundamental goal for this legislature in terms of results in Spain: to reverse the economic situation in which we found our country in December 2011.

Ladies and gentlemen, members of the Family Business Institute,

If you are kind enough to invite me to your assembly again next year, in April, we will have the opportunity to see whether what I have said here today was correct: that we are on the verge of turning our situation around and that the foundations for achieving that are increasingly solid.

By maintaining the same course and intensity of effort, we will continue working to leave the economic recession behind us and give Spanish society well-grounded reason to have hope once again. And I would very much like to take stock of all this with you after the necessary twelve months have passed before your next meeting.

What we face now is a difficult challenge and I am convinced that we will not stop until it has been transformed into a success story. It is going to demand from us all, and I mean everyone, a great deal of effort and sound judgement but, in return, it offers an outlook of economic recovery that will enable the opportunities and confidence that we should never have lost in the first place to be returned to Spain and to those who live here.

Thank you all very much for your attention. I now look forward to hearing your questions and your suggestions.

Q&A SESSION WITH THE PRESIDENT OF THE GOVERNMENT AT THE ANNUAL ASSEMBLY OF THE FAMILY BUSINESS INSTITUTE ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Q. For now, the only help received by Spain has been the forty billion [euros] to clean up the banking system, which will be paid back by the entities in the shortest time possible. The "troika" has done nothing but ask for sacrifices in exchange for what it offers. Have you not been tempted, Mr President of the Government, to ignore the "troika" and do something different by implementing a different economic policy?

President of the Government. That's right; we have received aid amounting to forty billion euros. It is a loan that the financial institutions will have to repay following a grace period of ten years and at an interest rate of 0.5%. This was essential for our country. We had a serious problem in a sizeable portion of our financial sector and that is why this move was so necessary. And I must say that I am grateful, because it is important to Spain, to whoever was responsible for taking that decision at the corresponding European institution.

That said, you asked me whether I have had the impression that the only thing being asked for by the European Union was to make adjustments and reforms and whether I could have implemented a different economic policy. I will be absolutely frank with you: if one forms part of a club, as we do, and one forms part of that club voluntarily, as we do, it is logical to say that one is not there to start ignoring the rules - we are in this club to try and improve those rules.

The economic policy put forward by my government for the next few years is fundamentally based - and I have reiterated this on several occasions - on five points. The first two points are our own exclusive responsibility: the first is to reduce the public deficit - we cannot live, and even less so under financial circumstances such as these, with a deficit at the level of 9% that we had before; and, the second consists of structural reforms.

As regards the public deficit, it's true that I would have liked to have had to achieve the results over a longer period of time - believe me, lowering the public deficit as we have done, in nominal terms by more than two percentage points and in structural terms by more than three, is no easy feat. We are talking about 22 billion euros in the midst of an economic recession.

This year, the deficit target had been set at 4.5%. However, as I said in my speech, the European Commission has changed that to 6.3%. This is positive. We must continue reducing the public deficit, but we are now going to do so in a more reasonable manner. Therefore, we will not need to make such extraordinary efforts this year as we did in 2012.

Secondly, we need to implement structural reforms, which is what we are doing. I have announced some of them here; others will be implemented over the course of 2012.

And then there are three points that specifically relate to European issues. I believe that Europe must send out a resounding message, loud and clear, to say there will be no going back on the Euro. I believe that the monetary union is not working. It makes no sense that certain countries are financing themselves at certain interest rates while others are financing themselves at much higher interest rates. Therefore, I have basically proposed and strongly defended three things to the European Union: firstly, that reforms be undertaken in the European Union as well, not only domestically within the Member States but rather EU-wide reforms and, above all, to continue developing the European single market. We are going to talk about energy at the next European Council and we are going to talk about the Digital Agenda at the European Council in October. So, reforms in Europe are essential and what we Member States can do is apply pressure, in the best sense of the word 'pressure'.

Secondly, it is essential that we achieve progress on European integration. Europe is a process that has taken place over many years - 56 years have passed since the Treaty of Rome in 1957. I believe this is a decisive moment for the European Union, even though the European Union is moving slowly. The process of launching the Euro itself took ten years, but now is the time to move forward on banking union, fiscal union and, later on, political union. Last year, we held a highly important European Council meeting in June where, in collaboration with the Italian Prime Minister, Mr Monti at the time, we convinced our partners of the need to move in that direction.

To highlight this point, it should be noted that the problem in Cyprus would not have arisen had we had banking union in place because there would already have been a single banking supervisor, clear rules shared by everyone, a common resolution mechanism, rules on direct recapitalisation and a European Deposit Guarantee Fund. Therefore, European integration efforts must continue.

Finally, we have the liquidity problems and the situation of certain European institutions. I think that more can be done in this regard but it's also true to say that things have already been done. Some of the decisions announced by the European Central Bank in the middle of last year were highly positive because they made it clear that, in the event of a problem, the European Central Bank is available to buy up bonds on the secondary market. It is true that in terms of help for small and medium-sized enterprises, strengthening collateral or creating another type of help or transactions with the banks, such as was the case in other countries with other central banks, further progress can still be made.

But if I were to say one thing to you about Europe it would be this: there are many things I have not liked, there are many issues on which we have had to stand strong, we are twenty-seven countries after all, but I think that Europe is moving in the right direction.

The deficit target revision for this year is positive. The decisions that, at the end of the day with all the problems we have had, were taken on countries such as Cyprus, even the extensions for Portugal and Ireland, and on countries such as Greece, were decisions that told the world: "what we need to do here is maintain the Euro". And that is a very positive message.

It's true that more action can still be taken and it's true that continued effort is required in that direction, but Europe cannot be built in one, two or even five years.

I insist, we must do our own homework well - the deficit and the reforms - and then we have to work, act and focus on ensuring that efforts are made in Europe towards that three-fold target: reforms, European integration and resolution of the liquidity problems.

Q. Another question I have from a member of the Institute is this: Do you feel satisfied with what you've done so far? Do you particularly regret any of the steps taken?

President of the Government. What I must say first of all is that there is absolutely no way whatsoever that I can feel satisfied with the economic growth figures or the unemployment figures. I am deeply dissatisfied with those figures. However, in the same way, I would like to say something else that I feel is very important: a good diagnosis must be the first step and only then can the appropriate decisions be taken.

Spain had - and I explained this in my speech - a number of very significant economic imbalances and the consequences of those very important economic imbalances are the low or negative economic growth and the increase in unemployment. Therefore, the first step to be taken is to correct the imbalances and then economic growth and job creation will come as the imbalances are corrected over time. The crux of the issue is that if we do not act on the imbalances and if we do not take decisions, which I know please almost nobody, it is impossible for there to be growth and job creation further down the road.

What have we done? I have tried to explain and, for that reason, I will summarise very briefly. We have reduced the public deficit, and I insist, under very difficult circumstances; we have made important reforms, such as the labour reform, which led, among other things, to two general strikes; and we have restructured the financial system, which was absolutely essential for laying the groundwork for growth and job creation in the future.

As I told you in my speech, over the course of this time, positive results have indeed been achieved in terms of correcting the imbalances: firstly, the deficit has been reduced - something that has been well received in various circles. The International Monetary Fund said that we are the country making the largest structural effort in this regard.

Secondly, the data from the foreign trade sector, which I also mentioned in my speech, and there has been an enormous effort from all the companies and family businesses.

Thirdly, the restructuring of the financial sector is now under way. Believe me, that was no easy task.

Private indebtedness is being lowered little by little, which together with the restructuring of the financial system could be said to have been the fourth large imbalance.

It is obvious that we still have certain credit problems, and this is the next short-term challenge to be tacked by the government, and we are absolutely aware that this is the case. It is true that debt needs to be lowered, but it's also true that some have a greater need to lower debt than others, and that those who are exporting, those who have always complied and those who are doing things right need to have access to credit. That is why this is a fundamental objective.

Therefore, from the point of view of the imbalances, things are working reasonably well and that is the prologue, the first step, towards later being able to grow and create jobs. Then we have the European issue to which I referred earlier: if Europe works fast, economic growth and jobs will arrive sooner; if Europe sends clear messages to the world about reforms, about integration and about resolving the liquidity problems and takes decisions, things will get done sooner.

Let me summarise: I am not satisfied in terms of economic growth and unemployment, it would be ridiculous if I were; secondly, I am only moderately satisfied with the progress made in Europe; and, thirdly, I believe that, in terms of correcting the imbalances, things are progressing better and that, I insist, is the first step, the essential step, towards generating growth and creating jobs.

As I have said on previous occasions, last year was a bad year with economic growth far below what we would have liked to see, but the situation will improve substantially in the final part of this year.

Q. Another question from the members, which has been asked by a number of them, is this: of the three medicines for recovering from the crisis (adjustments, reforms and stimulus measures), we have taken a large dose of the first, a little of the second and none of the third. Is the Government of Spain considering a change of treatment? Is Spain able to administer them or are its hands tied by demands from Brussels?

President of the Government. I believe that all three are absolutely necessary. In other words, if we make no adjustments and do not lower our debt, it will be very difficult for there to be economic growth and job creation. The same applies if we make no structural reforms: without structural reforms, without increased flexibility in the economy, it is very difficult for there to be growth and job creation. Stimulus measures are also necessary and we are going to talk about such measures.

However, I insist, it is fundamental that we lower the deficit, especially in a situation such as this; it is necessary to lower our debt just as the reforms and stimulus measures are also necessary.

Now, stimulus measures. It depends on what type of stimulus measures. I believe that we took the right decision in 2012 as regards the Supplier Payment Plan. That is a good stimulus measure because it means that the public administration services are paying their bills, which is only reasonable to expect. However, I do not think that such measures as the 'Plan E' are good stimulus measures as all it did was unreasonably increase our public deficit at a time when it was already excessively high. At the end of the day, these things always have to be paid for.

I think there are three issues on the table at the moment and the President mentioned some of them in his speech: taxation, infrastructure and credit.

Personally, I think that resolving the credit issue is fundamental. Investment, and by extension employment, requires confidence but it also requires money. I am absolutely aware of the difficulties currently being felt by many Spanish companies when trying to obtain credit. The position of some large Spanish companies has improved as a result of certain events that I spoke of earlier but, nonetheless, this is the main objective.

During the State of the Nation Debate in February, I announced the implementation, through the ICO and another series of... - I have some figures here about that, but I don't think I can... -, of 45 billion euros and, above all, we are implementing the restructuring process within the financial system. This is our challenge for the coming months.

Secondly, we have the issue of infrastructure. I am aware of and listened to what José Manuel Entrecanales just said in his speech. The situation Spain is in at the moment has forced us to undertake a drastic reduction in public spending. We have tried to do this in a balanced fashion and, believe me, it has not been easy. I quoted a figure earlier... I know that many people are talking about cut-backs and restructuring in the public administration services. It is very difficult, especially for the people, to see three hundred and something thousand jobs lost in the public sector in a little over one year. That is very tough on the people but everyone has to understand it.

We have made cut-backs under every heading in the budget and we have tried to do so in a balanced manner. I would like to be able to allocate many more resources to R&D+i and be able to dedicate more resources than we are dedicating right now to infrastructure. It is an issue that needs to be dealt with and, of course, as soon as the government has the first opportunity to do so, it will.

The third aspect is the issue of taxation. I do not like raising taxes and I have had to raise a fair number of them now. We have had to delay - I wish we had been able to do this in 2014 - the reduction, which in any event we will implement in 2015 if we are unable to in 2014, of the increase we applied to Personal Income Tax; we have been forced to raise Value Added Tax, although we tried to protect the interests of such sectors as tourism and maintain VAT at the average rate of 10% because they are highly important sectors for the Spanish economy. There are some countries with truly dramatic levels already, certain neighbours of ours, with 23% VAT in the hotel and catering sector.

We have had highly significant collection problems. In two years, 65 billion euros of tax revenue was lost in Spain, 65 billion euros. We are number 27 of 27 in the European Union in terms of VAT revenue/Gross Domestic Product, in the percentage of VAT/Gross Domestic Product.

As soon as it possibly can, the government intends to gradually lower taxes. However, the government believes right now, we strongly believe it, that now is not a good time to do that.

We have taken a number of partial measures in the Entrepreneurship and Youth Employment Strategy aimed, above all, at helping young people - those who are experiencing a situation of enormous complexity. I believe they could be useful, as could be certain changes we have made in terms of employment contracts.

But I must insist that Spain has another mission right now - to clean up the Spanish economy. Once the Spanish economy has been cleaned up, the rest will follow. It is true that certain things can be done at the same time and that's why I say this: the most pressing issue at the moment is getting credit to those who deserve credit, who work, who export and who are doing things right.

It is true that decisions can be taken along the way, even indicative decisions, regarding tax issues. However, this is obviously a priority for the government and you can rest assured that it will take place during this legislature.

Q . You have already answered a great number of the questions I had for you. I think I have two left, two issues that you have not yet tackled. The first is this: Why, after five years of crisis, has no great government pact been achieved in Spain with the opposition party other than the Constitutional Law on the Budgetary Stability Agreement?

President of the Government. Not even the Constitutional Law on Budgetary Stability. Not even on the Constitutional Law on Budgetary Stability was it possible to reach a government pact. It was possible to reach a government pact to reform the Constitution and establish the Fiscal Agreement in our Magna Carta and it was possible when we were in opposition. Following that, we presented a constitutional law to develop that constitutional legislation but we managed to get that through without the support of the main opposition party.

Just as it was not possible to reach agreements on issues that have been highly important in recent times, such as the labour reform; it was not possible. What's more, this is a constant criticism that is made of us: "much of the labour reform", they say, "needs to be undone".

Just as it was not possible to reach agreement on other issues that have also been highly important in recent times, such as the evictions issue, for example. It was also impossible to reach an agreement here. However, the government has a duty to act as responsibly as possibly and it is important to take steps that can lead to a solution for certain situations that are truly dramatic. However, it is also important that we preserve a mortgage system that has enabled millions of Spanish citizens to buy a home with credit. Millions of people, more than 96%, meet their repayments regularly. I believe that we have provided a balanced solution. It would be very easy to do what certain opposition political forces are saying we should do; but the government has to act responsibly regarding this issue and regarding many other issues.

We are now approaching another very important issue: we will see whether it's possible to reach an agreement regarding the issue of sustainability in our pension system; we'll see if that's possible.

It is very easy to say "we need to reach an agreement". It is harder to approve the reforms proposed in the Lower House of Parliament. That is much harder. However, I will say this: I would like to reach agreement, of course I would. I would like us to reach an agreement but I am also aware that the greatest responsibility at the moment falls on the Government of Spain and the Government of Spain must accept the cost, which we do accept, of the decisions we are taking, which are very difficult.

Honestly, I see no chance... with others, we have reached agreement on some issues, but I see no chance of certain others being willing to share that cost. In any event, I will never close the door on them, especially at a time when the efforts being made here are being made by all Spaniards and we're all paying a price. Perhaps one political party might pay a certain political cost; but the efforts are being made by the companies, the efforts are being made by the people, the efforts are being made by those public sector workers I mentioned earlier and the efforts are being made by the people of Spain as a whole. Of course I think it would be good that others also made an effort! But if they do not want to, the responsibility falls on the government and the government will therefore not fail in taking up the mantle.

The government has set a course. We had to make a very large reduction to the public deficit last year and so, this year, we will only need to ask for a smaller effort from the people of Spain. We are going to resolve the credit problem, we are going to stand our ground in Europe and we are going to continue the process of structural reforms.

As I said before, inflation will be less than 2% this year; our competitiveness will improve; the foreign trade sector will also improve; and the public deficit will gradually get better. And there we have the prologue to economic growth.

There was a very interesting debate - allow me to introduce this issue because I think it is interesting - on the forecasts made by the government. It was the wish of my government to produce a series of realistic forecasts. I clearly have no intention of inventing forecasts. I will not refer to the past, but I have no intention of inventing a series of economic forecasts that will not come true later, thus frittering away any vestige of credibility.

Last year we said, "growth in Spain will stand at -1.7%". In the end, it stood at -1.4% - a dreadful figure, clearly, but better than -1.7%. Just look at what other countries have done with their forecasts: in August 2012, the United Kingdom said it was going to grow by 1.8%. Well, this year, it has changed its mind and said, where it previously said 1.8%, there will only be 0.6%. In France, when they presented their budget for last year, they said: "this year, 2013, we will grow by 0.8%". Now they are saying: "no, growth will stand at 0%". And in Germany, they first estimated growth of 1.6% and are now saying: "we are going to grow by 0.4%".

In other words, the forecasts all changed and everyone made adjustments, as did the European Commission and the International Monetary Fund, to reflect the current situation. But I will say this: just as the forecasts have all now been revised downward by all the major economies of the European Union while, on the other hand, certain other countries in the rest of Europe have revised their forecasts upwards, what this exercise is actually about is making the right moves and maintaining this economic policy so that these forecasts can be amended upwards soon. That is precisely what this has all been about.

So, I insist, because I have gone off track slightly, I am willing to talk to anyone but the truth is that none of our structural reforms have been approved by them; what's more, they are asking us to change them.

Q. Mr. President of the Government, a comment, an invitation and a question: given that the government will be criticised whatever it does until there is economic recovery, a number of members are wondering, why not increase the pace of reform? Why not be more radical?

And I will end with this. Since the start of the crisis, we businesses have suffered from bad financing conditions and increased taxation, we have ventured into the export sector, we have improved our competitiveness and we have shrunk our profit accounts. What more can we do to help pull this country out of the crisis and what would you ask of us?

President of the Government . A more radical pace of reforms? There are two positions on that: those who don't want any reforms to be made and those who want the reforms to be made faster. I am a supporter of the latter. I believe that we have to implement these reforms, that is my position. I have announced here a sizeable package of reforms, but I will say something else: it is hard to find - at least, I have been unable to find - any other government that has implemented structural reforms such as those we have been implementing here within a period of a little over a year in power.

The Constitutional Law on Budgetary Stability is an absolute change in the way we manage the public accounts in our country. There was nothing like it before. There was no control over the public accounts of all public administration services as a whole, none at all. Well, now we have total control over the public accounts of all the public administration services as a whole, and that is very positive. I must add that the Spanish public administration services, both the regional governments and the local authorities, are making a great effort that nobody has recognised yet. It is easy to say "yes, reduce the administration services". Less than 300,000 public sector workers. They are making a great effort, as are the people of Spain in general.

That is a first-class structural reform, as the labour reform is a first-class structural reform, as the restructuring of the banking system is a first-class structural reform, as is the creation of the Asset Management Company deriving from the Bank Restructuring (SAREB) - what is being called the "bad bank"; as are the many measures we have adopted in terms of energy issues. Those are structural reforms and, now, the second National Reform Plan that we announced on Friday at the Council of Ministers meeting.

Therefore, we are going to continue with our reforms. I believe they need to be done and I believe that stopping short or not adapting to the world we live in or not striving for a more flexible and competitive economy would be absolutely ridiculous. Therefore, we are going to continue in that direction.

What would I ask of the business world? I am not going to ask for much. If I had to ask for something, I would ask this: keep doing what you are doing. I think that Spanish companies are making an enormous effort. I think that the foreign trade sector figures and the way they are opening up to foreign markets is incredibly impressive. The Europe of the Euro is in recession, which is where our main customers are to be found (France, Germany, Italy and even Portugal). Even so, our exports are on the rise. Our exports to Latin America are increasing; there we have a huge market. Also to Asia, and even to North Africa; another large market. They are regions of the world with enormous growth and where many opportunities are to be found.

I am fully aware that this is very complicated but this is one of the greatest concerns that my government has and I believe this is one of the issues we have to agree on, and I would like to also hear further contributions in the future.

So, keep doing what you are doing. I would ask you to keep investing. This is one reason why, as I said in my first speech, I am satisfied with the figure I heard here that 64% of the members of this institute, at least of those of you here, say you intend to continue investing in Spain.

I would ask you this: do everything you can to be competitive in terms of price. I know that is very easy to say and not so easy to do, right? And, above all, I would say one thing, which is not so difficult but of immense importance. I would ask you to speak well of our country - I think this is extremely important - to talk about the steps being taken in Spain so that international investors can be made aware of the efforts taking place, for them to realise that the imbalances are being corrected, to know that Spain is a good country in which to invest. We have heard positive news from certain multinational companies and I believe that we are going to hear more in the future.

Sometimes, I get the feeling that we talk, some of us... It seems that some of us prefer to talk about the negative and what is being done wrong. Listen, speak ill of the government but do not speak ill of the work being done to correct the imbalances and the progress being achieved, as there is no doubt that this is the prologue to economic growth and job creation.

Seeing how you asked what I would ask of you, just keep doing what you are doing and speak well of Spain.

Q. Thank you very much, Mr. President of the Government.

President of the Government. Thank you very much.