Responses from the President of the Government in the parliamentary control session.

Spain Mariano Rajoy · Prime Minister of Spain

29 January 2013 · Parliamentary control session

Context
Rajoy responded to parliamentary questions during a government control session in Spain's Congress of Deputies on January 29, 2013, addressing corruption and transparency.
Main themes
Anti-corruption measures, political party financing transparency, parliamentary debate on corruption, social crisis and unemployment, evictions and poverty, democratic credibility, transparency legislation, systemic corruption scandals, good governance, public institutions trust
Duration
~23 min
72nd percentile
Words
2,736
72nd percentile
Sentences
101
63rd percentile
Readability
44
45th percentile
Grade
13.3
60th percentile
Syntax
3.22
74th percentile
Vocabulary
2.13
33rd percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 50%49%
  • Institutional 37%36%
  • Ceremonial 9%9%
  • Social 3%3%
  • Geopolitical 1%1%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 3%

101 sentences in 43 paragraphs

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Cayo Lara, of the Parliamentary Group of the Left Plural

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Mr. Lara.- Mr. President of the Government, is the Government willing to hold a special plenary session to develop a plan to combat corruption?

President.- Thank you very much, Mr. Lara. I am willing to develop a plan against corruption agreed upon by all political parties that wish to do so. In fact, on the 21st of last month, the Vice President of the Government contacted the spokespeople or representatives of seven Parliamentary Groups in this Chamber, including you, as you know, and conveyed the following: first, the Government's willingness to subscribe to a pact for transparency and against corruption; second, the willingness to agree on the Law of Transparency, Access to Public Information, and Good Governance, currently being processed in the Congress of Deputies, as well as the utmost willingness to accept amendments; and, third, all spokespeople were informed that a commission had been made to the Center for Political and Constitutional Studies to prepare a report on possible measures in the field of combating corruption. This report will be ready in a few weeks, and we are willing to discuss it among all groups.

I believe that on these bases we can build positively together if there is the political will to do so. What I can say is that my Group has the political will to do so.

Mr. Lara.- Mr. Rajoy, indeed, the Vice President of the Government called me and offered me the opportunity to participate in a commission; but we believe that with that commission, only a whitewashing of the face of the problem of corruption is achieved at this moment.

In this Spain that is bleeding today with six million unemployed; with more than three hundred thousand people evicted from their homes; with poverty, social exclusion, and even suicides, and with the known cases of alleged corruption that are undermining our democracy such as the "Gurtel," "Urdangarín," "Palau de la Música," "Pokemon," "Campeón," "Fabra," "Pallerols," "Eres," "Baltar," "Matas"; the twenty million in a Swiss account of the former treasurer of the Popular Party, the news of supposed invisible envelopes in Genoa, and the suspicion of the origin of these funds have created public scandal, indignation, and social alarm.

In some cases, we are talking about corruption; in others, about alleged corruption; in others, about alleged irregular financing of political parties, in a perverse model, because we are talking about systemic corruption, which has grown, above all, in the wake of the real estate bubble.

Corruption is a cancer for democracy, which damages the credibility of public institutions and politics, which threatens public assets, which undermines the foundations of the democratic system, which causes citizen disaffection and fuels the "they are all the same" narrative that is the basis for populism. Corruption scandals are not resolved with a report from experts and a commission. Fraud is implicit in corruption and is not resolved by educating children from the age of eleven. Those who are corrupt know they are committing a crime, and so do the corruptors, and many were educated in good universities.

The underlying problem, Mr. Rajoy, is that political parties cannot be suffocated while some take resources through the back door of companies. There are more honest politicians in this country than corrupt ones. Therefore, corruption cannot continue to poison democracy, and financing must be public, fair, and transparent; and that is why we ask you for a special plenary session on corruption where it can be debated openly and a serious plan can be made to definitively end corruption in Spain. Otherwise, the Bárcenas bomb will likely explode in the Government's face as well.

President.- Thank you very much, Mr. Lara. I would invite you not to just recount things or say what we all already know, and I would invite you to be effective and propose measures that are useful.

I can tell you that throughout this Legislature we have presented a reform of the Organic Law on the Financing of Political Parties; a reform of the Penal Code regarding transparency and the fight against tax fraud and Social Security; also within a section of good governance and exemplary measures in that same Law of Transparency and the Fight against Tax Fraud in Social Security, and we have in the Cortes the Bill on Transparency in Access to Public Information and Good Governance.

I believe that all of this will mean more transparency, more control, and greater responsibility, and, as I said before, the Center for Political and Constitutional Studies is working on this issue along two lines: on one hand, collective measures to increase control and transparency over the accounts of political parties, and on the other, individual measures to promote good governance and exemplary conduct, which include both measures aimed at increasing control and repression. I believe that, without a doubt, these types of measures can be more useful and more effective than limiting ourselves to recounting what we see every day in the newspapers. I invite you to join this debate, I invite you to present measures, I invite you to let us all know your alternatives, and I also invite you to work, as I will do, in search of an agreement.

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Josep Sánchez Llibre, of the Parliamentary Group of Catalan Convergence and Union

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Mr. Sánchez Llibre.- Does the Government intend to relax the deficit targets for 2013 for the Autonomous Communities?

President.- Thank you very much, Mr. Sánchez Llibre. I believe we can agree on some things, and that is that Spain, as a whole, must reduce its public deficit. This is good in itself, it leaves resources for the private sector, allows access to financing and access under better conditions, and, moreover, it is a commitment we must fulfill within the excessive deficit procedure that the European Union has set for Spain.

I believe that this effort must be made by all of us. The deficit targets have been set in the Council of Fiscal and Financial Policy, ratified in Congress, also in the Senate, and also in the Conference of Presidents, and from there all the Autonomous Communities, except for three that have had elections recently, have presented their Budgets with a public deficit target for 2013 of 0.7 percent. The Government also fulfilled its commitment. And all of this has been communicated, in compliance with our obligation, to the European Commission.

I believe that, as of today, it would not be a good message to propose the modification of these criteria either for the markets or for anyone in the world since, as you know, our financing depends fundamentally on them.

Mr. Sánchez Llibre.- Mr. President of the Government, honestly, we believe that this is not the way. Either we work all Public Administrations in the same direction, or we will hardly be able to emerge from this situation unscathed. That is why, from Convergència i Unió, we ask you for a radical change of attitude, to seek the path of sensibility and dialogue, to relax the deficit of the Autonomous Communities and not to suffocate, Mr. President, social policies and give oxygen to the Autonomous Communities so that they can provide health, education, and social services with the highest quality and the greatest guarantee.

We not only ask this from Catalonia and from other Autonomous Communities, but also exactly fifteen days ago the European Parliament approved a motion to distribute the efforts of fiscal consolidation of all Administrations of the countries of the European Union in a fairer manner among the different Administrations, taking into account the services they provide. Also, the day before yesterday, Commissioner Olli Rehn of the European Commission and Minister Guindos, in Brussels, opened the possibility for this relaxation of the deficit of the different Autonomous Administrations.

Therefore, Mr. President, we ask you, with the utmost energy and from a political and democratic perspective, for this radical change of attitude. It is not fair, Mr. President, that in 2013 the Government has increased its deficit by 14 percent for the Central State Administration and, at the same time, Mr. President, has imposed a reduction of the deficit for the Autonomous Communities of more than 50 percent, going from 1.5 percent to 0.75 percent. It is also not fair, Mr. President, that you have increased all taxes -- VAT, personal income tax, special taxes, and corporate tax -- with an increase in revenue for the years 2012 and 2013 of more than forty billion euros that will all go to the Central Administration and the Autonomous Communities will not see a single euro of this increase in revenue, despite the fact that the majority of taxes are ceded at more than 50 percent.

Therefore, Mr. President, change your attitude and start the path of...

President.- Thank you very much, Mr. Sánchez Llibre. This debate already took place on the occasion of the 2012 Budgets, as you recall, and the difference between the initially planned 5.3 percent and the 6.3 percent that the Commission ultimately asked of us was not applied to the General State Administration; it was applied, fundamentally, to Social Security and unemployment benefits, which are items that affect all citizens living in all territories of Spain.

I understand and appreciate the enormous effort that the Autonomous Communities have made, and I believe it is a patriotic effort in the fight against the public deficit. And I understand and know how difficult it is, because we are also doing it in the Central State Administration. I know that some of the items of the Autonomous Communities are items of great rigidity, but also those of the Central State Administration. Think of the items for Social Security, unemployment benefits, transfers to Autonomous Communities, transfers to the European Union, or debt interest. In fact, in two years the Government has reduced the budgets of its Ministries by 25.8 percent.

Moreover, as you know, we help the Autonomous Communities that cannot even finance the deficit they are demanding from us, and we go to the markets to cover their debt and deficit, and under advantageous conditions for the Autonomous Communities themselves, as we have also helped them in terms of advances, payments on account, or return of settlements, and always at no financial cost. From there, if things change, which for now have not changed, it will be the time to talk because we will be in a different scenario.

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Alfredo Pérez Rubalcaba, of the Socialist Parliamentary Group

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Mr. Pérez Rubalcaba.- Mr. President, I have been concerned about the serious situation that Spain is going through. We have started the year frankly badly: territorial tensions have increased; political disaffection has also increased, and we have six million unemployed, Mr. Rajoy. Six million, a tragedy.

Your labor reform is wreaking havoc. Among other things, we have started the year with two million workers without the protection of collective agreements. I know that some of you call it flexibility; I call it exploitation. And a serious crisis, a tragedy, requires, I believe, a great effort; it requires an agreement among all: the Government, political groups, unions, and employers. That is why I have proposed to you, Mr. Rajoy, that we reopen political dialogue, that we reopen social dialogue, and that we try to reach an agreement, because it is the most important thing that the Spanish people are asking of us.

It is difficult, it is a difficult agreement, but I hasten to tell you that I believe there are areas where we can agree. For example, we have given forty billion euros to the Banks. You said that forty billion was an amount manageable by our debt. I ask you to create a fund of twenty billion -- exactly half -- to meet the credit needs of small and medium-sized enterprises, entrepreneurs, and the self-employed. The Spanish people are asking, and rightly so, why there is money for the Banks and not for employment. So I propose to you, Mr. Rajoy, that we respond from this Chamber that yes, there is money for employment, that we will look for it under the stones.

But I also spoke to you about political disaffection, and that has a lot to do with corruption. Fighting against corruption, as you have said, is a responsibility of all, because it is true that it is seriously wounding our democracy. You have a corruption problem in your party that affects Autonomous Communities and City Councils, and it also affects dozens of political leaders. I ask you, Mr. Rajoy, that as the president of the party, you act with determination, you act with urgency, and you act with exemplary behavior. Determination, urgency, and exemplary behavior; that is what I ask of you, Mr. Rajoy.

President.- Thank you very much, Mr. Pérez Rubalcaba. The question is formulated in very generic terms. Spain, indeed, has its problems. I will refer, fundamentally, to economic issues.

I agree with what you have said about corruption, and I can only make you the same recommendation you have made to me. But I believe that the most important thing at this moment is what we are going to do in this situation.

The objective remains to grow and create jobs. We knew that this year would be a bad year. In fact, when we made the forecast in the Budget, we said: year 2012, economic growth -1.7 percent, and in the end it will be -1.3 percent; and year 2012, the increase in unemployment will be 672,000 people, and it is 694,000 people; a certainly dramatic figure, and we have to fight against it.

What are we going to do? Continue working to ensure that entrepreneurs have a favorable economic environment and credit; that is, we will continue with the process of structural reforms that we have initiated.

Secondly, we intend to launch, and present it here in the Chamber in the coming days, a package to stimulate the economy, as well as a Youth Entrepreneurship and Employment Strategy, with the aim of reducing youth unemployment, a topic we have been working on since November with trade union and business organizations.

And, thirdly, we will do everything possible to continue helping those who are in the most difficult situations; that is, to be equitable when distributing the efforts of this crisis.

Regarding agreements, I am always willing, but whenever I have presented important structural reforms here, I have received a response, which is the total and absolute no from the Spanish Socialist Workers' Party. If you want to rectify and reach understandings, I am at your disposal.

Mr. Pérez Rubalcaba.- Mr. Rajoy, the Socialist Party learned the lesson a long time ago, a long time ago, and we learned it forever. You then got away with legal tricks, and, Mr. Rajoy, I will tell you, you believed yourselves to be immune, and that is what you are paying for now, Mr. Rajoy, because impunity in this country, fortunately, no longer exists.

President.- Mr. Pérez Rubalcaba, you have not been very fortunate today, and I suppose that in your Group the situation of your party forces you to play those roles; but in any case, I will try to say what we are going to do over the next few months.

First of all, we will continue with the control of the deficit and with the banking restructuring. We have presented the Law of Market Unity. The labor reform is working very well. It is improving our competitiveness, as evidenced by the fact that the external sector deficit will be zero in 2013 and as evidenced by the fact that there are significant foreign investors -- we have seen cases in the automotive sector -- who have seen Spain. We will present, as I have said, soon an economic stimulus package, we have already approved the PIVE Plan and the SME Plan, which are very important for these sectors of the Spanish economy. And shortly, I insist, we will present in this Chamber a Youth Employment Strategy in accordance with the guidelines set by the European Union.

Spain is going through difficult times, but positive data is already emerging…