Responses from the President of the Government in the parliamentary control session

Spain Mariano Rajoy · Prime Minister of Spain

12 February 2013 · Parliamentary control session

Context
Rajoy responded to PNV parliamentary group questions during a Spanish Congress control session on February 12, 2013, addressing Basque competence disputes.
Main themes
Basque regional competences, centralization concerns, legislative reforms, regional autonomy, economic crisis response, intergovernmental dialogue, market unity, local government law, constitutional distribution of powers, structural reforms
Duration
~22 min
69th percentile
Words
2,603
69th percentile
Sentences
86
56th percentile
Readability
37
30th percentile
Grade
15.2
77th percentile
Syntax
3.29
82nd percentile
Vocabulary
2.19
47th percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 82%80%
  • Economic 7%7%
  • Ceremonial 7%7%
  • Social 2%2%
  • Geopolitical 1%1%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 2%

86 sentences in 43 paragraphs

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Aitor Esteban, from the Basque Parliamentary Group PNV

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Mr. Esteban.- Good morning, Mr. President.

I ask you about the legislative initiative of your Government regarding the Basque competential framework.

In our opinion, this year of the Legislature, the governmental legislative initiative has had two characteristics, among others: one, more Royal Decree Laws have been presented than Bills, and, secondly, there has also been a tendency to encroach upon the competences of the Autonomous Communities, sometimes based, in many of the laws, on a title as improbable as it is elastic, which is that of the general regulation of the economy, which serves the Government for one thing or another.

To cite a few laws that are still in process and that certainly concern us greatly, I would mention the Transparency Law, the Law of Market Unity, the Education Law, the announced drafts of the modification of the Regulatory Law of Local Government, or the Coast Law. At times we have salvaged fractures to the Economic Concert at the last minute, but always at the last minute in the Plenary, as, for example, in the Bill on Energy Sustainability.

I will not deny that there is exquisite treatment from the members of your Government regarding personal relationships; that is certainly true; but good words are of little use if they are not translated into actions. Today, a meeting of a working group regarding the Coast Law is going to be held, and at this moment, my Group still does not know whether what was agreed upon between the PNV Parliamentary Group and the Ministry will be fulfilled or not.

You and the Lehendakari had a meeting in which there were discrepancies and in which there were agreements, but in which it seems there was a climate of dialogue; however, from our Parliamentary Group, from the PNV, we must clearly express our concern about the centralizing bias of many of the Government's initiatives, although I also point out that on our part, there will be no lack of dialogue until that last second to try to reach an agreement. But I must tell you emphatically that we will denounce and oppose by all means at our disposal any attempt at encroachment upon competences.

President.- Mr. Esteban, as you know, the basic objective of the Government is to address the economic crisis to grow and create jobs, and this obliges us to make many structural reforms. We do this while being respectful of the distribution of competences. It is not my intention to recentralize anything, but it is my intention to make reforms.

In any case, I want to clearly state our willingness to talk with your Group or with the Basque Government about any aspect that may generate doubts, and I celebrate that this is, as I knew, also your willingness. To give you some data, in this Legislature, the General Administration of the State has presented three challenges against regulations of the Basque Autonomous Community, that is, one against the Law of Voluntary Social Welfare Entities, without us having requested the suspension, which is not a trivial matter as you know perfectly; and we have presented two positive conflicts regarding the regime of health benefits and extra pay. And the Autonomous Community has presented a resource in the area of public function against a Royal Decree Law of the Government and two conflicts regarding health care.

I would like to say one thing: both the Government and the Autonomous Communities have the authority—I believe that more than the authority, the obligation—to ensure respect for competences, for the distribution that the Constitution itself makes. Therefore, it is in a way normal that there are resources; but it is also normal and necessary, and that is why I celebrate your willingness, that we can dialogue to reach understandings. Certainly, the Government is fully willing.

You have mentioned some laws where there may be discussions. The procedure for setting the stability objectives for Autonomous Communities and the specificity of the foral regime, without a doubt, is a topic where we can talk. Regarding the future Local Regime Law, it will respect the specialty of the historical territories, which is already contemplated in the current Regulatory Law of Local Government. And on the issue of market unity, all of Europe continues to take steps towards market unity, and I believe that the excessive fragmentation of our market makes no economic sense; but I also think that it is a topic we can discuss and in which I believe that general interests, the competitiveness of our companies, and the possibility that they can contribute to growth and job creation should prevail.

In any case, the Government, I insist, is at the disposal of your Group and the Basque Government to...

Mr. Esteban.- Mr. President, the economic crisis cannot become an excuse to modify the competential structure of the State. It is evident that we disagree on where that competential line is, but I appreciate the willingness to dialogue and I reiterate our willingness to do so.

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Ms. Rosa Díez, from the Parliamentary Group Union, Progress and Democracy

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Ms. Díez.- Mr. President, you were very upset with me when in the Investiture Debate—I upset you and you reproached my conduct—I pointed out that political corruption was the greatest scourge of our democracy, something that hinders our recovery and that embarrasses us as a country. Tell me, President: at this point, and a year later, with all that has happened, do you still think that political corruption is not a problem for Spain and for our democracy?

President.- Thank you very much, Ms. Díez.

I have never denied that political corruption is a serious problem for our democracy. A different matter is that I do not think it responsible to extend the mantle of suspicion over the entire political class, of which, I remind you, we are all part, including those of us here. I say this because in politics, as in all areas, there is an immense majority of honest people who assume their public responsibilities at a high personal, family, and professional cost, and often without the possibility of defending themselves.

Therefore, we must combat corruption, but what cannot be done, because it is a huge injustice, is to generalize it over the entire political class.

Ms. Díez.- Mr. President, what is not responsible is not to acknowledge that political corruption is the greatest problem facing our democracy, because it is not only generalized, but institutionalized, which causes us enormous harm as a country, hinders recovery and the way out of the crisis, and is unforgivable. It is unforgivable in democratic terms.

The problem is not who denounces corruption; the problem is who does not combat it, who hides it, who minimizes it, or who agrees, for example, not to talk about corruption in the debates prior to the last elections, as if democratic corruption, corruption in politics, and corruption in institutions were not a problem.

Mr. President, that is the problem, hiding it, not combating it, and not combating it with laws. Here it is about combating it with laws; with laws that make, for example, the publication of the salaries of all elected officials or the publication of the complete accounts of political parties not a grace or a way to defend oneself, but a legal obligation, that affects us all, that is mandatory, and that all citizens can know, with transparency and at any time, what each public official earns, what each of us has, and, furthermore, the exact accounts of political parties.

Change the laws, President, so that the Council of Ministers cannot arbitrarily grant pardons; change the laws so that illicit enrichment of elected officials is a crime and change the laws so that illegal enrichment and financing of political parties is a crime.

Look, President, that is what we have to do. By the way, a Transparency Law that affects the Royal House, political parties, and all those who receive public subsidies. President, when citizens see us making these laws that go against our own impunity and that truly favor a higher quality democracy, they will believe in us and believe in democracy, and then in Spain we will be able to combine democracy with a capital D. That is what I ask of you.

President.- Thank you very much for your intervention, Ms. Díez.

You can say whatever you want, of course; but you have asked here that corruption be combated and with laws. So, I am going to provide you with some data and remind you of some things that have been done over the year and two months that this Government has indeed been in power, because the best argument to demonstrate that we are fighting against corruption is the reforms that we have promoted in this Chamber, some of which you referred to in your intervention as if those norms had not already been approved here.

Today, parties are subject to criminal responsibility, which had been eliminated in 2010; today there are new transparency obligations, such as publishing accounts once audited by the Court of Auditors; today there are new controls and limits for donations and debts of parties, and no company that contracts with them, or that is part of their business group, can donate to political parties, and today there are limitations and it is necessary to present to the Court of Auditors or the Bank of Spain the cancellations of debts to parties, which are limited. We have reformed the Penal Code and increased the penalties for concealment, simulation, or falsification of public accounts. We have presented, for the first time in the history of Spanish democracy, a Transparency Law, which is an excellent antidote against corruption. We have proposed to all Groups in this Chamber an agreement with measures against corruption. And we have commissioned the Center for Political and Constitutional Studies to propose measures.

Now I tell you that I will promote that the criteria of the Transparency Law be applied to political parties and any initiative you have, I am absolutely willing to discuss; but if there is any political force that has presented legal modifications in this Chamber and a Transparency Law, which is pioneering, it is the political force that I preside over.

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Alfredo Pérez Rubalcaba, from the Socialist Parliamentary Group

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Mr. Pérez Rubalcaba.- Mr. President of the Government, how do you plan to address the political crisis that Spain is going through?

President.- Governing, Mr. Pérez Rubalcaba. Spain has a Government with a majority support in this Chamber, a Government that comes from the polls and the will of the Spanish people, a Government that is governing and making decisions. In the last Council of Ministers, we approved six Bills and there has been a very important debate for Spain in the European Council, where we obtained a good budget for the next seven years.

If you are referring, when you talk about political crisis, to the same thing that Ms. Rosa Díez referred to in her intervention, I have nothing else to say: with transparency, approving measures, as we have done throughout this year, and we are willing to talk with any other political group if we can make and take more measures to be more effective.

Mr. Pérez Rubalcaba.- Mr. Rajoy, in the year that you have been governing, you have broken some basic social consensuses in Spain. You have done so when you have left millions of workers without coverage from collective agreements and by breaking the universalization of Healthcare; now you want to do it with Education. You are breaking rights that Spaniards have achieved over these thirty years. You did not talk about any of this in the general elections. Moreover, you denied it, and by doing so, by doing these things and these breaks of consensus without debate, without dialogue, and without prior electoral scrutiny, you have added to the economic and social crisis that our country has a political crisis, a crisis of politics.

A week ago, we learned of very serious facts affecting who until recently and for twenty years was the treasurer of your party: accounts in Switzerland, attempts to launder these accounts under the amnesty law approved by the Government, and alleged irregular handling of funds in the Popular Party. Your reaction has been to do nothing, deny, accuse everyone except Mr. Bárcenas, who, by the way, today we know is being treated with a generosity that is denied to the entire Spanish population.

Doing nothing, Mr. Rajoy, and that is the problem. You have done nothing because you cannot do anything. You do not have the political autonomy to do anything, and that lack of autonomy has led the political crisis to an unsustainable situation.

When a President of the Government breaks the rules of coexistence among Spaniards, when a President of the Government is unable to explain how his party has been financed for twenty years, the political crisis is served, and I, Mr. Rajoy, believe that you are not in a position to address that political crisis, because you are burdened by the social cuts, by the social setbacks, that you have imposed on all Spaniards, by the breaking of social consensuses that you did not mention in the electoral campaign, and by the lack of reaction to cases of corruption.

That is why, Mr. Rajoy, I ask you here today, in this Chamber, to resign, to step down, because you cannot resolve... I ask you, Mr. Rajoy, to resign, to step down, because you cannot resolve the political crisis that Spain faces today and that you yourself have created. I ask you, Mr. Rajoy, to resign because I believe it is the best for Spain and for the Spaniards.

President.- You have so many problems in your Group that force you to make these spectacles, Mr. Pérez Rubalcaba.

This is exactly the underlying problem of what is happening here. Look, there is a Government that has been voted for by the Spaniards, that is a majority, and that is facing the greatest economic crisis that Spain has experienced in recent years. We are making very important decisions in economic matters. By the way, in the situation that Spain is in at this moment, it is evident that you have absolutely nothing to do with it; but there is a Government that is making decisions, that is implementing reforms, fighting against the public deficit, and that is laying the foundations for an improvement in the economy.

Spain has another very important problem, which is unemployment, and the Government is making decisions and laying the foundations to overcome this situation for the future. You and your Government, who were in power over a year ago, apparently also have nothing to do with this situation.

I am not going to enter into, nor give any data here, nor mention any person who is sitting across from me at this moment in the Chamber, nor those who are outside of here. I simply tell you one thing, Mr. Pérez Rubalcaba: do exactly the same exercise of transparency that I have done with the accounts of your political party and also with mine. Do that, and when you do, maybe you will have the moral authority to say something. Until you do, you do not have it, Mr. Pérez Rubalcaba.