Speech and subsequent colloquium with the President of the Government at the "Beyond austerity: returning to the path of growth" conference, organised by "The Economist"

Spain Mariano Rajoy · Prime Minister of Spain

11 February 2013 · 'Beyond austerity: returning to the path of growth' conference, organised by 'The Economist'

Context
Rajoy addressed The Economist's 'Beyond austerity: returning to the path of growth' conference in February 2013, outlining Spain's economic reform strategy.
Main themes
Spanish economic recovery, austerity and fiscal consolidation, structural reforms, growth strategy, eurozone membership, public deficit reduction, bank restructuring, regional and municipal liquidity, competitive economy, economic policy coordination
Duration
~69 min
97th percentile
Words
8,245
97th percentile
Sentences
315
96th percentile
Readability
46
51st percentile
Grade
13.1
58th percentile
Syntax
3.17
69th percentile
Vocabulary
1.99
9th percentile
Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 42%41%
  • Economic 39%38%
  • Ceremonial 11%10%
  • Geopolitical 6%6%
  • Social 3%3%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 1%

315 sentences in 130 paragraphs

Ladies and gentlemen,

On 23 November 2009 I had the honour of participating, as the leader of the main party of the opposition, in a symposium concerning the Spanish economy organised by this prestigious publication. Today, I have the honour of returning here with you all, now as President of the Government, and, once more, I would like to make the most of this opportunity to thank this weekly publication for the invitation to participate in this symposium concerning the Spanish economy.

I am delighted that Spain and the Spanish economy have inspired so much interest at "The Economist". The economic press all over the world has been discussing Spain at length over the last few months. Probably, what has been discussed most is what we would have liked, and I think that symposiums such as this one have the great advantage of accurately and realistically focussing on the reality of the Spanish economy, without distortions, without disguising our problems, without ignoring our strengths and without falling into sensationalism.

If you will allow me, as well, to talk as an analyst for a moment, I would say to you that even the title of this symposium ("Beyond austerity: returning to the path of growth") shows a change in the way our country is perceived. Though a year ago questions were hanging over the sustainability of our public accounts, today these questions have been answered. Now, as the organisers of this seminar have successfully stressed, the goal is growth.

More than three years ago, when I participated in this forum for the first time, I made a realistic diagnosis of the problems associated with the Spanish economy and I put a series of measures forward which I deemed necessary to tackle these problems. I announced the urgent need to correct the serious situation with our public accounts, the need to solve financial problems in our companies and families, as well as the importance of carrying out the reforms the Spanish economy requires to be competitive.

We have already been implementing this line of action, with some changes that were required to adapt to the difficult nature of the original situation, for more than a year. On the first day, we began to work to immediately reverse this situation once and for all. From the very beginning, we had perfectly identified instabilities in the Spanish economy and we began to act in order to correct them.

Of course, the task is something smaller. It involves the following:

In short, this task is huge, but not insurmountable, as we have already solved this problem at other points in our history. It involves returning the ability for economic growth and job creation to our country, and we are completing this task within a very specific context, in which the European Union and belonging to the euro sets the rules of the game.

This is not an insignificant fact from an economic point of view, as given that we are members of the Monetary Union, devaluations performed to correct instabilities are no longer optional. On the contrary, instabilities have to be corrected using structural reforms, and encouraging increased integration is necessary so that differences in cycles and countries forming part of the Union may be diminished.

Ladies and gentlemen,

The fact that we belong to the euro zone requires us to have fiscal stability, a solid financial system and a flexible and competitive economy. Given this context, we are pursuing a well-designed, coordinated and comprehensive economic policy strategy. This strategy is based on a fiscal consolidation process for all public administrations, the finalisation of bank restructuring and the implementation of an ambitious collection of structural reforms.

In order to complete the fiscal consolidation process, we have established some solid foundations for control, discipline and transparency in budget management; we have implemented an ambitious deficit reduction plan and we have developed the mechanisms required to alleviate liquidity problems in Regional and Municipal Governments.

The Organic Law on Budgetary Stability and Financial Sustainability, which developed the constitutional reform passed at the end of the last Parliamentary term and which regulates all of the State's budgetary activity, has been a crucial part of this strategy.

A significant selection of fiscal and budgetary measures aimed at achieving deficit reduction objectives have been added to this regulatory instrument.

We opted for expenditure by means of reducing public expenditure, as the State Budget includes a 25.8% reduction in the expenditure of ministerial Departments for the 2012 and 2013 financial years, and also for the restructuring of the business and foundational public sector; but we have also opted for revenue, based on the reasoning that taxation makes restructuring more efficient.

In order to alleviate liquidity problems among the Regional and Municipal Governments, new mechanisms have been implemented in order to make it easier to finance these governments, such as the Regional Liquidity Fund for Autonomous Regions (18 billion euros in 2012, up to 23 billion euros in 2013) and the Supplier Payment Plan for Autonomous Regions and City Councils (30 billion euros), instead of implementing much more exhaustive control of their Treasury.

Thanks to the fiscal consolidation measures which were passed, the objective concerning budgetary revenue for 2012 was reached, increasing income by 4.2% compared with 2011. I want to emphasise that, though the Government did not act with the determination it did in this area, not only did public revenue not increase, but it suffered a fall of 2.7%.

In the next few weeks, information about the year-end 2012 public deficit will be announced. It will demonstrate that all Public Administrations have made an unprecedented fiscal consolidation effort. The primary structural public deficit reduction, in other words, the deficit which does not include the effect of the economic cycle or the interest burden, was expected to amount to 3.5% of GDP, approximately. This is an incredible achievement for our country and under our circumstances, and especially praiseworthy given that it occurred during a recession.

In terms of the fight against tax fraud, encouraging results are also beginning to emerge. In 2012, income exceeded 11.5 billion euros, 10.1% more than in 2011.

Important achievements have been made during the first year of government, but it is not enough. The objective of the Government over which I preside is to bring this policy to progress, using an extensive reform of Public Administrations in order to avoid duplications and inefficiencies. The objective is to have more efficient Public Administrations, which allow business initiative, investment, growth of the productive fabric and the development of new activity sectors to be encouraged. Before summer, we will have a detailed proposal in this sense.

In this spirit, the Council of Ministers will shortly approve the Local Government reform which is aimed at avoiding duplications with the powers of other Governments, as well as guaranteeing rigurous financial and budgetary control.

Ladies and gentlemen,

Fighting the public deficit and allowing resources which are intended for the payment of interest on debt to be channeled towards economic recovery is, consequently, one of this Government's priorities and courses of action, but not the only one.

In order to achieve a return to the path of economic growth (let's not forget that this is the matter "The Economist" invited us here to debate today) it is essential to confront the problem of access to financing. If there is no financing, companies cannot invest.

We need a strong, reliable and streamlined financial sector in order that the Spanish productive fabric is able to access the credit it needs to make new investments and to channel savings towards productive investment. This is why another of our main courses of action has been restructuring the Spanish financial sector.

This streamlining process is based on a commitment. On the one hand, it is a commitment to a process of recapitalising financial entities and implementing restructuring plans in viable entities or resolution in entities which are not considered viable; and, on the other hand, a commitment to the commissioning of the Management Company for Assets from Bank Restructuring (SAREB, Sociedad de Gestión de Activos Procedentes de la Reestructuración Bancaria) for unfreezing the property market and separating problematic assets from financial entities that have needed public support in order to recapitalise. This Company has already begun operations and has inspired the interest of international investors. Its goal is to achieve centralised management of those assets in order to proceed towards disinvestment and organised management.

In short, and also thanks to a loan from our European partners, foundations have been laid so that the bank may grant more credit in the most dynamic sectors of the economy.

However, having said that, it is not enough to only tackle short-term fiscal and financial insecurities. We are confronting a combination of structural challenges in order to achieve a high level of flexibility which will allow us win in terms of competitivity.

The aim of the reform package we are creating will make it possible to redistribute factors of production, especially employment, between the most dynamic companies and sectors, as well as to eliminate internal barriers to growth with a more favourable regulatory and administrative framework.

Structural reforms are capable of bringing about positive consequences in the supply factors which are behind economic growth. The ultimate end in mind is to improve the competitivity of the Spanish economy, as in an international financial context such as the current one, which has become very restrictive, we only need to improve our competitivity in order to resume growth, without requiring additional financing.

Among the structural reforms, as I already said the last time I participated in this forum, one of the most necessary and urgent reforms is that of our labour market and, as a demonstration of this importance, the employment market reform was one of the first significant measures adopted by the Government.

The deficiencies this institution has been demonstrating have led to copious job cuts over the last few years. This is why the labour reform, which was passed at the beginning of last year and has been one of the most ambitious commitments of this Government, is so important. This reform has concentrated on improving the employability of workers, making the creation of stable jobs easier, reducing the current dualism and encouraging internal flexibility in companies in order to avoid copious job cuts.

Given that this is a structural reform, we will have to wait to see its impact and wait in order that it might fulfill its potential. We all know that these measures do not have immediate effects, but we are already beginning to observe the first signs of a change in the employment market's patterns of adjustment. Certainly, the number of jobs decreased by a lot in 2012; but I would like to highlight a fact that is sometimes forgotten: more than a quarter of these job cuts were in the public sector.

Another essential component for improving competitivity is market unity, which is vital in order to make the mobility of factors of production and their productivity more easy, thus improving the efficiency and effectiveness of the Spanish domestic market. This means that every product or service which is offered under this regional regulation may be provided throughout the country, without any need for an additional procedure.

Consequently, the future Market Unity Act, whose Draft was passed by the Council of Ministers last 25 January, will have a positive impact on our competitivity. This measure is vital for companies to take advantage of their economies of scale and scope, encouraging internal business growth and competitivity as well as encouraging internationalisation.

These are only two examples of structural reforms that we are maintaining in order to return to economic growth and job creation.

We are also taking action in sectors which are key to our economy, such as tourism or momentum behind information and communication technologies.

Ladies and gentlemen,

All of the structural measures are intended to increase the medium and long-term competitivity of our productive sectors, notwithstanding the fact that some of the reforms which have already been adopted, such as that of the employment market, are already beginning to have an impact on improving competitivity, and its effects are being noticed in sectors which are very important to the Spanish economy.

A good example is the automotive sector, in which, thanks to the internal flexibility promoted by the labour reform, new investments are being made by companies. To mention just a few, companies who have made investments include Renault-Nissan, IVECO and Ford. These investments have benefits in terms of the increase in production and the creation of new jobs.

Thanks to this increased internal flexibility, adjustments in areas such as salary or the working day represent an alternative to job cuts, as this reform contributes to companies being able to better adapt their activity and working conditions to productive cycles, something which is vital to sectors such as the automobile sector, and is also allowing Spain to become a European benchmark in the automobile industry. In terms of exports, the Spanish automotive sector is the main industrial and export sector (32.6 billion euros in the first eleven months of 2012), which represents around 17% of the value of Spanish industrial exports.

Not only data in the automobile sector, but also data from our entire foreign sector are demonstrating the increased competitivity in our economy.

Traditionally, the Spanish economy has been characterised by its structural trade deficit. However, this situation is beginning to reverse: in the first eleven months of 2012, Spanish exports of goods and services registered a record high in nominal terms, reaching 294.5 billion euros, which represents growth of 4.3% compared with the same period in 2011.

This positive development in exports will doubtless have a fundamental macroeconomic impact on the future growth of the country. This positive export figure allows a drastic improvement in the trade balance. For the first time in the last twenty years, a surplus in the trade balance has been achieved, without including energy goods. In the same way, the trade balance, compared with our partners in the euro zone, is positive, something which has never happened before .

In addition, it is worth stressing that the growing flexibility and competitivity in our economy prevents us from having to depend on external financing. Between July and November 2012, the Spanish economy achieved a surplus in its current and capital account of 7.9 billion euros. This was the first time the Spanish current and capital account has had a surplus since 1998 and, as a consequence, it is the first time in the last fourteen years that Spain has not required net international financing.

These are the initial results of the radical change in economic policy that this Government has implemented. This is our course of action: austerity, structural reforms and international openness. We are going to continue working on this course of action because there is still a lot of ground to be covered.

We are aware of the fact that 2013 will probably be a difficult year for economic activity in Spain, though of course the downturn will not be as intense as the downturn experienced in 2012. Allowing for the necessary caution when predictions are being made, we can confirm that the prediction this Government forecasts, which is shared by international bodies such as the International Monetary Fund, expect that in the last part of 2013 and in 2014 our economy will recover positive growth rates in the Gross Domestic Product.

Ladies and gentlemen, in order to respect the timetable established by the events organisers, I am about to finish.

I have endeavoured, using a reasonable amount of time, to explain what we are doing in Spain in order to resume growth and job creation. Having said that, I don't want to end my speech without telling you this: a process of reform and increased integration in the euro zone must necessarily be added to these efforts. I can tell you that in this respect, progress has also been made.

In recent times, we have had good news in Europe. The European Council of June last year, which committed to increased integration; the approval in December of single banking supervision; the launch, by the European Central Bank, of a new liquidity instrument, WTOs, as well as decisions concerning the second support package to Greece all mould a new direction of European integration which has cleared doubts concerning the irreversibility of the euro.

Throughout this process, Spain has maintained a very active position, providing relevant proposals which have helped mould the new European "road map".

Good news concerning Europe keeps on coming; the most recent piece of good news came at the end of last week, when the twenty eight countries in the Union reached an agreement concerning the European Budget until 2020.

I am almost finished.

As I told you, I have endeavoured to summarise, in a few minutes, what the Government worked on last year and what our priorities are for this year. This is not an easy task, as lots of things have been done and many more things will be done in the forthcoming months.

This Government's reformer's zeal will not be distracted, nor will it falter or fail. Spanish society has provided sufficient proof of its responsability, maturity and entrepreneurial ability, when measures to develop these qualities are available. This and nothing else is the determination which motivates my Government: laying the foundations so that Spain and its citizens can write another successful page of our history.

Thank you very much.

COLLOQUIUM WITH THE PRESIDENT OF THE GOVERNMENT AFTER HIS SPEECH AT THE CONFERENCE ORGANISED BY "THE ECONOMIST"

Q .- I would like to congratulate Mr. Rajoy not only for this succinct overview of the economic changes which are underway, but also for having talked for twenty British minutes, not for twenty Spanish minutes.

I told Mr. Rajoy, when we were talking before, that it was unavoidable for me to begin this conversation by touching on today's issue and he answered me, and was absolutely right, that today's issue is the Pope. But I was referring to yesterday's issue, maybe in Spain, because when you are looking in from outside, you ask yourself not only whether Spain is suffering in this economic crisis, which has already lasted four years, but also whether there is a kind of political and institutional crisis, because you see the surveys and you see that support from the people and public confidence in the two main parties, which have been the foundation of Spanish democracy for the last forty years, has decreased significantly, and citizens seem to be demanding a regeneration in politics. What is your response to this?

President .- You said something which is true, that in Spain there are two main parties which have basically passed the responsibility of governing between one another since 1977.

Between 1977 and 1982, it was the Union of the Democratic Centre, but, in some ways, today's People's Party is the Union of the Democratic Centre of those years and, in fact, many people who in the early days belonged to the Union of the Democratic Centre are in the People's Party. There are Ministers in my Government who come from the Union of the Democratic Centre.

You said that the two main parties have probably lost public confidence. I would make a distinction between the people, in other words, Spanish citizens, and something different which is not exactly the people. If you know what happened in the last five elections which have taken place in Spain, all last year, it turns out that in all those elections, the electoral results have been, except in the two autonomous regions of Catalonia and the Basque Country, the place where something happened which happened on many other occasions, that the nationalist parties won, and in the other ones the People's Party or the Socialist Party also won. In fact, the most recent surveys published still say that the People's Party has the most support from the people, followed by the Socialist Party.

I think that this is important because, at the end of the day, a country which does not have a party system which has its flaws, its problems as well as all the difficulties that they can cause and all the mistakes they can make can be a country where the parties can fall into predicaments which are undesirable. In fact, the most stable countries where coexistence is organised best are countries with big parties that take turns being in power, and when this disappears other different things emerge.

Spain, at the moment, has the good fortune of not having, as happened in many other countries in the European Union, parties (forgive me for using this expression) which are outlandish.

Consequently I must say, and I insist, that the situation with parties in Spain, with all its problems and difficutlies, is reasonable and continues to be supported by the citizens.

Having said that, it is true that there are many things which need improvement; but this is always the case under any circumstances.

And, of course, I will do all I can in order that things such as those to which you referred at the beginning of your speech should not happen again. In any case, these things happen, unfortunately, in many places; they are a part of the human condition itself.

However, fortunately, Spain is a country that is regulated; in Spain the press is free, the press say what they deem to be appropriate and fair; in Spain there is a Court of Auditors which audits the parties' accounts; in Spain there is a Judiciary which is operating, at the moment, and which makes decisions which seem to them to be appropriate and fair, and in Spain there is a Parliament which controls the Government.

Consequently, I believe that there are things that can be done and all of the suggestions that are put to me and which appear to me to be reasonable and, in fact, I want to propose some in coming dates for improving things, we will be doing. But I believe that Spain is a country that currently has its economic difficulties as well as its political problems, but Spain is a great country, Spain is a democracy, a serious country that has overcome many things in recent years and which has experienced since 1977, when democracy returned to our country, the best phase of its recent history by far.

Thirty years ago Spain was an authoritarian regime, thirty years ago Spain was not in the European Union, thirty years ago it was closed to the world and today Spain is an advanced democracy with its institutions. Spain is in the European Union; Spain has an opinion; Spain is behind European integration; it has an amount equivalent to 46 per cent invested abroad; as I have just said, it has first rate exporting companies and it has some of the world's most important companies in the energy, communications, consultancy and construction sectors.

And so this is a country with enormous strengths. We will be doing everything in our hands to improve. There are things that can and should be improved and I believe we are all determined in this.

Q .- Do these things include, for example, a reform to the Law on the financing of political parties and to the Electoral Law so as to make the power of the top echelons of the parties not so strong and for citizens to have more possibilities of choosing the candidate they want? Or not?

President .- As regards reforms to the Electoral Law, Spain created an Electoral Law during the transition and so one has to place oneself in the context of when the Spanish Electoral Law was brought in. Above all, what the Spanish Electoral Law sought was one thing, and that was consensus and representing a large majority of Spaniards.

When dealing with such things one has to look back to what Spain was like in the years 1977-1980, when one had to come to an agreement, and this was achieved, with people coming back directly from exile, people who were not even living in Spain and with people who had been a part of the previous regime, including those who had been ministers. A colossal effort was made, with all of its difficulties. A Constitution was drawn up, with its difficulties, because it evidently has these; but the great value of what was done at that time is that it had a highly majority consensus and a good proof of this is that it was with this Constitution that Spain was governed by the UCD with a majority and in coalition, the Socialist Party with and without majority, and the Partido Popular with and without majority. This means that all of the large parties have governed.

The Electoral Law was passed with the agreement of all of the political forces and the Electoral Law, like all electoral laws, is debatable, like all systems. Do you think that a system like the one in Britain is fair? one in which you have constituencies and the one who wins 51 per cent of the vote gets the seat and the one who gets 49 per cent gets nothing, exactly zero? This could give rise to the situation, only in theory of course but it is possible, that one party gets 51 per cent of the votes for the whole country and another 49 per cent, with the one getting 49 per cent having zero seats. Or is the system in the USA normal, one in which California and, for example, Hawaii, each elect two senators when California has millions more inhabitants?

This means that all electoral systems are debatable and open to question and Europe has all kinds of models. In the United Kingdom the first past the post system is not valid for the European elections, they use the proportional system and this means that there are parties with no seats in the British parliament that are, however, represented in the European Parliament. And the same happens in Germany and in many other countries.

Well then, can the Electoral Law be modified? Of course it can be modified, like any Law, but what I do believe is most important, knowing the history of this country, is that any modification to the Electoral Law should be done with a broad consensus. I, of course, would never modify the Electoral Law by a majority vote. I would use a majority vote to increase or lower income tax but I would never modify the Electoral Law that way. I believe that there are basic consensuses that have to be preserved.

On political parties what we have done is to reduce public funding for the political parties. Since we came into Government this has reduced by 40 per cent in Spain. I am also entirely open to any modification that will make political parties more transparent. We are currently undergoing the annual audit by the Tribunal de Cuentas (Court of Auditors) and I am absolutely convinced that these things can be done much better and so we will be putting forward proposals for this in the near future. But, in any case I believe that this is not so much a problem of laws, which can undoubtedly be reformed, as one of compliance with laws, which are different things.

Q .- Isn't this a matter for the Judiciary, not for a public, political or parliamentary investigation, for example?

President .- The first control is carried out by the Tribunal de Cuentas. In Parliament anyone can question the Government on whatever he or she considers to be appropriate or advisable; then, undoubtedly, there is a judicial question and then, undoubtedly, the party itself. At the last meeting of the Executive Committee of my party I set up an internal committee of investigation to look at the party's accounts, at what was done and what was not done.

Q.- You are right to say that no electoral system is perfect and one can recognise the great achievements of Spain's Constitution over these past years, but one can also consider that these are different times and the needs are different. You said that these matters should only be handled with consensus. Would you, for example, consider setting up a constitution review commission in Parliament for this and call for a national debate on institutional reforms?

President.- I understand that this is on reforming the Constitution, not Electoral Law, am I right? On reforming the Constitution in general?

Q .- In general, including the Autonomous State, because there are many questions. Isn't that so?

President .- Yes, there are many. The Autonomous State. That is one of the matters under debate in Spain.

Does the Constitution have to be reformed in order to reform the Autonomous State? That is the great question that a lot of people are asking and, as is natural, there are opinions for all tastes. I will give you mine.

I believe that the Constitution, Spanish or any other, can be reformed. I believe that the Spanish Constitution is of great value, that it has integrated us all and I do believe that it can be reformed. In fact it has been reformed twice, and not for small matters. The last time that the Spanish Constitution was reformed was in 2011.

The President of the Government at that time, Jose Luis Rodríguez Zapatero, called me whilst I was at home in Galicia and said: "I need to reform the Constitution so as to bring in the Stability Treaty, the European Union's Fiscal Union", and in that same call - when it would have been normal and reasonable to say "let me think on it and I will call you"-I said: go ahead. And so we reformed the Constitution.

Why did we reform the Constitution? Because there was a clear objective, the approval of a Treaty so that the Spanish public accounts could become balanced public accounts and, secondly, because there was an overwhelming consensus, with the Partido Popular and the Partido Socialista having two thirds of the votes.

I believe that three things are required to reform the Constitution: firstly, knowing why we want to reform because, obviously, if we say "we have to reform the Constitution" but without saying why, we have a bit of a problem and so this is fundamental. As anyone will understand; secondly, a consensus, if not of all the parties but with a large majority, just as we did with ours; and, thirdly, we have to look for the right moment because reforms to the Constitution like the one you are suggesting requires the following procedure: firstly, two thirds in the Parliament; secondly, dissolution of Parliament; thirdly, calling an election; fourthly, this new Parliament is to approve this Constitution once again with two thirds and, fifthly, a national referendum. In other words, a complex procedure.

So, first of all, knowing what the objectives are; second, getting a sufficient consensus and, third, and also very important is choosing the right moment.

Presently there is a debate on Constitution reform and there are the following options on the table with regard to the model of State: First opinion, an absolutely respectable one: taking away competences from the Autonomous Communities and moving to a process for centralising the State. This is the opinion held by some.

Second opinion, held by others: no, let's move towards a federal state. I believe that Spain today is much more than a federal state, but they need to specify this. But this is another opinion.

Third opinion: no, let's move to another thing that is neither the first or the second. What we can do is split up national sovereignty and establish the right to self-determination or the right to decide. That is another opinion that can be held and, naturally, is one that can be discussed.

And then there is another opinion, that of those who say: we have a model that we have all approved, which has worked reasonably well, which is the sole point of union between us all and in which some things can be corrected and we are going to start correcting some things. I spoke earlier in my speech of a reform to the Administration, to all of them, so as to eliminate administrative duplications, so as to eliminate regulations, so as to become more flexible and to be able to speed things up. A profound reform of the Administration; we are going to try this. I have spoken of market unity and, instead of there being seventeen regulations, for example seventeen hunting licences or seventeen regulations for environmental matters or seventeen different regulations for transport, we will be making one single regulation.

This means that there are four different options on what the reform to the Constitution will be and there may still be two or three more.

So, one thing is to carry out the theoretical exercise in a newspaper and design a reform to the Constitution, or simply from a political party, and another is the responsibility held by whoever is presiding a Government.

I will never refuse a reform to the Constitution, among other reasons because I have participated in two, the last not so long ago; but I do believe that reforming the Constitution is not the same as lowering the rate of income tax, which could be done in twenty-four hours. One has to know very well what one wants to do, one has to see what consensus there is and one has to see the moment to when this should be done. This is my opinion which will naturally be shared by some and not by others; but it is always a good idea, when talking of these things to do so with moderate joy.

This means that the matters have to be studied well and to be very aware of what one is talking about, because one sometimes sees things that are truly notable.

Q .- Just to finish on this point. One could say, for example, that at the time of the "Moncloa Pacts" (for which there was absolutely no consensus at the start; rather, the consensus was achieved through an exercise in broad agreement. So you are saying that there is no consensus and neither is it the right time. That is not an argument either… But your argument is that it would be worse to try and achieve a consensus than to try and do this, no? I don't know if I have understood you correctly.

President .- No. I didn't quite say that. The situations are different. What there was in 1978 was a general consensus on two things in territorial matters: firstly, that national sovereignty was a common value for the Spanish population and this is something that was not disputed by practically anybody at the time; and another, was that one had to go towards a system of autonomic decentralisation as the State was a strongly decentralised State. These were, let's say, the two most important aspects and in which there was agreement. Then one could discuss whether to transfer this or another competence, whether we would one tax system or another.

And this worked. Just think… I do not believe that there is in the world a system that is as decentralised as the Spanish one. In Spain of every one hundred euros spent by the Public Administration, the Government that I preside over spends twenty.

Then there is Social Security and pensions, a little more than a quarter of total Public Administration expenditure; autonomous region spending is 36 or 37 per cent and local administrations 13 or 14 per cent, meaning that the decentralisation process in Spain has gone from 0 to 36 or 37 per cent of public expenditure in thirty years.

I believe that things were done in a reasonable manner but the positions today are not those of the constitutional phase. In the constitutional phase it was "we want amnesty"... This was another matter and there was an amnesty; but the theme was: we want autonomy. But now there are those who want recentralisation, there are those who want the right to self-determination, there are those who want to maintain the current situation with improvements… There are many different positions. My opinion at this time, my own - as president of the Government I can take fewer liberties than others, in fact I cannot take any liberty--, is that I believe that what we have to do is to maintain something that united us all, which has served us all and which I believe is perfectly capable of being improved and perfected.

This is what I am working on because everyone is discussing different things today. There are those who want the right to self-determination and there those who even want to return to a centralist system. Consequently, I believe that what in the end unites the great majority is the model we have, although it can be improved.

Q .- And will you be able to keep Catalonia within Spain with this model?

President .- Oh yes. Don't you worry about that. Spain is the oldest nation in Europe, the oldest; in other words we are the country in Europe that has spent most time living together, with our difficulties, with our problems, our issues and our better and worse periods. One of the best periods as been that of these last thirty years in which, as I have said, Spain despite the crisis has taken a colossal step forward.

Listen, I am going to give you one figure: in 1995 there were twelve and a half million people in work in Spain, in 1995 - not that long ago, just seventeen years--; and now, with the economic crisis we are suffering, there are seventeen million in work. As I said, in 1995: twelve and a half million. And just look at what the Spanish business sector is like, the big Spanish financial institutions, which are large banks on the world stage... This could tell you many things.

Catalonia? We are all united with Catalonia. We are united by centuries of history, we are united by trade, by personal relationships, we are united by the number of Catalans who have gone to live in other parts of Spain, we are united by the number of those from Galicia, Extremadura, Andalusia… who have gone to live there… In other words we are united by absolutely everything, we are united by what we have done together over these past years; among other things we have lived the European integration process together. And I am totally and absolutely convinced that the immense majority of Catalans, and I of course also want this, want us to continue as we are today.

I do not see why some want to deprive the citizens of Catalonia from Spain, I just don't see it. I believe that the majority of Catalonia's citizens do not want to be deprived of their status as Spaniards. It is true that there are some who, quite legitimately, can propose this, as people do in other parts of the world, and they have procedures for achieving this as established under current Spanish legislation. Of course, Spain has its laws, it has its rules of the game and it has its Constitution. So, if some people want to change the Constitution or the article that deals with national sovereignty, they can do that; but this has to be done with respect for the laws and with the legal procedures, because Spain is a democracy in which we are all subject to the Law.

Spain is a State governed by Law and every country has its procedures; the United Kingdom has its own, Germany has its own, the United States its own and Spain does as well. If people want to reform the Constitution they can and there are procedures for attempting this. What they also need are sufficient votes to achieve this.

But I, who will soon be having a conversation with the president of the Generalitat, will always be open to dialogue and I will always be prepared to listen to everybody; but, of course, there is only one thing that one cannot ask of the president of the Government of Spain, just one, one that gives me calm and balance, and that is that I cannot break the Law. In no way can I be asked to break the Law, because I am not going to do it.

Q .- In your speech you made reference to the fiscal and the external adjustment that your Government has made over the last fifteen months, and you referred to the credit problem as being fundamental for returning to growth and starting to create employment again. Are the conditions for this already in your hands or are they still outside of Spain? Does Europe have to do more or can Spain start moving now?

President .- Your question is a big one. It is comforting to be asked important questions and this one almost requires a conference.

I am going to try though and let's see if I am capable because it is not easy to summarise what I believe needs to be done in Spain, which is basically what we are trying to do. I believe that five things are necessary for Spain to have economic growth and employment, fundamentally: The first is a process of fiscal consolidation and a reduction in the public deficit. I believe we have to do this for many reasons: firstly, pure common sense: if you earn one thousand you can't spend 1,200 because you can spend 1,200 one time but not for much longer; secondly, because current financing conditions mean that we have to go to the markets and at present this is expensive and is difficult; thirdly, because we have a commitment - Spain, that is, not just me - with the European Union on certain requirements or figures for the public deficit; and, fourthly, because if the Administration asks for too much in the way of borrowings this takes resources away from the private sector.

Consequently, the first thing to do is what we are doing: dealing with the public deficit. The next step comes with the structural reforms in Spain for improving competitiveness in our economy and making it more flexible, and we are also preparing a package.

Third, structural reforms in Europe. Europe has to make more structural reforms. At the beginning of 2012 - I believe it was the second European Council I attended - along with some countries, including the United Kingdom, Sweden and other countries we presented a proposal for continuing to progress in the single market and make more structural reforms. I believe that Europe has to do this; in other words it has to have an economy that is more flexible, more integrated as well as a more competitive economy. Europe accounts for 25 per cent of global GDP and Europe, unlike other countries, also has a Welfare State that many others would like to have. The issue is being sufficiently flexible and competitive to be able to maintain this.

And so, third point, reforms in Europe. Deficit, reforms in Spain and reforms in Europe. Fourth issue, European integration. I believe deeply in the European project and I am one of those who think that Europe will become a kind of United States of Europe, although I don't know when. Probably some do not share this today, but Europe started in 1955, actually in 1957 with the Treaty of Rome… Actually it started before this, with the Coal and Steel Community, but it was 1957 and has been built piece by piece: at first there were six countries, today there are twenty-eight with Croatia, and it has been progressing little by little.

Who would have said a few years ago that Spain was not going to have a monetary or exchange policy? The peseta was the Spanish currency and now it appears to be part of prehistory. We were still paying with pesetas in Spain in this century. And Europe will continue advancing inexorably. And so the integration process is passing now through banking union, fiscal union, plus economic union and then there will have to be a political union.

There was a very important European Council in the month of June last year, that Council in which it was said that Italy and Spain had done something that they did not do; but that does not matter. That was the Council in which the talk, for the first time with clarity, was of where Europe is going. So Europe is moving, slowly in my opinion, others may think it to be fast; but I do believe that there is a need for more European integration. Now approval has been given for banking supervision, I believe this to be good news and we will continue to be working in the future.

Consequently, this is the fourth thing that is needed and fifth, at present there are liquidity problems. I believe that the decision taken by Mr. Draghi, who is here today in Parliament and whom I will be seeing this afternoon in La Moncloa, a decision that I referred to in my speech, was a good one. This was to put an instrument at the disposal of the Member States that need it for overcoming their liquidity problems and to announce that this was there and that, therefore, the euro is a strong currency and that it was going to be defended.

In summary, and I am not sure that I have been capable of summarising all this, there are five lines on which we have to work: first, fiscal consolidation in Spain; second, structural reforms in Spain; third, structural reforms in Europe; fourth, further European integration and fifth, solving the problems of liquidity.

Q .- European times are slow. What do you say to a Spanish family in which there is nobody working today? What hope can you give to this family that things are going to change for them?

President .- It is difficult because here, of course, we are talking a lot about macroeconomics, public deficit, interest rates, public debt, Draghi's instruments, of all these things and I always try to keep reference of two things: first, that there an enormous number of people in Spain who want to work and, second, that there are many people in Spain whose purchasing power has been damaged.

What hope can I give them? That for sure we are going to get out of this and that what we are doing is not in response to a whimsical decision by Mr. Rajoy, nor by the Government of Spain, but are laying the bases for getting out of this situation.

I presented myself in the elections with an electoral programme in which I said that I was not going to raise taxes. I have probably not kept this promise… Probably, no; I have not kept my election promises, but at least I have the feeling that I have done my duty and I have given some figures here in the speech I gave at the beginning. Everything we are doing is to lay the bases for the future.

We have done a lot of things badly in Spain in recent years, a lot of things done badly. It was not so many years ago that it had a surplus in its public accounts and Spain had an external debt that had to be around one third of its GDP: We have done some things badly and when things are done badly they have to be corrected, notes taken for the future and lessons learnt.

During many years I gave warnings, whilst in opposition - of course, this was a period in which growth stood at 3 per cent and there was a lot of employment creation - and I told the Government - this is true, I said this to Mr. Solbes when debating with him in the Budget debate -- be careful, be careful with increasing public expenditure. And I told him: revenues tend to be cyclical and expenditure has a certain tendency to be structural. I warned him of this and of the need to make reforms.

It is not a question now of criticising past times because, among other things, this does not help; but I tell the people of Spain that everything we are doing makes sense, that we are doing this because we need to, that we are going to come out of this situation and that Spain has already lived through crises in its history and that we have always come through them in the same way: with adjustments, competitiveness and the external sector. And that is how it will turn out this time as well.

Q .- Unfortunately our time has run out. I am enormously grateful. For me this has been a conversation that has been fascinating. I would like to have continued but that will have to be for another occasion, I hope. I want to thank you for coming here and for your willingness to exchange these points of view. Many thanks.

President .- Many thanks.