Bill on compensation and reparation for the children of the disappeared

Argentina Néstor Kirchner · President of Argentina

12 March 2004

Context
Kirchner addressed a ceremony at the Casa Rosada marking the introduction of a bill to compensate children of Argentina's disappeared, on March 12, 2004.
Main themes
Reparations for children of the disappeared, justice for victims of the dictatorship, human rights accountability, impunity laws opposition, Argentina's military dictatorship legacy, democratic responsibility, truth and memory, grandmothers and mothers of the Plaza de Mayo, national identity and shame, transitional justice
Duration
~11 min
38th percentile
Words
1,282
38th percentile
Sentences
36
22nd percentile
Readability
43
44th percentile
Grade
16.0
84th percentile
Syntax
3.52
94th percentile
Vocabulary
1.99
10th percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 61%61%
  • Social 19%19%
  • Ceremonial 14%14%
  • Geopolitical 6%6%
  • Economic 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

36 sentences in 10 paragraphs

Ladies and gentlemen, ministers of the National Executive Power; national and provincial authorities; members of the diplomatic corps; representatives of non-governmental human rights organizations; representatives of different faiths; children, young people: one truly wishes that this type of event did not exist. The ideal, as she just clearly stated, is that this is not even a reparative hand, because repairing the damage caused is impossible. Neither this type of recognition nor full justice will be able to repair such an aberration that we Argentines had to live through. But we must try to move forward with the elements we have; we must try to take the steps that are within our reach.

While what happened with the genocidal dictatorship in Argentina is extremely grave, what occurred during the democratic period has also been very serious. Without wanting to point fingers at anyone, I say this honestly, but for many years, thousands and thousands of men and women who participated in Argentine political life accepted the framework of concrete impunity as a method of coexistence, and we did so as a necessity for democracy to survive. In one way or another, with more or less shame, with more or less feelings, with more or less burden of conscience, the reality, when the history of these times is written, I know will be very harsh in this respect, despite the historical justifications that may be sought, for these 20 years of democracy in this sense.

I do not exclude the strength, courage, and decision to deepen very good steps that had begun to be taken, such as in 1985, in the trial of the commanders and others, which could have ended, had we advanced strongly and not had to carry on our backs the unwillingness to look aside or to the past for days, months, and years.

But there is something even more serious; when we advance on these issues, we encounter important media, with important scribes of the institutional and political life of Argentina who say that we should not disturb the past. I can assure you that I do not like to practice hatred or disturb the past; I do not know what they mean by disturbing the past. If disturbing the past for some means covering up, burying that painful truth that must be clarified and brought to the surface to know the truth of everything definitively. But here we are talking about justice; justice has no past, future, or present; it is justice; there are constitutional norms, rules, and laws that exist. I wonder, should we let time pass so that justice is not applied later, and when it wants to be applied, it is past? In Argentina, we are not trying to look back; we are trying to resolve the strongly pending issue that the Argentine Nation, the Argentine State, and all Argentines have, which is to apply justice. We must apply justice, not resentment, not revenge, not theories that equate situations.

I have always spoken out against the pardon, against the Law of Due Obedience and Full Stop, so I speak with absolute moral authority on the subject. But do not come to me with the equality issue; when one exercises the right to represent the State and exercises the applicability of the State and the functioning and norms of the State and so on, there is nothing that can be equated with things that supposedly may have happened on the other side. Let us also put an end to that absolutely unacceptable discourse that tries to confuse things.

That is why I believe that what will happen in Argentine society, apart from resolving the pending issues we have, I know that together we will continue to advance. Many of the things she just said we will all turn into a clear and concrete reality. We should feel shame, pain.

Today here, thank God, after all the things that have happened to us, the things that have been heard in this Hall, today a daughter of the detained and disappeared was here, in this Hall, surely with the spirit of her father, her mother, and so many Argentines who from this Government House felt that they were advancing over their own lives. Today they can be in this House, which must be the House of democracy, of justice, of dignity, where we can all express ourselves with full plurality. I believe that this event is a historic turning point; she was here, and what she said is truly profound, because that in this Argentina the things that happened happened, that we still have more than 500 children whose whereabouts we do not know, although the efforts of the Mothers and Grandmothers allowed for the recovery of 77 children, there are more than 500 children whose whereabouts we do not know. That there were mothers of children thrown at the mercy of the imperative voice of murderers who supposedly represented Argentinian identity. That we coexist with such things should also make us seriously reflect as Argentines, on this issue and on other issues, because when we talk about justice, we also talk about justice today; we do not want impunity today, we do not want violations of human rights today. Let us put an end to this story that human rights are a leftist issue; they are human rights; every human being who inhabits the world, in Argentine land, has the right to full respect for human rights and justice, which they try in any way to seek that they have parameters of determined profiles.

That is why I believe that today is as if the hand of the father, the mother of them has arrived. We are helping them to live, to realize themselves so that they fight hard to make a great Argentina. It is as if society were truly becoming aware of this situation, to make it flesh, so that such things never happen again, because all Argentines want full coexistence; we never want such things to happen again. That we never look aside again, that we think that a country can recover economically, socially, and that to avoid conflicts we cover this up, we cover that up, we cover so many things in Argentina that later… it covered us all, we had to live through the things that made us suffer and that have happened in this country.

That is why, children, I apologize; we cannot say anything more than sorry, but we are sure that with you, with the clear conscience you have, and with many Argentines, what we must sow in the new generations, the spirit and dignity of the Mothers, of the Grandmothers of Plaza de Mayo, and of different organizations that have fought, we will build an identity of coexistence, of peace, of love, of plurality, of tolerance, where we will know how to endure even the most different thoughts in full coexistence. That the imperative task of imposition never again goes through the channels that we had to go through, that such cultures and such methodologies never return.

I believe that you have sown very strongly, you, the Grandmothers, the Mothers, and this will be strongly reflected in the Argentina to come. Count on us permanently, and let us continue to advance, let us continue to recover memory, let us continue to consolidate justice, always without resentments and without hatred, but with much depth to find the path of truth and dreams, so that if someone looks at us, they realize that we were cowards, but that we reacted, although a little late, but at least to lay the foundation for the future of future generations. Thank you very much.