Interview with Mr. Nicolas Sarkozy, President of the Republic, in the Algerian newspapers "El Watan" and "El Khabar" on July 10, 2007, about Franco-Algerian relations, particularly in economic, military, and immigration matters.

France Nicolas Sarkozy · President of France

10 July 2007 · Interview in Algerian newspapers El Watan and El Khabar

Context
Sarkozy gave this interview to Algerian newspapers ahead of his first state visit to Algeria and Maghreb tour in July 2007.
Main themes
Franco-Algerian relations, Mediterranean Union, colonial history and memory, bilateral cooperation, economic partnership, military and security cooperation, immigration and mobility, Maghreb regional diplomacy, European neighborhood policy, Barcelona process, cultural exchanges, energy cooperation
Duration
~20 min
67th percentile
Words
2,444
67th percentile
Sentences
97
61st percentile
Readability
37
30th percentile
Grade
14.2
69th percentile
Syntax
3.17
68th percentile
Vocabulary
2.20
48th percentile

Translated from French

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

97 sentences in 16 paragraphs

QUESTION - Mr. President, you are going to Algeria, the first stop on a Maghreb tour, which will be the first outside the European Union. Specifically, what do you expect from this visit, especially since the desire of Paris to refound its relations with Algiers has been mentioned repeatedly? What do you mean by establishing an exceptional relationship with Algiers when the political relations seem dull and the idea of a "treaty of friendship" has been abandoned?

Furthermore, you have proposed the establishment of a "Mediterranean Union." What kind of structure could such a project lead to? Is it possible to talk about cooperation with the southern shore of the Mediterranean when Europe resembles a fortress, and do you think that the European neighborhood policy can serve as an alternative to the failed Barcelona process?

THE PRESIDENT - We can have friendship without a treaty of friendship. What matters most is to give the partnership between the two countries a concrete substance that is perceptible to both Algerians and French. To achieve this goal, we have set ourselves an ambitious but, I believe, realistic roadmap that covers all areas of cooperation between the two countries: training of executives, economic exchanges and investments, energy, military and security cooperation, mobility, etc. We have also defined a method to implement this program, including a series of visits at the political and technical levels to mature all these projects in view of another visit that I proposed to President BOUTEFLIKA at the end of this year. An objective (the exceptional partnership) £ a substance £ a method for its implementation: that is what I propose for Franco-Algerian relations in the coming months.

The deepening of our bilateral relations with each of the southern partners and the launching of the Mediterranean Union are two complementary approaches. The Mediterranean is our second area of solidarity, after Europe, and the two largely overlap. The prosperity, stability, and security of both shores of the Mediterranean are interdependent. Our history, our cultural life, our societies are mutually infused. Our common sea is also a major ecological challenge. Together, we can do better to develop trade, cultural, and human exchanges, prevent crises, and better manage those that already exist or arise. You ask me about the architecture of this project. I certainly have some ideas, but they are still preliminary, and if I wanted to make a very quick first Maghreb tour, it is precisely to consult our partners on the southern shore, and primarily those who constitute the heart for us, including Algeria, where I will start my visit, and which is called, if it wishes, to play a key role in this new initiative. Here too, it will not be a matter of remaking or undoing what has already been done, but of revitalizing what exists, seeing which structures would be best suited to ensure the steering of the system, and already deciding on some concrete initiatives. On all this, the advice and experience of President BOUTEFLIKA will be very valuable to me.

QUESTION - In one of your statements, you say: "I want to put an end to the repentance that is a form of self-hatred and the competition of memories that fuels hatred of others." Does this way of seeing things not hinder a real improvement in relations with Algeria, especially since Algiers is asking France to recognize the crimes committed during the colonization that lasted 132 years?

THE PRESIDENT - The younger generations, on both sides of the Mediterranean, are looking to the future rather than the past, and what they want are concrete things. They do not expect their leaders to, at all costs, mortify themselves by beating their chests for past mistakes or faults, because by that account, there would be much to do on both sides. This does not mean that we should overlook the past, as every great nation, and this applies to France as well as to any other country in the world, must assume its history, with its share of light and its share of shadow, and certainly there have been many shadows, sufferings, and injustices during the 132 years that France spent in Algeria, but there was not only that. I am therefore in favor of recognizing the facts, not for repentance, which is a religious notion and has no place in state-to-state relations. The work of memory must therefore continue, but with dignity and objectivity, shielded from controversies and attempts at political instrumentalization. This process must also take place on both sides, as it is not a matter of having one side accept without discussion the truth of the other. Only in this way can we gradually move towards a common reading of history, which we must not hide will take time. I will ensure on my side that this work is done, as far as the French administration is concerned, for example through cooperation between the two archive departments. The media also have a role to play and have already done much to enlighten public opinion. A more lucid and objective view of the past, on both sides of the Mediterranean, will do much to achieve peaceful relations between the two countries. But I also believe that we should not make memory issues a prerequisite because, in that case, we would penalize all the Algerians and French who expect rapid progress in our relations.

QUESTION - Are you satisfied with the level of economic relations and French engagement in Algeria, knowing that criticisms are regularly made regarding the timidity of French companies (they prefer commercial activity) to invest directly in Algeria? Furthermore, you expressed the wish for a rapprochement between Sonatrach and Gaz de France. You also stated that you agreed for France to cooperate with Algeria in the field of civil nuclear energy during the presidential campaign. Is this still your position? How do you see the evolution of energy cooperation between Algeria and France?

THE PRESIDENT - Algeria is our primary economic partner on the African continent. But this situation is far from guaranteed, as our companies face strong competition, and recent years have shown a trend of erosion of their positions. They therefore need to show more dynamism and imagination than ever. French companies will thus increasingly need to engage, as they have begun to do, in new forms of partnership with their Algerian counterparts. Investments are part of this, and I want ours to develop. In this regard, our companies are not so "timid," as in 2006 they were the leading investors outside hydrocarbons and the second, including hydrocarbons, behind the United States. We can do better, I am convinced. But this also requires removing certain obstacles to investment, whether related to land, the protection of intellectual property, or competition from the informal sector. On the other hand, beyond the large contracts that respond to the very ambitious government programs for modernizing infrastructure and present fantastic opportunities for French companies, I strongly believe in the necessity of developing the presence of our SMEs, which already account for 50% of our exports, and encouraging them to get closer to Algerian SMEs. I wish for the development of a genuine strategy to encourage this rapprochement between French and Algerian SMEs.

As for energy, I had the opportunity to emphasize, even before my election, its importance for the relationship between the two countries. It is indeed capable of structuring this relationship and illustrates the interdependence that exists between them. We are complementary: France has nuclear technology, while Algeria is beginning to think about the post-oil era. On the other hand, we both need to secure our gas supplies for the future as much as Algeria needs to rely on a safe and guaranteed access to the French market and, beyond that, the European market. Therefore, we can only wish for a rapprochement between French companies - GDF, but also Suez and TOTAL - and Sonatrach.

QUESTION - Is France ready to sell arms to Algeria, a country that tends to diversify its sources of purchase? And what will be the main lines of cooperation in the military field in the future?

THE PRESIDENT - I will be very open to Algerian requests, just as I am to those of the two neighboring countries, as long as they contribute to the goal of strengthening regional security and stability in these countries, which is a priority for me. Our companies have been approached for numerous projects to supply modern equipment in the naval, aerial, and land domains, as well as for proposals for industrial partnerships. It must be recognized that few have been realized to date, and I would be very happy to see a greater number come to fruition. Regarding military cooperation with Algeria, I am ready to go further, as I want to support it in its efforts to professionalize and modernize its forces and to face, alongside it, the security challenges in the Mediterranean and the fight against terrorism and trafficking. Thus, I wish for the conclusion of the agreement that had begun to be discussed before my election, as it would strengthen the trust between the armed forces of the two countries, intensify strategic dialogue, and develop the already engaged cooperation actions, particularly in terms of training executives.

QUESTION - According to French sources, nearly 350,000 Algerians live in an irregular situation in France. Will you opt for a police and radical solution to address this problem, especially since your statements during the presidential campaign raised fears of witnessing mass expulsions? What significance do you give to what is called "chosen immigration"? What will happen to the free movement of people, particularly regarding the conditions for granting visas to Algerian nationals?

THE PRESIDENT - We cannot ignore the issue of people in irregular situations. It is a reality that poses a number of problems in France and regarding which I have made commitments to the French people who elected me. However, I wish to resolve this issue in concert with the countries of origin and with the utmost humanity. My goal is to facilitate, not to make more difficult, the movement between the two countries and, beyond that, between France and the Maghreb countries. This goal is even an integral part of my Mediterranean Union project. But this involves a counterpart, namely unwavering cooperation to combat illegal immigration and clandestine networks. The equation is very simple: the more we are convinced that the Algerians, Moroccans, or Tunisians to whom we grant a visa will return to their country at the end of their stay, the more easily those who entered without a visa or are in an irregular situation will be readmitted, the more generous we will be in granting visas. I remind you that during my visit to Algeria last November as Minister of the Interior, I committed to working towards lifting the Schengen consultation, which was prolonging the delays, and that is now done. I also announced the reopening of our Consulate General in Oran, which is scheduled for next September. We also need to transfer to Algeria the tasks that are still being carried out in Nantes and to generalize biometrics. Our goal is to achieve this before the end of this year. In addition, we have increased the number of circulation visas of more than one year (34,000 in 2006) and will continue to do so for all Algerians, particularly business people and academics, who contribute to nurturing the bilateral relationship. I also encourage our Algerian friends to do the same.

As for chosen immigration, it is something else, since, by definition, it does not involve circulation, that is to say, people passing through, but those who are called to stay with us for a certain time. It is normal that, for these individuals, and as is the right of any sovereign country, we decide on the criteria that will lead us to select them. This is what countries like Canada, the United States, or Australia do, for example. It is also important to distinguish this immigration, which is intended to meet the needs of French society and the economy, from the situation of Algerians who stay in France for training and are expected to return to their country to contribute to its development after their studies or training period. Indeed, it is not our intention to fuel the "brain drain," quite the opposite, while knowing that it is up to the country of origin to create the professional and social environment that will encourage the trained executives to want to return.

QUESTION - Several countries and groups of varying power are currently working to intensify their relations with the Maghreb region. How does France perceive its future relations with this region without giving the impression of operating in a conquered territory? And what do you believe is the best solution to definitively resolve the Western Sahara conflict?

THE PRESIDENT - There are several questions in your question. Regarding the first, it would be quite adventurous for us to consider the Maghreb as a "conquered territory." Our history with this region teaches us a certain caution. Not only do we not claim exclusive relations, but such relations would not be healthy. Economically, our companies face fierce competition, and that is a good thing for Algeria. In the linguistic field, I obviously wish for Algeria to remain a great Francophone country - and we will do everything we can to help it - but it is also good that more and more young Algerians know English, and it is legitimate for Algeria to assert its Arab-Islamic identity and continue its efforts in teaching the Arabic language. Moreover, we ourselves wish to strengthen the teaching of Arabic in France, which corresponds to an old tradition but also to real needs. As for the question of Western Sahara, it is indeed high time to find a sustainable solution, as its persistence clearly hinders rapprochement between the Maghreb countries, which will be able to more easily meet the challenges they face, whether related to the aspirations of their populations or the fight against terrorism. Resolution 1754, adopted unanimously by the Security Council on April 30, represented a step forward. The first session of direct negotiations under the auspices of the United Nations, which it prescribed, took place near New York on June 18 and 19, and we welcomed it. A new meeting has been scheduled. I sincerely hope that these discussions will lead to a reasonable solution, acceptable to each of the parties, and I am confident that all the countries in the region that have influence on this issue, including Algeria, will be eager to contribute.