Interview with Mr. Nicolas Sarkozy, President of the Republic, in the Indian daily "Times of India" on December 4, 2010, on Franco-Indian cooperation, the Iranian nuclear issue, and the priorities of the French presidency of the G20.

France Nicolas Sarkozy · President of France

4 December 2010 · Interview in the Times of India

Context
Sarkozy gave this interview to the Times of India on December 4, 2010, during a state visit to India to advance bilateral cooperation agreements.
Main themes
Franco-Indian civil nuclear cooperation, Areva-NPCIL reactor agreement, nuclear liability legislation, naval defense cooperation, Scorpène submarines, people-to-people ties, G20 French presidency, Iranian nuclear issue, India-France strategic partnership, non-proliferation
Duration
~21 min
67th percentile
Words
2,486
67th percentile
Sentences
121
72nd percentile
Readability
47
55th percentile
Grade
11.7
41st percentile
Syntax
2.90
34th percentile
Vocabulary
2.12
30th percentile

Translated from French

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

121 sentences in 42 paragraphs

QUESTION - What is the status of the nuclear agreement between Areva and NPCIL regarding the first French nuclear reactors in Maharashtra? Do you expect to sign this agreement during your stay in India? If not, what would prevent you from signing it?

THE PRESIDENT -- The discussions currently being held between Areva and NPCIL concern the construction of the first two EPRs in a series of six. To be precise, there are actually two project agreements: one relates to the preparatory work for the construction of the reactors, and the other concerns the supply of the reactors themselves and the fuel.

France, as you know, has been the first advocate for India in the world on the issue of civil nuclear energy. We were the first to act to bring India out of the isolation it had been in since 1998 and to allow it to establish cooperations in this field. We did this because India has always behaved impeccably in terms of non-proliferation and because India needs civil nuclear energy, which is a clean energy, for its development.

France was also the first country to sign a cooperation agreement with India on civil nuclear energy; this was in September 2008, during the visit to Paris of Prime Minister Manmohan Singh. The discussions between Areva and NPCIL are the industrial translation of the historic partnership we launched then.

You ask me if we will be able to formally sign the agreement between Areva and NPCIL during my visit; what I can tell you is that discussions are ongoing and that everything is being done to this end.

QUESTION - Are you concerned, as the Americans are, about the Liability Act that was recently passed in India? Will you discuss these concerns with your interlocutors here, and are you satisfied with the responses you have received? Will the Liability Act delay or prevent the commercial contract for the nuclear reactors?

THE PRESIDENT -- It is perfectly understandable -- and it is even to their credit -- that the Indian authorities seek to ensure the highest level of protection for victims. This must be done under conditions that respect the principle of legal certainty and, above all, that facilitate the development of the Indian civil nuclear program by establishing safe rules that comply with international principles for Indian and foreign companies in this sector.

What we wish is for India to adopt rules and practices that are in line with international practice in this area, as defined in the Vienna Convention, nothing more.

This is a subject that I will of course address with Prime Minister Manmohan Singh, with whom we discuss all topics in a climate of great trust. He is a man of great wisdom, for whom I have a lot of respect.

QUESTION - There have been several discussions about strengthening naval cooperation between India and France. What type of cooperation do you have in mind, and what difficulties might you face?

THE PRESIDENT -- I would first like to remind you that naval cooperation between our two countries has made considerable progress in recent years, as illustrated by the partnership we have launched in the field of conventional Scorpène submarines.

This unprecedented cooperation reflects the relationship between our two countries: it is ambitious, based on trust, and it is long-term. Above all, it responds to a genuine logic of partnership, which is no longer a supplier-client relationship, but aims to produce together, sharing skills and know-how.

The project has indeed progressed well, as the hulls of the first two submarines are now completed. This year has also been marked by the order of the main submarine subassemblies, which will thus be gradually integrated into the hulls. This is a significant step, and I know that DCNS and the Indian shipyard are fully committed to delivering the first submarine as soon as possible.

In naval matters, I would also like to remind you that the French Navy and the Indian Navy are getting to know each other better, thanks to the organization of joint exercises that are working remarkably well. A new exercise of this type is planned for early next year.

QUESTION - We see large French companies establishing themselves in India, as well as intense cooperation between our two governments. We have great admiration for French literature, cuisine, and films. But we still do not see interaction between civil societies, a factor that is essential for a sustainable partnership. How do you plan to strengthen the ties that bind our two peoples?

THE PRESIDENT -- It is false to say that there is no interaction between our civil societies. In fact, they have developed significantly in recent years. Look at academic exchanges, to take just this example: they have increased by 25% every year for the past four years.

But where I agree with you is that these exchanges are not yet at the level of the friendship and -- you used the word -- admiration that our two peoples have for each other. We can do more, and we must do more.

That is why we decided, as early as 2008, with Prime Minister Singh, to make the development of human exchanges a true priority in Franco-Indian relations. For example, we set the goal of tripling the number of young Indians studying in France over the next three years. I tell you, Indian students are welcome in France. I hope that more and more of them will come to train with us.

Strengthening human ties between our two countries also involves improving the conditions for professional mobility. We need to facilitate the movement of business people, researchers, and professors between our two countries. We have begun to reflect on this issue; we are only at the beginning, but it is an essential project.

A word about our cooperation in the scientific field. If I chose to start my visit in Bangalore, which is somewhat the Indian capital of new technologies and space, it is to pay tribute to this modern India, at the forefront of progress, this India of the 21st century; but it will also be an opportunity for me to celebrate the excellence of Franco-Indian scientific partnership. I will visit ISRO, where two Franco-Indian satellites are being built in collaboration with CNES to study climatic phenomena and oceans. My visit will also be an opportunity to launch the work for the creation of a new technological institute in Rajasthan, to which France will contribute by sending teachers-researchers, students, experts, and by creating joint laboratories. These are just a few examples of the countless scientific cooperations that exist between our two countries and that we will continue to develop.

Human exchanges also involve culture. A significant part of the deep friendship and attraction between our two peoples comes from a genuine fascination for each other's culture. Indian culture, like French culture, radiates well beyond the borders of our countries. India, France, we believe that diversity is a wealth that must be preserved and made to live. That is why we are so committed to cultural creation. Because a culture that no longer creates is a culture that dies.

Cinema is a perfect example. Our two countries have managed to maintain a particularly rich and vibrant production. But today, we choose to go further and build a bridge between our two film industries. My visit will thus be an opportunity to sign a co-production agreement encouraging cross-participation between French and Indian productions in both countries.

QUESTION - I would like to discuss the subject of Iran with you. France has taken a very firm position on Iran, compared to most other countries. What kind of discussions will you have with Dr. Manmohan Singh on this subject? What do you expect from India?

THE PRESIDENT -- India is now part of the great powers. On the issue of Iran, as on all major international issues, its voice matters. Its engagement can make a real difference.

The Iranian crisis is undoubtedly one of the most serious threats to international security today. France's position has always been very clear: the prospect of a nuclear-armed Iran is simply unacceptable. But we also say just as clearly that Iran, like all countries in the world, has the right to civil nuclear energy, in compliance with international rules.

On several occasions, and very recently, the international community has made extremely ambitious proposals for cooperation to the Iranians, including in the field of civil nuclear energy, provided that it complies with its international obligations and renounces its illegal proliferating activities. Iran has rejected all of them.

Instead, it has continued to multiply provocations -- missile launches, increases in its enrichment levels, various threats... And I remind you that just over a year ago, intelligence services discovered a new clandestine nuclear site.

In the face of these provocations, the United Nations Security Council decided, last June, to adopt a new sanctions resolution, the fourth since the beginning of the Iranian crisis.

France, it is true, has been a driving force in the adoption of this resolution -- not to punish Iran, but to make the Iranian leaders understand that their strategy is leading them straight to failure. For us, it is not sanctions or dialogue; it is sanctions to bring the Iranians back to the negotiating table.

India can help us convince the Iranians that they are on the wrong path, that their choices are leading their country into a dead end, and that the Iranian people aspire to something other than the isolation to which their leaders condemn them. India's role will be even more decisive starting next January, as your country will sit for two years on the United Nations Security Council, which I welcome. On this issue, as on all the files under the responsibility of the Security Council, I hope that we can work in close consultation.

As you know, Catherine Ashton, the High Representative of the European Union, will meet on Monday and Tuesday in Geneva, with the Six, the Iranian negotiator. We have been waiting for a sign of goodwill for a year. This time, the Iranians must sincerely engage in these discussions and choose cooperation. This crisis has lasted too long.

QUESTION - France will host the next G20 summit. What will your priorities be? What is your opinion on the alleged "currency war" threatening to pit China and Germany against the United States and other deficit countries? What would you see as the solution?

THE PRESIDENT - The French presidency will have as its primary mission to continue and deepen the work initiated over the past two years to regulate international finance. The moralization of financial capitalism remains a priority for us. The historic advances we have made over the past two years will be pursued, and we will deepen all the projects on this reform agenda.

But if the G20 wants to remain legitimate, if it wants to live up to its responsibilities, then it cannot be a mere "management G20" that would simply complete the ongoing projects. It must set itself a new ambition, address new issues, and confront new challenges. If the G20 wants to be worthy of the expectations that our peoples have placed in it, it must remain the place where the new world of the 21st century is prepared.

We live in a rapidly changing world, a world undergoing profound upheavals. In this new world, we need new ideas. It is up to us to find these ideas, all together. If we do not do it, no one will do it for us.

It is in this spirit that France has proposed to its G20 partners to open new projects that are essential to the stability of the world.

The first is the reform of the international monetary system. You ask me about the possibility of a "currency war," which many commentators fear today. But remember that when I first raised the issue of the functioning of the international monetary system nearly a year ago, it is an understatement to say that my remarks were met with a lot of skepticism and caution. Today, everyone recognizes not only that this subject was legitimate, but that it was inevitable. Above all, everyone admits that the method proposed by France is the right one. This method is to move away from invectives and mutual accusations, as they resolve nothing, and to engage, together, in a deep reflection on a comprehensive reform of the international monetary system.

The second priority of the French presidency is the fight against the volatility of raw materials. Once again, this is an extremely difficult issue, but one that can no longer be avoided if we do not want the world to experience hunger riots again and if we do not want to continue to suffer from the brutal fluctuations in raw material prices — whether it be oil, gas, or agricultural commodities — which have dramatic consequences for the global economy.

The third priority is the reform of global governance, which has waited too long. Together with the World Bank and the IMF, it is now underway, but we must go further. I am of course thinking of the reform of the United Nations, and in particular the reform of the Security Council, which has been blocked for nearly twenty years. Together with our British friends, we have proposed an interim reform, as we are convinced that this is the best way, probably the only way, to finally break the current deadlock. Rest assured that France will continue to fight, as it was the first to do so, for India to finally obtain the place that rightfully belongs to it on the Security Council, that of a permanent member, and in all instances of global governance.

Finally, France has long advocated for the G20 to address development issues, because we believe that emerging countries have a prominent role to play in this area and because there cannot be strong and sustainable global growth without the economic takeoff of the poorest countries. I particularly wish for us to work on the issue of innovative financing. This is an essential topic, as it determines our collective capacity to meet the commitments made to combat climate change and achieve the Millennium Development Goals.

You understand, France's priorities for its presidency are particularly ambitious. France approaches them with great determination and realism. We know well that these tasks are too colossal to be completed within a single year.

Finally, the French presidency will be an open, inclusive presidency, one that will work collectively by closely involving all its partners, starting with India. I will have extremely in-depth discussions with Prime Minister Singh on all these topics, to which I know India is particularly attentive. I count on India to play its full role during the French presidency — I hope it will be a major player.