Interview with Mr. Nicolas Sarkozy, President of the Republic, in the Polish daily "Fakt" on December 6, 2008, notably on European defense and NATO, Euro-Russian relations, the European Union's action in response to the crisis, and the future of the Lisbon Treaty.

France Nicolas Sarkozy · President of France

6 December 2008 · Gdansk, Poland

Context
Sarkozy addressed Polish media during a visit to Gdansk on December 6, 2008, discussing European defense, NATO, Russia relations, and the EU's role amid crises.
Main themes
European defense and NATO, Euro-Russian relations, Solidarity movement and Polish history, Lisbon Treaty, European Union crisis response, missile defense system, ESDP strengthening, human rights and democracy, Georgia conflict, EU-Russia summit, French EU presidency, Central European security
Duration
~17 min
59th percentile
Words
2,077
59th percentile
Sentences
93
59th percentile
Readability
43
42nd percentile
Grade
12.8
55th percentile
Syntax
3.05
54th percentile
Vocabulary
2.18
45th percentile

Translated from French

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

93 sentences in 27 paragraphs

Q - You mentioned that the European family had been divided and that some members of this family had remained on the "wrong side of the wall" and that "they freed themselves," thanks to personalities like John Paul II, Geremek, Walesa, or Havel. What is the meaning of your visit today to Gdansk? What message can be taken from it for Europe and its future?

R - It is with great emotion that I come to Gdansk today. For Gdansk is not only a significant place in Polish history, it is also a place of memory for all of Europe—this Europe that was torn apart yesterday, now united and reconciled.

Gdansk is also a testament to the resistance against totalitarian oppression; it is the great adventure of the "Solidarity" union, which was able to both defeat communism and lay the foundations of democracy. It is here, in this city, that at the dawn of the 1980s, the wind of freedom was born that would triumph over totalitarianism. Lech Walesa and his companions, by fighting for their most fundamental rights, opened the way for a movement of dissent that would continue to grow and ultimately sweep away the Soviet empire. Without "Solidarity," without the commitment of Lech Walesa and all his companions, the European family would undoubtedly not have been reunited so quickly.

By coming here today, I want to pay tribute to all those who fought and continue to fight for the respect of Human Rights, in Poland, in Europe, and in the world. I belong to a generation that has been nourished by the example of "Solidarity," by the example of Lech Walesa, and by a few other great Europeans, like John Paul II and Vaclav Havel.

Freedom, democracy, justice, respect for the human person and their dignity are values that we, Europeans, must continue to uphold and defend everywhere in the world. That is the message I have come to deliver here, in Gdansk, on behalf of the European Union.

Q - The statements made in Nice during the EU-Russia Summit regarding the missile defense project have raised some questions about the meaning and future of European defense: what is the role of NATO and the United States in European defense?

R - It is normal for Europeans to question the best solutions to ensure their security and that of their allies. I have clearly expressed my views on missile defense. As I said at the NATO summit in Bucharest, it can provide a useful complement to nuclear deterrence in the face of limited strikes. The decision to deploy this defensive system, of course, depends on the countries involved, namely Poland, the Czech Republic, and the United States. But it seems natural to me that partner and allied countries, particularly those that are both members of the European Union and NATO, can discuss all these issues openly.

Furthermore, the European Union has been engaged for years in building a common foreign and security policy. Strengthening the European Security and Defense Policy (ESDP) is one of the priorities of the French Presidency. We must do much more to ensure that Europeans have the capabilities, particularly military, to carry out operations responding to crises and to strengthen European defense industries. I believe that on this point, there is a real consensus, particularly between France and Poland. Our soldiers are indeed engaged side by side in several important operations.

I am convinced that the development of European defense capabilities contributes to strengthening NATO. The Atlantic Alliance is essential for our security, particularly that of the European continent. It is based on a collective commitment to mutual defense. The development of European defense occurs naturally in complementarity with NATO. For a simple reason: we are members of two organizations, and the very idea of competition between the two makes no sense. I also believe that our American allies have every interest in a strong European defense that develops its military capabilities. This is indeed what President Bush said at the Bucharest Summit.

Q - Russian foreign policy seems, as was the case in Georgia, to sometimes be conducted through the diplomacy of the cannon, or elsewhere, through pressure on energy resources like gas. How should relations with Russia be managed, which is linked by recent, painful history to a large part of Central European countries, as well as being geographically close, bordering in the case of Poland?

R - The European Union reacted with exceptional speed and effectiveness during the Russo-Georgian crisis last summer. When I went to Moscow and then to Tbilisi, just four days after the fighting began, I did so as the President in office of the Union, and on behalf of all the Member States. And I believe that everyone recognizes today that the Union's engagement was absolutely decisive in resolving this conflict. In just a few days, we reached an agreement that allowed for the cessation of hostilities and the launch of a process for the withdrawal of troops to the lines prior to the outbreak of the conflict. Never before had Europe played such a decisive role in a crisis of this nature.

The European Union has since deployed observers on the ground. We are also providing significant support for the reconstruction of Georgia. A political negotiation process has been initiated in Geneva, under the auspices of the European Union, the United Nations, and the OSCE. Russia has fulfilled a large part of its commitments. Certainly, we are not at the end of the road, but things have improved significantly since the summer.

One lesson from this crisis for us Europeans is that we are never as strong as when we are united. It is because it was united that Europe was able to exert such influence on the course of events and shift the lines. We must absolutely continue down this path.

Beyond this crisis, we need to think together, with all our European partners, about the relations we want to have with Russia. You mention the painful history and the particular sensitivity of this great country—I have always been attentive to this, as I am convinced that we can only build a solid, trusting, and balanced relationship with Russia if we take this into account. But taking this into account does not mean that we must renounce our convictions or our values. To take just the Georgian example, I have always been very clear about the importance we Europeans attach to ensuring that the solution to this conflict respects the principle of territorial integrity and the principles of international law. On this issue, as on all others, we must engage in a sincere and demanding dialogue with our Russian partners.

We Europeans have political, economic, and energy interests that we must defend. We have security requirements that we must explain. It is in this spirit that the EU-Russia Summit in Nice took place. And it is in this spirit that I proposed a summit on the security of the European continent within the framework of the OSCE. While the European Union has a recognized defense and security policy, and while the solidity of the Atlantic Alliance, which we will soon celebrate the 60th anniversary of, is no longer in question, we have nothing to lose by opening a dialogue with our Russian partner on issues as important to us as the security of our continent.

Q - The G20 Summit in Washington emphasized the need to provide a "broader political response, based on closer macroeconomic cooperation, to restore growth." What do you think of the various initiatives proposed regarding the economic recovery and what approach should be favored at a European level?

R - The G20 in Washington, proposed by the European Union, marked a historic turning point. In the face of what is the most serious financial crisis we have experienced since the 1930s, the major world economies decided to respond in a coordinated and concerted manner.

This G20 ultimately led to the adoption of an ambitious and concrete action plan, as we agreed on the need for a global recovery, the establishment of a new regulation of financial markets, the introduction of a new global economic governance, more open to emerging countries, and finally the rejection of protectionism. This meeting thus resulted in considerable advances: the oversight of rating agencies, codes of conduct in banks regarding the remuneration of operators, the elimination of gaps in regulation, a review of accounting and prudential standards. We also decided to open the Financial Stability Forum to emerging countries.

The measures we agreed upon in Washington are extremely precise and concrete, and have disproven those, and there were quite a few, who explained to us that this summit would lead to nothing. We will have other international meetings on all these topics in the coming months, and I have no doubt that they will also lead to equally significant advances.

Regarding the European response to the crisis, it was obviously not a question of everyone adopting the same measures—that would not have made sense, as national situations are different. The idea, however, was to set up a toolbox that would allow each country to choose the tools suited to its own situation, that is, those best able to meet the needs of its economy—and that this be done in a concerted manner with the other Member States. And that is what we are currently doing.

It is in this context that I announced on Thursday an extremely ambitious recovery plan for the French economy, involving massive investments from the State but also from public enterprises and local authorities, which will accelerate the modernization of our country, particularly in the infrastructure and research sectors. This plan also includes support for the automotive industry, which has been hard hit by the crisis, and for the housing sector, as well as a strengthening of employment policies. All of this fits perfectly within the broader framework set by the Commission.

The approach we have favored with our European partners is both realistic, ambitious, and balanced, because it respects the particular situations of each while emphasizing the essential coordination among all Member States. Of course, we must now think about new steps, about frequent contacts. And in any case, the European countries participating in the G20 must continue to present a united and ambitious front.

Q - Regarding the Lisbon Treaty, despite the notable efforts made during the French Presidency of the European Union, the institutional future of the Union remains uncertain. Do you really think that the Lisbon Treaty still has a future, especially just before the Czech presidency, whose parliament has still not ratified the text? Moreover, do you regret the absence in Gdansk of President Kaczyński, who remains reluctant to ratify the treaty while awaiting a reaction from Ireland?

R - Of course the Lisbon Treaty has a future! I would like to point out that the parliaments of twenty-five Member States out of twenty-seven have approved the treaty and that the Czech parliament is preparing to resume the ratification process after the positive opinion issued by the Constitutional Court. We have therefore made good progress. This is explained by a simple reason: we need this treaty to function effectively at twenty-seven. No one imagines a third text after the constitutional project and the Lisbon Treaty. The terms of the debate are therefore clear, they are known to all: it will be either Lisbon or a return to the Nice Treaty, which everyone recognizes as insufficient.

What remains is to provide answers to the concerns expressed by Irish voters last June. We are working on that.

It is, of course, primarily up to the Irish to make proposals to us. At the last European Council, Brian Cowen explained to us what happened during the referendum and why the "no" prevailed. I know the determination of the Taoiseach to convince his compatriots that Ireland would gain nothing by isolating itself. I am sure that together we will find a solution that leaves no one behind and allows us to bring the European family together.

As for Poland, which is a great European country, I hope it will be at the forefront of European construction. It is in the interest of Poland and the Union. I hope that President Kaczyński will complete the ratification process by the end of the French Presidency. That would be a gesture of Franco-Polish friendship to which I would be personally sensitive.