Joint press conference of Mr. Nicolas Sarkozy, President of the Republic, Mr. Gordon Brown, Prime Minister of the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland, and Mr. José Manuel Barroso, President of the European Commission, on the action of the European Union in response to the international economic crisis and on the energy-climate package, in London on December 8, 2008.

France Nicolas Sarkozy · President of France

8 December 2008 · Joint press conference on the action of the European Union in response to the international financial crisis

Context
Sarkozy, Brown, and Barroso held a joint press conference in London on December 8, 2008, addressing EU responses to the global financial crisis and the energy-climate package.
Main themes
International economic crisis response, European coordination, anti-protectionism, G20 summit preparation, EU recovery plan, infrastructure investment, energy-climate package, digital economy, global governance reform, EU-UK cooperation, low-carbon industries
Duration
~24 min
74th percentile
Words
2,919
74th percentile
Sentences
179
86th percentile
Readability
61
89th percentile
Grade
8.8
9th percentile
Syntax
2.71
14th percentile
Vocabulary
1.94
5th percentile

Translated from French

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

179 sentences in 25 paragraphs

Just as a few years ago, investments provided significant stimulation for economies in this new era, we can invest in telecommunications, the digital industry, and other environmental technologies, in low-carbon industries and high value-added technical industries. This is therefore a way to look to the future while we address this crisis. We have invested heavily in infrastructure in the United Kingdom and we will continue to do so in the future.

I am pleased to see that cooperation is very good in Europe so that the EBRD and the European Bank are contributing to the development of structures in Europe. I believe that we can work hand in hand with the new American administration to encourage a response to global debt. This is what we talked about today, namely a digital, environmental, and solidarity-based Europe. I believe that this is a vision we can present as we try to resolve the current situation.

I would like to add a point: we agree that protectionism must be avoided at all costs in the coming months. We believe that any recourse to protectionism will delay recovery and would be a repetition of past mistakes. We think that all countries in the world must move in this direction and encourage us in these efforts. We are at the eleventh hour and we must now sit together and work to send a very strong signal against protectionism.

I want to introduce President SARKOZY. I am happy to welcome him back to Great Britain. As you know, his state visit was a tremendous success.

THE PRESIDENT - I want to make a brief remark to say that once again, I recognize myself in the analysis that Gordon BROWN has just presented. The financial crisis was serious, and we had to respond in a coordinated and strong manner. That is what we did. The economic crisis is serious. We must respond in Europe in a strong, rapid, and coordinated manner. We share the same analysis of the situation and we are well aware that the need to coordinate efforts to support activity in Europe is essential even if each country, depending on its specificities, does not necessarily use the same tools. And, already, we are preparing for the upcoming G20 summit, which is extremely important, to be held in early April here in London. Because we have made a commitment before the public opinions of the world that the same causes will not produce the same effects, that structural changes will take place, and that we will not be caught up in the usual routine. We know that the credibility of these changes that need to be made to global governance, economic reasoning, and an economic crisis of unprecedented severity rests on Europe's determination.

I would like to reiterate to Gordon my trust, my friendship, and the pleasure I have in working with him as well as with President BARROSO. And, undoubtedly, we will need to do more in Europe in terms of common energy policy and investment in energy, in terms of the digital economy and investment in the future, and in terms of training people.

MR. GORDON BROWN - I am also proud to work with President BARROSO, who has done an extraordinary job within the Commission. He has set up a recovery plan that will be discussed later this week. Mr. BARROSO.

MR. JOSE MANUEL BARROSO - It is a joy to be here again in London for a very important meeting where we also met with business leaders. I believe it is important to say that there was a good consensus and an excellent level of ambition. I was proud to see that there was full support for the plan presented by the Commission. I hope that this week, European leaders and the European Council will support this plan that we are going to present. It is an ambitious but pragmatic recovery plan, with more than one billion euros in incentives. We need targeted measures for this crisis that is defined as the first crisis of globalization. We need an effort with the real side of the economy so that all the engines of industry and the economy start functioning again. This is not the time to get caught up in dogmas; it is the time to be pragmatic to achieve a very high level of coordination and, at the same time, to pool all the instruments we have: the rules of the internal market and others to optimize positive synergies and minimize perverse effects. There needs to be an excellent level of cooperation and a European perspective, not only for us in Europe but also for our partners around the world. President SARKOZY and Prime Minister BROWN have said that they have set an example. But also the G20 has started and given the signal for all these efforts at the global level.

Gordon BROWN will chair the next G20 in April in London and he is determined to maintain this leadership for Europe and the rest of the world. I believe that if we work together, I am convinced that we can turn this crisis into an opportunity to achieve a high level of change for some. We can use this crisis to achieve two goals at once, so to speak, that is to say, use short-term stimuli to provide medium and long-term reforms, to improve competitiveness in Europe, to have cleaner industries, to invest in the energy sector, in the infrastructure sector, at all European levels, and to also encourage growth at the European level. We are also negotiating Doha.

QUESTION - I would like to know what the level of unity in Europe is? There is England and France on one side and Germany on the other. With all due respect to President SARKOZY, is there not a division between the incentives that are being given from an economic perspective?

MR. GORDON BROWN - Let me respond to the lack of unity. I do not agree with that. President SARKOZY and President BARROSO have led everyone to a situation where everyone has come to the realization that cuts in bank rates were necessary. There will be a meeting in January in the United States and then expenditures will be made on digital infrastructure, telecommunications, and this kind of effort.

THE PRESIDENT - First of all, I appreciate the respect. I am sensitive to it, but I would like you to realize what we are trying to do. Europe is 27 countries. We have a crisis that is unlike any other crisis. So, not only do we have to harmonize the positions of 27 countries, but moreover, we have to imagine new responses to a crisis that is unlike any other. So, it is certain that there is a duty of conviction.

But I would like to say a word about Germany. I received Mrs. MERKEL in France eight days ago. We talked a lot. I spoke with her on the phone yesterday. I believe I can say that Gordon BROWN also and President BARROSO as well. We share the same analysis of the situation with Mrs. MERKEL. I want to say that there is no disagreement with her. She confirmed this to each of us. Secondly, in the discussion we had yesterday, Mrs. MERKEL considers that the stimulus is so necessary that she herself has implemented it in Germany. She pointed out to me that the German stimulus plan was as important as the French stimulus plan. Then, for example, Gordon BROWN used the fiscal weapon. I think that, for his country, it was a choice he believes in, and why not? I did not use it. That does not mean there is a disagreement between us. It means that there is a toolbox that the Commission, that all of Europe makes available to the different states, and we choose from it. I do not share the analysis that would suggest that on the eve of our European Council, there is a disagreement about the severity of the crisis and the need for a stimulus. After that, we can look to the future; there are a number of us who think that, on certain points, we will need to do more for research and innovation. But that is not a disagreement. It is a reflection on what will need to be done next year. I think that the viewpoints have come immensely closer in recent weeks.

MR. JOSE MANUEL BARROSO - I want to confirm a point that should not be forgotten. There cannot be a one-size-fits-all approach for a Europe of 27. There are countries that will be above 4% growth, there are countries in recession, we have countries that have IMF programs to support their balance of payments. So, it would be erroneous to think that all countries can have the same reforms. In Germany, for example, I have complete confidence in the efforts that Germany is making and that Germany will make at the European level. Germany is the most important European economy. It would be unreasonable to think of a plan without the active cooperation of Germany. I agree with this analysis and I am sure that Germany is making very significant efforts, and, by the way, Angela MERKEL has said in the Bundestag, the German Parliament, that the German plan is already in line with the European stimulus plans. I believe that it is next year that we will return to this question. We must keep the analysis of the situation, knowing that it is evolving very rapidly. And I am convinced that Germany will be present at every appointment.

MR. GORDON BROWN - Last night, I also spoke with Chancellor MERKEL and we talked about the injection of liquidity into banks, the recapitalization efforts we are both making, the economic stimulus measures in Germany, investment in digital industries, and how we want to see this take shape in the future. So, you will see that we are in full agreement on this issue.

QUESTION - Can you tell us why the German Chancellor is not here? According to her teams, it is because she was not invited by the English. President BARROSO referred to upcoming measures. Will the measures go beyond the fiscal stimuli that have been discussed? Is this a point on which Germany might stumble? Since this could lead to another crisis.

MR. GORDON BROWN - Listen, this is a meeting we had with the business sector, with their leaders, and I invited the President of the European Union in office, President SARKOZY, the President of the European Commission, and they had the opportunity to exchange with these leaders. And that is how this meeting came about. You know that I meet with the German Chancellor very regularly and she will come to England very soon. As for the future, we agree that preparing for recovery is a good way to emerge from the crisis. We are looking at what is happening in the world of energy production. We are looking at what is happening in the world of highly skilled services. We must also consider what we can do better. And I am convinced that this is what the different countries are doing.

MR. JOSE MANUEL BARROSO - A small clarification. I believe it was on October 25. This has nothing to do with the European Council and I believe it was for November 17 for a meeting where the President in office of the European Union and I could come to listen and exchange with business leaders, as we had the G20 and this meeting was postponed. It would therefore be inconceivable for us to try to revive the European economy without Germany. It must be very clear. We are here to promote a common European response. And I am very proud to be here with Prime Minister Gordon BROWN. But this is the format of this meeting. Do not forget that and it makes sense that the President in office of Europe and the President of the Commission are invited.

QUESTION - Earlier you sent a signal against protectionism. Are you targeting the new American administration? And more generally, when do you think your stimulus plans will have their first effects?

MR. GORDON BROWN - I believe that all countries around the world are aware of the dangers of protectionism. It will have perverse effects on trade, on commercial exchanges, on the outcomes of the Doha negotiations, and we are very close to an agreement. What I am trying to do today is to have discussions so that we know how to respond to these demands and requests. There will be a ministerial meeting in the coming days to help smooth out the last difficulties. I encourage people to reflect on all of this. We must avoid protectionism being the response to this financial crisis. Therefore, my plea is that this trade agreement be signed in the coming days. It needed to be done before the end of the year. It was important to stick to this timeline, and I ask the countries that still have difficulties with this proposal to try to reach an agreement in the coming days. There is still much that depends on a cooperation agreement in the coming months to see how to restore a good level of economic activity. And this is where the European Council will have a common position on Thursday.

QUESTION - Have you discussed climate change? What are the prospects for this week?

THE PRESIDENT - Of course we discussed it. In fact, it is the role of the President of the Commission and the President of the Council to travel a lot before summits to try to bring all of Europe together on a common position. I was in Gdansk on Saturday with nine European heads of state and government. What did we do? We prepared for the next Council there. Of course, when I meet with the British Prime Minister, I report on the progress of the discussions to try to find a consensus on Thursday and Friday. And I reported this to the Chancellor yesterday. I will call the Prime Minister of Belgium and the Prime Minister of Spain. I tell you one thing: Europe must find a compromise. Europe must not give up its ambitions in terms of environmental protection. The crisis must not be an excuse to sacrifice the balances of our planet, and it is certainly not at a time when a new President of the United States sets ambitious environmental goals for the United States, the world's leading power, that Europe should give up its ambitions. And I believe I can say that Gordon BROWN and I, once again, are in perfect agreement. We will defend the Commission's energy-climate package. I do not hide from you that it is difficult. So, it is true that there are disagreements, but we are making progress. We are making progress. There are still two somewhat difficult points: how we organize solidarity for the countries that make the most effort, and the second point: how we help the countries that make the most effort to meet the 2020 targets. There you go. I cannot say more, but we are working a lot. We are talking a lot. There are many bilateral meetings to ensure success. This is not guaranteed; it is not easy to get 27 countries to agree on this ambitious goal. I can tell you that the three of us are working towards this goal, and we will do everything to achieve success.

MR. JOSE MANUEL BARROSO - I believe this is very important. It is even historic. We need this agreement at the European level. As President SARKOZY pointed out, we also have the Americans very close to our positions. And this is new as well. I remember many G8 meetings where we tried to encourage our American colleagues. There were also many attempts to convince the Japanese. And they would tell us why we should proceed in this way if the Americans are doing otherwise. And today, President-elect OBAMA told me on the phone that his first priority will be to work on energy and climate change. So, let us seize this opportunity. We must not miss it. That is why I am fully in favor of an agreement; this is indeed a plea in that direction. I believe that with a good spirit of compromise and taking into account the differences between the various countries, we can achieve it. It is very important to succeed, and it is also very important to understand that climate measures are not incompatible with the economy. They can, on the contrary, be a driver that encourages economic growth. Many of these measures aim to improve environmental efficiency. There are also other areas such as infrastructure where there is a combined effect. It is positive for our economy. It can create jobs, and it is also important for security. We must not forget Copenhagen. The Copenhagen negotiations must be a success. We must agree on a common position.

MR. GORDON BROWN - I applaud the work done by President SARKOZY and President BAROSSO on this huge and fundamental issue. And I am convinced that we can continue to work hand in hand with America on this issue. It will be a new path. I believe that President SARKOZY must return to France. So, I thank you all for participating.

Thank you very much.