Joint letter from Mr. Nicolas Sarkozy, President of the Republic, and Mrs. Angela Merkel, Chancellor of the Federal Republic of Germany, addressed to Mr. Herman Van Rompuy, President of the European Council, regarding measures to strengthen the Eurozone, December 7, 2011.

France Nicolas Sarkozy · President of France

7 December 2011

Context
Sarkozy and Merkel jointly addressed European Council President Van Rompuy in December 2011, proposing structural reforms to strengthen the eurozone amid the sovereign debt crisis.
Main themes
Eurozone crisis stabilization, Economic and Monetary Union reform, budgetary discipline and fiscal rules, strengthened eurozone governance, euro area institutional architecture, economic growth and competitiveness, treaty changes, balanced budget requirements, macroeconomic coordination, Franco-German leadership in EU reform
Duration
~11 min
40th percentile
Words
1,372
40th percentile
Sentences
69
45th percentile
Readability
26
10th percentile
Grade
14.4
71st percentile
Syntax
2.80
22nd percentile
Vocabulary
2.35
84th percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 74%74%
  • Economic 16%16%
  • Geopolitical 6%6%
  • Ceremonial 4%4%
  • Social 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

69 sentences in 37 paragraphs

Mr. President,

To overcome the current crisis, all necessary measures to stabilize the euro area as a whole must be taken. We are confident that we will succeed.

We are convinced that we must strengthen the architecture of the Economic and Monetary Union by going beyond the essential measures that are urgently needed for the immediate resolution of the crisis. These measures must be taken without delay. We consider this essential for the credibility and trust in the future of the Economic and Monetary Union.

The current crisis has clearly highlighted the shortcomings of the architecture of the EMU. We must address these shortcomings. To build a Union for stability and sustainable growth that allows us to preserve our European model, which combines economic success and social responsibility, we must significantly consolidate the foundations of the EMU. Alongside the single currency, a solid economic pillar is essential, supported by strengthened governance to ensure budgetary discipline as well as stronger growth and increased competitiveness. To achieve these objectives, we need a renewed contract between the member states of the euro area. This conviction is the driving force behind our proposal.

We need more binding and ambitious rules and commitments for the member states of the euro area. Because having a single currency implies sharing responsibilities within the euro area as a whole. This must allow for a new quality of cooperation and integration within the euro area.

We propose that these new rules and commitments be included in the European Treaties. Otherwise, the states whose currency is the euro will have to move forward. In this case, we will ensure that member states willing and able to participate can do so and that European institutions can play an important role. We will work to ensure that this new agreement is integrated into Union law as soon as possible.

The main features of this new Union for stability and growth are as follows:

* A strengthened institutional architecture

The governance of the euro area must be significantly strengthened. We must define a more integrated and effective institutional architecture without duplicating European structures and institutions. It will be based on the following principles:

- Regular summits (at least twice a year) of the heads of state and government of the euro area, with a permanent president. These summits will set the strategic guidelines for economic and budgetary policies in the euro area. The impact of our economic and budgetary policies on the euro area must be considered a matter of common interest, while respecting national responsibility.

- During the crisis, the Euro Summit should meet on a monthly basis: each meeting should focus on a specific agenda related to governance and policies aimed at strengthening growth, competitiveness, and budgetary stability. Countries that have signed the Euro Plus Pact will be invited to participate in discussions on related topics.

- A strengthened Eurogroup of ministers and a preparatory structure to prepare and implement the decisions taken by the Summit and ensure ongoing operations.

This framework will be fully consistent with the institutional architecture of the EU. We firmly reaffirm our commitment to fully involve the European Commission. The European Parliament and national parliaments must be adequately involved.

* A comprehensive prevention framework

All members of the Union for stability and growth have an interest in detecting and correcting unhealthy economic and budgetary policies well before they become a threat to the stability of the euro area as a whole. That is why we need a comprehensive prevention framework that strengthens coordination, monitoring, and compliance with rules, as well as positive incentives, based on current arrangements (new procedure for macroeconomic imbalances, EU 2020 Strategy, Euro Plus Pact, increased emphasis on competitiveness by Structural and Cohesion Funds, etc.) by further improving them.

This framework must include in particular:

- The adoption by each member state of the euro area of rules regarding a balanced budget that transpose the objectives and requirements of the Stability and Growth Pact into national legislation, preferably at the constitutional level or equivalent.

A new legal provision must specify the minimum requirements expected of the national rule on budgetary balance. The European Court of Justice, at the request of the Commission or a member state, should have the possibility to verify its transposition into national legal frameworks.

- The commitment of national parliaments to take into account the recommendations adopted at the European level regarding the conduct of economic and budgetary policies.

We must strengthen growth through competitiveness and convergence of economic policies among the members of the euro area at least. To achieve these objectives, and based on Article 136 and/or enhanced cooperation, a new common legal framework fully compatible with the internal market must be created to allow for faster progress in specific areas such as:

- Financial regulation

- The labor market

- The convergence and harmonization of the tax base for corporate tax and the establishment of a financial transaction tax

- Growth-supporting policies and better use of European funds at the level of euro area countries.

* A strengthened procedure for implementing sound budgetary policies

To complement the preventive aspect of the Pact and in particular to achieve the objective of structural budgetary balance and the ex-ante review of budget projects, a new procedure should be established to correct any breach of the 3% of GDP deficit threshold.

As soon as the Commission establishes that a member state has exceeded this 3% threshold, there must be automatic consequences unless the Eurogroup, by qualified majority, decides otherwise. Exceptional circumstances must be taken into account:

- The obligation for the concerned member state of the euro area to conclude with the Commission and to have approved by the Eurogroup by qualified majority reversed on behalf of the other member states a "European Partnership for Reform" specifying the budgetary and structural measures of that state to enable it to overcome its difficulties and assist it in its efforts

- A series of increasingly intense interventions in the rights of that state could be authorized as a targeted response to the breach of the ceiling. The steps and sanctions proposed or recommended by the Commission must be adopted by the Council unless a qualified majority of the euro area states decides otherwise.

Based on the provisions on the numerical benchmark for debt reduction as provided in the "six pack" (1/20 rule), the debt reduction procedure for euro area states whose debt exceeds the 60% of GDP threshold must be included in the new treaty.

* A permanent crisis resolution mechanism

We will accelerate the establishment of the permanent intergovernmental European Stability Mechanism (ESM). It must be effective in 2012 in order to better address future threats to the stability of the euro area as a whole, including the risk of contagion to other member states of the zone, allowing them to be assisted in case of emergency.

To optimize the effectiveness of the ESM and its decision-making capacity, specific "super majority" rules (85% of the subscribed capital of the ECB) must be implemented.

Regarding the involvement of the private sector, the ESM treaty should be revised to make it clear that the solution required for Greece was unique and exceptional. We remind that all other members of the euro area reaffirm their unwavering determination to fully honor their sovereign signature. A recital in the preamble must clarify that the euro area will comply with the practice of the IMF. As agreed, common terms of reference for collective action clauses (CAC) must be introduced into national legislations.

On the occasion of the fiftieth anniversary of the Treaties of Rome, we solemnly reaffirmed, with all the member states of the European Union, our determination to protect the achievements of European integration in the interest of future generations. To this end, we committed to adapting the political functioning of Europe to the evolving situation. It is in this spirit that we present our proposal to our European partners.

We are convinced that we must act without delay. We must make the necessary decisions at our next European Council meeting so that the provisions of the new treaty can be ready by March 2012.

We ask you, Mr. President, to accept the expression of our highest consideration.