Press conference by Mr. Nicolas Sarkozy, President of the Republic, on the decisions of the European Council regarding the strengthening of the Eurozone, in Brussels on December 9, 2011.

France Nicolas Sarkozy · President of France

9 December 2011 · European Council meeting · Brussels, Belgium

Context
Sarkozy addressed a press conference at the European Council in Brussels on December 9, 2011, outlining key decisions to strengthen the eurozone.
Main themes
Eurozone strengthening, Franco-German proposals, intergovernmental treaty, UK opt-out, ESM and EFSF management by ECB, IMF resource reinforcement, fiscal governance and automatic sanctions, PSI exclusion, private debt restructuring, financial services regulation, EU treaty reform
Duration
~31 min
84th percentile
Words
3,750
84th percentile
Sentences
170
85th percentile
Readability
59
85th percentile
Grade
10.3
24th percentile
Syntax
2.98
45th percentile
Vocabulary
2.01
12th percentile

Translated from French

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

170 sentences in 54 paragraphs

THE PRESIDENT - Ladies and gentlemen, good morning. I will make a brief comment before answering your questions.

First, we have just adopted the entirety of the Franco-German letter. All the measures outlined in the Franco-German letter regarding the strengthening of the eurozone will be included in the conclusions of our meeting.

Second, we had an extremely in-depth and difficult debate about the legal form that would carry the reforms we have adopted. As you know, we would have preferred a treaty reform at 27. This was not possible given the position of our British friends. Therefore, it will be an intergovernmental treaty at 17, open to all those who wish to join us. A large number of countries have indicated that they would like to join us. As I speak to you, there are two countries that have clearly stated they will remain outside: Hungary and the United Kingdom. And two countries that need to consult their Parliament or their coalition: the Czechs and the Swedes. For the others, they have expressed a desire to join the intergovernmental treaty.

The decisions we made early this morning allow us to move forward, to strengthen, as we wish, the euro, to see all the Franco-German proposals retained, and to resolve the legal issue that was under discussion: what form the reform of the eurozone should take, which will therefore be an intergovernmental agreement.

There are very important decisions that have been made, such as, for example, the exclusion of any recourse to the PSI, that is to say, a restructuring of private debt. Each European country has now committed to, which is quite normal, repaying its debt.

If there are questions, I will try to answer them.

QUESTION -- What is the timeline from now on?

THE PRESIDENT -- We have agreed, as was our wish with Mrs. MERKEL, that the text of the intergovernmental agreement must be drafted by March.

QUESTION -- And furthermore, is there a question of the states, particularly in the eurozone, lending money to the IMF so that it can intervene to help the most fragile countries in the eurozone?

THE PRESIDENT -- Within 8 days, we have decided to explore the possibility of a reinforcement of up to 200 billion euros.

QUESTION -- For the monetary fund...

THE PRESIDENT -- Exactly, but that is the question that was asked of me. Yes, of course, the question that was asked of me is, "Has it been considered to strengthen the resources of the International Monetary Fund?" Yes, it will even be in the conclusions. Finally, I hesitate with the term "conclusions" because these are not conclusions at 27. Let's say, these are conclusions of the 17 plus all those who wish to join us.

QUESTION -- Mr. President, have you reached an agreement on the status of the ESM? That is to say, will it be backed by the European Central Bank or not?

THE PRESIDENT -- So we have reached another agreement. I can announce it to you, it is the European Central Bank that will manage the EFSF and the ESM. There was a proposal from Mr. DRAGHI suggesting putting the competence of the central bank at the service of the European Fund, we considered it a very good idea. So the operator of the fund will be the ECB, and I would like to say that this is a great satisfaction for us and that it is one more element that will strengthen confidence in this fund.

QUESTION -- Mr. President, what was the problem with our British friends and this agreement you just announced about the ECB managing the fund? What does that mean? Will there be more money in the fund?

THE PRESIDENT -- No, no, that is not at all what I said. Mr. Draghi proposed to put the competence of the ECB at the service of the management and functioning of the European Fund. It is the ECB that will therefore manage the European Fund. This does not mean that a decision has been made to increase funding from the ECB. I adhere to the so-called Strasbourg jurisprudence; I do not comment on what the ECB should or should not do. Regarding the disagreement with our British friends, it is very simple: to accept a treaty reform at 27, David CAMERON asked for what we all considered unacceptable: a protocol in the treaty allowing the United Kingdom to be exempt from a number of regulations on financial services. This we could not accept since we believe, on the contrary, that part of the world's troubles comes from the deregulation of financial services and the need for European regulation. If we accepted an exemption for the United Kingdom, it would, in our view -- I am not saying it was Mr. CAMERON's position -- it would undermine part of the work that has been done in the service of financial regulation, which is very necessary.

QUESTION -- The intergovernmental agreement must be ratified by all parliaments, including the 27, or the 17?

THE PRESIDENT -- So, we agreed last night on the substance of the proposals to strengthen the euro: the PSI, governance, automatic sanctions, the management of the fund by the ECB. And we chose the legal path, that of an intergovernmental agreement, called 17 plus, that is to say, the 17 European countries plus those who wish to join us. Regarding the legal modalities, this will be the subject of the discussion we will have tomorrow morning because there are other questions to settle in the meeting we may have, perhaps not tomorrow morning, but today, given the time of our meeting. I can give you more legal details, but the path is chosen; it will not be a treaty at 27 for the reasons I indicated, it will not be protocol 12, it will be an intergovernmental agreement whose contours we will specify shortly, understanding that in our minds, the text, the final word must be written in March. We want to move very quickly now.

QUESTION -- Mr. President, following this agreement and this treaty at 17 and more, do you not fear the establishment of a Europe with totally two speeds by excluding the United Kingdom, first question? And the second, would you be in favor of including this treaty, let’s say in the treaty concerning the creation of the European Stability Mechanism, in order to link the two exercises and have something extremely solid?

THE PRESIDENT -- First of all, your question is extraordinary because I remind you that in the European treaty, membership in the euro is not a right, it is a duty, that everyone has been able to measure the extent of the crisis of confidence and credibility of the euro, that certain causes have produced dramatic effects and that we are trying to ensure that the same causes do not produce the same effects. And while we are doing everything to save the euro and strengthen Europe, you ask me the question: "Do you not think that the fact that the United Kingdom, which, moreover, negotiated an opt-out clause to not join the euro, feels in a two-speed Europe?" It is difficult; it is a choice; they said: "We want to be in Europe, but we do not want to be in the euro." I do not criticize, I do not make any comments, but it is difficult afterwards to say to those who want to save the euro and who are in the euro: "You organize yourselves, you draw the lessons from the crisis and you provoke a two-speed Europe." If there is a two-speed Europe, it is because there was an opt-out clause that allowed certain countries not to be in the euro while in the treaties, each of us must one day or another be in the euro. Moreover, there is a very different position, it seems to me, with our Polish friends who say: "We, when we are ready, we want to join the euro." No one can blame them for anything. And our British friends -- it is not a matter of blaming them -- who say: "Not only do we not want to be in the euro, but we are delighted not to be." And we, who defend the euro, who are trying to change the functioning of the euro and draw the consequences of the crisis, we are not going to apologize for doing everything we can to save our currency. I do not know if I have been logical enough, but it seems quite coherent to me. So I answer you willingly, yes, we would have preferred a treaty reform at 27. But from the moment it is not possible for the reasons I indicated, we draw conclusions. I had also said this at the time of the meeting with Mrs. MERKEL in Paris when we concluded our agreement.

I must say, let’s make the best of a bad situation; this will allow for a much lighter reform without the need for conventions, infinite delays as would have been required for a heavy revision of the treaties.

QUESTION -- First, since it is not a treaty at 27, what will be the role of the different European institutions, the commission, the European Court of Justice... first question...

THE PRESIDENT -- ...the legal service of the council has been very clear on this, from the moment it is not a matter of changing the competencies of the institutions but of doing more with them for a number of members of Europe, it does not pose any problem. Take the European Court of Justice. As you know, we did not wish for it to be able to judge the validity of a budget. But we have asked it to judge the compliance with the treaty of the golden rules. This is exactly what is provided for in its competencies. So that changes nothing. Regarding the commission and automatic sanctions, it is a political agreement of a number of states to say: "We will apply stricter rules, even before the adoption and ratification of an intergovernmental agreement." But the role of the Commission is indeed to be a guardian and possibly to impose sanctions. We are not changing the role of the Commission; we are simply saying: "From a political will, even before the treaty is adopted, we commit to respecting these rules and asking the Commission to apply these rules." So according to the council's own legal service, this does not pose any difficulty. I believe that each of you, who know well the functioning of European institutions, know this. Now, it would have been a whole different matter if we were changing the competencies of the institutions. But that is not the case.

QUESTION -- Do you think that the agreement that was more than sketched out last night is likely to calm the markets durably this time?

THE PRESIDENT -- Frankly, I would like to think so, as you do; well, sorry, I do not want to put words in your mouth, but I would like to think so and I would like to be able to say that press conferences at 6 a.m. are over and that meetings lasting 12 hours in the middle of the night will no longer be necessary. But you know, we are in the 21st century, a complex world where each of us -- and I first -- must show humility in the face of the complexity of the problems to be solved. I would not venture to make predictions. What I can tell you is that we had, with Mrs. MERKEL, laid the foundations of what seemed necessary to us to structurally change the functioning of the eurozone. This has been adopted by the 17 plus all those who want to join us. There are extremely important things, such as, for example, the clear and definitive refusal and the will to put it in the treaties, to abandon the PSI, that is to say, the restructuring of private debt, which is extremely important. For example, the institutionalization of a government of the eurozone, at the level of heads of state and government, which will meet very regularly, we proposed every month during the crisis. For example, the decision of an 85% majority to make decisions in the fund. These are extremely important things. Will this be enough? We will see; there is not just one criterion that will allow us to emerge from this crisis, but I believe that for all those who are attached to European construction, the decisions we have made are important and structured decisions.

QUESTION -- Mr. President, can you tell us more about Mario DRAGHI's proposal regarding the role of the European Central Bank? Will this intergovernmental treaty mean that no country will be obliged to hold a referendum? Thank you.

THE PRESIDENT -- First, regarding the referendum, these are decisions that belong to each country. The intergovernmental agreement does not lead to a convention and does not require a referendum consultation. Each of those who would like to choose this procedure, I do not see how we could oppose it. The decision of the central bank, this is very important what they have decided, and I am sure that in the coming days, as always with a bit of delay, a number of observers will understand what is happening. In addition to the second consecutive interest rate cut, the central bank, and this is the first time, to my knowledge, has just decided to lend for 3 years, which has never happened before, to banks, in an unlimited way, at an extremely low rate, since I believe the rate is 1%, for European banks.

The central bank has therefore decided to lend, in an unlimited manner, for example to Italian banks, this is just an example, liquidity at 1%. Today, the Italian state borrows between 6 and 7%. One does not need to be a great specialist to understand that tomorrow, thanks to the decision of the central bank, the Italian state will be able to ask Italian banks to finance part of its debt at rates that are undeniably lower than the market rates today, since the market rates today fluctuate between 6 and 7%. I take Italy as an example, but I could take Spain. I wonder if everyone has fully understood the significance of the decision that has been made by the central bank, which is not a small decision; it is an extremely important decision.

QUESTION --(Inaudible)

THE PRESIDENT -- To my knowledge, there has been no exchange. Naturally, the Governing Council certainly knew that there was a Franco-German letter and that there was a chance that this Franco-German letter would be adopted by others. But there is no program. The ECB lends in an unlimited manner to European banks at a rate of 1% over 3 years. You follow these issues extremely closely. Has this ever happened before? Never to my knowledge. Never. I don’t know, everyone will do as they wish. This means that each state will be able to turn to its banks which will have the liquidity, which will know that this liquidity cost 1%, and they will be able to request loans. Finally, I extrapolate, but each of you could make the same extrapolation, and it seems to me an important decision.

QUESTION -- I have two questions: Could you tell us more about the European Stability Mechanism and how it will be advanced and how these resources will be accumulated or not?

THE PRESIDENT -- Advancing was planned for 2013; we are now planning for 2012. I refer you to the Franco-German letter.

QUESTION -- Will the resources be accumulated with the EFSF?

THE PRESIDENT -- That is a debate among us that will be clarified tomorrow morning.

QUESTION -- The European Commission has just passed a package known as the six-pack with budgetary surveillance measures that go further than what is currently in place?

THE PRESIDENT -- Let’s say that the measures go further than the six-pack.

QUESTION -- Yours do, yes, but...

THE PRESIDENT -- No, those that we adopted today are not mine.

QUESTION -- There were also regulations that were planned and that were supposed to apply from December 13. Does that mean that these measures no longer apply, or will they apply during this period?

THE PRESIDENT -- Yes, yes, it continues; it is not retroactive what we have just decided; it is for the future, and I tell you our objective is March.

QUESTION -- How do you intend to enshrine the golden rule in the Constitution by March, at least before the presidential election?

THE PRESIDENT -- I have already answered this question in the company of Madame MERKEL at the Paris summit. The golden rule was a Franco-German idea dating back to August 16. It has now become an idea of the 17 or more. This golden rule will be integrated into the constitutions of each member state, and it is a rule that will apply to each of us, but regarding the modalities, let’s wait for the presidential election since it seems that there is no consensus in France. I have already said what I thought about a number of political forces, notably the German socialists or the Spanish socialists, two socialist parties that have made the golden rule their own.

QUESTION -- Regarding the ESM, will it benefit from a banking license?

THE PRESIDENT -- No, in the sense of whether it is a bank in the strict sense, is that the trick question you want to ask me? No, the answer is no.

QUESTION -- Have the sanctions been decided, that is to say, have you gone into detail about the sanctions that will be imposed?

THE PRESIDENT -- No, we have decided that they will be automatic for all those who do not respect the path towards the 3% deficit. They are not automatic regarding the debt reduction part, but we have not gone into detail about the nature of the sanctions. If you want, we have really made the political agreement, the main lines. There is now a drafting work that will begin with the Commission. I believe that this is still a summit that will be historic because the decisions that have been made are extremely significant and will durably change the functioning of the eurozone, the functioning of Europe, and moreover, it is quite encouraging to see that there are 23 countries that are already determined to apply, adopt, and make this intergovernmental agreement their own.

QUESTION -- You mentioned the new architecture you are proposing; you did not mention what was also an important point of your joint letter with the Chancellor, economic convergence, for example, taxation of financial transactions?

THE PRESIDENT -- On the taxation of financial transactions, we did not refer to it because anyway there is the text from the Commission that will come before the Parliament and the European Council in January. I do not see what more it would have brought; it is done. When I say it is done, it is coming for discussion. The Commission has made a proposal; they are coming for discussion.

QUESTION -- (inaudible)

THE PRESIDENT -- Why, in the letter, did we talk again about the taxation on financial transactions? The taxation on financial transactions is a proposal that Germany and France care a lot about, which has been the subject of a proposal that will be discussed by the member states and by the Parliament in January. So there is no problem. And on harmonization, on the contrary, it is provided in the text that will be distributed to you tomorrow; it clearly states a common economic policy in the service of growth with harmonization, and in the meetings that we request with Madame MERKEL every month, it will be on the theme each time of competitiveness and therefore of harmonization, of course. The response to the euro crisis is not simply budgetary discipline; it is budgetary discipline, but it is also growth, it is also competitiveness, and it is also convergence. You are absolutely right.

QUESTION -- A few weeks ago, you mentioned a European Union that was too integrated at 27; is this the beginning of a European Union that is less integrated at 27?

THE PRESIDENT -- You all know the efforts I have made and continue to make so that the United Kingdom is a member of the European Union, but we cannot force a country to appreciate the euro and to be in the euro if it does not want to be. It is a choice of our British friends; we respect that choice, but they cannot blame us for it. We cannot, on the one hand, ask for an opt-out clause to not be in the euro and, on the other hand, ask to participate in all the decisions of a euro that they not only do not want to have but also criticize; it is simply impossible.

Furthermore, regarding Europe at 27, which is indeed 27 but will be 28 with Croatia, it is a truism, and I apologize to you for saying that the more numerous Europe is, the less it can be integrated. To say that is an obvious truth. Just as it is obvious that if we have a common currency, we must have a common economic policy. It is clear. We do not want to exclude anyone from Europe, but we take note of the sovereign decisions that are also made, and we will draw the conclusions. We could not remain in the face of the crisis that shakes the euro with our arms crossed, without reacting, without drawing the consequences of the mistakes that have brought us to where we are; inaction was not a response. Those who did not want the euro, and I do not judge them, are not necessarily the best placed to resolve the forward march of the members of the eurozone. This can be said with great friendship for Great Britain and, of course, with a will that remains honorable. Each chooses their strategy and draws the consequences. We had said with Madame MERKEL, if it is not the treaty at 27, it will be the treaty, the intergovernmental agreement at 17 plus all those who want to join us.

Thank you very much.