Joint press conference of Mr. Nicolas Sarkozy, President of the Republic, and Mr. José Luis Zapatero, President of the Government of Spain, on Franco-Spanish relations, in Madrid on April 28, 2009.

France Nicolas Sarkozy · President of France

28 April 2009 · Joint press conference of Nicolas Sarkozy and José Luis Zapatero on Franco-Spanish relations · Madrid, Spain

Context
Sarkozy and Zapatero held a joint press conference in Madrid on April 28, 2009, addressing Franco-Spanish relations, the economic crisis, and Spain's upcoming EU Presidency.
Main themes
Franco-Spanish relations, economic crisis response, Spanish EU Presidency 2010, European Union governance, climate change, international security, fight against organized crime and terrorism, Somalia conference, G20 and new international economic order, Millennium Development Goals, Paris-Madrid-London axis, bilateral cooperation
Duration
~38 min
89th percentile
Words
4,501
89th percentile
Sentences
217
91st percentile
Readability
53
71st percentile
Grade
10.9
32nd percentile
Syntax
2.94
39th percentile
Vocabulary
2.04
17th percentile

Translated from French

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

217 sentences in 58 paragraphs

There were two questions that we addressed and that I would like to talk about in particular.

The economic crisis. We have shared over the past months, particularly since the autumn. Nicolas SARKOZY, then President of the European Union, mentioned a meeting of Heads of State and Government of the Eurogroup. We saw that it was absolutely necessary for there to be an active, engaged response from the governments of the European Union. We made commitments regarding the financial system and its collapse. We supported a strong fiscal initiative within the European Union and we did so recently within the framework of the G20 by stating clear principles for a new international economic order: transparency, regulation, the elimination of tax havens. These are objectives that we share 100%. The maintenance of the European social protection model, the fight against climate change, new sources of energy, and also the Millennium Development Goals that must be achieved.

And then, secondly, we addressed the question of the Spanish Presidency of the European Union. France has successfully presided over the European Union. This is a merit that belongs to the leaders and to President SARKOZY, and without a doubt, Spain will preside over the European Union seeking permanent collaboration, permanent support from this proximity of France, which is for us the great country, the important country for building the European Union.

A Presidency of the European Union, starting from January 1, 2010, which must above all be the Presidency of economic recovery and development, of establishing a new model of economic growth. A Presidency that must promote economic decisions of the European Union, decisions that are innovative, and I hope to count on the support of Nicolas SARKOZY for that. A Presidency that, in addition to this priority work in favor of economic recovery, must give a new impetus to political unity in the field of security in particular. Today, precisely, we signed bilateral agreements to strengthen the fight against organized crime, against terrorism. In the field of security, the European Union must play its role in the world, and we must meet the three major challenges for the international order: the fight against poverty and misery, the fight against climate change, and also promoting more understanding, dialogue, and seeking political solutions for the serious crises, for the conflicts that we are experiencing.

For example, President SARKOZY and I have agreed to propose holding an international conference on Somalia, a conference that will address the situation in Somalia, a conference that should provide a broad response, not only in the field of security, in the military domain, the problems posed by piracy to our two countries and others as well, but also to provide a comprehensive political response in the field of civil security. And all this to guarantee our security. We will work together in this area.

President SARKOZY, Nicolas, you know perfectly well that the will of Spain, of the Spaniards, is to have absolute understanding with France. We appreciate France and especially its President. This is a deep, intense, sincere affection, truly felt and forever.

THE PRESIDENT - Ladies and gentlemen, I have a serious problem: with the exception of personal judgments, I completely share President ZAPATERO's views on all the major issues he has just mentioned. So, if you allow me, I will not address them unless you have questions, to focus on two or three messages.

First, I want to tell the entire Spanish people how moved and touched Carla and I, as well as the delegation I led, were by the welcome, the interest, and the kindness that Spain, through His Majesty the King and through the President of the Government José Luis ZAPATERO, has shown us.

I would like you to take this at face value; it is not a diplomatic judgment, it is not the expression of a worldly sentiment. It is the feeling of profound emotion, and for me, I told José Luis earlier, speaking before the Cortes, filled with all the Spanish political class, was truly something that will remain as a great memory.

The second thing I would like to say is that France expects a lot from the Spanish Presidency of Europe, and President ZAPATERO can count on our total and complete support. José Luis ZAPATERO is a European leader who will have the chance and opportunity to lead Europe for six months, after the Swedish Presidency. Spain is a great country. This Presidency must be a great political moment for Europe in service of the economy, and truly, we will work hand in hand behind Spain and behind President ZAPATERO.

Finally, a third remark. The world needs a Spain that exercises all its international responsibilities. I have always thought this - very often, French journalists, long before I became President of the Republic, heard me speak of the necessity, in addition to the understanding with Berlin, of a Paris-Madrid-London axis; this is something I have always carried within me, independently, moreover, of the political choices of Spanish alternation. And so, Spain's presence in the major forums at the time of the G20 is a right for Spain, which is a member of the major economies of the world and must be able to express its position. Europe needs the greats of Europe to express their positions together in these major forums.

Finally, I would like to say to José Luis ZAPATERO that I have always enjoyed working with him. We have known each other for a long time, and I appreciate the politician. I enjoyed working with the Interior Ministers here, and I greatly appreciated that period when I was not President of the Republic and when José Luis received me and we talked.

It happens that I trust him; I do not do politics in Spain, and I have friends in many political currents in Spain. But spontaneously, we have always worked together, both of us. So, I am not unaware of his political commitment; he knows mine, but we have always been able to rise above it because we share the same conviction: that political leaders must assume their responsibilities. And how many times have I heard José Luis in Councils say: "Wait, let's make decisions, so that people understand what we decide." We have always worked hand in hand, and I believe it is in Europe's interest that today, Spain and France, together, pull Europe towards more policies and more determination and that we do not accept fatalism.

And, President ZAPATERO's words touch me because I know they are sincere. But rest assured that on this road of the European Presidency for Spain, you can count on us as allies, as partners, and as friends.

If of course there were some questions, I could elaborate.

QUESTION - Mr. President, Senior Presidente, what do you intend to do to protect the French and Spanish populations from swine flu, which has now become Mexican flu since this morning?

JOSE LUIS ZAPATERO - I would like to tell you that we have indeed addressed the question that logically concerns European governments, governments around the world. The World Health Organization is the body that has given the guidelines in response to this pandemic risk, following the swine flu. In Spain, of course, we are working on this issue; we have been providing information since we became aware of the scope of this epidemic in Mexico.

So far, all we can convey to citizens is a message of confidence. Preventive measures have been put in place. The response when there is a case, the response to treatment is a completely positive response. The Ministry of Health, in full coordination with the autonomous communities in Spain, with the World Health Organization, with the European Union, continues to work.

We have the scientific means, the therapeutic means to face this situation. Moreover, we must cooperate with countries that may have more difficulties than we do. I am thinking particularly of Mexico. The Government of Spain, through the Ministry of Foreign Affairs, is of course fully willing to provide additional aid to Mexico so that Mexico has more resources to face the risks of the spread of this epidemic.

Therefore, a message of tranquility. We are informed, and depending on the evolution of what the number of affected individuals could be, we will take further preventive measures, but while conveying a message of absolute tranquility.

THE PRESIDENT - Listen, France's reaction is the same as Spain's. For us, the key word is vigilance. We are preparing. Monitoring cells are in place. Experts are gathering all the elements. We received a message yesterday from the World Health Organization asking us to move to phase four. Concretely, this means that we must advise our fellow citizens against traveling to Mexico and take a number of precautions.

I would also like, together with President ZAPATERO, to convey a message of solidarity to President CALDERON. We are following the evolution of events minute by minute. We will provide all the information to our compatriots, without omitting any, and we will try to be as responsive as possible. What is needed is to be prepared. To be prepared for the most difficult so as not to have to face it.

We are clear-headed; it is neither about dramatizing nor minimizing. There is a world organization, the WHO, that is asking us to raise the level of vigilance, and that is what we are doing. Furthermore, we are putting in place a whole range of systems with the Ministry of Health. Roselyne BACHELOT is following this competently, every day.

QUESTION - I have a question for President SARKOZY. I would like to know if you share - you said you expected a lot from the Spanish Presidency of the European Union - do you share this idea that has just been put forward by the President of the Spanish Government, namely that the Spanish Presidency could indeed be the Presidency of economic recovery? And then, on the other hand, we have all witnessed the excellent understanding that exists between you, and I would like to know if you have had the opportunity to clarify the misunderstanding that occurred, in Spain at least, regarding this so-called statement by President SARKOZY about Spanish intelligence? Thank you.

THE PRESIDENT - First, I share President ZAPATERO's conviction that the question of the economic situation is major, and the President of the European Union in a little over six months, if he does not address the question of the economic situation in Europe and in the world... He is right; it is a priority.

In general, I will even go further; José Luis ZAPATERO and I have long thought that Europe suffers from a deficit - how to say? - of economic governance, to be clear. We are the two in Europe who have always been the most convinced of this issue. In other words, we are both for the independence of the central bank, we are both for the euro, we are both for everything that has been done, but we simply think that economic steering is a question that cannot be evaded, and that Spain making it a priority, nothing could be, in my eyes, more important.

So, total support, but I could also say that I recognize myself in many of President ZAPATERO's decisions. When advertising on the public channel is abolished in Spain, I think it is a fantastic choice, and I sometimes regret that the influence of the Spanish Socialist Party on European socialism does not cross the Pyrenees. When President ZAPATERO - it must be said that he is as well advised as I am, since our wives are engaged in a cultural debate - considers that the law protects in particular copyright on the internet, on creation, my God how I find myself in his convictions!

Finally, misunderstanding? There was no misunderstanding. The Spanish press is not to blame, the Spaniards are not to blame. It is the small ripples of a mediocre political debate in France. So there you go. The question is: "Did José Luis and I explain ourselves?" You don't think we have a second to lose on that? You know, we know each other well; I believe I can say that it goes beyond professional camaraderie. And do you think I have so little experience that I should fall into all the traps of Spanish politics? He is very experienced, and he does not want to fall into the traps of French political squabbling. So, did we talk about it? No. Are we interested? No. Do we turn the page? But we hadn't even opened it.

This does not mean that I do not consider him to be very bright. And I can even tell you something else, he is a bit too young as well, and then he runs too fast because yesterday, I went out for a jog before the state dinner and guess who I ran into. The security, I saw, suddenly became worried. There was a car that stopped and a gentleman who ran out of the car. It was him and he was going in the other direction. And yet, we agree.

QUESTION - Mr. SARKOZY, earlier you mentioned, in the Cortès, a common security staff. I believe this is a question that was extensively discussed this morning. On this issue, particularly the issue of illegal immigration, how will this translate concretely? Are we moving towards joint flights for the return of illegal immigrants? And I would like to know, Mr. SARKOZY, since we know that France and Spain have not always had the same positions, and even recently on this issue, do you welcome Spain's change of course on this matter?

THE PRESIDENT - I do not welcome any change of course, but I can say one thing, that we agree with Spain, not only on security issues but also on immigration issues. I add that, under the French Presidency, Europe has established - I speak under the control of Mr. MORATINOS - a European pact for immigration and at no time has there been a problem between France and Spain, and I speak under the control of Mr. MORATINOS and Mr. RUBALCABA.

Finally, we had talked about immigration with José Luis. We talked about it, I believe it was even in 2005 or 2006. We have never disagreed on the substance of things but on the degree of information and exchanges between the different countries of the Schengen area. And that is what had caused, at the time, a debate between us. There was not one who said - I in this case - "no immigrants." I have never believed in zero immigration. And there was not another who said: "we do not want to control immigration." I have never heard Mr. ZAPATERO say that. But simply, how do we ensure that while respecting Spanish law and French law, we exchange our information since we live in the same space? That was the debate at that time.

Today, we are on the same line, dare I say, it is the same policy and if naturally the Spanish authorities need the assistance of France to organize, for people who do not have papers in Spain or France, group returns, Spain is a democracy, France is a democracy, who could blame us for wanting to apply the law together?

So things are clear, our availability is total and complete.

QUESTION - I have a question for each of you. For President SARKOZY: this morning, we heard in the Cortès, you congratulated Spain for the agreement between the two major parties, the Popular Party and the Socialist Party, to speak in unison against the terrorism of ETA. You said that all of Europe applauded this agreement. I would like to know if you think it would also be necessary to have a pact of political unity between the political forces in France and Spain to face the crisis?

A question for the President of the Government ZAPATERO: what steps could France take for Spain to have a permanent position at the G20 summit? Thank you.

THE PRESIDENT - I believe there is no reason for Spain to be treated at the G20 in New York differently than it was treated at the G20 in London. For me, the matter is settled. I have never seen any discussion about changing the attendees in London. In London, there was Spain. In New York, there will be Spain.

Secondly, is a political pact needed for the crisis? Obviously, we will not be able to resolve a global economic crisis simply with national measures. But, at the same time, I fully understand that in a democracy, political forces have different ideas and express them. And between systematic division or systematic single thought, I think there is a just balance.

I do not believe we should stifle debate in a crisis situation, that all ideas should flourish and we try to choose the best ones. And, at the same time, to blame a national government for being responsible for the crisis is laughable because the crisis is international and it did not even come from Europe even if it is Europe that is suffering from it.

So there you go, everyone proposes. Voters choose. And, at some point, we still need to stick together, at least among countries. We need Spain, we need a prosperous Spain, a prosperous Germany, a prosperous United Kingdom and naturally, if France is in a situation of economic crisis, that does not help us. We are all in the same boat and the question is not simply played out on a left-right divide. The question is played out on another divide: the immobile and the conservatives on one side £ the movement and change on the other.

JOSE LUIS ZAPATERO - I would like to make two remarks. First of all, Spain was present at the G20 meeting in Washington, Spain was present at the G20 meeting in London and our goal is to be present at the G20 meeting in New York which will take place in September at the same time as the United Nations General Assembly. And I have full confidence, I think that the two previous meetings will be able to consolidate what is a completely logical presence. The Spanish government has worked on all fronts, the Spanish government has made all the successful efforts. We have had collaboration as important as that of the President of the French Republic.

Secondly, regarding the crisis and agreements, President SARKOZY explained it very well, it is about having a debate on the best ideas and I would add on my part, and going in the same direction as what the President of the French Republic said, we are facing a new situation and a situation that is global. It is a general crisis. And the old recipes are useless, the old recipes of models that have had more influence over the past years, these recipes are useless and can even be harmful. Ultimately, when we talk about labor market reform and employment, in fact, it would amount to deregulating the labor market and we know where these deregulation policies have led for the financial system. It turns out that when the financial system is on the brink of collapse, well, who has to come to save this financial system? It is the governments, through public spending, thanks to the public resources that some have criticized so much.

That is the objective reality that we observe. So, ideas and of course, in this debate of ideas, we must try to implement the ideas that would be the most effective. But when there is this lack, this total absence of private investment, to question the fact that we support with public funds the automotive sector, for example, and other sectors, would amount to applying an old recipe that does not work in this context. And, moreover, we must be fully aware of the fact that the efforts made by governments first to support the financial system essentially thanks to the impetus given by Nicolas SARKOZY last October and that has worked well.

The financial system survives, it has started to work again. We have provided a response thanks to public funds. This was reflected in the European plan in December. Spain has made an effort exceeding 2% of its GDP and we have therefore approved a set of measures essentially starting from January. We are in April, barely three months have passed and we need some perspective and, at the same time, objectivity to understand well that a set of measures that we deploy, a public investment of 33 billion euros of investment or 40 billion to support the credit system, to guarantee the cash flow of companies thanks to the official credit institute, well, all this needs some time to penetrate the fabric of companies because, of course, we must not forget in our response to the crisis that in 2009, there will certainly be new measures.

We must be attentive to the crisis and I also agree with President SARKOZY: if the European Union wants to be truly a political union, effective, at the service of citizens, it must have a much stronger economic government that has tools. We cannot have a single market, a single currency and then not have an economic government with power, with tools at its disposal. And this is a priority objective of the Spanish Presidency of the European Union.

QUESTION - Question to President ZAPATERO and President SARKOZY. What are Paris and Madrid going to implement to intensify their cooperation in the fight against Islamic terrorism and can this be done on the same model as what is being done, successfully, against ETA?

JOSE LUIS ZAPATERO - Today we have signed a declaration and an agreement on security. This represents a qualitative leap in the relations between our two countries in the field of security and more particularly regarding the fight against terrorism, all types of terrorism. We have created a strategic security committee that will meet every six months with the directors general of the state security forces and which will prioritize coordinating and planning our action in two fundamental areas: the fight against terrorism and organized crime.

This agreement regarding the strategic security committee will be accompanied by the strengthening of our collaboration in the operational field. Of course, the great experience in collaboration between the two countries in the fight against ETA is a good model for prevention regarding the fight against Islamist terrorism. We share risks, we share a common sensitivity and, in many cases, we also share objectives given the nature of this kind of terrorism.

THE PRESIDENT - Quickly, I think that the divide, the separation between political terrorism, religious terrorism and mafia activities, is an old divide. Terrorists feed off the activities of mafias and therefore, it is the same fight, under the same conditions and it is very important for us that Spain makes this determined choice. We could even imagine creating a Franco-Spanish GIR to attack criminals in their wallets, starting not from the act of delinquency but from the assets that are the result of the act of delinquency.

This is what we have experimented with in France and if we could, with our Spanish friends, be the first transnational collaboration to attack criminals and mafias in their wallets, by putting our two tax administrations together with our police forces, we would be all the more effective.

QUESTION - I would like to ask you a question about infrastructure. First of all, will there be a boost in electrical interconnection with France? Will France therefore have its infrastructure works between Perpignan and Lyon and also regarding Canfranc. Are there more studies? Are there dates? Here, there has been a call for more commitment from France, it was said that for the TGV, there should be fewer declarations of intent and more decisions? Is there also this commitment from France regarding the maintenance of roads in the Pyrenees? Have you talked about relations between France and Spain regarding EADS? Will France buy C295 planes from Spain? Thank you.

JOSE LUIS ZAPATERO - I must say that some of these questions, we need to keep for lunch, the lunch we are going to have now. Regarding electrical interconnection, we have made a lot of progress recently, the electrical interconnections between France and Spain, we have obtained funding from the European Union to meet this great energy need. There is a political will expressed by President SARKOZY as well, before the Cortès, to move from declarations to actions regarding the interconnections concerning the Pyrenees, regarding the different objectives and different projects.

I am completely confident, I think the coming years will be years of realization for everything related to interconnections between France and Spain.

THE PRESIDENT - Madam, we will respect all timelines. Well, of course, there are legal procedures, as you know, for work of this importance, and I cannot control all the timelines for public consultations, for appeals from one party or another. But I tell you one thing: France has made commitments to Spain, and it will do everything to uphold them. It is in our interest, whether it is for the high-speed train where we have - I speak under the authority of Minister BUSSEREAU - I believe three or four years for Lyon-Barcelona, with the question of the tunnel to be built towards Figueras. I do not think you have ever heard a President of the French Republic as determined to remove obstacles.

And regarding interconnection, we will respect it in the same way; a political choice has been made, and we take responsibility for it. This poses other problems for us, but you know, decisions that do not pose problems are not decisions. And I know that we are playing a part of our credibility.

Finally, we cannot tell Spain that we are your partners and your friends and that we will somehow ensure the twinship of our economies, of our political positions, and at the same time refuse to have a rapid transport system and energy connections. That would make no sense, none at all.

So, for that matter, we are a state governed by the rule of law like Spain, and we have procedures, possibilities for advocacy groups to make appeals. All of this is integrated, but I guarantee you that our will is to move quickly, as quickly as possible. And I am convinced that when all of this is realized, we will say to ourselves: "but how could we have taken so long to make a decision of this nature?" The decision has been made, and the political consequences are engaged. Now it is a matter of implementation, but I assure you that we will try and that we will do everything to meet the deadline.

Thank you.