Joint press conference of Mr. Nicolas Sarkozy, President of the Republic, and Mrs. Angela Merkel, Chancellor of the Federal Republic of Germany, particularly on Europe's action in response to the international economic and financial crisis, in Paris on November 24, 2008.

France Nicolas Sarkozy · President of France

24 November 2008 · Joint press conference of Nicolas Sarkozy and Angela Merkel on the international economic and financial crisis · Paris, France

Context
Sarkozy and Merkel held a joint press conference in Paris on November 24, 2008, addressing Franco-German cooperation on the global financial crisis and European policy priorities.
Main themes
Franco-German cooperation, international economic and financial crisis, European coordinated recovery, energy and climate package, Lisbon Treaty, innovation and research, NATO and defense, green growth and sustainable development, G20 Washington Summit outcomes
Duration
~30 min
82nd percentile
Words
3,572
82nd percentile
Sentences
207
90th percentile
Readability
56
79th percentile
Grade
9.5
16th percentile
Syntax
2.81
23rd percentile
Vocabulary
2.04
15th percentile

Translated from French

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

207 sentences in 41 paragraphs

Ladies and Gentlemen,

Good morning. I would like to reiterate to Chancellor Angela MERKEL and the delegation she leads how pleased we have been, along with the Prime Minister and the ministers, to welcome them and to have this working morning before we continue, with the ministers among themselves around the Prime Minister at Matignon and the Chancellor and I for lunch, following what we have done in response to the financial crisis.

If Europe has been united, it is because Germany and France have worked together, worked together on the changes that we deemed necessary in the financial system, on the opportunity to secure the international Summit in Washington. I must also say that at the Washington Summit, Germany and France worked from the same roadmap to achieve the same results with the same determination.

What has occupied a large part of our work is, of course, the economic crisis we are experiencing—a global crisis to which we wish to respond swiftly and forcefully in the service of an appropriate economic recovery for each country based on its situation, and coordinated. I believe we have truly agreed on this point. Yes, measures are needed in response to the economic crisis to achieve new growth as quickly as possible. Yes, they need to be coordinated.

We also discussed in great depth the energy/climate package. I would like to thank the Chancellor for maintaining Germany's commitment to securing an agreement on the 3-20 and on the timeline, which I remind you were negotiated under the German Presidency. We are practically on the verge of an agreement regarding vehicles, without going into detail since the agreement is expected to be formalized on December 11 at the European Summit. And we are also making progress on the extremely complicated agreement of the energy/climate package between the position of the Commission, the position of the new Member States, and the position of major industrial countries like ours. But, well, the positions are converging, and I am hopeful that we will succeed.

Another point that was discussed: the Lisbon Treaty. Germany and France are on the same page: we want the Lisbon Treaty, new institutions for Europe. We will make every effort to secure the Lisbon Treaty. We have also agreed on a common language towards our Irish friends. One can sense that things are also starting to unlock a bit on that front. The excellent statement from Czech Prime Minister Mr. TOPOLANEK and Sweden's ratification decision are extremely positive elements.

Finally, we have made progress on the issue of defense with a high-level industrial group on defense industries, and we talked about the Franco-German brigade. We have in our sights, if I may say so, the preparation for the NATO Summit, which will be organized by both the Germans and the French with the new American administration. Here too, we want to continue the work that was initiated at the NATO Summit in Bucharest, where Germany and France had the same position, and that was decisive.

And then, finally, we have decided that both on European recovery and for the year 2009, France and Germany will focus on innovation and research. The two ministers have discussed this. We have received the report from Claude ALLEGRE, whom I thank again for his excellent work. We want to make Franco-German cooperation a priority. We want to put it at the service of innovation. Innovation also in sustainable development, green growth, and the new challenges that are posed.

We really want Germany and France to be leaders in this area, and we will ensure that, in the months and years to come, innovation and research, with very specific projects, universities, schools, and training of people will be at the heart of the Franco-German project. There is a real desire on our part to seize, if I may say so, the opportunity presented by the financial crisis, the economic crisis, and the environmental crisis to create the conditions for a new sustainable growth that will rely on technology, innovation in new production processes, and it is Germany and France that will be at the heart of this ambition.

These are the topics we have discussed. We are very aware, both Ms. MERKEL and I, of the particular responsibility of Germany and France to lead all of Europe on the path to unity. And that is what is at stake.

MS. ANGELA MERKEL - Thank you very much for the hospitality that has been extended to us. This introductory statement clearly shows that, in various areas, Germany and France are cooperating very closely with multiple very practical, concrete initiatives that bring our countries closer together. This is also demonstrated by the report from the secretaries general for Franco-German cooperation. In foreign policy, there is anyway a very close cooperation, and the same will apply in the responses to the serious economic crisis.

In the context of the financial market crisis, we have cooperated very closely. We have exchanges on the results because the situation in the banks, the situation regarding credit provision, cannot satisfy us. The state has intervened, but there is still much to convince the banks to do what we expect of them, namely to grant credits. We will also find a common response, certainly with different instruments, to emerge from the economic crisis.

On November 7, under the French Presidency, we decided that at the European Council in December, the Commission would formulate proposals. That is what the Commission is currently doing. I have emphasized that I am keen on a number of measures that do not cost money. If, for example, we treat small and medium-sized enterprises better, the Commission could achieve a result by relaxing the "de minimis" rules, which would allow us to improve investments and certain aids. Or, on the issue of competition rules in the area of high-speed networks, we could have a real boost in innovation in Europe if we benefit from a bit of flexibility.

There are therefore several measures that can be taken that do not cost money. But we also had an exchange on the measures that seem most appropriate to us, and it is clear that each country must make a contribution that is coherently articulated with a European response to economic problems.

We are a single market. We have a common growth strategy in Europe. It would be disastrous that in a period where there is no growth, there is no European response at that moment. I would like to take this opportunity to sincerely thank the French Presidency, particularly for having created all the possibilities to reach an agreement on the energy/climate package. Germany wants to support what was started at the time under the German Presidency and which should be concluded under the French Presidency, so that we can finalize the energy/climate package and have a clear signal for Copenhagen next year. But it is clear that this energy/climate aspect must not come at the expense of jobs. We must achieve the objectives in a way that reconciles climate protection and growth. I believe we had very fruitful exchanges on this subject. I am quite confident that we will succeed.

I am pleased that the theme of innovation has been a central element of the discussions among ministers. If we do something in Europe, if we want to arrive at a common response, we must modernize the continent, renovate it. We must seize the opportunities offered by the economic crisis. And here, we have a very broad agreement, a very wide agreement between our governments. I am particularly pleased about that. Thank you again for this hospitality, and I look forward to this good cooperation.

QUESTION - Madam Chancellor, what are the main divergences between France and Germany regarding a common economic recovery program or regarding the reduction of VAT across Europe?

MS. ANGELA MERKEL - I do not know why the question of divergences is always asked. First of all, today, we have focused on the common points in our discussions. Among these common points, I believe I can say, on our behalf, that a general reduction in VAT may be the answer for some countries, but it is not the right answer for France and Germany. We are in complete agreement on this point. We will have further discussions on how we can provide targeted assistance. Germany's package of measures is currently under review in Parliament. Germany has implemented such targeted measures, such as the suspension of the toll or tax relief for artisans. We have made a number of contributions, and I wish for us to wait for the effects of these measures.

The risk we face a little today is that, every day, and given information that is not always easy, we confuse action with haste. I believe there is a good chronology. The national measures as they have been decided, a coherent European approach, climate protection so that it does not cost jobs but that we can also reconcile economies, jobs, and the fight against global warming. Mr. STEINMEIER and I have agreed to evaluate with the German government at the beginning of January whether this is what we need. Has the situation changed? Is it new? That is what needs to be done, and of course, in close cooperation between Germany, France, and other European countries.

THE PRESIDENT - I believe that, on this matter, things are quite clear. On the financial crisis, we acted together. On the analysis of the severity of the economic situation, we made the same observation, which has already led Germany and France to take a number of measures—on our side, I want to mention the exemption from the business tax for all new investments and the creation of an intervention fund to support a number of companies. The third element is an economic toolbox, as we did with the financial toolbox, to give further impetus to growth. So, we agree on coordination. We agree on the need to take further measures. France is working on it. Germany is reflecting on it.

Regarding a general reduction in VAT, France shares Germany's analysis that this general reduction may perhaps be suitable for some countries—I think of our friends in the United Kingdom—but, as far as we are concerned, what do we observe? A decrease in prices. Should we implement a general VAT reduction when we observe a decrease in prices? Should we allocate the maneuvering margins we have to the reduction of prices, while the price decrease is occurring, or to what Angela and I just mentioned: investment, innovation, research, schools, education, training? I believe I can say, speaking under Angela MERKEL's oversight, that we are rather choosing that path. This does not mean that we judge what others do. They may have other ambitions, other demands. I am very attentive and very pleased with what the Chancellor said about what could be a targeted reduction, targeted assistance in certain sectors or a targeted reduction in other sectors. You see, we are discussing, we are looking. The situation is not easy. This is what France is working on and what Germany is working on. So, more convergences than divergences, much more.

QUESTION - My question concerns what we expect from the European Commission on Wednesday and the proposals. These proposals, according to some rumors, are estimated at 130 billion euros. Are these concretely the aids from each country that will be added together, or is it another envelope that would be released in the name of Europe of the 27?

MS. ANGELA MERKEL - As far as I know, it is something else. Are we saying that a certain incentive for investments by member states and by the Commission must be made? Here, we say that we need to have at least 1% of GDP. This is something that the Commission could propose, but that does not mean that these are additional funds coming from Brussels. Brussels can accelerate and can grant aids, stimulate investments. As I said, we can relax certain rules, and that does not cost money. On this, national measures are added. Ultimately, all this operates on the same market. It does not matter whether we act at the national level or at the European level, depending on European competencies. It will be a mix.

These 130 billion is in relation to the European GDP. But this is not a diktat from Brussels. It is an order of magnitude regarding what we could do, and Germany has already initiated a large part of these measures, and, as I said, we need to continue examining this. Every day, we have new economic forecasts. All the economic analysis institutes are changing their forecasts practically hour by hour, and we are in the process of approving our first set of measures.

THE PRESIDENT - We have worked with Mr. BARROSO on the plan that he will announce and propose on the 26th. And then, we must adopt it on the 11th and 12th. That is the procedure. We have worked with him. But this is not a plan that is separate from what the member states are doing. It is a plan that will only be adopted if it is accepted by all the member states. Naturally, we have worked together beforehand.

What seems interesting to me is the idea of saying that there is an order of magnitude around 1% or 1.5% of GDP. This clearly shows us that we need to do something. I want to reiterate my full support for what Mrs. MERKEL said about the initiatives we can take by raising the thresholds of "de minimis" or the threshold effects on the calculation of what constitutes an SME. We can do a lot without mobilizing money. The "de minimis" is very important for us, especially with the competitiveness clusters. There are many things we can do.

Coordination is not just a coordination between states. It is a coordination with what the Commission is doing, the analysis it can have of the exceptional circumstances of the application of the pact, and I think that in the very near future, the Chancellor and I will have the opportunity to take an initiative to clearly show that we are completely aligned in our analysis.

QUESTION - Madam Chancellor, Mr. President SARKOZY announced other joint measures to revive the economy, and he said: "France is working on it, and Germany is considering it." Could you tell us what Germany is considering? How long will Germany be considering it?

MRS. ANGELA MERKEL - Germany is working on these measures, as you know. The government has approved a number of measures. We are in parliamentary discussion. Then we will have a rather complicated mediation procedure with the Länder before Christmas. I have made it clear that when it comes to infrastructure investments or investments in public buildings, we must never forget in Germany the level of the Länder and municipalities.

In other words, what Germany is doing at the federal level is one thing, but what comes next, in addition, is from another level. I believe that, once again, the balance is perfect. We act and reflect in parallel. It is perfectly possible. So, of course, the coalition government will meet on this at the beginning of January and see if what we have done is conclusive. We still have a number of things to do. For example, the CO2 tax on vehicles, we need to finalize that, and it will be a process because no one can predict the outcome of the economic crisis definitively. Anyone who claims otherwise is telling stories. We will still have many common exchanges, both on our reflections and on our actions.

THE PRESIDENT - I do not want any trouble with the German press. But if I had said: France is considering and Germany is working, I am not sure that would have been viewed more favorably! You need to understand something: our organizations are not the same. On one side, there is a federal country, and on the other side, a country that is more centralized. It is perfectly easy to understand. When we talk with the German government, there is the whole importance of the Länder, of local authorities. Each has its own decision-making pace and its own organizational problems to overcome. Nevertheless, our analysis remains the same. I add that, for France, we will wait for the proposals from the Commission, even if we have a fairly precise idea of what they will be. We will try to lend our voice, our strength to the revival of the European economy and the global economy.

I add one last point. We are really determined, Mrs. MERKEL and I, the German government, the French government, Mr. François FILLON, to ensure that the decisions from Washington are truly operational by the end of March and in April. We did not go to Washington just to talk. We went there to achieve results. This is very important; Christine LAGARDE knows this, as these are instructions that have been given to the finance ministers for the summit. I hope it will take place in London, at the end of March or the beginning of April, so that we can achieve results. I must say that the Chancellor fought to ensure that the term "hedge funds" appears in the text so that new rules are applied to tax havens. This is also a whole collaborative effort between the French, the Germans, and our European partners.

QUESTION - Double question. On the automotive plan, have you discussed coordination with the Italians and all Europeans to support the automotive industry in a coordinated manner that does not affect competition? And secondly, what is your analysis of the risk of deflation?

MRS. ANGELA MERKEL - In any case, we do not want measures that undermine competition. That is why we need a European framework, and we cannot simply subsidize the industry where, on the American continent, we see various activities being deployed to support the American automotive industry. Europe must see what is happening there in order to react appropriately because I cannot imagine that, in the end, it will be the least environmentally friendly cars that fare better due to a distortion of competition than the most modern and green cars. Europe will have to react to this, so we need to wait a bit to see what our reaction will be since, for now, we do not know all the measures that will be taken. We are in a situation where the news is difficult, but we should not always highlight the greatest risks.

During the summer, we talked about the highest inflation we have ever known. Now, we are talking about the opposite of inflation. We are doing everything to support the economy and to act on the psychological front, so that the most negative announcements do not come true, and we want to contribute to that in everything we do.

THE PRESIDENT - What is certain is that we will not let the automotive industry fall; this is a constant in Europe. I remind you that for France, the automotive industry, along with dealerships, represents 10% of the active population. So, 10%, we will not let them fall. I understood, by the way, that in Germany, there was exactly the same political will.

So then, how do we avoid disturbing the rules of competition? Perhaps we can also think about fiscal measures, maybe targeted measures. We will see. But our will is to help the automotive industry. As far as France is concerned, that is what we have decided to do - isn't that right, Jean-Louis BORLOO? - regarding electric motors and clean vehicles, with the bonus. But we cannot have, on one side, the Americans who are rolling out a plan of 25 billion dollars, as of the latest news, for exceptional interest rate loans to their three manufacturers, and us, finding ourselves in a situation where a state aid regime would prevent us from helping our European car manufacturers while at the same time imposing additional obligations on them to produce clean vehicles, with other parts of the world - I do not criticize them - that are helping them. The will to help the European industry, especially the automotive industry, is total. This is a point that brings us completely closer.

So, do we coordinate it? Look at CO2; that is what we are doing, in particular. Of course, this is difficult; I will not lie. In Germany, we do not build exactly the same vehicles as in France. But these are industries. What do we want, Mrs. MERKEL and I? To keep industries in Europe. I do not believe that a modern economy is one that solely bets on finance and services. The European countries that chose finance and services 30 years ago, look at the situation they are in today.

Our ambition is industrial - Germans and French. There are others who are behind us, the Italians... But that is our will: to defend European industry. To defend it by putting up protectionist barriers, we are for free trade; but to defend it by helping it through innovation, research, and technology. But that is yet another common point between the Germans and the French; we support our industry.

Listen, that is a good conclusion.

Thank you all.