Letter of mission from Mr. Nicolas Sarkozy, President of the Republic, addressed to Professor Jacques Marescaux, on the development of a new model for university hospitals, November 24, 2008.

France Nicolas Sarkozy · President of France

24 November 2008

Context
Sarkozy addressed Professor Jacques Marescaux in a formal letter of mission commissioning a reform proposal for France's university hospital centers (CHUs) in November 2008.
Main themes
University hospital reform, CHU governance, care, teaching and research missions, financial deficits and funding, research output assessment, medical career management, hospital-industry partnerships, excellence model, hospital attractiveness
Duration
~5 min
18th percentile
Words
655
18th percentile
Sentences
36
22nd percentile
Readability
37
29th percentile
Grade
12.7
53rd percentile
Syntax
2.76
18th percentile
Vocabulary
2.33
80th percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 42%42%
  • Social 33%33%
  • Economic 17%17%
  • Ceremonial 8%8%
  • Geopolitical 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

36 sentences in 12 paragraphs

Professor,

The university hospital centers (CHU) are fifty years old. In 1958, a small group of hospital physicians, among the best of their time, gathered around Professor Robert DEBRE, developed the content of a reform that was to give birth to the CHU. The ordinance of December 30, 1958, by creating full-time hospital positions, permanently structured the hospital and gave prestige to university hospital medicine.

The thirty-one CHUs have a triple mission of care, teaching, and research. Several signs indicate that their model is now in crisis. These institutions, each employing several thousand staff and housing several thousand beds, almost all report an operating deficit. A significant portion of their resources is devoted to primary care at the expense of specialized care. The teaching mission, in a context of continuous increase in the numerus clausus in recent years, also places a heavy burden on the CHUs, whose functioning sometimes excessively depends on medical interns alone. Under these conditions, research becomes a variable of adjustment in the activities of the departments. In fact, the disparities in research output between CHUs are very significant. In reality, it has become very difficult for a hospital practitioner to simultaneously and equally engage in care, teaching, and research activities.

All these difficulties stem from the peculiarities of the governance of the CHUs, which juxtaposes without making a real choice the logic of the university and the logic of the hospital. Under these conditions, the CHUs are at risk of losing their attractiveness to the best students and medical interns in a lasting way.

In 1958, the institution of full-time positions made the hospital attractive. Today, full-time is no longer sufficient for the prestige of the CHUs. New attributes must be found for them, in line with our times, so that these institutions continue to attract the best and produce care, teaching, and research of excellence.

I wish to entrust you with the mission of proposing a new model for the CHUs based on excellence. Your work should focus on the various aspects of a reform that I expect to be as ambitious and pioneering as the "DEBRE" ordinance of 1958.

You will first focus on producing an assessment of the scientific output of the research teams in the CHUs. This assessment must be shared and indisputable. You will examine the funding circuits, distinguishing the flows related to research, teaching, specialized care, and primary care. You will study the traceability of financial flows, from health insurance funds to the final beneficiary within the CHU. You will consider the possibility of adapting the pricing of care related to high-technology medical or surgical practices. The conditions for developing partnerships between the CHUs and companies, particularly in the health industries, should also receive your attention. Any potential legal difficulties in this area must be identified so that responses can be provided. You will propose improvements in the management of practitioners' careers to facilitate the joint exercise of one or more missions under realistic modalities. The contract and mobility must be at the heart of your reflections on human resource management. Finally, you will analyze the performance of the organization and management of the institutions today and formalize different scenarios for evolution both in the relationships between CHUs and within them.

To fulfill your mission, you will chair a commission composed of political, scientific, medical, managerial, industrial, and institutional personalities. This commission will itself set up working groups on the various themes I ask you to address.

You will benefit in your work from the support of the ministries of health and research.

Please submit your proposals to me by the end of March 2009. You will provide me with a progress report at mid-term at the beginning of February.

I thank you for accepting this mission, which I hope will be a decisive contribution to the sustainable strengthening of our country's research and innovation capacities.

Please accept, Professor, the assurance of my best sentiments.