Statement by Mr. Nicolas Sarkozy, President of the Republic, on local authorities in the face of the economic and financial crisis, the new distribution of public services across the territory, the reform of territorial organization, the professional tax, parity and dialogue in the public service, and the future of the Post Office, in Paris on November 27, 2008.

France Nicolas Sarkozy · President of France

27 November 2008 · Congress of the Association of Mayors of France (Congrès des maires de France)

Context
Sarkozy addressed the Congress of the Association of French Mayors in Paris on November 27, 2008, discussing the financial crisis and local governance reforms.
Main themes
Global financial crisis, local authorities and municipalities, territorial reform, public services distribution, professional tax reform, state-municipality financial relations, Dexia bank rescue, economic governance, parity and public service dialogue, postal service reform
Duration
~55 min
95th percentile
Words
6,638
95th percentile
Sentences
347
96th percentile
Readability
60
88th percentile
Grade
9.5
16th percentile
Syntax
2.87
30th percentile
Vocabulary
2.00
10th percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 49%47%
  • Economic 33%31%
  • Ceremonial 9%9%
  • Social 6%6%
  • Geopolitical 3%3%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 4%

347 sentences in 66 paragraphs

Mr. President,

Dear Jacques PELISSARD,

First of all, congratulations on your election. This is an opportunity for me to reaffirm my trust and friendship.

Congratulations to all the newly elected officials for whom this is their first congress. Even warmer congratulations to all those re-elected because while elected officials may say it was very difficult to be elected, re-elected officials know that fighting against voter fatigue and the demands of their constituents is not the easiest thing.

I am fully aware that your association's congress has expressed a lot of concern. If you allow me, I will speak freely, without a speech, to share my thoughts both on the conclusions and the emotions you have all expressed. And at the same time, I want to tell you that this is an appointment of yours that I know well, one I have often participated in, and I cannot imagine that a President of the Republic could exempt himself from hearing what mayors from all political trends and all regions have to say.

Listening to you, dear André LAIGNEL, and to you, dear Jacques, I was thinking: in essence, I am exactly in the same situation as the mayors in the room when they gather their constituents in their municipality. They come saying: "I am doing my best." The constituents say: "We expect more, we want more, and preferably at a lower cost." All of you in the room, whether from the north or the south, the east or the west, from the left, the center, the right, rural or urban, all of you have experience of these meetings. Because all voters say the same thing: "We want more services, we want more investments, we want more housing and less density. We want lower taxes and more services." I do not take any of your requests lightly, and I will explain myself before you.

But if I take stock, and even if the motion that André LAIGNEL just read is very reasonable: you want a fair tax system. Have you ever seen an AMF congress asking for an unfair tax system? You want a better balance between the burdens that the State places on you and what you receive in transfers. Has there been a single congress in the last 25 years, just one, regardless of the government or the majority, that has omitted this point, Jacques?

I will be very honest with what you say, and I will go to the end to ensure that things are clear between us and that at least there is no feeling that I am disrespecting you by subjecting you to one of those interminable speeches that start with half an hour praising the role of mayor, often by referencing one's own career to better evade the answers you expect to the concrete questions you have raised.

But for 25 years, everyone has said this. Why? What is happening in our country? Where do we stand today? We are in a situation where we came very close to catastrophe: a financial crisis that we have not seen in a century. To find a situation this grave, we must refer to the great crisis of 1929. The financial system suddenly found itself paralyzed—and this concerns you mayors. I did not see this in the motion, but if the State had not done its duty to save Dexia, it would have been 15,000 municipalities in France that had taken out loans from Dexia that would have found themselves in total distress. That too needed to be said. It was the State that came to save Dexia. It was the State that bought Dexia. It was the French State, the Belgian State, the Luxembourg State.

Why did I do this, that night, at four-thirty in the morning when I was told: "We need to mobilize billions of euros to save this bank, before 8 a.m. the next morning, because the stock markets open."? 15,000, do you hear me, 15,000 municipalities in France, there must be some in the room, mayors? There must be some who thought when they heard that Dexia was threatened: "What is going to happen?" Because we committed ourselves, we had to mobilize the money to save this bank. At that moment, who could I turn to? No one. Today, this bank is saved. We came very close to catastrophe. Not with a crisis that started, as I hear it said, in August 2007, that is not true! From August 2007, we had a classic crisis. On September 18, 2008, we entered a systemic crisis, for one reason and one reason only: because the world's leading economic power thought it could let a bank fail, Lehman Brothers in this case. And the entire world, astonished, discovered on September 18, 2008, that a bank could go bankrupt.

Ladies and gentlemen, I ask you to understand that at that moment, the world entered a new era. Trust disappeared. From a culture of risk at all costs, we moved to a total absence of risk-taking. The world then entered a systemic crisis that shook all the fundamentals of the international financial system.

I do not say this to exempt myself from any responsibility. Just as the mayor is responsible for everything in his municipality, including the harvests and the bad weather, the President of the Republic is in a way the mayor of the country. In essence, it is not abnormal that he is a responsible party since, in any case, one is needed.

But I want to share the situation with you so that everyone understands where we stand. At that moment, it was necessary to mobilize in 4 days the equivalent of 2,000 billion euros to prevent Europe from sinking, with entire countries, like Iceland, on the brink of bankruptcy—with the idea that a number of us had, to prevent seeing in front of the banking establishments in your municipalities the line of savers coming to withdraw their savings to avoid being robbed. That is what we had to do.

There are those who tell me: you found the money to save the banks, why can't you find the money to help us? I say: it is not the banks we saved, it is your savings, it is your businesses, to prevent the system from collapsing. Anyone in my position would have been led to do the same thing. A bank going bankrupt in the United States and it is a systemic crisis worldwide. Imagine, ladies and gentlemen, if we had let a bank in France or a bank in Europe fail? Since then, it has been necessary to prevent the bankruptcy of entire countries: Hungary, Ukraine, perhaps the Baltic States one day, to try to restart the system. Today, let us state things as they are: the financial situation is not worsening, but we are in an economic crisis. For the same price, we therefore have two crises. A major financial crisis that is roughly stabilized, and a large-scale economic crisis of which I want to say a word, because naturally it concerns the municipalities, the local authorities.

One word, however, to conclude regarding the financial crisis. If you compare what has been done on one side of the Atlantic and the other, I think we can be proud of what Europe has done. Europe, it is fashionable to criticize it—as a classic. We can still be pleased because the United States is on its third plan without having found the solution. As for Europe, we were able to find a European response to the financial crisis.

Of course, a number of you are having problems today renegotiating new loans, but at least regarding your main bank, it is saved. We can also ask—it's not me who is responsible for this either—how it is that the Crédit Local de France found the means for a subsidiary in the United States to take out subprime loans on a large scale? It is not clear what the accounting was between the objective of the Crédit Local de France, a subsidiary of Dexia, and risky investments in the United States?

Honestly, at some point, those responsible will have to explain themselves and a number of consequences must be drawn. It is all well and good to find that the State's signature is very useful when there is nothing left and everything is collapsing. But it will also be necessary that all those who were subscribed to bonuses are not absent from the distribution of penalties. It is not a matter of holding a grudge against anyone. It is not about doing, as they say in popular language, the crime of having a sour face, to put it mildly—but it is still a matter that those who led us here assume responsibility, including financial responsibility.

We are now facing an economic crisis whose duration we do not know, which is severe for all sectors and very severe for certain sectors. I am thinking particularly of the automotive industry, which concerns a number of your territories and which, believe it or not, involves 10% of the French active population. 10% of the French active population works directly or indirectly in the automotive sector!

My absolute conviction is that in the face of this crisis, we cannot remain idle—that old ideas, that old rules are not suited to a crisis that is new in its origin and in its unfolding.

I will have the opportunity by the beginning of December, in a few days, to announce a recovery plan that I wish to be ambitious for two reasons. The first is that I am convinced that from this crisis, we can turn it into an opportunity if France decides to accelerate its modernization and its competitiveness gap. Because the crisis that causes the upheaval allows us to seek new ideas and take new initiatives. It is an opportunity for our country to bounce back. You know, in a crisis, there are two strategies: either we wait thinking that the sky will fall on our heads—or we take multiple initiatives to catch up on our delay in universities, research, innovation, competitiveness, and infrastructure.

Allow me to take just one example, it is France that carries the idea of creating the European Assembly. In 1979 at that time, we were not talking about the European Parliament and it was France that fought for Strasbourg to be the capital of Europe with the European Parliament. Well, thirty years after France obtained the installation of the European Parliament in Strasbourg and thirty years after France practically fought for Strasbourg, the European capital, I note that the TGV still did not arrive in Strasbourg. Here is a perfect example of French incoherence. We make the decision that Strasbourg is a European capital, we propose the creation of a European assembly and we do not give ourselves the means to ensure that the high-speed train connects the capital of Europe and Alsace to the capital of France.

Let me tell you, my dear André, with all the friendship I have for you, that over the last thirty years, if my political history is correct, it is not all my fault. Which does not exempt me in any way, since it happens that I am the President of the Republic.

That is what I would like to catch up on, thinking that since no country will meet the criteria. And I turn, by the way, to those who campaigned during the presidential election on the need to reduce debt, on the need to reduce the deficit, and that this does not prevent signing the mayors' motion saying no closures, no reorganization of maps, no reduction in allocations, no reduction in the number of civil servants, but at the same time, reducing debt and the deficit. You will explain to me how we do that when we are in a situation?

I do not blame anyone. I say this to assume my responsibilities, but I cannot assume them alone. When André says—and he is right: "We do not reform France against local elected officials." You are a thousand times right, and I could have signed the motion of the Congress. But in the same way, let things be clear: I cannot be solely responsible for everyone. Everyone must take their share of responsibility regarding public spending, which is far too heavy in our country, because it weighs on employment, because we are in a European and globalization context that puts all your territories in competition, all your businesses in competition, and if we continue, then we will continue the process of delocalization that is killing our territories. That is an unavoidable appointment. So how are we going to do it? The recovery plan? Yes, I sign with both hands, Jacques. There needs to be a local authorities component because 75% of investments come from local authorities.

But I will go further; we will work on credit because I know perfectly well that the banks that yesterday found all the money available to finance the Internet bubble in any way, the real estate bubble in any way, the speculation bubble in any way - the same ones that lent to anyone - today refuse to lend £ and I cannot accept that. There are files of 3000 euros on the desk of the credit mediator. Who are we kidding? This is unacceptable because it is not the 3000 euros of the craftsman or the household that jeopardizes the financial situation of banks that have lent - for some, not for all, but for some - under any conditions. Therefore, there will be, in the recovery plan, a section for local authorities, a section for access to credit.

But I want us to go further, particularly on this French ailment of the accumulation of outdated regulations. I think we need to raise the threshold below which we are obliged to issue calls for tenders that cost a ridiculous amount of money. There is a community rule, Jacques, I believe it should be from 5 million euros. We have a French rule that is around 200,000 euros. There is certainly a balance to be found. I do not want to favor anyone £ but, after all, these calls for tenders, which are mountains of paperwork and are necessary for competition, mean that even the smallest investment takes months before it can be initiated.

So, in the recovery plan, I ask the Government - I will do it - for a section that will allow us to be exempted for a limited time - if you want with a commission that will follow this - from the rules that, today - we must recognize - exasperate those in charge, paralyze initiative, and reward those among us, who are sometimes very numerous, who do not want to take any risks, who are followers while France needs people who take risks, who undertake and who assume their responsibilities. I think this is as important for the recovery plan as anything else.

I will also fight, dear Jacques, for us to raise the de minimis level at the European level - you were absolutely right, André, on this point too. You know, I say this for the new elected officials, the de minimis is the level above which we are not allowed to make tax and social exemptions. This, by the way, harms our competitiveness clusters. It also influences the thresholds for defining SMEs and a number of rules. I want local authorities to be able, in their calls for tenders, not to have only the religion of price £ but to be able to give a share to small and medium-sized enterprises, to local companies, to companies that commit not to relocate, to companies that are environmentally responsible. In short, I think that when we make a call for tenders, we should not limit ourselves to a price analysis ignoring the quality-price analysis.

Therefore, in the recovery plan, both on access to credit and on a number of other things, we will make room for local authorities. There is a whole set - I am aware of this, Jacques - of files, roads, developments, buildings to be renovated, energy savings to be made, zero-interest loans that can be significantly boosted and that will provide work for our companies that need it very much, extremely quickly, and will also allow you to satisfy the population.

I would also like to say a word about something that concerns you and which I readily acknowledge is a thorn in my side, which is the problem of rurality. Why, after all, for thirty years, has our country been unable to define a modern land use policy? What is happening? Everyone says, - and I speak under the control of Hubert who fights with the qualities that are his: "We need to do land use planning." But I never see - aside from the more, always more - what a land use policy adapted to a rurality that has changed a lot in the last ten years can represent in terms of content.

We had a land use policy twenty years ago for territories that were dying because they were losing their population. I apologize, Ladies and Gentlemen, I speak very freely, after all, I was elected, I have a job to do and above all I must be frank. Twenty years ago, the land use policy was: to accompany territories that were emptying of their population. We were accompanying them towards death. Just one more minute, Mr. Executioner. Rurality has changed a lot because for the last ten years, on the contrary, not only has it stopped losing population, which is good news, but it is gaining population. And it is true that at the central level of the State, we have not taken this major change into account. The land use policy should not be made for territories that are emptying of their population but, on the contrary, for territories that are gaining population £ and therein lies the key to our inability until now, mine included - let things be clear - to define a land use policy adapted to today's reality. For me, this is an absolutely major task, Jacques, for 2009. I readily acknowledge that in terms of concepts, I have not done better than my predecessors. I remind you that I have only been here for eighteen months, even if for some it may seem longer than for others.

In any case, yes, this is the first strong message I take from your congress. We can no longer wait; we need to build a land use policy adapted to this new reality of rurality. Not everything is done only for the city, only for the big cities; we must think of the approximately 40% of the population who live there and who are increasing, and I will propose, Jacques, that we involve the AMF in this action. In any case, I set myself a goal: before March, we need to agree on an ambitious policy.

This allows me to address a contentious issue: the various geographical maps: hospital reform, military reform, judicial reform. I want to be very honest with you. Everyone, in all political parties, knew perfectly well that we had a problem with the judicial map, a problem with the hospital map, a problem with the military map. There is not a single person who will tell you otherwise. I am not saying that we did well, and naturally there are certain territories that may feel unjustly treated. But let's be clear, the defense budget is the second budget of the nation. Our military map corresponds to a time when we had military service. I did not abolish military service. There would be many things to say about that, frankly many things to say. It doesn't matter; we have a professional army. How do you want me, as the head of the armed forces and head of state, to maintain the same military map for a nation that has transitioned from conscription to a professional army? It is impossible.

But I will ensure that your concerns are taken into account since the State has decided that for the land released by the army, those that have market value, we will transfer them to the municipalities, asking for a clause of association for the State when the municipality has made a profit from the operation, either with offices or with housing that it has developed. This is a revolution. There are mayors here who are in municipalities where, fifteen years ago, the State decided to close a base and who still do not have ownership of the released land that has remained a shameful wasteland in a territory that, moreover, needed housing, offices, or industrial activity. The government will give these lands, will refrain from imposing any rules because it is up to the elected officials of the municipality to decide what they want to do with them, and will simply ask to be associated with the project that will be carried out.

Ladies and Gentlemen, I would like to say that this is unprecedented. And it is a testimony of trust for the elected officials that you are. The hospital map, we will have to face it. I am not worried because I know it is brutal when a maternity ward closes, but when we have such a need for facilities for long stays, for medium stays, for Alzheimer’s, for the extension of life expectancy, I believe that we could, in full consultation, together do what is necessary.

On the judicial map, just a word. Proximity justice is not about having a court within five minutes of your home; it is about having a judge who renders a decision in a timely manner £ and if possible a decision that is understandable. Since 1958, it had not changed. Fifty years! Fifty years, so listen, put yourself in my shoes: how to ensure, with less tax revenue, more expenses, and the crisis? And I do not touch the military map. I do not touch the judicial map. I do not touch the hospital map. At the same time, everyone tells me we need more money for Alzheimer’s, more money for cancer, more money for this, more money for that. It is not possible. I take responsibility.

So, what is true, and I want to take another step towards you: I need your help to change this. It is this second French disease of uniformity. Our territories are different, and in the name of equality, we should accept diversity while in the name of equality we create uniformity. This can no longer continue. I will take a number of examples to address a contentious issue, if I understood correctly, related to education. It is true that we cannot demand the same service obligation from a mayor of a rural municipality who does not even have an employee with the BAFA among his collaborators and - not to target anyone - from the mayor of the capital of France or a large city of one or two million inhabitants. I understand this perfectly, and we should be able to find an agreement, including on what André spoke about, the referrals that have been made to sanction this or that mayor.

I will speak to you without any caution. You know, before arriving, I was told: "Talk about everything but not about this. They are angry!" Listen, that is not me and it is not you because not talking about contentious issues is to be a coward, and it is cowardly not to respect the people who listen to you and watch you. I will talk to you about it.

On this issue, excuse me, I fully understand the feeling of injustice that a mayor may have when dragged before the administrative court by his prefect because he has few resources, has done his best, and has not succeeded. I am completely ready to review this. But what I do not accept - and I say this to elected officials from both the left and the right because it may happen to you one day to be in power - what I do not accept is that an elected official of the Republic says that he will not apply the law of the Republic. No one is above the laws. No one.

So, I make a distinction, and I say this, Mr. President, between the one who, in good faith, says: "I can't do anything about it; you are not going to blame me for that. I can't do it" and the one for whom it is a militant act of contesting the law. We cannot treat these two categories of elected officials the same way. I say this very simply. I will therefore take initiatives to go in your direction.

But I will go further. Believe me, I am speaking to people; I too dreamed of being elected, I too fought to be elected, I fully understand the frustration and at the same time the appetite one can have to do things. I will go further. Diversity may be the way that will lead us to solve a problem that has never been resolved for decades, which is the problem of territorial levels.

I have 35 years of political life behind me. I have never uttered a word to say that there are too many municipalities in France. Never. Because I believe that the specificity of the quality of life and the quality of French democracy is the irreplaceable network of municipalities and the brave people who - for nothing - agree to be on a municipal council.

Perhaps in high technocracy, it can be thought that these are burdens; I believe, on the contrary, that it is a wealth for our country, and that is why, dear André, I am myself very reluctant to the idea of universal suffrage for the election of community elected officials. Because at that moment, you will undermine the municipalities at the base because you will find yourself in a conflict of legitimacy.

I tell you. I respect those who think differently from me, but do not come to tell me that we protect the municipalities and that we want the municipality to be the base because if you elect the community of municipalities by universal suffrage, excuse me, there will be a conflict of legitimacy between the one who is elected in the municipality and the one who is elected in the intercommunal structure £ and there will no longer be a mayor in each of the municipalities. There will no longer be one; that is not true. We can wish for it, but do not come to tell me that we must protect the municipalities, that it is an irreplaceable geographical constituency by opposing it to another legitimacy elected under the same conditions.

That said, I call upon your sense of responsibility: can we continue? Municipalities, communities of municipalities, countries, departments, regions, the State, Europe. Who can tell me that France can continue under these conditions? It is unthinkable. No one understands anything anymore, no one finds their way. Moreover, everyone knows perfectly well that between departments and regions, it does not work. I have also been president of a general council; I know perfectly well that as soon as one is elected at the departmental level, one locks oneself into that departmental dimension and tells the other: "don't worry about that, it's our business." And often, by the way, we do it because while departments have historical legitimacy, regions have economic legitimacy.

So, we need to find a way out. And I have set myself a challenge, Madam Minister of the Interior, a reasonable one. It is to make my five-year term something useful for our country, and if possible, not to change my mind between what I thought before the elections and what I think after. Uniqueness, it's true! To avoid being unpleasant, I won't cite examples, but I also want things to be clear with you.

My idea is therefore the following, and let’s speak without caution. I think we need to give ourselves six months, at least until spring, to see if by some miracle in our country we could reach a consensus. Not a total consensus, André, but a consensus to say that immobility is not a solution.

Because when I am told that it is just a question of the distribution of competencies... Yes and no. Because everyone will fight tooth and nail to keep their competencies, and everyone will see the competency that is taken away from them as a humiliation they will feel. It is not simply a question of reforming local taxation. I hear talk of reforming local taxation.

So we need to go further. My idea is the following: around the notion of diversity, is it absolutely necessary that all regions of France be organized in the same way? I do not think so. I take an example: there are two "Normandies." We love them, but do we need two? In Alsace, there are a number of friends who have long thought that we should organize differently. Do you really believe that France has no choice but between total immobility on one side or complete change on the other? And what if we thought about diversity, about voluntarism, about experimentation? Would our country be stronger or weaker? I believe we need to introduce flexibility into this. The word flexibility in your motion has been included. I think you are right. The idea is therefore the following: let’s think, first, should we create a status for large urban areas? Undoubtedly, the problem arises. We have many departments, many municipalities, many regions, but too few urban areas.

Secondly, should we - which I think - encourage an experimental and voluntary movement to merge a number of regions that would wish to do so? Why refuse this chance? I am not from the camp of departmentalists against regionalists or regionalists against departmentalists. Can we not allow a movement of rapprochement between regions to happen on the basis of voluntarism, of debate among themselves because they believe that together they are stronger than alone? Listen, I will take another example, Brittany: four magnificent departments. I go to Nantes. I am told: "here, magnificent, here is the capital of Brittany." Oh really? But we are in Pays de la Loire? Okay, we can talk about history. We can do a lot. I am not trying to redraw the map; I am trying to make a country reflect on a problem that has been stuck for too long, and I believe we can think in a win-win system.

It is the same for departments and regions. Should we hesitate between total immobility, which we can see poses a considerable problem for our country's competitiveness, and the change that would lead to the elimination of departments? What no living person will manage to do because departmental identity in a large number of our regions, especially for rural departments, matters. I am not talking about my region, the Paris region, where we are very attached to departments... even though it only dates back to 1967!

But can we not imagine a new organization, keeping the canton? Between the department and the region, we would require both local authorities to work together. In short, there are many formulas that are possible.

In any case, my idea is primarily the work of the BALLADUR Commission, dialogue with parliamentarians, dialogue with associations of elected officials, a meeting in spring 2009. We will see if there are lines of consensus, and at that moment, we will try to think about what a new French territorial organization could be.

Ladies and gentlemen, if we do this, we are living up to our responsibilities, and I come to the professional tax because the problem arises. Why is the question of structural relief being raised? It is to eliminate taxes, not to create new ones. I take an example; I spoke about the automobile industry earlier, the Sandouville factory. When the Sandouville factory produces, at 100%, 300,000 vehicles per year, the professional tax weighs in at 50 euros per vehicle produced. Sandouville today produces at 40%, but the professional tax does not decrease. The professional tax today at Sandouville is 125 euros per vehicle. I will not allow Sandouville to close; I will not allow other automotive industries to relocate because we need industrial production on our territory and not just elsewhere. But we are the only ones with the professional tax. Can we continue like this?

Everyone can see that this problem is being raised. Of course, many ministers have reformed. The first - I believe it was Dominique STRAUSS-KAHN - did something very good. But what has it led to, ladies and gentlemen? That a third of the revenues from the professional tax is now paid by the State! This means that we now have a system where you can increase the professional tax, companies do not feel it, you do not feel it, but it is the State budget that contributes. It is not possible to continue like this. I say this all the more because I am fully aware that we cannot cut municipalities off from an economic tax, because if you do not involve municipalities in the economic fabric, you will not have a single municipality that will accept offices or a factory on its territory, because there will be no interest. The day there are only public gardens, where will we go to work, and where will we find jobs for your children?

So here are the challenges. I am determined to tackle this. I am not just determined to talk about it. I set a goal. I set a deadline, and I warn you. The professional tax since 1976, everyone talks about it, everyone denounces it, no one modifies it, and France continues to accumulate delays. Here is another challenge for 2009.

I would like to conclude with three topics. The first topic, parity and dialogue in the public service. Listen, I want to put an end to this situation where you are employers who are never asked for your opinion. There is no dialogue in the public service. There is an impression of dialogue, there is the formulation of dialogue, but there is no dialogue. There is no dialogue because you are never consulted on the status, because you are never consulted on increases, because you are never consulted on indices, and because when you are not satisfied with a collaborator, it is not you who can decide to part ways. Where is the dialogue? As for the dialogue between the State and the public service, allow me to say that it is very insufficient. How do you expect to dialogue with five million people? For a simple reason, it is that they are the same organizations, regardless of the public service: State public service, territorial public service, hospital public service.

All the reform that Eric WOERTH and André SANTINI are undertaking aims to try to introduce freedom into the system so that there can indeed be dialogue and that you, the employers, have your say. It must be noted that today a mayor is an employer who does not have a say. I would therefore like, André, speaking of parity, that we do not forget that parity is not just about the trade union organizations, for which I have the utmost respect and which we need; it is also about the employer that elected officials represent, who must be able to have their say. And there would be many other things to say, such as about merit, for example.

The second topic: the Post Office. I look at things. I am the one who asked that we take the time before taking any initiative regarding the Post Office. Immediately, by the way, it was said: "he is retreating." Because I have the choice, as I hear some commentators say, between being "stubborn" or "lacking courage." If I continue, I am stubborn. If I stop, I am retreating.

Why did I ask that we take a little time? First of all, because the Post Office is the quintessence of public service and that in a certain way, with the Post Office points, the Post Office has done remarkable work, remarkable work with rural commerce, very modern work. Certainly, but I will only change the status of the Post Office when I understand what this money would be used for.

But at the same time, I look at the postal services in Europe. There are two postal services that are 100% public: in France and Luxembourg. All the others have been, at one time or another, opened to the private sector, and this has yielded good results for the German post, which is now the owner of DHL. Nevertheless, I am obliged to look at the world as it is!

What is the characteristic of the world as it is? It needs logistics. In the world as it is, everyone wants to be able to consume products that are made at the other end of the world. So if there is a profession that has a lot of future, it is logistics. What have our German friends done? They changed the Post Office because they understood that with the Internet there would be fewer and fewer paper letters but that there would be more and more parcels to transport. That is the challenge, and it is in this context and only in this context that we will go, Jacques, for the modernization of the Post Office. It is true that we really needed time, but I am fully aware of this need.

Finally, thirdly, the whole question of public service. I remain convinced that we will not get out of this, dear Michèle, by discussing administration by administration and that you need to step up to the plate with the prefects to have a discussion at the departmental level about the map of public services as a whole. What territories cannot stand is that at the same time we close the hospital, the court, the police station, and threaten the sub-prefecture. The city that sees its hospital develop can make an effort on its court. The city that sees its court leave, well, we should not ask it to make an effort on its barracks. In short, I want a global discussion, I would say inter-ministerial at the departmental level, dear Michèle. This is a mission I entrust to you with Hubert FALCO so that we can carry out operations of this nature.

Finally, I apologize for having been far too long - but I wanted to speak to you from the heart, with my convictions, with what I would say is the love I have for politics, for debate - the situation, I know, is not easy for each of you. I ask you to believe that when you are the head of State, in these circumstances, it is not easy either.

I will take the motion that André read; I will meet with the bureau of the AMF next week with the relevant ministers, including the Minister of Education. Honesty compels me to tell you that he was that day the President of the Council of Ministers of Education in Europe - since he is holding the presidency - in Bordeaux. And we will get to work together. I promise you, and I promise you, Jacques, that I will be an honest and good-faith interlocutor but frank, like you.

Ladies and gentlemen, I thank you for your patience and your attention.