Statement by Mr. Nicolas Sarkozy, President of the Republic, on the renewal of European innovation policy, in Paris on December 9, 2008.

France Nicolas Sarkozy · President of France

9 December 2008 · Paris, France

Context
Sarkozy addressed ministers and elected officials in Paris to launch the European Innovation Area initiative under the French EU Presidency on December 9, 2008.
Main themes
European innovation policy, economic crisis as opportunity for reform, knowledge-research-society bridges, Bologna Process legacy, European Higher Education and Research Area, technological and industrial innovation, cross-partisan cooperation, Europe's competitiveness gap with the United States, French EU Presidency agenda
Duration
~37 min
88th percentile
Words
4,425
88th percentile
Sentences
229
92nd percentile
Readability
49
59th percentile
Grade
11.2
35th percentile
Syntax
2.90
34th percentile
Vocabulary
2.16
39th percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 38%38%
  • Institutional 29%29%
  • Social 14%14%
  • Ceremonial 7%7%
  • Geopolitical 6%6%
  • Technological 5%5%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

229 sentences in 53 paragraphs

Ladies and Gentlemen Ministers,

Ladies and Gentlemen elected officials,

Dear Claude Allègre, I could have placed you in the other categories as well,

Ladies and Gentlemen,

The world and Europe are going through an unprecedented crisis in terms of its violence, depth, and absolutely unprecedented nature.

In the face of the crisis, there is the understandable temptation to focus solely on the short term, solely on the urgent. And indeed, just settling for the urgent is already a full-time job.

In the face of the crisis, there is the temptation to forget the future because the present oppresses us.

In the face of the crisis, there is the temptation to say, "let's deal with the most pressing issues and we'll see later."

But frankly, if we do that, we will be roughly following the line of what we did in previous crises, which were, however, less serious than this one. Well, I think that would be a serious mistake. Because it is in the crisis that we prepare for the rebound. Because it is in the crisis that we can question the mistakes that have brought us to where we are. And because the crisis is the unique, unexpected opportunity to shake up dogmas, to question supposed certainties, and to overcome eternal conservatisms. And the crisis is the perfect revealer of who the reformers are and who the conservatives are. Outside of the crisis, there are the old patterns. Well, I don't want to upset anyone. But we can see roughly where we stand. In the crisis, there are new patterns, and the crisis is a test of truth. It reveals temperaments and convictions.

I assert: I want us to take advantage of this crisis to reset things in essential areas. Why in Europe, in general, and in France in particular, have we accumulated so many delays? If we do not reset things during the crisis, we will never do it. It is precisely because things are going badly that we must do it. That is why I have asked Claude Allègre, a man for whom I have admiration, a man in whom I have confidence, to work, within the framework of the French Presidency, on renewing the European innovation policy. The framework of the French Presidency, an immense responsibility. And if, in the name of this French Presidency, we are not capable of working with women or men from other political sensitivities, in the service of Europe, the future, and innovation, when will we do it? As President of the Union, every day, I work with Prime Ministers without asking whether they are from the left or the right. I was with the British Prime Minister yesterday, Claude was with me. To my knowledge, he is a socialist. We worked hand in hand. Prime Minister José-Luis Zapatero is a prominent member of the European socialist party. Should I refrain from working with him when we share so much with Spain, solely on the grounds that he is a socialist?

Claude Allègre belonged to a government, I believe I remember it was socialist, well, the government. We cannot reduce Claude Allègre to mere membership in a government. Moreover, he is free to have the political commitments and political friendships he wishes. In the same way, I am pleased to count Eric Besson among us every day. The question is, where are the people who want to shake up the dogmas that have caused us so much delay, where are the people who want us to move forward, where are the people who want us to prepare for the future? That is the question. I am ready to ask, to call upon, to ally with all those in Europe who want things to change.

Claude Allègre was the originator of the gathering at the Sorbonne on May 25, 1998, of four European ministers, a gathering that laid the foundations for what we later called the Bologna Process. It was there that the European Higher Education and Research Area was born. We can say that this Assembly plays the same role: dear Claude, you opened the European Higher Education and Research Area ten years ago, we are today opening the European Innovation Area.

I thank you, Ladies and Gentlemen, for coming to open this Area with us and for formulating and debating the first proposals that will constitute its foundations. I intend to rely on these proposals to propose to Europe nothing less than a new innovation policy.

We, the Europeans, must place at the heart of our economies the bridges that we lack between knowledge, research, and society. These bridges are called technological innovation and industrial innovation.

Innovation is what allows us to move from science to progress. To move from laboratories to the improvement of our daily lives. Innovation means fewer diseases, less pollution, less poverty, more growth, and more opportunities. It is through innovation that Europe will catch up on this growth delay.

Europe has an absolute necessity, it is not a choice, it is a necessity, to be the great continent of innovation, and I say it bluntly, to catch up with the delay it has taken on the United States. It is not showing adoration for the United States of America to say that their innovation system is extraordinarily effective. Why should we, the Europeans, remain with a demotivating system while our friends, our allies, and sometimes our American competitors have an effective system? The financial system in the United States led us to a wall, but their innovation system has generated companies and inventions absolutely unparalleled in the world.

We must therefore develop and consolidate Europe's capacity for innovation. Our old continent has exceptional resources. This old continent has demonstrated in recent months that we have the capacity to react. To get out of the financial crisis, we were very happy to find Europe. Because if we had been bound to the Paulson plan, honestly, they abandoned it even before we refused it. Which made the refusal easier.

I would like to remind you that Europe is still the main provider of brainpower on the planet. In 2004, Europe awarded 43% of the degrees obtained in OECD countries in science and engineering, compared to 22% for the United States. In Europe, nearly 25% of the degrees awarded are in science and engineering, compared to less than 15% in the United States. It is in Europe that the percentage of a cohort obtaining a doctorate is the highest. We still have considerable intellectual potential today. What are we doing with it? Are we valuing it or not? The recent Nobel Prizes and other international awards have shown us that Europe can compete with the United States. Our European research is of high quality. We have reason to be proud of it.

But as soon as we look at the indicators related to innovation, patent filings, types of patents, and business creations, we cannot deny the evidence: Europe is not able to convert the quality of its research into growth. This is still an absolutely considerable problem that should concern us all. It is not a question of ideology. It is a question of lucidity.

We train the younger generations, the young researchers well, but we do not know how to make good use of this tremendous human potential. And our well-trained young generations, in a largely free higher education system, thus funded by the taxes of Europeans, often leave to bring their talent to competing economies outside of Europe. Great result! We train the best with the taxes of European taxpayers. Once well trained, they leave for the benefit of other economies.

We must not accept that this situation continues. We must build a new strategy, let’s say it plainly, stronger than that of Lisbon. And stop going away repeating Lisbon, Lisbon, Lisbon. We will have a hard time putting content into it. The only content we are putting in is the years of delay we are taking to achieve the objectives.

The foundation of strong innovation is the absolute pursuit of research excellence. It is not enough to have good fundamental research to have innovation, but there is no innovation without top-level research. We must put an end to this distinction between fundamental research and applied research.

There should be no barrier between the two. Both are essential, and the boundaries are often tenuous. When we cite the great American universities like M.I.T. or the California Institute of Technology, it is because they have managed to combine the two. They have a dual objective: Nobel Prizes and patents. There is not one side with the nobility of Nobel Prizes, there is also the practical and pragmatic nature of patents. If there is no distinction between fundamental research and applied research, there must be a distinction between good research and less good. This means that there can be no good research and innovation policy without evaluation. A rigorous evaluation, a serious evaluation, an independent evaluation, dear Valérie, we know how to do it, and an international evaluation. We cannot accept that evaluation applies to everyone except research or certain large organizations. They are so big that they should not be evaluated? They must be evaluated because it is the guarantee of excellence.

Each country alone cannot provide this evaluation, but Europe, together, can do it. We must therefore create a European framework for independent evaluation.

I propose today that Europe have, like the United States, a European Academy of Sciences and Techniques, where all disciplines would be present, the so-called hard sciences but also economics, management, engineering, and which would also include all actors of innovation, - I dare say -: public and private. It would already be good to have one Academy; we are not going to create 50, one for the public, one for the private, one for applied research, one for fundamental research. One single Academy in Europe.

This Academy would have a triple mission of evaluation, for European programs, for scientific institutions in Europe, and for universities in Europe and around the world. It would give a globally recognized signal of excellence.

This would be symbolic of the creation of a true Europe of science and innovation, united in the face of future challenges.

Europe must also directly fund the best teams, with no other condition than excellence. This is the great advantage of European funding: it puts all scientific and technological teams in Europe in competition, and it concentrates a critical mass of funds on the best. In the spirit of the European Institute of Technology, proposed by President Barroso and actively supported by France, we propose to create a major European competition to finally bring forth the science and technology universities that Europe so desperately lacks. How can we determine excellence if there is no competition?

European procedures are still often too cumbersome, too lengthy, penalizing for small structures, businesses, or research laboratories, often the most creative and innovative. Together with President Barroso, we will double our efforts to put an end to these shortcomings. We must simplify the procedures for awarding European research funding. I prefer that researchers work on formulas rather than on forms. Honestly, that is not from me, but it is a good formula. Fine. You applaud the only thing that is not from me; honestly, that is cruel.

I will probably make some adversaries, but this European action must not be confiscated by a few experts. It must be perceived by all actors of research and innovation in Europe as their program. The European Research Council is an excellent example that guides us in the right direction. We must go further to ensure its independence and significantly increase its budgetary resources.

To move forward, I propose that the year 2009 be the year of innovation and creativity in Europe, and that this year, under the Czech and Swedish presidencies, be an opportunity for mobilization in every region, in every country, in every organization. The objective will be to accelerate the timeline and to revise the Lisbon agenda in 2010 and not in 2011 as planned, with simplified, more structured, and more focused procedures.

If we have simpler procedures focused on excellence, and only under this condition, we will be able to increase the contribution of research efforts made at the European level. Understand me, if we are sure that this money will be well used, we will put in more, the reform then the means. Not the means and then possibly the reform, I do not agree. Today, the budget that the European Union dedicates to research and innovation represents about 6% of the total budget spent by the Member States on research and innovation. The remaining 94% is spent at the national level and is not sufficiently coordinated. In other words, every time Europe spends one euro on research, only the use of six cents is coordinated within the framework of a genuine European policy. Whereas in the United States, it is strictly the opposite; the vast majority of public spending on research and innovation is coordinated by federal agencies, in a logic of funding excellence. I know the word comes back, but research is excellence, it is not the average.

I come to the weakest link in the French and European system, the link between research and innovation, and our ability to develop innovation itself.

We must take stock of the Lisbon agenda without complacency. It had the right objective, that of making the European Union the most attractive and competitive knowledge economy in the world by 2010. It provided Member States with relevant guidelines. But it did not achieve the expected results. I believe this is because it lacked concrete levers to act at the European level. I have just proposed one: strengthening the common budgetary effort on research. I propose another: to restore a dimension to programs that have proven effective but are underfunded. I am thinking of Eureka, which allows for more targeted support for innovative SMEs. And the evaluations it has undergone show that the objectives are regularly met. But we have let it wither. Today, for innovative projects, it has only about 300 million euros, down from 1,300 million in 1985 — there is no need to say that we had the Lisbon objective — in constant euros. Why are we leaving good tools unused today?

I would add that Eureka is a voluntary initiative. It is a method that provides flexibility to act and should help us coordinate the use of our national research and development budgets. This must be done with the minimum possible bureaucracy. I propose to coordinate like the European Research Foundation. I propose to call this new program the COPERNIC program, because it can revolutionize European cooperation in research and innovation. I propose to launch it through the very rapid accession of a few founding states to an Innovation Pact, which would be open to all members. This pact would be the commitment to work together, to coordinate our research programs on a voluntary basis, to establish a European innovation space with the rapid establishment of a single European patent, tax measures to promote the creation of innovative companies, the mobility of researchers, the mobility of university professors between countries, between public research and private research.

I will propose to countries that already dedicate more than 2% of GDP to research to develop and sign the Innovation Pact, a guide to translate our research potential into terms of growth.

Flexibility also means adapting the system to the situation of the countries. The state of research in the countries that recently joined the European Union is not the same as in the older member states. The new entrants primarily need to train their researchers and develop a solid research base. In contrast, many older Member States, like France, have a considerable public research base but need to make it more competitive and strengthen its links with businesses.

I propose to establish an ambitious innovation stimulation program specifically dedicated to the new Member States, funded, for example, by structural funds. This program could be aimed at creating and developing research and innovation infrastructures in the new Member States and also at training their researchers.

One of Europe's handicaps is its difficulty in translating its creativity into economic terms. We have good research, we have many startups, but we cannot make them grow or expand according to each one's choice.

So why not propose to our European partners to massively increase the innovation financing activity of the European Investment Bank? These funds must be repaid and remunerated by the projects themselves, which means that each project must create activity and revenue: this is the assurance of the operational nature of the projects.

Finally, it is not because we will do more and better at the European level that we will have to abandon the efforts of each of our countries, because it is still there that the essential means of action lie.

On this subject, I want to tell you that I will apply myself, no longer as President of the European Union, but as President of the French Republic, to show that France has understood the imperative to innovate and is undertaking both unprecedented reforms and financial means on this subject. We have launched colossal projects in eighteen months. Five billion euros to create ten world-class university campuses. But what is extraordinary is that we have managed without drama to accept the idea that not everything is equal, that we could first choose the best and that the others must continue to work. Fifteen billion more euros over 5 years will be invested in all our universities, which have finally become autonomous. A profound reform initiated by Valérie PECRESSE has made them autonomous, governable, responsible, and must open them up to business. The most attractive tax system in the world, it must be known, France now has the most attractive tax system in the world in terms of research with the research tax credit at 30%. I tell this to the ministers of Bercy, dear Luc, not necessarily you by the way, when they come to tell me it costs a lot, no it does not cost a lot, it works. Some administrations must realize that I cannot have as my only choices tax systems that cost nothing because they do not work and of which no one complains, and tax systems that cost, so to speak, a lot because they work. I will let you in on a secret, I want it to work even better, because the money spent on research is well-invested money and it was a serious mistake for France not to spend enough on its research in the past years. So it is good if the research tax credit works. I tell this to the finance committees, we did it for that, there is no need to take a disheartened look, we must see the reports I receive, the research tax credit costs us money. Oh yes, and what would all the research laboratories that would have been relocated have cost us if we had not implemented the 30% research tax credit? So there is no need to complain about a great success! I wish for France and for our economy that we spend even more in support of the research tax credit. We want to win and we want to keep companies that do not invest.

And in the recovery plan that I presented last week to the French, higher education and research are prominently featured, as they will benefit from an additional 700 million euros in investments in 2009, 700 million euros in addition to what we have decided, because I am taking advantage of the crisis to modernize France. I am tired of our country sacrificing investment for operation and to all those who ask me for a demand-driven recovery policy, it simply consisted of pouring water into the sand, distributing money that we did not have, to sacrifice the future for the present, that is what it meant. I have chosen a different policy: research, training, innovation, infrastructure, investment. I believe this is the only possible policy and this policy will create purchasing power, it will create growth and it will create jobs. That is why we chose it; if, by the way, systematic demand-driven recovery policies had worked, just ask those who lived through Mr. MITTERRAND's recovery plan and even Mr. CHIRAC's in the 70s what became of it. The appointment was the turning point of austerity in 1983 of grim memory; after having spent too much in pure loss, we also braked too much in pure loss, with a France that for decades exploded the unemployment counters. Well, that is not the policy I wish to engage in.

We will also make specific efforts in major strategic areas. This is the case, for example, with decarbonized vehicles, with 400 million euros of support for research in the coming years.

I would like to take advantage of this meeting to announce that France will implement an innovation strategy in nanotechnology, supported by clusters in Saclay, south of Paris, in Grenoble, and in Toulouse. Nanotechnology involves the manipulation of a few hundred atoms. They allow for the construction of products with astonishing properties in all fields. They cover vast application areas, for making batteries, solar sensors, medicines, and the electronic chips of the 21st century. We will create, in Saclay, nanotechnology integration centers, where fundamental research will work with companies to develop technologies, file patents, and create products. We will double the annual allocation for research projects in nanotechnology, raising it to 70 million euros per year, 350 million euros over 5 years. We will create a fund to invest in patents arising from these technologies and to valorize them in business. I want France to be at the forefront of nanotechnology, including, by the way, in research on their impact on health, which will be funded as part of the Grenelle de l'environnement.

Innovation is my absolute priority before the crisis, it is even more my absolute priority during the crisis. And we will go further in the effort because we will go further in the reforms.

An excellent evaluation report from INSERM, the major French health and medical research organization, was recently submitted to me. I will apply all of its recommendations, Valérie, particularly the one to separate, as in all major scientific countries, the functions of research operators from those of funding agencies for research. And none of the French research organizations will escape these reforms. If we want to be angry with me, here is a good reason. There will be reform for others and not for some. There will be reform for everyone.

The CNRS had a rare privilege at the global level, that of self-evaluation. Note that if it is a new method of governance, I see some advantages in applying it to myself. But no, strangely, we find that this self-evaluation rarely leads to energizing structures and redirecting efforts towards the best teams. It is a system, I say this very calmly, that cannot last. I wish for the CNRS to no longer self-evaluate but to be subjected to a rigorous external evaluation as soon as possible so that the entire reform of higher education and research can be opened. This reform will benefit from resources to support it, but, as I have always said and Valérie PECRESSE knows well, and I have said this in front of the heads of public research: there will be resources to support the reform, there will be no additional resources if there is no reform.

Ladies and gentlemen, in this time of crisis, there will be no better signal than to make this year 2009 the European Year of Creativity and Innovation.

For a few proposals that I have made today, I know that the Czech presidency and the Swedish presidency will enrich them. As far as France is concerned, this will be a priority for us.

You can count on me, at the European Council this week, dear Claude, to inscribe this priority and to tirelessly defend the necessity of putting all our forces on research and innovation to make it one of the engines of growth in Europe.

Ladies and gentlemen, this crisis marks the entry into the 21st century; either we are present at the rendezvous, or we are not. If we want to be present at the rendezvous, we must focus on research, innovation, higher education, training, and we must focus on investment. This is a historic opportunity. In a few years, when we look back at the crisis and analyze who made the right decisions, I hope that Europe will be among the continents that made the right decisions. I have no doubt that in a few years, researchers will explain to us why we ended up here and how we got out. Frankly, I would prefer to have their reports beforehand rather than afterward. But I have a conviction: this crisis is strong, we must take strong measures, this crisis is astonishingly rapid; we must not react, we must act. If we do not act in time, we will be forced to do more at the wrong time; this crisis compels us to think differently; we cannot apply the recipes of the last century to this crisis. This crisis can reshuffle the cards in globalization, between countries that have fallen behind and those that have moved ahead. We can catch up with the countries and continents that were ahead. The question will be decided in a few months and rests on a few decision-makers.

I would like you to understand that for us to succeed, we must not hesitate to break free from classic divisions to find the right course, and once the crisis is over, everyone can return to their family, politically speaking, if they like it and if they ultimately find that the habits have been too shaken up. But we cannot be conservatives, we cannot be immobile, we cannot look at the consequences of the crisis without reacting, and that is the message I wanted to convey here before this assembly, dear Claude; it is the message I will deliver to the European Council on Thursday and Friday. The map of innovation, the map of green growth and environmental protection, the map of the coordination of our economies, the map of new institutions in Europe, is a historic opportunity.