Joint press conference of Mr. Nicolas Sarkozy, President of the Republic, Mr. José Manuel Barroso, President of the European Commission, and Mr. Jean-Louis Borloo, Minister of State, Minister of Ecology, Energy, Sustainable Development and Territorial Planning, on the assessment of the French Presidency of the Council of the European Union, in Brussels on December 12, 2008.

France Nicolas Sarkozy · President of France

12 December 2008 · Joint press conference on the assessment of the French Presidency of the European Union

Context
Sarkozy addressed a joint press conference in Brussels on December 12, 2008, summarizing outcomes of the European Council under the French EU Presidency.
Main themes
French EU Council Presidency assessment, Lisbon Treaty ratification, Irish protocol and commitments, EU economic stimulus package, energy-climate package, EU institutional reform, Council President role, economic crisis response, reduced VAT decision, Croatia accession, EU budget reallocation, Franco-German cooperation
Duration
~63 min
96th percentile
Words
7,542
96th percentile
Sentences
461
98th percentile
Readability
63
92nd percentile
Grade
8.4
7th percentile
Syntax
2.72
15th percentile
Vocabulary
2.00
10th percentile

Translated from French

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

461 sentences in 63 paragraphs

Ladies and Gentlemen,

We have just concluded a European Council that will go down in history for Europe, as three types of major decisions were made unanimously. And I remember when, at the last European Council, I indicated that I had accepted unanimity for the energy-climate package, a number of people wrote that by doing so, I was renouncing, I was sacrificing the energy-climate package. You will see that this is not the case.

First of all, the Lisbon process is back on track. The Irish will be consulted again. To this end, we unanimously indicated that if the Lisbon Treaty were ratified by all member states, each member state would have a commissioner. If we remain with Nice, we will stay in a Commission whose number will decrease; if we move to Lisbon, each member state will have a commissioner.

Secondly, political commitments have been made to the Irish regarding neutrality, taxation, and family. These are recurring and important themes for our Irish friends. And we have put on the table a compromise that ensures that no one will be obliged to undergo a new ratification procedure for the Lisbon Treaty, that there will be no modification of the Lisbon Treaty. But at the same time, to give legal value to the political commitments of the twenty-six member states towards the Irish, we have committed that at the time of the next enlargement - will it be 2010, will it be 2011? - at the time when Croatia will presumably join us, at that moment, in any case, a new treaty will be needed, an accession treaty, ratified by the twenty-seven member states, since Europe at that time will become twenty-eight. Well, we will take this opportunity to add an Irish protocol to the Croatian accession treaty and, moreover, to increase the number of European parliamentarians, as had been indicated in the context of the Nice-Lisbon transition.

I would like to say how courageous the Irish Prime Minister has been. Bernard KOUCHNER and I were in Ireland. I believe I had three working lunches with Brian COWEN, Gordon BROWN was, as usual, an extremely constructive European. I will not hide from you that the discussions were long and precise, very early this morning, very lengthy this morning. Europe is resuming its institutional march forward; it will equip itself with strong institutions, and I think that no one can contest today the necessity of a Council President exercising true leadership, and not for six months, but for two and a half years.

For President BARROSO and for myself, this is a great satisfaction because we are committed to the Lisbon Treaty; it is a bit, after all, our child. The French no, the electoral campaign, Lisbon. I also want to say how much Chancellor MERKEL played an essential role at the time of the treaty's adoption. This is excellent news for all Europeans, and I have no doubt that with these responses and the crisis, all of Ireland will understand that we need it in Europe. We, the Europeans, need Ireland, and Ireland knows well that it needs others. It is together that we will face the crisis, and that is very good news.

Secondly, on economic policy, everyone showed absolute agreement on the seriousness of the crisis, not a discordant voice. Everyone agrees on the need for a stimulus based on President BARROSO's project, around 1.5 percentage points of GDP, everyone. And we even asked President BARROSO to use 5 billion euros that have not been spent on other budget chapters to put them to the service of the stimulus. The only thing we asked him is to propose specific projects. I will not go into detail; you will see the communiqué. I will, of course, answer your questions with the President, but we want fewer binding procedures, at least for the year 2009 and for the year 2010, the lifting - so that the projects can start faster - the lifting of the "de minimis" thresholds that France requested. And for those who might be concerned, we also decided in the same vein that on reduced VAT, the decision would be made before March, or rather at the Ecofin Council in March. We have been talking about this for three years; we are changing habits in Europe, we are talking a little less and acting much more. The decision will be made in March; it is the subject of discussions with Angela MERKEL. We found this agreement, and I made sure with the Chancellor - and I trust her completely - that it is in a constructive spirit that she will instruct her Finance Minister to address this issue.

Yesterday, we had a good dinner on the theme of the stimulus; everyone agrees, everyone is on the same page, we found, including with the President of the Eurogroup of Finance Ministers, Mr. JUNCKER, we found an agreement that states that the pact remains in force. We need a pact; this pact must be applied again the day after the crisis. Our medium-term objective remains the reduction of deficits and debt, but in exceptional situations, exceptional means. During the crisis, we take the necessary measures to combat the crisis. Complete agreement, and I ask you to believe it, everyone contributed, including Jan Peter BALKENENDE and the Swedish Prime Minister. Everyone is pulling in the same direction.

Finally, the energy-climate package. What is happening is truly historic; there is not a continent in the world that has established rules as binding as those we have just adopted unanimously, not a continent in the world. The objectives remain the same for 2020: the "three times twenty," I will not go back to that. As the presidency of the Commission, we asserted that the crisis could in no way be an excuse for not advancing on environmental protection. On the contrary, it is a desire to go further to change our economic models, to move towards sustainable growth, towards green growth, to modify energy sources in Europe, and frankly, it has been much easier than has been said.

My trip to Gdansk was extremely interesting. We must try to understand the problems. The only thing we did was negotiate for the new Eastern countries a number of exemptions. I will explain this very simply: a country like Poland, with 38 million inhabitants, is 95% reliant on coal; if we did not allow it to smooth its effort over a slope, I will give you some elements, it would mean imposing increases of 200 to 300% in electricity prices for Poles. This is not possible. It is not socially acceptable. It is not a question of defending the environment or not; it is not socially acceptable. So what did we do? We did something very simple: the Poles, like others, have the same obligations as all of Europe, but we allow them to allocate a part of the free quotas assigned to each government; well, they will have the right to allocate it to electricity producers, according to a slope that will lead them to 0 - I am talking about CO2 emissions in 2020.

It was difficult until the last moment, last night, with Hungary, with Poland; not that they did not want to meet the environmental protection requirements, but they are facing considerable economic and energy difficulties. This is truly something historic that has been implemented, and I made it clear to my European partners that it is not at the moment when the United States finally has an elected president who places environmental protection at the heart of his priorities that Europe will abandon this priority. That would make no sense; it would be lamentable, historically lamentable. There is Potsdam, there are the Americans; well, Europe will be able to speak up and say: here we are, we did it, now you do it. Europe can only be listened to if it is exemplary.

Finally, I would like to conclude by saying how happy I have been to work hand in hand with President BARROSO, who has been an intelligent, courageous, and responsive partner. And moreover, very pleasant in the countless trips we have made together. We will make another one to Brazil, since we have a summit, and frankly, I do not regret at all the change in the French position which consists, instead of criticizing the Commission - which does not serve much purpose - to work with it absolutely hand in hand. I want to say that the Council Secretariat has been remarkable. I want to pay tribute to my team; they have worked very hard. I want to say to Jean-Louis BORLOO how much he has helped us clear the ground on measures that were not at all technical but really extremely important; how much Bernard KOUCHNER is for me an indispensable partner and friend; how much we will miss Jean-Pierre JOUYET, even if he will take on responsibilities, we will continue to work together. As you know, Jean-Pierre JOUYET was my collaborator - if he allows me to say so - a few years ago, and I knew perfectly well what I was doing in proposing him. And then I would like to say to François FILLON that we have changed, I believe, habits. We are not in cohabitation, and we have done all the European Councils together, all the summits together; that is how we work. Because Europe is our daily life; it is not foreign affairs, Europe. It is perfectly essential that the Prime Minister, who has an interministerial vocation, is from January 1 to December 31 in European affairs with the President of the Republic. I have never understood these stories of reserved domains where the Prime Minister should not deal with Europe or international matters. I do not understand. Europe is crucial. Europe is our daily life. How can one imagine that the President of the Republic goes to Europe and then the Prime Minister does not participate at all? That makes no sense. I hope I am not being moderate in saying this; I hope I am being understood. So we have formed a remarkable team.

I would like to announce that in agreement with the Prime Minister, I have asked Bruno LE MAIRE to replace Jean-Pierre JOUYET, to be Secretary of State to Bernard KOUCHNER - who has also given me his agreement - for European Affairs. I signed the appointment decree early this morning. Bruno LE MAIRE will therefore be with us on Tuesday at the European Parliament. Let us not forget co-decision. This appointment, we thought a lot about it, the Prime Minister and I, we chose a young man, a talented, competent, deeply European man. And I hope everyone understands that, in my mind, this is also a way of saying to the majority that anyone who wants to contribute to the reform work we are undertaking in France is welcome. I cannot be a man of openness towards part of the left and not be of the same openness towards all the sensitivities of my own political family. No one would understand that. There you go.

I wish good luck to the Czech Presidency. It has been excellent news for Europe that Prime Minister Mirek TOPOLANEK has won the internal battle in his party. And I would like to say that he has been courageous, Mr. TOPOLANEK, because he won by saying that if he won, he would ratify, as authorized by the Czech Constitutional Court, Lisbon. What does this show? It shows that in countries where there is Euroscepticism, heads of state and government must be courageous and assert their convictions. I was elected with 53% in a country that voted no at 55%. And I, unlike the lady who was my opponent, did not promise a referendum. That is how we unlocked the situation in Europe. You know, our peoples can sometimes aspire to say "no" to Europe, but even those who aspire to say "no" to Europe do not want their head of state or government to be in the same position of isolation. And Mr. TOPOLANEK won; that is good, and he won by saying he would ratify Lisbon. He can count on France's support.

Do you want to know if I will miss this? Maybe. But after all, you will not blame me for loving Europe. It was truly two very beautiful days.

Mr. JOSE MANUEL BARROSO - Thank you, thank you very much. First of all, I would like to pay tribute to President SARKOZY and his team who have led Europe through a very difficult time. He started with an already very busy agenda, but the various crises - the crisis in Georgia, the financial crisis - made things difficult. His commitment, his dedication, his energy, his political intelligence have strengthened Europe. Over the last two days, I believe I can say, we have shown that Europe is united and resolved to move from crisis to recovery and to bring about sustainable prosperity.

Before the Council, I said that this would undoubtedly be the most important European Council I would be called to participate in. Indeed, that is the case. I am pleased to tell you that we have reached a historic agreement, not only because we can move forward on the Lisbon Treaty, but also because of the important decisions that have been made, which concern the political response to the crisis, the main concern of our citizens. We have also adopted a historic package on climate and energy, and it is by far the most ambitious program ever adopted in a country or on a continent. There is an agreement on the recovery plan in accordance with our proposal. We have agreed to place ourselves on the path to recovery. An approach that will be coordinated. It is about taking into account the approaches of the different Member States, acting together. It is about avoiding a solution that would be the same, imposed on all, but it is about coordinating our efforts. There is an agreement regarding the Commission's proposals to create sufficient economic momentum to have an impact to boost demand and restore confidence. It is about injecting 1.5% of GDP into European economies. But spending must be smart, intelligent so that our economies are more resilient to the crisis and more competitive. It is about providing this momentum and also aiming for sustainability. This must go hand in hand. I am satisfied that the European Council has followed the Commission's proposals which ask Member States to return very quickly within the framework of what the Stability and Growth Pact provides for deficits. It is about having this momentum, this short-term stimulus, but our concern is the medium and long term, and I believe we have reached a very large consensus on this point. I believe that this is indeed a serious crisis but if we handle it well, Europe can emerge strengthened.

Regarding the climate-energy package, you know that the Commission presented its proposals on this matter in January, on January 23 of this year. In less than a year, the Member States have reached a unanimous agreement on the most ambitious proposals ever known. The Parliament - I can say this today, and I would have said the opposite if the result had been the opposite - but I believe we can say today, yes, Europe has successfully passed its credibility test.

When we talk about the climate, we are serious. Now it is about finalizing this work, that is to say, also reaching an agreement with the European Parliament next week. I believe that this will be possible. In recent days, there has been tough negotiation, which is natural, but let us not forget the most important point: after all the adjustments made, we have guaranteed a 20% reduction in emissions by 2020, the target of 20% renewable energy by 2020, and we have also guaranteed that we will increase energy efficiency by 20%. Some time ago, many critical voices were raised saying that this would be impossible, that Europe would be unable to do it. And more recently, in the face of the economic and financial crisis, it was said: Europe will abandon its commitments. No, Europe has decided to stick to these commitments. I believe we have shown that energy security, climate action, and growth can all be pursued in a mutually supportive way to overcome the crisis. We knew that the world was waiting for us. Our message to our global partners is this: "Yes you can." Yes, it is possible, you too can do what we are doing. Yes, it is possible to achieve the goals we have committed to. That is the message we want to convey to all our partners. And I will be even clearer, especially to our American partners: there is a new President in the United States who has made a very important statement regarding the United States' commitment to the climate. We ask him to join us, Europe, and with us to lead the world in this global effort. We need American support in this initiative.

Regarding Lisbon, we have found a way forward with our Irish friends. It is a solution that takes into account Irish concerns, but does not require others to ratify again. Ireland will understand, I believe, how important it is for us that Ireland is with us, how important we can be for Ireland, as we have shown, in economic difficulties. I would like to pay tribute to the Irish Prime Minister, but also to the maturity of the twenty-six partners who have shown that it is possible to find a solution driven by a true European spirit. I can say that this European Council, under the leadership of Nicolas SARKOZY, has created a platform for us to navigate these turbulent seas, but now we need to think about the global dimension. There is a continuation at the G20 level. Now, I would like to call on the American President to align ideas with ours, creating this transatlantic plan for the climate. Let us do it for the good of Europe, America, but also the world. We need such momentum; without it, there will be no solution on a global scale. We know that in today's world we are increasingly interdependent. We need this effort of this dimension. Europe is ready; let us hope that others will be ready to make the same efforts.

THE PRESIDENT - Thank you, José Manuel. I forgot that on European defense, there are extremely important conclusions. Excuse me, but there are so many things. We will have the opportunity to talk about it, about Zimbabwe as well, there are very important decisions.

QUESTION - Mr. President, after all the successes you have described, are you reassured that the European Union will be in good hands starting January 1, 2009? What do you expect from the Czech Presidency?

THE PRESIDENT - Of course it will be in good hands. I said it. Do you want me to repeat it? Yes, it will be in very good hands. And then, there are rules that apply. The Czechs will hand over the Presidency to the Swedes. If the Swedish press asks me the question: is the Presidency in good hands? I will say: yes, it is in good hands. And then, in 2009, I hope we will have the Lisbon Treaty.

QUESTION - Mr. President, what measures have been adopted as part of the agreement on the climate-energy package to protect European industries, industrial sectors regarding pollution permits, so that they are not subjected more harshly to international competition? What are the exemptions that Italy and Germany requested?

MR. JEAN-LOUIS BORLOO - What was planned, in the event that there would be no agreement in Copenhagen - and only in that case, because as José Manuel BARROSO said, "Yes, United States can!", we will tell them in Poznan shortly, only in that case - for those facing extremely strong competition exposure criteria, we ensure that the most exposed European industry is required to move towards the best available technology. And below that technology, you do not pay, to simplify the quota, to put it simply. On the other hand, above that, you pay, you create this market in the same way, knowing that all of this is improved, progressive every year until 2020. This allows for... you know that the technology gaps are considerable depending on the sites: in some sectors, it is in the order of 20 to 30% but for others, it is 1 to 3. It is absolutely gigantic. So that is the balance that has been found, I must say quite simply and I must say with the unanimous agreement of those who have industry and those who do not.

THE PRESIDENT - I must pay tribute to Italy. As everyone knows, there was not huge enthusiasm at the beginning. We found, thanks to President BERLUSCONI, a fairly quick agreement, with Germany as well. It was necessary to negotiate a possibility to help new plants from 2013-2016, those that will be built and pollute less to avoid a distortion of competition between Poland and Germany. Everyone understood well that the world could not continue like this, that ultimately it was not a punishment inflicted on them, but an opportunity to move towards new production processes, and that this would require the entire European industry to modernize towards the best technologies. The benchmarks, which Jean-Louis spoke of, based on the 10% of what sells best, will force us to reform the entire European industrial apparatus to produce in a less polluting way. That is how we will win the battle of innovation and get ahead. Frankly, it has not been that difficult.

QUESTION - Mr. President, I had a question for you. Do you think that during these 180 days, you have convinced Europe or has Europe convinced you?

THE PRESIDENT - I have not thought of it that way. Undoubtedly, you know that... how do you want me to work every day, traveling so often, of course I am influenced by all the people I have met, everything I have heard. It has mainly taught me to take into account the problems of others. And the absolute necessity to find a compromise. It is very difficult when you are President of the Council to be attentive, to preside flexibly and at the same time not to let things drift. I had warned about the climate-energy package that there were things I would not do. I held firm. I do not like to finish at 4 a.m., exhausted, negotiating over three peanuts. Normal people work all day, go to bed at 10:30/11:00 p.m. I believe that having chaired an 8-hour meeting yesterday, it was absolutely unnecessary to go beyond that. I think that when you are twenty-seven heads of state and government around the table, you speak once to say what you have to say. You do not have to repeat it six times. I believe that if you speak to say: my position is non-negotiable, then it means you do not want a compromise, so you have to accept that and therefore I do not have to seek a compromise. I think the role of the Presidency is not to create some kind of unidentifiable monster where we have pleased everyone, but to try to be fair and equitable. Ultimately, the Presidency has put a package on the table. This package, we have carefully worked on and reflected upon with our teams, and it is true that we have modified it little. So, call it leadership, but I think it is organization.

Yes, I have been influenced by others. Above all, what we wanted to show is that the problem of Europe is that it did not have enough ambition. Because when you convene a European Council with great ambitions and great decisions, then you give yourself the means to overcome national blockages. Because everyone understands well that if it is for a great objective, you have to overcome selfish interests. If you do not have great ambition and great objectives, why would you want people to accept sacrificing small interests? Therefore, it is much easier to have great ambition.

The message I want to leave to Europe is this: we need to have great ambitions, not small ones. Because with small ones, no one understands anything and in the name of small collective ambitions, one does not sacrifice their selfish interests. In the name of a great collective design, one can accept to overcome their national fears. That is what has been demonstrated.

I also want to say that the European Parliament plays a very large role. I have had lunch three times with all the group Presidents, with Bernard KOUCHNER and Jean-Pierre JOUYET. They have provided us with considerable help. For example, before the European Council, I saw them to tell them where we were going to land. We are in co-decision on the climate-energy package. That is how it should work. Europe must exist. Europe must be proactive. Europe must have ambitions. Europe must stop being naive. Europe must carry a political project. Europe must do politics. Europe must shake up the world that must change. Europe must be present at the London summit with extremely strong proposals. Europe must not give itself the ridicule of not having functioning institutions. Europe must make efforts. The world needs Europe, but a Europe that holds its head high, that thinks something and that says something. The prize for the best European should not be given to the one who thinks nothing, says nothing, and believes in nothing to wake no one. We must take risks.

Around the table, I was extremely happy to see something: even when we did things that did not initially generate consensus, there was a great deal of tolerance, as long as we understood where we wanted to go. That is what was lacking: ambition, the will to carry a European model without aggression towards others, including when we talked about European defense this morning. I have no problem saying: in cooperation with NATO, with our friends from NATO, but Europe must have its own defense policy with its allies. But Europe cannot be a dwarf in defense and a giant in economic matters. That is not possible. On issues of this nature, we really found perfect agreement. It is progressing. I am sure that the beautiful years of Europe are ahead of us if we continue at this pace.

QUESTION - The Polish authorities explained to us that the solidarity mechanism you negotiated will give Poland 15 billion euros this year. That is a huge amount. I would like to see if you share this interpretation and also if you really told Prime Minister TUSK that he is the best negotiator you know.

THE PRESIDENT - I might know another good negotiator! First of all, Mr. TUSK was a demanding, tough partner, but honest, loyal, who kept his word. Poland will benefit from free quotas. But that is normal. Poland has 38 million inhabitants. Its industry was sacrificed during the time of the Iron Curtain and the Warsaw Pact. They are 95% reliant on coal. If we do not help them! But they must make an absolutely considerable effort. Donald TUSK negotiated well. He is a man of quality. I remind you that President KACZYNSKI negotiated well but signed the Lisbon Treaty in my office. From my point of view, it seems complicated to have signed the Lisbon Treaty in Brussels and refuse to sign it in Warsaw. It is the same! He still said around the table that he would not obstruct the adoption of the Treaty. The Hungarian Prime Minister is also a very demanding, very combative partner. What do you want? When you want to reach an agreement, it is normal for them to defend their interests. But they will also be at 0% in 2020, like the others.

QUESTION - You said this is the last summit of your presidency with twenty-seven, in any case, an important summit. What personal assessment do you draw? Do you have any regrets, since we are at the time of assessments? We say everything.

THE PRESIDENT - Really? What an invitation! It’s Christmas! To be frank, I have no regrets. The objectives we set for ourselves, I speak under your control, it is not that they were achieved, it is that we went well beyond. I am not talking about duration, even the health assessment of the CAP - I do not want to impose all that on you - the Union for the Mediterranean, etc., to which I attach crucial importance. No, I have no regrets. Simply, perhaps, this remark. When I started the presidency, I was told: "six months is little." But look at what we have done in six months. And then, what I really liked was tripling the number of European Councils compared to what was planned! I find that fantastic. We have changed so many habits! I think there should be summits on fixed dates, yes. I think that in a summit like that of the French Presidency, meeting twice would be shocking, would be ridiculous, absolutely ridiculous. And again, I am talking about councils but I do not forget the various summits at the Élysée. Europe needs to be much more responsive, much more mobile, and stop locking itself into procedures.

I take an example, it is so revealing: we started with the Lisbon Treaty yesterday, because it allowed the presence of the President of the European Parliament, Hans-Gert Pöttering. I turn around and see that the Minister of State, Jean-Louis BORLOO was not there. "Ask him to come back." "No, we can't, there are not enough chairs." One of my collaborators says: "I will give him a seat." No, we are going to make a revolution, a coup, we will put one more chair! That does not happen. If you do not put it, I will go get it myself! That is Europe dying! Is that a detail? It is not a detail. They are capable of spending hours determining the number of chairs per delegation! It makes no sense. We need to bring life. We need to bring flexibility. We need to bring freedom. We need to bring interactivity.

Another example. We talked about economic policy at dinner yesterday, José-Manuel can say it was very free. I said this morning at the council: we will not talk about it again. We read the text, if you have problems with the text, you tell us, but we will not redo the same discussion. We will not talk about the same things twice in a row. There were three hours to discuss it at dinner, I will not accept a minute of debate in the morning. I accept the debate on a formulation that would not work, because the presidency did not do its job well, I accept that completely, but no new debate. We cannot function if we do not set extremely precise rules. It is true, I have sometimes refused the floor, things like that, because we do not have to repeat the same thing multiple times when we are twenty-seven. When it happened that a head of delegation said that what he was asking for was non-negotiable, I said: "it is non-negotiable, then prepare to announce failure! Because if we start saying: it is what I propose or nothing, it is not worth our while to find a compromise. That is not European.

That is why we got along well with José-Manuel, because we had the will to move things. I must also say that Jean-Claude TRICHET, President of the ECB, I appreciated the pragmatism he is showing at the moment. I did not understand that it was possible, but it is, and Jean-Claude has done remarkable work at the head of the ECB. I must say that even in the discussion we had about the economy, he was very free, accepting remarks, exchanges, of course, we listen, and especially on the support plan for banks, he was among the most proactive. There you go. I believe that is what Europe needs: great ambitions, less formality, less snobbery about procedures, badges, accreditations, the deadly boredom of meetings where, under the pretext that the problems are difficult, we talk about the periphery of the problems. Take now the text we have produced, there are no small subjects. There are ministerial councils for more technical subjects, there on heads of state and government, we need to do politics.

QUESTION - You spoke about European defense. In what way, for you, is it a success? In what way, for you, can European defense be a success when in the letter from BAN Ki-Moon regarding the European intervention in Congo, you say no?

THE PRESIDENT - These are indeed different subjects, I speak under the control of Bernard KOUCHNER. First of all, on European defense policy, it is a success to see that now, no one sees European defense policy as an aggressive policy towards the United States. But it is a monumental progress; even President BUSH said at the last NATO summit in Bucharest that European defense policy was necessary. Our Polish friends will take their full part in it. I do not want to go into detail about everything we are announcing, it is essential and I have in mind the next NATO summit in Strasbourg. We need to move forward. Our British friends are ready to move forward. All Europeans understand that it is not: either friendship with the United States or independence of Europe's security. We can do both. We must indeed do both, together.

On the question of Congo. I also want to pay tribute to all that Bernard KOUCHNER has done in this area. The problem is not at all that Europe does not want to take its part; Europe is ready to take its part. I make two remarks. The first is that currently, in the DRC, there are 17,000 UN soldiers, which is the largest UN operation. I am sorry, when there are already 17,000 soldiers and I am told that only 800 are serving, I wonder if it is necessary to send 3,000 more, with 17,000! First remark. It is a question.

Second remark. We mention DRC, Rwanda, Angola. I myself spoke on the phone with President DOS SANTOS, who is a regional actor, who told me: "the Angolan army, of which you know the effectiveness, is ready to engage for peace provided it is under UN mandate." The question I ask is: "is it, for the sake of efficiency, better, if reinforcements are needed - I remind you that there are 84 aircraft there - is it not better to first call on regional forces, almost ready, established, than on European forces?

Last point. Regarding European forces, we are in Chad. Now, after fighting to ensure that we are, with Bernard KOUCHNER, in Chad to stabilize this region of the world, with Darfur next door where everyone told us: it is a new operation in quotation marks "France-Africa" by France. I do not see how we could be reproached for not wanting to be present in the DRC.

Finally, if it is a matter of helping through an air bridge for food, humanitarian aid, why not? And then, if you want me to go to the end of my thought, one day we will have to discuss the presence of French troops, for example in Côte d'Ivoire, where I am eagerly awaiting the elections; that we redeploy soldiers in service of peace in other regions of Africa where, moreover, we know our responsibilities. We cannot do everything. I told Secretary-General BAN Ki-Moon, he is doing it, by the way. He is a man I support and appreciate. There may be organizational problems and not just problems of quantity or number.

Saying this does not mean being disinterested in the DRC where, by the way, we have planned with Bernard KOUCHNER to go in January 2009 and I will have the opportunity to say more. It is really not a lack of interest. I have spoken with President KAGAME, President KABILA, President DOS SANTOS. Bernard has been there. We are trying to find the best solution. We cannot also be everywhere, always, without limit. And above all, perhaps there are places where there is not a single UN soldier. Going there where there are 17,000 UN soldiers... Between that and doing nothing, there is a balance we are trying to find. We do not want to do nothing.

QUESTION - You said in your speech in Strasbourg that you would not allow bad habits to settle in Europe again. You intended to weigh on the European stage, so I wanted to know how you think to do this concretely?

Secondly, under your Presidency, there has been a deterioration in relations between the European Union and China. What advice do you give to the Czech Presidency to establish good relations with China?

THE PRESIDENT - You have a particularly nice way of asking the question. Am I alone to bear the blame? Is it that the European Parliament did not receive the Dalai Lama? The Belgian Prime Minister did not receive the Dalai Lama? And the Czech Prime Minister did not receive the Dalai Lama? Am I mistaken? Because I do not know, listening to your question I was wondering if I was the only one responsible. I regret this tension. I regret it because I believe it is in Europe's interest to have good relations with China, and it is in China's interest to have good relations with Europe. Because when China consumes European products or sends us its tourists, it is good for the European economy. But when French and European companies order from Chinese companies, it is good for Chinese growth. It goes both ways.

Secondly, I went to the Olympic Games. As President of the European Council, I was the one who made the decision to go. Even if everyone supported me. But I had said that I would see the Dalai Lama before the end of 2008, I did it. It is not about having good or bad relations with a partner by letting them dictate your conduct. Friends do not dictate each other's conduct. They are vassals. The idea I have of Europe is a free, independent Europe, defending its values.

So the advice I give, first I have no advice to give, the rule I impose on myself is to react to all this with a lot of calm, a lot of serenity. There is only one China. I say this for Taiwan and for Tibet. And we need China in global governance. We will find ways to dialogue calmly and serenely. But not at the price of renouncing our own European values. By the way, are you German? That was indeed the position of Mrs. MERKEL? I believe that at the time she was not entirely understood by the entire German political class. You see that the axis between Mrs. MERKEL and me works well.

QUESTION - Mr. President, you explained to us that Europe needs strong institutions. However, if I remember correctly, the negotiators of Nice and Lisbon concluded that in order to have a strong Commission, it was necessary to have a smaller Commission. Did these negotiators make a mistake, or do you think that the Commission should have a different role, perhaps a little less centralizing?

THE PRESIDENT - I think they made a mistake. I have the right to have convictions. First of all, we asked that the new President of the Commission be appointed in July. The commitment I made, I kept. There will be European elections in June, based on the Treaty of Nice and the appointment of the President of the Commission in July. This is extremely important. You know my choice, my support; I have not changed and I have not wavered.

Secondly, regarding the Commission: it has an essential role, but I think it is a mistake to eliminate the Presidency every six months - it will remain, but it will not be in the same manner - and at the same time to deprive certain countries of a representative in the Commission. That is too much.

So, if we have Lisbon, certain countries will no longer preside over Europe. They will be somewhat virtual presidents since there will be an elected president for two and a half years. And if at the same time you deprive a national representation in the Commission, you are making a serious mistake. It is a serious mistake. The best proof is that all of this was not stabilized since the Treaty of Lisbon provided - you know very well, you are very familiar with the matters - that we would discuss it again in 2014. So it is clear that it was not so certain. But I find it too much to deny certain countries the possibility of a presidency and to additionally deny them a commissioner.

I add that if the Commission does not have a German commissioner and a French commissioner and three Baltic commissioners, in your opinion, is the Commission stronger or weaker?

Finally, last point, I give my point of view, I think that in the future we need to strengthen the powers of the President of the Commission. I explain myself, it is very simple, because the more commissioners you have, the more authority the President of the Commission must have over the commissioners so that there is a doctrine. Otherwise, it is chaos. We are twenty-two commissioners or thirty commissioners; I do not see what that changes to the problem. I tell you as I think: it changes nothing. So it is a commitment I made with full knowledge of the facts. It was that or no Lisbon. I find that it is not at all a sacrifice.

Finally, last point, the Commission needs strong leadership at the head of the European Council. Because if there is no strong leadership at the head of the European Council, the Commission then finds itself in a situation where it must both be the guardian of the spirit of the treaties and engage in politics. The right balance of our institutions is a political Council President who leads a Commission President, guardian of the spirit of the treaties, who must, in perfect partnership with the Council President, do his work at the intersection of technique and politics. If there is no strong leadership at the head of the Council, the Commission finds itself in a very unpleasant situation of having to be everything at once, which weakens it. This is the magic and subtlety of European institutions. I believe in it very strongly. Far from weakening the Commission, our proposal strengthens it. With a Commission President who has authority. During these six months, I often called Mr. Barroso to say: help us, because all your commissioners do not have the same speed of reaction. That is what I think. Now that I am leaving, I can say it.

QUESTION - Mr. President, to return very quickly to the assessment of your presidency, a presidency, as has been said, that has been a crisis management presidency. In the end, do you think you have reconciled the French with the idea of Europe?

THE PRESIDENT - Crisis management... still! The energy-climate package has nothing to do with crisis management. The European defense policy has nothing to do with crisis management. The Union for the Mediterranean with Israel, Deputy Secretary-General - let us pay tribute to the Marseille Summit, Bernard was fantastic - with the Palestinians, all the Arabs and the Arab League present, that is not crisis management.

Crisis management: we had a war, finance, and the economy. Have we reconciled? In any case, we have made progress. I think that the image of Europe today is stronger than it was at the beginning of the French Presidency. But the events have certainly served us.

But I would like to conclude by saying this: I was passionate about what I did. I was very happy to do it. It has been a great honor, not at all a burden. It has been a considerable opening of mind for me. It has been exciting, fulfilling, and quite easy. I think that when you have the chance to preside over twenty-seven countries like this, it is a fantastic opportunity, which you have no right to complain about. I have been President of the Council from the very first second and I will be until the last. I hope that all those who succeed me will love the job as much, because Europe deserves to be embodied, deserves to be defended, and deserves to have a face. I can truly say that I have made new friends, I have discovered many things.

I am not talking about you... Well, Merry Christmas!