Joint press conference of Mr. Nicolas Sarkozy, President of the Republic, Mr. José Manuel Barroso, President of the European Commission, and Mr. Manmohan Singh, Prime Minister of India, notably on Euro-Indian relations and the international financial crisis, in Marseille on September 29, 2008.

France Nicolas Sarkozy · President of France

29 September 2008 · Joint press conference following the Europe-India summit · Marseille, France

Context
Sarkozy, Barroso, and Singh held a joint press conference following an EU-India summit in Marseille on September 29, 2008, covering bilateral relations and the global financial crisis.
Main themes
EU-India strategic partnership, international financial crisis and reform, free trade agreement negotiations, climate change and clean energy, civil nuclear energy cooperation, global financial system re-founding, terrorism and security cooperation, Myanmar and Iran diplomatic concerns, Afghanistan and Pakistan situation, EURATOM participation, G8 coordination, international institutional reform
Duration
~30 min
82nd percentile
Words
3,574
82nd percentile
Sentences
173
85th percentile
Readability
44
45th percentile
Grade
12.0
46th percentile
Syntax
2.90
33rd percentile
Vocabulary
2.14
34th percentile

Translated from French

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

173 sentences in 46 paragraphs

THE PRESIDENT - Ladies and gentlemen, together with Prime Minister SINGH and President BARROSO, Javier SOLANA, Bernard KOUCHNER, Madame IDRAC, and Mr. MANDELSON, we have held a summit in Marseille, and I thank the Mayor for this, which I hope will mark a significant moment in the relationship between the European Union and India. In summary, before President BARROSO presents the concrete elements of our agreement, we wanted, together with the Indian Prime Minister, to show how strategic the relationship between Europe and India is. It is strategic in a commercial sense, and we have decided to accelerate discussions to negotiate a bilateral Europe-India free trade agreement. There has notably been a debate, an exchange between the Indian Minister of External Trade and Commissioner MANDELSON to see how we could move more quickly towards this agreement.

We also discussed an extremely concerning issue, which is climate change, and we welcomed the Indian government's willingness to move towards civil nuclear energy. President BARROSO proposed to India to participate, on all issues of research and security, in EURATOM, which is naturally consistent with India's desire to contribute to the success of the Poznan conference in December, because we have asserted that the world needs India to combat climate change.

We also talked about a number of extremely important files where we need India. We expressed to India our great concern regarding the situation in Myanmar, the intolerable attitude of the Burmese junta, particularly towards humanitarian organizations and humanitarian aid. I believe I can say that we have a convergence of views even though India, as a neighbor of Myanmar, has its own language.

We discussed the Iranian issue and the necessity to deter Iran from acquiring nuclear weapons. Here too, I believe I can say that there is a strong convergence of views between India and the European Union. We mentioned the issue of Afghanistan and the question of Pakistan, which will be the subject of further discussions during lunch.

And then, I would like to say that we have - I believe I can say it this way - a strong convergence of views on the financial crisis. In any case, in principle, on the necessity for major countries, economic powers of today and tomorrow, to coordinate to lay the foundations for a new international financial system. There is a clear awareness in India that it risks being affected, at some point, by the crisis that began to emerge in the United States.

I also wish to tell you in this regard that, concerning President BARROSO and myself, I will take the initiative, in agreement with President BARROSO, to gather in Paris in the coming days - of course, the President of the Commission, whose essential role is well known - the four European countries that are members of the G8: Germany, Great Britain, Italy, France, the President of the Eurozone, Mr. JUNCKER, and the President of the ECB, Mr. TRICHET, so that we can prepare in the best conditions for the global summit that I have called for on the re-founding of a new international financial system, so that Europe can speak with one voice as much as possible. We have also, with President BARROSO, discussed other initiatives that we will take in the coming days regarding the financial crisis.

MR. MANMOHAN SINGH - Mr. President, Dr. BARROSO, ladies and gentlemen of the press. From the outset, I would like to thank President SARKOZY for his extraordinary hospitality, the hospitality extended to me and to the members of my delegation in this beautiful city of Marseille.

We had very useful and constructive discussions with President SARKOZY as well as with the President of the Commission, Dr. BARROSO, and his colleagues. Our partnership, based on common values and our democratic commitment, human rights, fundamental freedoms, and pluralism, is an important pillar of the emerging new world order. We shared our views on our respective regions and exchanged ideas on global issues, including the current financial crisis, the reform of international institutions including the United Nations, energy and food security, climate change, and terrorism. We agreed to reach a total trade volume of 100 billion euros per year in the next five years and to conclude a bilateral free trade agreement between the European Union and India by 2009.

We reviewed the joint action plan of October 2005 and agreed to add new areas of cooperation, including vocational training, new biological technologies, the exploration of solar energy in India, and research in the field of civil nuclear energy, including fusion energy.

We discussed several issues related to the fight against terrorism, including cooperation between EUROPOL and its counterpart in India.

We launched a program on energy, clean development, and climate change that provides for collaboration in the field of clean coal technologies, energy efficiency, renewable energies, adaptation and combating climate change, and the transfer of climate-friendly technologies. Agreements between India and the European Union were signed yesterday, and we decided to work towards finalizing memoranda of understanding in the field of education and culture.

I am extremely satisfied with the discussions we had today. The fact that we hold annual summits between India and the European Union reflects the great importance that both parties attach to this strategic relationship. We are convinced that the strategic partnership between the European Union and India contributes to peace in the world, to prosperity in the world, and to its stability. I am confident that our relations will continue to grow and diversify based on the many synergies and complementarities that exist between us. Thank you.

THE PRESIDENT - Thank you, Mr. Prime Minister. Mr. President BARROSO.

MR. JOSE MANUEL BARROSO - Thank you, Mr. President. President SARKOZY and Prime Minister SINGH have just presented the essential content of our summit.

Allow me to highlight a few points. First of all, this cooperation between the European Union and India, which is the largest democracy in the world, is essential. I think it is important to recognize that our engagement with India also reflects this sharing of common values. In concrete terms, I am very pleased with the results of this summit because India and Europe have shown a common commitment to finding multilateral solutions to common challenges, from climate change to the organization of global trade, as well as peace, security, sustainable development, food prices, and energy security.

This is now reflected in the revision of the joint action plan that guides our cooperation. There are four priorities in this joint action plan: peace and security, sustainable development, research, and cultural exchanges.

We also decided to launch today a joint work program on energy, clean development, and climate change. I draw your attention to this because, especially considering the multilateral negotiation priorities for Poznan and Copenhagen, it is really important that India and Europe can work more on these very important issues. The European Investment Bank has just indicated its intention to sign loans totaling 300 million euros in the fields of renewable energies and technologies to reduce the impact of climate change.

Another aspect that I cannot fail to mention, especially in this city of Marseille that hosts us today, so close to Cadarache, is India's association with the ITER project. We have just finalized negotiations between Euratom and India regarding cooperation in the field of nuclear fusion. This agreement organizes the modalities of India's collaboration in the ITER project. I also proposed to Prime Minister SINGH, and he accepted this idea, that we could now cooperate between Euratom and India in the field of civil nuclear security and civil nuclear research. I think the time has come to reflect on the best way to reflect developments in international nuclear cooperation. It seems appropriate to explore, with all concerned parties, the possibility of scientific cooperation in this area.

We also discussed other issues. I will not go into detail, particularly the issue of hunger in the world, where Europe remains very committed.

I want to emphasize in concrete terms that this summit was also an opportunity to highlight the strategic importance of our trade and investment agreement. We emphasized the need to complete these negotiations, if possible, by 2009. Yesterday, the horizontal agreement on civil aviation was signed. This agreement should soon be followed by a new technical cooperation program in this sector. Soon, I hope, we will also be able to conclude an agreement on maritime transport.

The European side, especially President SARKOZY, also wanted to congratulate and commend Prime Minister SINGH for his remarks on the recent attacks against Christian communities in India. This is a minority that, of course, has its rights protected under the Indian Constitution, but we appreciated the vigor and clarity of Prime Minister SINGH's remarks, who unequivocally condemned these attacks.

We also discussed the issue of international finance with Prime Minister SINGH. And here, I would like to tell you something. As President SARKOZY has just pointed out, we need to do something on a global level. I want to commend the excellent cooperation that took place, even this weekend, between several European governments and some regulators, which allowed for the resolution of extremely sensitive issues. We commend these efforts.

In the same way, we commend the initiative taken by the U.S. Congress, which has reached a political agreement for an American bailout plan. It is clear that these are essential measures to restore confidence in the markets, but we need more structural measures. That is why I want to support the proposal made by President SARKOZY at the United Nations General Assembly for an international summit to address these issues, to find some structural proposals. We must prepare for this summit at the European level. That is why I support the initiative to gather the European G8 member countries, plus the President of the Eurogroup and the President of the European Central Bank. And I want to tell you that together, the French Presidency and the Commission, President SARKOZY and I, are preparing initiatives that we can present to the European Council on October 15. I find it essential, apart from the short-term measures that national regulators are taking in cooperation with the European Central Bank and the Commission, that beyond that, we can have a structural European response. This is the only way to ensure that stability and confidence can be restored. And the markets will react, I am sure, positively to these initiatives. Thank you.

THE PRESIDENT - Ladies and gentlemen, we will now take your questions.

QUESTION - I would like to know if you could tell us more about cooperation in the field of civil nuclear energy and whether we can now expect an agreement to be signed between France and India on this issue tomorrow during the bilateral meeting in Paris?

MR. MANMOHAN SINGH - Ladies and gentlemen, India is seeking cooperation with all countries of the world on all issues related to the promotion of civil nuclear energy in our country. The U.S. Congress is currently voting on legislation that will allow for bilateral cooperation in this area between India and the United States. Some time ago, the Nuclear Suppliers Group agreed to adapt its guidelines to allow cooperation with India on all issues related to civil nuclear cooperation. We welcome the opportunity to work with France as well as with other countries in this area. Tomorrow, we have a bilateral summit with France. This is an issue that will be discussed, and I hope that results will emerge from this meeting.

THE PRESIDENT - We discussed this when I had the pleasure and honor of being received in India with Mr. KOUCHNER. I have always believed that India is a major power. In 20 or 30 years, India will be the world's most populous country, and I do not see how we can tell our Indian friends: participate in the fight against climate change but without civil nuclear energy, which we know is the cleanest energy. It is a total inconsistency. France, which trusts India, which trusts the Indian Prime Minister, has worked hard to ensure that India can access civil nuclear energy.

We are pleased that things are moving forward. Tomorrow, I will have the pleasure of receiving the Indian Prime Minister for a summit, this time not an EU-India summit, but an India-France summit. It is quite likely that we will have to discuss this issue and make decisions.

QUESTION - I have a question for the Prime Minister. You mentioned the agreement that is to be concluded by 2009 - the end of 2009 - but it seems that the project does not align with the positions adopted by India as the negotiations have evolved.

MR. MANMOHAN SINGH - Listen, these are ongoing negotiations. We understand what the issues are on the table, how we will address them. Even if we have not resolved everything, we have time to resolve these issues by the date mentioned in the joint communiqué.

QUESTION - This is a question for the President of the Republic. As we saw this weekend, the financial crisis is worsening in Europe. There has been a nationalization in Great Britain, a rescue plan for Fortis, and this morning, Dexia is plummeting on the Paris stock exchange. You said last week that you would take your responsibilities, that you would guarantee French banks, you said this in Toulon. How will this be implemented, and are you afraid of potential contagion to other French banks?

THE PRESIDENT - Well, the financial crisis is testing the financial sector, including in Europe. This weekend, we worked a lot, President BARROSO and I. Contacts have multiplied between the various European governments. The situation calls for rapid responses. Everyone must show composure and a sense of responsibility. What I said in Toulon, I confirm today, and I note with great interest that what I said last week in Toulon is being implemented today by our European partners.

I noted with satisfaction, as did President BARROSO, that an agreement has been reached in the United States between the Administration and Congress on the plan known as PAULSON. This is good news. Furthermore, in the United Kingdom, Belgium, Luxembourg, the Netherlands, and Germany, what have the states done? They have intervened to ensure the security and stability of the financial system in their countries and thus in Europe. I fully support these initiatives, which go exactly in the same direction as the commitment I made in Toulon. We must not yield to destabilization. We must support our banks. But beyond the cyclical problem that calls for composure and determination, there is the structural problem. How did we get here? Under what conditions? I reaffirm my call for a summit in the coming weeks to lay the foundations for a new international financial system. The meeting to which I will invite the four European G8 leaders, the President of the Eurozone, the President of the European Central Bank, along with President BARROSO, is to prepare all of this.

I add that with President BARROSO, it is our responsibility to set the agenda for the European Council on October 15. We decided this weekend that, of course, we will discuss the financial situation and that we will make proposals in this regard. Let it be clear: we are working hand in hand. Europe proved, during the conflict between Russia and Georgia, that it existed. Europe must show the same determination in economic and financial policy regarding the crisis we are experiencing. That is exactly what we are determined to do, President BARROSO and I.

QUESTION - My question is for President SARKOZY and Prime Minister SINGH. Mr. President, could you tell us more about the discussions you had regarding Pakistan? Does the European Union think that the way the United States is attacking certain regions of Pakistan is a legitimate way to intervene in that country? Mr. Prime Minister, can you tell us about the assurances given by the European Union regarding Iran?

MR. MANMOHAN SINGH - Regarding our attitude towards the Iranian nuclear program, I have explained it several times and I reiterated it at this morning's meeting with President SARKOZY. I said that Iran is a signatory to the Non-Proliferation Treaty, and as a signatory to the Non-Proliferation Treaty, Iran has the right to have everything necessary to develop cooperation in the field of a civil nuclear program, and as a member of the Non-Proliferation Treaty, it must also comply with all the obligations that arise from it.

We do not support the idea of a state armed with nuclear weapons. Therefore, there is absolutely no question of supporting Iran's nuclear military ambitions. This is the position I explained to President SARKOZY and his colleagues this morning.

THE PRESIDENT - Regarding Pakistan, I had the opportunity with Bernard KOUCHNER to meet the new Pakistani President. I told him how fundamental it is for us that Pakistan commits itself unreservedly to the fight against extremists. Any leniency towards extremists would first be paid for, as we saw recently with that abominable and cowardly attack on the Marriott hotel. I must say that I was struck by the determination shown by the new Pakistani President.

We want to help Pakistan. If Pakistan fights decisively against extremists and the Taliban, then the question of incursions by non-Pakistani armed forces will no longer arise. We stand by Pakistan in the fight to defend the values of democracy. This is a major issue for security and for the balance of the world. We will have the opportunity with Bernard KOUCHNER - he has already been - to go to Pakistan to lay the foundations for this essential collaboration. We need Pakistan to ensure that the Afghan people have the conditions for peace and development to which they are entitled.

QUESTION - I have a question for the Prime Minister and the President. A topic was raised by President BARROSO regarding Christians in India. Did the Indian Prime Minister mention the issue of Sikhs in France regarding the need to wear turbans? I would also like to ask Mr. BARROSO about this blue card, which is currently a very diluted version, and with the economy suffering, will you return to the way you presented this blue card?

THE PRESIDENT - We respect Sikhs, their customs, their traditions, and they are welcome in France. But we have rules, rules regarding the neutrality of civil servants, rules regarding secularism. These rules do not apply specifically to Sikhs, Muslims, or anyone else; they apply to everyone. On the territory of the French Republic, the rules of the French Republic apply to everyone, without exception. There is no discrimination. Rest assured that Sikhs are welcome and that we respect their traditions and habits, just as we are sure that they also respect the laws, traditions, and customs of the French Republic.

Secondly, I would not have gone so far as to compare the issue of the turban, however important it may be, with the massacres that Christians have suffered. I think that they are not of the same nature, you will agree.

I would like to say that I was happy to affirm my friendship with the Indian Prime Minister, who is a courageous man, and the words he used to condemn the massacre of Christians do honor to India. I had the opportunity to tell him this, President BARROSO also said it, we expressed our deep concern regarding Christians, but we are reassured by the determination of the Indian Prime Minister. I knew he was a courageous man; he has shown it once again.

MR. JOSE MANUEL BARROSO - Regarding this blue card, we made a proposal, as you know, precisely to make it easier for professionals, graduates to come to Europe. We want more people to come to Europe, namely migrants, particularly skilled and qualified migrants. Sometimes they face difficulties. This proposal is being negotiated in the Council, and I believe the final result will be positive. Naturally, sometimes we desire more ambitious results, but that is how we work in the European Union. You must understand, we are twenty-seven countries, and therefore, in the end, it is a compromise among all these countries because it is closely linked to their national sovereignty. But I believe the result will be positive, a balanced position that will facilitate Indians, in particular, to come to Europe and also to cooperate within our member states.

MR. MANMOHAN SINGH - Regarding the Christian minority in India, allow me to say that India is a secular state. We are a country that is multi-racial, with multiple religions, and the Constitution of India guarantees all citizens of India their freedom and right to preach and practice the religion of their choice. There have been some sporadic incidents in certain regions of our country, but our government has taken a very firm position. I myself condemned these acts by saying that they were acts that brought shame to the country. The central government has sent its forces to enable state forces to uphold the rule of law. I would like to reaffirm again that the government of India and our entire country will always defend the secular values that are the very foundation of the Indian Constitution. We respect the rights of all religious minorities to profess and preach the religion of their choice.

THE PRESIDENT - Ladies and gentlemen, thank you.