Statement by Mr. Nicolas Sarkozy, President of the Republic, on the constitutional law of July 23, 2008, for the modernization of the institutions of the Fifth Republic, in Paris on October 1, 2008.

France Nicolas Sarkozy · President of France

1 October 2008 · Statement on the constitutional law of July 23, 2008 for the modernization of the institutions of the Fifth Republic · Paris, France

Context
Sarkozy addressed a ceremony in Paris to seal the constitutional law of July 23, 2008, marking the most significant reform of France's Fifth Republic since 1962.
Main themes
Constitutional reform of the Fifth Republic, modernization of institutions, sealing of constitutional law, presidential term limits, strengthening parliamentary powers, executive legitimacy, cross-party consensus, institutional stability, Fifth Republic history
Duration
~15 min
52nd percentile
Words
1,816
52nd percentile
Sentences
79
52nd percentile
Readability
44
47th percentile
Grade
12.6
52nd percentile
Syntax
2.97
43rd percentile
Vocabulary
2.23
57th percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 65%65%
  • Ceremonial 27%27%
  • Geopolitical 6%6%
  • Social 1%1%
  • Environmental 1%1%
  • Economic 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

79 sentences in 31 paragraphs

Mr. Prime Minister,

Mr. President of the Senate,

Mr. President of the National Assembly,

Madam Keeper of the Seals, dear Rachida,

Mr. President of the Committee for the Modernization and Rebalancing of the Institutions of the Fifth Republic, dear Édouard,

Ladies and Gentlemen, and, if you allow me, dear friends,

It has been more than a century since the sealing of laws, even constitutional ones, is no longer a condition for their validity, nor for their entry into force. However, the practice of sealing our most solemn texts has persisted, thus demonstrating our particular attachment to them. This was the case for the Constitution of October 4, 1958, which was sealed in this place by Michel Debré exactly fifty years ago. This was also the case for the main constitutional laws that modified it. But it was also the case, for example, for the law of October 9, 1981, abolishing the death penalty.

It is therefore natural that we gather here this morning to proceed with the sealing of the constitutional law of July 23, 2008, modernizing the institutions of the Fifth Republic. By the number of articles concerned and the scope of the modifications undertaken, this law constitutes the most significant reform of the Constitution since 1962.

I want to take this opportunity to thank all those who have invested and mobilized to enable the adoption of this text:

- First and foremost, Mr. Prime Minister Édouard Balladur, and the members of the committee he graciously chaired, among whom are Jack Lang, who showed great courage and foresight in this matter, and Pierre Mazeaud - but this does not mean that the other members were not insightful and courageous; they were. I would like to thank Mr. Prime Minister Balladur for the high quality of the work he chaired and for the commitment of the committee members to the modernization of our Constitution. These members were diverse, coming from different political backgrounds. They demonstrated a great sense of the general interest. I want to mention among them the constitutionalists, the law professors who helped us greatly and who engaged both within the Committee and outside it. You did beautiful work, and above all, you prioritized the general interest. When compared to some smaller reactions, your work stands out even more.

- I would also like to thank the members of the Government and the parliamentarians who were particularly involved, of course the Prime Minister, the Keeper of the Seals, the Minister for Relations with Parliament, but also all the ministers who committed themselves, the presidents of the Assemblies, who understood before many parliamentarians that it would be good for parliamentarians to vote for a strengthening of their powers, the rapporteurs - Jean-Luc Warsmann and Jean-Jacques Hyest - the group presidents who had to overcome much inertia.

We had a dense, vigorous, always dignified debate of high quality, which revolved around deep convictions. It is no minor exercise to modify 47 articles of the Constitution with several hundred pens at once; it is even the first time that such a reform of our institutions has been undertaken in a parliamentary framework, as everyone had their concerns: for some, Turkey; for others, the powers of the executive; for others still, the rights of citizens. But in the end, it matters little: all of this was dignified, and everyone understood that the movement would allow for the modernization of our Constitution. Ultimately, even if everyone may find fault with one provision or another, no one can contest that this is an ambitious, balanced, and profoundly coherent text, and no one can claim that a soft consensus could prevail over the reformist ambition. Some would have liked to go further, others would have preferred to go less far, but I observe with great interest that no one contests the relevance of this reform. Believe me, I am pleased about that.

- It is finally just to thank all those who, in the ministries, the administrations, the ministerial cabinets, facilitated, in the shadows and with discretion, the perfect success of this reform. Prime Minister Balladur will not hold it against me for having a special message for Emmanuelle Mignon, who relayed the Committee with her quick pen. In total, this is a great reform, and I want to express my deep gratitude to all.

In this solemn moment, everyone realizes the importance of the stakes attached to this constitutional revision.

The Constitution of 1958 brought to our institutions a stability that they sorely lacked and a strong executive capable of undertaking the necessary reforms for the country. This is an incomparable asset to which the law of July 23 does not in any way detract, especially since it, on the contrary, strengthens the legitimacy of the institutions of the Republic.

Limiting the number of consecutive terms of the President of the Republic to two encourages the President to act rather than to endure. We have had so much time to endure; the time has come to act, even if it changes habits. Establishing a parliamentary veto on executive appointments prevents certain individuals from being appointed for reasons of collusion rather than for reasons of competence. Setting a requirement for choices based on competence and independence of mind is what we expect from the Republic. Allowing the President to come and speak before Congress asks him to explain his actions while valuing national representation. Subjecting the examination of texts to non-negotiable deadlines, having them preceded by an impact study, framing the use of the accelerated procedure, the new name for the emergency procedure, is choosing better quality standards and therefore greater efficiency.

But a strong executive is not incompatible with a strong Parliament. General de Gaulle called for both. They are, on the contrary, complementary. Each must support the other because reform is difficult. In the world we live in, where everything is fluid and complex, no one can govern alone. The executive and the legislative must balance each other so that each uses its powers while being aware of its responsibilities.

The government can refuse to engage in dialogue with Parliament, but it exposes itself to the risk that the law will not be adopted. The executive can send troops abroad, but it now knows that it will have to account to Parliament. Parliament can vote on a resolution, but it can no longer maneuver between the insidious criticism of government action and the questioning of the government's responsibility.

Since 1958, the institutional balance of our country has increasingly tilted in favor of the executive, starting with the President of the Republic. I regretted that when France chose the five-year term, it did not draw any other consequences in terms of institutional reform, while the five-year term has been an additional cause of imbalance. It was therefore necessary to rebalance our institutions. We have done so with a constant concern for the middle ground, without weakening the executive, but without cheating with Parliament, whose powers, Mr. Prime Minister, have been considerably strengthened.

The law of July 23, 2008, also grants new substantial rights to citizens. This is not the least of its merits.

By allowing citizens to contest, through the exception, the conformity of a law with the rights and freedoms constitutionally guaranteed, France rises to the rank of the most advanced democracies and fills one of its main gaps in terms of the rule of law. What almost all Europeans could do by appealing to the supreme judge, the French were prohibited from doing. Who could be satisfied with this situation?

In the face of the impersonal machinery of administration and modern societies, the defender of rights gives each citizen the guarantee of being able to assert their rights. He is a face of equity; he is a face of humanity in an increasingly cold and procedural society.

By transforming the Economic and Social Council into the Economic, Social and Environmental Council, the law of July 23 places ecology at the heart of our concerns, as current generations demand and as our sense of responsibility towards future generations requires.

By allowing French citizens abroad to have deputies, we recognize - and this is no small matter - that two million French people who proudly represent France in the world are citizens like any others.

By opening the Superior Council of the Judiciary to society and allowing litigants to approach it directly, we fully embody our conception of justice rendered in the name of the French people, who have the right to demand a sense of responsibility from those who exercise power.

In the very year we celebrate its fiftieth anniversary, our Constitution has managed to reform itself; it has managed to modernize. In a world where everything changes, it has given itself the means to change as well, without losing anything of what makes its strength and effectiveness over time. It has chosen more balanced institutions, an exemplary Republic, and an irreproachable democracy.

It is now our responsibility to draft and adopt the organic laws, ordinary laws, and assembly regulations necessary for the implementation of the reform. We must do so while maintaining high the ambitions that presided over the law of July 23. It will then be up to our institutional practice to bring the spirit of this revision to life.

With the Prime Minister, we have thus wished to apply the reform even before it is strictly legally applicable, concerning the engagement of French soldiers in Afghanistan. I observe with interest that those who were most opposed to the constitutional reform in July were in September the most ardent in asking me for its anticipatory application. Ladies and gentlemen, the Republic will remain the Republic as long as those who were wrong in July can try to be right in September. I want to say to everyone that France has strengthened the legitimacy of its choice in Afghanistan by organizing this debate and this vote. This debate and this vote did not weaken France; they strengthened it.

Each of us will certainly now be keen to give full measure to each of the new rights. That is why, as you have understood, I am very happy, and why not say it, proud to preside, in the company of the Committee, the parliamentarians, the Government, this ceremony of sealing the constitutional law of July 23, 2008.

July 23, 2008, will remain a date, Mr. Prime Minister Balladur, in the history of the Fifth Republic. This date will be associated with your name, with the action of your Committee and this small number who were willing to resist corporatism, conservatism, inertia, and all those who think that one is faithful to France by keeping it immobile, while I believe that France is faithful to its history by looking to the future and not burdening itself with all the inertia that has held it captive for so long.

Thank you.