Statement by Mr. Nicolas Sarkozy, President of the Republic, on the future of the printed press, in Paris on October 2, 2008.

France Nicolas Sarkozy · President of France

2 October 2008 · Opening of the General States of the Written Press · Palais de l'Élysée, Paris, France

Context
Sarkozy addressed press owners, journalists, and media professionals at the Élysée Palace for the opening of the General States of the Written Press on October 2, 2008.
Main themes
Future of the printed press, press freedom and independence, digital revolution and structural crisis, state aid and public funding, press pluralism and democracy, distribution and printing costs, economic viability of press companies, role of the state in media, General States of the Written Press, journalism and public trust, constitutional reform and media, post-war press regulations
Duration
~34 min
87th percentile
Words
4,112
87th percentile
Sentences
202
89th percentile
Readability
49
61st percentile
Grade
11.4
38th percentile
Syntax
2.98
44th percentile
Vocabulary
2.21
51st percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 42%42%
  • Institutional 23%23%
  • Social 22%22%
  • Ceremonial 7%7%
  • Geopolitical 3%3%
  • Technological 2%2%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

202 sentences in 90 paragraphs

Madam Minister,

Ladies and gentlemen of the Parliament,

Ladies and gentlemen presidents, directors, representatives of professional organizations, press groups, publications,

Ladies and gentlemen professionals of the press and media,

Ladies and gentlemen journalists,

Ladies and gentlemen,

I am pleased to welcome you to the Palais de l'Élysée for the opening of the General States of the Written Press, which I announced before the summer holidays.

Since that announcement, most of you have expressed your interest in this initiative and your desire to be involved.

The truth is that all of you present here, journalists, press owners, printers, distributors, you have been waiting for these General States, you have even been demanding them for a long time. Each of you knew that it was necessary, that it was urgent, each of you was well aware that the status quo could no longer last, that the crisis was worsening year after year, this crisis which is both a structural crisis, with the digital revolution, but also, as everyone knows, a distinctly French crisis: high printing and distribution costs, weakness of the distribution network, lack of financial stability of press companies, loss of trust between journalists and readers...

The Head of State, as the guarantor of institutions, must ensure that the press has the conditions for its existence and development.

The press is part of the balance of powers. What is bad for it is bad for democracy. The press is an economic product; it obeys the law of supply and demand, it must be profitable. This is still the best way for it to be independent. But the press is not and will never be a product like any other. For this reason, it cannot be left to the sole forces of the market.

In the wake of the sealing of a constitutional law marked by the ideal of an exemplary Republic, our country is therefore continuing its march towards a more mature, more balanced democracy, reflecting on the role that the press plays in an irreproachable democracy, and giving itself the means to strengthen it.

The difficulties in your sector are multiple, complex, and sensitive. They extend, to varying degrees, from our major national and regional daily newspapers to magazines and specialized press, from print media to digital media. Their complexity results from a tangle of problems accumulated over time and never truly addressed. The internet and free publications exacerbate the problems. They did not create them.

The financial crisis could tempt us to postpone change once again. I believe, on the contrary, that it justifies it more than ever.

In many respects, the State is fulfilling its role by proposing and organizing these General States.

Each year, it allocates nearly 1 billion euros to the press, about 10% of its turnover. As a major player in the system, the State must be the first to question, with you, the effectiveness of this public aid.

In the aftermath of the Second World War, the State also directly set the rules governing the press that still exist today. At that time, it did so for legitimate reasons: the sharing of the scarcity of paper, printing presses, and transport, the availability of printing presses, pluralism, the free communication of ideas as well as the ethics of information. It was right to do so.

But the economic and societal environment of the press has completely changed. It is therefore up to the State to verify that the rules it created still achieve the goals they set out to accomplish.

This is not the case. The post-war system, inspired by the ideal of the Resistance, was meant to promote a flourishing, independent, and diverse daily press of general and political information. However, never has the daily general press been in such poor shape as it is today.

Our responsibility is, of course, to ensure the necessary conditions for the existence of a free, independent, and pluralistic press. The constitutional law of July 23, 2008, recently reminded us of this.

Our responsibility is also to ensure the economic health of a sector that supports tens of thousands of people, hundreds of SMEs, and contributes to the well-being of all.

That is why the State will do what it has to do. It will take its responsibilities.

However, everyone here knows well that the future of the press largely rests on your shoulders. Your difficulties will find no solution if you remain divided, as you have so often in the past, instead of uniting to create the conditions for change together.

That is why I do not want the State to decide in your place, to choose on behalf of your press companies. It could not do so anyway. On the contrary, I wanted the General States to involve all concerned actors in a common desire to share a diagnosis and to identify solutions. I am pleased to see that this is indeed how they have been received.

Identifying solutions is the ultimate goal of the General States. It is not just about voicing grievances, even if that is important. It is not about writing yet another report on the subject, even if very good ones have been written in the past. It is about agreeing on a number of changes to be implemented so that the French written press can emerge from the unacceptable difficulties it has faced for 30 years, which will only worsen if nothing is done.

Today, as you will have understood, I want to speak to you frankly. Because I believe that it is due to a failure to confront the truth that your sector is in crisis.

Of course, we should not caricature the situation of the French press. The French are among the world's top magazine readers. Regional and departmental daily press has managed to maintain the attachment of its readers thanks to quality, local information, and appropriate distribution. News websites are among the most consulted, reflecting a strong demand for information and highlighting the structuring role of "brands" in the digital communication landscape.

Likewise, we should not underestimate the difficulties faced by the written press in other Western democracies. We are not alone, even if we are among the most severely affected. Everywhere in the developed world, the written press is confronted with the triple impact of the digital revolution: the culture of immediacy, the culture of free content, the transformation of the advertising market. Everywhere, paid print media must justify their existence in the face of an exhaustive, global, immediately accessible, and largely free digital offer. Everywhere, journalists are questioning the future of their profession, the role of their craft. Less and less collectors of information, they wonder, in the age of blogs and participatory sites, how to convince their readers that their mediation is still useful, still necessary.

I also want to ensure that the roles of each party in the evolution of our written press over the past 30 years are not misrepresented or stigmatized: vilifying the Book Syndicate to better silence the responsibility of publishers is all too common; railing against journalists' copyright to better obscure the investment delays in the web is all too frequent; criticizing content and editorial choices to avoid discussing production or distribution is all too classic.

The General States cannot be a platform for invective, nor for a one-sided view of the problems. They must be a space for the good faith search for common solutions. The questions they have to address are sensitive and complex enough that they should not be treated with excess, approximation, or caricature.

On this subject, as on others, we do not start from a blank slate. In terms of the press, more than in many other sectors, it would be illusory to say that history does not matter. This history, the particular history of each of your groups, of each of your titles, we want it to continue. We want your cultures, your journalistic traditions, to thrive.

That is why, alongside the major groups, we must preserve the conditions for an autonomous press arising from collective, individual, or family histories, which make your sector a patchwork of personal adventures, passionate citizens, and committed personalities.

That said, fleeing from excess, caricature, and simplification, on which nothing can be built, cannot lead us to once again turn a blind eye to the extent of the crisis facing the French press.

Declining circulation, falling advertising revenues, the collapse of the advertising market, the press cannot simultaneously cope with the 35-hour workweek, rising wages, and increasing raw material costs.

Attracted by the internet and free publications, or disappointed by the content, readership is dwindling and aging.

As for digital press, it does not currently represent a viable alternative model. How could it, when it is free for the reader, much cheaper for the advertiser, and subject to limitless competition?

Beyond the very real economic impasse for many of you, it is the model of the written word that is at stake. We cannot be indifferent to this, as the role of the written word is essential for the formation of consciousness and the structuring of public debate. Regularly reading a daily newspaper or a general and political information magazine places one in a position to receive general information about the state of society and the world. This is a very different approach from seeking information on the internet according to one's whims, needs, and interests.

We must preserve and nurture this desire for general information, this long-term civic education. It is up to you to do this by working on content. It is up to us to help you by creating the conditions for an economic model that allows you to thrive.

What has made and will always make the press, what gives it and will always give it its independence, what ensures it has investors, that it is respected, that it participates in the democratic debate, is that it is read.

For that, it needs to invest: invest in readership, invest in editorial projects, invest in networks and distribution methods, invest in digital sites, invest in solid newsrooms capable of meeting the needs for analysis and investigative information that is verified, prioritized, courageous, and free.

However, the prevailing trend in the press, particularly in political and general information, the trend we must combat, that we must correct, is the impoverishment. Impoverishment of content when less than 20% of sales prices are allocated to them. Impoverishment of newsrooms when social plans drain newspapers of their reason for being, journalism. Impoverishment of networks with the disappearance of too many foreign correspondents. Impoverishment of the profession with poorly paid, poorly equipped, precarious journalists. Impoverishment of press companies with insufficient equity to invest, innovate, and prepare for the future.

The central challenge of the General States is to put an end to this vicious circle that forces the press to exhaust itself in a relentless race to survive external shocks of costs, competition, and societal changes over which it has no control or has lost control.

My conviction is that there is no inevitability.

No inevitability that the printing and distribution costs of the press are among the highest in the world, and our newspapers among the most expensive.

No inevitability that our press is the least well distributed and that dailies arrive at readers' homes when they are already at work.

No inevitability that it is unthinkable to create new dailies in France, even if I have noted, as you all have, recent announcements in this regard. This is the first blow to pluralism and the free communication of ideas and opinions.

No inevitability that circulation is declining, while circulation is increasing in Italy, Sweden, Denmark, as well as that of free publications, such as Le Parisien - Aujourd'hui en France, Les Echos, or La Croix. The reality is that there is still a demand when the offer meets expectations and is well distributed.

No inevitability that the undercapitalization of press groups exists, provided that a newspaper is a profitable activity. No inevitability that the presence of French companies among global multimedia groups is weak, provided that we first allow French groups to establish themselves in France.

Whether in print or online, I believe in the future of the written word because, more than ever in our complex world, I believe in the necessity of analysis and investigation.

I believe in the future of paid journalism because I believe in the value of verified, analyzed, sorted, and prioritized information. I do not oppose free press and paid press. If the free press has advertisers, it is because it has an audience. And if it has an audience, it is because it meets a need. But I do not believe that there will come a day when no one is willing to pay for analysis and investigation. I do not believe that there will come a day when no one will agree to buy a newspaper every morning, because in addition to information, we buy a culture, a story, a layout, references, habits, authors, editorial choices, and more than anything, perhaps, a vision, commitments, boldness, and talent.

It is madness to believe that advertising will one day finance all information: free access is a delusion and the death of the printed press.

I also believe in the future of paper. I know well that younger generations are growing up in and with the digital universe. I know that experiments are underway to develop digital newspaper readers, halfway between a computer and a mobile phone, which reconcile the comfort of paper and the accessibility of digital. This "electronic paper" is indeed a promising niche for new and real revenue for the press, unlike the Internet, which struggles to impose a paid model.

But I do not believe in a sudden, irreversible, and even less total shift of the printed press to the digital universe. I rather believe in their complementarity.

What is certain is that in the face of the uncertainties of the future, in the face of the impossibility of predicting the evolution of reading habits, the role of public power is to create the conditions for your professional environment to be healthy, to preserve your economic balances, to enable you to seize all the opportunities of a society more than ever eager for knowledge, culture, and information, to allow your activity to adapt continuously without constraint and without hindrance, and to ensure that innovation is possible and encouraged.

The essential thing is not to protect the medium; it is to protect "the brand." It is not to protect paper; it is to protect the written word.

I want to say this clearly: press subsidies are naturally part of the reflection of the États généraux. Together with all professionals, the State must question their objectives and their effectiveness; it must reflect on the issue of scattering and ask whether the subsidies are going where they should go.

But if the State is ready to take its responsibilities to better assist the press in its transformations, the outcome of the États généraux cannot be limited to a reallocation or an increase in subsidies without any structural change. The press needs subsidies; that is a fact. But it also needs a clarified economic context. Otherwise, we would be providing the same solutions to the same questions.

To organize the work, I have asked four respected, independent personalities, all with extensive experience in the world of journalism, to chair four discussion and proposal poles, four working groups, which will together form the États généraux of the press.

Bruno Frappat, a great journalist and editorialist, who has worked for Dauphiné Libéré, Le Monde, and La Croix, and is currently the president of the Bayard group, will chair the working group tasked with reflecting on the future of journalism professions.

I believe it is crucial to dedicate an entire field of reflection to this question and to the role of writing in the society to come. Because the crisis of the press is primarily a crisis of journalism.

This group will be tasked with reflecting, in particular, on initial and ongoing training, responsibility, the rights and duties of editorial teams, reader trust, the status and ethics of journalists, their remuneration, and their copyright.

I want to say this clearly as well: at a time when it was so easy to flatter young people by turning a blind eye to illegal downloading, I fought to defend the copyright of artists and producers. Today I will fight to assert that copyright is an essential principle, but it is unrealistic that within the same title, one cannot publish the same article on multiple platforms without having to pay for it multiple times.

And then I want to tell the press that it must reflect on certain of its practices. Outreau, the Baudis affair, these are realities. You have everything to gain by daring to talk about them.

I thank Bruno Frappat for agreeing to take on this sensitive reflection. I know that journalists, in their diversity, but also in the face of the major questions posed by the future of their profession, trust him to create a dynamic of hope, honesty, freedom, and responsibility.

Arnaud de Puyfontaine, former deputy director of Le Figaro, who later became president of Emap and Mondadori France, and former president of the Association for the Promotion of Magazine Press (APPM), will chair a pole dedicated to the industrial process of the press.

Yes, the printed press is an industry. Printing, transporting, distributing, prospecting, the printed press is an extremely sophisticated logistics operation serving an extremely fragile and perishable product: the newspaper.

This project is all the more crucial as it is the place of all fatalisms, the fatalism of printing, the fatalism of distribution, while concrete progress can be achieved if only it is decided.

Like many of you, I believe that distribution is the primary problem of the printed press. At a time when marketing has become so important, it is still remarkable that the press is so poorly sold! That the profession of newspaper seller is among the most thankless and least well-paid! That a distributor spends more time moving unsold items than getting to know their clientele and improving their offer! That finding a newspaper on Saturday, Sunday, or during holidays, at a tobacco shop or in a supermarket, is a feat! And that abroad, French press is hard to find!

I wonder about the implications of Article 1 of the Bichet law, which states that "the distribution of printed and free press," when this law actually offers no flexibility?

It is not a matter of throwing the baby out with the bathwater, forgetting that the mutualization of distribution allows for cost reduction and ensures a pluralistic distribution of the press. It is a matter of taking stock of the archaic nature of our system and the dramatic disadvantages that result from it.

The NMPP has undertaken a modernization plan to increase the number of distributors and improve the attractiveness of the profession. I know the sensitivity of the ongoing negotiations. But we must move faster, further, and stronger.

Similarly, the distribution of the press by the Post Office has recently been the subject of new negotiations. I know the importance of the efforts made by all actors. But we must strongly develop home delivery, which is a priority avenue for the distribution of daily press and an important source of jobs. Regional dailies have shown the way.

Digital technology generates a lot of hope. It is a new press to be invented and offers so many opportunities to seize.

But digital also presents many threats: fragmentation and evolution of usage, the pressure of free access, the uncertain respect for intellectual property, the risk of a decline in the quality of information, the transformation of the advertising market which primarily focuses, and in very high proportions, on a few globally known sites, but never French ones.

Digital press has not yet found its economic model; that is a fact. However, it is a horizon line for a large part of the press. This major issue will be addressed by Bruno Patino, the new director of France Culture and former vice-president of the management board of Le Monde group, former president of Monde Interactif and Télérama, whose reflection on this subject is visionary and recognized.

Finally, François Dufour, a journalist, editor-in-chief of three children's dailies, co-founder of the Play Bac group, which has been able to create and develop new concepts on paper, and who represents the national daily press at the World Association of Newspapers, will be responsible for addressing the questions related to the relationship between the press and society.

What is the role of the press in a contemporary democracy and how can it be strengthened? What are the expectations of the readership and how can trust be regained? How can the editorial offer be modernized? How can we bring young people back to reading dailies? How can we guarantee pluralism, independence, and the coexistence of media companies of all sizes? What are the obstacles to the formation of large French press and multimedia groups?

The media industry, culture, and creation will be among the greatest factors of wealth and employment in the coming years. There is no reason for foreign groups to come and invest in our country while no French group, or so few, invests in France or abroad.

This question is not taboo, nor is the increasing concentration of regional press, nor the rights and duties of editorial teams. It is not separable, nor is it incompatible with the protection of pluralism and opinion press, in a context where the number of platforms has significantly increased.

With these four personalities, the États généraux are in good hands, I am certain of that. I can only thank them, and those who will come to assist them, for accepting my proposal. They will meet frequently within a steering committee coordinated by Bernard Spitz, my office, the Minister of Culture, and the media development department.

I have asked these four personalities to conduct very broad consultations and to form working groups representative of the entire profession. They will make proposals to me in the coming days, which will take your suggestions into account.

An Internet site, which I hope will be relayed by your own sites, as well as public debate days, are planned.

I wish for readers, consumers, and citizens to be involved in the États généraux. The press should not only speak to professionals in the press.

Similarly, I have proposed that journalism schools that wish to participate in the work, possibly in connection with management schools, be involved, and I thank them for the favorable reception they have given to this proposal.

Finally, it seems essential to me to document ourselves on the press sector in countries that are comparable to ours, to learn from their successes as well as their failures, while of course maintaining our lucidity about the specificities of our system and our freedom to preserve them.

The États généraux of the press must not be a sham of consultation. In the face of the magnitude of the issues, I believe in the power of discussion. I will listen and take into account what is said. My demand is that difficult subjects are not, once again, evaded.

We do not have the right to fail. All subjects are on the table, the most technical - state aid, legal and judicial announcements, the sponsorship regime, the sharing of value in the distribution chain, home delivery - as well as the most sensitive - independence, pluralism, credibility, the Bichet law, the future of book workers...

I hope that a frank discussion will lead to ambitious decisions, which do not boil down to the lowest common denominator, which could only be that of state aid. My goal, I repeat, is that we find shared solutions. For that, everyone must commit.

It is not only the future of publishers that is at stake. It is that of the entire profession: journalists, printers, press operators, distributors, and sellers...

In two months, we will take stock of the progress of the process. My wish is to be able to quickly engage with you in the necessary reforms, legislative, regulatory, fiscal, and financial, heralding hope and change. I call on the responsibility of each of you. I call on your love for the profession, your love for the press, your love for democracy. The press must succeed in its adaptation to the world of the 21st century. We must be, we will be, up to this challenge. I am convinced of it.