Press conference by Mr. Nicolas Sarkozy, President of the Republic, notably on the simplified European Treaty and European construction, in Lisbon on October 19, 2007.

France Nicolas Sarkozy · President of France

19 October 2007 · Press conference at the European Council · Lisbon

Context
Sarkozy addressed a press conference in Lisbon on October 19, 2007, following the European Council's adoption of the simplified Lisbon Treaty.
Main themes
Lisbon Treaty adoption, European institutional reform, French parliamentary ratification, European Council proceedings, Polish and Italian negotiations, EU presidency, High Representative appointment, European Parliament seat allocation, Franco-European leadership
Duration
~37 min
89th percentile
Words
4,483
89th percentile
Sentences
258
93rd percentile
Readability
64
94th percentile
Grade
8.4
7th percentile
Syntax
2.85
28th percentile
Vocabulary
2.03
14th percentile

Translated from French

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

258 sentences in 51 paragraphs

Ladies and Gentlemen,

Good morning. This European Council has just concluded a little earlier than we might have feared, even though we worked late into the night. This translates into very good news for Europe, as the simplified Treaty has been adopted. We had envisioned it, we had dreamed of it, and now it is a reality. Europe has equipped itself with a simplified Treaty. I had the opportunity to propose the idea for the first time in September 2006, and here we are, Europe emerging from ten years of institutional entanglement. This is an extremely important event, and Europe will have reformed institutions that will allow it - at least, that is what we can hope for - to be as effective as possible. This treaty must now be ratified.

Speaking under the oversight of Bernard Kouchner and Jean-Pierre Jouyet, France will engage in parliamentary ratification, and I hope that this ratification can take place as soon as possible, that is to say, in December 2007. I would be very pleased if France could be one of the first countries in Europe to ratify this simplified Treaty. Because, after having blocked the Constitution, you will understand that, as head of state, I will see only advantages in France setting an example by adopting new institutions.

The French political forces will each take their responsibilities. I want to emphasize, however, that among the 27 countries that adopted it, the governments, whether socialist, liberal, or conservative, did so under the same conditions. It is, after all, the Presidency of Mr. Socrates, an excellent Portuguese Prime Minister known for his commitment to the European Socialist Party, who proposed this adoption. I am confident that all French political forces will draw the necessary conclusions.

This is a commitment I made during the campaign, and this commitment has been fulfilled. Furthermore, the heads of state or government reaffirmed the common goal of the treaty entering into force on January 1, 2009. France was very keen on this since it will preside over the Union from July 1, 2008, to December 31, 2008. It will therefore be up to France to prepare for the establishment of these new institutions. This means that the renovated institutions must be able to function in January 2009. The stable President of the European Council will take office on that date. As for the High Representative of the Union, it has been agreed that he will be appointed after consultations, particularly with the European Parliament, because he will also be the Vice-President of the Commission. The European Parliament must be involved, and since there will be European elections in June 2009, what I said regarding the stable Presidency of the Council will not apply to the Presidency of the Commission, and we have a problem regarding the High Representative. It is difficult to appoint him as Vice-President of a Commission that is ending just as elections are approaching. The President of the Union will be in early 2009, and the new institutions will be in January 2009.

I must also say that the agreement was quite simple to reach among us. We addressed the Polish requests, Mr. Socrates, Mrs. Merkel, and I during multiple bilateral contacts, and thus on Ioannina and the protocol annexed to the treaty, we found an agreement very quickly. It was prepared before we were here.

Regarding the number of Advocates General, it is not unusual; it is even normal - I told the Presidency - that our Polish friends have a fixed Advocate General like each of the large countries, that is to say, countries with around 40 million inhabitants and more. We have increased the number of Advocates General for the other countries so that it rotates; it was quite simple.

Satisfying the Italian request was a bit more complicated, and this led me to hold a meeting in our offices with Mr. Kouchner, the Polish President, the Italian President, and Jean-Claude Juncker. You don't change a winning team, since it was, with the exception of Tony Blair, the Brussels team. I was led to propose a balanced agreement that specifies the adoption of the European Parliament's report even if it will only be done in December with 750 seats for deputies, plus the president. And not 751 deputies; it amounts to the same. This avoided reopening a debate with others. Thus, one position is created that we allocate to Italy, which, instead of losing 6 seats compared to Nice, will lose 5. It will therefore have 73, and for the others, we will make a decision in December, with the understanding that this decision will be based on the proposal of the European Parliament.

You might wonder why we did not formalize it. Simply because our Polish friends did not want to highlight the fact that they have 4 fewer deputies. It is a compromise, and like any compromise, everyone must make efforts, and I was led to propose this solution, which was therefore adopted unanimously.

Two other things to tell you. The first is that you will see a joint statement on the recent developments in the financial markets. Its signatories may interest you, as they are Angela Merkel, Gordon Brown, and myself.

We worked on this statement this morning. You know that Angela Merkel and I share the same commitment to the need for transparency and regulation. It is important that the British Prime Minister joins our efforts by calling for more transparency and regulation in the financial markets.

I will see Gordon Brown tomorrow, as I will receive him at the Élysée before the rugby match. But, in any case, this bodes well for collaboration between Great Britain and France.

Finally, President Socrates indicated that at the formal Council in December, he would propose the creation of a group of sages of ten to twelve members who will reflect on the future of Europe and its place in globalization, echoing Gordon Brown's concerns. I made it clear that, in my mind, this does not involve reopening the institutional debates that were settled by the adoption of the simplified Treaty. It goes without saying that under these conditions, there will be no opening of new chapters regarding Turkey in November, and all of this is postponed to December. You know that I had made a package of this group of sages that should see the light of day next December and the opening of new chapters compatible with the association regarding Turkey.

Before answering your questions, I would like to say that the Portuguese Presidency has been very effective and extremely attentive to French concerns.

Q - Do you feel that this treaty is the last treaty for a long time? Second question: on both the right and the left, there are increasingly loud voices calling for a referendum. Do you totally exclude that?

A - Is it the last treaty for a long time? Europe is marked by treaties, as there have been almost every two years. Well, I think that, given the last five months, this should diminish the appetite for purely institutional issues, at least for normal, balanced people. So, I would not say it is the last, but we have nonetheless resolved important issues: the High Representative, the Presidency. We even had the luxury of resolving the issue of deputies. That is no small feat, and so I hope we can now add content. So, this is certainly not the last, but this one is likely to last longer than the others. I am not talking about the Treaty of Rome.

Regarding the referendum, I said during the campaign that I would fight for the adoption of the simplified Treaty and that if I managed to convince our 26 partners that the simplified Treaty was the solution, I would submit it to parliamentary approval. It would therefore be a betrayal of my word, and I know how vigilant "Libération" is about the respect of my word. So I cannot imagine that "Libération" would urge me to be perjured to such a promise. What would you say? It was fair game! So no, it is parliamentary, and moreover, it is not a constitution; it is not the Treaty resulting from the Convention. What we are putting in the Treaty has been the subject of a consensus among all political forces, including those who voted no, there you go.

Q - The French Presidency is in nine months; I imagine your team is starting to prepare for it. What priorities do you want for this French Presidency?

A - We are preparing it very actively, first because with François Fillon, Bernard Kouchner, and Jean-Pierre Jouyet, we have planned to tour all the capitals before the Presidency. I have already done a few, and I will naturally continue. I have also had the next Slovenian president who asked me for a meeting so that the Slovenian Presidency and the French Presidency can really work together.

Bernard Kouchner and Jean-Pierre Jouyet are in contact with the Slovenian ministers. As for the priorities, we have set them: an energy policy, an environmental policy, an immigration policy, a defense policy, a general orientation paper on the common agricultural policy, and then the preparation for the establishment of future institutions. I do not know if we will succeed, but it will be an extremely heavy and important Presidency that we are working on right now. Moreover, France is reaping the benefits of its commitment to the East and its commitment to the West with Great Britain.

Furthermore, regarding the South, France played an important role in solving the Italian problem. Because frankly, there is a difference of four million inhabitants between Italy and France. The large countries were previously in the same package at sixty, but today the gap is widening. Great Britain is at 60, France is at 62, and I am talking about European figures, not even our own. The degressive proportionality, to use the jargon you know better than I do, cannot be without consequence with a difference of 4 million.

Q - Everyone has observed in recent months that, given the fact that there was this institutional obstacle remaining on the path of the 27, there have been few legislative initiatives from the Commission, because there was a fear that this would ultimately reopen other contentious issues. Do you wish or do you think, now that this institutional obstacle has been lifted, that the Commission should have a more substantial, more developed legislative agenda and make more proposals in the coming months?

A - It is normal that Mr. Barroso made fewer proposals because Europe was blocked. You have often written this yourself. How can one write that Europe is blocked and ask it to multiply initiatives? You know the very positive appreciation that France has for Mr. Barroso's work, and he has indeed produced an excellent report on the Union's foreign policy, which we discussed this morning. It was extremely interesting. And, again, I see that France's ideas are progressing since it is no longer about opposing those who are for globalization and those who are for protection. I even hear the word reciprocity coming from Gordon Brown. It is advancing, it is progressing. We can now put forward the idea that community preference exists without being labeled as protectionist. This is very new, it is very important. We owe it to the remarkable work of Mr. Barroso. But, of course, the new institutions are not an end in themselves. We must take the initiative and give content, substance to Europe. That is what we will try to do.

Q - Do you not feel that the term "simplified Treaty" is not necessarily the best choice, because for the reader, the citizen, it is much more difficult to read than the Constitution, since it refers to other Treaties?

A - I am responsible for both successive names, and my first choice was even worse. I had spoken of a mini-treaty, and I readily acknowledge that if I had had the intuition of how we could get out of it, it was not good because it gave a minimal Europe. I say this all the more because I was the first to use it. I therefore had to rethink it twice to find the right expression. So, simplified Treaty, fortunately the name is not good because if it had been good, what success would we have encountered? But still, there are seven articles in the simplified Treaty. So obviously, since Europe is a long story, every time you say something, you refer to a multitude of texts. That is the past. But there are seven articles. So obviously, it is not something to be put in everyone's hands; it is not a simple read. It is a legal problem, but in relation to the work of constitutionalists, it is considerably simplified. But regarding the marketplace of ideas for new names, I fear that now it may be too late; we have done it.

Q - You praised the work of Mr. Barroso, who is a candidate for his own renewal at the European Commission in 2009. As you specified, France will be somewhat at the helm for the nominations. Does this mean that you support Mr. Barroso's candidacy for a second term? With the names that have already circulated, do you still support Mr. Blair's candidacy for the Presidency of the Council and Mr. Solana's candidacy for the Ministry of Foreign Affairs?

R - And that I oppose Mr. Juncker's candidacy...

Q - ...Mr. Juncker for the Eurogroup...

R - No, but I saw you were off to a good start. One, I stand by my statement: Mr. Barroso is a very remarkable president of the Commission. Moreover, this is a judgment that is unanimously expressed, and to those who would consider that he is not good enough, I could ask for some comparisons, and I am not sure that it would be flattering for the others compared. Because we have known commissions, and you who are the specialists and who follow this, you know perfectly well what I am talking about.

In an extremely difficult context, Mr. Barroso continued to work. Whether one is socialist or not, everyone can recognize that it was not easy for him, and he did it. Should he be the next president? I remember, history matters, even the most recent. When a head of government and a head of state agreed on the future, it ended badly. I believe it was Guy Verhofstadt, Gerhard Schroeder, and Jacques Chirac. So, I care too much for Mr. Barroso to do such a thing to him. Therefore, I will refrain from answering that question. Tony Blair, I met with him the day before yesterday, and he is a very remarkable man. He is the most European of the English. I do not know his intentions, but that one can think of him is quite intelligent. As for Jean-Claude Juncker, I know that he is the president of the Eurogroup. I even campaigned for him in 2004 when I was Minister of Finance. He is a man who has been in office, if my memory serves me right, since 1976, without interruption. It is not that I envy him, but it does give a certain culture, a history. So, for him to be the first president of the Council is an intelligent idea. You say at the helm. I will simply listen, consult, and we will reflect. Not being a candidate myself for any of these positions, we will have to make the best choice, but France is not taking a position now. It is premature, and it could also risk not highlighting the importance of this Lisbon Council.

Q - It is a great success for the Portuguese presidency, obviously, a signature on December 13. But there is something that poses more of a problem, which is the EU-Africa summit. Does this summit pose a problem for you due to the attendance of certain African heads of state?

R - I will be there. A great success for the Portuguese presidency is also a great success for the twenty-seven. In the same way, if we had failed, I am sure that we would have said who was the first culprit. This simplified Treaty, when we talked about it, I remember all the laughter, the mockery, well, in the end, it is done. It is even the only subject that you did not mock. But well, it is a great satisfaction. It is true that Mr. Socrates has been an extremely available, consensual president while also carrying a lot of convictions. He is a man whom I personally appreciate a lot, and I say this very sincerely and very seriously. He gains a lot from being discovered, and it shows that beyond political divides in Europe, we have worked hand in hand, without any difference.

Q - You wanted to engage in a discussion today about artificially undervalued currencies; has that been the case? And do your partners share your concerns about the current level of the euro?

R - We talked about it since I brought it up myself in the informal discussion this morning. Mr. Juncker could not stay since he is at the G7 Finance. Not everyone considers that the euro is too high, but everyone considers that other currencies are too weak. So, if this is the path to consensus and if someone tells me: "it's the euro that is too strong or it's the yuan that is too low, it's the euro that is too high or it's the dollar that is too low," you do what you want. But since currencies do not have absolute value but relative values, it should come back to the same somewhere.

Q - I have a question about the funds that are controlled by states, such as China, Saudi Arabia, or the United Arab Emirates. These funds have billions of dollars to invest, and there is a debate in Europe about whether there should be rules, national or European frameworks to control or regulate these state funds? I would like to have your opinion on this; what is France's position?

R - I want there to be rules, and I tell you that it is a very important element that Gordon Brown signed the letter with Angela Merkel. Because we are determined not to let ourselves be done in by speculative funds, by unscrupulous attitudes that do not meet the transparency criteria that we are entitled to expect in a civilized world. I have often expressed myself on the subject; it is unacceptable, and we are determined not to accept it. I also see the evolution of the English government, in my eyes very positive, in demanding transparency and regulation. Perhaps what happened in England with the eighth bank has alerted them. And indeed, they are right. I would have been alerted myself.

Q - On the international front, you will host Prime Minister Olmert this Monday in Paris. What will your message be in view of the upcoming conferences that will take place in Annapolis in the United States and then in Paris?

R - We will have the pleasure, with Bernard Kouchner, to have lunch with Mr. Olmert on Monday, before my departure in the afternoon for a state visit to Morocco. My message will be very simple. I will tell the Prime Minister, with all the friendship I have for him and all the commitment I have alongside Israel, that now is the time to make peace. One never takes too many risks when it comes to making peace. It is now that we must talk. It is now that we must put all our cards on the table. It is now that we must take the risk of building lasting peace. And this message is exactly the one I conveyed with the same Bernard, in New York, to Abu Mazen.

Peace will first come from the Israelis and the Palestinians. Peace will first be their business. And our Israeli friends must understand that it is primarily their business. And that if there is a step to be taken towards the other, it must be taken now. I do not share the opinion of those who think that this is not the time. It is precisely because there are all these difficulties in Gaza, in Israel, and elsewhere in the world. That is why, from my point of view, there has never been so many opportunities to reach a solution.

Q - What is your state of mind, the day after the announcement of your divorce from Mrs. Cécilia Sarkozy? Have you read the interview she gave to L'Est Républicain today? And do you share her analysis on the failure of your couple?

R - My state of mind is very simple: I was elected by the French to find solutions to their problems, not to comment on my private life. And I would have loved for a great newspaper like "Le Monde" to be passionate about Europe, rather than about my private life. But, after all, perhaps that is what one should be flattered by. What do you want me to say? If you believe that the French elected me for anything other than to work, work, and work again... For the rest, the French do not ask for any comments. They are much less interested in it than you are. And they are right. And perhaps they also have more modesty and more discretion, dare I say, a touch of elegance as well.

Q - You mentioned the Committee of Sages that will be set up in the coming months. Could you give us a profile of a Sage, in your eyes, in Europe? There are twelve, I believe.

R - I try to bring new ideas to Europe. I try. But bringing ideas that are not retained makes no sense. So, I try to bring ideas that will be retained. For that, what do I do? I put forward the idea and leave the door open as much as possible for others to appropriate it and for it to become their idea. The simplified Treaty: I brought this idea. But I was very happy that Mrs. Merkel transformed it, embodied it in her remarkable Presidency.

I will do the same for the group of Sages. I bring this idea by saying: here, should the European dream of the last thirty years be the same as that of the founding fathers? Let us reflect, and it is not the heads of state or government who can do it. I did not want to put a paper on the table that would freeze things. Broadly speaking, however, ten to twelve people. Why? Because I would not want there to be one per country, as the logic of one per country is an exclusively national logic. Whereas I want an exclusively European logic.

The second element, I do not believe that it should only be politicians. I think there can be scholars, historians, geographers, philosophers, business people. I think there should be women, I think it should be representative of all cultures, and I finally think that we need to give them time, two years, to be disconnected from the European elections in June 2009.

Q - Precisely, you were talking about the implementation or preparation of future institutions; how can we ensure that there is no collision at the top between the future stable president of the Council and the president of the Commission?

R - You see that there is a risk of collision. First, I think that the stable president should be wise enough to work as a team. I think that is extremely important, and much will depend on the personalities of each. Today, we have the Commission doing a bit of everything because the Presidency changes every six months. We will need to find new relationships with a presidency that is there for two and a half years. I am aware that this will require a lot of effort, compromise, and that there may be a risk, especially the risk of not choosing the best personalities. I think that strong personalities serving strong institutions is always preferable to falsely consensual personalities, those who cause the least trouble. But you talk about risks; undoubtedly, they exist, and I will not insult you by disputing that.

Q - At this summit, we are talking about a united, more competitive Europe. Will you speak on behalf of this Europe with the Chinese government during your next visit? This is not the first time, but it is the first time as president of France. Will you speak on behalf of Europe regarding currency? Do you have a comment on the National Congress of the CPCC, currently in China?

R - On the national congress, no. It happens that during my trip, I will be with Mr. Barroso, who will be there himself for the summit, and with Mr. Juncker. We will therefore have the opportunity to talk about relations between China and Europe. It is a considerable subject. You know that what our Chinese friends are doing is quite exceptional. I will simply emphasize this idea that the great powers of this world have rights but also duties.

Q - Mr. Bernard Laporte seems to be the subject of an investigation into his tax affairs, with elements that could be forwarded to the Prosecutor's Office. Do you still maintain your intention to bring him into the government?

R - The presumption of innocence is something that must exist. I have indeed applied it for André Santini; it seems reasonable to me. But you know what is extraordinary is that not one of you asked me about the social movements of yesterday. Look how the news changes. Forty-eight hours ago, it was the big French affair; my big appointment, it was read. And today, twenty-four hours after this big appointment, not a question. This is not a reproach, but it must mean that it did not go so badly after all. I mean that the government's strategy, firm on the objective of reforming special regimes and open, with a hand extended, to dialogue with electricians, gas workers, railway workers, and RATP agents, this strategy remains ours. This reform I am committed to; we will do it, but no one should be humiliated, and I was very happy with the position taken by a number of trade union organizations, like the JAC, and I am pleased with Xavier Bertrand's initiative to meet with the trade union organizations next week. I have always said that we had priorities on which we could not yield, but that there was room for negotiation, and I hold to that. Thank you.