Statement by Mr. Nicolas Sarkozy, President of the Republic, on the challenges and priorities of the hospital of tomorrow, in Bordeaux on October 16, 2007.

France Nicolas Sarkozy · President of France

16 October 2007 · Statement on the challenges and priorities of the hospital of tomorrow · Bordeaux University Hospital, Bordeaux, France

Context
Sarkozy addressed hospital staff and officials in Bordeaux on October 16, 2007, to launch a commission on the missions and future reform of French public hospitals.
Main themes
Hospital reform, access to quality care, hospital performance and efficiency, healthcare system challenges, hospital values and mission, attractiveness of medical careers, hospital deficit, continuity of care, hospital as economic actor, management autonomy, territorial vision, healthcare workforce
Duration
~40 min
90th percentile
Words
4,810
90th percentile
Sentences
320
96th percentile
Readability
50
63rd percentile
Grade
10.0
21st percentile
Syntax
2.58
6th percentile
Vocabulary
2.21
50th percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Social 59%59%
  • Institutional 24%24%
  • Economic 14%14%
  • Ceremonial 3%3%
  • Geopolitical 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

320 sentences in 71 paragraphs

Mr. Prime Minister, dear Alain,

Madam Minister, dear Roselyne,

Mr. Minister,

Ladies and gentlemen of Parliament,

Ladies and gentlemen,

It is a great pleasure for me to be in Bordeaux and to reconnect with the hospital and all the people who keep it alive. Each of my encounters with the hospital world is a significant moment. I am fully aware of the deep malaise that the hospital and its staff are experiencing today. As Head of State, I must pay tribute to the dedication of this staff, to their commitment to patients, to their attachment to the values of care, and to their professionalism.

I am proud to be at the Bordeaux University Hospital, which is one of the jewels of our hospital system, a hospital that has trained generations of healthcare professionals from both the mainland and overseas, in a tradition of excellence and humanism.

During my visit to the hospitals in the North on May 22, I announced a consultation on the missions of the hospital. It is the establishment of the commission responsible for organizing this consultation that brings us together today.

Where does the hospital stand?

- The hospital has values.

- The hospital faces challenges.

- We have a duty to provide answers to prepare the hospital of tomorrow. For me, these answers are management autonomy and a territorial vision.

I will not leave the hospital in immobility and conservatism.

The hospital is primarily defined by its values.

The first value of the hospital is service. The mission of the hospital is to serve the population. The remarkable gains in life expectancy that France has recorded over the past few decades are largely due to the hospital. The hospital is the cornerstone of the organization of care.

Openness is another value of the hospital. The hospital is open all the time, all year round, every day of the week, day and night. The hospital is the last resort. The openness of the hospital is an openness to youth who are training in medical and paramedical studies, it is an openness to excellence, it is an openness to international cooperation through research.

Finally, the hospital is an anchor point in the territory. This is not the least of the difficulties. The hospital is often the largest employer in a city, it is the primary investor, it is the main contractor in its city. The hospital is not just a health actor; it is a major economic player.

In a word, the hospital is a microcosm of the Nation, which makes it so endearing, so indispensable, and so close.

These values of the hospital are assets for addressing the challenges of tomorrow. These values unite the million women and men who dedicate themselves to patients every day in healthcare facilities.

The hospital of tomorrow is about values, but it is also about a series of challenges.

The challenge of access to quality care. Finding a doctor is a concern for many of our fellow citizens. In the evening, at night, on weekends, who should one turn to? Often, the demand ends up at the emergency services or with the firefighters. The result is waiting times of several hours in some emergency departments. We must better meet the expectations of the French. We need flexible and graduated responses, ranging from telephone advice to helicopter transfers. The continuity of care is a pressing obligation for all care actors: hospitals, clinics, and professionals working in the community.

The challenge of access to quality care is also the challenge of performance. Why should we hide from this? For businesses and others, performance is expected, while for the hospital, paralysis and incoherent functioning are accepted? On what grounds? The hospital must be efficient; the professionals who work there every day prove this. Efficiency is a guarantee of quality.

A performing hospital is one that improves its care processes to avoid tragedies.

A performing hospital is one that creates leeway to invest in innovation and new technologies.

A performing hospital is one that contributes to the rebalancing of health insurance.

Nearly half of public hospitals are currently in deficit. How can we accept this? You cannot tell me that there is nothing to change in a system where half of our public hospitals are in deficit. I find that unacceptable. I cannot be responsible for this in five months. It is clear that there is a problem if half of the hospitals are in deficit.

The second challenge facing the hospital is that of attractiveness and excellence.

The hospital has all the assets to attract the best. But the field of attractiveness is constantly expanding. There is remuneration, which matters, and that is normal. There is recognition of the results achieved by a team or an individual. There are career prospects, particularly for paramedical professions. There are working conditions and safety. I do not forget the tragedies in Pau and, more recently, in Josselin in Morbihan, where violence has infiltrated the heart of the hospital. Violence is increasingly present at the heart of the hospital. This is unacceptable.

Repeated on-call duties, because we ask a lot of the hospital, weigh heavily on doctors. If the continuity of care relies exclusively on the hospital, we run a major risk, that of a game where everyone loses: the patient, the hospital, the hospital practitioner. Everyone must take responsibility for the continuity of care.

If nothing is done to enhance the attractiveness of the professions, our hospitals and clinics will lose part of their substance. We must face reality. Some doctors are taking on multiple short-term assignments from one facility to another. Or, let’s be honest with the French, there are foreign doctors who are keeping the hospital running. Thank goodness they are here, the foreign doctors. But what hypocrisy: they are almost here by default. I want them to be selected, trained in our language, recognized, and fully integrated into the medical project of the establishment and the medical and nursing teams.

The hospital must strive for excellence. Excellence in care, with appropriate therapies and a culture of safety in care. Excellence in education, with medical and paramedical studies that prepare for the evolution of professions. Excellence in research, so that the hospital contributes its full weight to the prominence of French research in the world.

How do we respond to these challenges? How do we adapt? How do we build the hospital of tomorrow in the social context that our country is experiencing, where we must learn to talk to each other, to listen to each other, to understand each other, and to respect each other?

The first direction I want to give is management autonomy. I will not compromise on this. I want to give the hospital some breathing room. We need dynamism, projects, cohesive teams. A hospital focused on the quality of service provided to patients. I no longer want an organization without coherence, made up of a juxtaposition of individual talents. This requires a revolution in mindsets.

How can we achieve this revolution in mindsets? First, through a revolution in financing. This is an unavoidable subject. The activity-based pricing at 100% for short stays, we are implementing it in 2008. This will unleash the energies of the hospital and put an end to this absurd system—the global budget—that wanted the resources of an establishment to depend on its budgetary situation as it was assessed 20 years ago! Activity-based pricing is simply allowing the hospital to know why it works. Activity-based pricing is the primary condition for management, it is the foundation of autonomy. There is no autonomy without activity-based pricing.

The T2A at 100% is a strong measure for public hospitals. I want it to accompany the return to balance in accounts. I am talking about the operating accounts of public establishments. This is also performance. I want there to be no public health establishments with an operating deficit by the end of my term. Let’s look at things as they are. Today, deficit is a habit, dare I say, it is commonplace. Balance must be the norm respected by all; it is the best guarantee of the sustainability of hospitals, and I am speaking in front of former health ministers here, for whom I have a lot of respect, particularly Mr. Evin. I hope this will not cause you any trouble for me to say this. Finally, it is good to be sincere from time to time; it is not absurd either, and I have no ulterior motives, or if I do, they are well known... Listen, you cannot tell me that you love public hospitals and be satisfied with a situation where half are in imbalance. You cannot tell me that you love public hospitals and implement a global budget, meaning you have the means of one year based on what you did before. It is absurd; it makes no sense, and it goes well beyond left and right.

I have asked Roselyne Bachelot to study a schedule for the gradual deployment of T2A in the medium stay sector and psychiatric establishments. Because after all, Alain, if T2A is good for short stays, if autonomy is good for short stays, I do not see why it would not be good for medium stays and psychiatry.

It is essential that the modernization of hospital financing touches all of its instruments: T2A as well as the allocations financing activities that cannot be priced, because I willingly admit that there are activities that cannot be priced. The time is over when these allocations were used to maintain deficits. All financing must be based on objective criteria. We must leave leeway for the ARHs. But I believe in commitment to results rather than in the generalized artistic blur, in which no one knows where they are going or for whom they are working.

Next, the revolution of the contract. The management autonomy of the hospital must be based on the contract. The contract serves quality and performance. I want, Roselyne, the practice of the contract between the regional hospitalization agency, the ARH, and the establishment to be systematic so that everyone knows what they have to do. The contract must set clear, negotiated, quantified, communicable objectives, with a precise timeline and, dare I say, positive and negative sanctions.

For the contract to produce all its effects in the hospital, the ARHs must have only one obsession: quality and performance. That is why I want, dear Roselyne, that the directors of ARHs receive in 2008 mission letters assigning them specific objectives in this area. For the same reason, dear Gérard Larcher, we must question the evolution of the certification of establishments. Certification is a service rendered to the population. Its results must be widely published and lead to sanctions, positive or negative. We owe the truth to the French. Quality must be the cardinal principle of our hospital policy; there is no other possible choice. And I want certification based on objective criteria to replace publications by this or that newspaper, which is perfectly respectable. I believe that by doing this, we serve the hospitals.

For me, there is a close link between the autonomy of the hospital and its management mode. Here too, I call for a revolution; this time, it is a managerial revolution. The ARH-establishment contract must be reflected in the contracts concluded between the director and the hospital practitioners, starting with the heads of departments. It is essential that there is coherence between the commitments made by the establishment to the ARH and the commitments made by each hospital practitioner to the director and the president of the medical establishment commission.

The contract between the director and the practitioner must also set clear, time-planned objectives. At its expiration, it is normal for the director, the president of the CME, and the practitioner to review the latter's activity. And there must be recognition if the objectives are met and measures of adaptation if the objectives are not met. Everyone knows these hospitals where there are admirable doctors in terms of dedication and commitment, and others on whose shoulders rests the weight of a certain habit. It is nice outside, so one must be very nice. Because everyone knows establishments where in certain services, questions arise about certain practitioners.

So, we need some substance to bring a contract to life. I want collective and individual incentives to spread to all levels of the hospital: doctors, paramedical professionals, nursing assistants, service agents, managers and administrative staff, engineers, technicians, and workers. This incentive must take into account the difficulty of situations: a nurse who joins a geriatrics department must be recognized. Well, there are people who dedicate themselves and do a more difficult job than others; we need to value them, engage them, and reward them. A variable part has been established this year for surgeons. It is an encouraging start that must be extended in 2008. The incentive must develop within a contractual framework that recognizes autonomy and delegation of responsibilities for everyone.

Ultimately, the hospital will benefit from more direct, simpler, and contractual relationships between the director and the practitioners. I want to prioritize women and men over statuses. So, I will say something that is not politically correct, but I want the director to be the recognized boss, the only one. We cannot continue like this; I have led for twenty years, I have presided over the hospital for twenty years, but I know that in a hospital, everyone has the right to say no. This means that no one can say yes. There must be one boss, and only one. I do not know of any organization that works when there are as many bosses as there are activity leaders. There is only one boss, it is the director, who decides. He must be able to decide, in conjunction with the executive council. The director must be a manager of excellence, trained and regularly evaluated. I am in favor of opening the recruitment of hospital directors: to doctors, to managers from other public functions, why not to private sector managers? And this, of course, at the same time that different responsibilities will be opened to hospital directors.

The director must be able to freely decide to transfer non-core logistical activities to the private sector. The private sector generally manages these activities better. Autonomy must translate into decisions that introduce flexibility into a hospital that is suffering from rigidity. Sorry, but you live in the hospital; you know very well that to get anything done, it’s an obstacle course. We don’t know whom to ask, and when we ask, we don’t get an answer.

I want autonomy to give us the means to free up work. Because the 35-hour workweek was implemented to the detriment of hospital staff who paid the price of disorganization. Because we need to give professionals who want to work more the means to earn more, including in the hospital. Dear Roselyne, I hope we can quickly find a sustainable solution for managing overtime in hospitals. You know, I was not elected to evade problems, and I put myself in the staff's shoes; they work overtime and are not paid. I would not be happy; they are right. Now, we need to pay what is possible. And for the rest, for the time savings accounts, CET, we need to think about a solution where hospitals could convert these days into contributions to fund supplementary pensions. This is an opening in the negotiation that I suggest to you, Roselyne. All of this must be studied to offer different solutions at the local level. I am not sure that the same solution is needed everywhere. I know that the issue of overtime arises everywhere. But I am not sure, Alain, that everywhere it should be the same response. But for the Head of State to recognize that the problem exists, excuse me, is a novelty, and I want to be honest with people; when we work more, it is not normal not to be compensated in one way or another for the work we have done. Beyond this necessary adjustment, I want the possibility of a chosen contractual time for each hospital agent to be examined. This is a system that preserves everyone's freedom and introduces flexibility into operations. This contract must include commitments regarding the planning of working hours, which is one of the levers for modernizing the hospital.

The managerial revolution that I want for the hospital must be our response to the question of the attractiveness of these professions. The public hospital must be one of the first fields of application of the contract I mentioned in my speech on public service on September 19. In some cases, which would need to be specified, perhaps on an experimental basis, hospital practitioners could enter into a contract with their establishment. This contract would allow for improved remuneration for practitioners by modernizing the liberal activity regime. We can even imagine that an establishment, on a voluntary basis, could opt for a regime that would allow it to experiment with innovative practices in human resources management. But what do we risk? It can only get better.

For midwives and paramedical professions, it seems to me that the least we can do is to justly recognize initial competencies and acquired skills. I take my responsibilities and tell the Minister of Health that I am in favor of recognizing the training of nurses that lasts more than three years at the bachelor's level.

I know this raises issues. But everything raises issues. Every time I ask for something, I am told that it raises problems. Of course, if it didn’t raise problems, it would have been done. But I am sorry; after the baccalaureate, it is a bachelor's degree. There is no reason that nurses should not be recognized like others. No, it is a question of equity. We will address the statutory issues; I am aware of what that entails behind it, so what could be more normal than that?

I am in favor of revaluing the nursing profession. We need to gradually integrate health professions into the LMD system. This revaluation must have counterparts regarding the retirement age and the issue of working hours. This revaluation must be spread over time and cannot concern everyone immediately. But we will carry out this revaluation. Hospital professionals need security, security against violence and security in practice. I expect proposals in this area from the consultation that will be initiated to protect staff from violence.

I also want proposals to support professionals in their quality approach. I am thinking particularly, Gérard, of the evaluation of professional practices. To enhance the attractiveness of these professions, we must provide solutions for the continuity of care. If we do nothing, what will happen is that we will exhaust the professionals of the public hospital. That is what will happen if we do nothing. So, the solutions will necessarily be solutions of cooperation in the territory. What is important is the territorial vision. This is significant. I want to create a new dynamic for the hospital, a dynamic that feeds on management autonomy and territorial vision. The clearer and more efficient its management is, the better the hospital can cooperate, and I believe in territorial cooperation.

Cooperation is the only way to regain availability in the resources of the healthcare system. In reality, the hospital must refocus on its missions to better fulfill its responsibilities at the heart of its profession. The hospital cannot do everything alone; it must cooperate with liberal health professionals and the medico-social sector. A better articulation between the different actors in care is necessary for emergencies, continuity of care, long-term care, and the management of elderly people. The hospital cannot do everything, or we will explode the hospital.

The priority is the articulation of hospital emergencies and continuity of care. I call on all actors in the healthcare system to come to the table and provide solutions because at the heart of everything is the need of the person. There are innovative responses on the ground. I am thinking of medical homes on call. There is the telephone response, which can reassure a worried mother in the middle of the night. We must especially ensure coherence and connection, based on what exists in each territory and the specific needs of its population.

I want, Roselyne, continuity of care to be the first subject addressed by the regional health agencies (ARS). It is the first subject because the congestion of the hospital begins with emergencies; that is where we enter. The ARS are essential for deploying an efficient, coherent, and fair territorial organization of care. They must be established in 2009.

The ARS will carry the banner of access to quality care. They will know how to define the care pathways that are missing from our current planning tools, the regional health organization schemes. Each has its role in each pathway. Rather than reserving a particular activity for a specific establishment, the ARS must state what the role of each is: public hospital, private clinic, city professionals, to take care of the patient in the best and fastest way possible.

To promote cooperation within public hospitalization, shouldn’t we imagine territorial meetings of establishments? This is not about adding an additional level of administration but about giving meaning to hospital reorganization. The territorial vision that the ARS will carry will lead to better quality and better safety of care. It is also a question of activity and employment. If we all accept the idea that there can be a strategic vision of the territory, then we can have a predictive management of jobs in hospital sites. For now, there is no job management. To do this, we need a consensus on the requirement for quality and safety of care, a consensus on the evolution of sites and on the mobility of professionals within a territory. I hope, Mr. Minister, dear Gérard, that the consultation will allow us to reach these consensuses. We cannot remain with such an incoherent hospital map.

Public-private partnerships must become the rule. In each agglomeration, I want us to build joint projects for quality and safety around technical platforms. I no longer want a system where all the energy of the actors is spent competing, trying to demonstrate strength to be the last one standing, because that is indeed the reality of threatened hospital establishments. It is the best way to create a lose-lose situation. How many examples could we cite where public-private cooperation can benefit patients, professionals, and health insurance?

Finally, the territorial vision must apply to research and training. In the past, we have sprinkled, dispersed, and fragmented. The result, we know: no French university in the top 30 of the Shanghai ranking. We need to think about a policy that provides much stronger support to the teams of university hospitals that are in global competition.

To support the best teams, I want the consultation that you will organize, dear Gérard, to identify innovative solutions to allow hospital and university practitioners who wish to truly dedicate themselves to research.

The hospital must remain the place par excellence for applied training for health professions, doctors, nurses, and nursing assistants. In this regard, I would like to address the medical students, interns, and clinic heads I met earlier.

I hear their concerns, but I want to tell them that they can, that they must have confidence in the future. I am attached, like all of you, to the freedom of establishment; it is the founding principle of our liberal medicine.

But what is the concern of the French? It is equal access to quality care for all. We know that in some places, access to care is a problem. I hope we can find solutions in the consultation. The draft social security financing law for 2008 establishes a right to conventional negotiation, that’s all. No more, no less. No one can seriously contest the legitimacy of putting the question of the terms of convention on the agenda for discussions. Opening negotiations is the exact opposite of a coercive approach!

Representatives of medical students, interns, and medical students will be involved in the negotiations. I propose to formalize this commitment by amendment to the PLFSS. The conventional negotiation will only become enforceable after consultation with these representatives. This is therefore not a consultative opinion but a deliberative opinion.

Regarding the negotiation itself, I would like to provide a roadmap. First, we need to hold, starting in early 2008, a general assembly on medical demographics, as Roselyne Bachelot has committed to do. This is an excellent idea; the diagnosis of the situation must be shared. We also need to assess the incentive measures that have already been implemented.

Next, there will be no delisting or selective contracting for those currently in residency. And this will extend to externs. I do not want to change the rules of the game midway. We will establish an intelligent system with you.

In 3 or 4 years, we will together evaluate the effectiveness of these measures. That is when we will see if we need to go further and limit contracting for future residents, in one way or another, in the densest areas.

Finally, I hope that the negotiations will take into account the legitimate aspirations of young doctors for a renewed practice and a better quality of life. I attach the utmost importance to their aspirations.

There you have it, I have shared my vision for the hospital of tomorrow. It is a fundamentally positive vision. We need a strong hospital, a dynamic public service, a reinforced private sector. We need a modern, efficient, attractive hospital that listens to patients, where the staff is happy to work. We need a better thought-out territorial organization, more cooperative to meet the expectations of the French people.

Ultimately, we may be witnessing the end of an era, the one that began with the "Robert Debré" ordinance of 1958 on university hospitals. It is a model that has worked, making public hospitals an attractive model. Should we revisit this model? A lot has changed since then. The question is open.

Dear Gérard LARCHER, you will establish a status report by the end of November. Then, until spring, you will organize consultations on the missions of the hospital. This consultation must be as broad, open, and in-depth as possible. Gérard LARCHER is the right man for the job. The synthesis of the consultation will lead, dear Roselyne BACHELOT, to a series of concrete measures for the modernization of the hospital that you will implement.

You know, I have confidence in the Minister of Health, and I chose Gérard LARCHER because I trust his ability to ensure dialogue. But let no one be mistaken here, I will lead the modernization of the hospital, because it is my duty. I was elected to provide answers, to find solutions; we cannot remain with the malaise of the hospital. And I think this is very good news for all of you in this room, regardless of your profession, because you know well that it is immobility that will cause the hospital to die, not change; it is immobility. I believe in public hospitals; I believe in them strongly. But I think we need to act now. Listen, 50 years after the texts of Robert DEBRE, it may be time to make decisions that we have postponed for too long. Even if some will provoke changes in habits. A leader, autonomy, experimentation, evaluation, reward, quality of life. That is what I wish for the hospital, and believe me, my approach is perfectly sincere, and each actor in the hospital must feel that they are loved, respected, and valued.

We will talk with you, we will build with you, but let no one imagine that I will accept immobility. Everything is negotiable, except that. It is towards modernity that we must go, not towards immobility. It is towards novelty that we must go, not towards conservatism, and you know this very well, you health professionals who are constantly seeking new treatments, new medications, new methods, new practices. How can you, every day, in your profession oriented towards the future and change, think that you could remain in a universe that is only focused on the past and immobility? That is what is at stake. And you know, the staff who were there, with whom I have dialogued, I fully understand their frustration. An increasingly difficult job, increasingly difficult working conditions, increasing stress, and the feeling that no one cares. I understand this malaise. And my duty is to take it into account, but to take it into account for positive reasons, not negative ones, to turn everyone towards excellence. Thank you for listening to me.