Press conference by Mr. Nicolas Sarkozy, President of the Republic, on future investments and the government's policy in response to the economic crisis, in Paris on June 27, 2011.

France Nicolas Sarkozy · President of France

27 June 2011 · Press conference on future investments and the government's policy in response to the economic crisis · Paris, France

Context
Sarkozy held a press conference in Paris on June 27, 2011, outlining France's future investment priorities and government economic policy responses.
Main themes
Future investments program, nuclear energy policy, nuclear safety, renewable energy development, energy efficiency, higher education reform, cancer research, pedagogical excellence, greenhouse gas emissions, electric and hybrid vehicles, university autonomy, energy independence
Duration
~64 min
96th percentile
Words
7,670
96th percentile
Sentences
448
98th percentile
Readability
60
88th percentile
Grade
9.0
11th percentile
Syntax
2.80
22nd percentile
Vocabulary
2.08
24th percentile

Translated from French

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

448 sentences in 108 paragraphs

QUESTION - You have redirected, after Fukushima, the nuclear security policy; are there also projects that have been revised in the field of alternative energies to nuclear?

THE PRESIDENT - In fact, we have made three redirections, and the ministers or the Prime Minister can tell me if I am mistaken.

First, in the field of health: cancer. Cancer breaks too many lives. It is a disease that is too widespread. There are too many destinies that are shattered by it. We want a global research hub against cancer. The French problem is that there are many centers of excellence, including in the Paris region, focused on cancer. Can we combine our forces to truly make it a global hub? That is the first redirection.

The second redirection, in relation to the JUPPE/ROCARD Commission and the work we have done with Parliament, is the initiatives for pedagogical excellence. It is true, the centers of excellence, the excellent equipment, all of that is very good. But we thought that there were also new pedagogical methods in universities and that, fundamentally, if we wanted the best universities in the world, we needed to work on the "campus" aspect, the campuses, we needed to work on the equipment, we needed to work on the capital endowments of universities that are now autonomous, but we also needed to prioritize pedagogical initiatives, new projects, new programs, new methods. The whole world is moving; we cannot remain with teaching methods that are those of fifty years ago. What is needed is to prepare for the 21st century.

Finally, the third element of redirection: nuclear energy, with the specific area of nuclear safety. France already has a considerable lead over all others. Moreover, that is why France lost a number of bids for the construction of nuclear power plants. Our nuclear power plants are more expensive because they are safer. We have the will to invest further in nuclear safety.

Regarding energy, there are first the generators of the 4th generation. In fact, some are asking me for a moratorium on nuclear energy. I always find this proposal curious. What does a moratorium consist of? We keep the old plants and refrain from seeking new ones? If we keep the old plants, we keep those that are less safe and refrain from developing research for those that are safer. That makes no sense. We are investing in 4th generation reactors.

On renewable energies, we are also investing massively. The Prime Minister, Nathalie KOSCIUSKO-MORIZET, Eric BESSON, and I announced 12 billion euros of investment for offshore wind turbines, that is to say, wind turbines in the ocean. That is 12 billion euros. Solar energy has been multiplied by 5 since I became President of the Republic, and wind energy by 18. And we are still investing in decarbonized energies as part of the future investment program.

But we also believe, along with Nathalie KOSCIUSKO-MORIZET, that one of the most promising energies for the future is energy efficiency, energy savings. Everything that will allow this, we are working on. Take the future airplane, the composite airplane, that is to say, the lighter airplane, or the electric car. I am sometimes told: "But have you chosen between hybrid or electric?" No. We are investing massively with the private sector in reducing vehicle weight, in hybrid engines, in electric engines, in the bonus/malus system. Do you know that the French car fleet is the cleanest car fleet in Europe thanks to the bonus/malus system? We do not want to choose the right renewable energy. We want to invest massively to meet the 2020 target: 23% of renewable energies in French electricity consumption. Moreover, everyone who works on this issue knows well that there is no alternative to nuclear energy today. Therefore, we must develop nuclear energy and develop renewable energies.

I would like to add a final word to those who ask us to abandon nuclear energy. It is those very people who would like France not to meet its commitments from Copenhagen on greenhouse gas emissions. Because if we keep nuclear energy, it is because we want to maintain our independence, that we want competitive energy, that we do not want to impose phenomenal increases in energy prices on the French, but also because nuclear energy does not produce greenhouse gases. It is a clean energy. There is coherence in all our investments and our energy policy.

QUESTION - In the press release you provided us, priority is given within the framework of future investments to higher education, research, and training. In this context, how do you interpret the controversy surrounding the Baccalauréat? Does it not reflect the anxiety of parents and children about the future, and after the controversy over fraud, do you consider that the Baccalauréat is obsolete?

THE PRESIDENT - The Minister of National Education was on a major national television channel yesterday. He said perfectly sensible things that I completely support. But finally, I would like, please forgive me, to focus on future investments, and I have not announced, within the framework of future investments, any funding for the Baccalauréat.

I know that there is current news, I know that, but I would like to convince you of one thing. What we are talking about today is very important for our country, for your children, for yourselves, for the next twenty years. I know that current news is consuming and exciting, but it passes, the news, while future investments will benefit us in twenty years.

The question is: does France emerge stronger from the crisis or weaker? Are we capable, all together, of drawing the consequences of past failures, for which we are collectively responsible, to turn towards the future? What are the failures of the past? Too many taxes in France that stifle initiative. Too much public spending that burdens the weight of the State on the economy, not enough investments. Why are there relocations? Because our burdens are too heavy, because our products are not competitive enough, because we have not invested enough. That is what matters.

Moreover, we wanted the autonomy of universities, but the autonomy of universities, without the means provided to universities, would be useless. Autonomy is not an end in itself; autonomy is a means. I am very happy that it is François FILLON's government that has made an unprecedented effort for universities in the history of the Fifth Republic. That is what matters.

You know, it is a change, and for me, there is no greater satisfaction than seeing the academic world, which has been described for years as immobile, seize the future investments and the reform of universities to propose, in a wonderful emulation, projects in all universities: large, medium, or small.

Could we continue to regress in the Shanghai ranking? Was it acceptable that our best students went to grandes écoles and ignored our universities, and that the wealthiest families, when they wanted their children to pursue university studies, sent them abroad? Do you not think that this is as important as the fraud in the Baccalauréat?

Furthermore, I understand that for those who are victims of it, it is a problem, but Luc CHATEL's response is that there was no good solution, and he tried to take the response that best guarantees republican equality. He spoke to us about it, and I support his choice. There is no good answer because if we cancel the exam, then those who think they passed are unhappy; if we neutralize an exercise, those who did well say: "But why?" There is no good solution. I find that the solution he found is the most respectful of republican equality. I would like us to focus on the question of investment, innovation, and research.

QUESTION - Mr. President, regarding industry, industrial production remains below what it was before the crisis, and France's foreign trade is experiencing a record deficit. Alongside future investments, which are long-term, do you think that short-term measures are needed to preserve factories and jobs in France?

THE PRESIDENT - I believe that we have taken these measures, even if they were not understood at the time we took them.

The abolition of the professional tax is an anti-relocation measure. People who kept a factory in France were penalized by a tax, the professional tax, which existed only in France and nowhere else in Europe. That is to say, if you own an industry, a factory, if you set it up in France, you are penalized by a professional tax; if you set it up elsewhere in Europe, there is no professional tax. This is indeed a measure we have taken; it is 6 billion euros less in levies on businesses.

The research tax credit represents more than 4 billion euros additional. We have the most favorable tax system in the world for investment.

Why have we lost market shares? You are right to point this out, on the one hand, because our competitors are more numerous and often better, it must be said, and on the other hand, because we have not invested enough, we have not been competitive enough. That is the question that arises. That is why we abolished the professional tax; that is why we are implementing the research tax credit, so that our companies are more competitive and that we regain market shares.

The problem is that while we were implementing the 35-hour workweek, others were improving their training, improving their investments, improving their manufacturing processes, and that is where the gap began. The gap began in the early 2000s. So what do we do in the face of this?

Future investments for the next twenty years, and then all the economic policy that we have tried to implement. Continuing to invest in nuclear energy is also to support French industry. The decision made by our German friends will require them to find 40 to 45 billion euros to replace that energy.

In any case, we cannot continue to ignore the world. The question is to prepare France for the challenges of the 21st century. Why? To continue to finance our social model. You can see the questions that arise. Of course, there is the question of debt, but to repay the debt, there must be growth, savings, and growth. We pay more than 40 billion euros in interest on the debt each year. And that will not stop after the 2012 presidential election. This is a subject that concerns all French people. I was not elected for France to experience the woes of Greece, Portugal, or Ireland. Now is not the time to talk. That is why we have acted.

This reality is a reality of today's world. No one can exempt themselves from it. Too much operating expenditure, too many public charges, too many public jobs, not enough innovations, not enough research, not enough investments. I promise you, this is not a matter of left or right, opposition or majority; it is a matter of general interest; there is no other choice for our country. This is the choice that must be made. Because this is the path that all successful countries have taken. If France exempts itself from this path, it will pay for it with more unemployment, more relocations, and loss of purchasing power, and the impossibility of financing its social model. It is unavoidable.

When we made the choice of the 35-hour workweek, our German friends made the choice of investment and competitiveness. Today, they have fewer unemployed, less deficit, and more growth. Our Greek friends, like our Portuguese and Irish friends, are paying dearly, especially the Greeks, for the incompetence of previous governments that did not want to see that when efforts are made in time, catastrophe can be avoided. That is the situation they find themselves in. And it is not a coincidence, you see, that France is preserved from all these risks, that its rating is preserved, and that France can borrow at very low rates... Greece borrows at 30% for 2 years. At 30%! France borrows at around 3%.

You know, those who would have the idea of going back on the non-replacement of one civil servant retiring for every two, of going back on pension reform, or of refusing a golden rule that would require all governments to plan a balanced budget in the long term: that would be the explosion of debt, the explosion of deficits, and the impossibility for France to finance itself.

This is not a question of controversy, it is not a question of left and right, believe me. It is a question of common sense and the general interest. The whole world knows it. And precisely, if we want to preserve our social model, to preserve our social model, because we do not want to destroy it, we want to preserve it.

QUESTION - Two small questions if you allow me. First, will there be a particular method of measurement, evaluation of return on investment for the State?

Second question, given the economic stakes, and in particular this file and the economic calendar of appointments, for example European ones, it is essential that France does not have a vacancy too long in the position of Minister of Economy. When do you plan to reshuffle if Ms. LAGARDE is appointed in Washington?

THE PRESIDENT - I saw that we were heading south to arrive at the great north, with a mastery... I congratulate you!

Every year, we intend to conduct a public evaluation of the pace of disbursement of future investments. Projects that have been awarded and the results obtained by the awarded projects. So every year, this will be the subject, of course, of a press conference, but it will also be the subject of a parliamentary meeting so that Parliament is involved. 35 billion is a considerable amount. It is normal that the method is specific and it is normal that there is an evaluation. So things are very clear.

Of course, how do we evaluate a capital endowment of a university? But at the same time, realize that our universities were the only universities in the world not to have autonomy and not to have a capital endowment. What do we do with a capital endowment? For example, we can invest, we can guarantee loans, we can benefit from real autonomy. There was none. We even wonder what the commitment, creativity, and intelligence of French academics were to succeed without autonomy, without capital.

Total transparency therefore on allocations, and total transparency on results, including on royalties, on the failures that we will certainly have, but also on successes.

For the rest, I will wait to know if Christine LAGARDE, for whom I have friendship and trust, is appointed, to decide with the Prime Minister the consequences we draw from it. But before that is done, there is no question of discussing it or answering this question. There is, it seems to me, a minimum of courtesy towards the members of the Board of Directors of the IMF who would undoubtedly be very surprised to see that we act as if it were done. Until the last minute, we will be respectful of their decision and we will await it serenely.

QUESTION - Mr. President, you mention future investments and, in fact, I have a double question. On the one hand, when we compare our trade deficit today to that of Germany, we see that Germany is indeed invested in a number of industrial sectors - we always mention the same ones - machine tools, etc. - and we mention its SMEs. I would like to know, this is my first question: how do you see France in ten or twenty years, what will be France's strengths in ten or twenty years? And do you think that your future investments will be able to resolve France's chronic trade deficit?

THE PRESIDENT - What is certain, and you are absolutely right, is that we need to choose.

We cannot be at a global level in all sectors. This is indeed the great difficulty of future investments and their allocation. Because the French tradition is to somewhat confuse equality and egalitarianism, that is to say that if we had done as usual, we would have divided our 35 billion by the number of regions and allocated the same amount to each region. We did not want that.

Secondly, if we take the example of industry, we have selected, with Eric BESSON and Christine LAGARDE, ten industrial sectors that we consider major. I can take examples: energy, I have mentioned it. We cannot conceive of a strong economy in twenty or thirty years, especially in a country that has no fossil energy, without an extremely powerful energy industry. That is a first subject. By the way, it is a subject that our German friends have faced.

Secondly, health. It is an absolutely major industry. France has a social security system like no other in the world. This should not, from my point of view, be solely for paying royalties to this or that American laboratory, which is excellent, by the way. But we would therefore have a wonderful health protection system for the French that would lead to reimbursing research efforts and ensuring the profits of large foreign laboratories. This is a considerable issue for us.

Thirdly, I believe that there is no possible economy if we do not maintain a transport industry: airplane, train, vehicle, boat. The experience of the world shows, just the automobile, it is 10% of our active population. We believe that our industrialists cannot alone develop the airplane of the future, the car of the future, or the boat of the future. That is another sector.

If I had to take other subjects - take textiles. Textiles will remain a French reality but more on niches than on a leading industrial sector, as we knew it in the 19th century.

I could take other examples, such as communication. In the world we live in, it is an absolutely major issue to see that the large global communication groups are Anglo-Saxon groups, and that if we look at the French groups, their international dimension is still to be demonstrated. When some have an international dimension, they are not present in television and when some are present on television, they are absent in other sectors. The investment we want to make in digital is something extremely important for us.

Very clearly, it is not up to me, nor to the ministers and the Prime Minister, to define in twenty-five years what the significant sectors will be. The political commitment we make to the French is to make choices. We cannot do everything. These choices have been made.

For example, take the shipyards of Saint-Nazaire, which the Prime Minister and I, for different reasons, care a lot about. I am convinced that in the leisure society of the 21st century, the new generation of cruise ships has a future. And that in France, for decades, we have known how to build magnificent ships. If we had not taken 33% of the capital of the shipyards of the Atlantic, they would have left.

A century of skills, know-how can be lost if we make a wrong decision. It is no secret to say that I did not appreciate the decision that was made in the mid-2000s to abandon Pechiney. I think it is a mistake, I say it as I think, that it is not for that reason that I am right, to have made a form of impasse on the chemical industry. I know the problems of the chemical industry, but can we imagine a great economy without chemistry? There you go, that is the type of thing.

At the same time, if we had let Siemens become the owner of Alstom - Siemens is a remarkable company - what would the French TGV be today? What would it be? Where would we be?

The same goes for health. We know well that we will have to spend more money on the health of the French. It is unavoidable, because treatments cost more, because the progress of science comes at a price, because the acceptance of pain for patients decreases and that is perfectly normal. But, at the same time, can every city have its cancer center, I mean a team that researches in its corner against cancer? There were three liver transplantation centers in the Paris region, for example, which are extremely heavy techniques, but do we not have an interest in also grouping them together and giving the leading team the means to exist globally? There you go, what we are building.

These choices are not made by us alone. We discuss with the professionals of all these choices, of course, because we are not omniscient, naturally. But, choices, the excellence of international juries, an evaluation, is really the policy in which we are engaged, even if I cannot tell you what the major sectors of the French economy will be in ten years or twenty years.

QUESTION - Mr. President, you said earlier that you were not elected for France to experience the torments of Greece and we know that you are working a lot right now with your partners precisely on how to find a solution to the financial problem of Greece? Is it true in particular that the French Treasury, French financial institutions are proposing a plan to reinvest 70% of Greek loan repayments into new thirty-year loans at 50%, with the remaining 20% placed in so-called "zero coupon" securities? Is that correct?

THE PRESIDENT - Yes.

QUESTION - Does this proposal have a chance of being adopted by your partners?

THE PRESIDENT - I hope so. Well, with Christine LAGARDE we are working a lot on this. When I went - not last week but the week before - to Berlin, we laid the foundations for a compromise with the Chancellor on the voluntary participation of the private sector in the Greek drama. We committed to moving from principle to concrete realization. The principle is the voluntary participation of the private sector. Why? Because if it had not been voluntary, it would have been seen as a default with a risk of cascading immense disasters.

From that moment on, we worked a lot - well, the Minister of Finance worked a lot - with banks and insurance companies, not just banks, and insurance companies, on what a voluntary participation of the private sector could be. And we concluded that by spreading the loans over a thirty-year period, aligning these loans with European loans, plus an indexing premium on what Greek growth will be, there was a system that each country could probably find interesting. The idea being that we will not let Greece fall, that we will defend the euro, it is in all our interests.

And to those who propose this madness that would be leaving the euro, I would like to say that it is madness, a totally senseless thing. Why? Because I remind you that France is committed to a debt of 1,500 billion, denominated in euros.

If France or any other country leaves the euro, its currency will devalue, but the debt we owe will remain denominated in euros. So leaving the euro means doubling or tripling the debt of the country that leaves the euro. This is an argument that I have not heard much and I am surprised not to hear it.

Am I making myself clear? When you incur a debt in euros, you keep that debt in euros. If tomorrow you leave the euro, the first thing that happens when you leave the euro is that the national currency devalues against the euro. If the national currency devalues against the euro, your stock of debt increases mechanically by the amount of the euro devaluation. That is to say that those who propose leaving the euro are proposing nothing less than to triple or double the debt of the French. It is madness. That is what I think. I do not know if I have made myself clear enough.

I also think that the euro is a tremendous achievement of European construction. It is Europe, the euro. And if we are no longer in Europe, well, that leads to confrontations. And who thinks that we would be stronger alone to face the harshness of the world and the competition of the world? It is nonsensical. I mean, there comes a time when it is a matter of the general interest. I understand of course the realities of politics, I have participated in it myself, but there are limits, and the limit is responsibility and the general interest. I also say that we have made commitments to reduce our deficits in front of the whole world and that no one can call that into question. No one.

So of course, there will be the efforts that our Greek friends will have to make, both the majority and the opposition, that is for sure. And the project we have, we put it in the debate as an element that we hope is positive, we are also ready to amend it, the French project is not the alpha and the omega.

QUESTION - Mr. President, you mentioned in your introduction the underestimation of the crisis, saying "we." Do you include yourself in this "we" by saying that you underestimated the crisis? And does this general underestimation perhaps justify the fact that the disappointment regarding your record, particularly in terms of purchasing power, would be overestimated, oversized by the French, which would lead to a certain loss of confidence for the future?

THE PRESIDENT - I tried to follow the reasoning. I got there, because it was presented so courteously that I am sensitive to it.

Yes, there is an underestimation of the severity of the crisis. Why? Because the crisis has caused a lot of suffering in the world, and it has caused suffering in France - less than elsewhere. I do not underestimate the suffering of our compatriots in the face of the crisis - 500,000 more unemployed, but less than in other countries - and I would not want anyone to imagine that the crisis we experienced was a crisis like any other.

That is not true. Why? Because it is the first time in world history that we have experienced a crisis that affected all sectors and all regions of the world at the same time. The crises known in the past, including that of 1929, were crises that affected developed countries; we had Asian crises, we had crises in Latin America. Here, it is a crisis, you see, that has affected all regions of the world; everywhere we turned, things were collapsing. And we were not far from catastrophe.

I promised in my speech in Toulon that French savers would not be ruined, that the banking plan would allow us, without costing a penny to taxpayers, to preserve the savings of the French people. We kept our word.

But the world came close to the edge of the abyss, that is a reality. And furthermore, there are still many reasons that could lead the world to experience, perhaps not the same sequence, but a sequence just as grave in the future. I think it is not alarmist to say that.

Since you are talking about disappointment regarding purchasing power, I do not remember seeing a government that the French recognize for what it has done in terms of purchasing power. And so I know well that on the issue of purchasing power, we, like those who preceded us, will have an infinite difficulty in convincing.

But you follow, you who are professionals, the indices. You consult them; what do the official and independent indices say? That even in the heart of the crisis in 2009, purchasing power increased in France. Am I mistaken?

QUESTION - .... (inaudible)

THE PRESIDENT - That is commentary; I am talking about the indices. Do the independent indices, the indices from INSEE, the recurring indices that measure the evolution of the purchasing power of the French say that, including in the heart of the crisis in 2009, purchasing power increased?

That the French do not believe it, I understand, and I share your opinion. But if the indices said the opposite, you would have started your question by saying: "INSEE shows that purchasing power has decreased; what are you doing to make it increase?" As a professional, you did not start like that. You said: "there is a problem of trust towards you," so you started with commentary and then came to the fact. My way of responding to you is to start from the fact and try to change the commentary. So, what do you want me to say, including about the public service?

I would still like to tell the French that there are European countries that have reduced public service salaries by 15% and pensions by 15%. We did not want that. There are European countries that have reduced the "disabled adults" allowance. We increased it by 25%. There are European countries where the amount of scholarships in universities has been reduced by 25%. Not so far away, I am not denouncing anyone, but not so far away, a small arm of the sea. We did not want that, since we are increasing it.

Our response to the crisis is both to make savings and to invest. Because I think that a country that has experienced such a crisis cannot retract, but I would not want that to lead you to minimize the severity of the crisis that our country has experienced.

QUESTION - Mr. President, I would like to ask you a question about your future investment in yourself. There are many comments everywhere; we are talking about your change of style, it does not matter, are you thinking about 2012? Are you sincerely considering your candidacy, a possible re-election in 2012?

THE PRESIDENT - How nice it is to associate that with future investments! And I am really sensitive to that, and I would not have thought of it myself! But I would like to tell you something serious. 2012 is next year. So to say that one is not thinking about next year, no one would believe that. But I have a specificity. I am the President of the Republic; I have duties, the duties of my office, I cannot exempt myself from them. It is perfectly normal for political leaders who do not have the same duties of an office, who do not have the same responsibilities, to think of themselves, to think of their political family; that is normal, it is the free play of democracy. But I cannot; I am the president of France, president of the G8, and president of the G20. I cannot; I do not have the right. Even before thinking about a possible other mandate, I must think about finishing this one. The French gave me five years; there have been four, and there is a little less than a year left. It is my duty; I have no choice; I have obligations, an agenda, a responsibility, accounts to render, results to achieve, a government team with the Prime Minister to manage, decisions to make every day. I cannot distract myself from that.

The time will come; we will talk about it again, but it is not a formula, it is not agility, it is not a matter of style; it is a reality, and believe me, I measure this reality every day because every day I have to make decisions with the government, with the Prime Minister that are difficult decisions and that make the task quite complicated. But it must be done because there is no choice, and if we do not do it, and if I do not do it, no one will. So let us also get out of this habit that is so common, which consists of thinking about what we will do afterward when we have not even finished what we have to do. I will not move from this conviction because it is my duty throughout the year 2011, as I said in my wishes at the beginning of the year. There is no other choice, believe me.

QUESTION - Precisely by the end of your term, do you intend to address a question that has just been raised by economists from the Economic Analysis Council, who point out that to preserve the future of companies, it is necessary to preserve their competitiveness and reduce the burden of financing social protection that weighs on the accounts of companies? Do you intend to reopen this question of financing social protection by 2012?

THE PRESIDENT - No. We do not have and we will not carry out structural changes on the financing of social protection beyond the question of dependency. I will explain myself, not that the problem does not arise.

We cannot tell companies: "Here is everything we have implemented to strengthen competitiveness" and constantly put them under the stress of fiscal and financial instability, with a new project every day, with a new tax every day, with a new change every day. Companies need stability to be competitive.

That said, does the question of financing our social protection and its base arise for the coming years? Yes, of course it does. How to make our imports participate in the financing of our social protection, how to lighten the cost of labor so that we can put work at the heart of everything and that it is not discouraging to hire?

These are extremely important questions that could perhaps occupy part of the debate of the meeting that was mentioned to me a few minutes ago. It is a subject. But I think that it would create instability today when we need stability. So I do not close the door; I say: "Here is what it is." I add that it would be time for all these subjects to be considered in a European dimension. Not everything is reduced to the Franco-French debate. Especially in terms of taxation. Let us look at what others are doing; let us imagine what we could do together. And to the whole extraordinarily important question of our partnership with Germany and the strengthening of convergence between the German economy and the French economy. Because the more the world opens up, the more disparities within Europe are problematic. And the more we will need to drive this harmonization. We will have the opportunity to talk about it again. I do not want to tire your patience.

Perhaps one or two last questions?

QUESTION - Mr. President, to return to debt and deficit, I would like to know: given our deficits, at what level do you think it would become problematic to invest and find the necessary resources to invest, to maintain the growth we have today or hope for higher growth in the coming years?

THE PRESIDENT - For us, the point where everything tips, if you will, is the level of deficit below which France's debt decreases in relation to its national wealth. That is the rendezvous, in essence. There is no need to be an economist. What we know is that below 3% - around 3% deficit - given the growth rate, the debt, the weight of the debt decreases. That is the rendezvous; that is where the tipping point occurs; there is no need for 150 criteria! Above 3% deficit, France's debt increases in relation to national wealth; below that, gradually, France's debt decreases, not in absolute value but in relative value compared to the economy. That is the rendezvous.

And we have made commitments in Europe to be at that rendezvous by 2013. These commitments are not just things; it is not a question of liberalism or socialism, of right or left. There are governments of all political colors around the table of the European Council.

There is common sense; there is the general interest. We cannot continue to spend more than we earn. So having deficits during the crisis is perfectly normal. We lost 22% of our tax revenues in one go in 2009, the French state. It is normal for the deficit to increase. But when growth resumes, we cannot continue at this level of deficits.

So this rendezvous must be kept, not because it is Mr. FILLON, not because it is Mrs. LAGARDE, not because it is Mr. SARKOZY: because it is the national interest. There you go.

QUESTION - Mr. President, the socialists are opening this week the candidacy process for the primaries. Have you taken the time to evaluate their economic proposals, and do you think they meet the criteria you mentioned during your speech?

THE PRESIDENT - Frankly, the analysis has been quite quick. I imagine that these proposals will be developed and that there will be a need to discuss them when they have been elaborated and developed.

QUESTION - Hello, I return to the grand loan, to the method. The state has addressed local actors; it is a first in a way. What judgment do you have on the regions that are mostly left-wing and on the functioning of decentralization in France?

THE PRESIDENT - I must tell you that I was very impressed by the responsiveness of all the actors. I did not expect such a festival of innovations, initiatives, even sometimes from small teams that were considered losing on paper and that were selected. It is absolutely extraordinary. And what touched me even more is that it happened outside the institutions.

If you follow local files, there are teams from laboratories in universities that did not even go through the university's board of directors, who mobilized, who submitted their files, and who won. So I experienced this more as a huge French breath of fresh air where suddenly the levels were not an obstacle, but we could exempt ourselves from a somewhat conventional administrative process.

Furthermore, regarding French decentralization, frankly, it is the entire territorial reform that we have implemented, of which I say for my part that it is a first step and that certainly more will need to be done. Frankly: municipalities, communities of municipalities, countries, departments, regions, state, Europe... No, it was not possible to continue like that; it is not decentralization; it is the superposition of administrative levels that weigh heavily, that need to be financed, which generally step on each other's toes. That is why we wanted a territorial reform that brings the department and the region closer together by entrusting them to the same interlocutors so that at least they can talk to each other since they are the same. Today, in many regions, departments and regions do not talk to each other. There are 20 billion euros of common expenditures between departments and regions in the same sectors. This will be the subject of further comments, I imagine.

QUESTION - Hello, two questions Mr. President. You mentioned that the State is mobilizing for future investments, some companies as well, but do you perhaps consider that companies that pay very, very high salaries, in the millions of euros, may not be doing this work of future investment? And are you perhaps planning to tax these companies as Mr. BERTRAND mentioned? A second question regarding Libya. Are there currently discussions to get Mr. KADHAFI out of the country or perhaps even direct discussions? And do you perhaps fear that some of your allies might decide to leave the Alliance? Thank you.

THE PRESIDENT - I do not think that a few high salaries or very high salaries prevent corporate investments, but they are shocking. One sometimes wonders if certain very high executives are aware that they live in the same world as others. Frankly, it is true, the question arises. In certain banks that were in very difficult situations, which have recovered - that is very good - when we see salary increases or astronomical bonuses, it does not call into question the investment, but it is shocking. It is shocking.

That someone who discovers a new process, who makes an invention, who starts a business, who develops a project earns money, a lot of money because he has put his own money, his life at stake and the reward is there, good for him. What has Bill GATES brought to the United States? Wonderful!

But someone who is simply the head of a large company and who, by a windfall effect, sees his remuneration increase by 25% while the company was in a catastrophic situation before, that is shocking, it is true that it is shocking. One sometimes wonders if they think. It is certain. So Xavier BERTRAND has made proposals, we support them. But I would so much like a little common sense to prevent the government from having to react with a text. It is not great either, I readily acknowledge, but if there were common sense. If people could understand.

Secondly, I must truthfully say that I absolutely did not understand the violent reaction of the president of MEDEF regarding the bonus for employees. We could have discussed it calmly, simply. How can we tell French employees: "when there is a crisis, tighten your belts" and "when there is a recovery, you have no rights, just to be silent"? No, I do not agree, it is shocking. So I am not saying that the project that comes from the government did not deserve to be amended, to be changed, to be discussed again. Certainly. But why such a frontal opposition? It makes no sense. If there is money to distribute to shareholders because profits are significant, we can also think about distributing some to employees, they are part of it, the employees, in the increase of profits. Sometimes it seems that the simplest things are hard to get through. In any case, the government's determination is total. If a company distributes more dividends, makes more profits, it is normal that employees receive their fair reward. Not just the shareholders. Employees too. It matters, the employees.

On Libya, that is another subject.

I would first say that I was quite shocked by what I saw and heard about France's military investment. I would like to remind you that in 2009, France invested 18 billion euros in military equipment and research - this also benefits our civilian industry, as I mentioned at the Salon du Bourget. In 2010 again, 16 billion euros. I would also like to pay tribute to our soldiers who do absolutely remarkable work.

And on Libya, Mr. KADHAFI knows perfectly well what he needs to do for peace to return. After 41 years of dictatorship, it may be time to stop, for him to leave power and for Libyans to consider a democratic future. It depends only on him.

QUESTION - Mr. President, you regularly cite Germany as an example, but we have the feeling that the divergences between the two countries are multiplying, increasing. We see this very clearly with nuclear energy with a billion in the large investment plan at the moment when Germany announces its definitive exit from nuclear energy in 10 years. We have also seen it regarding Greece, Libya, and economic results where the two countries diverge. Does this not pose a serious problem for the functioning of Europe since the Franco-German couple is normally the engine of Europe?

THE PRESIDENT - No, on economic results, our two countries do not diverge. They are the two engines of the European economy. France had 1% growth in the first quarter. Germany's growth is even stronger, but to diverge, France would have to be in recession and Germany in growth, whereas France is in growth and, judging by the results of the first quarter, in strong growth.

But it is true that we have diverged on a number of issues. But then if I understand correctly, should we give up nuclear energy because our German friends are giving it up? That is to say, should I as President of the Republic turn my back on what General de GAULLE, Georges POMPIDOU, Valéry GISCARD D'ESTAING, François MITTERRAND, and Jacques CHIRAC have successively done? Since the choice of nuclear energy was confirmed by François MITTERRAND and it is to his credit, as by all my predecessors. You see the complexity of things.

Secondly, should we not have intervened in Libya because our German friends, who did participate in the Paris Summit, did not want to intervene? And at that moment, what would the atmosphere of the press conference have been? I would have been told - how do you say? - "follower." I have the choice between diverging or following! Allow me to choose a third way, the French way, of an independent country that makes its choices, that tries to gather its European partners around it.

My role is, with the government, to defend the superior interest of the Nation. And the superior interest of the Nation is to have an energy that guarantees our independence, and the superior interest of the Nation is that France remains faithful to its history and its message. Benghazi was about to be massacred and thanks to the French army and its allies, Benghazi was preserved. Just that, it seems to me, was the justification for our investment in Libya.

For the rest, it is precisely because we do not agree on everything that Europe is based on compromises and efforts. It is not simple but there are no other choices. And believe me, I prefer this to what the generations that preceded us experienced, because for the generations that preceded us, it ended differently, in war, and that is why I care so much about Europe which is peace.

Thank you.