Press conference by Mr. Nicolas Sarkozy, President of the Republic, on the action of the European Union in response to the armed conflict between Russia and Georgia concerning South Ossetia and Abkhazia, in Brussels on September 1, 2008.

France Nicolas Sarkozy · President of France

1 September 2008 · Press conference on the action of the European Union regarding the armed conflict between Russia and Georgia · Brussels, Belgium

Context
Sarkozy addressed a press conference at an extraordinary European Council in Brussels on September 1, 2008, regarding the EU response to the Russia-Georgia armed conflict.
Main themes
Russia-Georgia conflict over South Ossetia and Abkhazia, European Union unity, ceasefire implementation, six-point peace plan, Georgian sovereignty and territorial integrity, EU-Russia relations, international observation mechanism, humanitarian and reconstruction aid, French EU presidency leadership, rejection of spheres of influence
Duration
~33 min
85th percentile
Words
3,945
85th percentile
Sentences
179
86th percentile
Readability
48
58th percentile
Grade
11.7
41st percentile
Syntax
2.98
45th percentile
Vocabulary
2.10
27th percentile

Translated from French

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

179 sentences in 41 paragraphs

Ladies and Gentlemen,

The convening of an extraordinary European Council is not a usual measure. If I took the initiative with the support of all the countries of the Union, it is because Europe considers that the crisis in Georgia is of extreme gravity and that Europe wants to assume its responsibilities.

This is a very strong message of unity that Europe sends beyond the diverse sensitivities that naturally express themselves among its members. You certainly remember that the last extraordinary council was in 2003, regarding Iraq, from which Europe emerged divided, thus powerless and inaudible. Europe is today united around proposals that the Presidency has presented to the council.

Everyone agrees to consolidate the ceasefire obtained during the visit to Moscow and Tbilisi by Bernard Kouchner and myself on August 12. Everyone in Europe is calling for the full implementation of the six-point plan that was signed by all parties at the highest level. I also note that this six-point plan is the only document recognized by all parties involved. Europe believes that any peaceful and lasting solution to the Georgian conflict must be based on respect for the independence, sovereignty, and territorial integrity of Georgia and not on faits accomplis or unilateral measures that are contrary to international law. Europe will continue to be fully involved in resolving this crisis. Moreover, if Europe does not do it, who will do it in its place?

We will therefore engage politically by continuing mediation between the parties and, in agreement with all members of the Union, we will return to Moscow and Tbilisi accompanied by President Barroso, whom I want to thank once again for the very close proximity of our work, Javier Solana, the High Representative, and of course, Bernard Kouchner. We will ask Russia for the scrupulous application of the six-point plan.

Europe will be fully involved in the reconstruction of Georgia where we will extend our humanitarian assistance and we will take the initiative to convene an International Conference on the reconstruction of Georgia as soon as possible. We will also examine—this will be the entire work of the commission and I thank President Barroso—the strengthening of the relationship between Georgia and Europe.

Finally, the European Union will accelerate the establishment of an international observation mechanism to verify that the parties scrupulously respect their commitments.

I take away from our meeting the unity of all Europeans. I want to clarify that this meeting was not directed against Russia, but it is also clear that Russia's behavior in recent weeks, with its disproportionate military reaction, with the recognition of the self-proclaimed independence of the two entities, and with the maintenance of Russian troops on Georgian territory, has raised deep concern in Europe and beyond. What does Russia want? Trust and cooperation, or distrust and rising tensions?

The European Union desires a genuine partnership with Russia, a partnership that is in the interest of all, but to build a partnership, both sides must be willing. The European Union will therefore continue to examine the implications of this crisis on its relationship with Russia. It goes without saying that the meeting on September 8 is extremely important for the future of relations between Europe and Russia.

The unity of Europeans deserves to be emphasized; the return of spheres of influence is not acceptable. Yalta is over.

It was a session that occupied us for several hours, and speaking under the guidance of Javier Solana, President Barroso, and Bernard Kouchner, I can say that consensus was relatively easy to achieve. We unambiguously condemn the disproportionate reaction of the Russians and we, Europe, are aware of our responsibility in maintaining dialogue with our Russian neighbors. We are also aware of Georgia's expectations of the European Union. This expectation will not be disappointed with financial, humanitarian, and economic support.

José-Manuel Barroso: First of all, I would like to commend the initiative taken by President Sarkozy to organize this extraordinary European Council. The French Presidency and President Sarkozy have shown great determination and speed in managing this crisis. The French Presidency has effectively promoted and highlighted European unity, a unity that is increasingly important in the face of an extremely complex situation. Negotiating a ceasefire and the rapid dispatch of humanitarian aid would demonstrate an effective European Union at the forefront of the international response.

Today, the European Union is reacting collectively and providing responses by common agreement. And I believe I can tell you that we are sending clear messages to Russia, to Georgia, and also to the rest of the world, because it was possible, as President Sarkozy said during the European Council, to show that we are united in defending our values and that we also want to work together on this issue, on Russia, on Georgia.

The dramatic events of the last few weeks have raised serious questions about the state of relations between Russia and the European Union. We want a modern partnership that takes into account mutual fundamental interests, a partnership that we believe is in the common interest of Russia and the European Union.

But it is clear that in light of recent events, we cannot continue as if nothing has happened. That is why President Sarkozy, myself, and Javier Solana will go to Moscow and Tbilisi next Monday. This will be an opportunity to take stock of the situation. In particular, it will be the time to verify the status of the implementation of the six points of the ceasefire agreement. And we decided today that the Commission will review all new initiatives aimed at deepening our relations, so the Council can draw conclusions ahead of the Nice Summit in November. At this stage and pending these conclusions, we have concluded, and I quote point 10 of the Council conclusions: "The European Council mandates its President to continue discussions aimed at the full implementation of the six-point agreement. To this end, the President of the European Council will travel to Moscow on September 8, accompanied by the President of the Commission and the High Representative. As long as the withdrawal of troops to their positions prior to August 7 has not been achieved, meetings aimed at negotiating the partnership agreement are postponed." At the same time, we want to tell Russia that we are indeed working towards a constructive and responsible partnership.

Regarding Georgia, we are working together and we received today an enhanced mandate to prepare certain initiatives concerning Georgia. You probably know that the Commission has made available to Georgia 6 million euros to address the immediate needs of all civilians affected by the conflict. If we add to these 6 million the almost 9 million made available by the member states as well as the civil protection action coordinated by the member states, we see that the European contribution was not simply a rhetorical contribution; it was a concrete contribution on the ground. But there is work to be done. The major concern remains the fate of the 20,000 people displaced by the conflict. Our experts have been on the ground and will continue assessments in the coming days. We are ready to meet the imperatives, including through a donor conference very soon. And we have agreed that the European Union is determined to deepen political and economic relations. Our perspective is the creation of a free trade area, the facilitation of short-term visas, and a readmission agreement. It is of course also up to Georgia to commit itself to pursuing these objectives.

So, I can tell you that apart from these very important conclusions regarding our relationship with Georgia and Russia in the immediate term, the European Council also addressed longer-term issues that are reflected in the conclusions. I will not go back to them for now, but they concern the need to strengthen the common energy policy in Europe, particularly in terms of solidarity. It is a conclusion of the European Council to work with even more urgency in this area and also to strengthen our Eastern partnership. This is also something to put on the immediate agenda of the European Union.

And I want to say that I am a witness to how it has been possible, under the Presidency of Nicolas Sarkozy, to achieve a consensus on an extremely sensitive issue such as relations with Russia and the crisis in Georgia, which strengthens Europe and I believe is a source of hope for the weeks and months to come.

QUESTION - When you speak of an easy consensus, Mr. President, did the discussions also focus on the strategic and thus energy partnership with Russia? Is Europe not too dependent on Russian energy for it to be discussed or put on the table soon?

THE PRESIDENT - You will see it in the conclusions. There is the decision of Europe to do everything to diversify its energy resources. We have decided to postpone all discussions on the new strategic partnership pending our visit to Moscow and Tbilisi on September 8 and the concrete results we expect from it, including the full, immediate implementation of the six-point agreement, which was the subject of a long conversation last night that I had with President Medvedev. And which includes in particular the issue of the return of refugees, international discussions on stability, security in Abkhazia and South Ossetia, and the replacement of Russian troops with an international force, the form of which we have an agreement from the Union for Europe to participate, and this will be the entire mission of Javier Solana to see under what conditions between the OSCE and the European Union we can set up this force. I add, following what President Barroso excellently said, that I fully intend, with France as the Presidency of the Union, to push forward on the energy-climate package, because the best response to those who tell me that we are too dependent on Russian oil and gas is to make an effort in energy conservation, to diversify energy sources that are not simply geographical diversifications but also renewable energy and nuclear. And finally, not to neglect the institutional question, the Irish problem, because the crisis shows that Europe needs strong and stable institutions. So, this crisis should be an opportunity to move forward for Europe, and I believe that everyone will tell you that we are quite happy that Europe is showing political will and that it is Europe that is at the forefront to prevent war. And Europe has spoken with one voice; everyone agrees on the implementation of the six-point plan, on the move on September 8, and on the consequences to be drawn from it.

QUESTION - Mr. President, in light of what happened afterwards, do you not regret not having included the territorial integrity of Georgia in the plan of which you were the architect?

THE PRESIDENT - You know, we can have many regrets. But I simply observe, Mrs. Schneider, that the Russians entered Georgia following the events you know on August 7, that the ceasefire was obtained on the 10th, three days later. There are not many regrets to have from that point of view. And if on September 8 we achieve the withdrawal of Russian forces, it would mean that in one month, the European Union will have avoided war. So, I am sure there are many things we should have done much better, but I still observe that what has been done has allowed for the cessation of hostilities. As for the rest, Mrs. Schneider, I hope you do not discover that the problem of South Ossetia and Abkhazia began on August 7, since it has been the subject of United Nations resolutions since 1992. I add that the withdrawal of Russian troops is on the lines prior to August 16. Why, Mrs. Schneider? Because there were Russian troops that were planned and authorized under the peacekeeping forces by a decision of the United Nations. I imagine therefore that the territorial integrity of Georgia was not an issue before August 16. It should not be an issue now either. There are principles, and it is these principles that we have retained.

I also add, when we arrive with Bernard Kouchner on August 10, what do the Americans say? What does the whole world say? That the Russian forces are heading towards Tbilisi. And when we leave on the evening of the 10th, the Russian forces stop, a ceasefire is announced, and we then begin negotiations for withdrawal.

I admit that we have not succeeded in everything, but at last, we have never seen Europe in such a willing and reactive position to put an end to a very serious crisis. Now, the Council has recalled the principles: respect for integrity, sovereignty, and independence.

I would also like to say that at that time - I am talking about August 10 - the very clearly expressed will of the Russian leaders was to overthrow Mr. Saakashvili's regime. From the very first contact, I clearly indicated that this was unacceptable. It was not for the Russians to designate the legitimate government of Georgia. Moreover, it is the Georgian President himself who co-signed, with Mr. Medvedev and me, the six-point plan. To think about it at that moment was the best, perhaps even the only solution to avoid further deaths.

QUESTION - For President Sarkozy. I have difficulty understanding, in paragraph 3 of the conclusions, the sentence regarding each State in Europe. I also have before me your text from August 17 in Le Figaro where you say that Georgia is on European soil. Does this mean that Georgia, in your view, has the vocation to become, soon or eventually, a member of the European Union? Is this a muted enlargement here?

THE PRESIDENT - What does point 3 mean? It is very simple. In response to the concerns expressed by a number of countries, members of the Union or neighbors of the Union, concerns about what Russian policy meant, we wanted to emphasize that the principle of integrity, independence, and sovereignty naturally applies not only to Georgia but to all countries, whether they are, by the way, on European territory or not.

As for the issue of enlargement, I have had the opportunity to explain myself on this, particularly regarding the adoption of the Lisbon Treaty. I would like to remind you that only Lisbon allows for enlargement. The Nice Treaty - I was not there, I did not negotiate it - provides for a Europe of 27. I add that I have not been mandated to comment on the membership perspective of any particular country. The reconstruction work in Georgia, the conference we are going to organize, is the request of the Georgians. This request is not to join the European Union hastily. And so, this will not happen in a concealed manner.

QUESTION - To follow up on my colleague's question, a question of geography, still. If Georgia is in Europe, I would like to understand, if we draw a median line, why Turkey, in your view, is not there, since Georgia is, a priori, much further east, I would say, than Turkey?

A second question, if you allow me, regarding Ukraine. In the current circumstances, should we respond positively to Ukraine's request to clearly open a perspective of membership in the European Union?

THE PRESIDENT - Regarding Ukraine, with President Barroso, we will have the opportunity to chair the Summit between the European Union and Ukraine, a country of more than 40 million inhabitants. We have a lot to do to strengthen our relations with Ukraine before any possible membership. I must say, moreover, that Ukraine has not even made an explicit request for it, the first element.

The second element is an eternal debate. Is Europe an idea? Is Europe a geography? Everyone can have their own conception of things. I did not say that Georgia was in Europe; I said that this conflict between Russia and Georgia primarily concerned Europe. Everyone understands that well. Moreover, fortunately, we did not seek anyone to try to resolve this conflict, since only Europe was in a position to provide a response. You will see that, in the text, we added a sentence to express the importance we attach to strengthening relations with Ukraine and to defining an Eastern partnership that should allow, between indifference and membership, to find the paths of an ambitious middle ground.

QUESTION - I would like to know if this crisis does not show the dramatic insufficiency of European defense, because today, the European Union has all the appearance of a paper tiger, since it has absolutely no instruments to support its demands, unlike the Americans, for example.

THE PRESIDENT - Mr. Quatremer, I would like to say that, for once, I do not fully share your opinion. Well,...

MR. QUATREMER - ... Well, not too much.

THE PRESIDENT - ... But that Europe lacks a defense policy, that it should have a more ambitious defense policy, we defend this idea consistently. However, I would like to say that the solution to the crisis between Europe and Russia is not military. Well, listen, we did not see the fall of the Berlin Wall, we did not see the end of communist dictatorship, we did not see the end of the Warsaw Pact, to re-enter a new Cold War where it would be asserted that relations between Russia and Europe can only be expressed through military confrontation. I call on everyone to keep their cool.

Remember, you write, Mr. Quatremer! You tell me that it is a paper tiger, but then what would it be if we were a tiger outright, because a paper tiger that achieves - I am talking about Europe - the ceasefire, the withdrawal, even if partial, all in less than a month and which is today - I am talking about the European Union - the only entity capable of discussing to resolve the problem of Georgia? Will the problem of Georgia be resolved better with boats sent to the Black Sea or through diplomatic, political, economic discussion as we are mandated, Mr. Barroso, Mr. Solana, Mr. Kouchner, and I, to engage in?

I am told: "yes, but Russia is very important for Europe." Well, Europe is very important for Russia. Moreover, if that were not the case, I do not see why practically every day of this month of August, I would have been led, as President of the Union, of the Council, to have contact with Mr. Medvedev or Mr. Putin. It is true, Europe has fewer divisions than the United States in solving this crisis. Who today is the most effective in helping Georgia? Is it counted in the number of boats? I also want to say that the United States of America have been very loyal in managing the crisis with Europe. They had a tougher position on the substance than the one we expressed, but we tried to have a complementary position, and I was very sensitive to the fact that Mrs. Rice came at the request of President Bush to France to understand the spirit of the six-point plan. I remind you that it was Mrs. Rice who brought the six-point plan to Mr. Saakashvili and who pushed for Georgia to adopt it. So there was a complementary action, and I believe that this reassured many people in Europe to see certainly an independent position of Europe in relation to the United States but without opposition. I do not think that the response to this should be a military response, or even a NATO response. It is a political response; it is a choice that Russian leaders must make. What do they want in relations with Europe? We want partnership, we want peace, but we want respect for a number of principles. Georgia is an independent country; it is not for its great neighbor to set its borders. How do we achieve this? Through dialogue, through discussion, and I am hopeful that we will succeed. Of course, it is not simple; it is not simple for anyone, and President Saakashvili and Georgia know perfectly well that Europe will support them politically and economically. At the same time, let us not launch the Cold War like this, let us not strain relations, let us not show our muscles, demonstrations of force, bravado, sanctions, counter-sanctions. For what benefit and who will come out winning? No one. If one day we have to get there, when the time comes, everyone will take their responsibilities, and I will take mine, but that moment has not come, and if it is to come, it will be all the more effective if we have managed to keep our cool at the moment when we had to prioritize dialogue. There is a meeting on September 8, there is a plan; let dialogue and diplomacy do their work. If it works, the Union will have proven its effectiveness; if it does not work, we are perfectly all in agreement, the 27 and all the institutions, we will then meet and make other decisions, but we must scale things and the contacts I have with President Medvedev lead me to think that, in the current state of affairs, what we are doing is what needed to be done without insulting the future and without rushing. Immediately going to excess, and how do we get out of it afterward? The world has enough conflicts so that we do not add one without having given ourselves every chance to calm things down.

QUESTION - You repeatedly say that we must respect the plan, the six points, it is the most important, but since Russia already officially recognizes the two small countries on the territory of Georgia, how do you expect it to withdraw from its decision, or are there other means to persuade them?

THE PRESIDENT - Russia has expressed a political decision that we have condemned unambiguously, but it is Russia's right to express what it wishes to express. To my knowledge, the deliberations of the United Nations state that Abkhazia and South Ossetia are Georgia. The six-point plan provides for international discussions to be initiated on the issue of stability and security in Abkhazia and South Ossetia. What I wish, what President Barroso wishes, what Mr. Javier Solana wishes, what Bernard Kouchner wishes, is for these discussions to begin. Then I am told: "but there was the precedent of Kosovo..." but excuse me, before we recognized the independence of Kosovo, there were years of discussions in international forums, there was mediation by the United Nations, and I also reminded President Medvedev that when Europe recognized Kosovo, Russia condemned Europe's decision. They should not be surprised that we condemn Russia's decision. Let discussions begin, and what will they lead to? We will see. I add that it was very important for President Medvedev to accept the principle of discussion on the return of refugees, not just the refugees since August 7, but the refugees since the early 1990s because there can be no solution, because if we are to talk about Kosovo, then we cannot accept what has been called ethnic cleansing on either side, and everyone must be coherent as well. If he wants the self-determination of peoples, it is a principle to which I am very attached, but this principle applied to Russia's partners can serve others. What we want is for international discussions to be organized around the decisions that have already been made by the UN, that is to say, it is Georgia. There you go, in its territorial integrity.

Thank you.