Statement by Mr. Nicolas Sarkozy, President of the Republic, on a national strategy for research and innovation, in Paris on January 22, 2009.

France Nicolas Sarkozy · President of France

22 January 2009 · Paris, France

Context
Sarkozy addressed university presidents, business leaders, and officials in Paris on January 22, 2009, to unveil France's national research and innovation strategy amid the global financial crisis.
Main themes
National research and innovation strategy, higher education reform, university funding increases, crisis response and modernization, overcoming conservatism and immobility, Campus Plan investments, OECD competitiveness, economic recovery plan, knowledge economy, structural reform of research organizations
Duration
~32 min
84th percentile
Words
3,801
84th percentile
Sentences
227
91st percentile
Readability
56
78th percentile
Grade
9.6
17th percentile
Syntax
2.71
13th percentile
Vocabulary
2.13
33rd percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 57%56%
  • Economic 23%22%
  • Social 10%10%
  • Ceremonial 8%8%
  • Geopolitical 1%1%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 3%

227 sentences in 55 paragraphs

Ladies and Gentlemen Ministers,

Ladies and Gentlemen Elected Officials,

Ladies and Gentlemen Presidents of Universities, Directors of Grandes Écoles and Research Organizations,

Ladies and Gentlemen Business Leaders,

At the heart of a crisis such as the world has never known, it is our duty to put in place today the assets that will allow France to emerge strengthened from this ordeal. Research and innovation are the keys for our country to come out of this unprecedented crisis stronger.

I had the opportunity to say it during the European Innovation Summit: in the face of the crisis, it would be catastrophic for us to retreat into ourselves, it would be catastrophic to wait timidly for it to pass; this strategy of immobility, timidity, and withdrawal is forbidden to us. It is not a question of ideology, it is not a question of right or left, it is a question of common sense; there is no hope to be found in a strategy made of immobility and withdrawal.

The crisis gives us the opportunity to accelerate the modernization of obsolete structures and to change our mindsets, because in our country this is not something that is done easily, and yet it must be done. Regarding our research and innovation efforts, I do not need to convince you of the crucial dimension this will have in the new world that is taking shape.

A few months ago, together with the Prime Minister, we tasked Valérie Pécresse with coordinating the definition of a national research and innovation strategy. Why? Because in the absence of a clear strategy in this area and with a higher education and research system ill-suited to the challenges of knowledge and growth in the 21st century, we should not be surprised that France is struggling to find its place. It is not because we have a strategy that we will succeed, but honestly, when we do not have a strategy, we have very little chance of succeeding.

And today we are not among the leading countries in the industrialized world for research and innovation. There is a reason for this; it is because we have often shied away from the necessity to reform our universities and research organizations. I do not blame anyone; it is a fact that everyone can see. There are always good reasons not to carry out the reform, but in total, that amounts to bad reasons.

We must recognize that for decades, conservatism has always prevailed. No one was happy with the current state, but we had so many fears about the movement of reforms that we thought, in the end, it was better to keep a bad system rather than move towards a system that could be worse. But the forces of conservatism and immobility have always triumphed. This must stop.

Higher education, research, and innovation are our absolute priority.

We needed additional resources; there is a great debate in France, there is no area where you are told we have too many resources. We start discussing; you pay first, we discuss later. There is more first, better later. The additional resources, dear Valérie, we have committed with the Prime Minister, and we will continue to do so. Our universities have benefited since the 2008 budget from increases in their resources, and I assert that they have never experienced such increases.

The expenditure per year and per student has increased by 1,000 euros since 2007 and will increase by another 37% over the period 2009-2011, finally placing us in 2012 above the average of OECD countries. We do not boast about it, but we were below. We will surpass that. No government had previously made such an effort in such a short time, none.

The first capital allocations are being announced for the Campus Plan, with several hundred million euros being allocated as capital endowment to each of the ten selected projects. By the way, I must tell you, this is a total revolution. The idea of saying that finally, in France, we are capable of choosing projects. Ten. Will there be more, Valérie? We will see. But you have done something exceptional: accepting the idea that there were projects of excellence that should take precedence over others. This is not an easy matter in France; we start to hear you say more, more money. And for everyone, even those who had no idea for use. Here, we have made ten projects, and these ten projects have been selected based on indisputable criteria. And these are 750 million euros of additional investments, dear Patrick Devedjian, that are being allocated under the 2009 recovery plan — that is, in addition to the Campus Plan, we are putting in 750 million more to develop university and scientific facilities that had previously not been able to be funded due to budget constraints. In the recovery, we took part of the envelope managed by Patrick Devedjian and put it into higher education and research.

The great competence and commitment of university staff will be rewarded. 250 million euros are planned for the revaluation of their careers for the next three budgetary exercises, in addition to the approximately 800 million euros they will benefit from under the general revaluation measures of the public service. Doctoral studies will finally be taken into account as professional experience, which will also allow for a significant revaluation of all early careers for young doctors. Obviously, if we take them into account, it revalues the careers of young doctors. I have been hearing about this revaluation since I started in politics. And it was a demand from all the unions.

We are completely reviewing the statutory decree that organizes the services and promotions of teacher-researchers. I know this causes concern. It is about giving autonomous universities the means to best organize their training policy and their scientific policy. If they are autonomous, this must be reflected in the autonomy of their scientific policy and their training policy; otherwise, why would they be autonomous? It is also about allowing the best talents, in research, teaching, and the multiple essential tasks in a modern university, to finally be recognized and rewarded. The condition we set is to evaluate these activities and to evaluate them regularly for each teacher-researcher. Frankly, research without evaluation poses a problem. Moreover, any activity without evaluation poses a problem. It is the National Council of Universities, an independent body from the universities, that will conduct this evaluation. Listen, it is disheartening, but this will be the first time such an evaluation will be conducted in our universities, the first. In 2009. Frankly, we are a great modern country; this is the first time. It goes without saying that I fully support Valérie Pécresse's actions. In their vast majority, teacher-researchers bring their skills with admirable dedication to our universities. They have nothing to fear from this reform. It is designed to encourage them, not to discourage them. I see evaluation as the reward for performance. If there is no evaluation, there is no performance.

As for research and development expenditures, they began to rise to 2.16% of GDP in 2008 after having fallen to 2.12% in 2007. We injected 800 million into research in 2008, and we will continue to inject resources. Together with the Prime Minister, we only set one condition: that the reforms continue. There will be no additional resources without reforms. This is a sine qua non condition. Powerful instruments like the Research Tax Credit have been developed; today you have, Ladies and Gentlemen Business Leaders, and you have indeed made decisions — I think of Thales in particular — the most attractive tax system in favor of research in the world, in the world.

So I believe we have engaged in the battle for intelligence! And well engaged! We will carry it through to the end, but really, the additional resources will come if the reforms prosper and if evaluation develops. Otherwise, we stop.

I see nowhere that a system of weak universities, managed by a nitpicking central administration, is an effective weapon in the battle for intelligence. It is, on the contrary, an infantilizing system, paralyzing for creativity and innovation. That is why we have given autonomy to universities. Moreover, we have not invented anything very original. Autonomy is the rule for all countries where universities are developing. There is not a single example worldwide of great universities that are not autonomous. Well, we had to wait until January 1 of this year, 2009, to have autonomy. And I hope we will go faster and further in autonomy. I believe in particular that universities should benefit from full ownership of their assets, as this can be a very powerful lever for exercising this autonomy.

Nowhere in the major countries, except for us, do we observe that research organizations are both operators and funding agencies, both actors and evaluators of their own actions. I see that this can be comfortable. I could draw some conclusions for myself. It is quite a brilliant system, by the way; the one who acts is also the one who evaluates. Who can think that this is reasonable? This can create a certain comfort, an illusory comfort for the moment because we can clearly see the limits of the exercise. Nowhere like in France have we multiplied institutes, agencies, groups, and other microscopic organizations that dilute resources, responsibilities, pull in different directions, and waste time and money.

Does our "French-style" organization yield better results? Is it enough to say that it is a "French-style" organization to consider that we have closed the problem, closed the file, explored all avenues? I remind you that it is based on foundations defined in the aftermath of the Second World War, supplemented at the end of the 1960s, whose archaic features and rigidities were carefully frozen in the early 1980s. We thought in 1945, we thought a little more in the 1960s, and we announced that we stopped thinking in the 1980s. We are in 2009. Is that reasonable? Certainly, our best researchers receive prestigious awards: a Nobel Prize and a Turing Award last year, two Nobel Prizes this year. We have areas of excellence recognized and envied worldwide, mathematics, physics, and engineering sciences. But these admirable researchers and these strengths — I dare say — are they not the tree that hides the forest? Do they not sometimes serve as an alibi for conservatives of all stripes, found in significant numbers on the right and in countless numbers on the left? I say countless on the left because they are more numerous.

We remain far behind Germany and Great Britain in terms of the share of French scientific publications in the world — I am not, of course, talking about the United States, Japan, and now China, which is taking off.

Is research solely a question of resources and positions? How then to explain that with a research expenditure higher than that of Great Britain, higher and about 15% more tenured researchers than our English friends, France is far behind in terms of the share of scientific production in the world? You will have to explain that to me! More tenured researchers, fewer publications, and pardon me, I do not want to be unpleasant, at comparable budgets, a French researcher publishes 30 to 50% less than a British researcher in certain sectors. Obviously, if we do not want to see that, thank you for coming; there is light, it is heated... We can continue, we can write. It is a reality, and if the reality is unpleasant, it is not unpleasant because I say it; it is unpleasant because it is the reality, that is what we must see. Stop considering as sacrilege the one who states something and see if it is the reality. It is the reality that must be contested in this case.

The valorization and transfer of technology from research to businesses in France yield — I want to say it — mediocre results, mediocre, and this deprives us of hundreds of thousands of jobs that great North American campuses like the University of California at Berkeley, or even European campuses like the Dutch, British, and German campuses, are capable of creating, generating many jobs, a lot of added value, and a lot of wealth creation.

It is in France that the share of private funding in research is, by far, the lowest of all comparable countries, and believe it or not, this is worsening because in recent years it has tended to decrease. We have pushed tax incentives to the maximum with the research tax credit at 30%. This was necessary, but we need to go further to stimulate quality private research. We must undoubtedly direct the instruments at our disposal more towards the creation and development of innovative SMEs. French private research still needs to develop massively.

We do not have in France this culture that makes research a source of wealth creation and growth for an American or German business leader. For us, too often research is considered by French companies as a sort of luxury that is sometimes superfluous, and for large French companies that do a lot of R&D, research is conducted too in a closed environment, internally, as if ideas coming from outside were suspect and that it would be dangerous to engage with them. We must change this. Large and small companies must tap into the tremendous pool of public research, by entrusting it with contracts, forming partnerships, and hiring its researchers. We have put everything in place for this, and I expect this reflection on the national research and innovation strategy to mobilize companies to change their habits.

Moreover, it is absurd to oppose applied research and fundamental research. It is only in France that one can make people believe that private research and public research are opposed, whereas it is in the countries where private funding for research is the highest that the number of Nobel Prizes is the greatest and fundamental research is the most fruitful. We need to create this virtuous circle of private research and public research that complement each other. The combination will form an extraordinary engine for growth and employment if we can stop making ideology, stop engaging in partisan political battles, and if we can accept a pragmatic definition of what is best for research, higher education, and universities in our country.

Can we be satisfied with the "French-style" organization of the research and innovation system? Is there not an urgent need to put an end to a disastrous organization that multiplies structures and wastes resources?

Have there not been enough reports describing the situation? Do we need to wait any longer? Wait for what? For the situation to deteriorate? For us to fall further behind? For the crisis to pass? So that we can wait for the next one?

That is why we are gradually placing autonomous universities at the center of the research and innovation system and that research organizations must transform into funding agencies.

That is why we will simplify the organization of the CNRS by creating internal Institutes that will be funding agencies.

That is why we will restructure, integrate, and simplify the organization of research in the life sciences and health.

That is why we will simplify the rules of industrial property and that we will develop unique structures on each university campus allowing all actors in research and innovation, universities, grandes écoles, research organizations, and companies, to sit around the same table.

That is why the Caisse des Dépôts will launch a fund for the valorization of intellectual property arising from public laboratories.

This is not about copying foreign models. It is about creating the conditions that will allow our best researchers and the most dynamic entrepreneurs to achieve more scientific results, invent new products, and create new innovations.

Here is the objective we must achieve: strong universities, partners of modernized organizations playing the role of funding agencies. Universities open to industrial partnerships.

Ladies and gentlemen, I am pleased to see today gathered actors from public research, business leaders, and heads of private research centers.

The resources committed will mean nothing if we do not equip ourselves with clear strategic orientations for research and innovation. I called for this during a speech given to celebrate the Nobel Prize awarded to Albert Fert, a symbol of the very marriage of the highest level of fundamental research and the most effective innovation.

Our atomized system leads to a lack of national strategy for research and innovation. It is to contribute to this definition that Valérie Pécresse has brought you together in 9 working groups. I want to acknowledge the steering committee of this crucial project that Danièle Hervieu-Léger has agreed to chair. I thank of course all those who participate.

This public debate is essential, and we wanted association leaders to participate in the work and for everyone to disseminate information as much as possible because this concerns all of society.

The results of your work and this debate will be presented to the Government, Mr. Prime Minister, in the spring. The final decisions will then be made, and for the first time in the history of our country, and like all our major competitors, we will have a national strategy for research and innovation for the next four years. We will display our major national priorities. We will organize the action of the State and its scientific policy. The State must have a scientific policy just as it has an economic, social, fiscal, and penal policy. It must have a scientific policy.

This national strategy for research and innovation will be the keystone of the transformation of our system. Contrary to our bad habits, we invite you to a complete and coherent major change that will serve this national strategy which will concern both public and private research actors.

Sometimes I hear people say, "we need to take a break from reforms." I want to say: already tired? Come on, honestly, two years of reforms should be bearable! Others say, "it's going too fast." But what is going too fast? The changing world? But who can think that France and its 65 million inhabitants can go slower than the movement of the world? If France wants to have an impact on the organization of the 21st-century world, it must move at the speed of this world.

The risk is not in movement as long as the reforms are coherent and articulated around a strategy. The risk is in immobility.

Any slowdown in the pace of reforms will result in a delay that we will pay dearly for. Moreover, it is amusing, those who tell me "it's going too fast, we need to stop" do not contest that there are problems. We sweep a little dust under the rug and leave it for others. This means that we can be sure that others, those who will succeed us, will have even more difficulties in addressing these issues.

It is time to act. Any hesitation would be a fault that we would rightly be reproached for later. The definition of the national strategy for research and innovation will therefore go hand in hand with the continuation of the reforms of our higher education and research system. The development of the roadmap, the course, and the destination does not oppose, quite the contrary, the improvement of the performance of the engine. I believe that it is even linked. The Prime Minister and the Minister of Higher Education and Research will ensure this.

Immobilism, even regression, is forbidden to us. We know perfectly well that you are representatives of an exciting and therefore passionate field. I know perfectly well that what we have just decided will provoke reactions. But that does not surprise me. It is because it is difficult that it has not been done until now. Because if it had been easy, it would have been done. So there is no need to tell me that there will be difficulties; I know that. But the difficulties we will face in movement are much easier to overcome than those we would have faced in immobility. Indecision is the absence of a vision for the future.

There will therefore be a continuation of the reform movement in research in France.

I add that it would be somewhat singular to say: "there is a malaise in research." Publication of results, the flight of our best researchers, brain drain, questions raised by researchers, malaise in various organizations. Not enough results, not enough quality of life at work, not enough attractiveness, and we draw the conclusion that we are doing nothing. That we are watching. That we are commenting on the malaise. That we are describing the malaise. That we are reflecting on the malaise. That we are thinking about the malaise. We are maintaining the malaise.

We will respond to it! Through action, through decision. We do not claim to hold the truth; that is why we surround ourselves with as much advice as possible. I guarantee you that we have the will to move forward.

For this, the Prime Minister and I have made an exception to what is done in other areas. We have started to put money on the table and make it available to organizations before the reform. Because we are fully aware of all the promises that have been made and generally not kept. Thus, we are keeping promises that we have not made. This is quite rare. And no one can say that we are making this reform to save money since we are putting in more money. But I guarantee you that the will is there for things to change, for us to produce new results, for researchers to be happier, more effective, and for France to debate its scientific research policy every year. It is still a duty for society! How long has it been since we had a debate on what France's scientific policy was? It is still a subject! We cannot invest in all areas. It is still something we owe to democracy, this debate.

Moreover, there was no debate on immigration policy. And by the way, a few years ago, there was no debate on criminal policy. In fact, if we had continued like that, there would have been no debate on policy at all, since no one was interested and no one believed in it.

The same goes for European policy. We did not have a debate on European policy; we had debates on micro issues that even those who were knowledgeable did not understand. I could give examples.

Really, on higher education, on research, on innovation, 2009 will be the year of action and reform.

I thank you!