Statement by Mr. Nicolas Sarkozy, President of the Republic, on education reforms, in Saint-Lô on January 12, 2009.

France Nicolas Sarkozy · President of France

12 January 2009 · Ceremony of wishes (presentation of wishes) for education reforms · Saint-Lô, France

Context
Sarkozy addressed a New Year's ceremony in Saint-Lô on January 12, 2009, outlining his vision for education reform amid economic crisis.
Main themes
Education reform, social mobility, republican school mission, equality of opportunity, crisis and reform urgency, battle for intelligence, teacher welfare, vocational and classical pathways, status quo critique, social determinism, grandes écoles elitism, knowledge and freedom
Duration
~40 min
91st percentile
Words
4,856
91st percentile
Sentences
301
95th percentile
Readability
69
97th percentile
Grade
7.6
3rd percentile
Syntax
2.73
15th percentile
Vocabulary
1.92
4th percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Social 54%52%
  • Institutional 32%31%
  • Ceremonial 6%6%
  • Economic 6%6%
  • Geopolitical 2%2%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 3%

301 sentences in 58 paragraphs

Ladies and Gentlemen,

It is a great joy for me to be among you for this ceremony of wishes, in a city, Mr. Mayor, whose history symbolizes, against all odds, faith in the future. Saint-Lô, the "capital of ruins" of the Second World War - according to the lovely expression of Samuel BECKETT, who stayed there - Saint-Lô has managed to ward off the fate that seemed to condemn it to disappearance. Saint-Lô has managed to rise again, to rebuild itself, and to find the path to its freedom.

Warding off fate, outsmarting all forms of determinism, is the project of the school of the Republic. Wherever you come from, whoever you are, you must be able to succeed. You must be able to invent your destiny. Provided that you make the effort. Provided that you work. Provided that you never miss an opportunity to learn. Society cannot learn for you. The State cannot work for you. All the solidarity we owe to those of our children who must succeed will not solve this problem; we cannot work in place of someone who seizes the opportunity that society gives them.

Everyone, in our Republic, must have the means to conquer their freedom through knowledge.

This is a question of justice and a question of efficiency. A country of 60 million inhabitants, which recruits its elites from 10% of its population, would be the equivalent of a country of 6 million inhabitants. Therefore, we have a problem of justice, of social promotion in all families, and of immobility.

The task is not new, Ladies and Gentlemen, since Jules FERRY, and beyond partisan divides, all true Republicans have asked themselves the question: what mission for the school, what chance for our children, what status for our teachers? In some respects, as demonstrated by the statistics on the social composition of the grandes écoles, the difficulty of social promotion in our country not only does not diminish but worsens. It was easier a few years ago to ensure the social promotion of one's family than it is now. Is that normal? Is that fair? Can we accept it? I know perfectly well that the key question is that of the battle for intelligence. It is the key question for our country. How do we win it because it is the growth of tomorrow; it is the question of the best sharing of knowledge, and it is the question of restarting the social elevator.

I intend for us to carry this battle for intelligence through to the end because we must win it; we have no other choice. We must innovate more, seek more, train our young people better, and provide equal opportunities for all pathways, both vocational and classical.

So some would like, with the crisis coming, for us to take a "pause." Or even, as is classic in France, for us to roll back certain measures - barely implemented. I admit I do not follow the reasoning. Is it not precisely in times of crisis that the necessity to prepare for the future becomes most evident? Is it not precisely now that the need is felt and that reform in terms of education is most urgent? All day long, I am told: Mr. President, there is a malaise, and those who tell me there is a malaise also tell me to touch nothing. If everyone were happy, if the results were brilliant, if everything were going well in the best of worlds, I would understand defending the status quo and immobility, but even as there is malaise on all sides—among teachers, among students, among parents—does the solution consist of saying that in the face of this triple malaise, we do nothing, we do not move, we do not discuss anything, the only thing we could possibly discuss is giving more money? But if the solution of more money were the right one, then why have all the previous Education Ministers failed, when all the previous Education Ministers have given more money and more positions? I present things, you know, without any bias, without any ideology. What I wish for is a better chance for our children and teachers who are happy because they are at the heart of society.

But if it were enough, to respond to the malaise, to do nothing or to give more money, that is what they have all done, both left and right, Mr. CHIRAC with Mr. DEVAQUET, Mr. JOSPIN with Mr. ALLEGRE, Mr. PERIGROUX had nothing at all, of course, since from his point of view, one cannot say that he announced or put forth any reform project. It is certainly easier. And even Mr. FILLON, when he was Minister of National Education, faced problems. What do we do? We do not move. But if we do not move, the same causes will produce the same problems. If it were enough to hold demonstrations to solve the problems of education. But there have been demonstrations for 40 years, and for 40 years the crisis has worsened. Is that the solution? Do we believe that I am a man who does not take into account what has happened? I do not say that it is a matter of left or right. I say, let us look at what has happened. It is not by renouncing to act that we reassure. And it is not by renouncing to act that we solve problems. The price of immobility, I will tell you who pays it, it is the most vulnerable. Because in immobility, those of our compatriots who are socially the most favored always manage to get by.

It is the most vulnerable who pay for immobility.

To renounce to deeply reform our educational system, which has shown its shortcomings for so many years, would be to resign ourselves to the unacceptable. It would be to accommodate the difficulties of a school that struggles to lead all children to success.

I am therefore more determined than ever to continue the action we have initiated. I will explain myself.

We do not have the right to retreat. All governments have retreated. As a result, they have left the school facing its problems, the children facing the uncertainty of the future, and the teachers facing the satisfaction of a profession that is becoming increasingly difficult. All have retreated. Well, that is a right I do not grant myself. Of course, we must listen, we must explain. We must listen when one is willing to come to dialogue. Because if the way we conceive dialogue is to refuse to come, it is complicated.

I have been very attentive to the concerns that have been expressed, sometimes with a certain force, in recent months. They are quite understandable: perhaps never before have so many efforts been asked of all the staff of the National Education in such a short time.

These efforts have a meaning. They pursue a single objective: that of the emancipation of every child in France through the transmission of knowledge, for real equality of opportunity.

The National Education has previously met the challenge of quantity. Throughout the twentieth century, it welcomed more and more students, for longer periods. In 1930, high school graduates represented 2.5% of an age group. They are now 60%. The figures, it seems to me, are indisputable.

But we have 15% of children who leave primary school who do not sufficiently master the language skills to access other learning usefully. Upon leaving middle school, the orientation towards general secondary education is massive, but 15% of students, at the end of their second year, are invited to repeat. 150,000 young people leave the school system without any diploma and without any qualification. Now, everyone agrees on this. And our baccalaureate, sometimes presented as a sort of talisman, does not immunize our young people since one in two high school graduates loses at least one year in the first cycle of university, many drop out, and barely one in three completes their higher education without having repeated a year. That is the situation. I do not blame anyone. I do not reproach anyone. I say, that is the situation. In the face of this situation, Ladies and Gentlemen, the head of state must consider: move along, there is nothing to see, we think nothing, we say nothing, we modify nothing, we do nothing.

This difficulty in ensuring the effectiveness of our educational system is compounded by social injustices, which I say are unbearable.

Children from the most socially favored half of the population are twice as likely to graduate from higher education as those from working-class and employee backgrounds. Can we accept this injustice? My answer is clearly no. Because I do not want a two-speed France, a France almost split in two. That is to say, on one side of the social line where you are, you have opportunities that are not the same. It is the opposite of the Republic.

This situation is unacceptable. So, Ladies and Gentlemen, our society is going through a crisis, but it is not always the one that is said; it is rather the crisis of the future. With more and more families and more and more young people who are afraid of the future, our country has, undoubtedly, no more urgent mission than to get out of this deadlock, which takes on an even more dramatic dimension in the current economic crisis.

Let me be clear. It is up to our children to imagine and build their lives. It is not a matter of substituting a freedom that one might find too frightening with the comfort of absolute security, which everyone can see does not exist.

So, what are we going to do? We are going to make the school the place where, according to one's work and merit, destinies can be decided. With Xavier DARCOS, with Valérie PECRESSE, we will try to organize all our action around two principles:

1) Restore the authority of knowledge. The school has no other mission than to transmit knowledge, the highest possible. There is no question of lowering the level of expectation, because by lowering the level of expectation, we increase inequalities. There is something, moreover, scandalous about saying we will lower the level so that children from the most disadvantaged categories can access it. That would be to resign ourselves to a situation of total inequality.

2) We will also affirm, second principle, the same expectation for all. We want a system that strives for excellence. This expectation must be the same for all, but the unity of our school system does not imply uniformity of pedagogical approach. This is the extraordinarily difficult question; the school must be able to adapt to the different audiences it serves. Since an entire age group is meant to go through school, the diversity of children and the audiences you, the teachers, have to deal with must imply, while maintaining equality, the possibility of adapting to this diversity of audiences. When there are 2.5% of an age group in school, the diversity of audiences is less than when there are 60% of an age group.

The reform of primary school, which Xavier DARCOS has remarkably conducted, is a reform that I fully support, particularly in the matter of academic support. Everyone agrees that there are children who need to be more closely supervised than others because they have more difficulties, often correlated with the social difficulties of the family. What have we decided to do? To allow the teacher of a class to free up 2 hours of their time to provide support to the children who need it. This is certainly a different ambition than that of putting 3,000 teachers to constantly tour schools to support those who have been reported to them as children in difficulty.

But we are trying to be pragmatic; either this new formula works, and we develop it, or it does not work, and we change it. What is needed is to achieve results. I also believe a lot in the establishment of new assessment evaluations; I believe that the word evaluation must penetrate the National Education, and we should not be afraid of it.

I would like to point out that the number of children who have been helped thanks to the primary reform system is infinitely greater than what we had before. This also goes along with supervised, structured studies; we have invested money, and we are asking to go further in this area. It is not for me to take stock of everything that has been initiated and everything that remains to be done. Time is short. What I want to tell you is that after having addressed primary education and university, we will work on high school. Everyone is well aware that a reform is needed for high school. There is no reason to continue trying to present things with a noble pathway, the scientific pathway, and other pathways that would not be. If the high school, organized as it was, were a success, it would be known. Everyone tells me that it is not working. Therefore, we will carry out this reform while taking the time for consultation and listening.

We have therefore decided with the minister to ask Richard DESCOING to lead the consultation under the authority of the minister, with all stakeholders so that we are ready for the school year in September 2010.

I have only two certainties: the reform is necessary, and the timeline is for September 2010. No taboos except, I announce, that we will carry out this reform without taking away a single cent and without eliminating a position at the high school level. Richard DESCOING has the full confidence of the Minister of National Education and mine, to broaden the scope because everyone is concerned about high school, not just the children, not just the teachers; families and a number of people who have thought about it must be involved. I add, and this is a matter we discussed, Xavier DARCOS and I, with the representatives of high school students whom I had great pleasure in meeting, who seemed very reasonable to me, that we must engage in the best possible consultation with high school students, without demagoguery, but we must find a way to involve them.

We will work on this so that in each high school, they can give their opinions, participate because I am convinced that they too understand that this reform is necessary. And that we cannot afford to waste time. I will also have the opportunity to have lunch with the Minister and the representatives of high school students from this department since I would have liked to discuss with them at greater length and I was unable to do so. Moreover, I wish for this to include both general high school students and vocational baccalaureate students. It is very interesting for me to arrive and see that the representatives of high school students have requested to meet with me to discuss. But this is positive; it means that they are attached to their institution, that they are concerned about their future, that they want to discuss. We had a very interesting discussion; I regret that some unions I had invited did not want to engage in dialogue. That's how it is. We will have other opportunities to discuss, but how can we agree if we do not talk? There you go, and I do not want the school to become the battleground for political score-settling. In this matter, both the left and the right should show a lot of humility regarding the national education reform project because I see many who speak and very few who could give lessons considering what the reality was at that time.

I also tell the teachers, you have a fascinating job, crucial for the future of our society; we must naturally take into account your anxieties, your situations, your difficulties, and I am not against that. But you must also accept the idea that improvements are possible, including professional ones for you, as the reforms are implemented. Additional resources, yes: but with the reform, not additional resources before any reform because that is what has been done in the past, resulting in additional taxes and no reform. So here is what we will conduct, how we will do it. I must say that it is perfectly logical with what we have done in higher education, long the poor relative, with a university budget that will increase by one billion each year throughout the five-year term. I am always told about resources; last year, high school lost 57,000 students, in the economic situation we are in with the need to increase France's competitiveness. Can I afford to maintain the same level of charges on jobs in France when high school has 57,000 fewer children? Saying this is trying to appeal to the common sense of French society.

From all sides, there are demands for more money, but as soon as there is a levy, the same people who ask for money tell me, "Oh no, not us, not that." So we try to do our best to adjust resources and needs. So regarding this high school reform, it will happen. It will happen according to the timeline I indicated, and we will work closely with the Minister, Xavier DARCOS, to whom I want to reiterate my confidence, and Richard DESCOING, to imagine the best method to involve all high school students in France in this reflection on the future and to broaden the consultation; that will be Richard DESCOING's work with other stakeholders. I imagine that this issue is not simply that of high school. It is the more general problem of youth. The anxiety of youth is very difficult. What is a youth policy in the 21st century? How can we reflect on it? Our project is to work around one idea: the primary demand of young people is for a right to autonomy. The entire youth policy of the Government must be conducted around this idea of strengthening the autonomy of young people. Why? Because someone to whom we give the means of autonomy is a young person who becomes free to make choices, but he also becomes responsible.

It is not a question of thinking that autonomy is solely freedom; freedom without responsibility does not exist.

We must therefore try to respond to this demand for autonomy from our young people, to give them the means to choose. But to choose is to be free. To be free is to be responsible. That is how I would like us to build a youth policy. There would be many other things to say, but see on the guiding idea... With Prime Minister François FILLON, we have asked Martin HIRSCH to become High Commissioner for Youth and to carry out, in agreement with his colleagues Xavier DARCOS, Valérie PECRESSE, and those in charge of so many areas concerning youth, a youth policy.

Martin HIRSCH has my full confidence; he established the RSA, and he will oversee the implementation of the RSA. Martin HIRSCH is a man who has committed his whole life; he is the former president of Emmaüs, succeeding in this role to Abbé Pierre. I see a lot of interest in having a man who has made his life a life of commitment be the one who, within the government, under Mr. FILLON's authority, carries this idea of commitment to young people; that is what is important.

You see, this is what we are trying to do. Discontent, protests, demonstrations, that is democracy. The French, unfortunately, are well accustomed to seeing this spectacle. As soon as someone moves in national education. I do not take it lightly because my duty as President of the Republic is to listen to all sensitivities and the expression of all fears. I must not see behind every expression a partisan will; there are real concerns, and I must take them into account.

This is indeed what I did when we decided with Mr. DARCOS that we would postpone the principle of the reform by one year. We did it why? Because I felt with the minister the need for expression from French society. Look how difficult this is. We do not say: "Oh my God, how right he is to take the time for dialogue," and the same people who say: "Oh, he is going too fast," were saying: "He is retreating too soon." We had to find a balance between all this! Notice, you tell me, the President of the Republic, it's up to you to deal with this. Fine. But these are your children. These are your high schools, these are your schools, this is your work.

You understand well, with Minister Xavier DARCOS, we will carry out the urgent necessity of high school reform, taking the time, involving everyone. I will personally commit to this alongside the minister if he is willing. Because there is something like a part of the future of France at stake here. I will do with high schools as I like to do so often, go to the contact, meet, discuss, listen. Together we will build a project. There is no reason we cannot build a project in which a majority of good faith and common sense, especially the young people, can recognize themselves. We will carry out this reform with the young people. I ask Xavier to lead this with Richard DESCOINGS, and then I will strongly commit to convincing so that we find the right solutions, and then carry this broader youth policy, dear Martin HIRSCH, because I understand well that there is an anxiety, and we must respond to this anxiety.

Ladies and gentlemen, to conclude by thanking you for being here, thanking the parliamentarians who are present, and you for having made the effort to come.

There have been easier times to lead a country than the crisis we are experiencing today. This is true for all Heads of State and all Heads of Government.

I would like to end by saying two things. In this crisis, the captain must hold the helm firmly. Because a boat in a storm whose helm is not held firmly, nothing good can come of it.

I must dialogue, I must listen, I must consult, and I must also decide. With the Prime Minister, with the ministers, with the parliamentarians, with the intermediary bodies as they say, with the unions, but also be decisive. In a crisis, one must be capable of making decisions at the right time. If all the other countries make decisions and we do not, then it will not go well for you, it will not go well for the country. In all democracies, there are always people, which is perfectly normal, who are against, and they have their reasons. Others who are for. We must be careful that by trying to balance everything, it does not lead to immobility.

The second thing. I have the ambition for our country that we emerge stronger, we France, from this crisis than we entered it. Because in the face of this crisis, one can say: "Oh my God, we wait for it to pass, but we change nothing." Or on the contrary, one says: "Come on, we have no choice; we must reform, we must reform the hospital, we must reform high school, we must reform justice." Everyone was talking when all these issues arose about the necessity to change. They all agreed. It is enough for me to say: "Come on, we will reform."

Oh dear. We only hear those who do not want things to change. But the same people, three weeks before, were all in agreement that things should change. Provided that they do not change.

So from this crisis, we will try to make, with you, a tremendous opportunity for change. And the French, the French, we must trust them. They have this capacity for change. If I take two examples: the ban on smoking in public places: oh, what did we hear when we did it! No one agreed. Even some of my elected friends said: oh dear, slow down, slow down! They have had enough. Today, would you take a plane with a neighbor who smokes next to you? Today, would you go to establishments, to public places where people smoke? Not at all. You imposed, my dear compatriots, the reform. You imposed it on intermediary bodies that feared it.

Look at something else: advertising on television. What did I hear? My God. One would have thought for a year that everyone was against it! I now see the famous polls: everyone is for it. I tell you one thing: the political leader who will demand that advertising return to public service has not yet arrived. Because the French are pragmatic people. They like to judge based on results. They have heard too many speeches, too many promises. They now want results and to see what it yields.

Do not be afraid of change. Do not be afraid of the crisis. Do not be afraid for the future of your children. From the moment we are all determined to move towards change, to commit, we will emerge stronger. If we refuse, if we are afraid, if we remain stuck in the patterns of yesterday, ladies and gentlemen, then we will lose the battle of intelligence.

I want to win this battle of intelligence.

I want to say in closing to all the teachers that I have great respect for their work. I imagine that for them it is very difficult. Between families that have too many demands and those that do not have enough. I imagine that for you it must not be simple. With children and classes so heterogeneous in level, in origins. I imagine that sometimes you must ask yourself: did I make the right choice in this profession?

With the questions you may ask yourself about your place in the social hierarchy, in the organization of society, even as you have seen so many things that have scandalized you, about banks, about finance, about speculation. I understand this questioning that may take hold of you. But the country needs you. I know perfectly well that we sometimes ask too much of the school. To be the answer to divorce, to the economic crisis, to unemployment, to family work - no, that is me! I see a lady who has problems... that is me! I see that clearly.

But do not lose confidence in your profession. The French love you. Everyone knows that your job is very difficult. Everyone knows it. I can tell you as President of the Republic that I will multiply opportunities to meet with you because I know perfectly well that within you there is this questioning that haunts you. We are willing to make efforts, but will society take them into account? Will we be valued for these efforts we make, we the teachers? I know perfectly well that the vast majority of teachers are perfectly sincere and think only of one thing: the interest of their children.

You will not be the forgotten ones of this beginning of the 21st century.

I have many problems, many difficulties to face. I know that my role is also to be by your side. Beyond even the sole trade unions that represent you. Next to the teachers at the grassroots level.

Believe me, it was truly a duty for me to come here. To speak to you. I was well aware that some might take this as an opportunity. To express a bit of joy.

But what can you do, I am not a president of the Republic who will remain locked away in the Palais de l'Elysée. I want to come to the field. Because it is my duty. I love it. I love meeting and dialoguing. I know, it’s not very conventional and then we expose ourselves. When you come, it is so much easier to stay at the Elysée and always have the same people come. Who have seen so many before me and who will see so many after. I want to see the people. I want to come to the territory. In our provinces, to meet those who make the daily life of the country. To talk to you about the future and to tell you what we are trying to do. With, of course, the mistakes that we can all make. But also the confidence that I have in the future. There is no other choice.

Ladies and gentlemen, from the bottom of my heart, I hope you understand this, I wish each and every one of you a 2009 that will be as exciting for you as it will be for me.

I do not wish it to be as difficult, but I wish you to have much happiness in your professional lives and, if you allow me, also in your personal lives.

Thank you.