Statement by Mr. Nicolas Sarkozy, President of the Republic, notably on the economic and financial crisis, the economic recovery plan, the constitutional revision, and the reform of local authorities, in Paris on January 7, 2009.

France Nicolas Sarkozy · President of France

7 January 2009 · Paris, France

Context
Sarkozy addressed French parliamentarians and Parisian elected officials at the Élysée Palace on January 7, 2009, delivering New Year wishes and outlining France's response to the global financial crisis.
Main themes
Global financial and economic crisis, economic recovery plan, French banking system stabilization, interbank credit guarantee, constitutional revision, reform of local authorities, political solidarity and sincerity, securitization and systemic risk, savings protection, Dexia rescue
Duration
~51 min
94th percentile
Words
6,084
94th percentile
Sentences
341
96th percentile
Readability
59
85th percentile
Grade
9.4
15th percentile
Syntax
2.79
21st percentile
Vocabulary
2.08
24th percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 51%50%
  • Economic 32%32%
  • Geopolitical 8%8%
  • Ceremonial 7%7%
  • Social 1%1%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 2%

341 sentences in 79 paragraphs

Gentlemen Presidents of the Assemblies,

Ladies and Gentlemen Parliamentarians,

Ladies and Gentlemen representatives of the European Parliament,

Mr. Mayor of Paris,

Ladies and Gentlemen City Councilors,

Ladies and Gentlemen Ministers,

Mr. Prime Minister,

I am very happy to present you with these wishes for the new year in a somewhat renewed form. We are always torn between the concern for tradition and the somewhat burdensome nature of that tradition, which imposes obligations on each of us that we always fulfill with much affection, a naturally sincere affection, as is fitting in political life. And above all, that the elected officials of Paris are not hurt to be with the parliamentarians, and that the parliamentarians are not hurt to be with the elected officials of Paris. This is an experiment; if it works, we will continue. If it does not work, we will make a break, as they say. In any case, these are sincere wishes, wishes for each of you. These wishes are all the more sincere because I have some experiences to tell you that our profession is not easy, and therefore, regardless of your political feelings, your affiliations, or your responsibilities, you are here in this Palais de l'Elysée. You have mandates, and to have these mandates, you have scars. You have known successes, you have known failures; I speak from great experience myself—I mean failures. And it is undoubtedly a life, political life, particularly difficult, which does not forgive much, in which one is never disappointed by the strength of one's adversaries and sometimes a little disappointed by the lack of affection from one's friends. I do not speak for myself; I speak for those among you who may have experienced, at one time or another, feeling like a minority in their own political family. This tells you that these wishes, mine towards you, are perfectly selfless and totally sincere.

So, on the occasion of these wishes, none of us can overlook the crisis—an unprecedented crisis—that has struck the world in the second half of 2008. We all remember the sequence of events:

- first, the American real estate market turned upside down, with many American households unable to honor debts that had been granted to them under far too risky conditions, a banking system brutally weakened by the failure of a whole series of debtors.

- then, an extension of failures to other types of debts, and above all the impossibility of knowing where the risks were located due to their dispersion throughout the financial system through the mechanism of securitization, which we understood essentially meant mutualizing risks so that no one ever knew who was responsible for the debts; one only knew who was responsible for the bonuses.

- finally, the major difficulties, even the bankruptcy of actors who seemed unsinkable, causing widespread panic, blocking the entire banking system through the suspension of interbank credit.

That was just a few weeks ago...

In the face of this completely unprecedented situation—I believe that none of us, majority or opposition, could have even imagined witnessing such a spectacle on a global scale—we had to act immediately to:

- avert the risk of total paralysis of the economy by trying to restore interbank credit without which the banking system cannot function. To do this, it was necessary to restore the trust of banks in each other. This is what led us to guarantee interbank credit operations up to 320 billion euros. I take this opportunity to reiterate that these billions were not given or even promised to the banks, but that the State is fulfilling its role when it intervenes to prevent the bankruptcy of the financial system. Let this habit of seeing gifts or debts every time the State commits itself cease! If we had not done this, Ladies and Gentlemen, it would have been total collapse, because it was not the banks that were collapsing, but it would have been the French who would have come to queue at bank counters to claim their savings. No one could have borne such a consequence.

By restoring the functioning of the banking system, we thus guaranteed the deposits of individuals, saving savings. There was no panic among savers in France. That was no small thing. And when we saw what happened in Ireland, in Iceland, and in a number of countries, it could very well have happened in ours.

- then, it was necessary to rebuild the banks' equity so that they could lend while respecting prudential standards, and to save those whose bankruptcy would have led to dramatic chain consequences. This is what we did with Dexia, whose recent stock market performance I have seen with pleasure. Dexia is 15,000 municipalities in France that are in credit with it. Imagine the bankruptcy of Dexia; imagine, all of you who are elected officials, what that would have meant for your communities, the bankruptcy of Dexia. We entered the capital of Dexia where we hold a blocking minority and we changed its management team. Now I am told, but why didn't you enter the capital of the others? Because the role of the State is not to become a banker. We did not enter the capital of the others because, fortunately, the situation of our banks is nothing like that of the United Kingdom. Why is that? Because the United Kingdom and the United States are much more interconnected than France. In the United Kingdom, financial services account for 15% of GDP, in France for less than 3. So that does not present only advantages when things are going well, but when things go badly and finance collapses, it collapses less in a country that is less exposed to finance.

As for the 10.5 billion that have been paid to the banks out of the 40 authorized by Parliament, they are there not to save a bank from bankruptcy, but to prevent the contraction of credit.

On this point, I have heard comments: "privatization of profits, but socialization of losses"—I would like to remind you that these 10.5 billion that we made available to the banks, the banks remunerate them at 9%. I mean that on these 10.5 billion that were lent to the banks to constitute their equity, I want to tell the French that they made a good deal because it avoided bankruptcy, it allowed for the restoration, not enough, of credit, and above all, it is 10.5 billion placed at 9%. I ask, is there a single one of you who, today, has placed your savings at 9%? We did it with the banks; this was indeed a famous debate with the Commission, which thought we should have asked for a higher remuneration; I opposed that because, of course, one cannot say that the price of credit must decrease and at the same time lend at too high rates.

So, this is what we did initially. We will also, I say this under the control of the Minister of Economy and Finance and the Prime Minister, go beyond the first tranche of support for equity that was paid in December. Because I am convinced that our banks need it, just as I am convinced that they need the State to remind them that they must not only focus on repairing their balance sheets but that they must play their role towards their clients. The system is very simple: the more equity banks have, the more they lend. So we will lend money to banks to increase their equity so that they can lend more. We have also created a credit mediation, and we will bring bankers together again to hold them accountable. There is no longer any reason for interbank credit not to work, and there is no reason for us to find ourselves in front of the credit mediator for loans of 2, 3, 4, or 5 thousand euros. The economic system needs banks that take controlled risks. I would not understand that yesterday we did anything and that today we no longer accept this risk.

Throughout these weeks, France has tried to rise to the occasion, to rise to its responsibilities as President of the European Union, and I believe it was important to allow Europe to speak with one voice. This is just the beginning. There was the Washington Summit. On April 2, there will be the London Summit for the G20. It is crucial that what was said in Washington is transformed into decisions in London. France will not accept a summit for nothing. Washington was a first step. London must be conclusive. We need to rebuild the capitalist system, we need to moralize it, we need to put the entrepreneur back at the heart of the functioning of the market economy.

So a word about the stimulus plan.

Finance may seem unreal with the figures it juggles, but it is not everything; behind it are the investments of businesses, the purchases of housing and automobiles by households.

We therefore had to take the necessary measures to counter the indirect effects of this crisis on the economy. I want to say how complicated it is, how much the economic support plan of the summer of 2007 was attacked, deemed at the time perfectly useless. The first crisis began in August 2007. You, the parliamentarians, voted for the activity support plan in July 2007. If this is luck, allow me to say that luck is part of good management. And when we know the implementation delays between the moment a parliamentarian votes and the moment the economy benefits from it, the stimulus plan of 2007, attacked for being too generous at the time, was perfectly useful because this TEPA plan was applied to the French economy at the moment when the global economy was entering into crisis.

Furthermore, we have decided on a number of measures to stimulate the economy. I observe with great pleasure that Germany, which had not always been easy to convince, has today sided with— and that is a good thing because it is the largest economy in the eurozone—countries that want economic stimulus.

The deputies will therefore begin, as of this afternoon, the examination of this budgetary collective. Without interfering in your debate—and I take our representatives in the European Parliament as witnesses—I want to convince you of the ambition of this plan: 26 billion euros! 26 billion euros, for a country like ours that has been in deficit for about thirty years, 1.3% of GDP injected in support of the economy.

This plan also guarantees that the additional expenditures correspond to investment expenditures. I understand the controversy over purchasing power, demand. But finally, Ladies and Gentlemen, if stimulus through consumption worked, we would do it; it would be known. There have been two examples of stimulus through consumption. Certainly, crises are never the same, agreed. One from Mr. CHIRAC, one from Mr. MITTERRAND, so each of us has had this example in our own political family, one each, the ball in the center. What happened? It was of no use. In both cases, we poured water into the sand, we increased France's deficits, we gained no market share with the money we distributed, which we did not have, moreover. You know what we favored? Production abroad, since naturally when we stimulate like this, besides creating deficits, we push our compatriots to buy products from others, very good for solidarity, very good for the image of France, a little less good for the French economy.

What are we trying to do with the Prime Minister and the government? We are trying to take advantage of the crisis, in a way, without shocking anyone, to make it an opportunity to try to catch up on the delays unanimously described in the world, specific to the French economy. What are our delays, whether we are on the left or the right? Not enough investment, not enough research, not enough reforms, not enough work, not enough infrastructure. All the parliamentarians, all the elected officials who are here could testify that, in their region, there is a road missing, a TGV, a campus, an investment. Provided that due to the crisis, the stability pact is, in a way, put on hold to mobilize as much money as possible, to create expenditures that are not recurrent in the coming years, but investment expenditures that are not recurrent, that will provide work for workers, for French workers, that will create growth and jobs, and that, in addition, will allow us, when we come out of the crisis—because we always come out of the crisis—to rely on investments, infrastructure, research, and universities.

This is exactly what we are trying to do. I am told that it is not enough, that we need to do more. Why not? But I call on everyone to keep their cool. Why keep cool? The crisis is severe, but at the same time, we were promised a terrifying return, consumption is holding up, the testimony from the winter sports station union says: it is a historic season, and as for car sales, thanks to the scrappage bonus that has been so criticized, it is the market that is holding up the best in Europe. I add that this allows us to maintain the mid-range cars, that is to say, the cars manufactured in France. I am not saying at all that we have fixed things, I am not saying at all that we are out of it, I am simply saying that we need to be very attentive to the news from the economy to adapt a response based on the evolution of things, and who, today, can tell us what the evolution of things will be?

So, we are proposing this recovery plan of 26 billion with the exemption, moreover, of the professional tax that was decided with the doubling of the FCTVA to engage local authorities in the fight. If we need to do more, we will do more, but for goodness' sake, let everyone keep their cool so that we can be as closely aligned as possible with the reality of the current economic situation.

I take this opportunity to say that, of course, among car manufacturers, a crucial part is at stake for us. Car manufacturers represent 10% of the French workforce, which is 2.1 million workers, employees. We cannot let them fall. But let things be clear, we will help our car manufacturers, but we will no longer accept the relocation of production, not when it comes to winning a market, but when it comes to producing cars elsewhere that we will sell here. It is perfectly normal that we help them with taxpayer money. But if we help them with taxpayer money, it is to maintain an industrial structure. Look at what is happening with countries that have seen their industrial structure disappear.

From that moment on, we saved the banks, we are monitoring them, we are reviving the economy to get through the crisis as painlessly as possible. We are re-founding capitalism because the same causes cannot produce the same effects. And I understand that the French have been scandalized by certain excesses. Who wouldn't be? We cannot say that there will be no consequences, we cannot say that there will be no responsible parties. When it came to finding the beneficiaries of bonuses, the list was known. When it comes to distributing penalties, judging the responsible parties, drawing the consequences, why wouldn't we know those who brought us here?

We need very profound changes. The IMF cannot continue in its same role. The IMF had gradually become the body that examined countries that had nothing to see if they had the right to benefit from the help of others. But the IMF of Bretton Woods was not that; it was the financial and economic body to stabilize the world. We will have to talk about the monetary question. In 1945, in the aftermath of the war, there was only one great power, one great economy, therefore one currency. Who could tell me that in the 21st century, we will build a world with a single currency? We need to discuss the relationships between the dollar, the euro, the yuan, the yen, perhaps tomorrow the rupee.

In any case, if there is a new monetary system to be established, we cannot avoid the international monetary debate. Furthermore, we cannot avoid a new global architecture. Everyone is concerned about everything. You go to the FAO, and they tell you: we do not produce enough agricultural raw materials. It is the same people who are part of the World Trade Organization. They tell you: you produce too much. Who is telling the truth? Shouldn't we specialize international organizations? The UN for borders, peace, politics in the noble sense; the IMF for finance, the economy; another organization for culture; another for the environment. And then, we need to profoundly change our habits. Can we continue to hold the G8? Who here can think that we will solve the world's problems without China, without India, without South Africa, without a single African power, without a single South American power?

France must carry the message of change, of change in Europe and of change in the world. Well, this crisis gives us the opportunity to be heard. No one would understand conservatism. So I see that as soon as we propose something, it is normal, there is no need to be shocked, all those who have no interest in change find virtues in the status quo, but if we do not change in the crisis, when will we change? And who does not see that in France, we need to change? So, this will be the program for 2009.

I know that the number of texts you have to study is very important, I know the number of day and night sessions, ordinary or extraordinary, during which you sit. I sincerely thank you for what you do. Your tenacity for the opposition, your stubbornness for the majority. You all embody national sovereignty.

I know how busy you are. Many of you tell me so, but I especially know the immense expectation of our fellow citizens. Finally, which parliamentarian could complain of having too much work in the current situation of our country, of waiting for texts like sister Anne without seeing anything coming, of saying to themselves: my God, how boring it is? In the end, should there be too many texts or not enough texts? You will tell me, there needs to be a happy medium. Very well, but then either we reform, or we do not reform.

Furthermore, I wanted the reform of Parliament, and this reform is more exciting when one perceives the magnitude of what needs to be accomplished than when we legislate as usual with transposition texts and three people in session.

Parliament plays an essential role. We are at a moment in the history of our country where we need to reform the country, and therefore, we will continue to work and work very hard. I had introduced my remarks in 2008 by hoping that this would mark the beginning of a new era for your assemblies. Well, we achieved this by adopting in Versailles on July 21 last, the most ambitious constitutional revision in 50 years. In essence, we were all in agreement. Even those of you who did not vote for it were the first -- even before its entry into force - to call for the application of its provisions. It could not have been that bad, this reform! It is true, I was the one proposing it, that is a problem, but when it comes to voting on whether we have soldiers in Afghanistan and what they are doing there, is there a single parliamentarian who was against the vote? None, they wanted it, and that is perfectly normal. Just think, a democracy where Parliament does not even have a say when we send soldiers or when it does say something, it is six months later. Who will go back on this reform, who will go back on the possibility of voting resolutions for Parliament, who will go back on the shared agenda?

So history may remember the romantic nature of a victory obtained narrowly thanks to the courage and coherence of a few parliamentarians. We cannot blame them for aligning their vote with their convictions, or else let us replace the parliamentarians of our political parties with voting machines. You are on the right, so you never vote for left measures; you are on the left, so you never vote for right measures. In that case, there is no need for you to show up. There are a number of left-wing parliamentarians, and I thank them, who have been courageous, who came to vote with the others not to please me, not because they do not feel left-wing but because they thought it was not unreasonable to vote for a constitutional reform whose 4/5ths of the measures were included in all left-wing programs. We cannot blame them for being men and women of conviction and courage.

We have - you have - begun to implement the constitutional revision. But important implementing texts remain to be adopted; they will be the subject of your work during the year 2009.

Let things be clear between us. For 50 years, all the presidents of the Republic have criticized the monarchical drift of their predecessors. A must. I remember what was said about François Mitterrand and in "The Permanent Coup d'État," I remember what François Mitterrand said about General de Gaulle. All the constitutional revisions since 1958 have had the sole effect of increasing the prerogatives of the head of state or at least strengthening his institutional role.

Today, I assume the responsibilities entrusted to me by the French people. I did not seek this position from them to then tell them that I am not accountable for the decisions made in their name. They say "the omnipresident." I prefer that they say that rather than "the lazy king," we have known some.... By constantly saying that I do too much, at least we do not ask the question of what I am doing. It has happened in the history of our country. What is he doing up there?

But in my conception of a healthy and exemplary democracy, a strong executive implies a strong legislative, a strong Parliament, and the most sincere demonstration I could make of this was to ask through the Constitution that you be entrusted with the control of half of the agenda. Honestly, it is sometimes difficult for me to understand how parliamentarians would refuse to have control of half of the agenda. Strange.... And by the way, no one will go back on this reform, especially not those who did not vote for it.

There is not a Government that governs on its side and a Parliament that parliaments on its side. There are two intertwined powers, two actors of reform.

It is a great power that has been entrusted to you by this constitutional revision. But great power means great responsibility. It is about being even more exemplary. This implies that Parliament gives itself the means to improve its working methods. After all, I was a parliamentarian for 20 years; who can say that the problem of the working methods of Parliament in France does not arise, who can say it, who can seriously say that?

You will need more time to control the action of the Government, more time to evaluate public policies. It is fascinating in our country; we tear each other apart over an amendment, we tear each other apart over a bill, the amendment is voted, the bill is voted, the tax advantage is recorded, and we do not talk about it anymore. By the way, there is only one example: the budget debate is a passionate and exciting debate, the settlement law takes place in total indifference. I assert that the settlement law is more important than the budget law since on one side, it is a forecast, on the other, it is a realization. Who takes it into account? Who is interested in it, and who even talks about it? This means that the opposition will have more rights; it means that you will need more time to re-evaluate the legislation. I am always amazed to see that we can spend so much time discussing amendments without then caring to know their effects!

I will speak to you sincerely, even if it breaks a taboo. Can the strengthening of the rights of Parliament that we have collectively desired be summarized as spending more and more time in public session examining purely, strictly, literally repetitive amendments?

Is this the conception we have of the rights of Parliament? Right and left, we have all engaged in what is called "flibustering," all of us, and we have all observed the damage that this represented for us in public opinion. Is a political group in Parliament stronger, more listened to, more respected, more useful because it defends thousands of amendments on a text that contains only a few articles? Amendments drafted by machine where we change a comma or a word to clearly state that it is different. For my part, I do not believe so.

I am convinced that we respect a parliamentary group better by discussing with it its most important amendments and seeking to see if an agreement is possible. It may be possible to reach an agreement among us. I am certain that a group is better respected when it submits amendments that can be discussed without a priori, rather than when it submits thousands and, in the end, none are adopted, none. Of course, even the one who submits them does not want them to be adopted since they are not amendments meant to be adopted, they are not even amendments meant to be discussed, they are amendments meant to block. Well, I find that this is not a mature democracy that operates like this.

So can we consensually find time in public sessions to allow for more oversight and more evaluation? Both the majority and the opposition will benefit. By spending more time on these new constitutional prerogatives, including on appointments, while still keeping the necessary time for examining legislative texts?

Ladies and gentlemen, members of Parliament, you will now have a formal opinion to give on the most important appointments of the executive. This is democracy. Which government will one day go back on this, including on the President of France Télévisions? I hear people say: "He is appointed by the President of the Republic."

Was it not the President of the Republic who appointed the President of the CSA before? Was it not the President of the CSA with his small college who appointed the President of France Télévisions? Here, it is quite different; the government will propose a name, the CSA can say no, you can say no to a qualified majority that requires agreement between the majority and the opposition. Who will go back on this right?

This means that the year 2009 is the first year in which both majority and opposition parliamentarians will have to give their views on the appointment of a head of a public enterprise.

I remember, as Minister of Finance, how the appointment of the last CEO, who was excellent by the way, of EDF took place. Not a single parliamentarian was informed; it was a perfectly regal decision. Move along, nothing to see here! It turns out that the choice was very good. No debate, no hearing procedure, no vote. Is this the conception of a mature democracy? Is this what we want for the French Parliament? In 2009, you will have to debate the major appointments of the executive. You will give your opinion and you will be able to block them.

So, I naturally have no advice to give you. I hope that you will take hold, both majority and opposition, without taboos, of the question of organizing your work. Be imaginative, be innovative.

Almost no parliament in the world meets as much as yours. In the main democracies, only the Italians meet more. And even then, the Italian sessions last only a few hours a day, and in terms of hours worked, they work less than you do. How do the others do it? Do they legislate worse?

Our fellow citizens expect you to be imaginative. I am convinced that we can find a good agreement that allows the opposition to have more rights, more influence, and at the same time, does not give this somewhat disheartening spectacle on such important subjects, of seeing amendments submitted in droves simply to force the government to submit a procedural measure so that public opinion can say: look how mean they are. This is not a mature democracy. I have always believed that parliamentarians from the left, the center, or the right are better, should be better regarded, and that this is not the solution.

Finally, 2009 will be the year of the reform of local authorities. I hope that we can find a consensus on this reform that could well say in 2009 that nothing should change? Which of us has not complained about the absurd entanglements of the different territorial levels? I know, I have a bad memory with my attempt in Corsica. There were a number of people who helped me at the time without being from my political family. That does not discourage me.

I do not insult anyone when I say that our territorial system is upside down, that it sometimes resembles, you know, an inverted pyramid. The shelves are collapsing under increasingly frequent, increasingly convergent reports that are increasingly quickly filed away under the pile. The more convergent they are, the more intelligent they are, the more they are filed away under the pile. Without any of them ever being followed by effect. It is disheartening; on the observation, we are all more or less in agreement.

On the unreadability of competencies, we agree. Is there anyone who understands that high schools fall under the regions and colleges under the departments? And that naturally for school complexes, when there are both, there must naturally be an agreement between the department and the region? And still, in this specific case, the sharing of competencies is relatively readable. But there are only a small number of competencies of the local authorities in this situation. The general rule is entanglement, either because the competencies are shared or because they are delegated.

I am not talking, of course, about the general competence clause that the law recognizes for local authorities, which means that everyone intervenes on whatever they want as long as they believe they have a local interest in acting. When everyone meddles in everything, no one is responsible for anything. Is there still anyone who thinks that there is nothing to change?

Cross-financing follows the same logic. Moreover, it must be recognized that they are often the very consequence of the entanglement of competencies. But they reinforce the impression of confusion.

The most serious thing in my eyes is not so much this confusion of competencies as the irresponsibility to which it leads. This is particularly true in terms of local taxation. I do not know if the specialization of local taxes is the solution. But what I do know is that when we do not know who is responsible for the increase in levies, it disempowers all the actors in the chain. The taxpayer does not know what falls under the regional share, what falls under the departmental share, or what falls under the municipal share; the different actors are less vigilant when it comes to constantly raising local taxes. We should not blame anyone. For the past five years, the yield from local taxation has increased by 28%. The regional share by 54% and the departmental share by 36.5%.

These are the reasons why when I am told:

"It’s madness. The reform of local authorities, you can’t be serious. How many have failed at it!"

I want to respond:

"It’s you who are mad. It’s you who do not see that the elected officials can no longer stand this system. It’s you who do not see that the elected officials are the first to want this change. Because they are the ones who suffer the consequences on a daily basis. They are the ones who go through a gauntlet to carry their projects because the interlocutors are multiple."

Today, it is still too early to talk about the content of the reform. I cannot, on one hand, say that consultation is necessary, that consensus is needed, and announce, as it begins, the result. But if the page is still blank, we must write it together. And I guarantee that all questions will be asked, that all avenues will be explored, that no subject will be taboo, and then we will have to decide, somewhere after the European elections, before the summer of 2009.

That is why we created, around Édouard BALLADUR, a pluralistic reflection committee, comprising respected, indisputable personalities from diverse political backgrounds and possessing particular expertise.

Édouard BALLADUR will submit the results of his work before the end of February. Then will begin the time for all elected officials to appropriate this report and its conclusions.

Deputies and senators. Parliamentarians from the majority or the opposition. Regional councils or general councilors. Mayors and Paris councilors. I hope that everyone will take part in this debate and that we will decide, that we will also give the impression that we are a mature democracy. Of course, I know the strength of the department, I know the appeal of the region, but we cannot continue like this. I make a commitment, on behalf of the Prime Minister and the government: we want to change things.

Furthermore, we have too many levels. I believe that Mr. MAUROY is perfectly right: we do not have a true status for agglomerations. The Mayor of Paris knows well that, for me, the Greater Paris matters. For him, too. Perhaps we do not have the same vision. But can we adapt the same rules for a region of 12 million inhabitants with a problem at one point as for another? We will put all this on the table, and we will have to make decisions somewhere around the summer, autumn of 2009.

Ladies and gentlemen, I do not want to naturally abuse this speech. I would also like to conclude by expressing the hope that France, on the international level, continues to serve peace and human rights. To all those who wondered why we decided to go to the Middle East, it is because the images we see are unbearable for everyone, whether you are from the left, the center, or the right. There is no American leadership today, and even if there were an American leadership, I remain convinced that Europe, an independent, imaginative, autonomous Europe has something to say. This is what I wanted to convey to all our interlocutors. The problem of Gaza is not just a regional problem; it is a global problem. Because the confrontations there can lead to a lasting fracture between the West and the East. Could we bear that? Are we so far from that? So, of course, the situation is very difficult, but they need men and women of good will to help them understand and talk to each other, and to initiate a way out of the crisis. France condemned the entry of the Israeli army into Gaza. And France condemned the launching of rockets by Hamas. I sincerely hope that the initiative we took with President MOUBARAK will help find ways to calm. The guns must fall silent. We do not have time. They must fall silent immediately because the situation is catastrophic, and it is France's role to carry a message of peace and unity.

Ladies and gentlemen, thank you for accepting our invitation.

Thank you to the majority parliamentarians for their support.

Thank you to the opposition parliamentarians for their presence.

Thank you to the elected officials of the City of Paris, and thank you all for having, in essence, this common point of being passionate about France, its future, and its destiny.

Happy New Year.