Statement by Mr. Nicolas Sarkozy, President of the Republic, on efforts in favor of fundamental research in France and Europe, in Paris on July 26, 2010.

France Nicolas Sarkozy · President of France

26 July 2010 · 35th International Conference on High Energy Physics · Paris, France

Context
Sarkozy addressed the 35th International Conference on High Energy Physics in Paris on July 26, 2010, advocating for fundamental research in France and Europe.
Main themes
Fundamental research, high energy physics, particle physics, origins of the universe, science and society, long-term investment in knowledge, cosmology, defense of science against obscurantism, unity of knowledge, European scientific cooperation, technological innovation from basic research
Duration
~25 min
75th percentile
Words
2,954
75th percentile
Sentences
162
83rd percentile
Readability
49
61st percentile
Grade
10.8
30th percentile
Syntax
2.80
22nd percentile
Vocabulary
2.18
44th percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Technological 35%34%
  • Economic 23%22%
  • Ceremonial 13%12%
  • Social 11%10%
  • Geopolitical 9%9%
  • Institutional 8%8%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 4%

162 sentences in 41 paragraphs

Madam Minister,

Ladies and Gentlemen,

I am very pleased to be able to speak before your assembly gathered for the 35th International Conference on High Energy Physics.

You have come to share your work; you represent the elite of your discipline at the global level. And what a discipline it is! I certainly will not embark on a detailed description of your work; I would be quite incapable of doing so, even though I know how much you embody the essence of science, its primary ambition: to push the boundaries of knowledge, to explore and map territories of thought that are still unknown. There is no greater human adventure than the one you experience every day.

You study the mysteries of matter, this arrangement of billions upon billions of particles that makes the universe exist and not only exist, but also be coherent. At the edges of two infinities, the infinitely large and the infinitely small, the cosmos and the atom, your field lies upstream of other sciences.

Certainly, one can only be struck by vertigo when trying to imagine the questions you tackle! There was a time when they fell under metaphysics. That era seems far away, when the discoveries of Giordano Bruno led him to the stake and those of Galileo, - treated better! - to prison. Consider yourselves fortunate to live in your time! Science is a process, I know, fragile, and you must be defended, you scientists, you must be defended against obscurantism, against fanaticism, against the denial of facts and against the contempt for truth. These risks are current; they have existed in all times and eras.

At its core, your work represents humanity's oldest dream: to try to answer the question that humanity has always asked about its origins, the origin of the universe, but also the origin of matter. Fundamentally, why is there something rather than nothing? This existential question, you formulate it in scientific inquiries concerning the structure of the Universe: what is it made of? What are the forces that govern its evolution? But fundamentally, it comes back to the same question: why is there something rather than nothing?

And far from being overwhelmed by the complexity of the world around us, you are stimulated by the magnitude of the task. I recognize myself in this somewhat strange attitude! Ultimately, never to give up in the face of the unknown, to overcome the difficulties that have arisen for centuries, to tirelessly pursue the quest you have set for yourselves: these are the qualities of researchers, and particularly of fundamental research scientists.

To the gloomy minds, - there are a few of them -, who claim that your research is very far from the urgent issues our planet must address, the great diseases, poverty, the imperatives of development, I want to say that the urgencies of the moment must not, must never compromise the demands of the long term. It is a impoverishment to oppose these two realities, the urgency of the moment and the requirement of the long term. Knowledge is a whole: the surprises of the most gratuitous fundamental research have sometimes led to the most fruitful innovations that touch our daily lives. Your activities have advanced the most cutting-edge technologies, through the equipment you use, including the Web, which was invented at the European Organization for Nuclear Research.

Fundamental research does not aim for concrete applications, but a country that would relegate it to a secondary concern would commit a historical error. Science is a structure that must be complete: there are no applications without fundamental research, there is no qualitative leap in the progress of knowledge outside of fundamental research and its discoveries. It is not by pretending to improve the candle that electricity was discovered - this, I am pretty much ready to understand. Pasteur said: "There is not on one side fundamental research and on the other applied research. There is research and its applications, united to each other as the fruit of the tree is united to the branch that bore it." This tree of knowledge you cultivate in multiple ways. But you nourish it, which is still your common point: the love of knowledge.

Science is a whole that must be firmly rooted in society. May I remind you that a great specialist in your field, Steven Chu, was recently appointed U.S. Secretary of Energy (may our compatriot Claude Cohen Tannoudji, who received the Nobel Prize in Physics with him, not see this as any announcement from me!)? This example proves the ability of scientists to seize all fields of knowledge and even action.

From this profound unity of knowledge, you, the physicists, testify, notably through the recent history of your discipline: you have managed to break down barriers by linking cosmology and particle physics. And how many physicists have moved from counting atoms to analyzing the functioning of cells, to nourish the most recent advances in biophysics?

I ask you today to continue this breaking down of knowledge towards the general public. There is no need to be afraid, there is no need to be ashamed to share your discoveries with the greatest number. Our contemporaries are thirsty for knowledge; they are driven by immense curiosity about science. It is up to you, the scientists, to share your knowledge. One does not lower oneself by sharing the infinitely complex in a simple way. One can even consider that intelligence consists of knowing how to explain complex things simply. It is not so simple. At a time when the number of students enrolled in science is experiencing a very concerning decline, it is up to you to keep the love of science and scientific general culture alive in your respective countries.

Ladies and Gentlemen, we are in a time when science is sometimes called into question. It is true that by solving problems -- and that is the fate of the scientist -- you create others. By answering questions, you open up others, even more daunting to solve. But it is humanity's destiny to constantly create and innovate to progress.

So it is up to all of us, political leaders and scientists, to accompany the progress of science so that humanity truly progresses. It is indeed science and scientific research that will help us solve the problems humanity faces. Obscurantism, ignorance, conservatism can only lead to suffering, frustration, and regression.

That is why, together with Valérie Pécresse, we are proud that you have chosen France to hold your 35th conference.

You will allow me to see this as a tribute to the French scientific community that works in your field. Our country cultivates the intelligence of materials: the Nobel Prize of Pierre-Gilles de Gennes. Our physicists are the heirs of a long tradition, from Pierre and Marie Curie to Albert Fert, a recent Nobel laureate, not to mention the inventor of the wire chamber, Georges Charpak, to speak only of atomic physics.

This quality research flourishes in our major research organizations, the CNRS and its institute IN2P3, the CEA and its Institute for Research on the Fundamental Laws of the Universe, the IRFU. We have developed world-renowned laboratories. I will only mention the main teams: the Louis Leprince-Ringuet Laboratory, the École Polytechnique, the Linear Accelerator Laboratory, with the University of Paris-Sud in Orsay, the Nuclear Physics and High Energy Laboratory, with the Pierre and Marie Curie University and René Diderot University. All these teams illustrate the quality of French fundamental research, as also evidenced by the predominant role they play, at the European level, in the work of CERN in Geneva.

This tribute to French science is also for us an encouragement. France has undertaken unprecedented efforts in the field of research. In the face of the crisis, many countries have chosen to cut their research budgets. You should know that we have made the opposite choice! Not only have we not cut, but we have increased funding.

Western economies are going through a difficult period, a crisis like the world has never known since 1929. The temptation is obviously very strong to postpone the investments we need in the scientific field. If you were in our place, you would have the same temptation!

But we, France, have instead bet that higher education and research are the solutions to emerge from the crisis. The crisis should not lead us to postpone these investments in science, but rather to anticipate and consolidate them.

This is not a reckless gamble; it is a position of common sense. We do not have the right to retreat into obsolete certainties. We must relentlessly seek new solutions, constantly create new knowledge that will be the best weapon to fight against the crisis.

For us, it was first necessary to improve the responsiveness and efficiency of our higher education and research structures. And I say this before you: what would additional resources be worth if they were invested in obsolete structures? With Valérie Pécresse, we have given universities the opportunity to be autonomous to take charge of their future and play their full role in the research effort. A few years ago, pronouncing the word autonomy in France would have already brought people out into the streets. We have allowed our research organizations to break away from an organization so complex that it paralyzed their action.

We are reforming and investing like never before in our country.

Since 2007, the year of my election, the budget for higher education has increased by one billion euros more per year. Since 2007, the budget for public research has been increased by 800 million euros per year.

We are renovating our university campuses, with a grant of 5 billion euros that will promote the emergence of a dozen major campuses to the best international standards. Because the meeting of skills, ideas, degrees, and disciplines must take place within a real campus. The virtual campus does not exist. And I was tired of seeing that campuses existed everywhere in the world and that in France we dreamed of the campuses of others. Let’s stop dreaming; let’s make them. Why settle for looking at what others do? It is better to be inspired by them.

Finally, at the heart of the crisis, we have decided on a future investment plan of 35 billion euros for the next four years. Two-thirds of this investment will be dedicated to higher education and research, with one-third specifically allocated to applied research programs in the fields of aeronautics, space, decarbonized energies, or the digital economy.

We want these immense resources to allow the best teams and the best French campuses to emerge so that our country fully participates in global research. Among these teams of excellence that carry our hopes, I particularly want to salute the researchers of the Saclay plateau. Until today, their collective presence was almost considered a happy coincidence, and no one had thought to take advantage of the potential assets that this could represent. Can you imagine? It’s a bit like saying for years: look, we have high-tech companies, we have research centers, great schools, labs, universities, what a coincidence! It’s a bit like we had all the ingredients of Silicon Valley, but it was waiting for its Christopher Columbus! We had discovered, but we did not know it... We want to make Saclay one of the best research campuses in the world, by promoting the synergies and coordination of all the actors who work there: researchers, entrepreneurs, investors.

I know the hopes that this perspective raises in the French high energy physics community. You have developed a project whose quality I salute: bringing together more than 2,000 researchers in subatomic physics around ultra-modern platforms, you will be able to develop the "Physics of the Two Infinities and Space Research" hub around the laboratories of the CEA, the CNRS, the University of Paris Sud, and the École Polytechnique. You will have there, in your field, one of the most powerful research centers in the world, a center capable of supporting ambitious large equipment projects. And naturally, on the Saclay plateau, the proximity to the best specialists in other disciplines, - I am thinking particularly of laser specialists - opens up extremely interesting perspectives.

Finally, I do not forget that revolutions in knowledge sometimes arise in unexpected places, and that we must remain open to all forms of innovation. That is why I want to say to the French scientific community: "be ambitious, propose unprecedented projects, innovate in your proposals, overcome the old divisions of your organizations! Shake things up, shake things up, shake things up again." Since you said, Mr. President, in your opening remarks that democracy was not your concern, let me take care of it. What I mean by that is that with Valérie Pécresse, we do not want to replace one rigid system with another under the pretext that we have mobilized a lot of money. We want life. We want flexibility. We want pragmatism. We want you, the researchers, to be able to work freely in your disciplines. Well, then the question of evaluation, results, competition, in short, excellence will obviously arise. But that is your daily reality. And you do not need me to know that it is your daily reality.

For the Saclay operation, we have already programmed an investment of one billion euros. I have been hearing about Saclay since I entered politics, and I had never seen a single cent allocated to Saclay. We have allocated one billion euros. It is done. Other funding will follow, and I am quite certain that the teams present at Saclay will be able to present projects that are likely to be selected as part of the future investment plan.

But our ambitions are not limited to the scientific capacity of France. The excellence of research must be built within the European scientific space. France has taken initiatives to ensure that Europeans establish a common program in areas such as cancer research and Alzheimer's disease. We are not going to each look for solutions in our own corners. I hope this will be the case for other subjects, I think of high-performance computing or, of course, nanotechnologies.

We want to make Europe the leading scientific power in the world. Europe is currently the continent that trains the most engineers and PhDs. It is Europe that ranks first in the world in terms of scientific publications. In healthy competition with other continents, we must transform these assets into real advantages. Advantages for countries, populations, and economies of European countries. But also advantages for universal progress.

The economic difficulties we are experiencing should not lead us to timidly reduce the budgets we allocate to research and higher education. The Franco-German partnership illustrates this European ambition, and it will continue.

Beyond the European dimension, I call for genuine international cooperation. You are already implementing it. Research equipment has become more sophisticated, more efficient, and therefore more expensive. Your community needs investments in major equipment. We cannot shy away from this call. But we have every interest in working together, regardless of the continent to which we belong.

I will take just one example: the equipment at CERN in Geneva. With the most powerful particle accelerator in the world, which was inaugurated two years ago, the first collisions have yielded important results, which will be announced - from what I understand - during your conference. Alongside the collection of unprecedented data, the development of new technologies is at stake. The CERN particle accelerator has led to many technological advances, in medical imaging, in the treatment of cancerous tumors through hadron therapy. And to process the multitude of data collected in the large colliders, you have initiated a computing power that opens up immense prospects for scientific computing applications.

This simple example is enough to demonstrate the vital necessity of investing in major equipment. But the necessary investments can no longer be made by a single country, nor even by a small group of countries. Broad cooperation among states is necessary.

Rest assured that France will be committed to promoting this international cooperation and to holding its place in it.

Ladies and gentlemen, you have understood that it is with great pride and enthusiasm that I have addressed you today. You represent the hopes of global science, you represent the hopes of the planet regardless of your sensitivities or backgrounds. Ultimately, the future of the planet rests largely in your hands. Many were asking me why I was going to your conference. This shows that I still have a great effort in pedagogy to explain what you do. Is it not important, when one is the head of state of the fifth country in the world, to go and speak before a community of scientists who hold the future of the planet, in the long chain of knowledge and know-how? What is extraordinary is that one is surprised by my presence! What is extraordinary is that one does not systematically think of involving you in the major decisions, the major choices, and the major initiatives for which we, the statesmen, bear responsibility on a daily basis. Your work is not easy, nor is mine, but I believe we need each other. You need us to provide you with the means, the framework, and the protection of the freedom that you need. And we need you so that with your research, we can have innovative solutions to address the major problems of the countries we lead.

Thank you for choosing France, thank you for choosing Paris, and thank you to the French scientists for ensuring that French science is at the highest level of international standards.

Good luck and good work.