Statement by Mr. Nicolas Sarkozy, President of the Republic, on the fight against crime, delinquency, and illegal immigration, in Grenoble on July 30, 2010.

France Nicolas Sarkozy · President of France

30 July 2010 · Statement on the fight against crime, delinquency, and illegal immigration · Grenoble, France

Context
Sarkozy addressed officials and citizens in Grenoble on July 30, 2010, following an unprecedented outbreak of violence involving armed attacks on police officers.
Main themes
Fight against crime and delinquency, illegal immigration policy, law enforcement support, police violence in Grenoble, criminal networks in urban neighborhoods, republican order restoration, judicial response to violence, prefect appointment, state authority, zero tolerance policy
Duration
~33 min
86th percentile
Words
3,980
86th percentile
Sentences
255
93rd percentile
Readability
58
84th percentile
Grade
9.0
11th percentile
Syntax
2.64
9th percentile
Vocabulary
2.14
36th percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Social 47%44%
  • Institutional 42%39%
  • Ceremonial 7%6%
  • Economic 3%3%
  • Geopolitical 1%1%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 7%

255 sentences in 53 paragraphs

Ladies and Gentlemen,

I ask you to excuse my significant delay, which is due to the great appetite for words, something I fully understand, and therefore when we discuss, it is normal that we accumulate a lot of delay.

Madam Minister of Justice,

Mr. Minister,

Ladies and Gentlemen of Parliament,

Mr. Prefect,

Mr. Mayor of Grenoble,

Mr. President of the General Council,

Grenoble has just experienced an unprecedented outbreak of violence, which has deeply shocked our fellow citizens. The acts that have been committed here, I will not beat around the bush, I will qualify them as extremely serious and they deserve unequivocal condemnation. Law enforcement officers have been attacked by assailants who dared to shoot at them with real bullets with the intent to kill. These are attempts at murder; all means will be employed to ensure that the perpetrators are found and punished. And I tell the French people, we will find them all. Police officers from the BAC of Grenoble have been subjected to death threats. This is unacceptable. I want to assure them of our support, my trust, my gratitude, and to tell them that we will have no complacency, no weakness towards the delinquents and criminals who will be rendered incapable of causing harm and whose only place is in prison. An investigation is underway to find those responsible for these threats; all will be found and brought before justice. I cannot naturally say more, but you will see that the results will not be long in coming.

The man who fell under the fire of a police officer had just committed a robbery. Not content with having committed a robbery, he opened fire with an automatic weapon, a weapon of war, against the police officers. They responded in self-defense. As the head of state, I want to say that the police officers did nothing but their duty. The police acted properly, and I call on everyone not to confuse delinquents, victims, and law enforcement. The police acted correctly; there is nothing to reproach them for. They deserve our full support. If one does not want trouble with the police, one does not shoot at the police with a weapon of war in a country that is a state of law like France.

The police and judicial response has been firm: 26 arrests, 11 immediate appearances, 5 individuals incarcerated, and 10 summoned before a judge.

The violence that has struck the city of Grenoble is the work of a small minority, certainly a minority that wanted to mark its allegiance to criminals. It is too easy to say that there is serious crime on one side and petty crime on the other. In this case, petty crime has been instrumentalized by serious crime. We will not allow thugs to settle in the neighborhoods of Grenoble, which have become both their prey and their hideouts. Because these two individuals, once the robbery was committed, deliberately returned to this neighborhood, hoping to benefit from the impunity of the area.

Thus, we have decided to wage a war against traffickers and delinquents. As we did in Seine-Saint-Denis, we have decided to pay particular attention to certain territories that need targeted action to restore the conditions of republican order. Such is the case in this city and this department; there is no intention of stigmatization. All elected officials are concerned; this is not a matter of opposition, majority, left or right; it is a matter of general interest. Who could possibly have an interest in tolerating shooting with automatic weapons against police officers? No one.

With the Minister of the Interior, we have therefore decided to appoint a new prefect, Eric Le Douaron.

Eric Le Douaron has extensive experience; he has held the highest responsibilities in the field of security. This man has my full confidence, and as with Christian Lambert, I ask him to restore the authority of the State, without weakness, wherever it is called into question. Eric Le Douaron: no neighborhood, no street, no stairwell, no apartment block should escape republican order in this department and in this city. It is your duty.

There has been a great debate about whether a police officer can be a prefect. When one is a police officer, one has a sense of the State, and the prefect represents the State. And I do not have to choose with the Minister of the Interior the prefects solely based on their rank from a prestigious school of the Republic but based on their experience, their knowledge, their human capacity, and their desire to work. And I tell the elected officials, who have already had contact with Eric Le Douaron, you will be pleased to have a prefect of this quality. This does not mean that it is appropriate to condemn the actions of his predecessor, who is a man of quality. Simply, in the face of certain situations, it is my duty to find the best person for the best position. Eric Le Douaron, like Christian Lambert, will be that person.

Furthermore, I announce that our desire to dislodge traffickers from their hideouts will lead us to create a departmental GIR in Grenoble and in Isère that can carry out judicial investigations as closely as possible to the needs on the ground. For the past three days, a tax inspector has been stationed in the police services, and we will be looking into the assets of delinquents in Grenoble as well as in Isère in an extremely thorough manner.

So I hear the discourse that is sometimes held, and I bear no grudge against anyone. But I would like you to understand me. If, in the face of events of this gravity, I had not come, I would have rightly been reproached for not having grasped the seriousness of the problem. I come, and I am told: we must not stigmatize. One must know. Of course, there are wonderful things in Grenoble and in Isère; who could contest that? And I have been sufficiently in Crolles, as President Vallini knows well, to say how pleased I am with the imagination of the people of this department and this city, which hosted memorable Olympic Games a few years ago and has so many researchers, students, and quality individuals. But at the same time, I must see reality as it is; what has happened is unacceptable. I tell you, not a single police officer will leave. It is the delinquents who will retreat.

I also add that I have been proposed, I have seen, a "Grenelle of security," "a general assembly on security." Why not? But think about it: if I had come here to tell you: we have been shot at with real bullets by police officers, I am organizing a conference, who would have taken me seriously? This is not a social problem; what has happened is a problem of thugs; these are values that are disappearing. We must put a stop to it. So I know that within the framework of republican debate, there can be exchanges between political forces, which is normal. But who can think that a few additional neighborhood officers will eradicate the thugs, traffickers, and trafficking? We need to come together to show this minority that they have no hope and that we will act. And there can be no naivety or idealism in this matter.

I also wish that beyond our differences, we come together on video surveillance, video protection. We need it. There are not left-wing cameras and right-wing cameras. The fact is that delinquents, big or small, fear above all to be caught on camera because these are judicial evidence. And furthermore, it is the best way to protect the police and gendarmerie from any controversy.

I also wish that we attempt in this department an experiment by equipping a number of police and gendarmerie vehicles at night with body cameras. This is not at all about interfering in the private lives of the residents of Grenoble or the department of Isère. It is about being as effective as possible. 60,000 cameras will be installed by 2012. I will let those who wish to cry out about the infringement of individual freedoms do so. I believe that individual freedom is seriously infringed when thugs instill terror in front of residential buildings.

The anti-gang law adopted by Parliament last March provides for a one-year prison sentence for anyone belonging to a violent gang. Procedures are underway, and I ask your prefect to be particularly attentive, along with Madam Attorney General and Mr. Public Prosecutor, whom I thank for their presence, for the application of this new law.

We will also develop "agglomeration police." This has been the case since last year in the Paris region. Lille, Lyon, and Marseille will soon be concerned for a simple reason, and you know it well: delinquents ignore the administrative borders of our municipalities, our departments, and even our regions.

Since 2002, I have been on the front lines in the fight against insecurity. The number of crimes and offenses has decreased by 17.54%. At the same time, the "clearance rate," which reflects the effectiveness of law enforcement, has increased by one-third. In 2001, police and gendarmerie forces found 25% of the culprits; in 2010, they found 38% of the culprits. I have set a target of 40% for the minister.

Furthermore, I announce that starting September 7, the minimum sentences that work well but do not apply to repeat offenders—24,000 minimum sentences have been pronounced—will now be extended to all forms of aggravated violence, particularly violence against individuals holding public authority.

The establishment of an incompressible prison sentence of 30 years for the murderers of police officers or gendarmes will also be discussed in Parliament at the start of the school year. And here I want things to be clear; as the head of state, my duty is to work with everyone. I do not have to see if Grenoble is a city that has chosen a left-wing mayor or a right-wing mayor. I must work with elected officials, just as elected officials must work with the head of state. But each of us will be faced with our responsibilities. On an incompressible sentence of 30 years, I will ask Parliament to debate it. And I will ask everyone to set aside their partisan affiliations to vote on texts not based on the minister who presents them but on the utility of the text.

The police are watching us, the gendarmes are watching us, the population is watching us. The political posturing on both sides is not up to the situation. It is not a matter of knowing what such and such a party will think; that is its right; it is a matter of knowing what must be done in the face of this situation.

I will also ask you, I say this to the parliamentarians, to debate the scope of electronic bracelets. I particularly wish that magistrates can automatically sentence repeat offenders to wear electronic bracelets for a few years after serving their sentence. I am talking about repeat offenders. I was updating with the Minister of the Interior: imagine that we have 19,000 delinquents in France who have been implicated more than 50 times in our files. Are we going to continue bringing them from court to court?

Likewise, we will reevaluate the grounds for the revocation of French nationality. I take my responsibilities. French nationality should be able to be revoked from any person of foreign origin who has deliberately harmed the life of a police officer or a gendarme or any other person holding public authority. French nationality must be earned, and one must be worthy of it. When one shoots at a law enforcement officer, one is no longer worthy of being French. I also wish that the acquisition of French nationality by a delinquent minor at the time of their majority is no longer automatic.

Ultimately, the main cause of violence, Ladies and Gentlemen, is permissiveness and resignation. I have asked Michèle Alliot-Marie to prepare a profound reform of the criminal law applicable to minors, and I wish for us to examine without taboo all possible avenues. I do not have the truth. But let us agree that the ordinance of 1945 is no longer suitable for today's minors. Or should we consider that this text, which is over 60 years old, cannot be touched, cannot evolve? Here too, this is not a partisan question; it is a question of reflection.

Current delinquency does not stem from a sense of malaise, as I hear too often: it results from a contempt for the fundamental values of our society. The question of parental responsibility is clearly raised. I want parental responsibility to be called into question when minors commit offenses. Clearly negligent parents may find their responsibility engaged on a criminal level. When I look at police reports, and I see that a minor of 12 or 13 years old, at one o'clock in the morning, in a city neighborhood, throws Molotov cocktails at a passing bus, is there not a problem of parental responsibility? It is not about punishment. It is about making them react. Similarly, there is the question of family allowances. When a family does not report that their child is no longer attending school, can that family continue to go to the Family Allowance Office to receive benefits as if nothing had happened?

I fully understand that a mother, especially in single-parent families, may feel overwhelmed. Raising children is so difficult. But I do not understand why this is not reported to the school principal. And when the family reacts, the family allowances that have not been paid will be reimbursed when the child returns to school.

I also add that we cannot tolerate the behavior of certain young people who prevent others from studying. Therefore, we will open about twenty establishments next school year that I call school reintegration centers, which will have enhanced and adapted supervision. I wish, along with the elected officials of the department, to discuss opening one in Grenoble or in Isère as soon as possible.

These are, you know, those young middle school students who have already been expelled two or three times from other schools, who are passed from school to school because no one knows what to do with them. And who prevent others from studying and living peacefully. This is not a question of right or left, but a question of common sense. What do we do with them and how do we react? The threat of exclusion is a joke in the face of middle school or high school students who, in any case, are no longer attending school.

We must ask ourselves questions without taboos, without excess, it is true, without stigmatization, without amalgamation, it is true. But without weakness either. What the French expect from us is not that we hide behind a posture: "To me the big heart, or to me the big stick." No, it is not about opposing those who have a heart and those who are firm. It is about being worthy of the responsibilities that the French have entrusted to us, whether they are local, departmental, regional, or national. And to rise to the level of these responsibilities. The world is changing. Many of our young people have changed. Values have been destroyed; we must propose responses adapted to the situation. And not decline like others into a catechism that would be marked by the greatest inefficiency.

I also add that many young people who leave school at 16 have no qualifications and completely disappear from the system. Each of them, we will offer them training or work until they reach adulthood, because we can no longer allow dropouts to leave our systems like that. I am told, "Are you going to create a registry?" Yes. But if we do not create the registry, the young people who leave school at 16 and disappear until they are 18, do you think it does them any good to stay like that for 2 years? With nothing. There cannot be a single one of these dropouts without an appropriate response.

Finally, it must be recognized, I must say it, we are suffering the consequences of 50 years of insufficiently regulated immigration that has led to a failure of integration. We are so proud of our integration system. Perhaps it is time to wake up? To see what it has produced. It worked. It no longer works. I have never let myself be intimidated by the dominant thought. It is still unbelievable that young people of the second, even the third generation, feel less French than their parents or grandparents. All of you here could testify to this. All. You all have examples. Why do we not say it? Are we afraid? For me, it is not the observation that scares me, it is the reality. We do not have the right to complacency in this matter.

To succeed in this integration process, it is imperative to control the migratory flow. With an unemployment rate among non-EU foreigners that reached 24% in 2009.

I will not repeat the famous phrase of Michel Rocard in which I find myself: "France cannot accommodate all the misery of the world." I simply say, it is a lucid observation.

We will therefore evaluate the rights and benefits that irregular foreigners currently have access to. I am not talking about regular foreigners who naturally have the right to benefits; it would be absurd for it to be otherwise! I am talking about irregular foreigners. Ladies and gentlemen, my dear compatriots. An irregular situation cannot confer more rights than a regular and legal situation! Here too, it is not a matter of majority, of left or right, of president of the Republic or mayor.

I ask Eric le Douaron, who knows the subject well as a former director of the PAF, to show absolute firmness in the fight against illegal immigration. The general rule is clear: undocumented migrants must be returned to their country.

And it is in this spirit that I have asked the Minister of the Interior to put an end to the illegal settlements of Roma camps. These are areas of lawlessness that cannot be tolerated in France. It is not about stigmatizing the Roma, in any case. We have made great progress since the Besson law regarding the areas made available to them. When I became Minister of the Interior in 2002, less than 20% of parking areas were planned. I have checked with the minister. Today, more than 60% of legal parking areas are planned. Roma who come to France to settle in legal locations are welcome. But as head of state, can I accept that there are 539 illegal camps in France in 2010? Who can accept that?

I saw that some political leaders said: "But why are you dealing with this, the problem does not exist." It does not exist for a political leader whose home is not next to a camp. Perhaps their opinion would be different if they were personally affected?

We will proceed by the end of September to dismantle all the camps that are subject to a court decision. Where this court decision has not yet been made, we will take steps to ensure that it is made as quickly as possible. Within three months, half of these illegal settlements will have disappeared from French territory.

I also wish that starting next autumn, we reform the law applicable to this type of situation. The decision to evacuate the camps will be made solely under the responsibility of the prefects, and their destruction will occur by summary proceedings in the court of first instance, within a short timeframe. Our compatriots expect us to assume our responsibilities.

At the same time, I wish for us to engage in a significant reform to improve the fight against irregular immigration. Every year, tens of thousands of irregular migrants, including Roma, voluntarily leave with state assistance. And the following year, after having left the territory with state assistance, they return illegally to request another state aid to leave again. This is called "an abuse of the right to free movement."

Finally, the urban policy. We have dedicated 15 billion euros to it since 2005. These are considerable resources provided by the state. Including in Isère. But we are entitled to expect in return the respect of a certain number of rules.

Resources are not everything. We must also together, elected officials, ministers, and president, address the issue of allocation to certain neighborhoods. These aids must be allocated to the neighborhoods that need them the most. Today, all neighborhoods are asking for them. We must recognize that the geographical zoning is no longer adapted to the situation.

Another thing, there is no evaluation. We redo neighborhoods, we redo buildings, but if we put the same people in the same conditions, what are we going to change? I do not question urban policy, which is a progress. And we will continue. But our compatriots, who pay for this urban policy, are entitled to expect something different from us. And I say this because what is happening in these neighborhoods is extraordinary. There are people who only want to get out. There are considerable results. And all this can be destroyed because a minority creates chaos under the gaze of the media who do their job, attached as they are to the spectacular. And thus, years of work by associative activists, local elected officials, and governments are reduced to nothing, and we are headed for stigmatization.

I call for us to rethink our procedures. Evaluation is not a dirty word. And then, let us also reflect on social diversity. Because if we always put the same people in the same neighborhoods, let us not complain later that they become ghettos. Neighborhoods, including in the city of Grenoble, were a few years ago neighborhoods where there was diversity. Social diversity and diversity of origin. There are certain middle schools, I spoke about it with the president, where despite the efforts you all make, there is no longer a family that wants to enroll their children. It does not sound good to say it, and yet it is the truth. Why? Because we close our eyes. And because we do not question things. So obviously, I am told: "More police!" We will put more in Grenoble and in Isère. But that is not all. More resources, of course, but the state cannot always give more and expect less. Society cannot function like that. Your own families do not function like that. In our professional or personal lives, we do not function like that. The events that Grenoble has just experienced and their seriousness impose a firm response from us, but it may also be an opportunity to break away from the dominant thought on urban policy, immigration policy, and security policy.

Grenoble does not deserve the image that was given of it last week. Isère does not either. We do not have the right to squander our assets because of a handful of delinquents. And I would like to tell you in closing that we are determined to work with all those who, in good faith and with good will, want to work with us to solve this problem.

The war I have decided to wage against traffickers, against thugs, this war is for several years. It goes far beyond the situation of a government, a majority, or a party. And I am sure that in all political formations, there are men and women of good will who are determined to react and to support this action of the government of the Republic.

Thank you for your attention.