Statement by Mr. Nicolas Sarkozy, President of the Republic, on government efforts in favor of universities, particularly the reform on university autonomy, in Paris on September 26, 2011.

France Nicolas Sarkozy · President of France

26 September 2011 · Montaigne Institute debate on 15 years of university reform · Paris, France

Context
Sarkozy addressed the Montaigne Institute debate on university reform during the academic rentrée in Paris on September 26, 2011.
Main themes
University autonomy reform, higher education policy, French university history, student enrollment growth, academic governance, political will and reform, university modernization, May 1968 legacy, social diversity in higher education, university relocation to suburbs
Duration
~36 min
88th percentile
Words
4,356
88th percentile
Sentences
218
91st percentile
Readability
48
58th percentile
Grade
11.4
38th percentile
Syntax
2.93
38th percentile
Vocabulary
2.16
41st percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 47%46%
  • Social 27%26%
  • Economic 18%18%
  • Ceremonial 5%5%
  • Geopolitical 3%3%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 3%

218 sentences in 45 paragraphs

Ladies and Gentlemen,

On this day of the university rentrée, the Montaigne Institute has chosen to debate, with the insight that has made its reputation, a subject that is absolutely fundamental for the future of our country, that of our universities.

The title of this debate to which the Montaigne Institute invites us, "15 years of university reform: what achievements, what challenges?" immediately calls for a first observation from me:

15 years of reform projects, that's for sure,

15 years of marginal revisions, that's for sure,

15 years of attempts to adapt to an increasingly complex reality, that's certain.

But 15 years of reform, let's not exaggerate. One can say anything, except that the academic world, even over the last 30 years, has been tossed from major reform to major reform! We have talked about reforms, we have debated reforms.

There is a reason for this: apart from the time of Claude ALLEGRE, who was the first to understand that it was necessary to adapt our universities to the European context, the ministers of Universities, whether from the left or the right, wanted to, but could not, - and it was not their fault - carry out their reform projects. The reason is quite simple, it is that the minister of Universities, - and I hope you, the academics, understand this - has long been seen in his governmental position as the fuse that needed to be blown in case of a blockage. This concerns neither the left nor the right, it concerns everyone. The minister of Universities has been, for decades, put in place to avoid trouble for the government, and when there was trouble, that is to say when he said a word that corresponded to a truth, he left. The truth was forgotten, the word was forgotten, a successor was appointed to whom it was said: "no trouble, please!" That was the relationship between universities and the political power of our country.

What has this led us to? It has led to the state in which universities found themselves when in 2007 we launched our reform process. We have no other merit than having understood that we had no choice left. It was for the universities to reform or disappear. I use strong words, but there was no choice! I do not say that the reform we initiated was the only possible one; there were other paths, we debated them, in fact. But what was not an alternative was to tell the minister of Universities: "no trouble, therefore no reform." That was not an alternative, it was not possible.

In 2007, when we looked into the question of French universities, I realized that they had hardly changed compared to what they were 15 years earlier.

Except that the number of students had multiplied by 6 in 30 years. I want to make you reflect: a framework that changed only marginally and a demographic situation closer to a demographic explosion than to a demographic evolution - a number of students multiplied by 6 - 300,000 students in 1960, 1,700,000 in 1990, 2,300,000 this year. Can you imagine? We keep the same framework, and we go from 300,000 to 2,300,000 students? Can we imagine the disarray of the university structure in the face of this influx of students thrown into the universities? The entirety of the universities' resources was therefore absorbed by this tidal wave. No margin to change anything. Naturally, I do not dispute that it is a good thing that we have more students, but all the resources, and all the energies, were absorbed in this positive tidal wave that expresses the demographic health of our country.

This increase in the number of young people trained in higher education, which is a necessity, was not accompanied by a questioning of the organizational and statutory fundamentals of our universities. And nothing was planned to modernize our universities. We had to wait until the 1990s for the State to question the scandalous conditions in which these new students were welcomed, most of whom, as an aggravating circumstance, came from families that had never accessed higher education. Because not only did the academic world have to face an unprecedented demographic explosion, from 300,000 to 2,300,000, but moreover the students who joined you - and thank goodness -- came from backgrounds that until then had rarely frequented French universities. So, demographic explosion and a change in the social parameter of the students you address, absolutely unprecedented.

After what I would call the "Great Fear" of 1968, one can make any judgment one wants about 1968, but let’s say that I know few governments that had the courage to acknowledge 1968. It was even decided - was it a conscious or unconscious decision, history will tell -- but it is interesting, because nothing is by chance - it was decided to exile the universities to distant suburbs. So the structures remained the same, but the universities had to leave the heart of the cities. It was explained that there were reasons related to the price of real estate, but it was not just that.

Demographic explosion, social change, geographical distance: what does it all boil down to? Distrust, endemic distrust in truth between the political power as it was and the academic world.

For some, universities were designated as political enemies. For others, on the pretext that they were "political friends," nothing should change. As for financial capacities, without which no real modernization is possible, they were non-existent. Ultimately, what was expected was "no trouble."

It was only with the European harmonization of degrees and the construction of a European higher education area, initiated in 1998 by Claude ALLEGRE, that France became aware of its lag. That is the truth. And that is why I am so attached to the European idea and to Europe. Because Europe forces us to modernize. Europe protects us and compels us to modernize. It reminds us that there is a world, that we cannot deny the world, that we cannot refuse the world. And it is in this context that Claude ALLEGRE began the first modernization.

This international opening compelled French universities to question the entire architecture of their training programs, and I believe it was an opportunity for a tremendous collective awareness. The archaic nature, the fragmentation, the rigidity, fundamentally the confinement of a system at the end of its rope that despaired the most dynamic and dragged down the average, came to light. It was all the more striking because at the same time, our competitors, our neighbors, our friends, our allies were methodically organizing the increase in the number of students, while we confused egalitarianism with equality of opportunity. In the name of equality, we refused difference; in the name of equality, which was in truth egalitarianism, we refused excellence; in the name of egalitarianism, we refused competition. This was the great lie of a generation. I would like you to understand well that in my mind, it is not a matter of opposing the left and the right, but of embracing a period that led to this great French lie, that of leveling and that of egalitarianism.

I say this without beating around the bush, it led our universities to a true social segregation that did not speak its name. An insidious segregation with dreadful effects. For the children of the affluent classes, the grandes écoles - regardless of the efforts of the grandes écoles to open up, because if the grandes écoles have made efforts to open up, it is because the natural flow was not openness. When one belonged to an affluent social class, with connections, cultural habits, and work ethics, the prestigious path was that of the grandes écoles. For the children of others, by default, the impoverished universities relegated to the outskirts of the cities. Naturally, there are exceptions. Which ones? The universities that unofficially extricated themselves from the status, that is to say those that, without saying so, obtained permission, in the name of experimentation, to develop procedures that had nothing to do with the status of others. I would not want to name names because everyone has them in mind and everyone knows them. There were, in truth, two-speed universities, those of the status that continued to decline inexorably and those that managed to get by because they had silently negotiated exceptions to the status. And then the grandes écoles that were thriving.

I believe that this situation was further aggravated by the paralysis of university decision-making bodies. In 1984, the SAVARY law had reduced the meager share of autonomy that the FAURE law had granted to universities in 1968. There was not much autonomy in 1968, but it was immediately rolled back in 1984, and the principle of elections in all university decision-making bodies was established as if it were the system for universities, for international excellence, for academic quality. In 2007, this organization was a specificity of our country, and even within our country, a specificity of universities. No flexible decision, no effective decision. Flexibility for the grandes écoles, status for the universities.

I understand why things came to this: not only was there fear from governments towards the academic world, but moreover the academic world, after years of budgetary drought -- understand me, the budget was increasing, but as the numbers multiplied tenfold, the budget in relative value decreased, felt the necessity for reform. But it said to itself, in a crisis of confidence towards political power: "if they make a reform, it is not to help us, it is to give us less money," and thus tension -- a minority was tense because it considered that the university was its domain and that any opening was in some way a violation of the sacred principles of academia. But there was a majority that thought in good faith - and who was not necessarily wrong, by the way - that the reform was in truth only a pretext for a budget cut. That is where we made, it seems to me, the decision that needed to be made: autonomy and resources.

I remember very well the meeting we had, Mr. President, with the university presidents -- perhaps they remember it themselves -- we did not know each other, one could say we had preconceived notions -- I said: "we." We had to learn to know each other and to trust each other. At that time, I indicated to you that it was about additional resources, reform, and resources. No reform, no resources; a reform, resources. I deeply believe that one cannot restructure a field of state activity without first providing considerable resources. In both the private and public sectors, restructuring starts by costing money. It is the alliance of the two that has allowed us to move forward.

I must say that the university presidents were courageous because autonomy, for years, pronouncing the word "autonomy" was, like pronouncing the word "selection," extremely serious. What everyone knows in life could not be formulated. This is where we saw that the patient was indeed ill because he could not even hear the diagnosis. The first characteristic of someone who suffers, who is ill, is their ability to hear the diagnosis, to understand it, to integrate it, to make it their own. The situation was so blocked that one could not even pose the diagnosis. Formulating the words was already taking the risk of unprecedented mobilization.

Yet, there is not a single university system in the world that has succeeded without autonomy. But what is autonomy? It is simply trusting the academic community. It is nothing else. Autonomy is not the commercialization of universities, the opening to big capital, the arrival of business leaders; autonomy is simply that academics themselves had the power to decide for their students and for their universities. Autonomy is a tremendous gesture of trust towards a community that had ended up losing confidence in itself, sheltering behind a status that it knew was completely outdated and considering itself incapable of assuming its responsibilities. The magic happened, the law on university freedoms and responsibilities, which was carried with great talent by Valérie PÉCRESSE, was such a success that the deadlines of the calendar we had planned for the transition to autonomy were shattered. Because freedom is like that, when you let it in, it sweeps everything away, and when you trust people, you are always rewarded for that trust, whereas distrust allows for no construction. It is trust that made it possible.

Universities now have the opportunity to create foundations, to recruit staff according to their needs, to become owners and managers of their assets. I would like to remind you that this was the case in the Middle Ages. In the Middle Ages, universities were managers and owners of their assets, and it is contemporary France that has painstakingly stripped universities of their rights and properties. Each university can now build its own project and assert the uniqueness of its strengths.

Naturally, all of this does not come without problems, without difficulties. First, dear Laurent WAUQUIEZ, it was necessary to get the Ministry of Universities and its central administrations used to the idea that, fundamentally, a board of directors knows as much about the university as the central administration. I recognize the profound revolution we have asked of our administration. Imagine what it represents for a ministry that has managed your assets, your staff, and salaries for decades to relinquish a part of its power. It is like a questioning of its role, but no, the ministry's role is to coordinate, to harmonize perhaps, to set a national line to ensure equal opportunities. It is not meant to manage universities one by one.

Autonomy has also allowed us to place, and I insist on this, universities at the heart of research. Because I do not know if you, in the academic world, were aware, but you were being competed against by three major players. The grandes écoles, as I mentioned, were taking the best students. Universities around the world, particularly in Europe, exerted pressure and attractiveness on you, especially with Erasmus. But as these two competitors were not enough, a third one was found: research organizations. And who can say that French universities were still at the heart of French research? I believe it is very important that we further strengthen the links between research and innovation, research and university.

Without the autonomy of universities, we would not have been able to successfully implement the future investment program so intelligently set up by René RICOL.

I want you to understand the overall strategy: to trust the academic world through autonomy, to let you develop your projects, to modernize research, to place research at the heart of the university, and to give the university and research the means to develop.

This is the French response to the crisis, an unprecedented economic crisis, a financial crisis like we have never known. The French response is more reforms and more resources for our universities and for our research. It is you who are at the forefront of the response to the economic crisis we are experiencing. Placing universities at the heart of our system is a global strategy. For future investment, we have mobilized 35 billion euros, 22 billion of which will go directly to universities and research organizations. I do not know if you realize, in the current circumstances, the effort this represents. But I believe that the response to the crisis is not retraction. It is investment, it is research, it is training. French spending per student at university has just reached the OECD average, 10,000 euros per student per year. That is 2,000 euros more per student since 2007. When we relate this to the 2,300,000 students, we can clearly see the gigantic effort of the nation. It was a mistake to allocate the majority of the ministry's resources to high schools that were losing students and not to universities that were gaining students. Saying this does not blame anyone. It does not insult anyone; it is a recognition of the inability to face the situation and the real divide between the political or state ruling elites and the academic elites.

Increase in the number of researchers, increase in operating resources, considerable increase in resources for research. Increase also in resources to refurbish your facilities. There is something utterly unbearable when the French talk about universities, imagining that a pleasant campus with sports and cultural facilities can only be found in the United States, Spain, or England. This is why we have committed 5 billion euros to the Campus plan, with the renovation of ten leading university sites.

This brings me to another point: I am grateful to the academic community for accepting this idea, which is somewhat uncommon in France, that not everyone can aspire to world-class excellence, that it is possible to designate 10 major sites, to choose them through an international competition without crying out in scandal over republican equality. And I must say I was very pleasantly surprised by the capacity of the academic world, its flexibility, to immediately embrace the game of autonomy. Because autonomy implies competition, competition implies excellence, difference, diversity. All things you know yourselves in the selection process that has led you to be what you are. This does not mean that we will leave aside all those who are not in the ten projects. It means that France, like everywhere else in the world, needs locomotives because locomotives pull everyone up, and if we do not have a locomotive, we will not succeed. But this is also true for cities. It is not by impoverishing Paris that we will develop France. It is not by tearing down the regional capital that we will develop the region. The success of the top universities, the largest ones, will benefit, in terms of reputation or opportunity, all other universities.

You see the overall strategy: more resources for you, more autonomy, more trust, and at the same time, allowing the dynamism of competition among you to play out. The call for projects organized by René RICOL has led to an extraordinary flourishing of emerging teams, all more dynamic than the others, and some that won did not come from the largest university centers. And suddenly everyone thinks, "It is possible, we will be able to succeed."

So in this whole landscape, I want to commend the issue of university libraries. This is a subject that has required four years of mobilization to ensure they are open with extended hours and open on weekends. After all, libraries are better when they are open on the days when people can go. I would like to remind you that Marc BLOCH saw the decay of French libraries as a symptom of a defeat of thought. Bringing our universities up to speed in international competition also involves this.

The number of scholarships, because we have not forgotten the students, has increased by 25% since 2007, Jeannette BOUGRAB could testify to this. 25% more scholarship recipients, and the amount of social aid for universities has increased by half a billion euros since 2007 within the budgetary context to reach over 3 billion euros. And I want to add this 10th month of scholarship that will be paid for the first time this year. There has been a controversy over this point; it is strange. I am in favor of extending the duration of the academic year, as everyone knows, and it seemed honest to me that since students attend 10 months of classes instead of 9, they should receive 10 months of scholarship. But if they only attend 9, they will only receive 9. It is quite logical.

You have understood, and I would like to conclude with this, that this is a subject that fascinates me because it is at the heart of French modernization and that the university deserves much more than ideological battles of another time. There is not a left-wing university and a right-wing university; there is a university that must embody the diversity of opinions.

Is the reform and the movement to renovate universities complete? No, not at all. I did not come to tell you that we have accomplished everything and done everything; we have simply unlocked the system to allow it to reform itself. Therefore, we will need to continue. The conviction I would like to share with you is that I do not believe, I no longer believe, in great definitive and blocked reforms.

Let me explain: a phenomenal battle to get a reform voted on, and once it is voted, no one talks about it anymore. And we are so exhausted from having it voted that we instantly stop, saying, "Oh no, we are not going to start again." Perhaps to surprise you, I advocate for a university system that would reform continuously, where each year the government could present a text, not necessarily a definitive text, not necessarily a structural text, not necessarily a systemic text as economists say, but a legislative vehicle that allows, after consultation with the academic world, to see what we can evolve or change.

I take an example: the governance of universities. We have changed it a lot, but, as you know, there are things we have not succeeded in because we did not dare to go far enough the first time. And perhaps we will need to go further. I discuss this with many of you; it is true, and everyone knows it: the question of the role of qualified personalities is raised. You bring in qualified personalities; it is you who choose them, and you try to select the best, the most prestigious, those who can bring the most to your universities, and once you have brought them into the boardroom, you say to them, "Thank you, it is nice to have you, we forgot to mention, you do not vote." Is that correct? I think this is one of the areas where we can calmly reflect. Naturally, it is not about toppling a majority because a president has appointed qualified personalities; qualified personalities could vote and thus guarantee, in a way, a majority on the board of directors. And what if we trusted university presidents and qualified personalities?

A second, even more difficult subject: funding. We have increased the operating resources of your universities by 22% in the current budgetary context. The future is that you diversify your sources of funding as well, as all universities do around the world. How to differentiate them? First, there are research programs with companies that are geographically close to your universities or that are in your universities' areas of expertise. After all, what is healthier than companies asking your universities to organize research programs and fund you rather than funding foreign or French research organizations? What is healthier than your successful alumni being able to invest in your universities in the form of foundations? What is healthier than being able to create around each university places where your students could benefit from free premises to develop their businesses and that you would share in the profits of these businesses? Do you honestly believe that French universities will be the only ones that can say no to private funding? But look at the most beautiful universities in the world; who funds them? And what is your ambition? To have the most beautiful universities in the world.

I know there are still many problems regarding the transfer of assets. It is extremely complicated for organizing public-private partnerships. You really need to be not just a lawyer but a super lawyer to understand where to pull the file. Understanding the file is another matter altogether.

We still have a lot to do with Laurent WAUQUIEZ, whom I thank for accepting these responsibilities, but this does not require a definitive text on the future of universities. It requires successive, precise, sometimes technical texts in agreement with you to help you manage your universities.

So, ladies and gentlemen, universities that welcome their students better, students recruited from all walks of life, the best they can choose, research at the heart of your project, autonomy so that you can envision the future of your universities yourselves.

What I came to tell you is that we trust you. We have no preconceived notions; we simply ask you to take advantage of autonomy and ensure that our students can be welcomed in the best universities in the world. If we succeed in this, then we will have succeeded in modernizing France and enabling it to face the challenges of the 21st century under good conditions. That is the issue. It is solely there.

Do not let bad habits return, bad advice, those of fear, fear of students, fear of teachers, fear of the academic world, those of timidity, fear of the foreign, fear of openness, fear of business leaders. Do not let this fear return, fear of competition, fear of competence, fear of excellence. The university, on the contrary, is the domain of excellence, of openness, of the promotion of one another. This is what is embodied in the law of autonomy for universities.

I will just say one last word about tuition fees. I believe it would be a very bad idea for all universities to decide to raise their tuition fees because that would then give the impression from the outside of an economic barrier. I am well aware of what is happening outside, but do not let our reform be caricatured. For me, the sources of funding to prioritize are research, the private sector, the relationship with your ministries, not tuition fees. I say this not to recentralize this issue, I say this because I believe this reform is so important for you and for us. We have disrupted so many habits, so many comfortable statuses, so much immobility that all these immobilities and corporatisms would be so happy to take back by the hand of caricature what we have given by the hand of political will.