Interview with Mr. Nicolas Sarkozy, President of the Republic, in "Le Quotidien du Médecin" on September 28, 2011, on efforts in favor of doctors and the deficits of Social Security.

France Nicolas Sarkozy · President of France

28 September 2011

Context
Sarkozy gave an interview to Le Quotidien du Médecin on September 28, 2011, addressing healthcare reform, physician remuneration, and Social Security deficits.
Main themes
Medical convention and physician remuneration, medical desertification in rural areas, freedom of establishment vs. incentive measures, health centers and medical homes, excess fees and access to care, Social Security deficits, public health policy, general medicine as healthcare pillar, optional sector reform, doctor working conditions, performance-based payment
Duration
~22 min
69th percentile
Words
2,585
69th percentile
Sentences
144
79th percentile
Readability
48
57th percentile
Grade
11.0
32nd percentile
Syntax
2.75
17th percentile
Vocabulary
2.25
60th percentile

Translated from French

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

144 sentences in 32 paragraphs

THE DAILY -- The new medical convention generalizes performance-based payment in private practice. Should the C still evolve? What do you consider to be the fair price for a consultation?

NICOLAS SARKOZY -- Every time I meet with doctors or health professionals during my travels, I am confronted with the same questions: how do we respond to the challenges of medical desertification in rural areas? How do we support projects for regrouping around health centers and medical homes? How do we help doctors fully participate in public health policies, in the fight against Alzheimer’s or the Cancer Plan? Providing answers to these questions involves changing the remuneration of private practitioners. It is this evolution that I called for during a visit to the health center in Orbec in Calvados last December. I am pleased to note that since then, the contractual partners have reached the signing of a new medical convention. Who would have thought we could achieve such a result in less than a year? Now, doctors must take ownership of this new convention on the ground.

The price of the consultation remains, and I understand the attachment of many to this essential benchmark. I committed to ensuring that this rate would be revalued. I kept this commitment under particularly difficult economic conditions. I did it because I firmly believe that general medicine is a fundamental pillar of our healthcare system. If it falters, the entire structure is at risk.

Today, we have finally moved beyond a debate that had remained too long focused on the timing of the next revaluation to enter fully into a broader partnership between public authorities and representatives of private practitioners. It is within this framework that we can establish the principle of fair remuneration.

THE DAILY -- At the beginning of your term, you believed it was high time to act firmly to combat medical desertification. The convention only provides for incentive measures. Is that enough for you? Will it be necessary to reconsider the total freedom of establishment?

NICOLAS SARKOZY -- A doctor who permanently closes their practice in a village or neighborhood is not just the departure of a familiar figure or the disappearance of a local service; it is telling an entire population, sometimes elderly, sometimes disadvantaged: "You are abandoned, go seek care elsewhere!" This is humanly, socially, and therefore politically unacceptable. I do not accept it, and neither do local elected officials.

However, it cannot be a question of forcibly fixing doctors to their practices like serfs to their land. This is completely contrary to my idea of the freedom to practice this profession. We must therefore encourage the establishment of doctors and health professionals where the population needs them.

We have therefore decided, with Xavier Bertrand and Nora Berra, to intensify our efforts, not only on incentives but also on the deployment of health centers and medical homes, as they help improve the working conditions of professionals and maintain their presence in rural areas. Not only do they allow for shared burdens, but they also break the sometimes very harsh isolation of rural doctors. One must know what it is like to return home at night, exhausted after a day of consultations, to an empty office without anyone to exchange ideas with or simply talk to. Doctors often bear the weight of the world's misery; that is what makes their profession a true calling, but solitude is not a fatality. There were 170,000 doctors in 1990; there are 210,000 today. There is no shortage of vocations! So I say to professionals: take hold of all the tools we have made available to you. Patients are just as endearing at the end of a country road as they are on the coast! You chose this profession because you had a sense of mission. The State has made considerable efforts. There is now an obligation to deliver results.

THE DAILY -- To regulate excess fees, you demanded, four years ago, the implementation of the optional sector, warning that the State would act if the partners did not reach an agreement... Today, this file is at an impasse. What do you propose? Can the law include the optional sector in responsible contracts?

NICOLAS SARKOZY -- Access to care is, for me, a fundamental issue, and I cannot accept that, in certain territories or for certain specialties, the level of excess fees becomes an obstacle to care. I remain determined to find solutions. The status quo is not an option. The signatories of the medical convention reaffirmed their willingness to advance on the optional sector in the text signed in July. I have noted the hesitations of some. However, I believe that all stakeholders involved—doctors, health insurance, complementary organizations—have an interest in building together a new coherent partnership to guarantee insured individuals satisfactory coverage of healthcare professionals' remuneration. I will not take my eyes off this issue until a solution is found.

THE DAILY -- The reform of professional civil liability (RCP) is at a standstill. Can you reassure doctors in high-risk specialties that they will soon have comprehensive coverage?

NICOLAS SARKOZY -- We want to eliminate the sword of Damocles that indeed hangs over the heads of many professionals and especially to encourage young people to pursue these careers: yes, we need young anesthetists, young surgeons, young obstetrician-gynecologists to continue to meet the healthcare needs of the population tomorrow. As President of the Republic, it is my duty to prepare the future of our healthcare system. That is why the government has taken this complex issue head-on, which has hindered the activity of many healthcare professionals for several years. A solution has been found, which we had translated into the bill proposed by Senator Jean-Pierre Fourcade. This provision was censored by the Constitutional Council for formal reasons. My commitment is clear: we will reintroduce it in the 2012 finance law. Through a mutualization led by healthcare professionals, this system will provide a comprehensive response to the difficulties we have faced for over ten years.

THE DAILY -- Doctors continue to be overwhelmed by paperwork. Shouldn't we change gears in terms of administrative simplification?

NICOLAS SARKOZY -- I understand and share the exasperation of healthcare professionals. Too much medical time is wasted due to paperwork. I have asked Xavier Bertrand to scrutinize all administrative procedures and eliminate anything that can be eliminated. Already, simple files are progressing, such as the single file for entering a nursing home. Individual contact with health insurance... This process must continue and be amplified.

THE DAILY -- After the HPST law and the vaccination campaign against H1N1 flu without general practitioners, studies have shown that a gap has widened between private doctors and the government. How did you experience this period? Are the wounds not deep?

NICOLAS SARKOZY -- I have heard the criticisms and misunderstandings. Some general practitioners may have felt that public authorities wanted to build a healthcare system "without them." Yes, I want to reform proximity medicine to adapt it to the challenges ahead, whether it is an increasingly pressing demand for care from our fellow citizens or the different aspirations of younger generations of doctors. But this reform must be done with professionals and not against them. When I see that the new medical convention is signed by the main unions, I think we are moving in the right direction, that the profession knows how to come together to modernize a healthcare system that is a common good. I believe in the strong and lasting partnership that this new contractual pact offers. That is why I wanted to meet a few days ago at the Élysée the signing medical unions and the heads of health insurance to commend their sense of responsibility. To also highlight the quality of the action taken by Xavier Bertrand on this file, on which he has fully invested himself.

We have the extraordinary chance to rely in our country on well-trained general practitioners, in contact with the population, who constitute a proximity medicine that many countries envy for its quality and accessibility, and that the French people endorse. This is what we must preserve.

THE DAILY -- The Court of Auditors has denounced the historical deficits of Social Security in 2010 and the "poison" of debt. Shouldn't we consider a structural reform of Social Security revenues?

NICOLAS SARKOZY -- In 2010, as the court points out, the international economic and financial crisis severely cut Social Security revenues and deepened deficits and debts. Today, the choices are clear, for Social Security as for all our public finances: there is no question of allowing deficits to accumulate through reckless policies that would lead to a loss of sovereignty for France. I will not allow our country to experience the situation of Greece, Ireland, or Portugal. We must urgently restore our public accounts and bring Social Security back to balance. This is the essential condition to safeguard our social protection. What kind of healthcare system do we want to leave to our children? A system that spends always more than it can finance? Those who claim to want to always increase revenues to always increase expenditures are lying with incredible boldness. And the French people know it.

For 2012, the forecasts just announced show a substantial improvement in Social Security accounts, with the deficit of health insurance being less than 6 billion euros. We are returning to levels that were those before the crisis. The deficit of health insurance has been halved between 2010 and 2012. Finally, the financial trajectory of pension schemes has been restored thanks to the reform carried out last year. This reform is more than just the safeguarding of our pension system; it is the guarantee of our future. Regarding revenues, the evolution of the financing methods of social protection, in order not to penalize the competitiveness of businesses in France, indeed seems inevitable to me.

THE DAILY -- Do you plan to quickly reopen the debate on the "basket of care," that is, what falls under national solidarity, complementary coverage, and individual effort?

NICOLAS SARKOZY -- This debate must be engaged on serious bases. We must remind our fellow citizens that our country is characterized by a very high level of reimbursement: out of 100 euros you spend on your care, 91 are reimbursed. Such a level of coverage is unparalleled in the world. We often forget this. However, we cannot ignore the considerable pressures on our healthcare system; I think of the aging of our population and the development of chronic diseases. Therefore, we must have this debate, not to call into question our system, but to allow it to adapt and thus survive. One only has to look at what is happening in certain countries in Europe to see that everything can tip very quickly. Nothing is guaranteed. The protection of our Social Security system is a permanent battle.

I have asked Xavier Bertrand to work with all stakeholders to relaunch the debate on the place of complementary schemes in our healthcare system. We are at a crucial period, and we need to think collectively. Not so that health insurance saves a few million euros by lowering this or that reimbursement rate, but by building a new partnership between mandatory and complementary schemes.

THE DAILY -- In the immediate term, who should bear the main efforts of recovery?

NICOLAS SARKOZY -- We are engaged in a very clear recovery of our public finances, following the significant loss of revenues caused by the 2009 crisis. Regarding health insurance, we have set a clear course over several years: 3% in 2010; 2.9% in 2011; and 2.8% in 2012. For the first time since 1997, we met the ONDAM in 2010. And we will meet it in 2011.

We have shown that we can control health spending without undermining the pillars of our system, while continuing to invest: each year, our health system benefits from 5 billion euros. This is a considerable amount. Yes, we must make efforts, but with consistency over time: adapting drug prices to the product life cycle, effectively implementing a medicalized control of spending by limiting overconsumption and overprescription, promoting generic drugs, fighting against fraud and abuse. We must continue to optimize health spending in the service of quality care.

LE QUOTIDIEN -- Zero deficit in hospitals in 2012, is it still possible?

NICOLAS SARKOZY -- I note that we are on the right track: hospital deficits continued to decrease in 2010 (185 million euros compared to 475 million in 2007), which is all the more remarkable given that health insurance spending is controlled through the ONDAM. All stakeholders in the hospital are making a very significant effort that I want to highlight. A hospital with a structural deficit is a hospital that no longer invests, that no longer modernizes, that is no longer able to meet the healthcare needs of the population. Once again, I believe that there is actually a lot of clarity among hospital stakeholders, whether they are caregivers, administrative or technical staff, about the need to change the hospital. I do not recognize our hospital system and more broadly our health system in the apocalyptic descriptions that are sometimes made of it. I am struck to see that when our fellow citizens have the opportunity to receive care abroad during their travels, they return saying that we have in France one of the best, if not the best, healthcare systems in the world! Let us also look at the efforts made by the community to transform the hospital: the LMD reform to enhance the nursing profession; future investments, with six hospital-university institutes that will be centers of world-class excellence. All of this means better-trained professionals and therefore better recognized; the ability to build innovative projects and to maintain our country at the highest level in terms of research and innovation.

LE QUOTIDIEN -- The government promises a complete overhaul of drug policy through the bill currently under examination. The medical visit, even reformed, remains, while the industry retains control over the financing of medical training. Shouldn't we give ourselves the means for independent medical training?

NICOLAS SARKOZY -- The drug reform bill precisely carries a new ambition for medical training, with independent funding at significant levels. This is a substantial evolution. I had set three imperatives after the Mediator affair, in order to guarantee our fellow citizens absolute safety in the use of medication: total transparency; a real renovation of our drug policy; and in-depth consultation with stakeholders. All within a tight schedule. We are on track.

LE QUOTIDIEN -- In public health, plans accumulate, sometimes overlap, without always clearly discerning priorities -- and results. And the revision of the law of August 9, 2004, on public health, which was supposed to take place starting in 2010, is still not in sight. What are your plans in this area?

NICOLAS SARKOZY -- You are right; we often run after too many objectives at once in this area, without really prioritizing them. That is why I have set three strong priorities for the government in the field of public health since 2007: Alzheimer's disease, cancer, and palliative care. On each of these three topics, we have defined priorities, allocated resources, and I am personally following the implementation of these three plans with great attention. You noted that, particularly regarding Alzheimer's, France is cited as an example worldwide. I ask for only one thing: that my policy and that of my government be judged on results.