Statement by Mr. Nicolas Sarkozy, President of the Republic, on the treatment of social issues within the framework of the G20, in Paris on September 26, 2011.

France Nicolas Sarkozy · President of France

26 September 2011 · G20 Labour and Employment Ministers meeting · Palais de l'Elysée, Paris, France

Context
Sarkozy addressed G20 labor and employment ministers at the Élysée Palace in Paris on September 26, 2011, ahead of the Cannes G20 Summit.
Main themes
Employment and labor markets, social regulation, G20 responsibilities, globalization and inequality, social protection floors, financial and economic crisis, youth employment, ILO fundamental labor standards, growth and social cohesion, protectionism risks, emerging economies and social policy
Duration
~12 min
44th percentile
Words
1,492
44th percentile
Sentences
79
52nd percentile
Readability
57
81st percentile
Grade
9.9
20th percentile
Syntax
2.93
38th percentile
Vocabulary
2.21
53rd percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 38%38%
  • Social 28%28%
  • Ceremonial 15%15%
  • Institutional 12%11%
  • Geopolitical 6%6%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 1%

79 sentences in 26 paragraphs

Ladies and Gentlemen Ministers,

Ladies and Gentlemen Presidents and Directors General,

Ladies and Gentlemen,

I wanted to welcome you to the Palais de l'Elysée to express the importance that France attaches to this meeting of the labor and employment ministers of the G20 countries, the second of its kind after the one held in Washington in April 2010.

I know that Xavier BERTRAND, whom I thank, has conducted intense consultations with you in preparation for this meeting. He will allow me to warmly thank Gilles de ROBIEN, who has done remarkable work in listening and dialogue.

Ladies and Gentlemen Ministers, your contribution must be essential for the success of the G20 Summit in Cannes.

Social issues are at the heart of the challenges our countries face: the crisis has had devastating effects on our labor markets, with 30 million additional unemployed in less than 2 years! And the shockwave has spared no country.

Since your last meeting in Washington in 2010, the economic and social situation in the world has only reinforced the imperative to place employment at the heart of our priorities. The G20 will only retain its legitimacy if it manages to demonstrate its effectiveness in favor of growth and employment.

By placing social issues at the center of global reflection, we draw lessons from the crisis we have experienced. What has this crisis taught us? That the illusion of the all-powerful market, which was not to be hindered by any constraints, which could self-regulate, which could abstain from solid supervision, that this illusion has caused an absolutely unprecedented crisis. There is no freedom without rules, there is no market without rules.

The crisis has shown that globalization, if not urgently balanced, is not viable. Certainly, thanks to the globalization of trade, extreme poverty has decreased in the world, with the number of affected people falling by 400 million between 1990 and 2005. But at the same time that extreme poverty has receded, inequalities have increased, with the gap in GDP per capita between the billion poorest people and the billion richest people nearly doubling in the world since the beginning of this century.

Growing inequalities do not lead to more growth, but surely to more instability.

France concludes that in addition to financial regulation and economic regulation, social regulation must be added. And in the face of a crisis that has shaken our societies, we can no longer be content with simply displaying good intentions; we must take action, for if we do not, the response will be protectionism and "degrowth" and ultimately the regression of quality of life. If there is no social regulation in place, countries will turn to the bad solution of protectionism to defend themselves. There is no other possible choice.

The G20 must take its responsibilities, because the G20 represents two-thirds of the population and 85% of the world's GDP. Of course, there has been progress, but it is still insufficient. My friend Juan SOMAVIA is now invited to all G20 meetings. This is the minimum, but it took France to demand it. And I hope that Juan SOMAVIA will pound the table when necessary to say a number of things.

Throughout the year, we have talked about these issues. I am very pleased that Xavier BERTRAND has obtained the principle of a ministerial meeting on employment during the next Mexican presidency, and I thank the Mexican presidency for this.

We have also achieved the creation of an intergovernmental working group on youth employment, which is not a French or European issue, but a global one.

The question of strengthening social protection in all countries is also a question that is clearly posed. Growth and strengthening social protection. These are two subjects that must go hand in hand. Emerging countries that have gone in this direction, I think of Mexico with the Seguro Popular program of 2003, which aimed to provide voluntary health insurance, at a moderate cost, to millions of people, have shown that there is no need to choose between growth and improving social protection. The two go hand in hand.

I would like to commend the very useful contribution of the United Nations Advisory Group on the Social Protection Floor, chaired by Ms. BACHELET, and in which Martin HIRSCH participated. Again, let us agree, there is no question of imposing a single social model on the world. No one has that idea, especially not France. We know well that the differences are immense, but we must have an imperative of protection for the most vulnerable, and we must uphold fundamental labor rights.

Member countries of the G20, which are also members of the ILO, must ratify the 8 conventions on the ILO's fundamental standards. Understand me well, there is a minimum protection floor that concerns all countries, just as the aspiration for democracy concerns all countries. I will not go into detail about the 8 conventions, but we do not allow child labor, we do not allow prisoners to work, women and men must be treated equally. What justification can there be for a member country of the ILO not to ratify the 8 core standards of the ILO? I want the ILO to strongly remind this at each G20 meeting, because if G20 countries are not exemplary in respecting fundamental labor rights, then how can we effectively fight against social leveling down? Is this really the model we want, is this really what our peoples aspire to? I believe that if everyone pushes in the same direction, we must break out of the status quo.

I would like us to put the same energy into defending the 8 minimum social standards of the ILO as we do into defending the norms of trade freedom of the WTO. If our countries put 10% of the energy they put into defending the WTO into defending the ILO, I guarantee you that things would change.

I want the major international institutions to collaborate with each other. I am pleased that the IMF is collaborating with the ILO to assess the feasibility of creating a social protection floor. The IMF also has a say on wealth distribution and fundamental standards. The World Bank has also decided, and this is a good decision, that 12% of its loans would be allocated to financing social protection actions, because such actions help to support growth. This is 4 times more than in the past. The OECD, dear Angel GURIA, has also done exemplary work in identifying best practices that combine employment development and social protection development, particularly in emerging countries. Here too, we cannot treat all countries the same way, but that emerging countries are more proactive on social protection than the poorest countries in the world seems normal to me. It is not asking for something extraordinary to affirm this.

The ILO has expressed its wish to have an observer within the WTO at the conference on May 23. It is not for me to decide. But if it were up to me to decide, I would say "yes" and I would like to be explained if the answer were "no," what is the obstacle to trade freedom in having an observer from the International Labour Organization at the WTO, when the members of both organizations are the same. I would like to remind you of this nonetheless.

This is the message that France wishes to convey. Xavier BERTRAND knows well, when we set the agenda together, I was told it was too ambitious. I think it is not ambitious enough, because naturally all the subjects are linked.

I am pleased that France is organizing for the first time the meeting of employer representatives (B20: Business 20) and a meeting of employee union representatives (L20: Labour 20) at the same time. Can you believe it took this long for that to happen! It was legitimate to receive business leaders, and it would be illegitimate not to receive employee organizations! On what grounds? On what vision of the world? On what reality? I insisted, François BAROIN can attest to this, that the L20 be treated on the same terms as the B20. Because in my eyes, it is just as important to receive employee organizations as it is to receive business leaders. Both are interlocutors and both are at the heart of global growth.

Ladies and Gentlemen, I will conclude by saying this: crises bring their share of problems, and major crises bring major problems. But major crises are also an opportunity to bring about great changes, because there is urgency, and this urgency must lead us to push for these great pragmatic, just changes, with the goal of global growth, but great changes. We cannot set aside the social question in any country in the world. And in all countries of the world, the demand is the same: protect us.

And it is to this challenge that the French presidency has decided to tackle.

Thank you.