Statement by Mr. Nicolas Sarkozy, President of the Republic, on housing policy, in Meaux on November 28, 2008.

France Nicolas Sarkozy · President of France

28 November 2008 · Meaux, France

Context
Sarkozy addressed a housing policy audience in Meaux on November 28, 2008, announcing emergency measures to support the construction sector amid the global financial crisis.
Main themes
Housing policy, global financial crisis impact on construction, real estate market stability, homeownership access, social housing, economic intervention, French industrial policy, urban planning, Caisse des Dépôts housing scheme
Duration
~38 min
89th percentile
Words
4,591
89th percentile
Sentences
237
92nd percentile
Readability
64
93rd percentile
Grade
9.1
12th percentile
Syntax
2.90
34th percentile
Vocabulary
1.98
8th percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 44%43%
  • Social 33%32%
  • Institutional 17%17%
  • Ceremonial 4%4%
  • Environmental 2%2%
  • Geopolitical 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Not in focus 1%

237 sentences in 62 paragraphs

Madam Minister, dear Christine,

Mr. Mayor, dear Jean-François,

Current and former ministers, and why not future ones,

Ladies and gentlemen, parliamentarians,

And if you will allow me, my dear friends,

Housing is one of the sectors that is suffering the most from the global crisis currently affecting the entire world.

We have a problem with the automotive industry; I will not let the French and European automotive industry down in my capacity as President of the European Council. The automotive sector represents 10% of the French workforce. And I will not let the industry down in general. We see the insurmountable difficulties faced by countries that, over the last 20 or 30 years, have allowed their industries to decline. It is all well and good to invest everything in services, but when there is no industry, there are no services. And when we focus on a single product, we find ourselves in the situation of our English friends, where finance accounts for 15% of GDP, while for us it is 3%. And we see the results. We understand why I fought to save train manufacturing in France with Alstom, the Chantiers de l'Atlantique, we took a stake, Airbus, and the automotive manufacturers.

But construction is the second sector that is being hit hard by the crisis.

In recent months, we have seen over-indebted households in the United States being evicted from their homes and left on the streets. That is the result of the subprime crisis.

It is not that I am distancing myself from Meaux, Jean-François, or from Seine-et-Marne, dear Christian, I am getting there - but I would like us not to make the same mistakes that others have made.

In recent years, Spain has built too many homes. In recent years, Spain has built as many homes as France, Great Britain, and Germany combined. So we built without quality, without care for urban planning and architecture, and today we find ourselves with a massive real estate crisis where there are no buyers and where properties must be sold at a loss.

France has not experienced such excesses. But the financial crisis has worsened a real estate crisis - I am speaking in front of specialists, they will surely correct me - but a real estate crisis that I considered latent, because a sector where prices have doubled in ten years is a sector that is preparing for a crisis. And indeed, over the last 30 years, we have gone from real estate bubbles to crises. Prices have doubled in the last ten years. In 2007, these prices reached the highest level in France in relation to household incomes in 40 years! This cannot be without consequences. When there is a total disconnection between the evolution of buyers' incomes and real estate prices, we were preparing for a latent crisis.

Just because the real estate crisis in France is less severe than in the United States or Spain does not mean we can afford not to propose responses commensurate with this crisis because the construction sector alone represents one and a half million jobs. And in this matter, it is clear, when we stop programs, construction stops temporary work, partial unemployment begins, and then comes outright unemployment.

I add that we should not find ourselves in a situation where we stop programs today due to the financial and economic crisis, preparing for tomorrow's crisis with a shortage of supply, because the homes we do not build today will cost us in five years. And in five years, we will find ourselves with a demand that is still very strong and an offer that is too weak, leading to skyrocketing prices, and thus the same consequences.

I also add that I was elected on a project, which is to facilitate access to property for the French because the expectation of the French is to be able to own their homes.

When the situation is exceptional, we need an exceptional commitment.

That is what we did - I will not go back to it - to save the financial system. It is no longer worsening. I saw the Euribor this morning at 3.80; it had risen to 5.40, it is getting better, but we are not out of the woods yet. That is what we did by announcing the total exemption from business tax on all new investments until January 1, 2010.

That is what we are doing, with the measure of which the city of Meaux is currently at the forefront since we have, through a subsidiary of the Caisse des Dépôts, purchased a number of projects known as "sale in future state of completion."

It is very simple. I spoke with the developer himself. If he had not found a buyer, in this case, the subsidiary of the Caisse des Dépôts, the project would not have been launched. The city of Meaux would have found itself stalled, we would have built fewer social housing units, and construction would have had less work. And we have therefore decided, I thank Christine BOUTIN for this, that 30,000 homes that are currently, as we say colloquially, "stuck," with no financing, because you cannot ask private developers to embark on building homes without any guarantee of being able to sell them. And this means work, it means jobs, it means growth. So we decided to acquire them, which allows for more social housing, thus moving from a VAT of 19.6% to 5.5%, avoiding marketing costs and waiting costs. This means we can negotiate a price reduction, and we expect a price drop because let’s be honest, even if it is not very popular among those who sell, the best way to restart real estate, ladies and gentlemen, is for sale prices to become attractive again.

So I understand that for them to become attractive again, it is better that we have purchased the land at a lower price. And I understand the difficulty of operations that are, as they say, in the "pipeline"; you bought the land at the high price of 2007, you cannot sell it at the low price of 2008. But it remains that real estate will rebound, and real estate has always rebounded when a number of institutional, personal, and professional buyers say, "Now is the time, we are at the bottom of the crisis, we will buy back." That is still the difficulty for us.

We will do more for housing, but I do not want what we do to serve to maintain high prices. I want to tell developers, you have your problems and I respect them; yours is a very difficult profession. Construction has its problems, and I respect that, but parliamentarians and the government also have our problems. What we want is for prices to drop so that things can start moving again. That is the market economy. We must not forget that. And I do not want everything we put in, and that is why I fully support the operation carried out here in Meaux, and that we are launching on 30,000 homes, and we are ready to go further. I also support it because it triggers a price drop of around 20%. But when you find a client so easily, marketing costs also help facilitate the buyer.

So the price drop is justified.

The state will take its responsibilities. And we will support the drop in land prices - which is absolutely necessary - by releasing public land: 70,000 homes to be built by 2012. So I understand that we have often talked about it and have not often done it, but not me. But for as long as I have been in politics, a few years, I always hear that the state will release land. But we have made very strong decisions, particularly regarding military land, since you know, as Chief of the Armed Forces, I made the decision to restructure the military map. And I do not want us to find ourselves in what we have known for so long, where mayors find themselves 15 years after their garrison has left with land that is still fallow because the state has not released it. And so we are engaging in a true cultural revolution.

I have asked that for the released land, Mr. Mayor of Provins, particularly in city centers, the state gives it to you for free. I simply ask for a clause of return to better fortune. And that the state does not impose any conditions on what you will do with this land. It is up to you, the elected officials, to decide with the population. You want offices, you want social housing, you want homes, that is your problem. And it is not up to the state, and it is not up to the administration to add problems for you. But if you build offices, you will earn more money. So it is normal that the state, which has given you land, has a return clause. If you build social housing, you will earn less money. We will have a less strong return clause. But you see the considerable change we are making. In Moselle, we will eliminate 7,000 military jobs, we will release land in Metz. But this can be good news for the city of Metz. Because the future of Metz is not to remain just a garrison town, and this creates land for you. But I do not want the state to prevent you from doing things; I want it to encourage you to do them. So you see the cultural revolution we are putting in place. I do not want any wasteland, and I want things to move.

We will support your sector by investing in sustainable and environmental development.

All new constructions will have to meet the so-called "low consumption" standards before 2020. There is a gigantic source of growth here so that people live in homes that do not cost a fortune because they leak from all sides.

I will announce on December 4 a very powerful support plan for economic activity. And within it, we will include measures for the environment. But already, starting January 1, 2009, there will be a zero-interest loan and a tax credit on mortgage interest for all buildings meeting low consumption standards. In truth, I would like us to provide work for companies to create energy-efficient buildings. This generates growth, creates jobs, and you recover on lower rents because there will be fewer charges, the investment we have made.

The major issue lies in the 30 million old homes in which family budgets are evaporating through windows, walls, and roofs. Because the drop in oil and gas prices, we see where we stand. Although today, we were at $53 a barrel of Brent; when I was Minister of Finance in 2004, it was at $42. And in any case, we have an interest in investing in energy efficiency, and the state will benefit individuals starting in 2009 with a new zero-interest eco-loan; we will be able to borrow up to 30,000 euros without paying interest to finance insulation and renovation work. France needs work; it is investment, so we are offering a zero-interest loan of 30,000 euros to renovate and insulate your apartment or house; it is a "win-win" situation; it is not money thrown out the window because naturally, this money, this 30,000 euros in a zero-interest loan will save you on your charges, so you will find it worthwhile, and it provides work for construction.

For the measures to be effective, we need to concentrate our resources, and that is why I also wanted the reform of the 1% housing that we negotiated with social partners and that Parliament is currently adopting.

But I no longer want to hear that the funds allocated to housing are decreasing. Listen, the public effort dedicated to housing is increasing. We spent 28 billion euros in 2000; we will spend 35.5 billion euros in 2009. I see that some are giving me lessons on what to do; we wonder why they did not do it before. On the side of the councils, prices are falling because given the number of councils on this side, I am not bothered. We wonder, all these people who have so many good ideas, but why did you not do it? 28 billion euros in 2000, 35.5 billion euros in 2009, and we will increase our effort by 6.3% between 2008 and 2009. In a context where public finances are under severe strain, this is something extremely important.

Everyone must play the game. I do not accept, and I say this as I think, that banks double the capital requirements to grant credit to a developer-builder, but where does that come from again? There is a crisis: OK, it was not necessary to lend indiscriminately to anyone yesterday to stop lending today. What is the justification for doubling the capital requirement for developers who want to launch a program between what was happening in July and what is happening in November? The result is that if I let things go with the same capital, we will have half as many homes, whereas we need half more. This is unacceptable, and when, in addition to the rise in interest rates, banks decide to reduce households' access to mortgage credit, when they select households eligible for mortgage credit based on their employment contracts, it is the access to housing for our fellow citizens that becomes more difficult.

I cannot accept that. It is to prevent modest households from being completely excluded from access to mortgage credit that I have decided to extend the guarantee that the State provides through what we call Christine the social homeownership loans, and since November 1, 60% of households taking out a loan are eligible for this guarantee, compared to 20% before. Why do we put the State guarantee, Christian? For a very simple reason. Since people, banks are asking for more guarantees, we will put the State guarantee at the service of individuals. Since banks hesitate to do their job, we will do it. There were 20% of households with the State guarantee; there will be 60% of households who will have it and who can rely on this State guarantee since the State's signature is credible, let us put it at the service of French households.

That is why we are doing all this. We are monitoring things very closely. René RICOL, our Credit Mediator, is doing an excellent job, and I have asked him to publicly state the cases that have shocked him and to name the credit institutions that would have a shocking attitude. There comes a time when everyone must take their responsibilities. I have taken mine to save the banks; the banks must take theirs to avoid the economic crisis, a win-win situation.

I remember the debate, and I say this to my parliamentary friends, that we had in 2007 when I had the idea - it is true, an original one - to keep one of my campaign promises, a very original idea since generally, the norm is to forget the promises made before the election the day after the election, and I had promised that we would return to the possibility of deducting these loan interests when purchasing a primary residence. I remain convinced that there is no reason to pay taxes on the remuneration we give to our bank in exchange for the money it lends us. Remember, Jean-François, how hard we had to fight to pass this measure since a number of people, including some of my own friends, said: "Why support real estate? It is doing very well; there is no need." All those who were so talkative a year ago, I wonder why they are silent today. The famous TEPA law, which has been so criticized, and if there is anyone today who would like to tell me that the government should go back on the deduction of interest for the acquisition of a residence.

Homeownership is the dream of every family; everything must be done to promote this dream. I say this while taking my responsibilities. I do not see on what grounds social homeownership would be excluded from a social policy. The social aspect is not just that the most modest can be tenants; the social aspect is also that the most modest can be homeowners, like those families I met this morning. I do not see why homeownership should be reserved only for those with high incomes. I do not see on what grounds we should not consider as social policy the possibility given to a tenant of a social housing unit to become the owner of that social housing unit. Or else, one must have the courage to say: "Listen, you are poor, so you will not be a homeowner." I do not accept that. And perhaps even the most modest families are those who could be stabilized in life and have the greatest need to be homeowners. It is frankly a strange idea to feel complexed and to ask that social homeownership be excluded from a calculation for social diversity.

Moreover, diversity is less social depending on whether one is a homeowner or a tenant. What a strange idea? Social diversity is a very good objective. But are we less diverse when the mixed person is a homeowner? I am sorry; on the contrary, the fact that they are a homeowner stabilizes them in the neighborhood where we wanted to introduce social diversity.

Therefore, I want us to continue this. We will extend the Pass-Foncier to the purchase of an apartment and increase the number of beneficiaries to 30,000.

I add that I fully support the measures taken by Christine BOUTIN to prevent people from remaining for life in social housing. The problem is not to cover France with social housing; the problem is to build social housing and that the people in social housing are those who need it.

The measures we have taken aim to put an end to something that was unacceptable.

For twenty years, while the number of social housing units has significantly increased, the waiting list for social housing has continued to grow because we have extended the benefit of social housing to two out of three French people. By planning that social housing is for everyone, those who need it do not have access, and those who do not need it are condemned to stay there because they cannot become homeowners in the free market.

For social housing to play its role of social integration again, I wanted the income ceilings granting the right to social housing to return to the level they were at in 1997 when 55% of the population was eligible.

When a tenant's income becomes twice the income ceiling, the rental contract will be reclassified as a non-renewable three-year contract. Listen, we must be in a country where there are rules and that these rules are respected. A limit has been set, but starting January 1, 2009, we will apply the rule for entering social housing; we need rules: a ratio between income and rent. If these incomes exceed the ceilings, well, social housing is no longer for you; we give you three years to find your way. At that point, you leave your apartment for someone who needs it.

I add that in the case of under-occupation of a housing unit that has become too large, the tenant will be offered three relocation options in social housing at the same rent. If they refuse, they will lose, after notice, the right to occupy this too-large housing unit. Listen, there are so many people on the waiting list with children; we cannot accept that a single person is in a three-bedroom apartment. It is a very simple question; it is not a question of left or right; it is a question of common sense. And I also say to the developers, these people who have incomes must go into the free market with a solvent clientele. That will be very good for you. At the same time, it will free up housing for people who cannot go into the free market because they do not have the income. Can we, in our country, establish rules that we respect? We love to adopt rules that we do not respect.

I find these measures excellent, and I will, of course, follow their implementation starting January 1, 2009.

I will announce on December 4; I will not do it today, Jean-François, because I will do it within the broader framework of the recovery. I deeply believe that we need a recovery because after the financial crisis, we are in the economic crisis. I am told: "We must wait." Wait for what? Wait until we are certain we are in the crisis? We are there. Wait until there are more unemployed? We are there. Wait until people are a little more desperate? No. What seems to me to be the success of the European and French plan in the face of the financial crisis is that we acted beforehand. Wait until companies close or go bankrupt? I do not accept that. I believe we need to add more, and we will have measures in the coming days for housing. We are working to take the right ones, and it is not that simple. Once we have said we need to relaunch, we must try to be as effective as possible and ensure that every public euro is an euro that serves a purpose.

I also think we need to reassure homeowners and tenants when there are bad faith tenants; we should not defend them, and we must ensure that ownership is not stigmatized because one is a homeowner and that if some want to rent their property, they should be encouraged to do so and not have all the troubles in the world.

On this matter, independently of all these projects, there is the very difficult question of extreme poverty. We have made a considerable effort for emergency shelter places. We will have nearly 100,000 by the end of the year, a level never reached. Never.

We cannot let people die of cold in 2008 on the outskirts of Paris.

It is an extremely delicate matter, and we must take our responsibilities. We must create shelter places. It is done. We must act so that no one dies of cold in 2008 in one of the richest countries in the world. It is a scandal!

So, how can we do this while respecting the absolute principle of freedom? Because emergency shelter is not prison; it is free will. I believe we can reconcile the two. The Prime Minister was absolutely right to say that we cannot force someone to stay in an emergency shelter if they do not want to. He was absolutely right. The shelter is not prison; if they want to leave, they leave. The only question I ask is whether a man or a woman, in the middle of the night, in the Bois de Vincennes, perhaps sick, having drunk, living in terrible conditions for weeks, do they have the lucidity to know whether they want to or do not want to? This person is hungry; this person has not had a shower; this person is cold; this person is sick; this person is often injured; should the State consider that because someone in abominable conditions, under a small tent, at -10°, says: "I do not want to come," is this person lucid enough to decide their life or death? I ask the question. For me, they are not lucid.

What I propose is that this person be given food, a good hot meal, we offer to treat them, we allow them to take a shower or a bath, we show them the room or bed we are offering them; if they do not want it, they leave, they return to the street. It is about respecting the dignity of the person, respecting the autonomy of the person, respecting freedom; they leave. I think it is a risk, in some cases, to let someone die at their own discretion.

I say this; I think there is a common-sense balance to be found between the extremists of freedom and the extremists of forced placement in emergency centers. There are times when these people are afraid to go there, do not want to leave their animal, their dog, their only companion, all the emotional reserve they have. Then, there are those who tell me: "We must collect them forcibly." No. They are human beings. We must respect people. There are those who tell me: "We must let them, even die; it is freedom." No. When someone jumps off a bridge into the Seine or the Marne, and someone is on the edge and can save them, they will not say: "I will not dive because they did not want me to go save them!" That is called failing to assist a person in danger.

I therefore think there is a balance: to put people in a position to decide after having cared for them, fed them, allowed them to wash, and at that moment, they can leave quietly.

I wish for the minister and the Prime Minister to meet with the associations to see if we can imagine a middle solution that would prevent waking up in the morning with shame in our hearts upon hearing that a poor man has died because it is cold.

I propose that no one make it an ideological problem. Let us try to be pragmatic and have as our only ambition to save lives. It seems to me that with this formula, we reconcile everyone. We stop the scandal of people dying outside in the cold, and at the same time, we respect autonomy and freedom. I truly hope that we do not make it a problem of preconceived notions.

Ladies and gentlemen,

I am fully aware, and I would like to conclude with this, that housing is not simply an economic issue. What is more reassuring for a family than to be a homeowner? What is a more beautiful ambition than to say, like those families I met in your city, dear Jean-François, with the children who explained to me what color their room was? That is the ambition that must be ours, Christine, to enable access to homeownership. To place in social housing those who truly need it and in emergency housing those who truly need it.

Look at the history, it is very simple. It is too expensive, so those who could move out of social housing to buy in the open market remain in social housing, and since they remain in social housing, there is no space. Therefore, those who should have a place in social housing find themselves in emergency housing. In emergency housing, there is no space either between those who cannot enter social housing and those who are in an irregular immigration situation, which means that extreme poverty ends up in the Bois de Vincennes or elsewhere.

It is this system that I would like us to put an end to.

I have spoken very freely before you because I am fully aware that this is a major political objective and the government as well as the majority are expected to deliver results.

Ladies and gentlemen,

Thank you for your attention.