Statement by Mr. Nicolas Sarkozy, President of the Republic, on international access to civil nuclear power, in Paris on March 8, 2010.

France Nicolas Sarkozy · President of France

8 March 2010 · Statement on international access to civil nuclear power · Paris, France

Context
Sarkozy addressed an international forum in Paris on March 8, 2010, advocating for global access to civil nuclear energy in cooperation with the IAEA and OECD.
Main themes
Civil nuclear energy, international access to nuclear power, climate change and energy needs, nuclear safety and security, France's nuclear program, global energy demand, renewable energy, nuclear renaissance, ITER fusion project, international cooperation, degrowth ideology critique, north-south equity in energy
Duration
~23 min
72nd percentile
Words
2,768
72nd percentile
Sentences
166
84th percentile
Readability
47
55th percentile
Grade
10.7
29th percentile
Syntax
2.75
17th percentile
Vocabulary
2.19
46th percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Geopolitical 24%23%
  • Economic 19%19%
  • Technological 16%16%
  • Environmental 15%14%
  • Institutional 13%13%
  • Ceremonial 8%8%
  • Social 4%4%
  • Not in focus 3%

166 sentences in 47 paragraphs

Mr. Secretary-General of the OECD and dear friend,

Mr. Director General of the IAEA,

I want to reiterate how much France appreciates the clarity of your initial statements. It was about time. We need an honest man, a courageous man. Rest assured that we will support your actions.

Mr. President of the European Commission, with whom I take such pleasure in working day after day,

Ladies and gentlemen ministers, dear Jean-Louis BORLOO, dear Bernard KOUCHNER, dear Christine LAGARDE,

It is commonly said today that we have entered a new nuclear era, which you referred to as its "Renaissance."

The analogy with that glorious period of European history will undoubtedly spark many debates. But there are common elements with the Renaissance: the questioning of old ways of thinking, the challenge to irrational fears, faith in science, faith in technology, which were the hallmarks of the Renaissance.

It is up to us to ensure that this rediscovery of nuclear energy becomes an opportunity for progress and cooperation for humanity.

The history of nuclear energy is intimately intertwined with that of contemporary France; in 1896, Henri BECQUEREL discovered radioactivity. In the 1970s, France made a historic choice: the creation of a complete industrial sector for the massive production of nuclear electricity.

And across all governments, both left and right, this choice in favor of civil nuclear energy has been consistently reaffirmed. France has 58 reactors. France is committed with the two EPRs it is building in the third generation. France will have 60 nuclear reactors. France continues its research efforts. France wants to cooperate with all countries that wish to pursue civil nuclear energy.

France, along with seven major partners representing about 34 states, has launched the grand ITER project for fusion research, the construction of which will begin in June.

This prior experience does not give France any special privilege. But this prior experience imposes on France a duty: to share its experience with all those who wish to access or revive civil nuclear programs. It is clear, it is our policy, it is our will.

I have proposed to convene the ministers responsible for Energy, in cooperation with the IAEA and the OECD. I hope this forum will allow everyone to benefit from the perspectives of others.

Ladies and gentlemen, my dear friends,

The world population is growing and becoming wealthier. We will need 40% more energy by 2030. I say this to all ideologues, outside this room: we will need to find 40% more energy by 2030. The solution is not in the ideologies of degrowth or retreat. The ideologies of degrowth are selfish ideologies that want to keep the poor in poverty. That is what degrowth is: closing the door to progress and better living for those who have nothing.

The priority - I speak under the authority of Jean-Louis BORLOO, whose actions I want to commend in this regard - is the fight against climate change. My predecessor said, "The house is on fire." Everything must therefore be done to save the house, to save the planet, to meet our goals in the fight against global warming. We need nuclear energy. There is not a single serious person who can think that we can meet our goals with renewable energies alone. But we, France, do not say: "We need only nuclear." We say: "We need civil nuclear energy and we need renewable energies." We need both to protect the planet, to meet our commitments in the fight against global warming.

I add that 80% of the growth in electricity consumption by 2030 will come from non-OECD countries. Therefore, nuclear energy must be established in new countries, or these new countries will not achieve economic progress and will not escape poverty. So, let it be clear, France's vision is of a world that should not be divided between countries possessing nuclear technology, clinging to a privilege, and peoples demanding a right to nuclear competence that others would deny them. We do not want that vision. Civil nuclear energy can be, in France's eyes, the cement of a new international solidarity, where everyone will need each other to move forward.

The role of states will be absolutely crucial because to move towards nuclear energy, there must be a strong scientific commitment, as generations of technicians and engineers need to be trained.

There must be a strong financial commitment, because investment, modernization, and then decommissioning must be planned.

There must be a commitment to safety and security, as we are responsible to our peoples for safety and security.

Some will say that certain countries are not capable of this. I believe that behind this type of prejudice lies an intolerable contempt for others: there have been nuclear accidents in "northern" countries. The North has no lessons to give to the South. My conviction is the opposite; as long as our states work together over the long term, with a shared vision, safety and security will be an objective that we can all meet.

I wish to address the points that seem essential to me for a successful renaissance of nuclear energy.

1/ First, and allow me to be blunt, there is the question of financing: I do not understand and I do not accept the ostracism of nuclear energy in international financing. There is a scandal here. International financial institutions do not currently finance civil nuclear projects. The current situation effectively condemns countries to more expensive and more polluting energy. What a great result! I propose to change this, demanding that the World Bank, the EBRD, and development banks resolutely commit to financing clean civil nuclear energy.

There is another scandal: the issues surrounding the allocation of carbon credits through the Clean Development Mechanism. For ideological reasons from another time, a country that commits to civil nuclear energy cannot benefit from carbon credits. Meanwhile, credits fund all other decarbonized energies! Yet, civil nuclear energy is perfectly decarbonized. What is the logic of this position? None. But what are the consequences of this situation? More expensive, scarcer "carbon" credits, and a biased orientation of investment choices that primarily harms the poorest countries. I therefore propose and call on all countries that share this position to join us, so that all decarbonized energies can be financed by CO2 credits in the new global architecture after 2013. Do we want to be on track to meet the goals of reducing greenhouse gas emissions from carbon-based energy? To be on track, we need both nuclear and renewable energy.

2/ My second recommendation is that we take care to closely involve our populations in the projects. The time when one could impose a nuclear installation - as indeed, in my opinion, any sensitive industrial installation, such as in chemistry or oil - on a population, disregarding its concerns, is in the past. From secrecy arises anxiety. Our projects must be transparent, and to all countries wishing to engage in civil nuclear energy, France says: "The best guarantee of success in convincing your populations is transparency." There can be no development of civil nuclear energy without a commitment to transparency.

3/ My third proposal will be to prioritize training. It is not just about training engineers and technicians to operate in the plants, although that is at the heart of the matter. It is about mastering the scientific and economic aspects; I think of construction, project management, and electricity marketing. We are in a state of assumed interdependence. Our collective interest is that the development of nuclear energy is carried out by men and women with solid training.

In France, international openness is now established. Since 2007, we have tripled the number of students in nuclear energy. There is a massive problem, my dear friends, in training our elites. We are all lacking engineers and technicians in the sector worldwide. We have tripled the number of our students in France. This year, the international master's program in France will welcome students from around the world: from Jordan, Poland, the United Arab Emirates, Argentina, China, India, Vietnam, Tunisia, and Algeria. We want to share our expertise with you. There is work for everyone. In 2009, the French Atomic Energy Commission - now also the Commission for Alternative Energies - welcomed 1,000 foreign doctoral and post-doctoral students, 14% of whom are from the Maghreb.

That is good. But we want to go even further, and we will accelerate by creating an International Nuclear Energy Institute that will house an International School of Nuclear Energy. It will bring together the best teachers and researchers to offer very high-quality training, in Saclay, where we will create the largest campus in Europe, and in Cadarache. This Institute will be an integral part of an international network of specialized Centers of Excellence currently being established. We will set up a first center in Jordan. Other training centers for nuclear energy, with the support of France, will develop, such as the Franco-Chinese Institute of Nuclear Energy, which we are creating in cooperation with the University of Canton. Ultimately, my hope is to see the formation of a vast scientific network that will unite international efforts. I add that I have asked Bernard KOUCHNER to open a large number of scholarships for foreign students in nuclear energy. You understand well, we all need to train generations of engineers and technicians. It is not a single country that will achieve this, but the country that was first in civil nuclear energy is ready to share its skills, expertise, and experience with you.

4/ My fourth proposal is to make safety a collective priority. Let’s be clear, nuclear energy is not trivial. Even if all human activities have their risks: think of the disasters and the thousands of victims caused by oil, coal, chemistry, gas! Nuclear safety is not a national issue; it is a collective concern, Mr. Director General.

Thanks to constant vigilance, there has never been a significant nuclear accident in Western Europe. Conversely, let us think of the global trauma caused by the accidents at Chernobyl and in the United States.

It is necessary to entrust supervision to an independent Safety Authority. I am not an advocate of blindly applying the precautionary principle, which most often leads to doing nothing. But in the face of real risks, strict standards must be applied.

In Europe, dear José Manuel BARROSO, we still have progress to make. It was in June 2009 that we adopted - I will say finally! It is our fault - a directive on nuclear safety. European regulators will hold a conference in Brussels in 2011 to strengthen their cooperation. And a project for a European training institute for safety is on the table. It could become the first of a network of international nuclear safety experts.

Each country will have to make its choices. But to inform future decisions, I wish for an independent body, under the auspices of the IAEA, to establish an international analysis framework based on indisputable scientific and technical grounds. I ask, Mr. Director, that you classify the reactors proposed on the market according to safety criteria. Because today, the market only classifies according to price. Let the IAEA take responsibility for saying: here are the different reactors on the market, here is the classification based on safety.

Next month, in Washington, several dozen countries are invited by President OBAMA to discuss nuclear security. The UN Security Council has already stated mandatory principles; I think of Resolution 1540. The more nuclear facilities there are in the world, the stricter implementation of the Security Council's decisions will be necessary.

5/ The fifth priority is respect for non-proliferation. Non-proliferation is a cornerstone of international security. No one has an interest in a new arms race. And no one wants to have a state that cheats in their neighborhood. I want to reiterate how the voluntary decisions made by Libya in 2003 have, in this regard, a historic character. I do not share, far from it, all the orientations and statements of Libya. But that Libya voluntarily renounced nuclear weapons in 2003 is something we would like to see other countries do today. I see observers being very harsh with some, forgetting what they have done, and not harsh enough with others, refusing to look at what they are doing.

We cannot, on one hand — and this is the proposal that France is putting on the table — ask for civil nuclear cooperation, with the long-term partnership and responsibility that this implies, and on the other hand, deny our international obligations. I therefore propose that we suspend our nuclear cooperation with countries that do not respect their obligations. The European Union has already decided this, the G8 has already proposed it. My conception of law and justice is not that those who cheat should have the same rights as those who are honest. France will be uncompromising in defending the right of each state to access nuclear energy for peaceful purposes. But France will be uncompromising against those who violate collective security norms. If we respect international law, we have the right to cooperation for access to civil nuclear energy; if we violate it, we have no right to any collaboration.

6/ Lastly, the access to nuclear fuel. Given the scale of investments and the duration of projects, some, rightly, are concerned about the risks of supply interruptions. The security of fuel supply is currently ensured through long-term agreements. I believe we need to go further and establish supply assurances within the framework of the IAEA, Mr. Director. This is a collective commitment: in the event of a supply disruption, other suppliers will provide solutions. And to lend credibility to this commitment, I propose the creation of a Fuel Bank at the IAEA, funded by international contributions. The project is ready, the funding has existed since the European Union, under the French presidency, with the agreement of Mr. Barroso, decided to provide 25 million Euros to finalize it.

If the number of reactors expands significantly, the question of constructing new enrichment and reprocessing/recycling units, responding to industrial needs, may arise. Some wanted, a few years ago, to prohibit new countries from accessing these capabilities, on the grounds that they would be dangerous in themselves. France rejects such an approach, which would be economically absurd and would infringe upon the legitimate right to develop energy for peaceful purposes.

It is urgent to conclude a Treaty banning the production of fissile materials for nuclear weapons and to equip the IAEA with enhanced verification means for sensitive technologies.

7/ To conclude, I would like to address the issue of the management of spent fuel and ultimate waste. In the face of the accumulation of spent nuclear fuel, some practice long-term storage as is — this is the choice of the United States, Sweden, and Finland.

Others bet on the valorization of this resource through recycling. This is the choice of France, Russia, and Japan. This recycling allows for maximum valorization of the uranium resource while minimizing the ultimate waste to be stored. It seems to me that this is the most promising path for the future. That is why France wants to continue cooperating with many countries by making its reprocessing/recycling facilities available to all those who do not have them.

Ladies and Gentlemen,

You understand, the responsible development of nuclear energy is a fundamental issue for the future of the planet.

We must work together towards a new governance of nuclear energy that will rely on a strengthened IAEA, and we count on Mr. Amano for this and to define the assertion of a collective vision.

I hope that your work, led by Jean-Louis Borloo, will help establish its foundations. Ladies and Gentlemen, we do not have to tell the world to choose between progress and security, between poverty or respect for the environment. We have, thanks to the researchers of the 20th century, a tremendous energy; let us share it as best as possible, use it as best as possible for environmental purposes, for peaceful purposes, to help your countries emerge from poverty, to assist in the transition with the planned end of fossil fuels, all in perfect complementarity with the development of renewable energies.

This is France's commitment. France does not do this to give a lesson, France does not do this to stand out, not even to set an example. France does this because it is convinced that the sharing of civil nuclear energy for peaceful purposes is a decisive element for respecting environmental concerns and for a better distribution of wealth on the planet.

Thank you.