Statement by Mr. Nicolas Sarkozy, President of the Republic, on the fight against deforestation and climate change, in Paris on March 11, 2010.

France Nicolas Sarkozy · President of France

11 March 2010 · Paris Conference on the fight against deforestation · Paris, France

Context
Sarkozy addressed international delegates at a Paris Conference on March 11, 2010, to advance post-Copenhagen commitments on deforestation and climate finance.
Main themes
Deforestation, climate change, Copenhagen Agreement implementation, forest basin protection, international coalition, greenhouse gas emissions, biodiversity, sustainable growth, IPCC, fast-start climate finance, global warming, multilateral cooperation
Duration
~28 min
80th percentile
Words
3,365
80th percentile
Sentences
190
88th percentile
Readability
60
87th percentile
Grade
9.2
13th percentile
Syntax
2.83
25th percentile
Vocabulary
2.10
27th percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Environmental 34%30%
  • Institutional 25%22%
  • Geopolitical 16%14%
  • Economic 15%13%
  • Ceremonial 8%7%
  • Social 2%2%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Not in focus 12%

190 sentences in 41 paragraphs

Ladies and gentlemen ministers,

Mr. Minister of State dear Jean-Louis,

Mr. Minister of Foreign Affairs and European Affairs dear Bernard,

Ladies and gentlemen delegates,

In the wake of the Copenhagen Summit, the Norwegian Prime Minister and I proposed to move forward concretely and quickly in the fight against deforestation. The Paris Conference will, I hope, lead to specific decisions in the coming months, during a second meeting scheduled to take place in Oslo.

I thank the delegations from the major forest basins - those from the Amazon, the Congo Basin, Indonesia, Papua New Guinea, Malaysia, and also Russia - for responding to the invitation extended by Jean-Louis Borloo and Bernard Kouchner. I also thank all the other countries that wished to participate in our coalition, because we are a true coalition, a coalition of goodwill in service of this common good of humanity that is the forests.

I propose that this coalition defend the forests, mobilize for the forest, and demand funding for the forest.

Ladies and gentlemen,

I returned from Copenhagen more determined than ever to advance the fight against climate change. The Copenhagen Summit was frustrating, it was difficult, and yet it marked an essential turning point if we follow up on it.

The unprecedented mobilization that brought 130 heads of state to the event reflected, thanks to the IPCC, a general awareness of the issue: it is simply the survival of humanity and the planet that is at stake. And we will not give up on this objective because Copenhagen was an example of poor organization. I take my responsibilities; we must not confuse form and substance.

The analyses of the IPCC have had a catalytic effect, bringing together scattered information on the state of our planet and its worrying evolution. The debate on risk assessment, on the factors responsible for climate change, on the extent of its consequences, all these scientific debates are legitimate and must continue. The criticisms that have been leveled at some work of this formidable global network of scientists should not overshadow the essential: global warming is a reality. If there are disputes over methods, that is good; that is how science advances. We will not move to a single thought, to an analysis that no one could contest. But the objective is indeed that one. The IPCC therefore deserves our recognition and merits our support.

Once we have heard the scientists, what should political leaders do? I have tried to assume my responsibilities on behalf of France, with Jean-Louis Borloo and Bernard Kouchner. And to those who doubt, often in good faith, I would like to pose a simple question: does humanity have the choice to continue on the path of growth that would destroy biodiversity, that would destroy natural resources and fossil energies? Or should the coalition we represent not steer this mad rush towards the abyss by inventing a new truly sustainable growth that does not contribute to climate change?

I have not been the only one, of course, to make this choice and to assume my responsibilities in Copenhagen: the Copenhagen political agreement is now officially endorsed by 100 countries. This agreement sets for the first time a common level of ambition, where we limit global warming to a maximum of 2°C, we halve global greenhouse gas emissions by 2050. The agreement organizes cooperation among our nations around 10 specific commitments to reduce greenhouse gas emissions and assist the territories and populations most exposed to climate risk.

Much remains to be done, but we must absolutely resume work after Copenhagen. The tragedy of Copenhagen or its poor organization is that the work stops. We do not have the right to do that.

So our meeting today raises great hopes, dear Jean-Louis, dear Bernard, it is the first to address the modalities for implementing the Copenhagen Agreement. We did not gather in Copenhagen to give birth to an agreement, which we would have wished to be more significant, but to not implement the agreement we signed and which is now ratified by 100 countries; there are indeed many more than for the Kyoto Protocol.

France has fought for the protection of forests to be a priority for the entire international community. I was in Manaus last November, in the middle of the Amazon rainforest, to first express my friendship to President Lula and the importance that France attaches to the development of major forest basins.

I received in Paris in December the heads of state from the Congo Basin countries, as well as the Indonesian President, to tell them that France was by their side.

In Copenhagen, it was France that proposed that 20% of the 10 billion dollars that will be spent each year over the three years, 2010, 2011, 2012, under the "fast-start," be dedicated to forest basins. I will reiterate my conviction that countries with major forest basins on their territory cannot maintain this heritage of humanity alone. Their sovereignty is total, of course, but I want to say that they do not have the financial means to maintain it alone, while these forest basins serve all of humanity. It is all countries that must contribute to the financing. Our goal is to reduce deforestation by 25% by 2015, by 50% by 2020, and simply to end deforestation by 2030.

2009 marked significant progress in the "REDD+" agenda, which is the very subject of our conference. I would like to pay tribute to the considerable effort decided by Brazil, and thank the Brazilian Minister, Mr. Minc, who is among us. The actions announced by Indonesia, represented here by Minister Hasan and the President's Council Witoelar, also carry all our hopes. And of course, the efforts of the Congo Basin countries are crucial to achieving our overall goal.

In Copenhagen, 6 countries, including France and Norway, announced a commitment of 3.5 billion dollars over 3 years for "REDD+" programs in developing countries. I hope that our meeting will be an opportunity to confirm and expand this commitment, to organize effective coordination of this aid on the ground, and in addition to bring the private sector to take its full part in the established cooperation. It is not just about the public; the private sector must also be involved.

Your work should allow us to build, in a climate of trust, the mechanism we need to protect the forests and ensure the employment of the populations living there. A mechanism prioritizing transparency and results, so that funding rewards the efforts made. France has thus just offered Central African countries access to SPOT satellite images for a period of 5 years, and if you are interested, we are naturally ready to continue, so you can monitor the evolution of forest cover yourself. France is at the disposal of the countries of other major forest basins to help them build their national or regional capacities.

Naturally, the fight against deforestation, the protection of forests, and climate change should not overshadow the fight for development. One cannot go without the other. Protecting forested areas means that arable land cannot be expanded at their expense. We must therefore implement agricultural productivity improvement programs to meet the food needs of rapidly growing populations. We will not come to explain to you, while you have a population that is sometimes so poor, that we must choose between forest protection and misery for the populations of the forests or surrounding areas. That would be not only absurd but shocking. I wish for a study to evaluate the impacts, both positive and negative, of the "REDD+" agenda on food security, in order to establish best practices to reconcile the fight against poverty and the fight against deforestation.

A final word on forests. 2010 is the year of biodiversity. Forest basins are an essential reservoir of biodiversity, and they must therefore be the subject of appropriate measures. France calls for the creation of an intergovernmental platform of experts, in a way a "IPCC of biodiversity." Let us decide to create it at the United Nations Conference in Nagoya next October!

Ladies and gentlemen,

Through your work, you will show that the mobilization against climate change is not weakening. By concretely implementing a major point of the Copenhagen Agreement, you will restore confidence to global opinion. And from this first success, the entire negotiation will restart. The negotiation must restart under the auspices of the United Nations. France is committed to this framework of work, which must not be called into question. But I set a condition: that the results are there. Because the working method that consists of only advancing if the entirety, the unanimity of countries agrees is a method that leads to absolute failure.

2010 must be the year of decisive progress in two directions:

First, let us agree on the concrete advances achievable this year for each of the provisions of Copenhagen. I am of course thinking of financing actions in developing countries. We must establish a real investment plan of 30 billion dollars over 3 years, prioritizing actions with rapid impact. France, I tell you, will spare no effort to ensure that the promised funds are available. We can no longer hold conferences, promise funds, and not disburse; it is a matter of trust between us. It would make no sense; it would be profoundly shocking.

Secondly, beyond 2012, we have planned 100 billion dollars per year by 2020, of which 20% for forest countries. Only innovative financing will allow us to meet this challenge. France, through Bernard Kouchner, has been advocating this idea from the beginning. If there is no innovative financing, there is no money. That is my conviction. Others may not share it, but I will fight for it. In Copenhagen, we agreed on the principle of innovative financing and on the envelope, 100 billion dollars in 2020. France will therefore support Ethiopian Prime Minister Meles Zenawi in the mission entrusted to him, alongside Gordon Brown, by the United Nations Secretary-General. And we will take, with others, initiatives at the G20 - G20 that France will preside over in November 2011 - to adopt a tax on financial transactions. It is a matter of credibility for each of us. It is simply a matter of credibility.

And I ask the countries of Latin America, Africa, and Asia to understand that the divide is not a North-South divide; it is a divide between countries that want to act and have results and those that want to wait and let the storm pass. I say this to my African friends; we must break out of the usual organization, the poor on one side, the rich on the other, no! That strategy is a losing one. Let us put together all the countries that want to build a better future for the planet, whether they are from the North or the South, whether they are poor or rich, let us break the clichés; we need each other, and let us show all those who, behind beautiful words, want to do nothing because those who want to do nothing are those who do not want to pay. And if the money is not there, those who will pay the consequences of this absence will be the poorest, especially in Africa. I believe that each of us must look at the geopolitical map without being mistaken, and if a number of countries had not been there, including France, in Copenhagen, there would be no "fast-start," there would not be - I have a very good memory of the fight that had to be waged to get it - there would be no innovative financing, and there would not be the prospects of 100 billion dollars in 2020.

Now, we are ready to fight with other countries, but it is up to you, friends in Africa, friends in Asia, friends in Latin America, to make the choice: to which coalition do you want to belong? The one of progress or the one of immobility? Because if you do not help us, we will not succeed. The mountains to move, to evolve to make it understood that a tax on financial movements is not a drama, are so great that if France, with a few others at the G20, does not succeed, it will not happen. If we have Africa behind us, if we have part of Asia behind us, if we have Latin America behind us, then we will succeed. It is a choice.

I know the groups, the sub-groups, and I know even better the difficulty of recovering from one's sub-group. France is in Europe, it knows well. I am very European, but I will not be stopped because there is a small part of European countries that does not want to move forward. I know well, I say to the minister?, the G5 group, but within the G5 group, there are those who really want to move forward and those who do not want to move forward. I will not name names because everyone knows them. What do we do? Do we work hand in hand as Mr. Lula and I proposed? For me, that is my choice. You see alliances that would go from Ethiopia to Brazil, passing through France and many others - I mention Ethiopia because it was tasked with speaking on behalf of Africa - you see the power that this represents. I do not ask anyone to give up their neighbors, their friends, their habits. I simply ask you to understand that in 2010, the world is at a decisive moment, do we move or do we not move? France wants to move, and you will be, you, especially you Africans, you forest countries, the first to benefit from it. Even, be a little more demanding and ask all those who make declarations of love to you what they are willing to do. That was not in the speech. Let's say it was said but in a less strong way. There you go, that is what I think. I have completely lost the thread of my speech. It does not matter, in the end, I summarized it. There are all the details around it.

Since I am here, I will continue to massacre my own speech. I will say a word about the UN, because we can no longer now evade the problems and the real questions, it is no longer possible. The UN is absolutely essential and at the same time, it does not work. I am ready to debate with anyone who wants to about this reality. Why is the UN essential? Because the G192 is better than the G20, which is better than the G8, and the G8 is better than the G2. Mind you, in any case, the G2, there was no risk.

So, France is in favor of the framework being that of the UN. There is no doubt about that, we do not want to leave any country behind. Let me be clear, the smallest country, the poorest, its voice counts, just like the largest and the richest. So there is no doubt about that. First of all, there is no alternative strategy. I wish - I told the Secretary-General - if the G1929 does not want to be contested by the other "Gs", it must take more initiatives. Nature abhors a vacuum. If we created the G20, it is because on the G192 side, it is a bit heavy. But the working methods must change. I want to explain this in two minutes as I conclude before you.

Of course, the process of the United Nations is unanimity, it is the General Assembly. I do not contest that. But we must make a distinction between the moment when we vote on a finalized text and the moment when we prepare it. We cannot continue the fiction that 192 countries and their representatives can negotiate a text. It is crazy, we will never succeed. Or else, we will find ourselves every time as we did in Copenhagen, with a text that resembled a volapük, which was not a text, which was just a parenthesis. Apart from the thanks at the beginning and the greetings at the end, nothing was the subject of an agreement.

So, there had been a year of work to negotiate a text that did not exist, and we had to create between an official dinner and a short night of that - I say "that" - a real treaty or the beginning of a treaty. Who can believe that this can work? So I also take my responsibilities here, it was France that requested, that demanded the night meeting in Copenhagen. No one else, it was France. There was not even a meeting planned for the night. Can you imagine? Heads of State and government arrive on Thursday afternoon, there is the official dinner, and we had planned three hours in the morning to talk. So, we demanded a night meeting. And this meeting, I also take my responsibilities, I said: "we need a group of operational heads of State and government." And we pragmatically created a group of 28 heads of State and government who negotiated a political agreement in 24 hours that could not have been so bad since it was ratified the next day by almost all the others.

So, I say about Copenhagen, this group, this principle must continue. Should the group, dear Bernard, be 28, 32, 36? Let us not be more royalist than the king, we can perfectly imagine that we have forgotten some countries, that some countries want to invest in it. Good for them. But the question of a small representative group from Africa, from small island states, from all continents properly represented, is essential to prepare Bonn and then to prepare Cancun. I say this to our Mexican friends, if you do like you did for Copenhagen, you are heading for failure, that is certain! Therefore, we must immediately set up this smaller group, again I am not saying it must be limited to 28, and multiply the meetings of this group to prepare a text that we will put on the table in Bonn as a step and that we will adopt in Cancun. I would appreciate that, here, in your meeting, since you represent many people, you could call for the meeting of this expanded group. I see only advantages in that.

For the rest, and I will conclude with this, I am certain that we must reform the United Nations. That Copenhagen, that climate change, that the IPCC compel us to reform the United Nations or the United Nations will find itself in a deadlock. The Security Council must be expanded. That poses no problem. Imagine that there is not a single African country, not a single Latin American country, India, as a permanent member! It is unreasonable. Let us give each region of the world a quota of permanent member seats and let each region of the world designate in their own way, which will not necessarily be... We will not designate permanent members in the same way in Africa as in Latin America, what is the problem? It is already the case today. What is the difficulty? And as, next year, president of the G20 and president of the G8, France will take initiatives on this subject and on many others.

In the end, and I will conclude with this, 2010 can be a fantastic year. We have Copenhagen to relaunch. We have an international monetary system to reinvent. We have global governance to reform. We have the entire question of development to rethink, absolutely, completely, based on the elements from Copenhagen. It is exciting! What are we waiting for? Do we have the right to hold meetings? To shake things up a bit? If you do not take charge, I tell you, the calendar is already set to do nothing and the institutions are already agreed to do very little. That is exactly the question that is being posed.

I hope you understand that for me, coming here this morning was a big deal.

Good work.

Thank you all.