Statement by Mr. Nicolas Sarkozy, President of the Republic, on international efforts in favor of agriculture, in Paris on June 16, 2011.

France Nicolas Sarkozy · President of France

16 June 2011 · Statement on international efforts in favour of agriculture at the G20 agriculture event (Paris) · Paris, France

Context
Sarkozy addressed an international agricultural forum in Paris on June 16, 2011, speaking to world farmers' organizations during France's G8/G20 presidency.
Main themes
Global food security, agricultural production, commodity price volatility, eurozone stability, climate change and agriculture, demographic challenge, famine and malnutrition, Common Agricultural Policy, European integration, sustainable development, natural resource preservation, farmers' role in global economy
Duration
~26 min
77th percentile
Words
3,108
77th percentile
Sentences
172
85th percentile
Readability
46
50th percentile
Grade
11.3
36th percentile
Syntax
2.83
26th percentile
Vocabulary
2.19
46th percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 69%67%
  • Geopolitical 9%9%
  • Social 7%7%
  • Ceremonial 5%5%
  • Institutional 5%5%
  • Environmental 4%4%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Not in focus 3%

172 sentences in 55 paragraphs

Mr. Secretary-General, Dear Angel GURRIA,

Mr. Minister, dear Bruno LEMAIRE,

Ladies and gentlemen Presidents,

Ladies and gentlemen representatives of farmers' organizations,

You represent here the farmers of the world, and over the past 20 years, you have experienced more upheavals than the farming world has known in several centuries.

In the face of globalization, natural disasters, and the unpredictable law of the markets, you, the farmers of the world, are on the front line. You need stability; the world with you needs stability.

You will not hold it against me if, before talking about agriculture, I briefly mention the topic that will be at the heart of the upcoming European meetings by the end of June, namely the stability of the eurozone.

For the French, the primary source of stability is the euro. Remember the competitive devaluations that could ruin years of effort in just a few minutes.

The euro, along with the Common Agricultural Policy, is one of the great European achievements. And our duty is to defend and safeguard the euro. Without the euro, there is no Europe, and without Europe, there is no peace and no possible prosperity.

When it was necessary to act in response to the financial crisis, I did not hesitate. Today, as the recovery is underway, we do not have the right to weaken the euro.

I say this because for the past year, some countries in the eurozone have been going through an unprecedented crisis. These countries are implementing recovery programs without equivalent in history. Over the past year, we have made historic decisions to strengthen European integration.

In recent weeks, a public debate has developed on the forms, but not on the principle, of support for Greece. This debate is not illegitimate, and I understand that each of our European states, each of our institutions wants to assert its point of view.

But I ask everyone to take their responsibilities; what we need most today is unity. We must therefore move beyond national quarrels to regain a sense of our common destiny in Europe.

I call on everyone to show a spirit of responsibility and the sense of compromise necessary on which Europe was built. We must defend our single currency; we must defend European institutions. It is our duty to do everything possible to preserve the stability of the eurozone, for without stability, there will be no possible growth, and we are all concerned, and we must make decisions now.

For you, farmers of the world, what I have just said seems particularly true. Like all economic actors, you suffer from the volatility of commodity prices. You are at the heart of the global economy, but you are more than that. Because agriculture is not just any activity, nor is agricultural production just any commodity.

Your activity is the very condition of our survival on the planet. That is why it was so important for me to come and meet you this morning, and I want to thank the FNSEA and the Young Farmers for taking the particularly timely initiative of this forum.

The end of farmers is a fable, a fable that has been told to us for decades. Current events show us the urgency of putting agriculture back at the forefront of national political concerns.

Some peoples are already experiencing the dramatic reality of famine and the cruel lack of agricultural resources. One billion people are hungry in the world, and we talk about the disappearance of farmers. One-third of children born in developing countries are malnourished, and 3 million children die each year from malnutrition.

Behind the numbers, there are facts, and the facts are unbearable. This tragedy of hunger does not only concern South Asia and sub-Saharan Africa. It engages our ability to think about solidarity at the global level. How to feed the world and ensure the development of populations while preserving the planet and natural resources. Agriculture today must meet a triple challenge: demographic challenge, environmental challenge, development challenge.

Demographic challenge:

We will be 9 billion in 2050. Therefore, we must increase our agricultural production by 70% by then; this is unavoidable. However, while global agricultural production grew by 3% per year between 1960 and 1990, it has now fallen to just under half, at 1.5%. Every year, 30 million hectares are lost worldwide due to urbanization and industrialization. The challenge of production is therefore considerable.

We must create the conditions for a revival of global agricultural production growth. This will not be easy, as we are simultaneously facing the challenge of climate change and the preservation of natural resources.

Farmers, you are also on the front lines here. You all know how terrible the drought we are experiencing in France is. What is currently just an episodic event in our country is already a permanent calamity in some regions of the world. The IPCC estimates that African harvests could decline by 50% by 2020 due to drought. So, 3 billion people to feed in the world, 30 million hectares of agricultural land lost each year, and decreasing productivity due to climate change.

I know how mobilized farmers are on these issues. We must double our efforts to find alternatives in the field of energy as well as in agricultural practices.

We must revive and reinvent agriculture for the 21st century. What is at stake is also the future of the global economy, its capacity to sustain growth that is a source of development for populations.

This development challenge primarily concerns the farmers themselves. You represent 1.3 billion jobs worldwide; agriculture is the world's primary activity. 40% of the global workforce depends directly on local agricultural markets. But in developing countries, small farmers struggle to derive from their agricultural income the means to survive. And under the pressure of urbanization, the price of agricultural land continues to rise. In these conditions, how can we enable farmers to feed others when they, the farmers, cannot subsist on their own?

We must do everything to help them. It is a necessity for the development of entire regions that depend on farming activity for their entire economy. Nearly 80% of the poorest people in the world live where? In rural areas, and it is agriculture alone that can enable them to escape poverty.

Feeding the world sustainably and helping the economic development of the poorest populations without jeopardizing the future of the planet, these are the missions that our century has entrusted to farmers; this is what makes your activity a strategic one.

To these imperatives are added conditions of practice made more difficult, even impossible, by price volatility. Numerous parameters, such as population growth, the scarcity of arable land, and the declining growth rate of agricultural production, increase the gaps between supply and demand for food products. Undoubtedly, these tensions are the primary cause of rising prices and agricultural price volatility.

When we take wheat, the price of wheat rose from 140 euros per ton in July 2010 to 280 euros per ton in February 2011, only to fall back to 230 euros today. The food price index established by the FAO remains higher than the peak reached in 2008, when we were at the heart of the food crisis.

This price volatility has become unbearable, first for you, agricultural producers, in the North as well as in the South, because it creates absolute uncertainty about your incomes. It prevents you from investing. It penalizes your purchasing power. When prices collapse, your production potential is at risk. Such a situation does not exist in any other sector of activity. Name me another profession where one can lose 30% of their income every year! It does not exist.

Price volatility is equally unbearable for consumers, especially when prices suddenly soar: the food riots dramatically illustrate the consequences of fluctuations in agricultural commodity prices.

In the face of these developments, we must change our pace, change our scale, change our model, and stop thinking that everything will stop, that everything will be resolved without us taking any initiative. The G20 countries represent 70% of agricultural land, 82% of global cereal production, and 80% of global food trade: well, it is only natural that the G20 countries have the primary duty to lead this change and to imagine its foundations. This is why France has sought to have the agricultural issue included on the G20 agenda.

This mobilization is a first step; it was difficult. When France brought this agenda forward, no one believed it. No one. Today, it seems to me that the world has finally understood the crucial role that agriculture plays for the future of the planet. But it is not about wielding symbols. Raising awareness is good, but it cannot be enough. We must act; the word "action" is not a dirty word, and we must not be content to say that it is complicated. Frankly, if we were to only deal with what is simple, we would have a very light agenda! And we must act knowing how to break with the mistakes and missteps of the past. We cannot act in the 21st century as we did in the previous century. The world has changed; we must change our methods.

The new agricultural model that we wish for must, it seems to me, rest on two fundamental principles.

First principle: reinvest. Our meeting, and the work you will conduct over these two days, must signal the reinvestment of public and private funds in global agriculture. Producing more to feed people, producing better to ensure sustainable production, will only be possible if agriculture becomes a major investment area again.

In 20 years, at the global level, the share of public development aid dedicated to agriculture has fallen from 15% to less than 5%. In this area, states must keep their commitments, particularly the G8 countries, which, at the Aquila summit in July 2009, committed to increasing their support for agricultural development by $22 billion over three years.

Of course, public aid will not be enough. We must encourage private investments in agriculture as long as they are responsible. Private investments must promote the development of food production and contribute to the organization of production chains.

Finally, this financial effort must focus on research and innovation. Agronomy must once again play a driving role in ensuring the necessary growth of food production. All sectors must be mobilized, such as research on seeds, fertilization, and crop protection. We must focus research efforts on crucial subjects, such as new farming practices, water management, which we are discussing in France, or the structuring of agricultural sectors and local markets.

The second principle of the new agricultural model that we must build is modernized global governance.

In July 2008, at the Rome summit, I proposed a global partnership for food, food security, and agriculture based on international coordination, research, and coherence of funding. Since that date, the reform of the FAO has been launched, and the Committee on World Food Security (CFS) has been created. I welcome these reforms. But we must now go much further.

It is important to improve the functioning of global agricultural markets. Global agricultural markets are the least transparent of all. There is no transparency in global agricultural markets, so they are subject to extreme volatility. We have no information regarding global production, harvest forecasts, consumption demand, and even global stocks. It is time for the imperative of transparency to apply to agricultural markets.

With our G20 partners and the relevant international organizations, we wish to launch a new information system on markets, similar to what was done nearly ten years ago for oil. This tool would be hosted by the Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations, which is its role. And this tool would collect all data, including that concerning public and private stocks, and everyone could access it.

I wish for us to engage in this new system as soon as the meeting of the G20 agriculture ministers, dear Bruno Le Maire, takes place next week in Paris, and I want Europe to catch up in terms of information sharing. This new system should allow us to strengthen international cooperation on food security. And to improve international coordination to better anticipate and, above all, to better manage crises, of course.

Today, when an event occurs, each country reacts according to its immediate interest, without any consultation, even though its decisions can have dramatic consequences for the entire planet. We saw the effects of this in 2008, during the food riots, when some borders closed, prohibiting any export of foodstuffs, while, paradoxically, the available resources were sufficient to supply the market. This makes no sense.

In the face of the risk of crisis, major market players must be able to come together to provide a common response. The existence of a consultation forum would help avoid unilateral and therefore condemnable decisions. I hope you can reflect on this type of initiative that would make our world more united.

Finally, we must regulate the financial markets derived from agricultural commodities. I know there is a debate about the causes of agricultural volatility, and the role that various parameters, such as speculation or climate risk, can play. All of this is a subject of debate. But I propose one thing: let us not wait for experts to agree before we act! Because, in any case, the experts will not agree. If you wait, we will do nothing, and we cannot afford the luxury of doing nothing. I want the commitments made by G20 countries to improve the functioning of derivative markets, particularly oil derivative markets, to be extended to agricultural derivative markets. What we have done for oil derivative markets, is there a reason, an argument, for us to refuse to do the same for agricultural product derivative markets?

This is a crucial issue because the volume of these transactions in agricultural markets has increased unprecedentedly in recent years, while the gap between the reality of physical markets and that of financial derivative markets has also widened.

I will take just one example, that of the Chicago market. For agricultural commodities, derivatives are traded there each year at 46 times the annual U.S. wheat production, and I am told there is no speculation, and 24 times the U.S. corn production, and I am told there is no speculation. I would like someone to explain to me how it is possible to trade 46 times the annual U.S. wheat production and 24 times the annual U.S. corn production. We must remember that derivatives were originally created to protect commercial activities against fluctuations in the physical market! And now these derivatives increase the fluctuations of the physical market. To say this is to describe a phenomenon that anyone, without being a specialist, can observe. Today, in Chicago, on the commodity futures markets, 85% of the buying positions are held by purely financial actors, whose activities have no connection to the commodity being traded. This example proves how much our world has lost its sense of value, how much our world has lost its sense of reality, the sense of a capitalism that must serve the development and flourishing of populations. This kind of capitalism has nothing to do with the values we hold. To those who fear that France wants too many rules, I would like to reiterate that a market without rules is not a market, and that the capitalism we want is a production capitalism, not a capitalism that is solely financial.

Giving meaning to the economy, making capitalism work on both legs, does not involve intervening in prices, which I have never asked for, nor dismantling the financial economy that we need, but ensuring that the price formation process works well and preventing certain abuses. Is it normal that one can buy a large quantity, 17% of a physical market of a food commodity, without paying a single cent, not a cent? One can take a position in the cocoa market, so important for our African friends, buy 17 or 20%, not pay a cent, create panic and thus the effect of speculation, and resell a few weeks later the quantity thus acquired, pocketing the capital gain without having spent a cent. This is not the capitalism we want. And it is not respectful of the work of producers and farmers, and it is not in the interest of consumers. This is not the idea we have of value creation in a market economy that is based on work, that is based on added value, that is based on research, that is based on innovation, which does not consist of playing roulette in some stock exchange where, in every case, one wins. It is possible to change things if you demand it with us. In any case, the French presidency is determined to drive these changes.

Like physical markets, and like financial markets, agricultural commodity derivative markets must be subject to the imperative of transparency, the imperative of regulation, and the imperative of supervision. France's objective is for G20 countries to adopt strong decisions and principles in this area.

Ladies and gentlemen,

In anticipation of the G20 meeting in Cannes, France is preparing an action plan to reduce agricultural price volatility and lay the foundations for a productive and sustainable agriculture capable of feeding the entire world population by 2050. This is in all our interests, and there is room for all types of agriculture. There is room for American agriculture, there is room for European agriculture that we must defend, there is room for African agriculture, whose problem is its development and support, there is room for agriculture in Asia. The needs are immense, and we do not know how to meet them. So let us combine our efforts, and let us not think that what farmers in one region take, they take from others; they are part of a collective effort.

This plan will be discussed by the G20 agriculture ministers who will meet at the invitation of the French Minister of Agriculture in Paris next week, on June 22 and 23. But this plan will only be complete, solid, and reliable if farmers from around the world contribute to it. I therefore count on your work to inform the proposals we will present at the G20 summit at the end of this year. We need your solidarity because you are in a global market, and we must all stand together and imagine the agricultural model of the 21st century. I hope you understand that for me, it was really important to be with you today.

Thank you.