Statement by Mr. Nicolas Sarkozy, President of the Republic, on the regulation of commodity prices, in Brussels on June 14, 2011.

France Nicolas Sarkozy · President of France

14 June 2011 · Brussels, Belgium

Context
Sarkozy addressed EU commissioners and ministers in Brussels on June 14, 2011, urging regulation of commodity markets during France's G20 presidency.
Main themes
Regulation of commodity markets, raw material price volatility, scarcity of natural resources, G20 global governance, financial market regulation as model, transparency in commodity trading, sustainable global growth, energy security, agricultural commodity markets, derivative markets regulation, French G20 presidency agenda
Duration
~31 min
83rd percentile
Words
3,724
83rd percentile
Sentences
200
89th percentile
Readability
52
67th percentile
Grade
10.6
27th percentile
Syntax
2.81
23rd percentile
Vocabulary
2.16
39th percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 72%71%
  • Institutional 15%14%
  • Ceremonial 5%5%
  • Geopolitical 3%3%
  • Environmental 3%3%
  • Social 3%3%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Not in focus 2%

200 sentences in 58 paragraphs

Mr. President,

Ladies and Gentlemen Commissioners,

Ladies and Gentlemen Ministers,

Gentlemen Regulators,

Almost 40 years ago, it was the first oil shock. In 1973, the astonished world discovered that the price of a barrel of oil went from 3 to 18 dollars, from 3 to 18 dollars -- this morning, we were at 119 dollars a barrel.

And for the first time, economists around the world realized that the rise in the price of non-renewable resources posed an immense threat to the future of global growth. Well, Ladies and Gentlemen, forty years later, the threat is a reality. And we have no choice, we must act and act right now.

For a long time, the world has been organized around a false idea: that the world could have an abundance of raw materials. However, the world now knows that raw materials are finite resources, whether they are precious metals, energy materials, or agricultural land. These resources are and will increasingly be scarce, at the very moment when industries, particularly in emerging economies, have immense needs. This is very simply the cataclysmic scissors effect in which the world finds itself. Scarce and increasingly scarce raw material resources, and ever-growing energy needs.

The shortage of raw materials would lead to the paralysis of economic activity, the dislocation of our societies, and wars over hunger.

Thanks to the action of the G20, we have managed to overcome the most serious crisis the world has faced in a century. Growth has now resumed with global economic growth exceeding 4%. But we see that one of the main threats to growth is the rise in the price of raw materials. In what we are experiencing today, there is no surprise and indeed very little complexity. We have worked hard to regain global growth, and this global growth is threatened by the rise in raw material prices.

The G20 countries are the first concerned by this issue, and it is therefore the G20 countries that must establish the conditions, Mr. President, for sustainable growth. How can we achieve this? There is one principle: let us apply to the raw materials market the same rule that we have tried to apply to financial markets. There is one word, this word is not taboo: it is the word regulation. It is indeed regulation that was the principle we applied to the banking system and financial products. Finally, we now have an example; the extreme deregulation of financial markets brought the world to the brink of the abyss. A market without rules is no longer a market; this is what led to the catastrophe for financial markets. Are we going to allow the same catastrophe to occur for raw materials markets? The question is simple to ask, it is unavoidable. We cannot defer the answer.

Regulation does not mean control, it does not mean protectionism, it does not even mean setting prices administratively. Who would think of that? It is absurd; it has never worked anywhere. But without rules, I repeat, there is no market. The idea that one would want to show us that the market can function without rules is a false idea. And we must find the path between the absence of rules, which leads to the law of the jungle, and too many rules, which leads to paralysis. There is one word, it is the word regulation. Moreover, I do not understand why there is sometimes a certain shyness in using this word when we see such catastrophic realities as those we have experienced with financial markets; we do not want to find ourselves in the same situation.

So indeed, Mr. President Barroso, dear José Manuel, the French presidency has taken up this subject, which did not have consensus, but excuse me, if we were only to take up subjects that have consensus, the agenda of the French presidency would be significantly lighter since there is none, and I did not understand that the role of the presidency was to sit back, look at the problems, comment on them cautiously, and draw the conclusion that nothing should be done.

There is a triple challenge, and we do not have time to face it. We must face it right now:

- The first challenge is that of production: how can the global economy have enough resources at a reasonable price to meet the needs of the world's population? The challenge of production.

- The second challenge, - I join José Manuel - is the challenge of transparency. Frankly, the perfect counter-example is the functioning of financial markets before the crisis. If we have a direction, I do not know if we have the right direction, but we know the direction in which we do not want to go, and that is the direction of financial markets before the crisis. That is the perfect counter-example. I do not know a single person who comes to me and says: "we should do like the financiers before the crisis."

- The third challenge is the regulation of raw materials derivative markets.

I would like to say that these challenges are common to each of the markets to which you will dedicate your discussions: energy, agricultural products, and raw materials derivatives.

Our primary concern is the supply and production of raw materials.

By 2050, our planet will have 9 billion inhabitants, we know this; we have no right to say we were unaware, 9 billion inhabitants, nothing will change that. To meet the food needs of these 9 billion by 2050, global agricultural production must increase by 70%, and we are not yet capable of that, for a simple reason: the demand for agricultural products continues to grow, and agricultural production has increased at half the rate over the past 20 years compared to the period from 1960 to 1990.

Any questioning of agricultural production, particularly of the Common Agricultural Policy, would be absolutely contrary, Mr. Commissioner, to the needs of the world. I would still like us to reflect on this. The world needs 70% more agricultural production; the question that arises is whether Europe can refrain from increasing agricultural production on its territory. That would make absolutely no sense. We can develop European agricultural production while also helping African countries to develop their agricultural production, and with that, Ladies and Gentlemen, we will not be able to meet the needs of the 9 billion inhabitants that the planet will have by 2050. This is an unavoidable reality.

G20 countries must commit to respecting common rules of good conduct regarding the acquisition of arable land. Everyone must be able to develop their agriculture and agricultural productivity. I know how mobilized the African Union Commission is on this issue.

Feeding the world is an immense challenge that will occupy us all, and moreover, the strength of the Common Agricultural Policy is an extraordinary asset for Europe. I add, and President Barroso often repeats it rightly, that it is not widely known, but the European Union is the world's largest importer of food products. Therefore, to accuse the European Union of protectionism in this area is an absolute falsehood.

In the energy sector, we already know that we have entered an era of dwindling oil resources. We must develop alternative energies. We all agree.

I would like to say that among alternative energies, there is nuclear energy, which is the only energy that will also allow us to meet the greenhouse gas reduction commitments that we have, in Europe, committed to respecting. I would like to be told how we will meet our environmental commitments - and France fully supports the Commission's action in this regard - by developing fossil fuels while waiting for renewable energies and refraining from nuclear energy.

But - and here lies the problem - the dwindling of fossil energy cannot alone explain the volatility of oil prices. Allow me this small reminder: in 2008, oil prices fell from 140 dollars a barrel to 40 dollars in 6 months. I would like someone to explain to me what changes in economic growth can account for the fact that in 6 months, the price of a barrel of oil went from 140 dollars to 40 dollars. France accepts the increase in the price of the barrel because there is an increase in demand and a dwindling of supply; it understands. But that in 6 months - this was not in the Middle Ages, it was in 2008 - the barrel went from 140 dollars to 40 dollars, one cannot tell me: "move along, there is nothing to see, the oil market is functioning perfectly well." At the end of 2010, prices rose again. In January of this year, 97 dollars a barrel, in April, 120 dollars a barrel, and in May, the barrel lost 10% in one week. Again, I have not seen the economic movements that justify this totally erratic aspect.

So, of course, there needs to be dialogue between producers and consumers. Of course, we need to know how to mobilize excess capacities when they are available. Of course, we need to invest and increase research, both in agriculture and energy. But at the same time, we cannot remain idle in the face of these movements.

I add that there is an extraordinary injustice in the distribution of energy. When you think that 800 million Africans, 48 countries in sub-Saharan Africa, produce the same amount of energy as Spain alone. 48 sub-Saharan countries together produce the same amount of energy as Spain alone! Electricity consumption in Africa is 124 kilowatt-hours per person per year; that is barely enough to power a 100-watt bulb per person for three hours a day. All this is just 12 kilometers from Europe across the Strait of Gibraltar.

The question of investment in energy infrastructure is clearly a central issue in the evolution of the world. France has made very ambitious commitments regarding the development of renewable energies, but we can see, Ladies and Gentlemen, that we will not solve the problem solely with solar and wind energy, regardless of the commitments of others.

President Barroso spoke of an important word, transparency. He also said that when a country invests in resources, there should be publication of the money paid to those countries, in the fight against corruption, and he is right.

But let us talk about market transparency. The volatility of raw material prices thrives on one thing: the opacity of raw material markets. Because the truth is that raw material markets are not transparent; they are opaque. Is an opaque market still a market? The question deserves to be asked, for the first quality of a market - and we are proponents of a market economy - is transparency. However, there is no transparency, and I will try to demonstrate this. What are the stock levels? No one knows. Who knows the names of those who make such and such a transaction on a physical delivery or on a financial derivative? No one knows. There is no information on stocks. The countries that are able to provide information on stocks -- we were just talking about this with José Manuel not long ago -- are very few, even in Europe. As for those who make transactions in the market, no one knows them.

We opened the way in 2002, with the creation of the JODI (Joint Organisation Data Initiative) database. Now all G20 members must commit to improving the completeness of the information provided. I wish that each G20 country publishes a national report in the coming months detailing the progress made in this area. And, moreover, I see no reason why what we demand for oil should not be demanded for other fossil energies; I think of gas and I think of coal.

We must extend this transparency to agricultural markets, which are increasingly marked by price volatility. If we compare agricultural market prices over the last 5 years with the 15 years of the period from 1990 to 2005, global price volatility is twice as high for cereals, three times as high for sugar, and four times as high for rice, which is the staple food for a quarter of humanity. Is this normal? Is this acceptable? Is this sustainable?

Again, volatility when it reflects the influence of climatic hazards, we cannot do anything about it; when volatility reflects the influence of growing demand from emerging economies, we can accept it; but it is unacceptable that volatility reflects the influence of the recent financialization of global agricultural raw material markets.

It is therefore time for the G20 to take its responsibilities. I will return to this on June 16 before agricultural organizations, and on June 22, before the Agriculture Ministers of the G20 countries who will meet, dear Bruno Le Maire, in Paris.

We wish to launch a new information system on agricultural markets, similar to what was done ten years ago for oil with JODI. This tool would be hosted by the FAO, and it would collect all data, including that concerning private stocks, which will strengthen international cooperation.

Finally, the question that is perhaps the most distressing is the regulation of derivative markets for commodities. Hold on tight, last May, a historic record of 60 billion dollars was recorded for an initial public offering concerning a major commodity trading house. Responding to financialization is a crucial issue for the balance of the global economy.

Regarding oil, the size of financial markets is 35 times that of the physical market. It is traded in financial volume, 35 times the value of the physical quantity of oil. And I am told that speculation is not a problem! 35 times!

But for agricultural commodities, on the Chicago exchange alone, I ask you to pay attention to these figures, because they condemn the current system; each year, 46 times the annual U.S. wheat production is traded in derivatives on the Chicago exchange. 35 times for oil, 46 times the annual global wheat production. 24 times the annual corn production. But what can justify this?

Certainly, José-Manuel, it is complex. But there are dishonest systems that are complex as well. That does not prevent us from fighting them. I am not saying that there is dishonesty, but who can accept, when we do not have enough to feed the planet and given this evolution of the planet, that financiers trade 46 times the physical volume of the global wheat market?

At the same time, the number of actors involved in these markets has continued to grow: commercial actors have been joined by hedge funds and index funds, and with them, individuals have gained access to the commodity markets.

I am very concerned, I say this to President BARROSO, it is not about banning this financialization, it is not about intervening on price levels, but it is about demanding that the price formation process works correctly, and that we avoid, because it is our duty, unacceptable abuses.

France's objective is for G20 countries to adopt common principles of regulation and supervision applicable to all derivative commodity markets.

The first of these principles is therefore transparency. We are calling for the establishment of a registry that centralizes information regarding transactions on derivative markets, including commodities. At the very least, we should know the transactions; otherwise, there is no market. We also request that supervisors have reciprocal access to these registries. This is the proposal that the IOSCO regulators have brought before the G20 Finance, dear Christine LAGARDE, I am pleased that the European Union is already discussing a draft regulation on this subject.

Furthermore, regulation must be broadened. We must extend regulation to all products traded on commodity derivative markets, to all actors involved, and to all instruments used.

We must encourage the standardization of derivatives and their listing on regulated platforms or markets.

I believe it is unhealthy for markets to operate without a central counterparty that imposes margin calls. We must limit leverage; I take my responsibilities, France calls for a minimal cash deposit for each transaction.

Ladies and gentlemen, who can accept that a participant in a global market acquires 15% of the physical production of that global market without being required to pay a dime? Then resells 15% while pocketing the capital gain without having paid a dime? But naturally, when the participant buys 15% of the cocoa market, the price of cocoa rises. Is this market economy? Is this the world we want? Are these the values we believe in? Is this normal? Is this acceptable? And on the other hand, you have farmers producing cocoa in Côte d'Ivoire or elsewhere who are refused payment, and consumers in Africa whose only food is rice and who cannot buy it because under the pressure of speculation, panic, and lack of transparency, prices soar. Is this the world we want?

France states clearly: we do not want that world. Precisely, we do not want it because we are against protectionism and for market economy. And this functioning of markets is contrary to the ideas we uphold. It is the caricature of the ideas we uphold. And if we want the world to continue to function, and if we refuse to legitimize those who reject globalization, then we must clean up the world as it operates today. There is no choice.

One last word on supervision: we need to better articulate the actions of regulatory authorities on physical markets and those of financial market regulators, in order to detect -- I say it -- cross-manipulations of prices. Because I assert there are price manipulations. In stock markets, these manipulations are condemnable, including criminally. Why would we accept them in commodity markets? Just because it is global? Precisely, the G20 is global. So, it is the place where we must act. And again, I was outraged that a financial actor bought, by operating on both physical and financial markets at the same time, almost all the available cocoa contracts on an exchange, namely exactly 240,000 tons, 7% of global production, 15% of global stocks, 25% of European stocks, without spending a dime. And I am told that speculation would not be a problem? There must certainly be a problem with the translation of the word speculation.

Europe, Mr. President BARROSO, - and that is why I was happy to come here, because your conference is very important in the eyes of France - Europe has the duty to carry a model of implementing cooperation between financial regulators and physical regulators.

We want to give the world the means to sanction abuses. I would also say that position limits seem to me to be an interesting tool. When I see that -- excuse me, - position limits were introduced in the United States in 1936. What the United States did in 1936, Europe might perhaps take inspiration from in 2011, without creating an absolute debate between proponents of liberalism and others. That should be possible.

I add that the Dodd-Frank Act, passed last year, led the American regulatory agency to propose position limits on derivatives of all commodities; what the United States did last year, can we dream that Europe will do it?

This would prevent what happened in 2008 in the oil market, where three operators, ladies and gentlemen, three were able to take positions on 80% of the deliverable oil stock in the short term. That is not market economy, three operators, 80% of the stock. I hope that in this area Europe will show the way and at the same time take inspiration from what has already been done in the United States.

The determination of the French Presidency for all G20 countries to commit to this path is total. I am told: "yes, but be careful, there must be fair competition between financial markets and that investors should not be tempted to play regulatory competition between our countries." I know this argument, but I ask a question: if a country does not fight against mafias, should we give up fighting mafias? If a country or a geographical area has a regulatory deficit in a domain, should the whole world follow that country to lead to the collapse we experienced in 2008 with financial markets? Or should Europe, on the contrary, be a zone of stability? I would like us to reflect on this because the argument is served to me for everything: taxation of financial transactions: "you can't think about it, everything will go elsewhere. Don't think about financing developing countries, it doesn't matter." Market transparency: "you can't think about it, others are opaque." Market regulation: "you can't think about it."

So what is the image of the world we are going to give? Always aligning with the worst, with the smallest common denominator, a totally flattened world or the one that will set the path, that will set the line, is the one that believes in the least, that wants the fewest rules, that has the fewest values? And must we wait for that one to be convinced before we finally carry a model, a European model worthy of the name, respectful of the market, of information, of producers and consumers? Is that what we should expect?

The French presidency believes that the issue of regulating commodity prices is an emblematic file - and I will conclude with this - emblematic of market functioning, emblematic of economic issues, emblematic of respect for people in the world who have the right to survive with acceptable food prices, emblematic of the stable, organized, coherent world of the 21st century that we want, responding to values and not simply to unscrupulous interests.

I hope you have understood, ladies and gentlemen, that my presence alongside President BARROSO for this conference was very important to me. This is not a technical conference, as I have sometimes read, where you will exchange obscure arguments. It is about life, it is about the future of the world, it is about ensuring that we do not find ourselves once again on the brink of the precipice, turning our backs on the catastrophic example set by unscrupulous financial operators, who have brought the world to the brink, and from this dreadful experience, let us build a new world, based on something we deeply need: stability, transparency, and regulation.

Thank you.