Statement by Mr. Nicolas Sarkozy, President of the Republic, on international efforts in favor of agriculture, in Paris on June 22, 2011.

France Nicolas Sarkozy · President of France

22 June 2011 · G20 Ministerial Meeting on agriculture · Paris

Context
Sarkozy addressed ministers, ambassadors, and directors-general of international organizations in Paris on June 22, 2011, during the French G20 presidency's agricultural summit.
Main themes
Global agricultural crisis, food security, commodity price volatility, G20 agricultural action plan, agricultural market regulation, global production shortfall, poverty and famine, sustainable growth, natural resource preservation, French G20 presidency
Duration
~16 min
55th percentile
Words
1,916
55th percentile
Sentences
106
66th percentile
Readability
46
51st percentile
Grade
11.3
36th percentile
Syntax
2.72
15th percentile
Vocabulary
2.18
44th percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 92%92%
  • Ceremonial 5%5%
  • Social 1%1%
  • Technological 1%1%
  • Environmental 1%1%
  • Institutional 1%1%
  • Geopolitical 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

106 sentences in 35 paragraphs

Ladies and Gentlemen Ministers,

Ladies and Gentlemen Directors General of International Organizations,

Ladies and Gentlemen Ambassadors,

Who would have believed when the G20 first met in Washington that these meetings would lead us three years later to address the issue of agriculture?

And yet, rebuilding global capitalism is not just about changing its mode of operation; it is also about putting the needs of people and the activities of men back at the center of its priorities. Agriculture is the primary activity in the world; agriculture is the first response to the vital needs of populations. For those who still doubt it, current events provide terrible evidence of the urgency to place agricultural activity at the heart of our action. Since the beginning of the year, 44 million people have fallen into poverty; since the beginning of the year, in countries that risk being destabilized at any moment by riots over hunger.

For too long, we have been content to say that agriculture was just one parameter of global growth among others. When there were agricultural crises, due to a lack of consensus, due to a lack of courage, we wrote reports, we mentioned the need to reflect, later, always later. In fact, never. Today, it is time to act. Agriculture must reclaim its rightful place within a global economy that regains meaning, a global economy that creates value for all and shares it, an economy that respects the work of farmers and builds sustainable growth.

It is a matter of life for billions of people around the world; it is a matter of the balance of your societies; it is a matter of preserving our natural resources.

The surge in commodity prices today threatens the global recovery. It can plunge entire populations into famine and poverty. It will provoke riots if we do nothing. There is urgency today. We must act, act together, to prevent the world from experiencing another agricultural and food crisis.

That is why the French Presidency of the G20 has sought to draw on all the vital forces of global agriculture, gathering beyond just the G20: from the United Nations General Assembly to the World Economic Forum in Davos, from companies in the agricultural and agri-food sectors to the 48 states brought together by Germany on January 22, from international organizations to farmers from 70 countries, who gathered in Paris last week.

This mobilization must not make us forget the primary responsibility that lies with the G20 governments. It is up to you, Ministers of Agriculture, to propose the action plan that will guide all future achievements.

In the face of the financial crisis, the G20 demonstrated its ability to revive the global economy and then to establish a new regulation. The word regulation is not a dirty word. A market without rules is no longer a market. What we have been able to do for financial markets, our duty is to do for agricultural markets.

The G20 countries represent 65% of agricultural land, 77% of global cereal production, and 80% of global agricultural trade. The G20 countries have immense weight in global agriculture, and therefore immense responsibility for the future of global agriculture. We cannot say, you cannot say: it is the fault of others. It is our responsibility, and now, not tomorrow, now.

So I know that the current crisis is complex. If it is enough to say that problems are complex to avoid addressing them, and if we must give up addressing complex problems, enjoy tourism in Paris because all problems are inherently complex. But when we analyze what happened in 2008 as well as what is happening today, we clearly see the main limits of our current system.

We all know that global agricultural production is too low compared to demand. I would like to convey this idea in the media around the world: global production is insufficient compared to demand. And this will worsen. To feed the 9 billion people that the planet will have in 2050, global production must increase by 70%. However, over the past 20 years, global agricultural production has only increased by 1.5% per year, which is half of the rate during the previous 30 years. So we do not have to fear each other. If we add up the agricultural productions of all our countries, we will not be able to meet global demand. There is room for everyone.

This requires mobilization of all agricultures, those of Africa, Asia, the United States, and Europe, with the CAP. We must implement this mobilization starting today, because it is already today that shortages are being felt.

Let us take the example of wheat. At this time of year, we already know that the balance will be fragile between the expected production and the projected global consumption, driven by India and the Maghreb countries. The stocks available to complement production are not high enough, even as production from major exporters is likely to be much lower than in previous years, in the United States due to flooding in the Midwest and in Europe due to drought.

To produce more and better, we must reinvest in agriculture. We must help the poorest countries develop their own agriculture and ensure that the commitments made at the Rome Summit and the L'Aquila Summit are finally honored.

We must also encourage research and innovation through international cooperation programs.

We must improve infrastructure that allows for the transportation and storage of production. Many cereal harvests are destroyed because they have not been stored under proper conditions.

The second limit we face is the lack of information on agricultural markets. Agricultural markets are the least transparent of all markets in the world. Which country will agree to defend this opacity? Everyone works in their own corner. Each of us works in our own corner, and no one has a global vision of production and consumption prospects or even of stock situations.

The only available data comes from the U.S. Department of Agriculture, and Europe must catch up in this area. This lack of transparency fuels price volatility. The price of a ton of wheat has doubled in six months: from 140 euros last July to 280 euros in February 2011, before falling back to 225 euros today. Is this a functioning market? Can someone explain to me that it is demand that has changed in a year?

Volatility has dramatic consequences for everyone, producers and consumers, developing countries and developed countries. I think of European farmers who feel the volatility of prices all the more acutely because the Common Agricultural Policy (CAP) had long shielded them from fluctuations in the global market. I also think of African farmers; that is why I am pleased that NEPAD and the African Union are invited to the G20.

Volatility, let’s call it what it is, is a scourge. It is a scourge, volatility, for farmers and consumers, as well as for the stability of states; volatility is a threat, as it jeopardizes agricultural productivity in the years to come: What farmer can embark on major investments when he risks losing a third of his income the following year? What entrepreneur would dare to invest in such an unstable market?

What does France propose? To do for agriculture what we have been able to do for oil: to launch a joint database that allows everyone to access complete, reliable, and regularly updated information. I commend the commitment of European Commissioner Ciolos to make European data on major agricultural productions available as early as this autumn.

The extent of the current crisis is also explained, we must acknowledge, by our own limits, particularly by our inability to coordinate to prevent crises. We must learn the lessons from the tragedy of 2008, where everyone made unilateral decisions without coordination. We must avoid protectionist reflexes; we must agree on a code of good conduct that prohibits export restrictions for the purchase of emergency food aid. This involves establishing common rules for dialogue, and perhaps even creating a forum that would allow major agricultural market players to consult quickly as soon as a crisis arises.

We would be wise to decide to mobilize humanitarian reserves in the most sensitive areas. The idea is not to create public stocks to stabilize prices! That does not work. We know that it is impossible.

But we must at least ensure that, during food and humanitarian crises, the intervention of international organizations like the WFP does not contribute to rising prices because they buy large volumes on the markets at the most critical time! This situation may seem absurd, but it is unfortunately what we have observed too often.

We must experiment in Africa with different ways of using emergency reserves to learn from the most effective experiences on the ground. At the same time, insurance instruments should not be reserved for the wealthiest.

On all these issues, I know that the work of the World Bank can inform the proposals you will make to your colleagues, the Ministers of Finance and Development.

Finally, the current crisis reflects the limits of a predatory capitalism. Since 2008, we have seen massive land purchases: thus, in the year 2009 alone, intentions to purchase land exceeded 50 million hectares, an area the size of France, and 70% of these were in Africa alone. Under these conditions, how could African agriculture develop and benefit local populations? How? We must implement a code of good conduct for land acquisition.

Agricultural raw materials have become an underlying asset of financial derivatives, which are experiencing uncontrolled growth. The financialization of agricultural markets, even if it does not explain everything, contributes to price volatility and food insecurity for the most vulnerable. It opens the door to manipulations—I say manipulations—that we have seen in recent months. Everyone knows what happened in the cocoa market. I want to remind you that a market that is not regulated is not a market, but a lottery, a lottery where fortune smiles on the most cynical, instead of rewarding work, rewarding investment, and rewarding the production of value.

That is why the French Presidency of the G20 has sought for financial regulation to extend to agricultural derivative markets. It is crucial that you work with the Ministers of Finance because intelligent and effective regulation requires cooperation between regulators of physical markets and regulators of financial markets.

Reinvestment in agriculture, transparency in agricultural markets, coordination of states, regulation: these are the key words of the action plan that you have developed with Bruno Le Maire, whom I thank and who has my full confidence. I hope that you can adopt it tomorrow. Ladies and Gentlemen, the whole world is watching you, you, the Ministers of Agriculture. This constitutes a major step in the construction of a new global agriculture.

Ladies and Gentlemen Ministers,

The success of the G20 summit in Cannes depends on you. This is the first time you are gathered. This is the first time agriculture has reached the rank of a priority for global growth. By addressing the volatility of agricultural markets and ensuring food security for the world today and tomorrow, we are rebalancing the entire edifice of capitalism. By adopting this plan, you can change not only the lives of a billion farmers but also the very course of capitalism, so that capitalism regains its meaning: to contribute to the development and well-being of populations. The whole world is counting on your decisions, on your actions; the whole world cannot wait.