Statement by Mr. Nicolas Sarkozy, President of the Republic, on the challenges and priorities of agricultural policy in France and at the European level, in Paris on February 23, 2008.

France Nicolas Sarkozy · President of France

23 February 2008 · Inauguration of the 45th International Agricultural Show · Paris, France

Context
Sarkozy addressed farmers and ministers at the inauguration of the 45th International Agricultural Show in Paris on February 23, 2008, outlining national and European agricultural priorities.
Main themes
French agricultural policy, European agricultural ambition, farmer income and prices, community market stabilization, agricultural competitiveness, France's agri-food trade balance, climate and health risk management, UNESCO gastronomic heritage candidacy, large distribution competition, agricultural sector restructuring
Duration
~37 min
89th percentile
Words
4,457
89th percentile
Sentences
224
91st percentile
Readability
56
79th percentile
Grade
10.3
24th percentile
Syntax
2.92
37th percentile
Vocabulary
2.06
20th percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 44%43%
  • Social 16%15%
  • Institutional 15%14%
  • Ceremonial 12%12%
  • Geopolitical 11%11%
  • Environmental 3%3%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Not in focus 2%

224 sentences in 45 paragraphs

Mr. President, dear Christian PATRIA,

Mr. Minister, dear Michel,

Ladies and gentlemen,

I am very happy to be here among you on the occasion of the inauguration of the 45th International Agricultural Show, and I greet all the foreign ministers who honor us with their presence. I also salute the farmers of France, as well as all those, industrial business leaders, artisans, and employees, through whom France stands at the forefront of nations in the agricultural and agri-food sector.

Dear Christian PATRIA, I am fully aware that this Agricultural Show is an extraordinary showcase of French trades and products. It is a global meeting, an opportunity for discoveries, and an occasion for pleasure.

For centuries, agriculture has been part of French identity and tradition. Today, beyond its cultural dimension, agriculture carries a double challenge. An economic challenge, I will return to that, and a civilizational challenge. Agriculture has shaped our landscapes. Agriculture has given our homeland a soul, and even today, agriculture allows France to be the second largest country in Europe by area. Without agriculture, our country would be a desert.

Agriculture and the trades that shape it are also the source of our country's gastronomic diversity. I took the initiative for France to be the first country to submit, as early as 2009, a candidacy to UNESCO to allow the recognition of our gastronomic heritage as part of the world heritage. We have the best gastronomy in the world, at least from our point of view - well, we are willing to compare ourselves with others - and we want this to be recognized as part of the world heritage.

My conviction is that at the beginning of the 21st century, agriculture is strategic; it is strategic for France, but my dear European friends, it is also strategic for Europe.

I have not changed. I want a new ambition for agriculture in Europe, and I assert that 21st-century agriculture must be a production agriculture, an agriculture where every farmer is considered an entrepreneur, who must live from their work with prices that recognize the quality of that work.

I want to start my remarks with this, because everything depends on it. Farmers do not want to be bureaucratized. Farmers do not want to be subsidized. Farmers want to live from their work. The first essential question is that of prices and therefore of community preference. I will return to that. Agriculture is a job; the farmer is an entrepreneur; there is know-how, and there is a desire to be compensated for that know-how. France is the world's leading exporter of processed agricultural products. The surplus of our trade balance in this sector, speaking under the control of Michel BARNIER, is 9 billion euros in 2007. We must maintain this major asset for the French economy. Agriculture is a key element of our strategic economy; agriculture is not simply a nostalgic reserve of a way we could see our territories two centuries ago; agriculture is a cutting-edge sector of the French economy, on par with aeronautics, on par with nanotechnologies, there is agriculture. For this, I have spoken with your agricultural leaders, hasn't it, dear Jean-Michel, we need a "new agricultural deal," we need a resolute, coherent action at the national, European, and international levels.

At the national level, I made commitments on September 11 last year. I want to account for them today.

Thanks to remunerative prices that European farmers will obtain, they will find new prospects. If the sowing of crops has increased by 5% this winter, if dairy farmers have been able to increase their production by 20% in January, it is thanks to prices and increased competitiveness. We need a genuine community policy for market stabilization.

We have defined the conditions for the generalization, starting in 2009, of climate risk management mechanisms to all our farms. Simultaneously, the implementation of a health compensation fund will allow for better management of the consequences of health crises, similar to the case of bluetongue disease.

Living from prices - I do not hesitate to say it - means that everyone must play the game of competition. This has been a debate between the representatives and us, on the famous Galland law. We have maintained a specific framework for agricultural products. And I am fully aware that we cannot leave farmers alone in the face of five players from large distribution. I say this to Mr. BEDIER. But at the same time, I ask farmers to better structure their sectors to organize discussions. There is not hell on one side and paradise on the other. There is a collective effort; it is easier when one is in front of others to hit on each other; I simply tell you that the State will not let you down, to guarantee you in discussions with large distribution that you will not be alone, but at the same time, the State asks you to restructure certain sectors, of which it must be said that the chaos that reigns there is responsible for the low prices they obtain. I want to speak the truth, at least as I receive it, as I recognize it, and from that moment on, we can conduct the reform concerning the negotiability of sales conditions, farmers in this reform must find their benefit. I say this to Jean-Michel, to the President of the Young Farmers, I have not let you down. But I have never held the easy discourse that says that when there are problems, I think particularly of fruits and vegetables, it is always the others. I remember that between certain regions, there was no solidarity during a number of crises. So, we have a mutual effort to make.

We must therefore organize ourselves. This is crucial, particularly for the pig sector - of which Michel BARNIER rightly told me - that is currently going through a crisis, I believe, unprecedented compared to what we have known. This raises a question regarding competition law. We have taken the initiative of a memorandum to the European Commission, to strengthen the commercial organization of supply and ensure the development of French inter-professions. And I would like the Commission to understand that organizing producers does not harm competition; quite the contrary.

I have wished to support an agriculture that contributes to the sustainable development of our country and Europe, and ensures the sanitary quality of our products. So I know that some of you - you participated in the Grenelle de l'Environnement - I know that some of you were afraid of being the victims of the Grenelle de l'Environnement. I thank you for participating because I have long believed that farmers are the first victims of pesticides and are not the first culprits. And it is useless to oppose one another. We have been able to sign unprecedented agreements between organizations that did not even consider meeting last September! I will not let farmers be pointed out in our country. If there were no farmers, the nature, the landscape of our country would not be what it is today. And I pay tribute to your leaders who have agreed to engage in this effort of discussion. So, the effort made every day by French agriculture to adapt to new requirements must be recognized at the community level. I want to say it, I wish that at the community level - I say this to Joseph DAUL - there is a strengthened harmonization of environmental and sanitary standards within Europe. We must have the same standards if we want quality and safety for the European consumer, and competition among farmers from different countries must be fair. I say this, dear Jean-Michel, I will not accept that French farmers suffer from distortions of competition. I add that what I think about environmental standards, I also think about the issue of GMOs. Europe must move forward in unison, at the risk of a lack of coherence.

So, the urgency of the fight against climate change also requires that we progress quickly in the use of renewable energies. Agriculture and forestry will be the main actors in our effort to reduce greenhouse gas emissions. Research in biofuels, which we will still help fiscally, the exploitation of forest biomass, innovation in green chemistry, must be strengthened because these are additional resources and sectors of the future for French agricultural operations.

Finally, I wanted to strengthen in 2008 the policy of support for the creation of agricultural enterprises and the establishment of young people, by engaging a budget of 130 million euros to finance the famous, Mr. President, subsidized loans. Later, I will bring my support to the renewed pact for the establishment of young people in agriculture. I would like to say one thing to the French, that ten years later, 90% of the agricultural enterprises that were supported continue to thrive. And I say this in front of the President of Crédit Agricole, what economic sector can say that 90% of the new enterprises that were supported survive? I want to say a second thing: if we do not promote the establishment of young farmers, we kill French agriculture. The question of the establishment of young farmers is central. I say this to the President of the CNJA, there are two major questions - there are many others - there is the question of prices and community preference and the question of the establishment of young people. There is mountain agriculture, there are special aids, but if we can have a profession where a young person who establishes themselves says in 20 years, "I can still do my job," and where a farmer, regardless of their age, says, "I will have prices that compensate my work," if we do that, just that, we have already solved 80% of the problems of French and European agriculture.

So, a word on small pensions, everyone has talked to me about it and the maintenance of the purchasing power of retired farmers. These questions will be examined before the end of the first semester of this year, before the end of June. I want to do it methodically, but I tell you I want to do it without demagoguery. What does that mean? I want first to reduce the "pockets of poverty," because there are pockets of poverty in the agricultural world where some retirees are completely forgotten by successive revaluations, and I want to prioritize studying measures in favor of spouses and widows. I want the work of spouses to be recognized and the misery of certain widows to be alleviated.

You see, the path I traced in Rennes is becoming clearer. The commitments have been kept, and I want to thank Michel BARNIER for the exceptional quality of his action in service to our agriculture, dear Michel, to our forests, and to our fishing, which is fully part of your areas of concern.

So, at the European level, there is immense work to be done on the Common Agricultural Policy, to adapt it to new challenges. I will take my responsibilities; I am determined to play an offensive role on this essential subject, and perhaps this will be a subject of debate among us, so let us debate; I do not believe in a purely defensive and conservative posture that has too often been ours. We have been wrongly put on the ropes regarding the Common Agricultural Policy. The Common Agricultural Policy is first and foremost the first European policy; those who want to destroy the CAP do not believe in Europe, do not believe in Europe. I add that in this European agricultural sector, there is no reason to leave the field open to our American friends and American farmers. They do not do it for themselves; why should we do it for us?

I want to place France at the heart of a European project.

During the presidential campaign, I committed to doing everything possible to turn the page on the "no" vote to the Giscard Constitution. I would like to explain myself to you. You, the farmers, I know perfectly well that part of you voted "no" - I voted "yes." But allow me to say one thing. How do you expect us to have an influence in Europe on agricultural policy choices if France remains the country that said "no" to Europe? How do you expect me to make France's voice heard at the negotiating table in Europe if we are outside the table? And do you believe that the other 25 countries would wait quietly while France and the Netherlands were outside? I do not pass judgment; I do not blame anyone for their vote, and I can even understand the reasons that led some to vote "no." And I became President of the Republic nine months ago. France was outside, and nine months later, I ask you to judge. It is France that proposed the simplified treaty. It is France that had it adopted. And the France that said "no" was the first to ratify it. We are not in the same situation today for negotiating with our partners as we were yesterday. Whether you voted "yes" or "no," it is clear. And I want to return to the question of the referendum. You know, I tend to speak my truth; I do not have a temperament for hypocrisy and lies. Moreover, if you like hypocrisy and lies, you have choices in the political arena; there is plenty of it. So, at least accept this difference. I do not like to lie; I do not like to be hypocritical. If I had told our partners that we would hold another referendum, do you think they would have accepted the simplified treaty? Is there even one person who thinks that? And if we continued to say "no," do you believe that Europe would continue to fund the Common Agricultural Policy? I took my responsibilities, but be careful, ladies and gentlemen, I did not take these responsibilities after the elections; that would be too easy. I said before the elections what I would do afterward. I said in the debate with the lady - you remember, the one who was my opponent in the presidential election - I said that I would not hold a referendum, that I would propose the simplified treaty, that I would put France back at the heart of Europe, and that I would ensure that we regained our place within the Community of the European Union. That is exactly what I did, and believe me, it was not easy to achieve. So from that moment on, what do we do with it, and what do we decide?

Because you know very well that the future of agriculture is not played out in Paris alone, and it is not played out in Brussels alone. It is first played out in Geneva. I want to say a word about the WTO. The WTO is not an external factor imposed on us: we are actors in the WTO, and even if it displeases some, we are indeed actors. In the WTO, there is not just Mr. LAMY; there is also France, and I believe that Europe must show much greater resolve to defend its interests, and I regret that Europe accepts increasingly significant concessions without any return. This attitude is a dead end. I therefore ask that negotiations within the World Trade Organization resume on healthy bases, with clarified objectives, and let it be clear: the government of the French Republic will firmly oppose any agreement that would sacrifice the interests of French and European agriculture. Since unanimity is required, everyone is now facing their responsibilities. I add, to be perfectly understood, that when I am told that the agreement will allow for growth, to my knowledge, there has been no agreement for 7 or 8 years, and there has never been such strong global growth. Do not come to explain to me - I prefer an agreement, but not at any cost - that if there is no agreement, there is no growth, because the French, like the Europeans, see that for the past 7 or 8 years, it has been exactly the opposite. I also add that I do not see why we should feel guilty for Europe defending its interests while the United States of America does so with such energy, passion, and effectiveness for their agriculture? This should make us think, because the United States has understood that there is a supremacy of their "green power."

So we can no longer continue to impose on our agricultural businesses environmental dumping, social dumping, fiscal dumping, monetary dumping, the scale of which grows every day, well beyond the muted debates in Geneva. I do not want to disturb them, but they should not count on my signature to continue at this pace under these conditions.

We are moving further away from our initial objectives in this cycle. Emerging countries believe they have only rights and no duties. I believe in the emergence of global powers such as China, India, South Africa - where I will be going next week - Mexico, Brazil. I fight for these countries to have rights on the international stage that correspond to their size. But I tell them with the same strength, you do not have only rights; you also have duties. That is why, Jean-Michel, I fight for the G8 to become the G13, because imagining solving the world's major problems without inviting an African country, without inviting a South American country, and forgetting China and India seems unreasonable to me; the word seems weak in my eyes.

Finally, on the community level, I want to engage, with the European Commission and its president, José Manuel BARROSO, whom I support, who is a man of quality, in a genuine renovation of the Common Agricultural Policy.

There, we are at the heart of everything. Some of my own friends would recommend that I wait. Wait. Wait for what? For the sky to fall on our heads. In France, whenever there is a problem, there are always sympathetic people saying we must wait, but wait for what? France's problems will not be resolved if we do not address them. And the Common Agricultural Policy, I know it is funded until 2013, but 2013 for a 22-year-old who is starting out is tomorrow morning. What happens in 2013? Well, I will not do as many others have done, sweeping the dust under the rug and passing the total on to others. No, there is no need to wait. We must discuss immediately in an offensive manner. Should we wait for the next discussions on the review of policies and the budget of the European Union in 2010? Wait for the negotiation on the future of the CAP in 2013? I want a break from conservatism and immobility.

I am convinced that the CAP must be renovated, restructured. That is why I propose that starting July 1 of this year, two different but deeply complementary exercises be conducted by the French Presidency, dear Michel.

The first exercise will be the health check of the CAP. The Commission made proposals as early as November. They are actively discussed under the Slovenian presidency, and it will be the responsibility of the French Presidency to successfully carry out this negotiation in the second half of this year. I know that this is primarily a technical exercise, but it is an important exercise because the decisions we make in this context will apply from 2009. I want to be clear: I will ensure that this exercise is an opportunity to engage, starting in 2009 - and I weigh my words - in a genuine restructuring of the implementation modalities of the CAP in our country, which will be done in total coherence with our political objectives for 2013.

I can already hear some telling me: "But let’s discuss the political principles of the CAP, and let’s wait until 2013 to reform the tools. In the meantime, the health check of the CAP should allow us to apply patches to rebalance support according to the new market conditions." Wait for what? A new health crisis, a new economic crisis? Should we wait for a new relocation of our livestock to take action?

Well, no! I take my responsibilities; France will engage during this exercise in a genuine discussion with each of our European partners with the dual objective of better managing climate, health, and economic risks and maintaining production activity in fragile territories.

Carrying out this exercise under our presidency is of course only of interest if we agree - this is the second exercise - on the objectives of the restructured CAP. A little method does not hurt.

I will propose to our partners, dear Joseph DAUL, with the European Parliament, a major player in the Common Agricultural Policy, and I will meet the 7 group presidents before the French Presidency and the Commission, a discussion on a new political framework applicable in 2013 for our agriculture in Europe. It is not a matter of calling into question the agreement on the budget, which runs until 2013, nor of preempting the next discussion on the general review of community policies. It is about giving a new coherence to the Common Agricultural Policy by agreeing on the objectives that should guide it. The discussion on the budget will come afterward; the budget is the consequence; the cause is the objectives; that is the method, after all. It is unbelievable; we will not talk about the budget as long as we have not agreed on the objectives. We will agree on the objectives, and we will put a budget at the service of those objectives.

For me, I have four objectives:

Food security - I have told agricultural unionists - is a major issue for 400 million European consumers. You are the guarantors of food security. This means a regular, accessible supply, guaranteed in terms of health. This means defending our food in its diversity, its tastes, and its flavors. I do not resign myself to the uniformity of our food model. And then, it means not leaving the food of Europeans to speculation and the lowest health or environmental standards. Moreover, I do not see why we would impose very strict and justified rules on our farmers regarding traceability and animal welfare while continuing to import meat from other parts of the world to which we impose no rules on animal welfare and traceability. It is the same consumers who will buy. There is no reason.

The second objective is that we must participate in global food balances. Listen, looking at the world, what explains the rise in agricultural prices if not the growing food demand, particularly in Asia? There are so many people who die of hunger; we will not be told that we have too many farmers.

The third objective is to contribute to the fight against climate change and to improving the environment.

And the fourth objective, in my eyes, is the balance of our territories.

Finally, I want a market management that holds farmers and sectors more accountable.

A renewed community preference. Now that is progressing. When during the electoral campaign I spoke of community preference, it was just about the time that Michel and I were saying bad words. There was even one person who told me: "That reminds me of LE PEN," so if LE PEN says the sky is blue, I must say it is red. Community preference is not a bad word; if we created Europe, it is precisely for community preference, or else we should not have created Europe. If we created Europe, it is to create the conditions for a market to develop a European agriculture that has our preference over others. I add that, as global prices rise, it is precisely the time to establish community preference. I also add that there must be reciprocity and an end to naivety in discussions with the Union.

Finally, I would like instruments that allow for the maintenance of production activity in fragile territories; we must absolutely keep this mechanism, particularly in grassland areas and mountainous regions. Mountain agriculture is essential for the balance of our territories. This must go through a reform in France, before the end of the year, of support for grassland areas; Michel is taking care of it.

I propose that this debate be conducted by the Council of Agriculture Ministers. Naturally, as President of the Union, I will be personally attentive to it.

My dear friends, you have understood, I want the ambition that will drive French agricultural policy to be put at the service of Europe. And by speaking before you and thinking of the 600,000 visitors to this fair, I wanted to take my responsibilities.

And I would like to conclude by saying this: the farmers of France have often been flattered, often, on the eve of elections - notice how there are always elections - you have often been flattered. What I want is to achieve results and for you to judge me not simply on words, on speeches, but on what we do with the Minister, on what we achieve and for which we fight. Often, in the past, it has been said: "But what do you know about agriculture?" It is true, I was not raised on a farm; with the number of books that have been written about me, you must know that. The values of the agricultural world are values that I know well. They are those of work, those of effort, those of merit, those of freedom, the freedom to work, those of family, it is the solidarity with family, with colleagues, with the territory and with the village; those values have made France, I was not elected to abandon those values, they are the ones I believe in most deeply. I add that if we let our countryside die, the disaster of our countryside today will be the tragedy of our cities tomorrow. There is not a countryside on one side and a city on the other. If we can no longer live in our countryside, we will be forced to go to our cities, where there is no housing, where there is not enough work, where there is not enough quality of life. So, I have the feeling, coming here, to this hall, apologizing for having been too long, but as you can see, I spoke with the passion I have for what you represent and for what French agriculture represents. I feel I am defending a model of French civilization. Thank you.