Letter of mission from Mr. Nicolas Sarkozy, President of the Republic, and Mr. François Fillon, Prime Minister, addressed to Mr. Eric Woerth, Minister of Budget, Public Accounts, and Civil Service, on the fight against fraud and abusive practices, October 11, 2007.

France Nicolas Sarkozy · President of France

11 October 2007

Context
Sarkozy and Fillon addressed a mission letter to Budget Minister Woerth on October 11, 2007, outlining a comprehensive plan to combat fraud against French public finances.
Main themes
Fraud prevention, public finances, mandatory contributions, social benefits fraud, undeclared work, tax fraud, sanctions and enforcement, European cooperation on VAT fraud, taxpayer rights, public trust in social systems, budget management
Duration
~13 min
44th percentile
Words
1,518
44th percentile
Sentences
49
32nd percentile
Readability
22
5th percentile
Grade
17.5
92nd percentile
Syntax
3.25
78th percentile
Vocabulary
2.35
83rd percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 63%63%
  • Social 16%16%
  • Economic 14%14%
  • Ceremonial 4%4%
  • Geopolitical 2%2%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

49 sentences in 22 paragraphs

Mr. Minister,

Fraud and abusive practices affecting the public finances of France have reached intolerable proportions: several tens of billions of euros each year according to the Council of Mandatory Contributions. This observation, even if it remains partial, reflects the widespread sentiment among our fellow citizens that public money is too often poorly managed and poorly spent, and sometimes wrongly collected.

The fight against fraud and abusive practices lies at the intersection of several of our strongest political concerns: the restoration of public finances, the rebuilding of trust in our social systems, the maintenance of a high level of solidarity, the acceptance of taxes, and the proper use of public funds.

Our ambition in the fight against fraud must be commensurate with the scale of this phenomenon. We must act, first and foremost, in the area of fraud related to mandatory contributions, which encompasses all forms of tax and social fraud, particularly undeclared work.

The French people are particularly expecting us, secondly, to combat fraud related to the numerous public aid schemes or social benefits in our country, including unemployment insurance, health insurance, family or old-age benefits, housing assistance, social minima, as well as subsidy schemes for businesses or agriculture.

The main axes of a new ambition for the fight against fraud

We ask you to initiate a systematic plan to combat all fraud and abusive practices that undermine public finances. You will ensure, first of all, that all relevant services are equipped with appropriate tools, in terms of procedures and sanctions, so that they can carry out more effective and better-targeted controls.

In the fiscal area, where the State already has proven verification methods, the increased effectiveness of the fight against fraud must be found in a balance between, on the one hand, better targeting of controls on dishonest taxpayers through the creation of procedures better suited to constantly evolving fraud techniques, and, on the other hand, the simplification of tax law and relations with the tax administration for all honest taxpayers.

To better target ephemeral fraudulent activities that evade controls by relying on high mobility, international networks, or the use of information technology, you will explore the modalities for introducing a "tax flagrant offense" procedure into our law. Similarly, in order to enhance our chances of sanctioning transnational fraud, primarily affecting VAT, you will prepare the proposals that France will formulate within the framework of the European Union presidency in the second half of 2008, aimed at improving information exchanges between control administrations and creating, in particular, a structure for exchange and coordination at the European level, modeled on Europol or Eurojust. At the same time, we insist that the rights of honest and good-faith taxpayers continue to be strengthened in their relationship with the administration, by all means you deem appropriate.

Regarding the fight against undeclared work, where significant gains in efficiency must be achieved, you will seek better coordination among the agents responsible for controls, whose investigative means you will strengthen by granting them the same communication rights as those enjoyed by tax services. Furthermore, to make the sanctions applicable to employers of undeclared workers more deterrent, you will ensure the effective application of minimum flat-rate fines, the creation of which will be proposed to Parliament as part of the social security financing bill. With this system, the employer of illegal work will be subject to a flat-rate fine corresponding to several months of evaded contributions, unless they can prove the date on which the hiring took place.

The challenge of combating fraud related to social benefits, the financial stakes of which are not even precisely known, is the one for which the most significant efforts must be made. Because this form of fraud and abuse undermines the very foundations of national cohesion, it must become a constant concern for all managing administrations: State, social security, local authorities, UNEDIC, complementary pension schemes, agricultural social mutuality, etc. You will ensure compliance with the conditions for payment and the counterparty requirements for the granting of certain allowances, and will propose, where appropriate, to clarify them. The failure of some beneficiaries to meet the obligations associated with the rights they enjoy is perceived as a profound injustice by all French people who strive to live decently from the fruits of their labor. We also ask you to expedite the preparation of texts allowing for the consideration of the abnormal lifestyle of certain beneficiaries to correct their resource declarations in cases of manifest disproportion.

Finally, for those who persist in defrauding the various benefits or aids established by the community, you will also strengthen the deterrent nature of the sanctions provided. It is indeed unacceptable that a fraudster can continue to benefit from the benefit or aid for which they sought to cheat. Depending on the severity of the offenses committed, it should be possible to suspend certain allowances for periods of one or several years.

A new administrative organization

Specifically regarding fraud related to social benefits, the fragmentation and compartmentalization of managing administrations (State, Social Security, joint organizations, local authorities) is an undeniable factor of complexity, even if it does not excuse the insufficient results our country achieves in controlling these expenditures. In light of this situation, it appears that a new administrative organization will be necessary to carry out the extensive plan to combat fraud that we wish to initiate.

You will propose a reform of the attributions, composition, and functioning of the National Committee for the Fight Against Fraud (CNLF), which will be chaired by the Prime Minister, whom you will assist, if necessary. This committee will bring together the main ministers concerned and will be endowed with expanded competencies in the action field defined above.

The first mission of this Committee will be to catalog the various forms of fraud and to define a methodology for evaluating them. In this regard, you will quickly initiate an inspection mission aimed at shedding light on fraud related to social benefits and public aid. It will also be the Committee's responsibility to ensure good coordination of control means across the entire field, as well as the rapid deployment of new investigative methods. In this respect, the Committee will explore, without taboos or preconceived notions, all possibilities for securing through increased computerization and the use of automatic file cross-referencing. On this point as well, it may usefully call upon a mission of technical and legal expertise. Armed with these analyses, the National Committee for the Fight Against Fraud will finally have the task of proposing all necessary improvements for an increasingly effective and better-targeted anti-fraud effort.

To ensure the secretariat of the CNLF and to provide you with all necessary support in your mission, a National Delegation for the Fight Against Fraud (DNLF) will be created and placed, by delegation from the Prime Minister, under the Minister of Budget, Public Accounts, and Civil Service. On this occasion, the DNLF will receive the attributions it needs from the interministerial delegation for the fight against illegal work (DILTI), which will be dissolved. In the interest of good administrative coordination, the DNLF will also provide the secretariat for the National Commission for the Fight Against Illegal Work, chaired by the Minister of Labor, Social Relations, and Solidarity, Mr. Xavier BERTRAND, who retains full authority over labor inspection.

A new dimension of public management

Beyond the necessary new means of control and sanction, you will, through the National Committee for the Fight Against Fraud, be responsible for integrating the fight against fraud into the operational, permanent objectives of State administrations and social organizations. Wherever possible, you will assign them specific deadlines for strengthening internal control systems, cross-referencing computer files, and deploying computer applications that allow for enhanced control. You will also include the fight against fraud as a priority objective in the various forms of management and performance contracts that bind the State to the administrations responsible for either the collection of contributions or the payment of benefits. On this occasion, in order to develop a culture of control where it may be lacking, you will examine whether it is appropriate, in certain cases, to establish forms of collective or individual incentives based on the results of the fight against fraud.

The new revenues linked to the fight against fraud, as well as the savings made on transfer expenditures, will make it possible to reduce the levies that still weigh on the work of the French people. That is why we wish for the efforts undertaken by public administrations, under your leadership, in the fight against fraud to be subject to precise accounting and an annual detailed presentation to Parliament.

During the various stages of the design and implementation of this action plan, you will work closely with the relevant ministers and social partners. You will also ensure that you consult all representative organizations of businesses and beneficiaries of aid and social benefits. We will review the progress of this particular mission in one year and any adjustments that may be necessary.

In renewing our confidence in you, we ask you to believe, Mr. Minister, in the assurance of our best sentiments.