Statement by Mr. Nicolas Sarkozy, President of the Republic, on the challenges of the French automotive industry, particularly environmental, in Paris on October 9, 2008.

France Nicolas Sarkozy · President of France

9 October 2008 · Mondial de l'Automobile · Paris, France

Context
Sarkozy addressed automotive industry leaders at the Paris Motor Show on October 9, 2008, outlining energy, environmental, and industrial challenges facing France's auto sector.
Main themes
French automotive industry, environmental challenges, energy transition, CO2 emissions reduction, post-oil era, industrial competitiveness, renewable energy, climate change, mobility and freedom, economic employment, sustainable development, French manufacturing decline
Duration
~36 min
88th percentile
Words
4,307
88th percentile
Sentences
215
90th percentile
Readability
52
68th percentile
Grade
10.9
31st percentile
Syntax
2.93
38th percentile
Vocabulary
2.13
33rd percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 63%58%
  • Environmental 16%14%
  • Institutional 13%12%
  • Ceremonial 6%5%
  • Geopolitical 3%2%
  • Social 1%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Not in focus 7%

215 sentences in 33 paragraphs

Mr. Minister of State, Dear Jean-Louis,

Mr. Minister, Dear Luc,

Presidents,

Ladies and Gentlemen, if you allow me, Dear Friends,

After the visit I have just made, I would like to share with you a very deep conviction: the love story between the French and the automobile is far from over. The passion for the automobile is very much alive in our country. It is no coincidence that the Mondial de l'Automobile is the largest trade show in the world for this sector. Ahead of Tokyo, ahead of Detroit, far ahead of Frankfurt. I would not say this on Saturday. It is no coincidence that this year, attendance is even greater. It is no coincidence that the automobile show is celebrating its hundredth anniversary in 2008, here in our country, which is also the cradle of the automobile industry and must remain so.

Moreover, we have several reasons, we French, to hold on to our automobile industry, which employs nearly 2.5 million people across the entire sector; that is no small matter, it represents 10% of the active population. Beyond the well-known major manufacturers, there exists a considerable number of suppliers and subcontractors who are at the heart of competitiveness and innovation in this sector, which remains the leading industrial sector in terms of research and development spending. With the automobile, we are at the heart of the real economy that we so desperately need, that is to say, an economy that produces, invests, and innovates to meet the needs of women and men.

But the automobile industry is today, I am convinced, at a turning point in its history. What a chance for you, the leaders, to be in a position where there is so much to change. I feel very much in solidarity with you. Three challenges:

An energy challenge, of course: the recent rise in the price of a barrel of oil, even though prices have since fallen again, they have fallen but are still double what they were in 2004. We depend almost entirely on our road transport. However, the world is on the verge of reaching - before 2020 in any case - the ceiling of its hydrocarbon production capacity. In short, it would be enough to wait... But if the supply of oil cannot rise and demand in transport, in emerging countries continues to grow strongly, then we can fear that the recent shock our economy experienced regarding oil prices is only the beginning of a long process. I remind you that before the financial crisis we are experiencing, we faced an unprecedented crisis in raw materials. We should not forget that. My responsibility is not to wait, to hope, and to trust. My responsibility is to prepare for the post-oil era right now. The 21st century will be the century of the end of oil, and it will therefore see the end of the car as we know it. The security of our energy supplies requires, in transport as in housing, that we organize the energy transition right now. It is crucial to reduce our dependence on fossil fuels, by making energy savings of course, but also by developing all forms of renewable and sustainable energy.

The second challenge, no less important, is the environmental challenge: the transport sector alone accounts for a quarter of global CO2 emissions; the automobile cannot remain aloof from the major ecological challenge that is the fight against climate change. Everywhere it is possible, everything must be done to reduce carbon dioxide emissions. The fact that it is possible to reduce our CO2 emissions more easily and at a lower cost in other areas such as buildings cannot serve as an excuse for inaction in transport. I will not allow anyone to caricature the automobile as the symbol of a society that exhausts resources and destroys the environment. The automobile has too often been an easy target for advocates of degrowth. Individual rapid transport is an extraordinary achievement of the 21st century for quality of life, economic efficiency, and openness to the world. Renouncing it in the name of ecology would be a major misunderstanding when technology today allows us to reconcile individual travel and respect for the planet. Sustainable development is not about abolishing freedom, it is not about going backward, it is not about renouncing the mobility that the car allows; it is about inventing modes of transport that are comfortable, safe, economical, and the most environmentally friendly. Environmental issues are serious matters that require people to come together to seek, to innovate, and to reconcile freedom, mobility, and respect for the planet.

The third challenge that you must face is the industrial challenge: the automobile industry is present both in each of our territories and around the world. It is an absolutely fundamental component of the French industrial tool. I do not accept the idea that France, which produced up to 3.2 million cars in 2004, now produces only 2.5 million in 2007. I do not accept the idea that a country with our automobile industry has become a net importer in the automotive sector. There is an urgent need to act. I want to affirm that the automobile industry, today and tomorrow, has its rightful place in France. I said it last Monday, with Carlos Ghosn, to the employees of Renault in Sandouville, the automobile in France is not over. I stand against all those who would confine our country to service activities, finance, and tourism. I remember those who spoke of the virtual economy, one where there were no customers, no products, where the only thing was to raise funds. One can have unconfessed desires when recalling all those people who gave lessons. The old economy was industry, a product, a customer. You remember all that. Of course, we need services, but if industry leaves, services will also leave, especially since they are even more easily relocatable. Absurd! France needs industry; this is a conviction I have deeply ingrained in me for a long time. The responsibility of the French public authorities is to support technological and industrial changes to ensure, in particular, the sustainability of sites, activities, and jobs in the French automotive sector.

These fundamental challenges, very difficult for you, I propose that we face together by giving ourselves the means to meet them.

We will first support the demand of our fellow citizens for more fuel-efficient and lower CO2-emitting vehicles. We will therefore maintain the bonus/malus system established at the end of last year for passenger cars sold in our country. It has proven, dear Jean-Louis Borloo, its undeniable effectiveness, as sales of vehicles benefiting from a bonus, that is to say, the most fuel-efficient and lowest CO2-emitting, have increased by 50% in the first six months of 2008. This maintenance will continue throughout 2009, with the same thresholds and amounts. Beyond its success in encouraging the French to equip themselves with cleaner vehicles, such support for the automotive market seems welcome in the current period we are going through. I add that this bonus/malus mechanism will be extended to other equipment goods, gradually and in consultation. I believe in the bonus/malus. I believe in the necessity of public authorities to encourage the purchase of clean vehicles to create a market and a virtuous circle. Because the more people buy clean vehicles, the less these vehicles will cost to manufacture. This is called market solvency. What I am saying is not particularly intelligent, but I believe in the bonus/malus. Let the message be heard once and for all. Jean-Louis Borloo could also testify to the consistency of the support for his idea that I have shown from the beginning. And indeed, if we had not had a bonus/malus, the last industrial production index would not be at the level it has been. The bonus/malus has been a bonus since, in total, I believe the State has paid 250 million euros more. That is very good; you need it. We must help you.

The State must also be exemplary in terms of sustainable development. It will therefore take its share by strictly limiting, through a decree, the emission ceiling of vehicles purchased by the State to 130 grams per kilometer traveled, which is the maximum threshold for vehicles benefiting from the bonus, starting January 1st next year. I am not the one who will tell others to do what we do not do. It is clear. The State demands, the State applies the same rule - there is no need to postpone this to the next Saint Glinglin - starting January 1st next year. And I especially want the State and its public establishments to engage in a particular effort to renew their vehicle fleet: too many vehicles, too powerful, too fuel-consuming, and too polluting. I want a very serious reorganization, including and especially in the conditions for granting so-called "company" vehicles, but I also intend for all vehicles older than ten years to be replaced, starting in 2009, by new vehicles that are more fuel-efficient and more environmentally friendly. This project will be conducted as part of the second phase of the State reform, which I intend to initiate in the coming weeks, starting in 2009. We will spend money to invest. Ultimately, this will save money in the end and support the market, which also needs it.

At the European level, France, holding the Presidency of the European Union, intends to contribute to the continuation of efforts to design vehicles, again, more fuel-efficient and emitting as little CO2 as possible. This is precisely the purpose of the European regulation project on CO2 emissions from vehicles, which is currently under negotiation. France will continue to defend an ambitious environmental agreement, that is to say, an agreement that allows for a significant reduction in CO2 emissions by 2012 compared to today and which will lead, after 2020, to a new significant reduction in emission thresholds. But for this ambition to take shape, I want to remind you that an agreement must be reached with all our partners. We are not alone. In any case, the complete absence of an agreement constitutes the most unfavorable option for the environment. We are negotiating.

Just as France supports the objective of 20% renewable energy in our final energy consumption by 2020, I want our country to continue to increase the share of renewable energy in transport. Starting next year, we will begin to replace some unleaded 98 gasoline pumps with a fuel containing 10% ethanol, E10. The target for the incorporation of biofuels by oil companies is confirmed at 7% until 2010, which is even beyond the European objectives. In the same perspective, I want flex-fuel vehicles, running on E85, to be quickly exempted from the malus that currently affects them and which does not take into account the full environmental benefit of such vehicles. Finally, the State will continue to engage alongside pilot projects for the production of second-generation biofuels, which is extremely important. These projects are intended to become references in Europe and the world in terms of green chemistry and future biofuels. There is no need to remain at the first generation, especially with the story of rising agricultural raw material prices. The second generation is much more promising.

Finally, as in the days of the French automotive pioneers, I want France to become the place where the technological breakthroughs of tomorrow are imagined and prepared, the place where the vehicle of the future is invented, one that will allow the world to reconcile mobility, growth, and respect for the environment. This is the very high ambition I set for us for the coming years. To achieve this, France will engage, starting now, in a vast research and support plan for "decarbonized vehicles," that is to say, vehicles with the lowest possible CO2 emissions, whether they are fully electric vehicles or rechargeable hybrid vehicles.

I feel that we are at a historic turning point in the mode of propulsion of vehicles. I know well that the end of the internal combustion engine has been predicted a hundred times and that so far we have been wrong a hundred times. But I believe that in this year 2008, three major changes are coming together: the rise in oil prices makes alternative energies more profitable than ever, batteries have made absolutely extraordinary technological progress, and finally, there is a collective awareness of the climate emergency. All of this has happened very quickly, in just a few years. I therefore believe that within three years, no manufacturer will be able to afford to complete their range without offering "decarbonized vehicles." I point to the cooperation agreements signed today between EDF and our two major national manufacturers, Renault and Peugeot-Citroën, on electric vehicles. This evolution, which is now possible, is up to us to bring to fruition as quickly as possible, and in the best interests of the French people.

I would like to add that no one would understand that France, which is the country best positioned to promote the development of electric vehicles, because it has CO2-free electricity, at a guaranteed long-term cost, with virtually no external dependence. No other country has as many reasons to promote the development of this sector. We will not deprive ourselves of doing so.

This plan that I am announcing to you will include a significant component of support for research and development of decarbonized vehicles. To make them available, with all the guarantees of cost, performance, and safety, we must invest massively in research. In total, we will mobilize 400 million euros of public funding over the next four years, exclusively for R&D on decarbonized vehicles. These funds are already available from the additional one billion euros allocated to research by the Grenelle of the Environment and in the competitiveness clusters and from the "demonstrator" fund of ADEME, which has just launched its first call for projects.

On the specific subject of the batteries that will equip all decarbonized vehicles tomorrow, I ask Jean-Louis Borloo and Luc Chatel to take charge of this absolutely strategic industrial issue, in order to best coordinate public and private efforts, particularly in the competitiveness clusters concerned with this technology. I remind you that we have allocated 1.5 billion euros to the competitiveness clusters to promote research and development.

The "decarbonized vehicles" plan that I propose to you today will also include an important component of support for demand for such vehicles. Let us be pragmatic, for once. For the price of vehicles to be affordable, they must be produced in series. This is absolutely essential. For investments in mass production to be made, there must be assurance that a solvent demand exists. I believe it is time to break out of this dilemma. The ecological bonus of 5,000 euros, already available for any vehicle emitting less than 60 grams of CO2/km, will be extended to light commercial vehicles and maintained in these terms until 2012. This is about giving visibility to both buyers and manufacturers, and this system is only intended to be re-examined, if necessary, once the threshold of 100,000 decarbonized vehicles has been reached. Understand me, it is quite logical. Until now, I have been told: "consumers say I won't buy it, it's too expensive." And manufacturers say: "I won't produce it, there isn't enough demand." We are all looking at each other like a standoff. We need to make demand solvent. We will therefore massively solvent demand through the bonus, which we will keep and extend. But naturally, I say, we do not intend to subsidize the purchase of vehicles for life. That is not the role of the State. So I am sort of landing on my feet, at least in terms of coherence. When the solvent demand is sufficiently large, I have set the target at 100,000 decarbonized vehicles, we can discuss, negotiate, and debate. Jean-Louis Borloo and Luc Chatel will lead this. Is it 100,000? Is it more? Is it less? It doesn't matter, but at that point, I believe we will have truly entered into mass production and that we must let the market fulfill its function of matching supply and demand. I believe that at that point we will have really been able to lower the cost of mass production.

I think that by announcing the date of 2012, we are giving manufacturers enough clarity to invest in this.

At the same time, always the same reasoning, I cannot stand this idea where the State makes injunctions and then behaves differently. This is no longer acceptable. At the same time, I want the State to set itself the objective of better coordinating the purchases, dear Jean-Louis, of decarbonized vehicle fleets by both public and private organizations. I ask administrations and leaders of major public establishments and companies to quickly communicate - that is, before the end of the year - the contribution they could make to this objective. I have noted that La Poste, dear Jean-Paul Bailly, - if he is not here, we will convey my friendship and my request, well, my request and my friendship - was willing to acquire 10,000 decarbonized vehicles by 2012, and I cannot imagine, dear Pierre Gadonneix, that you would attach less importance to my friendship and my request. EDF cannot lag behind when it comes to vehicles for which it will produce and distribute the fuel. You see, our goal, Jean-Louis Borloo and Luc Chatel, is to create a solvent market. We will help you with research, we will help you kickstart the market, after that, it is up to you with your teams, your technicians, your know-how, to continue the effort. But France, a country of nuclear energy, must absolutely be a leader in electric vehicles; I imagine that within the family there are plenty of possibilities, we must also let competition and the market do their work.

The development of decarbonized vehicles also implies a profound evolution in the way we distribute electricity in our country. First, we must be able to charge at home. Each individual will have to organize themselves in existing buildings, but I want at the very least that new constructions integrate charging points for vehicles from the outset. Charging is absolutely crucial; you see the context we are in. We must be able to charge at every stop, at work, at the supermarket, in parking lots. I want us to mobilize the managers of each of these spaces, Jean-Louis, either through regulation, through concession contracts, or through simple commercial interest, to undertake an equipment program allowing for vehicle charging. Finally, we must equip urban spaces, public roads, with the creation of stations suitable for fast charging.

It is essential to coordinate this equipment, to program it, and I want the State to commit to this program. Because manufacturers will not make vehicles if they cannot sell them, and manufacturers will not sell vehicles if the charging infrastructure is not available. We understand the work we have to do on our side.

These investments represent considerable sums. But they will be spread over a long period and shared among individuals, local authorities, electricity distributors, public space managers, and will likely be amortized through the sale of electricity. I remind you that France, after all, to those who tell me that I want to spend money, I want to remind you that France paid 47 billion euros in oil bills in 2007, more than half of which was for transport. So this is not an investment that should scare us. France has the means to invest; France does not have the means to accumulate operating expenses.

But the reality is that equipping our country requires a thorough adaptation of our technical standards, our urban planning and co-ownership rules, and even energy pricing, Pierre. I therefore ask Jean-Louis Borloo and Luc Chatel to establish as soon as possible a working group on these issues, bringing together energy distributors, automobile manufacturers, representatives of local authorities, building professionals, and more broadly all public space managers. The proposals must be available by June 2009 on the necessary normative evolutions, the programming of investments, and their financing, because my ambition is that we have voted on all the necessary laws and taken all the necessary decrees before January 1, 2010. 2009 is the year when we will evolve the standards, the equipment, the pricing, so that you, the manufacturers, can fully engage in the development of decarbonized vehicles.

Finally - this is the last component of the "decarbonized vehicles" development plan that I am announcing to you and not the least - the State will be present alongside all French automotive industries engaged in the vast technological transformation imposed by the development of the electric motor. I have never had the slightest scruple in defending a strong intervention of the State to protect our industrial heritage. At least give me credit for the longevity of my reflection on the subject. This is also what will guide me in the reform I wish to make to the professional tax, which has the absolutely ridiculous and unique characteristic in the world of taxing and thus discouraging investment in our territory. And I will not leave things as they are. So I am fully aware of the problems this may pose for local authorities. I am fully aware of all this, but I do not intend to keep a tax that penalizes our industry, that penalizes our competitiveness, that penalizes our development. And the year 2009 will be the year of the professional tax reform and the easing of the French territorial map. So, I know it is difficult, but I fear that I was elected to tackle difficult issues. The easy issues, rest assured, my predecessors did not hesitate to resolve! There is naturally no criticism, but how funny it is, I see only difficult issues, so the easy issues... well, everyone starts with what they want.

So finally, I would like to conclude with something that I believe to be profoundly true: I am for the freedom of commerce, I am for the market economy. Finally, I see that the U.S. Treasury is preparing to grant 25 billion euros in long-term loans, at unbeatable rates, to its three automobile manufacturers so that they can renovate their factories that are over 20 years old, so the real doubt that grips me - because I sometimes doubt - is: are we Europeans, much, much, much too naive? When I say that I doubt... But I believe that we are too naive and I believe above all that this has gone on long enough. This means that it has gone on long enough. I am for friendship with the United States; I do not need to demonstrate it. Our partners and friends support their manufacturers with all their might. That is their strictest right. But then, I do not want us to live in a framework where we would not have the right to help our manufacturers in the same way to engage in a major technological transformation, crucial for environmental protection and vital for the energy security of our country. I therefore intend to propose to the European Commission and our European partners to revise the community framework for state aid. Why? Well, simply to align this community framework for state aid with the very goals we are pursuing within the framework of the climate-energy package. There is a manifest question of coherence here. We cannot tell our manufacturers here are the environmental protection objectives that are ours and at the same time, we do not help you achieve them. Worse, not only do we not help you because we have set competition rules, of which we have not understood that competition is a means and not an end. This is what I have been explaining for years. But moreover, we seriously harm your competitiveness by seeing others do what we ourselves prohibit. This makes no sense. And I will not let anyone, by the way, say that I am not for Europe. Europe, in my eyes, is made to protect, to encourage, to support, and not to be this kind of informal organization where nothing can be said or done. Following, by the way, a manifest absence of thought.

So, I want to propose to our European partners to consider opening a strategic intervention axis of the European Investment Bank (EIB) in favor of European automobile companies, as long as they resolutely commit to the path of "decarbonized vehicles." The EIB has previously intervened in the strategic fields of aeronautics and space. It is just as strategic and urgent that the European automotive industry succeeds in the technological and industrial transformation that lies ahead.

Ladies and gentlemen, we are on the brink of an exciting period for the automotive industry, for the French people, and for us as political decision-makers. It is not so often that we can, around major technological projects, unite and reconcile our economic, environmental, and human interests. This is the case today. It is the case thanks to you, to researchers, to industrialists, to consumers, to civil society, to environmental NGOs. If we are here today, it is thanks to all those who have prepared and enabled a true energy transition to begin, to prepare for the post-oil era. As in the thermal insulation of buildings or the development of renewable energies, this is a true dynamic of growth. A sustainable growth, a growth rich in jobs, a growth respectful of the environment, beneficial to all and economical with our resources. I have come today to propose that the car, a symbol of yesterday's growth and prosperity, also be the vector of tomorrow's growth.

I hope you understand, the French State is indeed behind the automotive industry.

Thank you.