Statement by Mr. Nicolas Sarkozy, President of the Republic, in agreement with all the heads of state and government of the countries of the European Union, on the necessary measures to be taken for the stabilization of the financial system, in Paris on October 6, 2008.

France Nicolas Sarkozy · President of France

6 October 2008 · Statement on the measures to stabilise the financial system (meeting of EU heads of state and government) · Paris, France

Context
Sarkozy addressed EU heads of state and government in Paris on October 6, 2008, presenting coordinated European measures to stabilize the financial system amid the global financial crisis.
Main themes
European financial crisis response, banking system stabilization, coordinated EU government action, financial market regulation reform, accounting standards reform, global financial system reform, state aid flexibility, shareholder accountability, international summit call, hedge funds and rating agency oversight, executive remuneration reform, Paulson plan acknowledgment
Duration
~35 min
87th percentile
Words
4,219
87th percentile
Sentences
209
90th percentile
Readability
47
55th percentile
Grade
11.5
39th percentile
Syntax
2.90
35th percentile
Vocabulary
2.13
33rd percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 56%56%
  • Ceremonial 15%15%
  • Institutional 14%14%
  • Geopolitical 9%9%
  • Social 5%5%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

209 sentences in 52 paragraphs

Ladies and Gentlemen,

We have agreed that I will briefly present the decisions we have made, then each of my colleagues and friends will present a few minutes of reflection, and we will respond to one question from each participant in this meeting.

Here are the decisions we have been led to make.

The first: we have made a solemn commitment from the heads of state and government to support banking and financial institutions in the face of the crisis. Each government will act according to its own methods and means, but in a coordinated manner with other European states. In a way, we have established a doctrine.

Secondly, in the event of public support for a struggling bank, each member state present at this meeting commits to ensuring that failing leaders are held accountable and that shareholders also bear the burden of the intervention.

Thirdly, given the exceptional nature of the economic and financial circumstances, the European Commission must demonstrate flexibility in the application of state aid rules for businesses as well as in the principles of the single market; in these areas, it must decide as quickly as possible given the urgency.

Fourthly, similarly, the application of the stability and growth pact must reflect the exceptional circumstances in which we find ourselves, according to the provisions of the pact designed for this purpose.

Fifthly, to put European banks on the same footing as their international competitors, the heads of state and government request that accounting rules regarding the classification of assets in bank balance sheets be modified to take into account the duration of holding these assets by banks.

The Commission, on the one hand, and the accounting standard-setting bodies, on the other, must work urgently to resolve this issue before the end of the month.

Furthermore, we have also been concerned about the medium term. We call for an international summit as soon as possible, with the most affected states, on the re-founding of the global financial system. This re-founding will be organized around the following principles: all actors in financial markets must be regulated or monitored, not just commercial banks. In practice, this concerns rating agencies, investment banks, and hedge funds. Secondly, accounting and prudential standards must be reviewed to prevent the creation of speculative bubbles when things are going well and liquidity crises like those we are experiencing when things are going poorly. The remuneration systems for market operators and executives will be reviewed to prevent them from encouraging excessive risk-taking to combat what can be called "short-termism."

Fourthly, the strengthening of political oversight over the various international institutions responsible for regulating markets and setting accounting and prudential standards will be initiated to ensure the coherence of their actions.

Finally, we call for the establishment of a task force in times of crisis between supervisors, central banks, and finance ministries.

We also wanted to acknowledge the decisions made in the United States with the adoption by Congress of the PAULSON plan, which contributes to stability and confidence.

Ladies and Gentlemen, we are fully aware of the responsibilities that weigh on our shoulders to restore and bring back confidence and to rise to the events we are experiencing. As you can see, this meeting was necessary, and I believe it is productive.

I will now give the floor to Angela MERKEL.

MRS. ANGELA MERKEL - Ladies and Gentlemen, I am pleased that at this meeting we have been able to reach the agreements presented by Nicolas SARKOZY. I believe that this meeting is a contribution to the trust we must place in our financial system. Trust that is essential. This trust is important for the businesses in our countries, this trust is important for taxpayers, for savers in our countries, and we have agreed to establish a coherent approach where there are national responsibilities for each member state, of course, but we must also ensure that European member states do not create disadvantages for themselves due to their national decisions. And we know the responsibility of political leaders, but the lesson to be learned from this financial crisis must be to hold those responsible accountable on the one hand, and on the other hand, to equip ourselves with the rules and mechanisms that will prevent these crises in the future. For this, we demand, and I am pleased, that we wish for an international meeting because we cannot do it alone in Europe. I am very happy that we talked about accounting standards. We indicated that an agreement should be reached by the end of this month; this is a very important signal to banks and financial institutions.

MR. GORDON BROWN - I would like to thank President SARKOZY for organizing this meeting. In Britain, we are doing everything in our power to ensure the security and stability that households and businesses need. The same message is coming today from all European members of the G8. The message to families and businesses is that, just as our central banks are already doing, liquidity will be ensured to preserve confidence and stability. We have agreed that we need to do more to coordinate our responses in times of crisis and in the interest of stability, including deciding to organize an international meeting where we will present to leaders the five principles of integrity, accountability, and coordination of the system, five principles that we have approved today.

This crisis that has come to us from America has affected all businesses, so we have decided to ask the European Investment Bank to provide £25 million in financial means for loans to SMEs. We have also decided to do much more to clean up the system when irresponsibility has prevailed, and we have decided today to establish a college of supervisors. I believe that the coordination we are showing in Europe will be extended and repeated by the international meeting we have decided upon, which will bring together the major countries of the world.

MR. SILVIO BERLUSCONI - I will not repeat what my colleagues have said. I will simply say that today we have clearly seen the willingness of the European governments that have gathered to guarantee the savings of their citizens and to preserve citizens' confidence in our banking system. A system that must be able to continue its indispensable role of support and assistance to the real economy, both for businesses and consumers. This is what was expected of us, what our European citizens expected of us. Well, this is what we have committed to do as European governments. The governments that have gathered here have taken a first step; then, on Tuesday in Luxembourg, there will be a meeting of the finance ministers of the 27 European countries, and I think that around the 15th of the month, this will be concluded by the meeting of the European Council. The European Central Bank, the Commission, ECOFIN, and the European Council will work from today on new rules for the transparency of the presentation of accounts of banking institutions, for the accountability of their management, for the adaptation of accounting rules, and for the strengthening of controls that have been applied by rating agencies and which have proven inadequate. I personally express my satisfaction following this meeting. I hope that our finance ministers and all of us from the 27 countries within the European Council can transform what has been written in this document, which is a document of proposals to our partners. I thank President SARKOZY for convening us here, we, members of the G8, at a time when the G8 is not functional since there has been a change of Prime Minister in Japan and we are also experiencing a moment of transfer of responsibilities of the G8 Presidency to the Europeans, as Italy will be responsible for the G8 starting next year.

MR. JOSE MANUEL BARROSO - Thank you. First of all, I would like to express my satisfaction and commend the spirit of true cooperation, the recognition of the European dimension in this very important issue, and the willingness to achieve coherence and coordination of European efforts in order to strengthen stability and confidence.

Regarding, more concretely, the work of the Commission, I am pleased that we now have a consensus among all participants in this meeting to quickly make a proposal to amend accounting rules to prevent our European banks from being at a disadvantage compared to other banks. I believe we can also move forward with a proposal for regulation aimed at better regulating rating agencies. You know that this Wednesday, the Commission presented a proposal regarding the capital requirements for banks and also presented proposals for supervisory colleges.

We will also launch, by the end of the year, a legislative initiative aimed at improving existing deposit guarantee rules, ensuring better convergence between national systems. There was also a consensus among all participants on this initiative. Finally, the Commission has decided to set up a high-level independent expert group to study ways to strengthen and improve the framework of financial supervision in Europe. Based on a report they will provide us, we will make further proposals in the future.

The essential message is that we have achieved a great convergence between the actions we must take in the short term and other more structural actions that we can promote to strengthen stability and confidence.

MR. JEAN-CLAUDE JUNCKER - In the face of the serious financial crisis, the most serious we have experienced since the end of the Second World War, Europe cannot react in a disorganized manner. This was a meeting of a Europe that wants to act in a coherent and consistent way. The essential message that emerges from our work is that liquidity will be ensured with the aim of restoring the confidence that is currently lacking. But it is clear, as Mrs. MERKEL said, that the obligation is not only that of governments, but that the private sector must also participate in the effort that is its own to establish confidence.

The stability and growth pact will be fully respected, in accordance with the provisions of the pact as amended in March 2005, which allow us to give it a more economic perspective. It is clear that regulation will become more precise and detailed without becoming a stranglehold. But all actors must know that in terms of supervision, other ancillary elements, reality will become different from what it was.

I would like to draw your attention to the fact that all of Europe must react. And so we will have with the member states, the European Union, which was not represented here, a virtuous dialogue on which we will agree. We will begin to do this next Monday, at the meeting of the Eurogroup, and Tuesday, at the ECOFIN meeting.

MR. JEAN-CLAUDE TRICHET - Mr. President, I believe this was indeed an important meeting for the entire European Union and certainly for the euro area. We welcome the measures taken since the beginning of the financial crisis by the European Central Bank, by the Bank of England, and by other central banks. I had the opportunity during this meeting to recall what we have done and all the decisions we have made to ensure liquidity in Europe, and I also provided figures, particularly regarding term refinancing. €420 billion corresponds to decisions we have made to ensure the liquidity of the banking system in exceptional circumstances. Our normal refinancing itself is at €190 billion, which is in addition to what I just mentioned.

I also mentioned that we have intimate cooperation on the international level, particularly with the sister institution, the Federal Reserve, and that we will ensure liquidity in dollars in Europe with a "swap" agreement we have with the Federal Reserve of $240 billion. Simply this to give an idea of the orders of magnitude.

I believe that this meeting, which includes many important guidelines that we approve at the European Central Bank, will allow us to face circumstances that indeed require responsibility from all actors, determination, a lot of determination, and which must enable, as we strive to do in our field, to strengthen, preserve, and enhance trust. Because trust is certainly the most important ingredient in the current circumstances.

I believe that the conclusions you have before you are aimed at a significant strengthening of trust.

QUESTION - (inaudible)

MR. GORDON BROWN - We chose to save Northern Rock; British depositors have been protected. Where we have acted, we have done what was necessary, and we will continue to do what is necessary to preserve the stability of the financial system. And today, we have agreed to say, as central banks are already doing, that liquidity will be ensured to preserve stability and confidence. That is the message that all European citizens want to hear.

QUESTION - I would like to ask Mr. BARROSO, you have called for a structured European response. Are you satisfied with the response?

MR. JOSE MANUEL BARROSO - I am very satisfied. I believe there has been a great degree of convergence and common will and commitment regarding the European dimension. There will be other meetings. Next Monday, next Tuesday the ECOFIN, on October 15 the European Council. I am convinced that a strong consensus is possible. I would like to emphasize that what we have established has been confirmed, namely the competition rules on state aid. This has been applied with the necessary flexibility.

It is also clear that we will continue with the European stability pact. This pact is very important for growth and stability. It will be done within a framework of flexibility and adaptability. Our fundamental policies provided for flexibility and adaptability. And there has really been an expression of the need for coherence among all European partners. I believe this is a global issue. And it required finding global solutions as well.

QUESTION - Madam Chancellor, you have called for a coherent approach from all. What about Ireland, since Ireland is the only country that provides a guarantee for all deposits? How do you respond to that? Also regarding competition among banks?

MS. ANGELA MERKEL - We have asked the Commission to seek dialogue with Ireland. We have also asked the European Central Bank to do so. It is of course important that we have a balanced approach, that we do not inflict mutual harm. And therefore, decisions must be in accordance with European competition rules. And today, we have established that we believe the Commission and the European Central Bank should open discussions with the Irish government.

I repeat that it is unnecessary to make further public statements. In hearing my response, you see that my satisfaction is, after all, measured.

QUESTION - A question for President SARKOZY. If I understood correctly, our finance minister said that a European fund of 400 million should be created to help European banks. Why did you abandon this proposal and who among your colleagues opposed it?

THE PRESIDENT - I had all the less difficulty in abandoning this proposal. I never assumed, proposed, or imagined it. Is my answer sufficient?

I add that I will therefore answer a question that you did not ask me. What is very important is that, in the face of a global crisis, Europe exists and presents a response. What is very important is that we have responses to the urgency. That is what we are doing. And that we all commit together to call for the organization of a summit so that tomorrow, the same causes do not produce the same effects. This is a true refoundation that we must address. There is the crisis. There are emergency measures. There is coordinated action. We are fully aware of our responsibilities.

And then there is the future. The future, in a few weeks or a few months. But we want to lay the foundations for a capitalism of entrepreneurs and not of speculators. We want transparency. We want moralization. We want value creation. We want people to have confidence. And we want, in fact, from this crisis, that it results in what the Bretton Woods agreements were, 60 years ago, a new world. That at least from all this, from all these problems, we know how to make it an opportunity to build something in which people will have confidence. And whether we are English, German, Italian, whether we are at the Central Bank, at the Commission, whether we are group presidents, we all agree on this.

Each of our countries has its rules, its legislation, its culture, and each has decided to take a step towards the other to present a coherent face. Europe exists and has a will. So we will continue, as Silvio Berlusconi said, with the ECOFIN, with the European Council on the 15th, with the summit for which we have requested a meeting. I myself, as President of the Council, have met with the Irish Prime Minister, the Dutch Prime Minister, I will have lunch with the Spanish Prime Minister, I will meet with the Polish Prime Minister, and I will have contacts with other member states. What matters is that Europe fights for its ideas, for its values, that it defends them. Not to impose them on others, but to restore confidence. We want a capitalism of entrepreneurs, once again. We do not want this speculation. That is why we have gathered, and it is a long journey with other meetings to follow. Of course, there were cultural differences; otherwise, we would not need to meet. But it is not a drama. It is not today that we ignore that there is an Anglo-Saxon culture, that Germany has its own organization in Länder, that Mediterranean countries may have other ideas. Everyone knows that. And it only adds to the merit of the necessity we had to meet, to listen to each other, and to find a compromise. In service of whom? Well, in service of Europeans. And we hope for the whole world, which needs Europe to manifest its stability. In the context of elections in the United States, elections in Japan, we must take our responsibilities. Thank you for not asking me that question, and I was very happy to answer it.

QUESTION - Mr. TRICHET, your responsibility is being emphasized, particularly regarding interest rates. There is a very strong expectation, especially from French consumers; there is a problem with credit, there is a problem with financing for individuals to build their homes, banks are refusing loans. How can you act?

MR. JEAN-CLAUDE TRICHET - My answer is all the simpler because, as you know, we just met last Thursday at the Governing Council, and I indicated what our diagnosis was. I could simply say: European households, the 320 million Europeans who are our fellow citizens in the euro area today - we will be 325 million when the sixteenth country joins us on January 1st - can count on us to ensure price stability. And I would say that this is very important for household confidence. It is of considerable importance; they can count on us to ensure that companies themselves have medium and long-term credit that incorporates a low level of inflation over the medium and long term. And finally, it is also very important for financial stability that we can be counted on to be an anchor of stability. So, in this area, I would say that we contribute as much as we can to confidence, and I have been able to express confidence in the fact that we have gradually regained control, if I may say so, over inflationary tensions. I said that there are still some and that they have decreased.

QUESTION - I believe everyone is aware that Europe alone cannot do everything, as Madam MERKEL said. What type of collaboration and what type of awareness of the problem do you expect from the American authorities? You have called for an international meeting; what will be the implications from Washington regarding this problem and for this meeting?

MR. SILVIO BERLUSCONI - We must say that we are all pleased with the decision made by the United States. This decision should ensure that banks and the financial world in the United States reach a level such that they will no longer pose a difficulty for the European economy and the global economy. With the United States, with other major economic systems, China and India, we are working to refound a global system within banking institutions, and we will do so through a new format that we have decided to implement within the G8. That is to say, not only the meeting of the eight most industrialized countries in the world but also the meeting of the fourteen most important, that is, beyond, China or South Africa, which will host representatives from the African continent during a working day. The new G8 will represent more than 80% of the world economy. This seems to me the ideal place to carry all this out, to make a decision regarding the refoundation of the world's banking and financial systems. I believe it is important to remind our fellow citizens that Europe does not run the risks of the American system. European citizens, Europeans are savers. They are, to a very large extent, homeowners. There has been no drop in housing prices. In Italy, we have an economy based on businesses, and we know very well that it is the real economy and work that create wealth and not the financial world, and this is true for Italy and for Europe. What we have decided to develop together with the support of ECOFIN, the Commission, and the European Council seems to me entirely appropriate to prevent upheavals in our banking system. Banks must continue to support our businesses. On behalf of my colleagues, we wrote in the conclusions, I would like to congratulate the European Investment Bank, which has decided to allocate 30 billion euros for financing SMEs. We address the same Bank with a request: that it supports the projects of major European infrastructures and that it takes on a larger share of the risks that banks will encounter when financing the small and medium-sized enterprise system. We believe that these directives, which will be translated very quickly into concrete decisions, can have the effect of allowing us to overcome this crisis, the most serious since 1929. Nevertheless, European governments are united and ready, and determined to implement all necessary decisions.

To answer a question that was not asked of me - but I will follow Mr. SARKOZY and do as he did - I would say that today's situation is very different from the situation in 1929. At that time, finances were completely detached from the real world. Today, our stock markets, without trauma, have conducted an evaluation of companies well below their actual capacity to generate wealth. Many companies have seen their stock decrease by 70% compared to their value a year ago. Nevertheless, they generate the same profits as a year ago, so what is most important? It is to support the real economy so that there is no decrease in consumption and production and to maintain the profitability of our companies. We tell investors, shareholders: be calm because, today, your stocks undervalued by the market will regain their value. When I am asked how long it will take, I say 18 or 24 months, and I would say that those who have invested in our industries, well, they have nothing to fear in a future that does not concern us from this point of view.

QUESTION - Given this situation, should there not be a general reflection to consider at the ECOFIN council, and that these financial instruments, these extravagant speculations be purely and simply banned if they cause so much damage to the real economy? In Germany, there is a broad debate on this issue, as Mr. BERLUSCONI just mentioned, there is indeed a real debate in the population to relegate such things to casinos.

MR. JEAN-CLAUDE JUNCKER - I do not want, at my age, to start a career as a casino visitor. Risky financial products are poorly understood. We need increased transparency; we must know what is happening, and I would add, banks must know what is happening because I assert that many banks do not know exactly what is happening. One can be imaginative, inventive, and shift the risk of one's own irresponsibility onto others. That is a game that must come to an end. As President SARKOZY said, we want a capitalism of entrepreneurship and not a capitalism of adventure. That is not acceptable. And we would like the compensation structures of bank executives to be changed so that they are not rewarded when they expose their institutions and their clients to reckless risks. This perverse logic must be broken.

MR. SILVIO BERLUSCONI - I would like to add something to this. We need to bring ethics back into the world of finance. Those who offer savers products that they know very well do not correspond to reality, that is not acceptable.

THE PRESIDENT - You have noted that Silvio BERLUSCONI continues his response to the first question. Ladies and gentlemen, thank you.