Statement by Mr. Nicolas Sarkozy, President of the Republic, on the relations between the European Union and Russia, in Evian on October 8, 2008.

France Nicolas Sarkozy · President of France

8 October 2008 · Conference on "Where is the world going?" (Evian, October 2008) · Evian, France

Context
Sarkozy addressed the Evian Conference on October 8, 2008, focusing on EU-Russia relations and global governance amid the financial crisis, with Russian President Medvedev present.
Main themes
EU-Russia relations, new multilateralism and international governance, global financial crisis, multipolarity and world order, international institutional reform, European Union presidency, Cold War fears, Russia's resurgence, coordinated global response, G8 expansion, financial regulation
Duration
~27 min
79th percentile
Words
3,251
79th percentile
Sentences
134
76th percentile
Readability
43
42nd percentile
Grade
13.3
59th percentile
Syntax
3.02
50th percentile
Vocabulary
2.21
52nd percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Geopolitical 75%72%
  • Economic 12%12%
  • Ceremonial 8%8%
  • Social 2%2%
  • Institutional 2%2%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 3%

134 sentences in 36 paragraphs

Ladies and Gentlemen, Heads of State and Government,

Dear Dmitri,

Dear Thierry de Montbrial,

By choosing the central theme "Where is the world going?", the organizers of this Conference could not have been more accurate: today, it is indeed the feeling of a world without a compass and without reference points that prevails.

After several decades in which the world was divided into two camps, the unipolar order around which it was predicted the world would organize has not withstood the multiplication of crises, the development of global challenges, and the emergence of new powers. We are facing a radically new situation, which opens the era of "relative powers," and which therefore generates instability. No actor, no matter how powerful, can alone resolve crises, face challenges, or even rally the world to its own vision of things.

I said it three weeks ago before the United Nations General Assembly: instability and disorder will amplify if we do not adapt the international institutions inherited from a now obsolete order to the realities of the 21st century. This new multipolarity will only give birth to a new balance, that is to say, it will only be a factor of peace and prosperity, if we know how to frame it together through a new multilateralism. This involves, for France, the enlargement of the Security Council, the opening of the G8 to major emerging powers. We are in the 21st century, we have international organizations from the 20th century; what is surprising is that it works as well as it does, despite that. It is time to change our organization.

The unprecedented financial storm that has shaken the world for more than a year and which has escalated in recent weeks confirms the terms of this analysis to the point of caricature: the financial crisis that originated in the United States has spread everywhere in the world, a consequence of globalization—no country, even among those best endowed with natural resources and foreign exchange reserves, is immune to its repercussions, even if some are resisting better than others—only the coordinated action of central banks and governments will be able to stem the systemic risk and ensure the financing of economies; there can be no isolated response to global challenges. France and the European Presidency are working on this global and coordinated response. In the coming hours, we will find its realization. By revealing the extent of the excesses of a financial capitalism left to its own devices, the exorbitant cost to society, the crisis has thus demonstrated the urgency of defining a new regulatory framework that will prevent future excesses and refocus the financial system on its true function, which is to finance the economy. This is the goal of the expanded G8 Summit that I have proposed to hold before the end of the year. I thank Dmitri Medvedev for understanding this initiative and Russia for being ready to join it. I also tell the Russian President that, in my mind, the G8 is a minimum.

I will not dwell further, Ladies and Gentlemen, on France's vision for building a new international governance. I have already outlined it, and the presence today of Russian President Dmitri Medvedev and my role as President of the European Council gives me the opportunity to focus my remarks on a subject that I consider fundamental: the future of relations between Russia and the European Union.

Let us not hide it, and we know each other well enough, President Medvedev and I, to speak frankly: the relationship between Russia and the European Union has just undergone a severe test. I draw the conclusion that the European Union and Russia must not drift apart, raising the fear of a new division of Europe, even reviving the fantasies of a "new Cold War." This new Cold War would be a historical mistake.

For several years, Russia has made a comeback: a return to growth leading to new wealth—a return of state authority—a return of Russia's influence on the international stage. The world, and Europe more than anyone, has an interest in a prosperous, stable Russia engaged in world affairs. This is our interest. Europe wants a strong Russia: the history of European construction, let us think a little, the history of our continent has taught us that a good neighbor is a happy neighbor. But the vigor of this return has surprised and sometimes worried: internally, the modalities of restoring state authority have raised questions, and externally, the resort to a rhetoric of force and the accumulation of disputes or irritants with several EU member states have raised fears that Russia might consider confrontation as one means among others to defend its views and promote its interests.

This judgment, of course, must be nuanced. It has been my role as President of Europe to nuance it: first, because there are still significant areas of cooperation between Europe and Russia: against international terrorism, we are together to prevent the return of a regime allied with Al-Qaeda in Afghanistan, we are together against maritime piracy, against the proliferation of weapons of mass destruction, we are together. This is obviously the case regarding the Iranian nuclear issue, as shown by the recent adoption of the Security Council resolution that confirmed we are united in rejecting a nuclear-armed Iran. Secondly, because we must do justice to Russia for the considerable path it has traveled in less than a generation, after seven decades of totalitarian night, where it sometimes took several centuries for our European countries—one must also note that the Russian people appreciate the restoration of the state and the return of growth—finally, we must recognize that Russia—and honesty is not a sign of weakness—we must recognize that Russia may have felt neglected by Western countries, which no longer saw it as an equal partner, to the point that Russia may have believed that only the balance of power would allow it to gain respect.

The Georgian crisis has driven a new, deep wedge into the trust between Europe and Russia. I have enough confidence in President Medvedev to speak frankly, and I appreciated this ability to engage in dialogue at a time when few were willing to accept dialogue. I thought that the Russian military's reaction was disproportionate to the Georgian military intervention. I say things as I think them. There was a Georgian military intervention that was a mistake. But the Russian military's reaction was disproportionate. Moreover, I do not believe that the unilateral recognition by Moscow of the self-proclaimed independence of South Ossetia and Abkhazia is acceptable. In Europe and elsewhere, the questions and fears about Russia's real objectives, particularly towards its neighbors, and about the methods it deems legitimate to implement to achieve them have created this crisis of trust.

This discomfort between Europe and Russia, if it continues to settle in, would have serious consequences, both for the stability and prosperity of the entire European continent and for the global balance of the world.

I want to tell you this because I believe it deeply: the fate of Europe and that of Russia are linked. They are linked by geography; it is rare for countries to change addresses. They are linked by history; they are linked by culture, yes, by culture; they are linked by the growing interdependence of our economies. The complementarities between Europe and Russia are evident: the Russian market is expanding rapidly. It is, for Europe, the third most important outlet; and to succeed in modernizing and diversifying its economy, Russia must rely on Europe, which is its main trading partner and the largest foreign investor: 80% of investments made in Russia come from the European Union, and 80% of Russian investments abroad are destined for the European Union. Building confrontation between us would be madness. In 2007, Europe invested ten times more in Russia than China, another neighbor of Russia! Europe buys a third of its energy from Russia, and Russia sells 60% of its gas and oil exports. Europe therefore needs Russia to ensure the security of its supplies, and Russia needs Europe to ensure the security of its outlets. Reason thus commands Europe and Russia to be strategic partners for each other. We are neighbors; we have a strategic interest in working together.

Indispensable to each other, Europe and Russia are also two essential actors in the new multipolar world: Russia has spectacularly risen from the traumas of the 1990s—Russia is once again a power, a listened-to power, which has both the means and the will to influence world affairs. For its part, the European Union, which already constitutes the largest economic and commercial entity, is intensifying its efforts to establish stable institutions and military means that will allow it to fully play the role of a global actor to which its assets destined it. The nature of the relations that will be established between Russia and Europe will therefore also depend on the global balance of the international system and our ability to face the major problems of the world. We saw it during the Georgian conflict; it was the mediation of the European Union that allowed the cessation of hostilities and opened the way to a negotiated process to resolve a crisis whose consequences go beyond the Caucasus region alone. The partnership between Europe and Russia is an opportunity for the world, for its stability, for its prosperity, and for its peace.

So between us, we must restore trust, which is the condition for reviving an ambitious Euro-Russian partnership. How to do this?

First, by resolving the Georgian crisis.

With the deployment of European observers alongside those from the OSCE and the UN and the withdrawal of Russian troops from the areas adjacent to South Ossetia and Abkhazia, as we had agreed at the end of long negotiations, Europe and Russia will have kept their word and fulfilled the first part of their contract. The crisis began on August 8; today is October 8. Two months. So, I see the self-righteous who found that it was not clear enough, not fast enough. You know the proverb "when I examine myself, I worry; when I compare myself, I reassure myself." It was essential to halt the worsening of the crisis of trust and to show that dialogue between Europe and Russia produces results, and thus today's announcement is crucial. It is now necessary, on the ground, for the parties to refrain from any provocation and respect the work of international observers. It is also necessary that the same desire to find just, lasting solutions in accordance with international principles presides over the international discussions that must take place a few kilometers from here, in Geneva on October 15. To succeed, these discussions must involve all concerned actors, but also respect each other's positions. This will be, I believe, the subject of part of our lunch.

To alleviate the discomfort that has settled in and to restore trust between Europe and Russia durably, it is also necessary that both sides demonstrate in our words and actions the same desire for listening, partnership, and dialogue. The European Union has made clear gestures in this direction during the Georgian crisis. I took the bet on dialogue with Moscow at a time when it was not obvious and when many voices, in Europe and elsewhere, were advocating for the adoption of sanctions. Well, I do not regret having taken the bet on trust and dialogue. The Union has put its relationship with Russia "under observation," but it has chosen dialogue, and the full implementation of the agreements of August 12 and September 8 opens the prospect of resuming negotiations for an ambitious framework agreement, both in terms of scope—the "four spaces" defined at the St. Petersburg summit—and in terms of the intensity of cooperation.

Such ambition, if shared, will pave the way for a true "common economic and human space" between Russia and the European Union:

- in the field of energy, we have a partnership to create, based on transparency, reciprocity, the rule of law, and non-discrimination, and ambitious cooperation to promote energy efficiency and the development of new energies;

- in terms of investments, which must be welcomed on both sides within the framework of predictable, clear, stable rules;

- in the field of trade, by establishing a strengthened and comprehensive free trade agreement, which would build on the results of Russia's accession to the WTO, which remains in its interest, and ours.

- In the financial sector, where the crisis we are experiencing and its repercussions in Europe as well as in Russia demonstrate that we have a common interest in defining converging rules and practices in terms of regulation, accounting, and oversight, Dmitri Medvedev has made proposals. There is nothing in his proposals that shocks me or that contradicts what I think myself.

- Between our peoples, finally, by facilitating travel in accordance with the agreements reached on visas, with the ultimate goal of a visa-free movement space, and by multiplying exchanges between our civil societies. What better way to promote a better mutual understanding of the values to which we are attached, democracy and human rights? A common economic space between Russia and the European Union, that is a vision worthy of the century we are beginning.

Europe hopes that Russia will not hesitate to make this strategic choice of partnership that is not limited to the particular relationships that Russia maintains with each of our members. The outstanding bilateral disputes must be resolved, as the very foundation of the Union is the solidarity among the states that compose it. Russia must engage in negotiating the framework agreement with the legitimate concern of defending its interests and the right for those interests to be taken into account, but also with the willingness to reassure and provide answers to the questions of European countries that are not all without merit. I am thinking particularly of the energy sector, where the era of suspicions must give way to the era of mutual security.

I heard President Medvedev present his ideas for a new security pact from Vancouver to Vladivostok. Well, I want to tell him that we are ready to discuss it, because security, in Europe and beyond, is a common good and therefore another natural field of cooperation between Europe and Russia. This cooperation must first be based on the achievements, which are far from negligible but that we can still develop: at NATO, first, where the NATO-Russia Council, a symbol of the end of the Cold War, offers a framework for common strategic reflection, but also for concrete cooperation between our defense systems; within the European Union next, where Russia's military participation in the EUFOR operation in Chad can foreshadow a true partnership; and we were pleased to have our Russian friends by our side on this very difficult issue. We could even make Russia a privileged interlocutor of the ESDP. France is ready, in each of these organizations, to deepen the common work with Russia.

But these dialogues and cooperations undoubtedly lack coherence. And it is here that Dmitri Medvedev's proposal meets a real need. So, why not lay everything on the table, all together, institutions and concerned countries, everything that concerns the security of our continent? And since we are at the beginning of the century and you have made this proposal, why not modernize together a way of thinking, reflexes, habits that date back to the Cold War? We can undoubtedly do this within the framework of the OSCE, the only forum that brings together all the actors of pan-European security on an equal footing. I propose that a Summit of the Organization be specially convened for this purpose before the end of 2009 so that we can discuss your proposals and those of the European Union for new pan-European defense concepts.

This exercise will naturally require a willingness to compromise, Dmitri, a mutual understanding and mutual honesty—an effort to inscribe our common security in a renewed framework based on our interests but also on our values: the tragic history of our continent teaches us that there is no lasting security that rests solely on the balance of power. The balance of power is not the guarantor of lasting security; democracy is also needed, as are human rights, which are essential factors of stability. It is not about giving lessons to anyone. Each of us has our weaknesses in our own countries. But that is the message that the European Union carries. It is this message that I will carry in the dialogue we will have with Russia on this issue of security.

A pan-European security framework would therefore include security arrangements, particularly in the field of conventional arms, but also the reaffirmation of these values and the instruments and institutions that allow for their expression and protection. This framework should also allow for the peaceful resolution of disputes, because the Georgian crisis has taught us that a supposedly frozen conflict can quickly degenerate into open war.

Finally, but is it necessary to specify, this dialogue in which we are ready to enter with Russia, I say to Dmitri, must involve our American friends and allies. I do not take my instructions from America, but America is our friend and ally. We should not fear this relationship between Europe and the United States. We are friends, we are allies. We have our own vision. We are not agents of any power. But when we talk about security, from Vladivostok to Vancouver, it also concerns our allies. It concerns security on our continent, because the security of our continent rests on a strong transatlantic link. I feel independent enough to assert this link. We have been quite pleased, we in Europe, to have this link at least on two occasions.

As much as the nature of institutions or the contours of alliances, security in Europe also depends on the definitive renunciation of the ambition of "spheres of influence," and on the respect for the territorial integrity and independence of each country. I say this in front of the Serbian President; recent history has not been easy for the Serbian nation, which has a vocation, in my eyes, to integrate into the European Union. Let us not forget: Russia's "near abroad" is often also that of the European Union. It is a fact of our "common neighborhood." It must be a field of cooperation, not a ground of rivalries.

Ladies and Gentlemen,

The multiplication of crises and the rise of global challenges have highlighted the disorder of the world while revealing the inadequacy of the rules and international institutions inherited from another era. We have the responsibility today to invent nothing less than a new global governance. We owe it to preserve peace and prosperity for our peoples, and to prevent international relations from tipping back into a zero-sum game where some must necessarily lose for others to win. This reasoning is nonsensical.

The relationship between Europe and Russia has been tested over the past few years. We must overcome this malaise, for between Russia and Europe, the partnership is natural, it is necessary. It will be a major factor of balance. It will make a decisive contribution to the stability of the international order that we must build. Never in these past weeks have I regretted betting on dialogue and trust with the President of the Russian Republic, Dmitri Medvedev, whom I am happy to see here in Evian.

Thank you.