Statement by Mr. Nicolas Sarkozy, President of the Republic, on actions in favor of the victims of Storm Xynthia, in La Roche-sur-Yon on March 16, 2010.

France Nicolas Sarkozy · President of France

16 March 2010 · Statement on actions in favor of the victims of Storm Xynthia · La Roche-sur-Yon, France

Context
Sarkozy addressed officials and elected representatives in La Roche-sur-Yon on March 16, 2010, to outline government relief actions following Storm Xynthia's devastating impact on Vendée and Charente-Maritime.
Main themes
Storm Xynthia disaster relief, victims and casualties, national solidarity and fraternity, material damage to homes and infrastructure, emergency rescue operations, dike destruction and rebuilding, agricultural and oyster farming losses, acts of heroism and courage, state aid commitments, first responder mobilization
Duration
~33 min
86th percentile
Words
4,009
86th percentile
Sentences
219
91st percentile
Readability
46
51st percentile
Grade
11.3
36th percentile
Syntax
2.78
20th percentile
Vocabulary
2.38
87th percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 35%34%
  • Social 22%22%
  • Economic 21%21%
  • Environmental 14%13%
  • Ceremonial 7%6%
  • Geopolitical 1%1%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Not in focus 2%

219 sentences in 105 paragraphs

Ladies and gentlemen ministers,

Gentlemen presidents of the general councils,

Mr. Mayor,

Ladies and gentlemen elected officials,

On February 28, Charente-Maritime and Vendée were hit hard by a national disaster.

When I came the day after the events, the extent of the disaster was not yet known. Today, we know what it is: 29 dead in Vendée, 12 in Charente-Maritime. Across the entire French territory, the storm Xynthia caused the death of 53 people.

My thoughts are first and foremost with the victims, the men, women, and young children who found themselves trapped in their homes in the middle of the night by the rising waters.

In the face of this tragedy, I want to express to their families and friends the pain and solidarity of the entire Nation. The nightmare of that night of February 28, 2010, will remain etched in the memory of the French people.

The material damage is considerable. Charente-Maritime and Vendée are two martyr departments.

1,000 damaged homes in Vendée, 5,000 in Charente-Maritime. 767 people evacuated in Vendée, 2,000 in Charente-Maritime.

192 flooded farms in Vendée, 350 in Charente-Maritime, wiping out the exhausting work of our farmers. The oyster farming profession has paid a very heavy price.

In both departments, hundreds of businesses in commerce and crafts have been hit hard by this storm of truly exceptional violence.

The dikes were overwhelmed; in some places, they were cut like sheets of paper even though they had been built one meter above the highest level ever recorded by man.

Today, 120 kilometers of dikes in Charente-Maritime, 75 km in Vendée need to be rebuilt. Road, port, and rail infrastructures have been destroyed or severely damaged.

I say to the victims of storm Xynthia, in Charente-Maritime, and in Vendée as in all affected departments: national solidarity has begun to manifest itself. It will continue to express itself.

The State will not abandon the victims of the storm.

It is often in distress and misfortune that the most spectacular bursts of national unity and fraternity occur. The president of Villiers spoke about it.

The history of our country bears witness to this.

Through their courage, the people of Vendée and Charente have provided a remarkable example to all the French.

In recent days, the greatest distress and the most exceptional acts of courage have coexisted here.

I think of those two volunteer firefighters who went to save families trapped in their attic while they themselves had just lost their home!

I think of that young man, Samuel Veillard, whose story has been reported to me, who, in diving gear, exhausted in front of the operational center, was asking for news of his two children. He had not been able to take care of them because he had been called urgently to save a 7-year-old child with his grandparents.

The drama of February 28 has sparked a wave of solidarity, all the more moving because this wave was natural and spontaneous.

I think of the hundreds of people who opened their homes to the victims, abandoned their work to help the rescue efforts, provided clothing and blankets.

Here, many people lost everything. Others gave them everything. I want to say to the people of Charente and Vendée: I am proud of your exemplary behavior. Proud to be the Head of State of a country capable of inspiring such acts of sacrifice and heroism, where the words community, mutual aid, and national solidarity still hold all their meaning.

The toll could have been much heavier if the public authorities had not been reactive and organized.

Considerable resources have been mobilized.

In Vendée: nearly 1,000 firefighters from the SDIS participated in emergency rescue operations, supported by 220 firefighters from 23 other departments and 111 civil security military personnel.

The same mobilization in Charente-Maritime: 500 departmental firefighters, 200 from outside, 156 civil security military personnel immediately intervened.

Without the selflessness and professionalism of these men and women engaged on the ground, the number of victims could have been dramatically higher. I remind you that 765 people in Vendée and 700 in Charente-Maritime were saved from drowning and exhaustion, including 90 by helicopter rescue.

I address all those who took part in the rescue operations: firefighters, professionals, volunteers, civil servants, civil security military personnel, gendarmerie and armed forces.

You saved hundreds of lives. The Nation thanks you.

I also associate with the same thanks the individuals who ensured the coordination and direction of the rescue operations, particularly the two prefects, Mr. Henri Masse and Mr. Jean-Jacques Brot, as well as the teams from the prefectures and state services.

I also want to salute the remarkable action of the presidents of the general councils, dear Dominique Bussereau, dear Philippe de Villiers for your decisive contribution to the smooth running of the rescue operations. And I associate all the elected officials of the department, all the elected officials of the region, all the municipal elected officials who participated in organizing the rescue efforts.

Ladies and gentlemen, I do not accept any fatalism in the analysis of the causes of this tragedy.

29 dead in Vendée, 12 in Charente-Maritime, this toll is unacceptable, this toll is incomprehensible.

Certainly, this disaster is the consequence of the conjunction of two natural phenomena: a storm of exceptional power and a very high tide coefficient.

But this observation justifies nothing, excuses nothing. How, in 21st century France, one of the world's leading powers, a country at the forefront of modernity and technological progress, could several dozen people drown in their homes? Should I ask this question?

I wanted all the light to be shed, and I asked for an interministerial mission to present me with a report on these events and for a first preliminary report to be submitted to me within 10 days. I therefore have this document, which is provisional in nature but nonetheless enlightening.

The preliminary report confirms my statements of March 1.

The disaster of February 28 is not only the product of climatic events. I will take my responsibilities. This disaster is the result of a cascade of questionable or nonsensical decisions, negligence, non-compliance with regulations, and neglected expertise.

It is obviously not my place to point fingers or determine responsibilities in these dysfunctions.

My role is to draw all the lessons from the events of February 28 so that such a tragedy never happens again.

After the time of extreme emergency aid, the absolute priority must be national solidarity towards the affected individuals. The time has come for compensating the victims and repairing the damage.

The recognition of the state of natural disaster in Charente-Maritime and Vendée, which allows for the initiation of compensation procedures, occurred in exceptionally short timeframes, as I had committed: the natural disaster order was issued the day after my visit on March 1. The disaster occurred on February 28, the order was issued on March 1.

From now on, I announce that claims of less than 2,000 euros will be compensated without any expertise, within a period of less than one month.

Furthermore, exceptional resources will be deployed by insurance companies so that claims of a higher amount, the most serious, are subject to the fastest possible expertise.

Insurance companies will mobilize all available experts so that the assessments of claims can be made right now.

I want to assure you of my absolute and vigilant determination regarding the insurance companies.

I also ask banks to ensure that people who have lost their homes effectively benefit from facilities for deferring their mortgage payments so that they are not faced, in addition to their difficulties, with additional cash flow problems.

I ask the departmental mediators of credit to mobilize under the authority of Mr. Gérard Rameix, national credit mediator, to assist businesses affected by the storm in their dealings with banks.

And I ask that, as an exceptional measure, people living in the most affected areas who have lost their homes be able to appeal to the local representative of the credit mediator in connection with Mr. Yann Boaretto, the "Mr. Insurance," to help them resolve their difficulties, including mortgage repayments.

Eric Woerth has instructed the tax services and URSAFF to examine all requests for payment deferrals and the waiver of late payment penalties and surcharges requested by households, businesses, merchants, artisans, and liberal professions.

For individuals, I announce that the 2010 property tax and housing tax contributions will be fully waived, upon request from the taxpayer, when the premises have been destroyed or suffered damage such that, after assessment, they are destined for demolition.

But the issue is not only financial. What is at stake is the possibility for people who have lost their homes, who narrowly escaped death and who have suffered, to find a roof to start living again!

The grouping of mutual insurance companies (GEMA) has agreed, I announce to you, to finance the temporary relocation for six months of evacuated individuals. This point is definitively acquired. I want to thank GEMA for this important gesture, and I am sure that all insurance companies will want to do the same.

If necessary, the State will mobilize the emergency relocation aid fund (FARU), which will be solicited through your mayors.

But beyond the emergency, we must question the issue of urbanization in risk areas.

What do the French expect following this tragedy?

They expect clear choices from public officials.

Well, I will say it with the utmost clarity: what happened on February 28 can happen again at any moment. There have been too many victims, too many tears, too much misfortune. I have also heard the anxiety of the victims for whom, as Philippe de Villiers said, "Where the sea has come, the sea will return."

In areas exposed to the highest risks, we have no right to allow our fellow citizens to resettle as if nothing had happened. That would be irresponsible. Moreover, the very idea of returning to live in the places of the disaster is unthinkable for the victims. How can we imagine rebuilding where there have been deaths, where death can strike again at any moment?

A precise mapping is being developed to identify high-risk sites. But I want to be clear on this point: we will not negotiate the risk; it imposes itself on everyone, the risk is not variable; the storm Xynthia has just reminded us of this.

I ask the prefects and mayors concerned to take immediate measures to prevent the reoccupation for residential purposes of sites that were devastated by the sea on February 28. It is a matter of people's safety. Everyone must understand this. Where there is a mortal risk, no one will return to live there.

In these areas, it is essential that all reconstructions and all developments subject to building permits are now prohibited.

At the same time, individuals who cannot return to their homes ravaged by Xynthia will be compensated for the loss of their homes.

Again, national solidarity will apply, within the framework of amicable acquisition procedures or through expropriation measures for public utility. But insurers must take their share of this burden by agreeing to compensate the victims even when they rebuild outside the site where their home was located.

At the same time, I ask the prefects to coordinate the actions of local elected officials, insurers, and the State to ensure that individuals who can no longer live in high-risk areas can find housing or rebuild another one in a nearby but safe area. All efforts will be mobilized to identify new buildable land, particularly through public land establishments.

My dear compatriots,

It is the absolute duty of the State to facilitate the resettlement of our affected fellow citizens in safe places and under equivalent conditions.

The "fund for the prevention of major natural risks," intended for such circumstances, currently only covers torrential floods. I ask Jean-Louis Borloo and Chantal Jouanno to immediately initiate a legislative reform to extend the scope of intervention of this fund - better known as the Barnier fund - to include all types of flooding, particularly from marine submersion. Amendments will be made in this sense to the Grenelle 2 bill, which is being examined urgently and will be adopted next summer.

Farmers, oyster farmers, and shellfish farmers have once again been severely affected.

Part of the damages will be compensated by insurance companies, particularly the immediate crop losses for major crops or the damage to agricultural, oyster farming, or shellfish farming buildings and equipment.

As for the uninsured losses, I announce to you that they will be compensated by the State. This is the case for the damage caused to pastures. It is also the case for the restoration work on cultivated land, to reduce the amount of salt present in the soil, through the use of gypsum. The State will compensate these losses and the restoration work on the soils through the National Fund for Agricultural Disaster Guarantees based on the rules for using this fund. Bruno Le Maire, who is here, will ensure this.

Bruno Le Maire has allocated a budget of 100 million euros to support farmers in taking out insurance contracts. The law on the modernization of agriculture and fishing will strengthen this support for the development of insurance against climatic hazards in agriculture. We can also see the obligation for farmers to develop an insurance practice. Farmers must take advantage of these mechanisms to insure themselves. There are too many hazards. We cannot leave them alone in the face of these hazards.

The surveys for the census of "agricultural disasters" have been ongoing since March 8, I announce to you, and they will conclude at the end of this month.

Oyster farming and shellfish farming have suffered heavy damage. We will not allow French oyster farming, which is also a victim of repeated disasters, to be destroyed.

An emergency aid plan for oyster farmers has been established. A budget of 20 million euros is available to allow for the reconstruction of buildings and the purchase of oyster and shellfish farming equipment. The system is currently being notified to the European Commission. It will naturally, dear Bruno Le Maire, complement the compensations made by insurers. It is not one or the other; it will be both.

In light of the urgent financial situation of each agricultural operator, 2.5 million euros for the coverage of contributions owed to the M.S.A. have just been unlocked. 3 million euros for the coverage of loan interest have just been delegated to the prefects of Charente-Maritime and Vendée, who are at the disposal of farmers.

I announce to you today that immediate cash injections will be made by banks for oyster farmers, shellfish farmers, and the most troubled farmers, through advances on the compensation amounts from the National Fund for Agricultural Disaster Guarantees. The State will finance the entirety of the interest on these loans.

Furthermore, direct European aid from the CAP will be preserved for agricultural operations affected by the storm, in order to guarantee the necessary income for families living on these farms.

In addition, instructions for great leniency towards affected businesses have been given to tax and social services. Banks have been invited to actively contribute to the recovery of economic actors affected by the disaster. I have no doubt that the banks that benefited from national solidarity when they were in crisis will be eager to do the same for their clients; if necessary, I will ensure this.

The State will finally take all its responsibilities regarding the reconstruction of uninsured assets of local authorities. It will utilize the provisions planned for the restoration of damaged roads and networks. The Minister of the Interior, Brice Hortefeux, is at the disposal of all elected officials, and the State will, of course, participate in the ongoing work for the urgent repairs of damaged dikes. It is out of the question to leave small municipalities or small intercommunal syndicates, which have rightly initiated the work of strengthening or repairing breaches, alone in facing an expense that was naturally not planned in their budgets.

We will draw on all available funding sources. I have asked Mr. Pierre Lellouche, Secretary of State for European Affairs, to request the European Union's solidarity fund intended to address this type of situation.

Finally, I want to express my conviction that after February 28, 2010, nothing should be as it was before in terms of natural disaster prevention.

We must improve alert systems, making them even more precise and effective. Météo France will immediately integrate a vigilance system called "submersion wave" into its weather vigilance procedures.

I wish for all municipalities located in high-risk areas to have a communal safeguard plan aimed at anticipating crisis situations.

The Xynthia storm raises the question of how we are collectively prepared to face natural disasters.

The risk prevention plan, established by the prefect after deliberation by the municipal council, is a fundamental tool for protecting populations. This tool, the PPR, is imposed on urban planning regulations. It alone allows for the establishment of the necessary rules and limits regarding construction in high-risk areas.

We must speak the truth: in Charente-Maritime as in Vendée, we were behind schedule. And this observation unfortunately applies to the entire national territory.

Out of 864 municipalities exposed to the risk of marine submersion in France, only 46 have an approved prevention plan. The situation is no better for other risks, such as forest fires and seismic risks. I tell you, my dear compatriots, this is no longer tolerable.

We will generalize risk prevention plans. To do this, we must put an end to bureaucratic approaches and dilatory maneuvers. Too much time has been lost. We cannot continue like this and allow a few individuals to block vital procedures for our fellow citizens. Common sense has long since deserted this crucial issue of natural risk management. And in the end, the general interest has been lost sight of. What is at stake is human life. I intend to restore order in our prevention and risk management policy.

We will significantly accelerate the deployment of risk prevention plans across the territory. We can no longer wait years for these to be implemented. Let us remember that the plans for predictable natural risks (PPR) were created by the law of February 2, 1995. Do not come to me saying that it is not possible, that the procedures are complicated, that consultation needs to be extended... This has been going on for 15 years. Our objective is simple, I announce to you: in three years, all municipalities located in high-risk areas will be covered by a prevention plan.

Instructions will be given by the Minister of the Interior to the prefects. The State will take its responsibilities. Decentralization is a tremendous achievement, but it will not be at the expense of the safety of our compatriots. Better protecting our compatriots by strengthening the powers of the State representative is also about better protecting our elected officials.

I ask Jean-Louis Borloo and Brice Hortefeux to personally ensure that the necessary legislative changes are made to simplify and accelerate the procedures for developing PPRs. The prefect must be able to prioritize the safety imperatives of the population over any other consideration.

In the same vein, we will reform our natural disaster insurance system.

Let’s be clear: this system is currently incomprehensible. It is obviously perfectly ineffective, as it does not encourage prevention, and therefore it is unjust. I ask the relevant ministers to initiate the reform of the natural disaster regime, which will naturally remain based on national solidarity but will take into account the need to strengthen prevention and encourage responsible behavior. There is no reason that responsible individuals should not benefit from this, including in the amount of their insurance compensations, while irresponsible individuals make others pay for their irresponsibility.

The "dikes" plan that I have asked Jean-Louis Borloo to implement will be in the same spirit, the same approach. It complements the reform and generalization of the PPRs. We want to strengthen the dikes to improve the protection of populations. But I want to make it clear that we will not create one more meter of new dike for the sake of real estate speculation. It is not about opening up areas exposed to a significant risk of submersion to urbanization. Therefore, there will be no dikes to allow for new housing developments in high-risk areas.

The Xynthia storm has severely damaged coastal dikes. At least 150 kilometers need urgent renovation. The State, I announce to you, gentlemen Presidents, will exceptionally cover 50% of the cost of this work. But the storm has highlighted the deplorable state of the entire national dike network, of the 1,000 kilometers of coastal dikes and the 7,000 kilometers of river dikes in our country, for it would be pointless to ignore part of the reality. And the reality is that at least half of these structures would today need to be reinforced. Based on an average cost of one million euros per kilometer, our investment backlog is between 3 and 4 billion euros.

It must be said that we are paying, in this area, the consequences of a confused and perfectly obsolete system. The number of project owners is countless. The principle of exclusive funding by property owners and those directly protected—a principle established by a law from 1807—is clearly no longer effective. And, in this area as well, public investments have been notoriously under-dimensioned for decades.

I therefore request a multi-year national plan in favor of dikes. The State will mobilize the Barnier fund, based on a permanent intervention rate of 40%—50% for everything we have to repair with you, 40% for the deficit.

Finally, given the effect of dikes on water reflux, a basic precaution should have been taken long ago: in high-risk areas of submersion, it should no longer be possible to build housing behind the dikes. Because sooner or later, regardless of their height or solidity, they will one day be submerged. A little common sense does not hurt in urban planning.

Ladies and gentlemen, France has been severely hit three times by natural disasters in the past 10 years: December 1999, January 2009, February 2010. We cannot cheat with nature. If I have come, it is to show all the victims that the State will keep its word, and I announce to you that I will return at the beginning of summer to present the "dikes" plan. The victims must not feel abandoned. I also tell the elected officials that it is not for me, nor for anyone else, to prosecute anyone, and if there is to be a prosecution, it is justice, but let things be clear, as the two Presidents of the General Councils have asked me, we will not authorize any reconstruction in deadly zones. I prefer to bear the sadness, the grief, the anger of someone who was born in a place and wants to return there rather than jeopardize lives, those of those who would go back to live in deadly zones and those of rescuers and emergency responders. Once is enough. Naturally, it is not a matter of swinging from one extreme to the other and condemning the entirety of the French coastline; it is about distinguishing between deadly zones and areas where there is a low risk of minor flooding. This is the work we must do, and for the rest, it is out of the question to leave areas fallow. There we will have prohibited habitation, but we will of course allow farmers to develop their work.

Ladies and gentlemen, you have understood that from this dreadful catastrophe, we must seize the opportunity to review our organizational system, our insurance system, our risk prevention system. My duty is to be responsive. The direction is set, the principles are established. I now count on each of you so that Charente-Maritime and Vendée can turn the page on this February 28, which will unfortunately remain in our memories for a long time.

Thank you.