Statement by Mr. Nicolas Sarkozy, President of the Republic, on the fight against insecurity, particularly through efforts in favor of the police and gendarmerie, and the judicial response, in Bordeaux on January 22, 2008.

France Nicolas Sarkozy · President of France

22 January 2008 · Statement on the fight against insecurity, police and gendarmerie efforts, and the judicial response · Bordeaux, France

Context
Sarkozy addressed police, gendarmerie, and local officials in Bordeaux on January 22, 2008, to discuss crime-fighting results and policing strategy reforms.
Main themes
Public security and crime reduction, policing strategy reform, community policing, clearance rates and delinquency statistics, police deployment and methods, police-elected official cooperation, gendarmerie, judicial response, urban safety, Minister of Interior legacy
Duration
~25 min
75th percentile
Words
2,962
75th percentile
Sentences
179
86th percentile
Readability
65
94th percentile
Grade
8.3
6th percentile
Syntax
2.72
15th percentile
Vocabulary
2.09
25th percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 64%54%
  • Social 17%15%
  • Ceremonial 15%12%
  • Economic 4%3%
  • Geopolitical 1%1%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 16%

179 sentences in 27 paragraphs

Ladies and Gentlemen,

I would like to thank the Mayor of Bordeaux for kindly hosting us, dear Alain,

The parliamentarians,

The ministers,

Michèle ALLIOT-MARIE, who is at home,

Rachida DATI,

Xavier BERTRAND,

I have come first to congratulate you on the excellence of the results you have achieved. It has not been easy, neither in this city nor in this department. It required questioning habits. It required patience, because the clearance rate began to rise before the numbers started to fall.

I remember very well coming here several times, in 2003 and 2004, and nothing was changing, but we could see that progress was being made. There were more activities in the services, there was more clearance, there were more arrests, but we could not manage to lower, to bend the curve. From that moment on, together with your leaders, we started to work. What was not working? Here, I would like to thank you all, because you accepted to do the most difficult thing, which is to question your habits. I would particularly like to thank the elected officials, and especially the Mayor of Bordeaux, because it was courageous to accept the idea that there were too many real estate developments, first in Bordeaux and across the entire community.

It is not simple, it is not easy. I remember very well the discussions we had, because every time a police station is opened, it pleases the neighbors, but we, Michèle and I, reason by saying: yes, a police station means police officers or gendarmes inside the facility who are not on the street. The transition from a little over thirty installations, I believe, from 33 to 22, that is, a reduction of one third in two years has been successful. It required closing police stations, but it required the trust of the elected officials to be able to do this essential work. You accepted to do something that has not been easy for the "pilots of the plane," to go from three in the car to two. The fact of operating with two vehicles for arrests allows for three people to keep the other three available to intervene, that was also a novelty. Doubling the BAC (Brigade Anti Criminalité) as well, which allows me to say a word about this matter of proximity.

Ladies and Gentlemen, I had the pleasure of being Minister of the Interior before Michèle. She has the pleasure of doing a job that I loved very much. It is true, I am told "you are returning to your first loves." It is true, I enjoyed being Minister of the Interior. I love working with police officers, gendarmes, who are men and women who believe in their profession, and who want to see progress.

Frankly, one would have to be strangely made not to love this ministry. A deeply human ministry. I loved working, but when I became Minister of the Interior, what did we see! There was an organization that was certainly extraordinary, but which produced appalling results.

There was not a conversation without people saying: we are afraid, we have had enough of insecurity. Insecurity was the primary concern of the French. That and community policing, they talked about it, but the results, they also talked about them, the French. The catastrophe, demobilized officers, very poor results, violence that had exploded. There is no question of returning to a strategy that produced catastrophic results.

In five years, we had found a way to increase delinquency by 15%. Frankly, as I do not want to believe that it is because the ministers were not good, it must therefore have been the strategy that was not good. Because if the strategy was good, it means the ministers were not good. One must choose. I always prefer to think that people are good.

We completely changed the strategy. We changed your equipment, changed your methods, and we developed a concept of proximity that I care about a lot, which is that the police must be on the ground and not in the facilities. The police must be on the ground at the times when delinquents are on the ground. Having the maximum number of personnel between 8 AM and 11 AM is useless, because our clients at that time are sleeping, as they are not big workers, they are sleeping.

So, we redeployed the police. That is community policing. A police force on the ground at the times when delinquents are on the ground. And for what purpose? I can have temperament, but I am not mean. I remember going to a large city in the south, everyone remembers, in Toulouse. I was angry that day, why? Because I discovered that the clearance rate, hold on, was at 11%. A little over 11% and a little less than 12. I asked a senior officer when going to the station: "Sir, what is the last initiative you took?" He said we took a fantastic initiative. Which one? Moreover, he was happy. "I organized a rugby tournament with the youth." Oh really, wonderful, can you tell me what your job is, Sir?" He said: "I am a senior officer, I am a police officer." OK. Do you think that in a district where you find one culprit out of 10, there is no other concern than organizing a rugby tournament with the youth of the neighborhood? If the police organize a rugby tournament, fine, but who is going to arrest the delinquents? The primary job of the police and the gendarmerie is to apprehend delinquents and protect victims. If you do not do this job, there is no one who can replace you. Understand me well, I am not against peripheral activities, but they must remain peripheral with impressive results. I have the utmost respect for social workers, association leaders, sports instructors, all very useful people, but your job is security and for security, you must arrest the culprits, and that is crucial.

So what are we going to do now with Michèle? We are going to give you the best chances to progress further because I know well that with the statistics, I see nationally, you are at nearly 36% clearance rate and I specify with the famous community policing they were at 24, that is to say that in 6 years, we go from 24% to 36% and this month, Michèle has obtained exceptional results, since you have risen to almost 42. What can we do to help you further? We are going to put a lot of emphasis on technical and scientific police. I want to explain this to you, including if there are union representatives - I speak for the Police and associations for the gendarmes, it is not easy either - we did a job from 2002-2007 of increasing personnel, it is true. I want us now to work around the plan prepared by Michèle ALLIOT-MARIE on quality, less than quantity. I explain: the files, the samples, the investigation methods that will allow you to move from the religion of confession to that of proof. I want a police force and a gendarmerie that move from confession to proof. I know well that it was in the culture of our houses, confession is useful but proof is scientific police. So, we are going to put a lot of emphasis on that and not just in Ecully, but also in a decentralized way so that you can, in your police stations, I care a lot about this, have access to these files and that we can be more effective.

Secondly, Michèle is working on the question: "what is the equipment of a modern police and gendarmerie"? It is something that is exciting. We have changed your equipment, we have changed your vehicles, I want us to go further towards non-lethal weapons for two reasons. The first is that I want you to be able to engage with fewer personnel and more security. You have weapons that you can only use in very specific cases and so we often have to engage you in greater numbers. With non-lethal weapons, however, we can diversify your actions. I want us to think about the new generation flashball with longer range. I remember when, in 2002, I announced the generalization of the flashball. Oh my, what did we hear? Thanks to the flashball, we avoided many tragedies, especially during the riots of 2005, but we need longer ranges to protect our officers. I also add that for those we arrest, non-lethal weapons are better. I also want us to think about the equipment, especially during urban problems for the BAC and the officers. I dream that we generalize cameras for all vehicles, starting first with those that intervene at night because cameras are judicial evidence, I will come back to this dear Rachida, because cameras are deterrent and finally because cameras protect you from controversy. I have had enough of the controversies at Roissy I, when we were escorting foreigners in an irregular situation. From the day we put in place associations and cameras, there has been no more controversy and thus a modern police force is a police force that, upon arrival, will have cameras in all vehicles that intervene. That is what we absolutely need. I also think about helicopter police, which is an absolutely essential element for intervention. I much prefer that in large urban areas, instead of you being motorized with powerful vehicles to pursue delinquents, you use helicopters. It is an essential element for you to be able to intervene. You see, we are thinking about all this.

Finally, the last point, and this is the reason for the presence of Madame the Keeper of the Seals, the penal response, the judicial response. I want to thank the Attorney General, the First President, and all the magistrates. And I will give a figure that I have never given. You know that countless police officers and gendarmes have indicated to us over the years, "we have had enough of always arresting the same people." Is it true or not? I have not stopped hearing that. And during the presidential campaign, I developed the idea of the necessity of minimum sentences. And I overcame the controversy that these minimum sentences would contradict the principle of individualization of punishment. Absurd! I say this in front of the magistrates, if the maximum sentence does not contradict the principle of individualization of punishment, I do not see why the minimum sentence would contradict it. We voted - thank you Rachida DATI - this text. It was voted on August 10. It came into effect in September. Do you know that we already have 4,500 decisions made based on minimum sentences? That is to say that from now on, repeat offenders know that it will cost them dearly.

And in the excellent result you have achieved, the penal response - thanks to the magistrates - is a decisive element. Rachida DATI, at my request, had the Assembly vote and it has just finished in the Senate, a security sentence for "serial killers" and "serial rapists." That is to say that we are going to make significant changes in French law. Until now, you arrest a rapist, you arrest a criminal, he serves his sentence, minus any reductions, except when there are security sentences, but finally, he gets out. And society washes its hands saying "but how can this man who got 20 years, let’s assume at worst he serves 20 years, get out." I am sorry when someone has raped at 22 years old and gets out 20 years later, they are 42 years old. And I do not intend to leave wild beasts at liberty. So we have introduced into our law what had never existed before, a security sentence after the prison sentence, that is to say, for these individuals to be released, they must first have served their sentence and then society will decide whether or not they are dangerous. And I had this idea when I came to PAU this summer. I am going back. We were with Michèle and you know when I see the husband of the lady, the nurse, who was beheaded and whose perpetrator placed the head on the television before leaving, and what do I say to the husband when the magistrate - I do not blame him, I describe a situation - says to the husband "I am going to render a dismissal because the individual was irresponsible." And the husband says to me "if there is a dismissal it means it did not happen, give me back my wife." What do we respond? What do we say? It does not concern us, it is bad luck. It could have been the situation of any one of you. Well, from now on, I said to myself: he is irresponsible, we will put him in a psychiatric hospital and in the treatment in the psychiatric hospital, in the treatment there is the notion of permission. And well good luck to whoever encounters this individual. We cannot leave them at liberty, that is not true. And human rights are first and foremost the rights of the victim.

We have taken on this debate, and those who disagree should say so. Just like those who disagreed when I wanted files on genetic fingerprints, where supposedly it infringed on the freedom of whom? In the same way, I want rapists to report to the police station or gendarmerie every month and to be heard, and those who do not want to be treated should not be released. And I am ready to take on these debates in front of French society calmly. But our priority is the victims. Not the guilty, the victims.

So that does not prevent us from extending a hand. We will, with Fadela AMARA, announce a plan for the neighborhoods, which I am following day by day. I have convictions, I have made commitments, and I will keep them. And this concerns the police and the gendarmerie because it is you who, when there are problems, find yourselves on the front line. I did not accept that in Villiers-le-Bel, 81 officials were hit by projectiles. I will not be the President of the Republic who accepts, in the country of which he is the Head of State, that one can shoot at an official or a soldier with impunity; that is not possible. Michèle ALLIOT-MARIE knows this perfectly well; we are looking for the shooters, believe me, we will find them and we will not let them get away. Because I do not want there to be a single police officer or a single gendarme who thinks: "this is the new trend in France, we can shoot at them!" 81 of your colleagues were hit, not one responded. Let us pay tribute to the French police and gendarmerie.

We are going to make a plan where we will stop investing in buildings; we will continue what has been launched, of course. But allow me to tell you that renovating a building if you leave people unemployed inside, five years later you have to redo it again! If we think that we solve the problem by renovating buildings, we are completely wrong. I think we should have started by finding work and training for people. In any case, that is done. And we will therefore analyze the situation of each young person; we will give them a new chance for qualifying training. Those who want to work will succeed. Those who do not want to work will not succeed. It is important to understand these things. And you, police officers and gendarmes, must know that you live in a society where we know the values that are those of our country: work, merit, effort, reward. And I wish that these values are also those that inspire the gendarmerie and the police.

And, I will conclude with this, that there be more fluidity for you, that we do not wait for you to be so tired of waiting to promote you, that there be a little more recognition of experience and merit. That we are not afraid to appoint young people. I prefer that we take risks and sometimes make mistakes by promoting people who may not always meet expectations rather than taking none and discouraging everyone. You have committed yourselves to the police and the gendarmerie; they must be - the police and the gendarmerie - factors of social promotion. That is the work we are doing hand in hand with Michèle ALLIOT-MARIE, and I do not care if people say that I am interested in this; it is true. And I congratulate you for your work. Just be careful. A police officer or a gendarme goes home in the evening. Death is not part of the job. Every time we have a tragedy like this, it is because we have not been good professionals.

I ask you for a lot of commitment, and at the same time, there are procedures. I also ask you to respect your ethical rules because we cannot accept either familiarity or the use of first names. You are the police and gendarmerie of the Republic. Therefore, your appearance must be impeccable, and that starts with not using first names, and no slouching in vehicles even if we are two on patrol, because it is the uniform.

Ladies and gentlemen, I hope you understand, Mr. Mayor, I was very happy to be here alongside Michèle ALLIOT-MARIE, Rachida DATI, and Xavier BERTRAND, to whom I also want to express my thanks for the work they are all doing.

Happy New Year to you and your families. Thank you all.