Statement by Mr. Nicolas Sarkozy, President of the Republic, on the recommendations of the Attali Commission for the liberation of French growth, in Paris on January 23, 2008.

France Nicolas Sarkozy · President of France

23 January 2008 · Statement on the recommendations of the Attali Commission · Paris, France

Context
Sarkozy addressed the Attali Commission in Paris on January 23, 2008, responding to its 316 proposals for liberating French economic growth.
Main themes
French economic growth liberation, Attali Commission recommendations, structural reform, rent-seeking and inequality, education inequality, labor and goods market reform, national modernization, political consensus for change, conservatism and stagnation, comprehensive reform strategy
Duration
~58 min
95th percentile
Words
6,931
95th percentile
Sentences
406
97th percentile
Readability
60
88th percentile
Grade
9.0
11th percentile
Syntax
2.75
17th percentile
Vocabulary
2.02
13th percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 36%34%
  • Economic 34%32%
  • Social 15%14%
  • Ceremonial 9%9%
  • Environmental 4%4%
  • Geopolitical 1%1%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Not in focus 6%

406 sentences in 45 paragraphs

In essence, you have done the hardest part, which is to think. You leave us with the easier part, which is to act. Fundamentally, in the work of the Commission, you have chosen the President you needed. I do not see who could have ordered such a menu. I will tell you very frankly what I think about it.

First of all, I want to thank you, of course, Jacques ATTALI and all the members of the Commission for the remarkable work you have accomplished. Generally, when one starts like this, it goes badly, since the next sentence distinguishes oneself from what has been proposed. I want to say that I adhere to the essence of your conclusions.

If some have been frightened by the content of your proposals, I find them rather reasonable in essence.

Your observation is a perfectly reasonable one. In a world that is changing at a very high speed, France has fallen behind while it has exceptional assets. I challenge anyone to say that this observation is not reasonable. You add that by regulating everything in minute detail, we have built a real corset that prevents growth, and that the consequences of this weakness in growth are paid for by the most vulnerable. An undeniable observation.

You tell us that rent-seeking is triumphant, that inequalities are more glaring than ever: the figures you recall regarding education are a striking testimony to the failure of a supposedly egalitarian system that has only exacerbated inequalities. I will cite one among many: the children of workers made up 25% of those admitted to Polytechnique in the 1950s, 1% today! And there are so many people who tell us that we must continue as before, sleep peacefully, and above all change nothing?

You tell us that the relative decline of national wealth compared to our main partners will lead to absolute decline if we do not react. You are right. You also tell us that growth can return for all if we have the courage to choose the path of reform. And that is what interests me, that is what I was elected for. That is why I want to mobilize the energy of the French people. Change, movement, the French are ready if it is reform for all, for the benefit of all, and primarily for today's excluded. I regret that it took this Commission for us to come together. What a waste of time, we should have come together before the election, hold the election together, and draw conclusions together. But, better late than never. I observe that I am gathering support well beyond the current majority, and I am pleased about that.

So, since we wrote to you with François Fillon, you have not spared your efforts. Jacques, you have assembled an exceptional team, with experts from various countries and backgrounds, a non-partisan team, with people who are not French, which is a good thing. It is not just the French who love France. The stagnation of France is not just a problem for the French, and especially dear Mario, in Europe. We were all gathered in these same places on August 30, to kick off your work. I had asked you to be bold, because our country needs an intensive modernization cure.

You come back with 316 proposals, many hearings, many debates, which have already fed into the public debate. I love it! The most critical are those who call for the fastest change. From this point of view, that does not change, so we will set them aside - the most critical.

You have fulfilled your part of the contract. It is a coherent project, you tell us that it must be applied in its entirety in a tenacious and sustainable manner, fighting against all forms of conservatism. Tenacious and sustainable, those are words that resonate with me.

But already, 50 years ago, that was the message of your predecessors led by Jacques Rueff and Louis Armand. They were tasked with "removing the obstacles to economic expansion." Your mission is to "liberate growth." You propose a comprehensive package, because reforms support each other. It would be useless to reform the labor market if the market for goods and services remained mired in Malthusian rigidities. To those who tell me that I am undertaking too many reforms at once, I think they really do not understand anything. It is precisely because we are undertaking all the reforms at the same time that we have a chance to complete the process of change. So, we must find the most appropriate sequence. In this whole, where I fully agree, I will take on a few disagreements. You call for debate, I cannot be the only one not allowed to debate. That would be too sad, and given my temperament, that would not be possible.

You tell us that the implementation of your project constitutes a political, technical, and national challenge; changing France is everyone's business. I agree.

The message you deliver is indeed the one I heard during the electoral campaign. Your eight ambitions, I share them with all the French people. With François FILLON and the government, we have started to implement them. I like your way of presenting the challenges that need to be met, which the members of your Commission have presented around your three key ideas.

Yes, we must give ourselves the means to fully participate in global growth, and we must do so with a bit more ambition, because, until now, pardon me, but for the past thirty years, we have been very pleased when we have a little less growth than others, when global growth is going in the right direction, and we are delighted when the decline is a little less severe than others, when it is going in the wrong direction. There you go, the ambition, pardon me, of governments of both the left and the right for the past thirty years. When things are going well, we do a little less well. When things are going badly, we do a little less badly. And then we say: in any case, France is rich, we will get by like this. So, we are not placing ourselves in this strategy.

We need a more efficient educational system, universities, and research. I agree with your first fundamental decision, which is that every student must master the fundamentals before the end of sixth grade. That is why I have asked for the reform of primary education to be initiated, because, honestly, to focus on middle schools and high schools while omitting that before middle school and high school, there is primary education... Primary education is the priority, because everything we do in middle school is too late if we have not focused on resolving primary education.

You call for the principle of freedom: the gradual abolition of the school map. Already, when I first said this, my God, what a commotion!

Today, it is progressing, that is evident. But in general, all your proposals that emphasize free choice, individual freedom, seem perfectly legitimate to me. Moreover, the reform of universities that was initiated last summer responds to this ambition. I was actually surprised, and François FILLON can testify to this. I thought: of course, autonomy is needed for universities. Who could defend that non-autonomous universities could have the slightest chance of succeeding? I thought this is a hot topic, we will go gradually, and inspired by the famous Gresham's law in reverse, where bad money drives out good, good status drives out bad, I had asked the government to create an optional autonomy status, that is to say, to allow universities to choose autonomy or to keep the old status. I thought this would allow us to pass, well, we had an uproar because they all wanted autonomy, right away. Wonderful! For thirty years, governments have backed down in the face of autonomy. I propose the autonomy status. I say: I will not yield on this, you will choose it: mobilization on the theme of the unity of the Republic, we all want autonomy. Rather good news. The autonomy of the university and the reform of governance have been voted on for four months.

We will free up considerable funding to create real campuses, 5 billion drawn from the proceeds of the sale of EDF shares, 1 billion more per year for universities, contributing to the development of the world-class hubs you wish for. Calling for private partnerships, you recommend it, it is absolutely essential, and for heaven's sake, let us not stick to this absurd reasoning that private money would necessarily lead to privatization. That makes no sense. On what grounds would private money be legitimate to invest anywhere other than in universities? That if it were to arrive in universities, it would lead to a form of privatization, which, by the way, no one wants.

Of course, we will need to open higher education more to the world, make our research more competitive, and develop private research. I will make extremely strong proposals in this area next week. Finally, on this subject, we have tripled the research tax credit, and we are ready to go further. As for your proposals on biotechnology, they will be taken into account, no problem.

Strengthening the competitiveness of our economy, supporting SMEs, Mr. ROUX DE BEYZIEUX, I am fully convinced of that. The government adopts the objectives you set for SMEs' access to public markets; this is the continuation of Mr. Lionel STOLERU's report. Easing the effects of thresholds, so that at least there are no longer social and fiscal consequences. Respect for payment deadlines, you spoke of gold, we will not have consensus. I told the Prime Minister and the Minister of Finance, so we will make a law because now it has been too long since we have been talking about this, including a law for the State because the State cannot tell others to do what it does so poorly for itself. Expanding the financing possibilities for SMEs, of course, help us to get out of a system where we willingly lend money to those who do not need it, a classic French situation, and the reform of the ISF allows SMEs to access this financing. I will need the support of Mr. Mario MONTI to convince the commission that the "Small Business Act," if American companies are entitled to it, I do not see on what grounds European companies would not be entitled to it. We do not make Europe to have fewer rights than others; that is simply absurd. I am not the only one to convince that this needs to be done; Americans reserve a portion of public contracts for SMEs. On what grounds should European companies not have the same right?

A record number of companies was created last year, 320,000; now the challenge is to allow them to grow, these gazelles you have spoken to me about so often.

Investing in promising sectors for tomorrow's growth, digital technology. Your proposals are plentiful. Apart from a few very isolated points, I adopt them. It is essential to democratize access to digital technology by ensuring optimal coverage in 2011 and access for all to very high speed by 2016. We are discussing this with the operators. To give coherence to the whole, I will take up your proposal to appoint a digital development officer, provided that he will not only have to worry about digital technology but also about the consequences of digital technology on the evolution of society. Ultimately, it is less the digital technology that needs to be supported than the digital society that needs to be posed and developed, and this requires, of course, a high-level officer.

In terms of health, sustainable development, infrastructure, tourism, you are right; we can be pioneers of a new growth, sustainable and durable growth. You mentioned it, renewable energies will be at the heart of the implementation of the Grenelle de l'Environnement. We will develop CO² capture and storage, we will conduct a general review of mandatory levies to redirect taxation towards environmental protection, provided, Jacques, that this is done with constant levies, so what we create on one side must be eliminated on the other, and furthermore, administrations will have the obligation, I say the obligation, to buy and invest in clean products. We cannot continue like this! Clean products cost more, and we wonder why there is no market. Therefore, we cannot lower prices. You have seen the first decisions we have made in this area. We will not disappoint you; we have made a choice with the Prime Minister and the government for sustainable development, to put France at the forefront of these issues in the world, and we will draw all the consequences from it.

You propose to experiment with Ecopolis, exemplary neighborhoods or cities. I would even like to change the semantics. We have created new cities, which means we have made the same failure elsewhere. We want, like what you propose to us, to create a new city. It is not the new city that interests me, because the new city is the city with its flaws, it is the new city. We will take up the concept of Ecopolis, we will create a new city and I wish for France to become a leader in the popular art that is architecture and urban planning, which is a major art. There is no need to buy a ticket to see it. It is the mark of the dynamism of a society, a civilization, and an era. I cannot be satisfied with the fact that major architectural and urban projects are happening elsewhere: Barcelona, Bilbao, Berlin, Doha, Abu Dhabi. And Paris, the grand Paris and all our urban conurbations, what is happening? A debate to determine whether we should have towers or not. Finally, we are overwhelmed. The question is not whether there are towers or cubes, the question is an urbanism that allows people to live well and for France to demonstrate a dynamism that unfortunately it has lost. I guarantee you that I am in favor of these experimental projects, that I will get involved in them and that a worthy era, a project of civilization must carry urban projects and a reflection on the new city. It is at the heart of everything.

Regarding the precautionary principle, we may have a disagreement. Proposing its removal on the grounds that it hinders action is, in my opinion, based on a misunderstanding. The precautionary principle is not, at least from my point of view, a principle of inaction. It is a principle of action and expertise to reduce uncertainty. The precautionary principle is, in my eyes, not a principle of prohibition, it is a principle of vigilance and transparency, it must therefore be interpreted as a principle of responsibility. We have a disagreement, I am ready to debate it but it would be contradictory from my point of view to say that we will promote sustainable development, and the first decision we make is to remove the precautionary principle. I want to say that at some point, we must still be understood. You understand each other, that’s perfect. But we must also be understood by all the others. And I say this to Jacques, good faith is not the best shared thing in the world. Your report is too important for us, Mr. Prime Minister, as it is for me, to let it be caricatured, on an expression where I see very well what you meant. But that is the difference between the reflection commission and a Head of State. I do not have the right to that. I must be understood immediately. Because I do not have the time. Since my time is the time for action, it is not the time for long-term reflection. So, I will not take the risk, I prefer to say and close the door immediately on one point, no matter what. On the precautionary principle, the consequences would be too great in terms of misunderstanding. Even if I see well that, from your point of view, it is not the precaution that you want to remove. I will even go further: we have created a society where, ultimately, and this is what you wanted to say, the one who takes the least risk is the most valued. We have rules, laws, regulations to ensure that in the end, the good manager is the one who has taken no risk. I believe that the good manager is the one who takes risks. And that we must help him, support him and that it is not a problem to fail if we have tried. It is catastrophic to spend your life trying nothing. If that is the challenge to the precautionary principle, we agree.

And by the way, with the Prime Minister, we are working on one thing: I very much wish that there are areas where we can say that the rules will not be quite the same. To try, when you see what Jean NOUVEL is doing in Abu Dhabi, with the Louvre, it is exceptional. This museum, you arrive at it both by land and by sea. It is certain that if there were a coastal law... I am not against the coastal law at all which has allowed many things. It has not allowed everything because, by the way, when we see certain departments in France, we say: my God, it may have come a little late. I am for the coastal law. Let no one claim that I am against it. But, at the same time, we must become a country that encourages risk-taking and initiative-taking.

You say that we need to reconcile mobility and security, two notions that, far from opposing each other, must support each other, I fully agree with you. You call for the modernization of social dialogue - that is the heart of what we do. Dialogue, and at the same time, efficiency. We reformed the special retirement schemes, I signed the decrees. We could have done without the nine days of strikes. But, at the same time, what the social partners did on the employment contract, frankly our method was not so bad. What did we say with the Prime Minister? We let you discuss until January 1. On January 1, if there is something, we will take it. If there is nothing, we will go further. Choose. They chose. They asked for fifteen more days. But, in the end, it is a real success. We will start again on social protection since we are having a meeting on February 6. I fully agree with you. Trade union organizations are not obstacles to change. They are indispensable, unquestionable partners, provided they are representative.

You raise the question of the representativeness of trade union organizations, the reform of their financing, the majority agreement, and the development of social dialogue, particularly in SMEs. Yes, the criterion of representativeness, I have said all the bad I think about it. The financing, I have pointed out all the limits of this financing. The majority agreement, I indicated that we were in favor of it.

And, of course, if we make the majority agreement, I say this to ROUX DE BEZIEUX, there must be a partner in SMEs. Because I do not see with whom we make a majority agreement if there is no union. I have still called the attention of all our compatriots on this subject. Unions are not obstacles to change. What is an obstacle to change is non-representative unions. So politicized. That is an obstacle to change. Not the unions. We need unions and we will therefore go with you. They are seized with all the subjects of the social agenda. They will start their discussions tomorrow, and have until March 31 to conclude them. If an agreement is reached, it will be taken up by law; if there is no agreement, we will take the lead. The rules of the game are perfectly clear. I am for dialogue. But a dialogue where we understand what we are discussing and where we set a limit. There you go, if naturally it takes fifteen more days, we will give them.

In terms of the labor market, more flexibility in exchange for new securities. Yes. The conventional termination of the employment contract and the portability of the right to training are, for example, among your proposals. That is what we are doing. It is only a first step. In 2008, we will embark on new paths: reform of vocational training, and we will go very far, reform of unemployment insurance and I wish that the social partners assess your proposal for a professional transition contract, so we will put it on the discussion table. This proposal will therefore be taken up. You propose to make it easier to arbitrate between income and leisure, another way of saying work more to earn more, we are largely in agreement. The question of Sunday work. Well, listen, we cannot be the country in the world with the most tourists and continue to say that we should not work on Sundays. There comes a time when, after all, to continue to say that the right sidewalk of the Champs-Elysées is a tourist area where we can open stores, the left sidewalk is not a tourist area, we must close them. What do you want me to say? When you think that there are people who are sincere in defending these ideas! Your proposal to allow by majority agreement of companies to negotiate on working time is exactly the proposal we have put on the table. Promoting the employment of seniors, which everyone now realizes must be at the heart of our policies, you have made several proposals. I will speak frankly. I will tell companies, dear Anne LAUVERGEON, that their position on the employment of seniors is not reasonable. Anne LAUVERGEON does not represent, by herself, all companies but still, at the head of a company, it is not reasonable. We cannot say on one hand that the French must work more and on the other hand have French people losing their jobs in the company at 57 and 58 years old. No, that is not possible. It’s your story of the right bank and the left bank. If you put me on the right bank or left bank! I am well aware that if I am on neither, I will be uncomfortable but I want to be on both. It is not possible, we cannot say the French must work more, and at the same time, have as the only idea not to hire anyone after 50 and give no career perspective to people after 55. Everyone will make an effort, but I will also bear that effort. The question of seniors is essential, essential. Cumulative employment retirement, that does not scare us, the removal of unemployment insurance contributions for seniors, why not? Let’s see, let’s examine, let’s reflect. We want fifty-somethings to be able to continue working. First of all, a fifty-something is young. Returning to work is always preferable to inactivity, a major economic and social issue. You want to rationalize all the devices that currently exist around social minima, that is exactly what we are doing with the active solidarity income. We have launched experiments in about forty departments. I would like to draw your attention to a difficulty, which is that it costs a lot of money at the beginning and only produces income later. I see the method because change starts by costing money because it is not true that we can make all changes without investing. We must invest and, on the issue of social minima and active solidarity income, it starts to cost money before it brings in since people return to work and therefore need it less. As, at the same time, Mario MONTI's friends monitor the evolution of deficits, you see the difficulty, I will say a word about it.

Mobility, your approach to the housing issue seems right to me, all the proposals aimed at facilitating the release of land, buildable areas, go in the right direction, public-private partnerships in the construction of social housing, no problem. Social access to property, we agree. We have also obtained a commitment from the HLM sector on the ownership of 40,000 occupants per year. It is a first step. Should we go further and be even more proactive, why not?

Reform of landlord/tenant relations, we have made part of the journey you are asking us with the reduction to one month of the security deposit that you recommended and that we voted for. We will overhaul the system, in the direction of greater security in these relations. The substitution of an insurance system for the guarantee system is already under study.

Economic mobility is equally essential, enhanced vigilance in favor of competition, in the service of consumers: I want to say that I agree with your proposal for a single Competition Council, we will work on it. No one understands anything about the multiplicity of directions and organizations on competition. To enable consumers to better assert their rights, I agree. Class actions I ask to reflect, because I would not want to have all the disadvantages of American society, without having all the advantages. I see the interest, but comparison is not reason. I have seen what it has done for certain companies. Before going there, I still want to think about it and see a number of safeguards that we can put in place.

The distribution, an immense subject, I apologize, but having been Minister of Finance, I initiated the first agreements and, at the time, I was subjected to a barrage of criticism, including from a number of my friends who thought I was in favor of new regulations to lower prices. Remember. Luc CHATEL has undertaken a truly remarkable job. I take my responsibilities; I am in favor of negotiability, there it is said, it is done, like you. So you might ask me: why go through the triple net? Because I need to have a majority to vote for it, and there needs to be a process to get there, that's how it is. So I told Luc CHATEL and the Prime Minister about the triple net to start, negotiability at the end. That is exactly what I said, it is exactly what you propose. So you do not propose to go through the triple net, but if I can, in eight months with the Prime Minister, achieve the same results... It is a very difficult subject. I add, regarding the laws you mentioned, that I was so much in the minority in my own political family. But look at what is happening: small businesses have been martyred, our city peripheries have been disfigured, hard discount stores are now in city centers, and prices in our large supermarkets are rather higher than elsewhere, a beautiful result! Fortunately, we have made laws to protect small businesses and consumers. What would it be if we hadn't done that? It wasn't in the text, but I felt so strongly that it had to be said.

You propose to reform regulated professions, specifying that it is not about eliminating all regulation: that would indeed be unacceptable when guarantees regarding professional competence are needed or when people's safety is at stake. But yes, there are perfectly obsolete regulations; Paris is still the only city in the world where it is difficult to find a taxi. I apologize, it is a reflection that I readily admit is not of very high intellectual caliber. There are other subjects that are much more difficult; I think of para-pharmacy. These are not small issues, Jacques, why? I can see that if we allow part of para-pharmacy in large supermarkets, we lower prices, and that is good for consumers, that is true. But at the same time, my job as Head of State is also to think about land use planning and the true public service mission of pharmacies. In this debate, we cannot reduce everything to just the question of prices. Because if tomorrow, in a number of small towns or territories, there are no more pharmacies because everyone knows they partly rely on para-pharmacy, then how do you manage land use? And how do you respond to the loneliness of a number of people, not just the elderly for whom the pharmacist is the only source of life and contact? Growth is not just quantitative; it is also qualitative.

I must therefore, with the Prime Minister and the Minister of Finance, consider the extent of the problems every time we make a decision. I was elected; I must do my job for five years; it is not a question of fear. Not a part of the problem. I must think that the consumer who is happy to buy cheaper does not want to live in a desert. There would be many other things to say, but we will still address this matter of regulated professions.

I also think about the issue of divorces. The proposal made by the Government and the Keeper of the Seals, I support it: that we can move towards a divorce without a lawyer and without a judge. I like lawyers a lot; I have good friends among them, dear Jean-Michel DARROIS, and I myself, after all, was a lawyer longer than I have been Head of State. You see that each time, complexity is not simply about corporatist interests, as they say; these are people who are also fighting for their lives.

Finally, you advocate for a new governance, reform of the State and the public service, which is absolutely crucial. Many of the directions you propose resonate with priorities we have initiated: limiting the number of ministers, which is exactly what we did with François FILLON - by the way, I have the weakness to think that no government will ever be formed in the same way since François's government. We have initiated a general revision of public policies; I share many of your recommendations, development of public service agencies, reduction of the formality of consultations, establishment of multi-year budgeting - we have already decided on these - simplifying administrative procedures and modifying the status of the public service to give more meaning to social promotion, there is no problem. The idea of creating a permanent committee involving civil society actors and making its proposals on simplification public, we will retain it. Taking advantage of retirements to reduce public employment. Listen, frankly, we have done it for 23,000 people this year. I am told it is not enough, but it should not have been a problem to do it before. Never had it been the case, never. Why is it not easy? Because the social problem is immediate, and the budgetary advantage comes in 15 years. There you go, yes, there are business leaders here, wonderful business leaders, but still, you work for a strategy; you work for yourselves too. And it is not so simple; it is not so simple to make people understand that by reducing public employment, we improve the quality of public service. I add that we share the economy in half by giving purchasing power. We will continue, and we will go much further. The hospital, I am very interested in your proposals: outsourcing peripheral services of healthcare provision, rationalizing governance, it is not rationalization; there is no governance, there are no leaders, there are no responsible parties; everyone has the power to say no, no one has the power to say yes. There you go, the problem of the hospital. Better management of our health expenditures through the generalization of regional health agencies, strengthening the role of the health insurance alert committee, clarifying the roles between administrators and social partners. All these proposals are good, Ladies and Gentlemen; we will have to make extremely important decisions in this area. Because let’s speak clearly: health expenditures are not going to decrease; we live longer, treatments cost more, the relationship to pain is even more demanding. I have noted that we should not tax labor because it is relocating, and we should not tax capital because it is relocating too. If we do not tax either labor or capital and, on the other hand, we must preserve purchasing power, and therefore we must not touch consumption... Not bad, we talked about the quadrature of the circle; it is worse because, after all, we must tax capital gains. But what is the capital gain if not the alliance of labor and capital? At some point, this question will arise, to which is added another very difficult problem: what is the boundary between mutual insurance and health insurance? An essential subject, extraordinarily difficult. What is the barrier between solidarity and insurance? And particularly on such a sensitive issue as long-term dependency, Alzheimer’s, what do we do? I am in favor of creating a fifth risk; how do we finance it? These are debates we will carry, but they are not small questions. These are extremely heavy debates. Many other proposals - but I have already been too long - regarding territorial organization. You want to strengthen intercommunal cooperation; you are right. Abolishing the departmental level, at least within 10 years. I want to express my disagreement. I will explain myself to you. The region has economic legitimacy, and still, if you wanted to give everything to the region, you must have the courage, Ladies and Gentlemen, to go further. Do not keep 22 regions; if you are in this logic, because each French region is very insignificant compared to a German Land, so it is not simply the abolition of departments; it is the simultaneous abolition of half the regions. That is where you propose something; I do not agree. Departments have historical legitimacy, and people are very attached to the commune; why? Because in a world that has become a village, it costs much more to lose one’s identity than to accumulate layers of local authorities. And that too is a decision I must make. It has been so long that we have been mocked for having too many communes in France. Yes, technocratically, that is true, but given the quality of life, the rooting of democracy, and networks of solidarity, it is much less accurate. The issue of departments, I will not go there because I do not believe that the French are ready to give up the historical legitimacy of a department. It is not a question of fear either; it is a question of priority. I am much more interested in leading the reform of the hospital, the reform of vocational training, the reform of primary education, the reform of the university, the reform of programs, the reform of health insurance than in fighting over the reform of departments. Because it is not essential for the competitiveness of France. We can modify the relationship of the French with public spending, for example, regarding indexing on local authorities. We have already started that. The question arises. And the question, Jacques, arises very simply; we cannot judge the government on the reduction of deficits without thinking that, in the deficits, there is the "social security" package, thus retirement and health insurance, and the "local authorities" package. Take the business tax. It is capped on added value; the State pays 35% of it. Elected officials increase it, and the increase is not felt by businesses. It is not true since it is the State that pays. Business leaders are the first to tell me: reduce spending, cut the deficit. Okay, there are 20 billion in social contribution reductions. Everyone tells me we need to create an employment bonus. Okay. What does that mean? That it is the State that pays for salary increases that are no longer given in businesses. I remember a business leader who no longer operates but had very strong opinions, who told me: "if my business were managed like the State, it would be bankrupt." That is true. And if the State had fewer early retirements than you have been financing for decades, there would be less deficit too. Because the difference between the business leader and the State is that the business leader who no longer needs someone gives them to the State in the form of early retirement. That must be over. But we, the people who have nothing left, the excluded, fortunately, the State takes care of them. Because who would take care of them otherwise? It is not at all that I am reserved; I am also trying, freely, to participate in this debate to tell you that we will take up a very large part of your proposals.

But on the proposals we will not take up, those regarding departments, I do not want you to think it is out of fear. Fear is not a feeling I naturally experience. I am obliged to make priorities. It is already very difficult to govern France, which we are doing with the Government and the Prime Minister. But let us focus our energy on priorities for transforming France; otherwise, we risk paralyzing the entire system.

The roadmap you have outlined shows that there are many reforms still to be undertaken. Some have begun to be implemented in the laws passed since the summer. Others are part of the objectives assigned to the government; I also find proposals I made on January 8 when presenting my wishes to the press. For example: extending participation in SMEs. So, we are going to completely change the system. We are going to have a real societal debate, I think. Companies that make profits are wonderful, but we will talk about profit sharing: 1/3 for shareholders, 1/3 for investment, 1/3 for employees. As an indication, it is a real societal debate.

The role of the Caisse des Dépôts, perfect. I spoke about it with the Prime Minister this morning; I really want us to change that. All countries have sovereign funds, have industrial policies; we will use the Caisse des Dépôts as an instrument for a genuine industrial policy. You are right.

You encourage us to accelerate the reform. If you did not exist, we would have to create you! When I think that some reproach us for going too fast, I would say: "but look at what they told me." And so, deep down, I am very centrist in all this.

The slowdown of the international economy, the turbulence of the financial markets, must lead us to redouble our efforts. This is a reason to go further and faster in the necessary changes. And if I go out into the field, it is exclusively for that, to see for myself because it is my duty that the changes we decide on and talk about are implemented.

The overtime figures, we have just received a new number that is exceptional: there were 20 million overtime hours in October, 40 million in November. There were 40% of companies with more than 10 employees that used overtime in October, 50% in November. It is working. And so we want to continue in this direction.

You tell me that the hand must not tremble. It will not tremble. But we also need to explain, to prepare, and then for people to follow us. You will embark on a tour of the regions of France to discuss your proposal with the French people. A wonderful idea, everything you can do as educational action will not be done for a government or a majority, you will do it for our country because there is no other choice for us.

We will launch a government seminar in early February to decide and coordinate the priority measures among those you have proposed. The letters of mission that we signed with the Prime Minister to the ministers will be completed at the end of this seminar to incorporate the proposals you make. We will, of course, involve Parliament in this work and we would see only advantages in Parliament taking up the work of your commission to see what they agree on, what they disagree on, to give it a legislative translation. You propose a monitoring and support unit regarding the decisions made and measuring their impact on growth, that is also agreed. Madame Christine LAGARDE, Monsieur Luc CHATEL, Monsieur Hervé NOVELLI who are with us today, are on the front line and will integrate many of your recommendations into the law for the modernization of the economy that will be presented to Parliament as early as spring. The ministers in charge of Education, Housing, Labor, Public Accounts, Health, and Justice will also be involved because growth is everyone's business. I promised you that your report would not end up on the shelves of a library. Well, I hope I have given you the feeling that this is what we want to do. I propose that we meet again in six months to take stock. And I would like to tell you that, already, you have succeeded. There was the Armand RUEFF Commission, there will now be the ATTALI Commission. Allow me to tell you one thing, I will do everything to ensure that you are not disappointed by the reforming work of the Government and myself. Thank you.